Mowing during rainfall enhances the control of Cirsium arvense

Pastoral farmers in New Zealand have described dramatic demises in populations of the weed Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop., a perennial herb indigenous to Eurasia, following its mowing during rainfall. To test the hypotheses (1) that the mowing of C. arvense during rainfall increases the control of this weed and (2) that the causal organism in this ‘mowing-in-the-rain’ effect is the vascular wilt fungus Verticillium dahliae, two series of field experiments were carried out in C. arvense-infested pastures in New Zealand, one in autumn 2008 (Experiment series 1, 9 farms), and another in spring/summer 2008–2009 (Experiment series 2, 12 farms). The effect of mowing in the rain as compared to mowing in the dry was to reduce the % ground cover of the thistle in the spring following treatment by 21 and 32% in Experiment series 1 and 2, respectively. Correlations of this ‘rain versus dry’ effect with the incidence of V. dahliae in the subterranean parts of C. arvense shoots sampled in each of the two field experiment series provided no statistical evidence that the effect increased with V. dahliae incidence. Thus these experiments provide no support for the hypothesis that V. dahliae is the biological mechanism for the ‘mowing-in-the-rain’ effect. Nevertheless, they do support mowing during rainfall as a simple and effective management tactic for C. arvense.     

Does transmission of the rust pathogen,Puccinia punctiformis,require stem mining vectors?

Recent research in Europe has suggested that stem mining insects may be important for vectoring the pathogen Puccinia punctiformis, and largely responsible for its systemic infection in the weed, Cirsium arvense. However, here we present comparative survey data showing that the level of systemic disease is the same in Europe and New Zealand, with and without stem miners, respectively, casting doubt on the idea that these insects are necessary for transmission of the fungus.     

Pollen availability,seed production and seed predator clutch size in a tephritid—thistle system

Summary We develop a simple model explaining clutch size behaviour ofOrellia ruficauda on its principle host in North America,Cirsium arvense. Offspring of flies feed solely on thistle seeds and seed production is pollen-limited. Thus, female flies risk reduced offspring fitness when committing large clutches to hosts (female flower heads) occurring in localities where male plants are locally absent. We therefore predict that attacked hosts will contain fewer eggs in such localities, a prediction that is consistent with data obtained in the field: large clutches are never laid in flower heads in low-pollination localities. However, larvae reared from such low-quality hosts are significantly smaller on average and will therefore carry smaller egg loads as adults. Small clutches in poor-quality hosts may thus be an expression of lower per-adult fecundity. Nevertheless, sufficient numbers of large, fecund flies are produced in low-pollination localities to make this last explanation less convincing.     

A methodology for risk analysis of plurivorous fungi in biological weed control: Sclerotinia sclerotiorum as a model

In New Zealand, research is being performed on the use of the ubiquitous plurivorous ascomycete Sclerotinia sclerotiorum, as a biocontrol agent for Cirsium arvense in pasture. As a consequence of the wide host range of this fungus, the proposed biocontrol may pose a risk to non-target arable plants. Crop disease risk is primarily due to the formation of sclerotia. These perennating bodies may directly infect susceptible crops sown at the biocontrol site in years after the biocontrol event. Additionally they may cause infection in neighbouring crops through the formation of apothecia from which airborne ascospores are dispersed. A methodology for a risk analysis is proposed, embodying both temporal and spatial processes, where the relative disease risk from biocontrol is defined as the ratio of added to naturally occurring inoculum.Exponential decay is proposed as a suitable model for the survival of sclerotia in soils beneath pastures, and data from an ongoing study are used in a preliminary parameterisation. The model is applied to published data on initial sclerotium population size and unpublished data on natural levels of soilborne sclerotia, to reveal how a withholding period, defined as the interval of time that must elapse for the ratio of added to natural inoculum to equal unity, may be calculated.For quantifying escape and aerial dispersal of ascospores from a treated pasture, three mechanistic models are proposed. Firstly, a simple one-layer model of escape, giving a provisional estimation of 81% of released ascospores escaping the pasture canopy, is discussed. Secondly, ascospore dispersal within and close to the biocontrol site (<30 m) is described by a model revealing abrupt decline in the atmospheric concentration of ascospores within short distances from the biocontrol site. Thirdly, for predicting ascospore concentrations at greater distances (>100 m), a Gaussian plume model is proposed. In a first approximation, these models are used in an example calculation to show how a hypothetical safety zone might be determined. A map of the province of Canterbury showing the locations of different agricultural activities and infestations of dense populations of C. arvense, revealed that potential biocontrol sites mostly do not border arable land and that a safety zone would therefore be feasible.The study presented here provides conceptual and mathematical frameworks for risk analysis of the use of plurivorous fungi in biological weed control, using S. sclerotiorum as an example. However, before a judgement may be made about the phytosanitory risks associated with the use of S. sclerotiorum to control C. arvense in pastures in Canterbury, the models developed in this paper must be parameterized using data collected under a wide range of conditions in the field.     

