Advances in on-line monitoring and control of mammalian cell cultures: Supporting the PAT initiative

In recent years, much attention has been directed towards the development of global methods for on-line process monitoring, especially since the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) launched the Process Analytical Technology (PAT) guidance, stimulating biopharmaceutical companies to update their monitoring tools to ensure a pre-defined final product quality. The ideal technologies for biopharmaceutical processes should operate in situ, be non-invasive and generate on-line information about multiple key bioprocess and/or metabolic variables. A wide range of spectroscopic techniques based on in situ probes have already been tested in mammalian cell cultures, such as near infrared (NIR), mid infrared (MIR), 2D fluorescence and dielectric capacitance spectroscopy; similarly, the electronic nose technique based on chemical array sensors has been tested for in situ off-gas analysis of mammalian cell cultures. All these methods provide series of spectra, from which meaningful information must be extracted. In this sense, data mining techniques such as principal components regression (PCR), partial least squares (PLS) or artificial neural networks (ANN) have been applied to handle the dense flow of data generated from the real-time process analyzers. Furthermore, the implementation of feedback control methods would help to improve process performance and ultimately ensure reproducibility. This review discusses the suitability of several spectroscopic techniques coupled with chemometric methods for improved monitoring and control of mammalian cell processes.     

Enabling PAT in insect cell bioprocesses: In situ monitoring of recombinant adeno-associated virus production by fluorescence spectroscopy

The process analytical technology (PAT) initiative shifted the bioprocess development mindset towards real-time monitoring and control tools to measure relevant process variables online, and acting accordingly when undesirable deviations occur. Online monitoring is especially important in lytic production systems in which released proteases and changes in cell physiology are likely to affect product quality attributes, as is the case of the insect cell-baculovirus expression vector system (IC-BEVS), a well-established system for production of viral vectors and vaccines. Here, we applied fluorescence spectroscopy as a real-time monitoring tool for recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) production in the IC-BEVS. Fluorescence spectroscopy is simple, yet sensitive and informative. To overcome the strong fluorescence background of the culture medium and improve predictive ability, we combined artificial neural network models with a genetic algorithm-based approach to optimize spectra preprocessing. We obtained predictive models for rAAV titer, cell viability and cell concentration with normalized root mean squared errors of 7%, 4%, and 7%, respectively, for leave-one-batch-out cross-validation. Our approach shows fluorescence spectroscopy allows real-time determination of the best time of harvest to maintain rAAV infectivity, an important quality attribute, and detection of deviations from the golden batch profile. This methodology can be applied to other biopharmaceuticals produced in the IC-BEVS, supporting the use of fluorescence spectroscopy as a versatile PAT tool.     

Chemometric modelling with two-dimensional fluorescence data for Claviceps purpurea bioprocess characterization

Modern bioprocess control requires fast data acquisition and in-time evaluation of bioprocess variables. On-line fluorescence spectroscopy and the application of chemometric methods accomplish these goals. In order to demonstrate how time-consuming off-line analysis methods can be replaced for bioprocess monitoring, fluorescence measurements were performed during different cultivations of the fungus Claviceps purpurea. To predict process variables like biomass, protein, and alkaloid concentrations, chemometric models were developed on the basis of the acquired fluorescence spectra. The results of these investigations are presented and the applicability of this approach for bioprocess monitoring is discussed.     

Technology outlook for real-time quality attribute and process parameter monitoring in biopharmaceutical development—A review

