Membrane fusion of Semliki Forest virus involves homotrimers of the fusion protein.

Infection of cells with enveloped viruses is accomplished through membrane fusion. The binding and fusion processes are mediated by the spike proteins in the envelope of the virus particle and usually involve a series of conformational changes in these proteins. We have studied the low-pH-mediated fusion process of the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV). The spike protein of SFV is composed of three copies of the protein heterodimer E2E1. This structure is resistant to solubilization in mild detergents such as Nonidet P-40 (NP40). We have recently shown that the spike structure is reorganized during virus entry into acidic endosomes (J. M. Wahlberg and H. Garoff, J. Cell Biol. 116:339-348, 1992). The original NP40-resistant heterodimer is dissociated, and the E1 subunits form new NP40-resistant protein oligomers. Here, we show that the new oligomer is represented by an E1 trimer. From studies that use an in vitro assay for fusion of SFV with liposomes, we show that the E1 trimer is efficiently expressed during virus-mediated membrane fusion. Time course studies show that both E1 trimer formation and fusion are fast processes, occurring in seconds. It was also possible to inhibit virus binding and fusion with a monoclonal antibody directed toward the trimeric E1. These results give support for a model in which the E1 trimeric structure is involved in the SFV-mediated fusion reaction.     

Membrane fusion of Semliki Forest virus requires sphingolipids in the target membrane.

Enveloped animal viruses, such as Semliki Forest virus (SFV), utilize a membrane fusion strategy to deposit their genome into the cytosol of the host cell. SFV enters cells through receptor-mediated endocytosis, fusion of the viral envelope occurring subsequently from within acidic endosomes. Fusion of SFV has been demonstrated before to be strictly dependent on the presence of cholesterol in the target membrane. Here, utilizing a variety of membrane fusion assays, including an on-line fluorescence assay involving pyrene-labeled virus, we demonstrate that low-pH-induced fusion of SFV with cholesterol-containing liposomal model membranes requires the presence of sphingomyelin or other sphingolipids in the target membrane. The minimal molecular characteristics essential for supporting SFV fusion are encompassed by a ceramide. The action of the sphingolipids is confined to the actual fusion event, cholesterol being necessary and sufficient for low-pH-dependent binding of the virus to target membranes. Complex formation of the sphingolipids with cholesterol is unlikely to be important for the induction of SFV--liposome fusion, as sphingolipids that do not interact appreciably with cholesterol, such as galactosylceramide, effectively support the process. The remarkably low levels of sphingomyelin required for half-maximal fusion (1-2 mole%) suggest that sphingolipids do not play a structural role in the SFV fusion process, but rather act as a cofactor, possibly activating the viral fusion protein in a specific manner.     

Membrane and protein interactions of a soluble form of the Semliki Forest virus fusion protein.

Semliki Forest virus is an enveloped alphavirus that infects cells by a membrane fusion reaction triggered by the low pH present in endocytic vacuoles. Fusion is mediated by the E1 spike protein subunit. During fusion, several conformational changes occur in E1 and E2, the two transmembrane subunits of the spike protein. These changes include dissociation of the E1-E2 dimer, alteration of the trypsin sensitivity and monoclonal antibody binding patterns of E1, and formation of a sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-resistant E1 homotrimer. A critical characteristic of Semliki Forest virus fusion is also its dependence on the presence of both cholesterol and sphingomyelin in the target membrane. We have here examined the conformational changes induced by low pH treatment of E1*, the water-soluble, proteolytically truncated ectodomain of the E1 subunit. Following low pH treatment, E1* was shown to bind efficiently to artificial liposomes. Similar to virus fusion, optimal E1*-liposome binding required low pH, cholesterol, and sphingomyelin. The E1 ectodomain, although monomeric in its neutral pH form, assembled into an SDS-resistant oligomer following treatment at low pH. This low pH-induced oligomerization required target membranes containing both cholesterol and sphingomyelin. Our results demonstrate that the E1 ectodomain responds to low pH similarly to the full-length E1 subunit. The ectodomain facilitates the characterization of conformational changes and membrane binding in the absence of virus fusion or other virus components.     

