Peptidic termini play a significant role in TCR recognition

TCR recognition of class I MHC is dependent on the composition of the antigenic peptide and the MHC. Single amino acid substitutions in either the MHC or the peptide may dramatically alter recognition. While the major interactions between TCR and the peptide/MHC complex appear to be focused on the complementarity-determining region (CDR)3, it is also clear from the cocrystal structure of class I MHC and TCR that the amino and carboxyl ends of the peptide may play a role through interactions with the CDR1. In this work we show that gp33 variants substituted at the peptidic termini at the putative CDR1 contact regions show improved recognition in B6 mice. The rank order of recognition is different using the P14 transgenic T cells, suggesting that one reason for improved recognition is a change in the TCR repertoire that recognizes the peptide. However, the affinity of the TCR by some of the peptide/MHC complex with increased recognition is improved, as shown by increased tetramer binding to P14 T cells. These substitutions at the termini of the peptide-binding cleft cause localized conformational changes as seen by changes in mAb binding and crystallographic structures. The different peptide structures also show different conformations in the center of the peptide, but these are shown to be energetically similar and thus most likely have no significance with respect to TCR recognition. Therefore, small conformational changes, localized to the CDR1 contact regions, may play a significant role in TCR recognition.     

Dual T cell receptor expressing CD8+ T cells with tumor- and self-specificity can inhibit tumor growth without causing severe autoimmunity

The engineering of Ag-specific T cells by expression of TCR genes is a convenient method for adoptive T cell immunotherapy. A potential problem is the TCR gene transfer into self-reactive T cells that survived tolerance mechanisms. We have developed an experimental system with T cells that express two TCRs with defined Ag-specificities, one recognizing a tumor-specific Ag (LCMV-gp(33)), the other recognizing a self-Ag in the pancreas (OVA). By using tumor cells expressing high and low amounts of Ag and mice expressing high and low levels of self-Ag in the pancreas (RIP-OVA-Hi and RIP-OVA-Lo), we show that 1) tumor rejection requires high amount of tumor Ag, 2) severe autoimmunity requires high amount of self-Ag, and 3) if Ag expression on tumor cells is sufficient and low in the pancreas, successful adoptive T cell therapy can be obtained in the absence of severe autoimmunity. These results are shown with T cells from dual TCR transgenic mice or T cells that were redirected by TCR gene transfer. Our data demonstrate that the approach of adoptively transferring TCR redirected T cells can be effective without severe side effects, even when high numbers of T cells with self-reactivity were transferred.     

Cutting edge: competition for APC by CTLs of different specificities is not functionally important during induction of antiviral responses

The hypothesis that T cell competition for access to APC influences priming of CTL responses is a controversial issue. A recent study using OVA as a model Ag supports this hypothesis and received considerable attention. However, using a comparable approach, we reached a different conclusion. We analyzed whether TCR transgenic T cells specific for lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus gp33-41/D(b) could inhibit the priming of endogenous responses against gp33-41 and against two other lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein-derived CTL epitopes. After priming with different stimuli, gp33-41/D(b)-specific TCR transgenic T cells reduced the endogenous gp33-41/D(b) response in a dose-dependent way, but all other endogenous responses were unaffected. Even when >10(6) TCR transgenic cells were combined with weak priming, no reduction of responses other than of those specific for gp33-41/D(b) was observed. Thus, competition for APC by CTLs of different specificities is not of functional relevance in antiviral immune responses.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes generated by short-term in vitro TCR stimulation in the presence of IL-4 are therapeutically effective against B16 melanoma

P14 TCR transgenic CD8+ T cells (LCMV gp33-specific) were activated by antigen in the presence of either IL-2 or IL-2+IL-4 to generate effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs). The therapeutic effectiveness of such IL-2- or IL-2+IL-4-grown CTLs was tested in mice that had received intravenous inoculations of B16.gp33 melanoma cells 7 days previously. Administration of P14 CTLs activated by antigen +IL-2+IL-4 was significantly more effective at reducing melanoma colony formation in the lung than those grown in the presence of antigen +IL-2. Highly significant improvement in survival was observed with 80% of B16.gp33-inoculated mice showing long-term survival after therapy with 10×10⁶ antigen +IL-2+IL-4-activated P14 CTLs. Similar therapeutic effectiveness of antigen +IL-2+IL-4-activated P14 CTLs against subcutaneously inoculated B16.gp33 melanoma cells was also found. There was significant reduction in P14 CD8+ T cells in the peripheral blood of B16.gp33-inoculated mice than in mice that did not receive B16.gp33 melanoma cells, indicating possible homing of P14 CD8+ T cells to the site of tumor growth or antigen-induced apoptotic cell death. These results may have implications in tumor therapy using CTLs grown ex vivo, especially during early stages of tumor formation. They also support the concept that the therapeutic effectiveness of CTLs can be governed by the cytokine context in which they are activated.     

