Lack of an adrenal cortex in Sf1 mutant mice is compatible with the generation and differentiation of chromaffin cells

The diversification of neural-crest-derived sympathoadrenal (SA) progenitor cells into sympathetic neurons and neuroendocrine adrenal chromaffin cells was thought to be largely understood. In-vitro studies with isolated SA progenitor cells had suggested that chromaffin cell differentiation depends crucially on glucocorticoids provided by adrenal cortical cells. However, analysis of mice lacking the glucocorticoid receptor gene had revealed that adrenal chromaffin cells develop mostly normally in these mice. Alternative cues from the adrenal cortex that may promote chromaffin cell determination and differentiation have not been identified. We therefore investigated whether the chromaffin cell phenotype can develop in the absence of an adrenal cortex, using mice deficient for the nuclear orphan receptor steroidogenic factor-1 (SF1), which lack adrenal cortical cells and gonads. We show that in Sf1-/- mice typical chromaffin cells assemble correctly in the suprarenal region adjacent to the suprarenal sympathetic ganglion. The cells display most features of chromaffin cells, including the typical large chromaffin granules. Sf1-/- chromaffin cells are numerically reduced by about 50% compared with the wild type at embryonic day (E) 13.5 and E17.5. This phenotype is not accounted for by reduced survival or cell proliferation beyond E12.5. However, already at E12.5 the 'adrenal' region in Sf1-/- mice is occupied by fewer PHOX2B+ and TH+ SA cells as well as SOX10+ neural crest cells. Our results suggest that cortical cues are not essential for determining chromaffin cell fate, but may be required for proper migration of SA progenitors to and/or colonization of the adrenal anlage.     

Reduction of endogenous TGF-beta does not affect phenotypic development of sympathoadrenal progenitors into adrenal chromaffin cells.

Adrenal chromaffin cells and sympathetic neurons are related, but phenotypically distinct derivatives of the neural crest. Molecular cues that determine the chromaffin cell phenotype have not yet been identified; in contrast to a widely held belief, glucocorticoid signaling is apparently not relevant (Development 126 (1999) 2935). Transforming growth factor-betas (TGF-betas) regulate various aspects of embryonic development and are expressed in the environment of sympathoadrenal (SA) progenitor cells. We have previously shown that neutralization of endogenous TGF-beta from E4 to E8 in the quail embryo significantly increases numbers of adrenal tyrosine hydroxylase-positive cells. Whether endogenous TGF-beta may also be involved in influencing phenotypic development of adrenal chromaffin cells and their SA progenitors has not been analyzed. We now demonstrate that neutralization of endogenous TGF-beta1, -beta2 and -beta3 with a pan-anti-TGF-beta antibody in quail embryos during distinct time windows does not alter phenotypic development of chromaffin cells. In situ hybridizations revealed unaltered expression of neurofilament (NF-160), synaptotagmin I and neurexin I in adrenal glands. Likewise, the NF-associated antigen 3A10, and polyphosphorylated NF epitopes (RT 97) were unaltered. Most importantly, the typical ultrastructure of adrenal chromaffin cells including their large chromaffin secretory granules, a hallmark of the neuroendocrine phenotype, which distinguishes them from sympathetic neurons, was not affected. We therefore conclude that neutralization of endogenous TGF-beta influences chromaffin cell proliferation, but does not interfere with the development of the typical chromaffin cell phenotype.     