Spike protein oligomerization control of Semliki Forest virus fusion.

We have recently shown, using cleavage-deficient mutants of the p62-E1 membrane protein complex of Semliki Forest virus that p62 cleavage to E2 is necessary for the activation of the fusion function of the complex at pH 5.8 (a pH optimal for virus fusion) (M. Lobigs and H. Garoff, J. Virol. 64:1233-1240, 1990). In this study, we show that the mutant precursor complexes can be induced to activate membrane fusion when treated with more acidic buffers (pH 5.0 and 4.5), which also appear to dissociate most of the p62-E1 complexes and change the conformation of the E1 subunit (the supposed fusion protein of Semliki Forest virus into a form which is resistant to trypsin digestion. These data suggest that p62 cleavage is not essential for membrane fusion per se but that the crucial event activating this process seems to be the apparent dissociation of the heterodimer, which in turn is facilitated by the spike precursor cleavage.     

Membrane protein lateral interactions control Semliki Forest virus budding.

Semliki Forest virus, SFV, directs the synthesis of two membrane proteins, p62 and E1, which form a p62E1 heterodimer in the endoplasmic reticulum. After being transported to the plasma membrane (PM), they are incorporated into the virus membrane during the process of virus budding. Electronmicroscopic analyses of the envelope in matured virus show that the heterodimers are clustered into trimeric structures (spikes) which further form a regular surface lattice with T = 4. In this work we have used a genetic approach to study the importance of the trimerization event for virus budding. We have coexpressed a budding competent form of the virus heterodimer with another one which cannot be used for particle formation because of a defect in nucleocapsid (NC) binding. We show that the NC binding-deficient heterodimer is able to inhibit the budding of the competent one in a concentration-dependent manner and that the NC binding-competent heterodimers can rescue the incompetent ones into virus particles. This suggests that the heterodimers are complexed together, probably into the trimeric structures (spikes), at the PM to expose a multivalent binding site for the NC and thereby drive efficient virus budding.     

Semliki Forest virus induced cell-cell fusion at neutral extracellular pH

Semliki Forest virus-induced cell-cell fusion from within was considered to exclusively occur at mildly acidic pH (<6.2). Data of this study show that such cell fusion can also be triggered by transient acidification of the cytoplasm of infected cells at an extracellular, neutral pH. Results were obtained by utilizing NH₄Cl pulses combined with covalent modification of cell surface proteins. The observation implies a revision of the current consensus regarding the mechanism of Semliki Forest virus induced cell-cell fusion. We propose a model in which at least two peptide segments of the viral spike protein E₁ may be involved in triggering the fusion event.     

An epitope of the Semliki Forest virus fusion protein exposed during virus-membrane fusion

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) is an enveloped alphavirus that infects cells via a membrane fusion reaction triggered by acidic pH in the endocytic pathway. Fusion is mediated by the spike protein E1 subunit, an integral membrane protein that contains the viral fusion peptide and forms a stable homotrimer during fusion. We have characterized four monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) specific for the acid conformation of E1. These MAbs did not inhibit fusion, suggesting that they bind to an E1 region different from the fusion peptide. Competition analyses demonstrated that all four MAbs bound to spatially related sites on acid-treated virions or isolated spike proteins. To map the binding site, we selected for virus mutants resistant to one of the MAbs, E1a-1. One virus isolate, SFV 4-2, showed reduced binding of three acid-specific MAbs including E1a-1, while its binding of one acid-specific MAb as well as non-acid-specific MAbs to E1 and E2 was unchanged. The SFV 4-2 mutant was fully infectious, formed the E1 homotrimer, and had the wild-type pH dependence of infection. Sequence analysis demonstrated that the relevant mutation in SFV 4-2 was a change of E1 glycine 157 to arginine (G157R). Decreased binding of MAb E1a-1 was observed under a wide range of assay conditions, strongly suggesting that the E1 G157R mutation directly affects the MAb binding site. These data thus localize an E1 region that is normally hidden in the neutral pH structure and becomes exposed as part of the reorganization of the spike protein to its fusion-active conformation.     