Enhancing incidence of Puccinia punctiformis, through mowing, to improve management of Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense)

Biological control of Canada thistle using Puccinia punctiformis has been largely unsuccessful in part due to a low incidence of systemically infected shoots and heterogeneous distribution of teliospores in the soil. The present study investigated the feasibility of strategic mowing to improve incidence of systemically infected shoots, and enhance intra- and/or inter-season disease development in two unused pastures. Mid-season mowing of plots in July lead to a greater proportion of systemically infected shoots in experimental plots observed at seasons’ end compared to unmowed plots. Late-season mowing in September resulted in the highest levels of systemically infected shoots early the next summer. Over time, September mowing treatments significantly increased the proportion of systemically infected shoots compared to no mowing. The number of healthy shoots declined over time in mowed plots, whereas the number of healthy shoots in unmowed plots either increased or remained constant. These effects were observed in experimental plots in both pastures. It is proposed that mowing followed by regrowth of systemically infected shoots may help overcome the monocyclic nature of the pathogen and enhance severity of this disease.     

Increased performance of Cirsium arvense from the invasive range

The Evolution of Increased Competitive Ability (EICA) hypothesis suggests that plants from the invasive range should perform better than plants of the same species from the native range. To properly test this, we need to compare growth of plants from the two ranges in a common environment. Ideally, all the natural enemies should be excluded, to make sure that the differences are not due to different response of plants from the two ranges to the natural enemies. We used the above design to examine the difference in growth and reproduction in Cirsium arvense plants from the invasive (North America) and native range (Europe). To account for possible differences within the ranges, we used plants from two regions, separated by at least 1000 km, in each range. Because the higher performance of species from the invasive range can be caused by their higher ability to acquire resources we compared growth of the plants in two different nutrient levels. The results indicate that plants from the invasive range are larger in most size parameters as well as parameters more closely related to fitness. For aboveground biomass, the response of plants from the invasive range to nutrient addition was weaker than that of plants from the native range and the difference between the ranges was stronger in the nutrient poor substrate. The results are in agreement with the EICA hypothesis and suggest that plants from the invasive range have higher ability to use resources and are thus able to perform well also in nutrient poor conditions.     

Grasshopper response to a 40-year experimental burning and mowing regime, with recommendations for invertebrate conservation management

Grasshopper assemblages were sampled in 44 plots in each of three adjacent sites in a 40-year-old southern tall grassland experimental area in South Africa. Specific plots received particular mowing and/or burning treatments over the 40-year period. Grasshopper responses to vegetation type, and to different burning and mowing practices, were site-specific, despite the close proximity of sites. This suggests that grasshopper assemblage composition is not entirely deterministic and depends on the trajectory of plant succession. Grasshopper species richness and abundance decreased from annually to triennially burnt plots, and increased in plots mown once per year to plots mown three times per year. Burning in the first week of August (winter) was more favourable for grasshopper assemblages than burning in autumn or after the first spring rains. Mean grasshopper species richness was highest in plots mown after the first spring rains, and the mean number of individuals was highest i n plots mown early in summer. When annually burnt plots were compared with annually mown plots, grasshopper abundance and species richness were highest in the burnt plots. A rotational winter burning programme, which is practical under African conditions, is recommended for the conservation of grasshoppers and other invertebrates.     

Effect of abandonment and plant classification on carbohydrate reserves of meadow plants

We studied the effect of cessation of management on carbohydrate reserves of plants in meadows with different environmental characteristics and plant composition. We recorded storage carbohydrates and seasonal changes for 40 plant species. We asked whether there are differences in responses of carbohydrate reserves in forbs versus graminoids and in plants storing starch versus plants storing osmotically active carbohydrates. We analysed belowground organs before the meadows were mown and at the end of the vegetation season in mown versus recently abandoned plots. Whereas starch and fructans were widely distributed, raffinose family oligosaccharides were the main carbohydrate reserves of the Lamiaceae and Plantago lanceolata. Properties of carbohydrate reserves differed between forbs and graminoids but no difference was found between plants storing starch versus osmotically active carbohydrates. Graminoids had lower carbohydrate concentrations than forbs. We observed a positive effect of mowing on carbohydrate concentrations of graminoids in the dry, calcium-rich meadow and higher seasonal fluctuations of these values in the acid, wet meadow, suggesting that local factors and/or the species pool affect carbohydrate reserves. Despite local conditions, graminoids represent a distinct functional group in meadows from the point of view of their storage economy. We suggest that as well as growth, storage processes should also be considered for understanding the functioning of meadow plant communities.     

