The kinetics of hematopoietic stem cells during and after hypoxia. A model analysis

A previously described mathematical model of the hematopoietic stem cell system has been extended to permit a detailed understanding of the data during and after hypoxia. The model includes stem cells, erythroid and granuloid progenitors and precursors. Concerning the intramedullary feedback mechanisms two basic assumptions are made: 1) The fraction "a" of CFU-S in active cell cycle is regulated. Reduced cell densities of CFU-S, progenitors or precursors lead to an accelerated stem cell cycling. Enlarged cell densities suppress cycling. 2) The self renewal probability "p" of CFU-S is also regulated. The normal steady state is described by p = 0.5, indicating that on statistical average each dividing mother stem cell is replaced by one daughter stem cell, while the second differentiates. Diminished cell densities of CFU-S or enlarged densities of progenitors and precursors induce a more intensive self renewal (p greater than 0.5), such that the stem cell number increases. The self renewal probability declines (p less than 0.5) if too many CFU-S or too few progenitors and precursors are present. The model reproduces bone marrow data for CFU-S, BFU-E, CFU-C, CFU-E, 59 Fe-uptake and nucleated cells in hypoxia and posthypoxia. Although the ratio of differentiation into the erythroid and granuloid cell lines is kept constant in the model, a changing ratio of CFU-E and CFU-C results. The model suggests that stem cells and progenitor cells are regulated by a regulatory interference of erythropoiesis and granulopoiesis.     

Hemopoietic precursor cell defects in nonanemic but stem cell-deficient W44/W44 mice

Hematopoietic stem cell deficiencies cause a severe macrocytic anemia in W/Wv mice. W44/W44 mice, on the other hand, are not anemic, but, since they accept marrow implants without prior total body irradiation, they have inherited a stem cell lesion. In an attempt to identify the aberrant stem cell(s), we have determined the concentration in W44/W44 marrow of hematopoietic precursors known to be deficient in W/Wv marrow. The in vitro erythroid burst-forming units (BFU-E), the in vivo spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S), and the cells that repopulate the erythroid compartment of stem cell-deficient mice were examined. The progenitors of 7-day bursts are dramatically reduced in W/Wv marrow but are present in normal concentrations in W44/W44 marrow. W44/W44 marrow CFU-S, unlike W/Wv, generate visible spleen colonies 10 days after injection into lethally irradiated recipients. The colonies are, however, smaller and at least 2 times less numerous than those produced from equivalent numbers of +/+ marrow. An additional defect was the inability of W44/W44 stem cells to compete with genetically marked +/+ cells during erythroid repopulation. An estimate of the number of W44/W44 stem cells needed to compete with +/+ cells was provided by enriching W44/W44 progenitors fivefold. Twice as many enriched W44/W44 marrow cells as unfractionated +/+ cells were required to replace competitor cells. This suggests that there are up to 10 times fewer stem cells somewhere in the W44/W44 erythrogenerative pathway. The data support the conclusion that an erythroid progenitor less mature than the BFU-E is one of the cells most severely affected by expression of the mutant gene.     

Radioprotection of mice with interleukin-1: relationship to the number of spleen colony-forming units

Compared to saline-injected mice 9 days after 6.5 Gy irradiation, there were twofold more Day 8 spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S) per femur and per spleen from B6D2F1 mice administered a radioprotective dose of human recombinant interleukin-1-alpha (rIL-1) 20 h prior to their irradiation. Studies in the present report compared the numbers of CFU-S in nonirradiated mice 20 h after saline or rIL-1 injection. Prior to irradiation, the number of Day 8 CFU-S was not significantly different in the bone marrow or spleens from saline-injected mice and rIL-1-injected mice. Also, in the bone marrow, the number of Day 12 CFU-S was similar for both groups of mice. Similar seeding efficiencies for CFU-S and percentage of CFU-S in S phase of the cell cycle provided further evidence that rIL-1 injection did not increase the number of CFU-S prior to irradiation. In a marrow repopulation assay, cellularity as well as the number of erythroid colony-forming units, erythroid burst-forming units, and granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells per femur of lethally irradiated mice were not increased in recipient mice of donor cells from rIL-1-injected mice. These results demonstrated that a twofold increase in the number of CFU-S at the time of irradiation was not necessary for the earlier recovery of CFU-S observed in mice irradiated with sublethal doses of radiation 20 h after rIL-1 injection.     