Membrane fusion process of Semliki Forest virus. II: Cleavage-dependent reorganization of the spike protein complex controls virus entry

The envelope of the Semliki Forest virus (SFV) contains two transmembrane proteins, E2 and E1, in a heterodimeric complex. The E2 subunit is initially synthesized as a precursor protein p62, which is proteolytically processed to the mature E2 form before virus budding at the plasma membrane. The p62 (E2) protein mediates binding of the heterodimer to the nucleocapsid during virus budding, whereas E1 carries the entry functions of the virus, that is, cell binding and low pH-mediated membrane fusion activity. We have investigated the significance of the cleavage event for the maturation and entry of the virus. To express SFV with an uncleaved p62 phenotype, BHK-21 cells were transfected by electroporation with infectious viral RNA transcribed from a full-length SFV cDNA clone in which the p62 cleavage site had been changed. The uncleaved p62E1 heterodimer was found to be used for the formation of virus particles with an efficiency comparable to the wild type E2E1 form. However, in contrast to the wild type virus, the mutant virus was virtually noninfectious. Noninfectivity resulted from impaired uptake into cells, as well as from the inability of the virus to promote membrane fusion in the mildly acidic conditions of the endosome. This inability could be reversed by mild trypsin treatment, which converted the viral p62E1 form into the mature E2E1 form, or by treating the virus with a pH 4.5 wash, which in contrast to the more mild pH conditions of endosomes, effectively disrupted the p62E1 subunit association. We conclude that the p62 cleavage is not needed for virus budding, but regulates entry functions of the E1 subunit by controlling the heterodimer stability in acidic conditions.     

Mechanisms of mutations inhibiting fusion and infection by Semliki Forest virus

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) infects cells by an acid-dependent membrane fusion reaction catalyzed by the virus spike protein, a complex containing E1 and E2 transmembrane subunits. E1 carries the putative virus fusion peptide, and mutations in this domain of the spike protein were previously shown to shift the pH threshold of cell-cell fusion (G91A), or block cell-cell fusion (G91D). We have used an SFV infectious clone to characterize virus particles containing these mutations. In keeping with the previous spike protein results, G91A virus showed limited secondary infection and an acid-shifted fusion threshold, while G91D virus was noninfectious and inactive in both cell- cell and virus-liposome fusion assays. During the low pH- induced SFV fusion reaction, the E1 subunit exposes new epitopes for monoclonal antibody (mAb) binding and forms an SDS-resistant homotrimer, the virus associates hydrophobically with the target membrane, and fusion of the virus and target membranes occurs. After low pH treatment, G91A spike proteins were shown to bind conformation-specific mAbs, associate with target liposome membranes, and form the E1 homotrimer. However, both G91A membrane association and homotrimer formation had an acid-shifted pH threshold and reduced efficiency compared to wt virus. In contrast, studies of the fusion-defective G91D mutant showed that the virus efficiently reacted with low pH as assayed by mAb binding and liposome association, but was essentially inactive in homotrimer formation. These results suggest that the G91D mutant is noninfectious due to a block in a late step in membrane fusion, separate from the initial reaction to low pH and interaction with the target membrane, and involving the lack of efficient formation of the E1 homotrimer.     