Real-time monitoring of bioprocesses by the integration of analytics at critical unit operations is one of the paramount necessities for quality by design manufacturing and real-time release (RTR) of biopharmaceuticals. A well-defined process analytical technology (PAT) roadmap enables the monitoring of critical process parameters and quality attributes at appropriate unit operations to develop an analytical paradigm that is capable of providing real-time data. We believe a comprehensive PAT roadmap should entail not only integration of analytical tools into the bioprocess but also should address automated-data piping, analysis, aggregation, visualization, and smart utility of data for advanced-data analytics such as machine and deep learning for holistic process understanding. In this review, we discuss a broad spectrum of PAT technologies spanning from vibrational spectroscopy, multivariate data analysis, multiattribute chromatography, mass spectrometry, sensors, and automated-sampling technologies. We also provide insights, based on our experience in clinical and commercial manufacturing, into data automation, data visualization, and smart utility of data for advanced-analytics in PAT. This review is catered for a broad audience, including those new to the field to those well versed in applying these technologies. The article is also intended to give some insight into the strategies we have undertaken to implement PAT tools in biologics process development with the vision of realizing RTR testing in biomanufacturing and to meet regulatory expectations.     

Raman based chemometric model development for glycation and glycosylation real time monitoring in a manufacturing scale CHO cell bioreactor process

The Quality by Design (QbD) approach to the production of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) emphasizes an understanding of the production process ensuring product quality is maintained throughout. Current methods for measuring critical quality attributes (CQAs) such as glycation and glycosylation are time and resource intensive, often, only tested offline once per batch process. Process analytical technology (PAT) tools such as Raman spectroscopy combined with chemometric modeling can provide real time measurements process variables and are aligned with the QbD approach. This study utilizes these tools to build partial least squares (PLS) regression models to provide real time monitoring of glycation and glycosylation profiles. In total, seven cell line specific chemometric PLS models; % mono-glycated, % non-glycated, % G0F-GlcNac, % G0, % G0F, % G1F, and % G2F were considered. PLS models were initially developed using small scale data to verify the capability of Raman to measure these CQAs effectively. Accurate PLS model predictions were observed at small scale (5 L). At manufacturing scale (2000 L) some glycosylation models showed higher error, indicating that scale may be a key consideration in glycosylation profile PLS model development. Model robustness was then considered by supplementing models with a single batch of manufacturing scale data. This data addition had a significant impact on the predictive capability of each model, with an improvement of 77.5% in the case of the G2F. The finalized models show the capability of Raman as a PAT tool to deliver real time monitoring of glycation and glycosylation profiles at manufacturing scale.     

Dynamic metabolic engineering for increasing bioprocess productivity

Yield and productivity are critical for the economics and viability of a bioprocess. In metabolic engineering, the main objective is the increase of a target metabolite production through genetic engineering. However, genetic manipulations usually result in lower productivity due to growth impairment. Previously, it has been shown that the dynamic control of metabolic fluxes can increase the amount of product formed in an anaerobic batch fermentation of Escherichia coli. In order to apply this control strategy, the genetic toggle switch is used to manipulate key fluxes of the metabolic network. We have designed and analyzed an integrated computational model for the dynamic control of gene expression. This controller, when coupled to the metabolism of E. coli, resulted in increased bioprocess productivity.     

A novel LED‐based 2D‐fluorescence spectroscopy system for in‐line bioprocess monitoring of Chinese hamster ovary cell cultivations—Part II

This study was performed in order to evaluate a new LED‐based 2D‐fluorescence spectrometer for in‐line bioprocess monitoring of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell culture processes. The new spectrometer used selected excitation wavelengths of 280, 365, and 455 nm to collect spectral data from six 10‐L fed‐batch processes. The technique provides data on various fluorescent compounds from the cultivation medium as well as from cell metabolism. In addition, scattered light offers information about the cultivation status. Multivariate data analysis tools were applied to analyze the large data sets of the collected fluorescence spectra. First, principal component analysis was used to accomplish an overview of all spectral data from all six CHO cultivations. Partial least square regression models were developed to correlate 2D‐fluorescence spectral data with selected critical process variables as offline reference values. A separate independent fed‐batch process was used for model validation and prediction. An almost continuous in‐line bioprocess monitoring was realized because 2D‐fluorescence spectra were collected every 10 min during the whole cultivation. The new 2D‐fluorescence device demonstrates the significant potential for accurate prediction of the total cell count, viable cell count, and the cell viability. The results strongly indicated that the technique is particularly capable to distinguish between different cell statuses inside the bioreactor. In addition, spectral data provided information about the lactate metabolism shift and cellular respiration during the cultivation process. Overall, the 2D‐fluorescence device is a highly sensitive tool for process analytical technology applications in mammalian cell cultures.     