Development of chromaffin cells depends on MASH1 function

The sympathoadrenal (SA) cell lineage is a derivative of the neural crest (NC), which gives rise to sympathetic neurons and neuroendocrine chromaffin cells. Signals that are important for specification of these two types of cells are largely unknown. MASH1 plays an important role for neuronal as well as catecholaminergic differentiation. Mash1 knockout mice display severe deficits in sympathetic ganglia, yet their adrenal medulla has been reported to be largely normal suggesting that MASH1 is essential for neuronal but not for neuroendocrine differentiation. We show now that MASH1 function is necessary for the development of the vast majority of chromaffin cells. Most adrenal medullary cells in Mash1(-/-) mice identified by Phox2b immunoreactivity, lack the catecholaminergic marker tyrosine hydroxylase. Mash1 mutant and wild-type mice have almost identical numbers of Phox2b-positive cells in their adrenal glands at embryonic day (E) 13.5; however, only one-third of the Phox2b-positive adrenal cell population seen in Mash1(+/+) mice is maintained in Mash1(-/-) mice at birth. Similar to Phox2b, cells expressing Phox2a and Hand2 (dHand) clearly outnumber TH-positive cells. Most cells in the adrenal medulla of Mash1(-/-) mice do not contain chromaffin granules, display a very immature, neuroblast-like phenotype, and, unlike wild-type adrenal chromaffin cells, show prolonged expression of neurofilament and Ret comparable with that observed in wild-type sympathetic ganglia. However, few chromaffin cells in Mash1(-/-) mice become PNMT positive and downregulate neurofilament and Ret expression. Together, these findings suggest that the development of chromaffin cells does depend on MASH1 function not only for catecholaminergic differentiation but also for general chromaffin cell differentiation.     

Development of adrenal chromaffin cells in Sf1 heterozygous mice

Adrenal medullary chromaffin cells are derivatives of the neural crest and are widely believed to share a common sympathoadrenal (SA) progenitor with sympathetic neurons. For decades, the adrenal cortical environment was assumed to be essential for channelling SA progenitors towards an endocrine chromaffin cell fate. Our recent analysis of steroidogenic factor 1(Sf1) −/− mice, which lack an adrenal cortex, has challenged this view: in Sf1 −/− mice chromaffin cells migrate to the correct “adrenal” location and undergo largely normal differentiation. In contrast to Sf1 homozygous mutants, heterozygous animals have an adrenal cortex, which, however, is smaller than in wildtype littermates. We show here that the Sf1 +/− adrenal cortical anlagen attract normal numbers of chromaffin progenitor cells into their vicinity by embryonic day 13.5 (E13.5). Two days later, however, only a few scattered cells with highly immature features have immigrated into the adrenal cortex, whereas the remainder form a coherent cell assembly ectopically located at the medial surface of the gland. These cells appear more mature than the scattered intracortical chromaffin progenitors and express the adrenaline synthesizing enzyme PNMT with a delay of 1 day in comparison with wildtype littermates. Nevertheless, chromaffin progenitor cells undergo a numerical reduction of approximately 30% by E17.5. Together, our data suggest that normal adrenocortical development is critical for the correct immigration of chromaffin progenitors into the cortical anlagen, for the timing of PNMT expression and for the regulation of chromaffin cell numbers.This work was supported by a grant from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (SFB 488, TP A6).     

Molecular probes for the development and plasticity of neural crest derivatives

We have isolated cDNA clones for several mRNAs expressed in sympathetic neurons but not in adrenal chromaffin cells, two neural crest derivatives thought to share a common precursor. The tissue specificity, developmental expression, and hormonal regulation of these genes have been characterized using Northern blot and in situ hybridization analysis. We find that these mRNAs are independently regulated in development rather than synchronously induced. Our evidence also implicates Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) in the induction of one of these genes in postmigratory crest cells. Two of these genes become induced in mature chromaffin cells, which express a neuronal morphology in response to NGF. These results support the idea that the phenotypic plasticity of neural crest derivatives reflects a common precursor, the multipotentiality of which is sustained through terminal differentiation.     

Analysis of mice carrying targeted mutations of the glucocorticoid receptor gene argues against an essential role of glucocorticoid signalling for generating adrenal chromaffin cells.