Membrane phospholipid asymmetry in Semliki Forest virus grown in BHK cells

The distribution of phospholipids across the membrane bilayer of Semliki Forest virus grown in BHK cells has been examined by treating the virus with bee venom phospholipase A₂ and sphingomyelinase C from Staphylococcus aureus. From the amounts of different phospholipids which are degraded rapidly (half-time about 1 min for phospholipase A₂) we calculate that in virus isolated 16 h after infection about 95% of sphingomyelin, 55% of phosphatidylcholine, 20% of phosphatidylethanolamine and less then 5% of phosphatidylserine is present on the outer leaflet of the virus envelope. Less than 5% of the virus was permeable to macromolecules before or after treatment with phospholipases as judged by accessibility of the genome to external ribonuclease. A much slower (half-time about 1 h) breakdown by phospholipase A₂ of originally inaccessible phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine appeared to be due to an enzyme-induced loss of lipid asymmetry since the original asymmetric distribution of phospholipids was maintained for several hours when the virus alone was incubated at 37°C. However, virus incubated for 20 h at 37°C showed a marked loss of phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylserine asymmetry and a greater susceptibility to lysis by longer treatment with phospholipase A₂.     

Proteins synthesized by Semliki Forest virus and its 16 temperature-sensitive mutants.

The proteins synthesized in chicken embryo fibroblasts infected with wild-type Semliki Forest virus and 16 temperature-sensitive mutants derived from it were studied by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In addition to the structural proteins, five nonvirion proteins (NVP) with molecular weight of 130,000, 97,000, 86,000, 78,000 and 62,000 were found varying amounts in cells infected with the different RNA+ mutants and also in the wild-type-infected cells. Pulse-chase experiments suggested that NVP 130, NVP 97, NVP 86, and NVP 62 are precursors presumably of the structural proteins. The amount of NVP 78 was not affected by the chase, and it may represent a translational product of the nonstructural part of the genome. The NVP 130 was shown to be a common precursor of the structural proteins by tryptic peptide mapping. Kinetic evidence from one of the mutants (ts-3) suggested that NVP 86 is one of the precursors of the capsid protein. A common feature of all the RNA+mutants was the inability to cleave the NVP 62 into E2 and E3, suggesting that this cleavage is a crucial reaction in the virus maturation.     

Functions of the stem region of the Semliki Forest virus fusion protein during virus fusion and assembly

Membrane fusion of the alphaviruses is mediated by the E1 protein, a class II virus membrane fusion protein. During fusion, E1 dissociates from its heterodimer interaction with the E2 protein and forms a target membrane-inserted E1 homotrimer. The structure of the homotrimer is that of a trimeric hairpin in which E1 domain III and the stem region fold back toward the target membrane-inserted fusion peptide loop. The E1 stem region has a strictly conserved length and several highly conserved residues, suggesting the possibility of specific stem interactions along the trimer core and an important role in driving membrane fusion. Mutagenesis studies of the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV) here demonstrated that there was a strong requirement for the E1 stem in virus assembly and budding, probably reflecting its importance in lateral interactions of the envelope proteins. Surprisingly, however, neither the conserved length nor any specific residues of the stem were required for membrane fusion. Although the highest fusion activity was observed with wild-type E1, efficient fusion was mediated by stem mutants containing a variety of substitutions or deletions. A minimal stem length was required but could be conferred by a series of alanine residues. The lack of a specific stem sequence requirement during SFV fusion suggests that the interaction of domain III with the trimer core can provide sufficient driving force to mediate membrane merger.     

Oligomerization-dependent folding of the membrane fusion protein of Semliki Forest virus.

The spikes of alphaviruses are composed of three copies of an E2-E1 heterodimer. The E1 protein possesses membrane fusion activity, and the E2 protein, or its precursor form, p62 (sometimes called PE2), controls this function. Both proteins are, together with the viral capsid protein, translated from a common C-p62-E1 coding unit. In an earlier study, we showed that the p62 protein of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) dimerizes rapidly and efficiently in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) with the E1 protein originating from the same translation product (so-called heterodimerization in cis) (B.-U. Barth, J. M. Wahlberg, and H. Garoff, J. Cell Biol. 128:283-291, 1995). In the present work, we analyzed the ER translocation and folding efficiencies of the p62 and E1 proteins of SFV expressed from separate coding units versus a common one. We found that the separately expressed p62 protein translocated and folded almost as efficiently as when it was expressed from a common coding unit, whereas the independently expressed E1 protein was inefficient in both processes. In particular, we found that the majority of the translocated E1 chains were engaged in disulfide-linked aggregates. This result suggests that the E1 protein needs to form a complex with p62 to avoid aggregation. Further analyses of the E1 aggregation showed that it occurred very rapidly after E1 synthesis and could not be avoided significantly by the coexpression of an excess of p62 from a separate coding unit. These latter results suggest that the p62-E1 heterodimerization has to occur very soon after E1 synthesis and that this is possible only in a cis-directed reaction which follows the synthesis of p62 and E1 from a common coding unit. We propose that the p62 protein, whose synthesis precedes that of the E1 protein, remains in the translocon of the ER and awaits the completion of E1. This strategy enables the p62 protein to complex with the E1 protein immediately after the latter has been made and thereby to control (suppress) its fusion activity.     