Rapid and selective expansion of nonclonotypic T cells in regulatory T cell-deficient, foreign antigen-specific TCR-transgenic scurfy mice: antigen-dependent expansion and TCR analysis

Foreign Ag-specific TCR-transgenic (Tg) mice contain a small fraction of T cells bearing the endogenous Vbeta and Valpha chains as well as a population expressing an intermediate level of Tg TCR. Importantly, these minor nonclonotypic populations contain > or = 99% of the CD4(+)Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells (Treg) and, despite low overall Treg expression, peripheral tolerance is maintained. In the OT-II TCR (OVA-specific, Vbeta5(high)Valpha2(high)) Tg scurfy (Sf) mice (OT-II Sf) that lack Treg, nonclonotypic T cells markedly expanded in the periphery but not in the thymus. Expanded T cells expressed memory/effector phenotype and were enriched in blood and inflamed lungs. In contrast, Vbeta5(high)Valpha2(high) clonotypic T cells were not expanded, displayed the naive phenotype, and found mainly in the lymph nodes. Importantly, Vbeta5(neg) T cells were able to transfer multiorgan inflammation in Rag1(-/-) recipients. T cells bearing dual TCR (dual Vbeta or dual Valpha) were demonstrated frequently in the Vbeta5(int) and Valpha2(int) populations. Our study demonstrated that in the absence of Treg, the lack of peripheral expansion of clonotypic T cells is due to the absence of its high-affinity Ag OVA. Thus, the rapid expansion of nonclonotypic T cells in OT-II Sf mice must require Ag (self and foreign) with sufficient affinity. Our study has implications with respect to the roles of Ag and dual TCR in the selection and regulation of Treg and Treg-controlled Ag-dependent T cell expansion in TCR Tg and TCR Tg Sf mice, respectively.     

Chronic modulation of the TCR repertoire in the lymphoid periphery

Using TCR V beta 5 transgenic mice as a model system, we demonstrate that the induction of peripheral tolerance can mold the TCR repertoire throughout adult life. In these mice, three distinct populations of peripheral T cells are affected by chronic selective events in the lymphoid periphery. First, CD4+V beta 5+ T cells are deleted in the lymphoid periphery by superantigens encoded by mouse mammary tumor viruses-8 and -9 in an MHC class II-dependent manner. Second, mature CD8+V beta 5+ T cells transit through a CD8lowV beta 5low deletional intermediate during tolerance induction by a process that depends upon neither mouse mammary tumor virus-encoded superantigens nor MHC class II expression. Third, a population of CD4-CD8-V beta 5+ T cells arises in the lymphoid periphery in an age-dependent manner. We analyzed the TCR V alpha repertoire of each of these cellular compartments in both V beta 5 transgenic and nontransgenic C57BL/6 mice as a function of age. This analysis revealed age-related changes in the expression of V alpha families among different cellular compartments, highlighting the dynamic state of the peripheral immune repertoire. Our work indicates that the chronic processes maintaining peripheral T cell tolerance can dramatically shape the available TCR repertoire.     

B cell-dependent TCR diversification

T cell diversity was once thought to depend on the interaction of T cell precursors with thymic epithelial cells. Recent evidence suggests, however, that diversity might arise through the interaction of developing T cells with other cells, the identity of which is not known. In this study we show that T cell diversity is driven by B cells and Ig. The TCR V beta diversity of thymocytes in mice that lack B cells and Ig is reduced to 6 x 10(2) from wild-type values of 1.1 x 10(8); in mice with oligoclonal B cells, the TCR V beta diversity of thymocytes is 0.01% that in wild-type mice. Adoptive transfer of diverse B cells or administration of polyclonal Ig increases thymocyte diversity in mice that lack B cells 8- and 7-fold, respectively, whereas adoptive transfer of monoclonal B cells or monoclonal Ig does not. These findings reveal a heretofore unrecognized and vital function of B cells and Ig for generation of T cell diversity and suggest a potential approach to immune reconstitution.     

