Mutagenesis induced by 5-bromouracil and methyl methane sulfonate: role of DNA polymerase I

A polA1 mutation in the DNA polymerase I gene of E. coli results in a drastic reduction of the frequency of mutagenesis induced by 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BUdR). Comparisons of the effect of a polA1 mutation on mutagenesis induced by methyl methane sulfonate (MMS), ultraviolet irradiation (UV) and 2-aminopurine (2-AP) demonstrated that a similar effect of a polA1 mutation is observed with MMS. This effect is much less marked with UV-and-2-AP-induced mutagenesis. It follows that DNA polymerase I plays a key role in the process of mutagenesis induced by BU and MMS. Bearing in mind that mutagenesis provoked by UV, MMS and BU involves participation of the accompanying induced error-prone system, the sources of the differences in requirement for DNA polymerase I are critically examined.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">IXR1</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">HMO1</Emphasis> genes jointly control the level of spontaneous mutagenesis in yeast <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae</Emphasis>

The yeast genes IXR1 and HMO1 encode proteins belonging to the family of chromatin nonhistone proteins, which are able to recognize and bind to irregular DNA structures. The full deletion of gene IXR1 leads to an increase in cell resistance to the lethal action of UV light, γ-rays, and MMS, increases spontaneous mutagenesis and significantlly decreases the level of UV-induced mutations. It was earlier demonstrated in our works that the hmo1 mutation renders cells sensitive to the lethal action of cisplatin and virtually does not affect the sensitivity to UV light. Characteristically, the rates of spontaneous and UV-induced mutagenesis in the mutant are increased. Epistatic analysis of the double mutation hmo1 ixr1 demonstrated that the interaction of these genes in relation to the lethal effect of cisplatin and UV light, as well as UV-induced mutagenesis, is additive. This suggests that the products of genes HMO1 and IXR1 participate in different repair pathways. The ixr1 mutation significantly increases the rate of spontaneous mutagenesis mediated by replication errors, whereas mutation hmo1 increases the rate of repair mutagenesis. In wild-type cells, the level of spontaneous mutagenesis was nearly one order of magnitude lower than that obtained in cells of the double mutant. Consequently, the combined activity of the Hmo1 and the Ixr1 proteins provides efficient correction of both repair and replication errors.     

DNA-repair characterization of cdc40-1, a cell-cycle mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The cell-cycle specific mutation cdc40-1, which has been previously shown to be sensitive to MMS at the restrictive temperature, was further characterized as a DNA-repair-deficient mutation. cdc40-1 mutants shown only slight sensitivity to UV irradiation. Double mutant studies shown that rad6-l is epistatic to cdc40-1 with respect to sensitivity to UV irradiation and MMS. rad50-1 is epistatic to cdc40-1 with respect to MMS sensitivity in G1 stationary cells, but not in logarithmic cultures. An additive effect is seen between cdc40-1 and rad50-1 with respect to UV irradiation. cdc40-1 mutants are defective in UV-induced mutagenesis at the restrictive temperature. UV-induced levels of recombination are normal at both temperatures, while MMS-induced recombination is enhanced at the restrictive temperature.     