Radiosensitivity and proliferative activity of vertebral CFU-S surviving in mice injected with oncogenic activities of 239Pu or 241Am

Survival, radiosensitivity and capability to produce differentiated progeny were followed in CFU-S from lumbar vertebrae of mice injected with 198.6 kBq 239Pu/kg or 208.6 kBq 241Am/kg. The CFU-S assay and 59Fe uptake into spleen colonies were used. The number of CFU-S from treated mice was significantly lower than in controls. Higher radiosensitivity of CFU-S from 239Pu- or 241Am-treated mice was demonstrated using additional exposure to 0.5 Gy X-rays 1, 24, 48, 72 hrs after cell transplantation and expressed more precisely by survival curves obtained 1 hr after the marrow cell injection. The effect of 239Pu on CFU-S was characterized by Do 0.58 Gy (n = 0.91) and that of 241Am by Do 0.64 Gy (n = 0.91); corresponding control values were Do 0.89 Gy, n = 1.11. Lower iron utilization due not only to the decreased CFU-S numbers, but also to the defective production of erythroid cells per one CFU-S was found. Complexity of radiation effect on hemopoietic stem cells was demonstrated by the present study.     

Radiosensitivity of vertebral bone marrow CFU-S surviving in mice internally contaminated with239Pu or241Am

Summary The radiosensitivity of pluripotent hemopoietic stem cells was studied in ICR Swiss mice (28 g/mouse) given i.v. 198.6 kBq²³⁹Pu/kg as citrate complex or 208.6 kBq²⁴¹Am/kg as nitrate at the age of 10 weeks. The bone marrow cells were examined at the early and late phases of radionuclide contamination. To obtain data for survival curves andD ₀ of stem cells the CFU-S assay was used and the donor vertebral marrow cells were exposed to the complementary X-irradiation either early after injection to the heavily irradiated recipients or to the in vitro irradiation given before the transplantation. To determine the iron uptake in splenic erythroid progeny the recipients given marrow cells unexposed to the X-rays received 37 kBq⁵⁹Fe 6 h before they were killed and the relative activity per colony was calculated. The radiation effect of the used actinides on the bone marrow cells resulted in decreased cellularity and seriously altered both relative and absolute CFU-S numbers. The radiosensitivity of CFU-S increased in all intervals examined (D ₀ from 0.60 to 0.86 Gy, in controls 0.97 to 1.06 Gy) and was more expressed when the CFU-S were exposed to the X-rays immediately after the bone marrow cell transplantation to the heavily irradiated hosts. The stem cell pool appeared, especially at older age, to be affected also in its ability to produce erythrocytic progeny.     

AN EARLY RESPONSE OF THE MORPHOLOGICALLY RECOGNIZABLE ERYTHROID PRECURSORS TO BLEEDING

⁵⁵Fe autoradiography of the peripheral red blood cells has been used to study the proliferation of the recognizable erythroid precursors in bled animals. The transit time of the recognizable erythroid precursors present in the bone marrow and labelled with ⁵⁵Fe 6 hr before bleeding, remains unchanged, but the number of red cells produced by these precursors is significantly greater than normal. It is deduced that the increased red cell production is brought about by an increase in the number of divisions that the cells undergo during maturation and that a shortening in the red cell cycle time is implied. The possibility that the transit time of the progeny of cells differentiating into pro-erythroblasts after bleeding may be shorter than the transit time of the precursors already differentiated before bleeding, is briefly discussed.     