The role of TCR engagement and activation-induced cell death in sepsis-induced T cell apoptosis

Sepsis induces extensive apoptosis in T and B cells suggesting that the loss of immune effector cells could be one explanation for the profound immunosuppression observed in this disorder. Unfortunately, the mechanisms responsible for lymphocyte apoptosis in sepsis remain unknown. In T cells, apoptosis can occur through activation-induced cell death (AICD) in which engagement of the Ag receptors by cognate Ag or polyclonal activators such as bacteria-derived superantigens induces activation, proliferation, and apoptosis. We examined whether proliferation and AICD are necessary for apoptotic cell death in sepsis using normal and TCR transgenic mice. Results show that although sepsis resulted in activation of a small percentage of T cells, no proliferation was detected during the first 48 h following onset, a time when extensive apoptosis is observed. We also observed that T cells do not enter the cell cycle, and stimulation via the TCR in TCR transgenic animals does not enhance or decrease cell death in sepsis. Interestingly, T cells recovered from septic mice retained their ability to proliferate and synthesize cytokines albeit at reduced levels. With the exception of IL-10, which was increased in lymphocytes from mice with sepsis, sepsis caused a decrease in the production of both proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines. We conclude that lymphocyte apoptosis in sepsis does not require proliferation, TCR engagement, or AICD. Thus the immunosuppression observed in sepsis cannot be the result of T cell deletion via the TCR.     

TCR revision generates functional CD4+ T cells

CD4(+)Vβ5(+) peripheral T cells in C57BL/6 mice respond to encounter with a peripherally expressed endogenous superantigen by undergoing either deletion or TCR revision. In this latter process, cells lose surface Vβ5 expression and undergo RAG-dependent rearrangement of endogenous TCRβ genes, driving surface expression of novel TCRs. Although postrevision CD4(+)Vβ5(-)TCRβ(+) T cells accumulate with age in Vβ5 transgenic mice and bear a diverse TCR Vβ repertoire, it is unknown whether they respond to homeostatic and antigenic stimuli and thus may benefit the host. We demonstrate in this study that postrevision cells are functional. These cells have a high rate of steady-state homeostatic proliferation in situ, and they undergo extensive MHC class II-dependent lymphopenia-induced proliferation. Importantly, postrevision cells do not proliferate in response to the tolerizing superantigen, implicating TCR revision as a mechanism of tolerance induction and demonstrating that TCR-dependent activation of postrevision cells is not driven by the transgene-encoded receptor. Postrevision cells proliferate extensively to commensal bacterial Ags and can generate I-A(b)-restricted responses to Ag by producing IFN-γ following Listeria monocytogenes challenge. These data show that rescued postrevision T cells are responsive to homeostatic signals and recognize self- and foreign peptides in the context of self-MHC and are thus useful to the host.     

Study of the mechanism of TCR antagonism using dual-TCR-expressing T cells

The mechanism of action of TCR antagonists is incompletely understood. T cells expressing two distinct TCRs have been used to test competition for TCR occupancy as a potential mechanism. Previous studies with CD4 T cells showed that an antagonist for one TCR inhibited the response to the other TCR (cross-antagonism), whereas studies with CD8 cells failed to demonstrate cross-antagonism. To determine whether CD4 and CD8 cells were intrinsically different or whether the differences were the result of the use of different effector assays, we studied both CD4 and CD8 dual-TCR-expressing T cells. In the CD4 system, consistent with previous reports, cross-antagonism of proliferation was observed. In the CD8 system, cross-antagonism was observed using proliferation as readout but not when target cell cytolysis was used. These results suggest that different mechanisms may be involved in the inhibition of proliferation and inhibition of cytotoxic effector function, the latter only involving competition for TCR occupancy. Inhibition of proliferation appears to be more complex and other mechanisms such as sequestration of signaling molecules or negative signaling may be involved. The fact that 10- to 20-fold more antagonist was needed to achieve cross-antagonism compared with inhibition of the cognate TCR is consistent with the hypothesis that competition for TCR occupancy is also a major, albeit not sole, mechanism of antagonism of the proliferative responses of CD4 and CD8 cells.     