Molecular mechanisms underlying the generation of distinct cell phenotypes is a key issue in developmental biology. A major paradigm of determination of neural cell fate concerns the development of sympathetic neurones and neuroendocrine chromaffin cells from a common sympathoadrenal (SA) progenitor cell. Two decades of in vitro experiments have suggested an essential role of glucocorticoid receptor (GR)-mediated signalling in generating chromaffin cells. Targeted mutation of the GR should consequently abolish chromaffin cells. The present analysis of mice lacking GR gene product demonstrates that animals have normal numbers of adrenal chromaffin cells. Moreover, there are no differences in terms of apoptosis and proliferation or in expression of several markers (e.g. GAP43, acetylcholinesterase, adhesion molecule L1) of chromaffin cells in GR-deficient and wild-type mice. However, GR mutant mice lack the adrenaline-synthesizing enzyme PNMT and secretogranin II. Chromaffin cells of GR-deficient mice exhibit the typical ultrastructural features of this cell phenotype, including the large chromaffin granules that distinguish them from sympathetic neurones. Peripherin, an intermediate filament of sympathetic neurones, is undetectable in chromaffin cells of GR mutants. Finally, when stimulated with nerve growth factor in vitro, identical proportions of chromaffin cells from GR-deficient and wild-type mice extend neuritic processes. We conclude that important phenotypic features of chromaffin cells that distinguish them from sympathetic neurones develop normally in the absence of GR-mediated signalling. Most importantly, chromaffin cells in GR-deficient mice do not convert to a neuronal phenotype. These data strongly suggest that the dogma of an essential role of glucocorticoid signalling for the development of chromaffin cells must be abandoned.     

Molecular markers of sympathoadrenal cells

Cells constituting the sympathoadrenal (SA) cell lineage originate from the neural crest and acquire a catecholaminergic fate following migration to the dorsal aorta. Subsequently, SA cells migrate to sites widely dispersed throughout the body. In addition to endocrine chromaffin and ”small intensely fluorescent” cells in adrenal glands and in extra-adrenal tissues such as the paraganglia, this lineage also includes neurones located in sympathetic ganglia and in the adrenal gland. It is widely assumed that these cells are all derived from the same precursors, which then differentiate along divergent pathways in response to different external stimuli. During embryonic differentiation, SA cells lose some of their early traits and acquire other distinguishing features. To help understand how the lineage diverges in terms of phenotype and function, this article examines the cellular expression of a variety of ”marker” proteins that characterize the individuals of the lineage. In particular, differences between adrenal medullary adrenergic and noradrenergic chromaffin cells in the expression of proteins, such as the neural adhesion molecule L1, the growth-associated protein GAP-43 and molecules involved in the secretory process, are emphasized. Factors that might differentially regulate such molecular markers in these cells are discussed. Received: 29 December 1998 / Accepted: 1 April 1999     

Development of adrenal chromaffin cells is largely normal in mice lacking the receptor tyrosine kinase c-Ret

c-Ret encodes a receptor tyrosine kinase that is essential for normal development of the kidney as well as enteric and sympathetic neurons. Since sympathetic neurons and neuroendocrine chromaffin cells originate from a common progenitor cell, we have examined the relevance of c-Ret for the development of adrenal chromaffin cells by analyzing mouse mutants lacking c-Ret. Adrenal chromaffin cells express c-Ret mRNA at embryonic day (E) 12.5 and 13.5, yet levels of expression decline at later embryonic and postnatal ages. Adrenal medullae of c-Ret deficient mice show normal numbers of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)-immunoreactive cells at E13.5 and at birth. Ultrastructurally, adrenal chromaffin cells of c-Ret(-/-) mice appear unaltered: chromaffin cells develop typical secretory chromaffin granules, the morphological hallmark of chromaffin cells, and synaptic terminals appear normal. However, adrenaline levels and numbers of chromaffin cells immunoreactive for the adrenaline synthesizing enzyme phenylethanolamine-N-methyltransferase (PNMT) are reduced by about 30% in c-Ret-deficient mice arguing for a direct or indirect role of c-Ret in the regulation of PNMT. Thus, despite expression of c-Ret, adrenal chromaffin cells develop largely normal in mice lacking c-Ret. We therefore conclude that sympathetic neurons and neuroendocrine chromaffin cells profoundly differ in their requirement for c-Ret signaling during development.     