PROLIFERATION OF ERYTHROID AND GRANULOCYTE PROGENITORS IN THE SPLEEN AS A FUNCTION OF STEM CELL DOSE

A study of the kinetics of cellular proliferation, in the morphologically unrecognizable haemopoietic progenitor cell compartment, as a function of injected CFU-S dose has been carried out in the spleens of lethally X-irradiated mice using ³H-TdR labelling. Amplification in this proliferating cell compartment was observed to decline as CFU-S dose increased. The number of divisions in the differentiated line arising from CFU-S up to the first appearance of recognizable erythroid precursors were calculated to be 9.2, 12.5, 15 and 17 for the 2, 0.35, 0.05 and 0.007 femur equivalent doses respectively. The growth of cell populations arising from CFU-S was biphasic, with a rapid initial phase having a doubling time of about 6.3 hr, and a slow phase of doubling time around 1 day. Analysis of the rapid phase by the FLM method gave a cycle time of 5.6 hr. Recognizable labelled erythroid precursors were detected at the same time as, or just after, the change in slope of the growth curve. Significant numbers of proliferating (labelled) granulocytes only appeared in the spleens of animals receiving the higher marrow doses (2 and 0.35 femur). The erythroid to granulocyte ratio was also a decreasing function of marrow dose.     

Proliferation of erythroid and granulocyte progenitors in the spleen as a function of stem cell dose.

A study of the kinetics of cellular proliferation, in the morphologically unrecongizable haemopoietic progenitor cell compartment, as a function of injected CFU-S dose has been carried out in the spleens of lethally X-irradiated mice using 3H-TdR labelling. Amplification in this proliferating cell compartment was observed to decline as CFU-S dose increased. The number of divisions in the differentiated line arising from CFU-S up to the first appearance of recognizable erythroid precursors were calculated to be 9-2, 12-5, 15 and 17 for the 2, 0-35, 0-05 and 0-007 femur equivalent doses respectively. The growth of cell populations arising from CFU-S was biphasic, with a rapid initial phase having a doubling time of about 6-3 hr, and a slow phase of doubling time around 1 day. Analysis of the rapid phase by the FLM method gave a cycle time of 5-6 hr, Recognizable labelled erythroid precursors were detected at the same time as, or just after, the change in slope of the growth curve. Significant numbers of proliferating (labelled) granulocytes only appeared in the spleens of animals receiving the higher marrow doses (2 and 0-35 femur). The erythroid to granulocyte ratio was also a decreasing function of marrow dose.     

Regulation of recovery in the erythroid lineage: model studies

Abstract. Based on data from the literature, the major regulatory features were established for the erythroid population regenerating after perturbation. A mathematical model is proposed which takes into account: (1) the increase in the proliferating CFU-S due to depopulation of CFU-S and BFU-E/8 pools due to increased migration caused by erythropoietin; (2) regeneration of erythroid precursors due to short-range factors and (3) gradual reduction in the short-range effects and increase in the humoral influence on BFU-E/8, BFU-E/3 and CFU-E together with short-range suppression of progenitor differentiation and acceleration of maturation in all subpopulations due to humoral factors. The kinetics of subpopulations as a function of feedback and maturation rate are analysed. The dependence of erythrocyte production on erythrocyte depletion in the blood and on the feedback coefficient is defined.     

Regulation of recovery in the erythroid lineage: model studies

Based on data from the literature, the major regulatory features were established for the erythroid population regenerating after perturbation. A mathematical model is proposed which takes into account: (1) the increase in the proliferating CFU-S due to depopulation of CFU-S and BFU-E/8 pools due to increased migration caused by erythropoietin; (2) regeneration of erythroid precursors due to short-range factors and (3) gradual reduction in the short-range effects and increase in the humoral influence on BFU-E/8, BFU-E/3 and CFU-E together with short-range suppression of progenitor differentiation and acceleration of maturation in all subpopulations due to humoral factors. The kinetics of subpopulations as a function of feedback and maturation rate are analysed. The dependence of erythrocyte production on erythrocyte depletion in the blood and on the feedback coefficient is defined.     