Adaptable TCR avidity thresholds for negative selection

Central tolerance plays a significant role in preventing autoimmune diseases by eliminating T cells with high and intermediate avidity for self. To determine the manner of setting the threshold for deletion, we created a unique transgenic mouse strain with a diverse T cell population and globally increased TCR avidity for self-peptide/MHC complexes. Despite the adaptations aimed at reducing T cell reactivity (reduced TCR levels and increased levels of TCR signaling inhibitor CD5), transgenic mice displayed more severe experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and lupus. The numbers and activity of natural (CD4(+)CD25(+)) regulatory T cells were not altered. These findings demonstrate that the threshold for deletion is adaptable, allowing survival of T cells with higher avidity when TCR avidity is globally increased.     

Competition for specific intrathymic ligands limits positive selection in a TCR transgenic model of CD4+ T cell development

Efficient positive selection of a broad repertoire of T cells is dependent on the presentation of a diverse array of endogenous peptides on MHC molecules in the thymus. It is unclear, however, whether the development of individual TCR specificities is influenced by the abundance of their selecting ligands. To examine this, we analyzed positive selection in a transgenic mouse carrying a TCR specific for the human CLIP:I-Ab class II complex. We found that these mice exhibit significantly reduced CD4+ T cell development compared with two other transgenic mice carrying TCRs selected on I-Ab. Moreover, many of the selected cells in these mice express endogenous and transgenic receptors as a consequence of dual TCRalpha expression. Dramatic enhancement of the selection efficiency is observed, however, when fewer transgenic cells populate the thymus in mixed bone marrow chimeras. These results suggest that positive selection is limited by the availability of selecting peptides in the thymus. This becomes apparent when large numbers of thymocytes compete for such peptides in TCR transgenic animals. Under such conditions, thymocytes appear to undergo further TCRalpha gene rearrangement to produce a receptor that may be selected more efficiently by other thymic self-peptides.     

Peptide fine specificity of anti-glycoprotein 100 CTL is preserved following transfer of engineered TCR alpha beta genes into primary human T lymphocytes

TCR with known antitumor reactivity can be genetically introduced into primary human T lymphocytes and provide promising tools for immunogene therapy of tumors. We molecularly characterized two distinct TCRs specific for the same HLA-A2-restricted peptide derived from the melanocyte differentiation Ag gp100, yet exhibiting different stringencies in peptide requirements. The existence of these two distinct gp100-specific TCRs allowed us to study the preservation of peptide fine specificity of native TCRalphabeta when engineered for TCR gene transfer into human T lymphocytes. Retroviral transduction of primary human T lymphocytes with either one of the two sets of TCRalphabeta constructs enabled T lymphocytes to specifically kill and produce TNF-alpha when triggered by native gp100(pos)/HLA-A2(pos) tumor target cells as well as gp100 peptide-loaded HLA-A2(pos) tumor cells. Peptide titration studies revealed that the cytolytic efficiencies of the T lymphocyte transductants were in the same range as those of the parental CTL clones. Moreover, primary human T lymphocytes expressing either one of the two engineered gp100-specific TCRs show cytolytic activities in response to a large panel of peptide mutants that are identical with those of the parental CTL. The finding that two gp100-specific TCR, derived from two different CTL, can be functionally introduced into primary human T lymphocytes without loss of the Ag reactivity and peptide fine specificity, holds great promise for the application of TCR gene transfer in cancer immunotherapy.     

Different development of myelin basic protein agonist- and antagonist-specific human TCR transgenic T cells in the thymus and periphery

Myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific T cells are thought to play a role in the development of multiple sclerosis. MBP residues 111-129 compose an immunodominant epitope cluster restricted by HLA-DRB1*0401. The sequence of residues 111-129 of MBP (MBP(111-129)) differs in humans (MBP122:Arg) and mice (MBP122:Lys) at aa 122. We previously found that approximately 50% of human MBP(111-129) (MBP122:Arg)-specific T cell clones, including MS2-3C8 can proliferate in response to mouse MBP(111-129) (MBP122:Lys). However, the other half of T cell clones, including HD4-1C2, cannot proliferate in response to MBP(111-129) (MBP122:Lys). We found that MBP(111-129) (MBP122:Lys) is an antagonist for HD4-1C2 TCR, therefore, MS2-3C8 and HD4-1C2 TCRs are agonist- and antagonist-specific TCRs in mice, respectively. Therefore, we examined the development of HD4-1C2 TCR and MS2-3C8 TCR transgenic (Tg) T cells in the thymus and periphery. We found that dual TCR expression exclusively facilitates the development of MBP(111-129) TCR Tg T cells in the periphery of HD4-1C2 TCR/HLA-DRB1*0401 Tg mice although it is not required for their development in the thymus. We also found that MS2-3C8 TCR Tg CD8(+) T cells develop along with MS2-3C8 TCR Tg CD4(+) T cells, and that dual TCR expression was crucial for the development of MS2-3C8 TCR Tg CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells in the thymus and periphery, respectively. These results suggest that thymic and peripheral development of MBP-specific T cells are different; however, dual TCR expression can facilitate their development.     