Improvement of bioprocess monitoring: development of novel concepts

The advancement of bioprocess monitoring will play a crucial role to meet the future requirements of bioprocess technology. Major issues are the acceleration of process development to reduce the time to the market and to ensure optimal exploitation of the cell factory and further to cope with the requirements of the Process Analytical Technology initiative. Due to the enormous complexity of cellular systems and lack of appropriate sensor systems microbial production processes are still poorly understood. This holds generally true for the most microbial production processes, in particular for the recombinant protein production due to strong interaction between recombinant gene expression and host cell metabolism. Therefore, it is necessary to scrutinise the role of the different cellular compartments in the biosynthesis process in order to develop comprehensive process monitoring concepts by involving the most significant process variables and their interconnections. Although research for the development of novel sensor systems is progressing their applicability in bioprocessing is very limited with respect to on-line and in-situ measurement due to specific requirements of aseptic conditions, high number of analytes, drift, and often rather low physiological relevance. A comprehensive survey of the state of the art of bioprocess monitoring reveals that only a limited number of metabolic variables show a close correlation to the currently explored chemical/physical principles. In order to circumvent this unsatisfying situation mathematical methods are applied to uncover "hidden" information contained in the on-line data and thereby creating correlations to the multitude of highly specific biochemical off-line data. Modelling enables the continuous prediction of otherwise discrete off-line data whereby critical process states can be more easily detected. The challenging issue of this concept is to establish significant on-line and off-line data sets. In this context, online sensor systems are reviewed with respect to commercial availability in combination with the suitability of offline analytical measurement methods. In a case study, the aptitude of the concept to exploit easily available online data for prediction of complex process variables in a recombinant E. coli fed-batch cultivation aiming at the improvement of monitoring capabilities is demonstrated. In addition, the perspectives for model-based process supervision and process control are outlined.     

Automatic real-time calibration,assessment, and maintenance of generic Raman models for online monitoring of cell culture processes

Raman spectroscopy is a multipurpose analytical technology that has found great utility in real-time monitoring and control of critical performance parameters of cell culture processes. As a process analytical technology (PAT) tool, the performance of Raman spectroscopy relies on chemometric models that correlate Raman signals to the parameters of interest. The current calibration techniques yield highly specific models that are reliable only on the operating conditions they are calibrated in. Furthermore, once models are calibrated, it is typical for the model performance to degrade over time due to various recipe changes, raw material variability, and process drifts. Maintaining the performance of industrial Raman models is further complicated due to the lack of a systematic approach to assessing the performance of Raman models. In this article, we propose a real-time just-in-time learning (RT-JITL) framework for automatic calibration, assessment, and maintenance of industrial Raman models. Unlike traditional models, RT-JITL calibrates generic models that can be reliably deployed in cell culture experiments involving different modalities, cell lines, media compositions, and operating conditions. RT-JITL is a first fully integrated and fully autonomous platform offering a self-learning approach for calibrating and maintaining industrial Raman models. The efficacy of RT-JITL is demonstrated on experimental studies involving real-time predictions of various cell culture performance parameters, such as metabolite concentrations, viability, and viable cell density. RT-JITL framework introduces a paradigm shift in the way industrial Raman models are calibrated, assessed, and maintained, which to the best of authors' knowledge, have not been done before.     