Role of cholesterol in fusion of Semliki Forest virus with membranes.

The low pH-triggered membrane fusion activity of Semliki Forest virus is dependent on the presence of cholesterol in the target membrane. When liposomes containing phospholipids and cholesterol analogs were used, fusion activity was observed with steroids which did not have a planar nucleus or an isooctyl side chain at C-17, but fusion activity was not observed when analogs which lacked the 3 beta-OH group were used. Binding of virus to liposomes at low pH was similarly, but not totally, dependent on the presence of a 3 beta-OH sterol.     

Reversible acid-induced inactivation of the membrane fusion protein of Semliki Forest virus

Previously, it has been shown that the exposure of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) to a mildly acidic environment induces a rapid and complete loss of the ability of the virus to bind and fuse to target membranes added subsequently. In the present study, incubation of SFV at low pH followed by a specific reneutralization step resulted in a partial reversion of this loss of viral fusion capacity, as assessed in a liposomal model system. Also, the ability of the viral E1 fusion protein to undergo liposome-stimulated trimerization was restored. Furthermore, acid-treated and neutralized SFV largely retained infectivity. Exposure of SFV to low pH induced dissociation of the E1/E2 heterodimer, which was not reversed upon neutralization. It is concluded that the SFV E1 fusion protein, after acid-induced dissociation from E2, rapidly adopts an intermediate, nontrimeric conformation in which it is no longer able to interact with target membrane lipids. Neutralization restores the ability of E1 to interact with membranes. This interaction, however, remains strictly dependent on low pH.     

Enzymatic defects of the nsP2 proteins of Semliki Forest virus temperature-sensitive mutants

We have analyzed the biochemical consequences of mutations that affect viral RNA synthesis in Semliki Forest virus temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants. Of the six mutations mapping in the multifunctional replicase protein nsP2, three were located in the N-terminal helicase region and three were in the C-terminal protease domain. Wild-type and mutant nsP2s were expressed, purified, and assayed for nucleotide triphosphatase (NTPase), RNA triphosphatase (RTPase), and protease activities in vitro at 24°C and 35°C. The protease domain mutants (ts4, ts6, and ts11) had reduced protease activity at 35°C but displayed normal NTPase and RTPase. The helicase domain mutation ts1 did not have enzymatic consequences, whereas ts13a and ts9 reduced both NTPase and protease activities but in different and mutant-specific ways. The effects of these helicase domain mutants on protease function suggest interdomain interactions within nsP2. NTPase activity was not directly required for protease activity. The similarities of the NTPase and RTPase results, as well as competition experiments, suggest that these two reactions utilize the same active site. The mutations were also studied in recombinant viruses first cultivated at the permissive temperature and then shifted up to the restrictive temperature. Processing of the nonstructural polyprotein was generally retarded in cells infected with viruses carrying the ts4, ts6, ts11, and ts13a mutations, and a specific defect appeared in ts9. All mutations except ts13a were associated with a large reduction in the production of the subgenomic 26S mRNA, indicating that both protease and helicase domains influence the recognition of the subgenomic promoter during virus replication.     