Exclusion and inclusion of TCR alpha proteins during T cell development in TCR-transgenic and normal mice

Allelic exclusion of immune receptor genes (and molecules) is incompletely understood. With regard to TCRalphabeta lineage T cells, exclusion at the tcr-b, but not tcr-a, locus seems to be strictly controlled at the locus rearrangement level. Consequently, while nearly all developing TCRalphabeta thymocytes express a single TCRbeta protein, many thymocytes rearrange and express two different TCRalpha chains and, thus, display two alphabetaTCRs on the cell surface. Of interest, the number of such dual TCR-expressing cells is appreciably lower among the mature T cells. To understand the details of TCR chain regulation at various stages of T cell development, we analyzed TCR expression in mice transgenic for two rearranged alphabetaTCR. We discovered that in such TCR double-transgenic (TCRdTg) mice peripheral T cells were functionally monospecific. Molecularly, this monospecificity was due to TCRalpha exclusion: one transgenic TCRalpha protein was selectively down-regulated from the thymocyte and T cell surface. In searching for the mechanism(s) governing this selective TCRalpha down-regulation, we present evidence for the role of protein tyrosine kinase signaling and coreceptor involvement. This mechanism may be operating in normal thymocytes.     

CD4+ TCR repertoire heterogeneity in Schistosoma mansoni-induced granulomas

The hallmark of Schistosoma mansoni infection is the formation of liver granulomas around deposited ova. The initiation of granuloma formation is T cell-dependent since granulomas are not formed in their absence. We investigated whether a few T cells arrive to initiate the inflammatory lesion and subsequently expand locally, or whether a large repertoire of systemically activated T cells home to the delayed type hypersensitivity reaction induced by the ova. The TCR repertoire of single granulomas from the same liver were analyzed by PCR using Vbeta-specific primers and CDR3 analysis. Each granuloma has a very diverse TCR repertoire indicating that most of the T cells recruited to these lesions are activated systemically. At the same time, sequence analysis of individually sized CDR3 products from single granuloma indicate that a fraction of T cells expand locally at the lesion site. Using TCR transgenic mice containing a pigeon cytochrome c-specific T cell population or lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus infection tracked with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus-specific tetramers, we demonstrated that nonspecific T cells home to the granuloma if they are activated. However, recombinase-activating gene 2(-/-) pigeon cytochrome c-specific TCR transgenic mice fail to form granulomas in response to S. mansoni ova even after T cell activation, suggesting a requirement for egg-specific T cells in the initiation of these inflammatory lesions. Understanding the mechanism of T cell recruitment into granulomas has important implications for the rational design of immunotherapies for granulomatous diseases.     

Virus-induced activation of self-specific TCR alpha beta CD8 alpha alpha intraepithelial lymphocytes does not abolish their self-tolerance in the intestine

TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) represent an enigmatic subset of T cells, particularly, in regard to their potential functions and the apparent persistence of cells expressing self-specific TCR. We have used mice that are transgenic for the TCRalphabeta specific for the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-derived peptide gp33, and TCRalphabeta-transgenic mice that coexpress the gp33 Ag ubiquitously, to analyze the functional properties of TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha IEL in the presence, or absence, of their specific MHC-restricted Ag, and to assess the impact of molecular mimicry during a potent LCMV infection on potentially self-reactive TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha IEL. In this study, we show that the presence of the specific self-Ag results in reduced expression of IL-2, IFN-gamma, and IL-10 by resident TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha IEL while expression of mRNA for TGFbeta is not affected. We further demonstrate that despite their secluded location in the epithelium, TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha IEL are activated after infection of the intestinal mucosa with LCMV. Importantly, LCMV-induced activation of self-specific TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha IEL does not reverse their tolerance as no cytotoxic activity or up-regulated expression of proinflammatory cytokines is detected and no overt signs of autoimmunity are seen. Taken together, these results are in support of an immunoregulatory role for self-specific TCRalphabeta CD8alphaalpha in the intestinal mucosa and clearly speak against an involvement of this cell subset in inflammatory reactions and tissue destruction.