Probing plasmid partition with centromere-based incompatibility

Low-copy number plasmids of bacteria rely on specific centromeres for regular partition into daughter cells. When also present on a second plasmid, the centromere can render the two plasmids incompatible, disrupting partition and causing plasmid loss. We have investigated the basis of incompatibility exerted by the F plasmid centromere, sopC, to probe the mechanism of partition. Measurements of the effects of sopC at various gene dosages on destabilization of mini-F, on repression of the sopAB operon and on occupancy of mini-F DNA by the centromere-binding protein, SopB, revealed that among mechanisms previously proposed, no single one fully explained incompatibility. sopC on multicopy plasmids depleted SopB by titration and by contributing to repression. The resulting SopB deficit is proposed to delay partition complex formation and facilitate pairing between mini-F and the centromere vector, thereby increasing randomization of segregation. Unexpectedly, sopC on mini-P1 exerted strong incompatibility if the P1 parABS locus was absent. A mutation preventing the P1 replication initiation protein from pairing (handcuffing) reduced this strong incompatibility to the level expected for random segregation. The results indicate the importance of kinetic considerations and suggest that mini-F handcuffing promotes pairing of SopB-sopC complexes that can subsequently segregate as intact aggregates.     

Reciprocal intrapool variation in plasmid copy numbers: a characteristic of segregational incompatibility

An experimental analysis of the concept that incompatible plasmids occupy a common intracellular pool from which copies are drawn at random for replication and assortment is presented. Intrapool variations in an incompatible heteroplasmid strain are inevitable and it is shown that these variations can be exploited by differential selection to amplify one plasmid at the expense of the other. Constant overall copy number is demonstrated for isogenic wild-type replicons and also for isogenic copy mutants whose copy numbers are so great that segregational incompatibility cannot be measured. In the test system used, that of the Staphylococcus aureus plasmid pT181, the rate of replication is probably determined by the availability of a trans-active initiator protein, RepC. In heteroplasmid strains containing wild-type and dominant copy mutant plasmids, although intrapool variation occurs, the total copy number is not constant but varies as a consequence of selection for or against the mutant plasmid. This is because all of the RepC is synthesized from the mutant plasmid (the wild-type is hyper-repressed) and therefore the selection affects the supply of RepC at the same time that it affects the copy number of the plasmid. None of these effects are seen with single plasmids or with compatible pairs.     

Random replication and random assortment model for plasmid incompatibility in bacteria

To understand the incompatibility between two related plasmids, both of which replicate in an autonomous state under a common control mechanism, we have developed a model that assumes a random choice mechanism for replication of plasmid copies and their random assortment into daughter cells upon cell division. Segregation kinetics by this model is analyzed mathematically and the number of generations required for segregation is calculated as a function of plasmid copy number per cell. The results obtained offer enough quantitative data to make our model reasonably realistic.     

Mutations of temperature sensitivity in R plasmid pSC101.

Temperature-sensitive (Ts) mutant plasmids isolated from tetracycline resistance R plasmid pSC101 were investigated for their segregation kinetics and deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) replication. The results fit well with the hypothesis that multiple copies of a plasmid are distributed to daughter cells in a random fashion and are thus diluted out when a new round of plasmid DNA replication is blocked. When cells harboring type I mutant plasmids were grown at 43 degrees C in the absence of tetracycline, antibiotic-sensitive cells were segregated after a certain lag time. This lag most likely corresponds to a dilution of plasmids existing prior to the temperature shift. The synthesis of plasmid DNA in cells harboring type I mutant plasmids was almost completely blocked at 43 degrees C. It seems that these plasmids have mutations in the gene(s) necessary for plasmid DNA replication. Cells haboring a type II mutant plasmid exhibited neither segregation due to antibiotic sensitivity nor inhibition of plasmid DNA replication throughout cultivation at high temperature. It is likely that the type II mutant plasmid has a temperature-sensitive mutation in the tetracycline resistance gene. Antibiotic-sensitive cells haboring type III mutant plasmids appeared at high frequency after a certain lag time, and the plasmid DNA synthesis was partially suppressed at the nonpermissive temperature. They exhibited also a pleiotrophic phenotype, such as an increase of drug resistance level at 30 degrees C and a decrease in the number of plasmid genomes in a cell.     