The fusion peptide of Semliki Forest virus associates with sterol-rich membrane domains

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) is an enveloped alphavirus whose membrane fusion is triggered by low pH and promoted by cholesterol and sphingolipid in the target membrane. Fusion is mediated by E1, a viral membrane protein containing the putative fusion peptide. Virus mutant studies indicate that SFV's cholesterol dependence is controlled by regions of E1 outside of the fusion peptide. Both E1 and E1*, a soluble ectodomain form of E1, interact with membranes in a reaction dependent on low pH, cholesterol, and sphingolipid and form highly stable homotrimers. Here we have used detergent extraction and gradient floatation experiments to demonstrate that E1* associated selectively with detergent-resistant membrane domains (DRMs or rafts). In contrast, reconstituted full-length E1 protein or influenza virus fusion peptide was not associated with DRMs. Methyl beta-cyclodextrin quantitatively extracted both cholesterol and E1* from membranes in the absence of detergent, suggesting a strong association of E1* with sterol. Monoclonal antibody studies demonstrated that raft association was mediated by the proposed E1 fusion peptide. Thus, although other regions of E1 are implicated in the control of virus cholesterol dependence, once the SFV fusion peptide inserts in the target membrane it has a high affinity for membrane domains enriched in cholesterol and sphingolipid.     

Membrane fusion of Semliki Forest virus in a model system: correlation between fusion kinetics and structural changes in the envelope glycoprotein.

This paper presents a kinetic analysis of low-pH-induced fusion of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) with cholesterol-containing unilamellar lipid vesicles (liposomes), consisting otherwise of phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine and sphingomyelin. Fusion is monitored continuously with a lipid mixing assay, involving virus bio-synthetically labeled with the fluorophore pyrene. At pH 5.55, 37 degrees C, SFV-liposome fusion occurs on the time scale of seconds. Extensive fusion (up to 60% of the virus) requires an excess of liposomes, while a low-pH preincubation of the virus alone results in inactivation of its fusion capacity. The onset of fusion after acidification of virus-liposome mixtures is preceded by a pH- and temperature-dependent lag phase. Early in this lag phase, a conformational change in the E2E1 spike glycoprotein occurs, involving formation of a trypsin-resistant E1 homotrimer, exposing a conformation-specific epitope (E1"). These changes are followed by a rapid, cholesterol-dependent binding of the virus to the liposomes (as assessed by sucrose density gradient analysis), subsequent fusion starting only after an additional delay. This sequence of events strongly suggests that the E1 homotrimeric structure represents the fusion-active conformation of the SFV spike, the actual fusion complex possibly involving a higher order oligomer of E1 trimers.     

Multistep regulation of membrane insertion of the fusion peptide of Semliki Forest virus

A prevailing model for virus membrane fusion proteins has been that the hydrophobic fusion peptide is hidden in the prefusion conformation, becomes exposed once the fusion reaction is triggered, and then either inserts into target membranes or is rapidly inactivated. This model is in general agreement with the structure and mechanism of class I fusion proteins, such as the influenza virus hemagglutinin. We here describe studies of the class II fusion protein E1 from the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV). SFV fusion is triggered by low pH, which releases E1 from its heterodimeric interaction with the E2 protein and induces the formation of a stable E1 homotrimer. The exposure and target membrane interaction of the E1 fusion peptide (residues 83 to 100) were followed using a monoclonal antibody (MAb E1f) mapping to E1 residues 85 to 95. In agreement with the known structure of SFV and other alphaviruses, the fusion peptide was shielded in native SFV particles and exposed when E1-E2 dimer dissociation was triggered by acidic pH. In contrast, the fusion peptide on purified E1 ectodomains (E1(*)) was fully accessible at neutral pH. Functional assays showed that MAb E1f binding at neutral pH prevented subsequent low-pH-triggered E1(*) interaction with target membranes and trimerization. E1(*) was not inactivated by low pH when treated either in the absence of target membranes or in the presence of fusion-inactive cholesterol-deficient liposomes. Thus, the membrane insertion of the E1 fusion peptide is regulated by additional low-pH-dependent steps after exposure, perhaps involving an E1-cholesterol interaction.