The development of radiation late effects to the bone marrow after single and chronic exposure

The marrow is a tissue distributed in numerous skeletal parts and works as an organ which is composed of a haemopoietic cell parenchyma and a supporting stroma. The pathophysiological mechanisms involved in the radiation-induced late effects depend mainly on the damage produced to each of these elements. Parenchymal cell damage ends with a failure of the stem cell pool to supply an adequate number of highly differentiated functional blood cells and is clinically manifested as aplastic anaemia or leukaemia. The effects of radiation on the haemopoietic stem cell can be measured by means of spleen colony forming units (CFU-S) in rodents. The self-maintaining capacity of the CFU-S was found to be lower than normal 16 weeks after a dose of 0.64 Gy. In larger animals it is only possible to measure the activity of some of the progenitor cells, estimating the number of granulocyte-macrophage colonies in culture (CFU-GM) as an indicator of stem cell changes. Their number in the blood is about 50 per cent of normal even 160 days after about 0.78 Gy. The stromal cells are also radiosensitive if measured with respect to their capacity to support long-term cell replication in vitro. Marrow fibrosis develops after single, repeated and chronic radiation exposure, and a dose of 40 Gy impairs the capacity of the marrow to support haemopoiesis.     

Thyroid hormones induce hemopoietic pluripotent stem cell differentiation toward erythropoiesis through the production of pluripoietin-like factors

We have previously reported that E pluripoietins are produced in mice after a single 20-mg injection of cytosine arabinoside (Ara-C) and that they are able to initiate the determination of hemopoietic pluripotent stem cells (CFU-S) toward the erythrocytic lineage. However, the mechanism of E pluripoietin release is still unclear. Since the stimulating effect of thyroid hormone on erythropoiesis is well known, we postulated a link between this hormone and the E pluripoietins. In previous papers we demonstrated that L-triiodothyronine (LT3) exhibits the capacity of inducing CFU-S differentiation toward erythropoiesis in vitro. Two series of data presented here suggest that LT3 acts indirectly on CFU-S determination by promoting the release of E pluripoietin-like factors. First, the Ara-C injection which induces the production of E pluripoietins in mice also promotes an increase in the LT3 plasma level. Second, medium conditioned with bone marrow cells exposed in vitro for 90 min to LT3 (even though this medium does not contain LT3) has E pluripoietin-like effects, inducing CFU-S differentiation toward the erythrocytic lineage.     

Ultrastructural Aspects of Erythropoietic Differentiation in Long-term Bone Marrow Culture

Long-term liquid cultures of mouse bone marrow produce stem cells (CFU-S) and differentiated granulocytes for many months. Addition of AMS (anaemic mouse serum) to the cultures almost entirely eliminates the granulopoietic activity and stimulates erythropoiesis, with full erythroid maturation and the production of adult haemoglobin. Ultrastructural analsysis of in situ fixed material reveals the cell shape and surface morphology of the erythroid maturation series, and the generation of erythroblastic islands in vitro. Each erythroblastic island consists of one or more synchronously maturing cohorts of erythroid cells undergoing four or five divisions between proerythroblast and normoblast. Each island is centered on a macrophage, which interacts with the developing erythroid population in several ways. Expelled nuclei are phagocytosed by the macrophage, which also has large areas of closely apposed membrane with the erythroid cells, gap junctions, and possible reciprocal vesicular activity. Changes in the adherent layer (stromal cells) also occur with the transition from granulopoiesis to erythropoiesis. There is a reduction in the endothelial cell cover, and mobilisation of lipid from the granulopoietic associated apidocytes.     