On plasmid incompatibility

In this paper is presented a brief review of the current state of information on plasmid incompatibility followed by a detailed mathematical model dealing with incompatibility between autonomous homogenic plasmids and based on the assumption that the intracellular plasmid copy pool is randomized with respect to assortment during cell division. Two cases are considered: one in which each plasmid copy replicates once in each generation of cell growth (regular replication) and one in which plasmids are chosen at random for replication from a common pool, irrespective of their replication history (random replication). In both cases, it is assumed that the partition of plasmid copies to daughter cells at cell division is regular—existing plasmid copies are divided equally among the two daughter cells (equipartition). In the case of regular replication coupled with equipartition, it is shown that the survival of heteroplasmid cells (cells containing at least one copy of each of two incompatible plasmids) during exponential growth in a nonselective medium is given by H = H₀[1 − 1/(2N − 1)]ⁿ, where H₀ and H are the numbers of heteroplasmid cells after 0 and n generations of growth, respectively, and N is the plasmid copy number in newborn cells. In the second case, (random replication-equipartition), it is shown that the survival of the heteroplasmid population during exponential growth under nonselective conditions is given by H = H₀[(N − 1)(2N + 1)/(2N − 1)(N + 1)ⁿ. Sample calculations are presented to show that segregation is more rapid in the latter than in the former case. Finally, some of the plasmid-linked genetic determinants that might be expected to affect the expression of incompatibility between nonisogenic plasmids are briefly considered. These determinants include recognition specificity for replication origins, recognition specificity, specific activity of copy number control systems, and recognition specificity of partition systems.     

Studies on plasmid replication. III. Isolation and characterization of replication-defective mutants

Some 85 Staphylococcus aureus mutants phenotypically thermosensitive for penicillinase plasmid segregation (Seg-) have been isolated and characterized. Some of the mutations were plasmid-linked and those studied in detail were found to be defective in plasmid replication, most problbly at the initiation stage. Analysis of the segregation behavior of these mutants suggested a figure of 2.7 for the average number of plasmid copies per cell in a random culture. Other mutations were host chromosome-linked and these could be divided into at least three classes on the basis of their ability to maintain plasmids of the two different incompatibility sets: some were defective for type I plasmids, some for type II, and some for both types. One host mutant, defective in segregation of type I but not type II plasmids, was defective in polymerization of both.     

Pedigree analysis of plasmid segregation in yeast

We have used pedigree analysis to investigate the mitotic segregation of circular and linear DNA plasmids in Saccharomyces cerevisae. Circular ARS plasmids, which bear putative chromosomal replication origins, have a high segregation frequency and a strong bias to segregate to the mother cell at mitosis. The segregation bias explains how the fraction of plasmid-bearing cells can be small despite the high average copy number of circular ARS plasmids. Linear ARS plasmids do not show strong segregation bias, nor does the 2 mu ori-containing plasmid YEp 13, when it is present in strains containing intact 2 mu circles. In the absence of endogenous 2 mu circles, YEp 13 behaves like an ARS plasmid, showing a strong maternal segregation bias. The presence of a centromere on circular ARS plasmids eliminates segregation bias. We discuss a model for plasmid segregation, which explains these findings and the possible biological significance of mother-daughter segregation bias.     

Random diffusion can account for topA-dependent suppression of partition defects in low-copy-number plasmids.