Nerve Growth Factor and glucocorticoids regulate phenotypic expression in cultured chromaffin cells from adult rhesus monkeys

Adrenal chromaffin cells and sympathetic neurons are both derivatives of the neural crest. Despite their morphological and functional differences, chromaffin cells retain some developmental plasticity and if treated with Nerve Growth Factor (NGF), can express certain characteristics of sympathetic neurons. However, there is some age and species variability in the response of chromaffin cells to NGF: in general chromaffin cells from adult animals are not considered to be dependent on NGF for survival, and chromaffin cells from adults of several species fail to respond to NGF in vitro by growing neurites. This is in contrast to the dramatic effects of NGF on chromaffin cells from perinatal rats. We have examined the requirements of chromaffin cells from adult rhesus monkeys to survive, to proliferate, and to express a neuronal morphology in vitro. NGF greatly enhances the proportion of rhesus chromaffin cells that form neurites and the length of the neurites that are formed, but the conversion to a neuronal phenotype is more limited than in chromaffin cells cultured from young rats. NGF also enhances rhesus chromaffin cell survival, but fails to stimulate their proliferation, in contrast to its effect on perinatal rat cells [18]. Glucocorticoid hormones (GCs) specifically antagonize the effects of NGF on neuritic outgrowth while promoting chromaffin cell survival. Thus adrenal chromaffin cells from rhesus monkeys retain a degree of developmental plasticity even in the adult animal.     

Cellular 'neoteny': a possible developmental basis for chromaffin cell plasticity

Adrenal medullary chromaffin cells, SIF cells and sympathetic neurons are derived from the sympatho-adrenal sublineage of the neural crest, and represent a range of cellular phenotypes extending from endocrine to neuronal. It is suggested here that these cell types may represent different stages of developmental 'arrest' along a linear pathway whose endpoint is a cholinergic sympathetic neuron. This model explains the 'transdifferentiation' of mature cells seen in this system as simply a delayed realization of transitions that normally occur between these stages during development. Such a 'linear model' of phenotypic diversification may be applicable to other developing systems that generate closely related but distinct cell types.     

Expression of neurotrophin receptors trkB and trkC and their ligands in rat adrenal gland and the intermediolateral column of the spinal cord

Neurotrophins and their trk receptors constitute major classes of signaling molecules with important actions in the developing and adult nervous system. With regard to the sympathoadrenal cell lineage, which gives rise to sympathetic neurons and chromaffin cells, neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) and nerve growth factor (NGF) are thought to influence developing sympathetic neurons. Neurotrophin requirements of chromaffin cells of the adrenal medulla are less well understood than those for NGF. In order to provide the bases for understanding of putative functions of neurotrophins for the development and maintenance of chromaffin cells and their preganglionic innervation, in situ hybridization has been used to study the expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and NT-3, together with their cognate receptors trkB and trkC, in the adrenal gland and in the intermediolateral column (IML) of the spinal cord. BDNF is highly expressed in the embryonic adrenal cortex and later in cells of the cortical reticularis zone. Adrenal medullary chromaffin cells fail to express detectable levels of mRNAs for BDNF, NT-3, and their cognate receptors trkB and trkC. Neurons in the IML express BDNF and trkB, and low levels of NT-3 and trkC. Our data make it unlikely that BDNF and NT-3 serve as retrograde trophic factors for IML neurons but suggest roles of BDNF and NT-3 locally within the spinal cord and possibly for sensory nerves of the adrenal cortex.     