Plasmid DNA fermentation strategies: influence on plasmid stability and cell physiology

In order to provide sufficient pharmaceutical-grade plasmid DNA material, it is essential to gain a comprehensive knowledge of the bioprocesses involved; so, the development of protocols and techniques that allow a fast monitoring of process performance is a valuable tool for bioprocess design. Regarding plasmid DNA production, the metabolic stress of the host strain as well as plasmid stability have been identified as two of the key parameters that greatly influence plasmid DNA yields. The present work describes the impact of batch and fed-batch fermentations using different C/N ratios and different feeding profiles on cell physiology and plasmid stability, investigating the potential of these two monitoring techniques as valuable tools for bioprocess development and design. The results obtained in batch fermentations showed that plasmid copy number values suffered a pronounced increase at the end of almost all fermentation conditions tested. Regarding fed-batch fermentations, the strategies with exponential feeding profiles, in contrast with those with constant feeding, showed higher biomass and plasmid yields, the maximum values obtained for these two parameters being 95.64 OD₆₀₀ and 344.3 mg plasmid DNA (pDNA)/L, respectively, when using an exponential feed rate of 0.2 h⁻¹. Despite the results obtained, cell physiology and plasmid stability monitoring revealed that, although higher pDNA overall yields were obtained, this fermentation exhibited lower plasmid stability and percentage of viable cells. In conclusion, this study allowed clarifying the bioprocess performance based on cell physiology and plasmid stability assessment, allowing improvement of the overall process and not only plasmid DNA yield and cell growth.     

Monitoring of complex industrial bioprocesses for metabolite concentrations using modern spectroscopies and machine learning: application to gibberellic acid production

Two rapid vibrational spectroscopic approaches (diffuse reflectance-absorbance Fourier transform infrared [FT-IR] and dispersive Raman spectroscopy), and one mass spectrometric method based on in vacuo Curie-point pyrolysis (PyMS), were investigated in this study. A diverse range of unprocessed, industrial fed-batch fermentation broths containing the fungus Gibberella fujikuroi producing the natural product gibberellic acid, were analyzed directly without a priori chromatographic separation. Partial least squares regression (PLSR) and artificial neural networks (ANNs) were applied to all of the information-rich spectra obtained by each of the methods to obtain quantitative information on the gibberellic acid titer. These estimates were of good precision, and the typical root-mean-square error for predictions of concentrations in an independent test set was <10% over a very wide titer range from 0 to 4925 ppm. However, although PLSR and ANNs are very powerful techniques they are often described as "black box" methods because the information they use to construct the calibration model is largely inaccessible. Therefore, a variety of novel evolutionary computation-based methods, including genetic algorithms and genetic programming, were used to produce models that allowed the determination of those input variables that contributed most to the models formed, and to observe that these models were predominantly based on the concentration of gibberellic acid itself. This is the first time that these three modern analytical spectroscopies, in combination with advanced chemometric data analysis, have been compared for their ability to analyze a real commercial bioprocess. The results demonstrate unequivocally that all methods provide very rapid and accurate estimates of the progress of industrial fermentations, and indicate that, of the three methods studied, Raman spectroscopy is the ideal bioprocess monitoring method because it can be adapted for on-line analysis.     

Bioprocess in-line monitoring using Raman spectroscopy and Indirect Hard Modeling (IHM): A simple calibration yields a robust model

To increase the process productivity and product quality of bioprocesses, the in-line monitoring of critical process parameters is highly important. For monitoring substrate, metabolite, and product concentrations, Raman spectroscopy is a commonly used Process Analytical Technology (PAT) tool that can be applied in-situ and non-invasively. However, evaluating bioprocess Raman spectra with a robust state-of-the-art statistical model requires effortful model calibration. In the present study, we in-line monitored a glucose to ethanol fermentation by Saccharomyces cerevisiae (S. cerevisiae) using Raman spectroscopy in combination with the physics-based Indirect Hard Modeling (IHM) and showed successfully that IHM is an alternative to statistical models with significantly lower calibration effort. The IHM prediction model was developed and calibrated with only 16 Raman spectra in total, which did not include any process spectra. Nevertheless, IHM's root mean square errors of prediction (RMSEPs) for glucose (3.68 g/L) and ethanol (1.69 g/L) were comparable to the prediction quality of similar studies that used statistical models calibrated with several calibration batches. Despite our simple calibration, we succeeded in developing a robust model for evaluating bioprocess Raman spectra.     