Evidence for the repair of potentially lethal damage in irradiated bone marrow

Summary The effects on cell survival of maintaining bone marrow cells (CFU-S) in situ following irradiation and before assay by transplantation was investigated. When the CFU-S cells are maintained in situ following irradiation survival drops and plateaus at about 9 h post-irradiation. Evidence is presented that this decrease in survival may be due to potentially lethal damage repair (PLD) inhibition caused by post-irradiation in situ holding. This effect on PLD repair is different than that usually found in cells in vitro and in vivo tumors in that it mainly alters the shoulder rather than the slope of the survival curve of CFU-S cells. It is different than PLDR found in vivo for normal mammary and thyroid gland epithelial cells because in situ holding decreases rather than increases the survival of CFU-S cells. Evidence is also presented that the radiation survival curve for in situ bone marrow cells (CFU-S) may not have a shoulder.Supported in part by NIH, NCI grants P01 CA 19298 and P30 CA 14520Supported in part by an American Cancer Society Clinical Fellowship     

Residual radiation effect in the murine hematopoietic stem cell compartment

Stem cells surviving radiation injury may carry defects which contribute to long-term effects. The ratio of 125-iododeoxyuridine (IUdR) uptake into spleens of lethally irradiated recipient mice between day 3 and day 5 after cell transfusion revealed reduced proliferative ability (PF) of spleen seeding cells in parallel with reduced CFU-S content of donors throughout the study period of one year after 5 Gy gamma irradiation. Additional data aided in evaluating possible mechanisms of PF reduction. Within the range of the graft sizes used, PF was independent of the numbers of cells or CFU-S transfused. Radiation-induced increase in loss of label between days 3 and 5 and prolonged doubling time of proliferating cells indicated enhancement of cell maturation and increase in mitotic cycle time. Increased IUdR uptake per transfused CFU-S suggested extra divisions of transit cells due to insufficiency in the stem cell compartment. It is concluded that persisting defects in surviving stem cells interfere in a complex way with cell proliferation in the hemopoietic system.     

Isolation of two early B lymphocyte progenitors from mouse marrow: a committed pre-pre-B cell and a clonogenic Thy-1-lo hematopoietic stem cell

Two novel early B lymphocyte precursor populations have been identified by their capacity to differentiate in Whitlock-Witte bone marrow cultures. Cells expressing neither the B lineage antigen B220 nor Thy-1 contain committed B cell precursors which differentiate in short-term culture into pre-B and B cells. The other population expresses low levels of Thy-1, and lacks B220 as well as the T cell markers L3T4 and Lyt-2. The Thy-1+ cells which initiate long-term B cell cultures contain clonogenic B cell precursors at a frequency of 1 in 11, a 100-fold enrichment over unseparated bone marrow. Thy-1+ cells are also highly enriched for myeloid-erythroid precursors (CFU-S). Thy-1+ cells allow long-term survival of lethally irradiated mice and fully reconstitute the hematopoietic system, including T and B lymphocyte compartments. These results indicate that this population (approximately 0.1% of bone marrow) may contain the pluripotent hematopoietic stem cell.     

Induction of stem cell cycling in mice increases their sensitivity to a chemical leukaemogen: implications for inherited genomic instability and the bystander effect

Preconception paternal irradiation (PPI) modifies haemopoietic and stromal tissues of offspring and increases risk of generating lympho-haemopopietic malignancy if those offspring are then exposed to a leukaemogen. We hypothesised that this increased risk was related to inherited damage which had caused increased stem cell proliferation rates. To test for this link, in vivo, rapid stem cell proliferation was established by giving sub-lethal irradiation (3Gy gamma-rays) and allowing 3 days recovery. At this stage, 60% of haemopoietic spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S) were in DNA-synthesis, compared to <10% in unirradiated controls. Two groups of mice, unirradiated controls and irradiated animals, were then injected with 50mg/kg methyl nitrosourea (MNU) and observed daily for onset of lympho-haemopoietic malignancy. In a further control group of 60 mice, irradiated but not injected with MNU, only one leukaemia developed. In unirradiated controls, 20% of the mice developed malignancies between 3 and 8 months later: in the irradiated, MNU-treated groups, 95% developed malignancies between 2 and 7 months later. Thus, at least one powerful potentiating mechanism for induction of lympho-haemopoietc malignancy following inherited damage can be related to haemopoietic stem cell proliferation. Genomic instability is exposed by cell proliferation and has been implicated in this type of damage. However, a regulatory stromal microenvironment plays a part in inducing that proliferation. Thus, the microenvironment is the effective "bystander" which is thought to promote and amplify genomic instability, and thereby influence the induction of malignancy both in PPI offspring and in mice with induced stem cell proliferation.     