The maintenance of partition-defective (Par-) mini-P1 and mini-F plasmids was studied in topA strains of Escherichia coli, which are defective in topoisomerase I activity. The partition defects were substantially but not completely suppressed in broth-grown cultures. This suppression was not due to a large increase in copy number. However, the absolute number of copies of Par- mini-P1 plasmids per average dividing cell is sufficiently high to account for the modest stability observed if a random distribution of the copies to daughter cells is assumed. The similar number of Par- plasmid copies in wild-type cells are distributed in a considerably worse-than-random fashion. Thus, it is unnecessary to propose, as was suggested previously, that an active, par-independent pathway operates in topA strains to ensure proper segregation of the plasmids to daughter cells. Rather, it seems likely that the lack of topoisomerase I activity aids the random distribution of the partition-defective plasmids, perhaps by facilitating their separation after replication. The results of studies carried out at reduced growth rates were consistent with this view; when topA cells containing Par- mini-P1 plasmids were cultured in minimal medium, in which the copy number of the plasmids per average cell is sharply reduced, very little suppression of the partition defect was observed.     

Clustering versus random segregation of plasmids lacking a partitioning function: a plasmid paradox?

Plasmids lacking a functional partition system are randomly distributed to the daughter cells; plasmid-free daughter cells are formed with a frequency of (1/2)2n per cell and cell generation where 2n is the (average) copy number at cell division. Hence, the unit of segregation is one plasmid copy. However, plasmids form clusters in the cells. A putative solution to this potential paradox is presented: one plasmid copy at a time is recruited from the plasmid clusters to the replication factories that are located in the cell centres. Hence, replication offers the means of declustering that is necessary in a growing host population. The daughter copies diffuse freely and each copy may with equal probability end up in either of the two cell halves. In this way, the random segregation of the plasmids is coupled to replication and occurs continuously during the cell cycle, and is not linked to cell division. The unit of segregation is the plasmid copy and not the plasmid clusters. In contrast, the two daughters of a Par+ plasmid are directed in opposite directions by the plasmid-encoded partition system, thereby assuring that each daughter cell receives the plasmid.     

Compatibility and molecular properties of plasmid Rms 149 in Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Escherichia coli

Two recombinant plasmids have been constructed which code for chloramphenicol resistance but otherwise have properties similar to those of the tetracycline resistance plasmid pT181 and its temperature-sensitive replication (Tsr) mutant pSA0301, respectively, concerning their stability in the host cell and behavior in incompatibility tests. Incompatible heteroplasmid clones have been established using these four plasmids, and their segregation during growth under nonselective conditions has been followed. The results obtained proved the ability of a wild-type plasmid to complement an incompatible Tsr plasmid mutant for its autonomous maintenance at restrictive temperatures. On the other hand, at permissive temperatures, the rate of heteroplasmid segregation was higher for wild-type/wild-type plasmid pairs than for wild-type/Tsr pairs, while at restrictive temperatures the two types of heteroplasmid clones presented similar segregation rates. The possible implications of these results are discussed.     

Effect of the deletion of a fragment dispensable for the autonomous maintenance of plasmid pT181 on the competition between incompatible plasmids

The deletion of the 560-bp HindIII C fragment from pT181 derivatives does not change the stability or copy number of the plasmid but affects its ability to compete with undeleted, incompatible plasmids for maintenance in the host cell. The disadvantage of the deleted plasmids seems to be manifested at the level of replication. It results that for plasmid pT181 a sequence dispensable for autonomous maintenance and replication control could affect the outcome of the competition between autonomous, incompatible plasmids.     

Copy-number control of the Escherichia coli chromosome: a plasmidologist's view

The homeostatic system that sets the copy number, and corrects over-replication and under-replication, seems to be different for chromosomes and plasmids in bacteria. Whereas plasmid replication is random in time, chromosome replication is tightly coordinated with the cell cycle such that all origins are initiated synchronously at the same cell mass per origin once per cell cycle. In this review, we propose that despite their apparent differences, the copy-number control of the Escherichia coli chromosome is similar to that of plasmids. The basic mechanism that is shared by both systems is negative-feedback control of the availability of a protein or RNA positive initiator. Superimposed on this basic mechanism are at least three systems that secure the synchronous initiation of multiple origins; however, these mechanisms are not essential for maintaining the copy number.     

A DNA segment conferring stable maintenance on R6K gamma-origin core replicons.