Analysis of chemometric models applied to Raman spectroscopy for monitoring key metabolites of cell culture

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) initiative of Process Analytical Technology (PAT) encourages the monitoring of biopharmaceutical manufacturing processes by innovative solutions. Raman spectroscopy and the chemometric modeling tool partial least squares (PLS) have been applied to this aim for monitoring cell culture process variables. This study compares the chemometric modeling methods of Support Vector Machine radial (SVMr), Random Forests (RF), and Cubist to the commonly used linear PLS model for predicting cell culture components—glucose, lactate, and ammonia. This research is performed to assess whether the use of PLS as standard practice is justified for chemometric modeling of Raman spectroscopy and cell culture data. Model development data from five small-scale bioreactors (2 × 1 L and 3 × 5 L) using two Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines were used to predict against a manufacturing scale bioreactor (2,000 L). Analysis demonstrated that Cubist predictive models were better for average performance over PLS, SVMr, and RF for glucose, lactate, and ammonia. The root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) of Cubist modeling was acceptable for the process concentration ranges of glucose (1.437 mM), lactate (2.0 mM), and ammonia (0.819 mM). Interpretation of variable importance (VI) results theorizes the potential advantages of Cubist modeling in avoiding interference of Raman spectral peaks. Predictors/Raman wavenumbers (cm⁻¹) of interest for individual variables are X1139–X1141 for glucose, X846–X849 for lactate, and X2941–X2943 for ammonia. These results demonstrate that other beneficial chemometric models are available for use in monitoring cell culture with Raman spectroscopy.     

Bioprocess monitoring and computer control: key roots of the current PAT initiative

This review article has been written for the journal, Biotechnology and Bioengineering, to commemorate the 70th birthday of Daniel I.C. Wang, who served as doctoral thesis advisor to each of the co-authors, but a decade apart. Key roots of the current PAT initiative in bioprocess monitoring and control are described, focusing on the impact of Danny Wang's research as a professor at MIT. The history of computer control and monitoring in biochemical processing has been used to identify the areas that have already benefited and those that are most likely to benefit in the future from PAT applications. Past applications have included the use of indirect estimation methods for cell density, expansion of on-line/at-line and on-line/in situ measurement techniques, and development of models and expert systems for control and optimization. Future applications are likely to encompass additional novel measurement technologies, measurements for multi-scale and disposable bioreactors, real time batch release, and more efficient data utilization to achieve process validation and continuous improvement goals. Dan Wang's substantial contributions in this arena have been one key factor in steering the PAT initiative towards realistic and attainable industrial applications.     

Extracellular vesicles concentration is a promising and important parameter for industrial bioprocess monitoring

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are membrane vesicles that are produced by cells to be released into their microenvironment. In this study, we present the EV concentration as a new factor for optimization of industrial bioprocess control. The release of EVs depends on many cell properties, including cell activation and stress status, and cell death. Therefore, the EV concentration might provide a readout for identification of the cell state and the conditions during a bioprocess. Our data show that the EV concentration increased during the bioprocess, which indicated deteriorating conditions in the bioreactor. This increase in EV concentration in the fermentation broth was the consequence of two different processes: cell activation, and cell death. However, the release of EVs from activated living cells had a much weaker impact on EV concentration in the bioreactor than those released during cell death. EVs and cells in the bioprocess environment were quantified by flow cytometry. The most accurate data were obtained directly from unprocessed samples, making the monitoring of the EV concentration a rapid, easy, and cheap method. These EV concentrations reflect the conditions in the bioreactor and provide new information regarding the state of the bioprocess. Therefore, we suggest EV concentration as a new and important parameter for the monitoring of industrial bioprocesses.     