Colony formation in agar by adult bone marrow multipotential hemopoietic cells

Erythroid colony formation in agar cultures of CBA bone marrow cells was stimulated by the addition of pokeweed mitogen-stimulated spleen conditioned medium (SCM). Optimal colony numbers were obtained when cultures contained 20% fetal calf serum and concentrated spleen conditioned medium. By 7 days of incubation, large burst or unicentric erythroid colonies occurred at a maximum frequency of 40–50 per 10⁵ bone marrow cells. In CBA mice the cells forming erythroid colonies were also present in the spleen, peripheral blood, and within individual spleen colonies. A marked strain variation was noted with CBA mice having the highest levels of erythroid colony-forming cells. In CBA mice erythroid colony-forming cells were mainly non-cycling (12.5% reduction in colony numbers after incubation with hydroxyurea or 3H-thymidine). Erythroid colony-forming cells sedimented with a peak of 4.5 mm/hr, compared with CFU-S, which sedimented at 4.25 mm/hr. The addition of erythropoietin (up to 4 units) to cultures containing SCM did not alter the number or degree of hemoglobinisation of erythroid colonies. Analysis of the total number of erythroid colony-forming cells and CFU-S in 90 individual spleen colonies gave a correlation coefficient of r = 0.93 for these two cell types. In addition to benzidine-positive erythroid cells, up to 40% of the colonies contained, in addition, varying proportions of neutrophils, macrophages, eosinophils, and megakaryocytes. Taken together with the close correlation between the numbers of CFU-S in different adult hemopoietic tissues, including individual spleen colonies, the data indicate that the erythroid colony-forming cells expressing multiple hemopoietic differentiation are members of the hemopoietic multipotential stem cell compartment.     

Role of splenic stroma in the action of bacterial lipopolysaccharides on radiation mortality: a study in mice carrying the Slj allele

Slj/+ mice display a slight macrocytic anaemia due to a defect in their haemopoietic organ stroma. They have a deficient endogenous spleen colony (CFU-end) formation following sublethal doses of gamma-radiation compared with their normal +/+ littermates, which is likely to be due to the low pre-irradiation CFU-S content of the Slj/+ spleen. CFU-S in these congenic mice do not differ in their sensitivity to gamma-irradiation or stem cell-activating factor. While injection of +/+ mice with 10 micrograms of lipopolysaccharide-W (LPS) one day prior to irradiation led to a substantial increase in their survival, the survival of Slj/+ mice was only slightly increased. Irradiation induced a similar dose-related reduction in the numbers of CFU-S in the spleen and femora of LPS-injected Slj/+ mice compared to similarly treated +/+ mice when measured directly after irradiation. At Day 9 after irradiation, injection of LPS led to a significantly higher CFU-end formation and higher numbers of CFU-S and nucleated cells in the Slj/+ spleens compared to LPS-injected +/+ mice. No such differences in the radioprotective effect of LPS were observed in the +/+ and Slj/+ mice with respect to the splenic and femoral 59Fe-incorporation and the femoral CFU-S numbers at Day 9. These data strongly suggest a contribution by immigrating CFU-S to the CFU-S numbers and endogenous colony formation in at least the Slj/+ spleen after LPS injection and subsequent sublethal irradiation. The observations also imply that the splenic organ stroma may play a mediatory role in the radioprotective action of LPS. In addition, the data represent an extreme example of a lack of correlation between animal survival and haemopoietic parameters. Caution should be taken when applying endogenous colony counts as a means of screening potential anti-radiation drugs.