Immunohistochemical identification and comparison of glial cell lineage in foetal, neonatal, adult and neoplastic human adrenal medulla

The differentiation of glial cells in developing, neonatal, adult and neoplastic human adrenal medulla has been studied immunohistochemically. From 8 to 28 weeks' gestational age, S-100 protein and its β-subunit revealed two different glial cell populations in adrenal glands, namely Schwann-like and sustentacular cells. Schwann-like cells were spindle-shaped cells forming a continuous layer around groups of sympathetic neuroblasts, often in contact with Schwann cells of nerve fibres entering neuroblastic groups. Sustentacular cells were round or oval cells with dendritic cytoplasmic processes; they were not associated with nerve fibres and mingled both with sympathetic neuroblasts and differentiating chromaffin cells. The developmental fate of Schwann-like cells was different from that of sustentacular cells. Schwann-like cells disappeared from the 28th week of gestational age, in association with the disappearance of sympathetic neuroblastic groups, and they were rarely found in neonatal and adult adrenal medulla. In contrast, sustentacular cells persisted between medullary chromaffin cells, and their number and dendritic cytoplasmic processes progressively increased from foetus to adult. In eight cases of primitive adrenal neuroblastic tumours of neonatal age (five undifferentiated neuroblastomas and three ganglioneuroblastomas), Schwann-like cells were found at the periphery of tumoral nests with a lobular growth pattern, while rare sustentacular cells were associated with neuroblasts. In two cases of adult phaeochromocytomas, only sustentacular cells were detected between chromaffin tumoral cells. Our findings suggest that the glial cell types and their distribution in primitive adrenal medulla tumours closely resemble those observed during development in the groups of adrenal sympathetic neuroblasts and in the clusters of chromaffin cells     

Immunohistochemical identification and comparison of glial cell lineage in foetal, neonatal, adult and neoplastic human adrenal medulla

The differentiation of glial cells in developing, neonatal, adult and neoplastic human adrenal medulla has been studied immunohistochemically. From 8 to 28 weeks' gestational age, S-100 protein and its β-subunit revealed two different glial cell populations in adrenal glands, namely Schwann-like and sustentacular cells. Schwann-like cells were spindle-shaped cells forming a continuous layer around groups of sympathetic neuroblasts, often in contact with Schwann cells of nerve fibres entering neuroblastic groups. Sustentacular cells were round or oval cells with dendritic cytoplasmic processes; they were not associated with nerve fibres and mingled both with sympathetic neuroblasts and differentiating chromaffin cells. The developmental fate of Schwann-like cells was different from that of sustentacular cells. Schwann-like cells disappeared from the 28th week of gestational age, in association with the disappearance of sympathetic neuroblastic groups, and they were rarely found in neonatal and adult adrenal medulla. In contrast, sustentacular cells persisted between medullary chromaffin cells, and their number and dendritic cytoplasmic processes progressively increased from foetus to adult. In eight cases of primitive adrenal neuroblastic tumours of neonatal age (five undifferentiated neuroblastomas and three ganglioneuroblastomas), Schwann-like cells were found at the periphery of tumoral nests with a lobular growth pattern, while rare sustentacular cells were associated with neuroblasts. In two cases of adult phaeochromocytomas, only sustentacular cells were detected between chromaffin tumoral cells. Our findings suggest that the glial cell types and their distribution in primitive adrenal medulla tumours closely resemble those observed during development in the groups of adrenal sympathetic neuroblasts and in the clusters of chromaffin cells     

A bipotential neuroendocrine precursor whose choice of cell fate is determined by NGF and glucocorticoids

Adrenal medullary endocrine (chromaffin) cells and sympathetic neurons both derive from the neural crest. We have found that the embryonic adrenal medulla and sympathetic ganglia are both initially populated by precursors expressing neural-specific genes. By birth, however, the medulla consists largely of chromaffin cells. In primary culture, the medullary precursors have three developmental fates: in NGF they continue to mature into neurons and survive, whereas in glucocorticoid they either extinguish their neuronal properties and exhibit an endocrine phenotype, or else continue to develop into neurons but then die. These data suggest that, in vivo, the adrenal medulla develops through both the glucocorticoid-induced differentiation of bipotential progenitors and the degeneration of committed neuronal precursors, which have migrated into the gland.