Turning food waste to energy and resources towards a great environmental and economic sustainability: An innovative integrated biological approach

Food waste (FW) management is a global conundrum because of the rapid population growth and growing economic activity. Currently, incineration and landfill are still the main means for FW management, while their environmental sustainability and economic viability have been in question. Recently, the biological processes including anaerobic digestion, aerobic composting, bioethanol fermentation, feed fermentation etc. have attracted increasing interest with the aims for energy and resource recovery from FW. However, these biological approaches have inherent drawbacks, and cannot provide a comprehensive solution for future FW management. Therefore, this review attempts to offer a critical and holistic analysis of current biotechnologies for FW management with the focus on the challenges and solutions forward. The biological approaches towards future FW management should be able to achieve both environmental sustainability and economic viability. In this instance, the concept of zero solid discharge-driven resource recovery has thus been put forward. According to which, several innovative biological processes for FW management are further elucidated with critical analysis on their engineering feasibility and environmental sustainability. It turns out that is an urgent need for turning current single task-orientated bioprocess to an integrated biological process with multiple tasks of concurrent recovery of water, resource and energy together with zero-solid discharge.     

Automated flow cytometry for monitoring CHO cell cultures

Flow cytometry has been used to accurately monitor cell events that indicate the spatio-temporal state of a bioreactor culture. The introduction of process analytical technology (PAT) has led to process improvements using real-time or semi real-time monitoring systems. Integration of flow cytometry into an automated scheme for improved process monitoring can benefit PAT in bioreactor-based biopharmaceutical productions by establishing optimum process conditions and better quality protocols. Herein, we provide detailed protocols for establishing an automated flow cytometry system that can be used to investigate and monitor cell growth, viability, cell size, and cell cycle data. A method is described for the use of such a system primarily focused on CHO cell culture, although it is foreseen the information gathered from automated flow cytometry can be applied to a variety of cell lines to address both PAT requirements and gain further understanding of complex biological systems.     

Metabolic engineering of bacteria

Yield and productivity are critical for the economics and viability of a bioprocess. In metabolic engineering the main objective is the increase of a target metabolite production through genetic engineering. Metabolic engineering is the practice of optimizing genetic and regulatory processes within cells to increase the production of a certain substance. In the last years, the development of recombinant DNA technology and other related technologies has provided new tools for approaching yields improvement by means of genetic manipulation of biosynthetic pathway. Industrial microorganisms like Escherichia coli, Actinomycetes, etc. have been developed as biocatalysts to provide new or to optimize existing processes for the biotechnological production of chemicals from renewable plant biomass. The factors like oxygenation, temperature and pH have been traditionally controlled and optimized in industrial fermentation in order to enhance metabolite production. Metabolic engineering of bacteria shows a great scope in industrial application as well as such technique may also have good potential to solve certain metabolic disease and environmental problems in near future.     

Applications of metabolic modeling to drive bioprocess development for the production of value-added chemicals

Increasing numbers of value added chemicals are being produced using microbial fermentation strategies. Computational modeling and simulation of microbial metabolism is rapidly becoming an enabling technology that is driving a new paradigm to accelerate the bioprocess development cycle. In particular, constraint-based modeling and the development of genome-scale models of industrial microbes are finding increasing utility across many phases of the bioprocess development workflow. Herein, we review and discuss the requirements and trends in the industrial application of this technology as we build toward integrated computational/experimental platforms for bioprocess engineering. Specifically we cover the following topics: (1) genome-scale models as genetically and biochemically consistent representations of metabolic networks; (2) the ability of these models to predict, assess, and interpret metabolic physiology and flux states of metabolism; (3) the model-guided integrative analysis of high throughput ‘omics’ data; (4) the reconciliation and analysis of on- and off-line fermentation data as well as flux tracing data; (5) model-aided strain design strategies and the integration of calculated biotransformation routes; and (6) control and optimization of the fermentation processes. Collectively, constraint-based modeling strategies are impacting the iterative characterization of metabolic flux states throughout the bioprocess development cycle, while also driving metabolic engineering strategies and fermentation optimization.