Risk analysis for biological weed control – simulating dispersal of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (Lib.) de Bary ascospores from a pasture after biological control of Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop.

Biological control of Cirsium arvense(L.) Scop. in pasture by the plurivorous plantpathogenic fungus Sclerotiniasclerotiorum (Lib.) de Bary mayresult in the formation, escape and aerialdispersal of ascospores, creating an additionaldisease risk in down-wind market garden crops. To determine the width of a safety zone for apasture subjected to this form of weed control,we simulated the spatial pattern in the ratioof added (due to biocontrol) to naturallyoccurring airborne ascospores (due to marketgarden crops) around a 1ha virtual biocontrolpasture under either sheep or dairy cattlegazing over a 91-day emission period in 1996 inCanterbury, New Zealand. This was achievedusing a unique combination of two computermodels; SPORESIM-1D (for spore escape from avegetation source) and PC-STACKS (a modernGaussian plume model for dispersal beyond asource). Plumes of dispersing ascospores weremodelled for each hour of the emission periodfor both the virtual market garden andbiocontrol sites, and the aerial density of theascospores was averaged over the period. Assuming that a 1:1 ratio of added to naturallypresent spores is acceptable, no safety zonewas necessary for either of the modeledpastures. A ten-fold ratio (1:10 added tonatural) necessitated safety zones of 300 and150 m for the sheep and dairy pasturerespectively. Uncertainties associated withextrapolation of this conclusion to individualpasture management scenarios, and to otheryears and climatically different regions arediscussed.     

Integrating multiple disturbance aspects: management of an invasive thistle,Carduus nutans

Background and Aims

Disturbances occur in most ecological systems, and play an important role in biological invasions. We delimit five key disturbance aspects: intensity, frequency, timing, duration and extent. Few studies address more than one of these aspects, yet interactions and interdependence between aspects may lead to complex outcomes.

Methods

In a two-cohort experimental study, we examined how multiple aspects (intensity, frequency and timing) of a mowing disturbance regime affect the survival, phenology, growth and reproduction of an invasive thistle Carduus nutans (musk thistle).

Key Results

Our results show that high intensity and late timing strongly delay flowering phenology and reduce plant survival, capitulum production and plant height. A significant interaction between intensity and timing further magnifies the main effects. Unexpectedly, high frequency alone did not effectively reduce reproduction. However, a study examining only frequency and intensity, and not timing, would have erroneously attributed the importance of timing to frequency.

Conclusions

We used management of an invasive species as an example to demonstrate the importance of a multiple-aspect disturbance framework. Failure to consider possible interactions, and the inherent interdependence of certain aspects, could result in misinterpretation and inappropriate management efforts. This framework can be broadly applied to improve our understanding of disturbance effects on individual responses, population dynamics and community composition.     

Effects of delayed hay removal on the nutrient balance of roadside plant communities

1. Mass losses and nutrient losses from fresh roadside cuttings were studied in the field during a 6-week period. Large amounts (over 50%) appear to be lost from the cuttings. The losses were positively related to initial nutrient concentrations during this short-term study. Mass and nitrogen losses were best explained by the initial C:N ratio, phosphorus and potassium losses by the initial phosphorus concentration.
2. For potassium the losses were particularly large (up to 90%). For this element only, the observed relationship between loss rate and initial chemical composition could not be established significantly. It is concluded that potassium is mainly lost by leaching whereas the major nitrogen, phosphorus and mass losses are most probably caused by rapid microbial decomposition of readily soluble substances.
3. Using existing data on chemical composition of other roadside cuttings, nutrient losses after different hay removal delay times were modelled for different plant communities. All or most of the losses were assumed to return to the soil system.
4. When soil impoverishment is aimed for, cuttings should be removed within 1 or 2 weeks in most plant communities. If removal is delayed longer, the amounts of nutrients removed will often fall below the annual atmospheric input. In plant communities where annual above-ground production of nitrogen and phosphorus are lower than the annual atmospheric deposition already, rapid removal of the cuttings may be the only way to maintain at least potassium at a limiting level.
5. The main effect of hay-making on the soil nutrient status most likely consists of a reduction of the potassium availability, at least on sandy soils with a low cation exchange capacity and provided there is little delay in hay removal.