The plasmid R6K gamma origin consists of two adjacent modules, the enhancer and the core, and requires R6K initiator protein pi for replication. While the core alone can replicate at a low level of wild-type pi protein, we show here that host cells do not stably maintain core plasmids. The presence of the enhancer segment confers stable inheritance on core plasmids without a significant change in average plasmid copy number. Deletions and site-directed mutagenesis indicated that the stability of core plasmids is not mediated by binding sites or consensus sequences in the enhancer for DnaA, pi protein, gyrase, Fis, or Dcm methylase. Proper segregation of core plasmids requires only the R6K stb or stability-related region, which includes the 20-bp segment of the 100-bp enhancer adjacent to the core. The use of the pi 116 mutant protein, which increases plasmid copy number fourfold, does not stabilize core plasmids lacking the enhancer. We also show that at an elevated level of wild-type pi, the gamma-origin plasmid is unstable, even in the presence of the enhancer. We discuss the differences and similarities between the R6K stability system and those found in other plasmids.     

Properties and incompatibility behavior of miniplasmids derived from the bireplicon plasmid pCG86

Summary Many plasmids belonging to the F incompatibility groups contain more than one basic replicon. The chimeric plasmid pCG86 is an example of such a multireplicon plasmid. The two basic replicons of pCG86, RepFIIA/FIC and RepFIB have been cloned and re-ligated, the copy numbers of the clones have been determined, and the incompatibility behavior of plasmids containing the ligated replicons and the individual replicons has been studied. The bireplicon plasmids are not expected to be incompatible as recipients with monoreplicon RepFIB or RepFIIA/RepFIC plasmids, since when one replicon is challenged by an incoming replicon, the other should be able to handle the plasmid's replication. In our studies, we found that challenge with either monoreplicon plasmid resulted in incompatibility. This incompatibility was increased in bireplicon plasmids in which RepFIB was duplicated. We conclude that in the bireplicon plasmids, challenging the replication control of one replicon by an incompatible plasmid can interfere with the replication originating from the second replicon.     

Surprising dependence on postsegregational killing of host cells for maintenance of the large virulence plasmid of Shigella flexneri

Low-copy-number plasmids all encode multiple systems to ensure their propagation, including replication, partition (active segregation), and postsegregational killing (PSK) systems. PSK systems kill those rare cells that lose the plasmid due to replication or segregation errors. PSK systems should not be used as the principle means of maintaining the plasmid. The metabolic cost of killing the many cured cells that would arise from random plasmid segregation is far too high. Here we describe an interesting exception to this rule. Maintenance of the large virulence plasmid of Shigella flexneri is highly dependent on one of its PSK systems, mvp, at 37 degrees C, the temperature experienced during pathogenesis. At 37 degrees C, the plasmid is very unstable and mvp efficiently kills the resulting cured bacterial cells. This imposes a major growth disadvantage on the virulent bacterial population. The systems that normally ensure accurate plasmid replication and segregation are attenuated or overridden at 37 degrees C. At 30 degrees C, a temperature encountered by Shigella in the outside environment, the maintenance systems function normally and the plasmid is no longer dependent on mvp. We discuss why the virulent pathogen tolerates this self-destructive method of propagation at the temperature of infection.     

Bovine papilloma virus plasmids replicate randomly in mouse fibroblasts throughout S phase of the cell cycle

Bovine papilloma virus (BPV) replicates as a multicopy nuclear plasmid in mouse fibroblasts. Using fluorescence activated cell sorting and mitotic selection procedures, we show that the replication of BPV occurs throughout S phase of the cell cycle and that replication is confined to S phase. After one round of chromosomal DNA replication, almost one quarter of BPV plasmids have replicated more than once, while a similar number of plasmids have not replicated at all. While multiple forms of BPV exist in the cell, all forms show the same pattern of replication. These results are consistent with a model in which BPV plasmids are chosen at random for replication throughout, and only during, S phase and support the view that the completion of S phase is a specifically activated event in the cell cycle rather than simply the end of one round of chromosomal DNA replication.