Characterization of MMS-sensitive mutants of Neurospora crassa

Several MMS-sensitive mutants of Neurospora crassa were compared with the wild-type strain for their relative sensitivities to UV, X-ray, and histidine. They were also compared for the frequency of spontaneous mutation at the loci which confer resistance to p-fluorophenylalanine. The mutants were also examined for possible defects in meiotic behavior in homozygous crosses and for any change in the inducible DNA salvage pathways (as indicated by their ability to utilize DNA as the sole phosphate source in the growth medium). On the basis of these characterizations, the present MMS-sensitive mutants of Neurospora can be placed into three groups. The first group includes three mutants, mus-(SC3), mus-(SC13), and mus-(SC28). These are slow growers, insensitive to histidine with no apparent meiotic defects and may have reduced frequency of spontaneous mutation. In addition, their mycelial growth is sensitive to MMS but the conidial viability following MMS, UV or X-ray treatment appears normal or only slightly more sensitive than the wild-type. The second group includes only one mutant, mus-(SC15); its mycelial growth is very sensitive to MMS but the conidial survival following treatment with MMS or UV appears normal; however, the conidial survival following exposure to X-ray is significantly reduced. This mutant shows an increase (more than 10-fold) frequency of spontaneous mutation, but behaves normal like the wild-type with respect to fertility, growth rate and insensitivity to histidine. The third group includes mutants mus-(SC10), mus-(SC25), and mus-(SC29). These mutants are very sensitive to UV, X-rays and MMS and to histadine but have normal growth rates on minimal medium. Mutant mus-(SC10), but not mus-(SC25) and mus-(SC29), has an increased (11 ×) frequency of spontaneous mutation. On the basis of data presented, the MMS sensitivity of the first group of mutants cannot be ascertained to arise from a defect in the DNA repair pathways; instead, it may stem from altered cell permeability or other pleotropic effects of the mus mutations. However, it can be suggested that the second and third group of mus mutants may indeed result from a defect in the DNA repair pathways controlled by the mus genes; this conclusion is based on their cross-sensitivity to a number of DNA-damaging agents such as MMS, UV and/or X-ray, high frequencies of spontaneous mutation (mutator effects) and defects in meiotic behavior.     

Effect of degradative plasmid CAM-OCT on responses of Pseudomonas bacteria to UV light.

The effect of plasmid CAM-OCT on responses to UV irradiation was compared in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, in Pseudomonas putida, and in Pseudomonas putida mutants carrying mutations in UV response genes. CAM-OCT substantially increased both survival and mutagenesis in the two species. P. aeruginosa strains without CAM-OCT exhibited much higher UV sensitivity than did P. putida strains. UV-induced mutagenesis of plasmid-free P. putida was easily detected in three different assays (two reversion assays and one forward mutation assay), whereas UV mutagenesis of P. aeruginosa without CAM-OCT was seen only in the forward mutation assay. These results suggest major differences in DNA repair between the two species and highlight the presence of error-prone repair functions on CAM-OCT. A number of P. putida mutants carrying chromosomal mutations affecting either survival or mutagenesis after UV irradiation were isolated, and the effect of CAM-OCT on these mutants was determined. All mutations producing a UV-sensitive phenotype in P. putida were fully suppressed by the plasmid, whereas the plasmid had a more variable effect on mutagenesis mutations, suppressing some and producing no suppression of others. On the basis of the results reported here and results obtained by others with plasmids carrying UV response genes, it appears that CAM-OCT may differ either in regulation or in the number and functions of UV response genes encoded.     

Anti-mutagenic effect of ultraviolet light on spontaneous tyrosine tRNA ochre suppressor mutations in Escherichia coli

Summary The numbers of tyrosine tRNA ochre suppressor mutations arising spontaneously or after UV irradiation in different strains of Escherichia coli K12 are considered. The DNA sequence change requisite for this type of mutation would be a transversion at a cytosine between two purines, where pyrimidine-pyrimidine photoproducts could not form. We find that UV mutagenesis does not produce these tyrosine tRNA ochre suppressor mutations. With lexA51 recA441 defective cells, the spontaneous yield of these mutations is elevated and UV irradiation produces a significant decrease in the numbers of this particular mutation. As explanation we suggest that the spontaneous appearance of these mutations reflects mutation at apurinic sites, the efficiency of which is elevated in lexA51 recA441 cells (with derepressed SOS functions and an activated form of RecA protein). The addition of UV damage in the DNA of these cells cannot further stimulate the positive functions that are required for the production of these mutations and are typically associated with UV mutagenesis (induction of SOS functions, activation of RecA protein and introduction of a targeting photoproduct) but apparently can have a negative effect on mutagenesis, hitherto not realized.     

A structural model for sequence-specific proflavin-DNA interactions during in vitro frameshift mutagenesis.

Molecular models describing intermediates that may lead to proflavin-induced 1 bp deletions during in vitro polymerization by E. coli DNA polymerase I Klenow fragment are proposed. The models provide structural explanations for the fact that the induced frameshifts always occur opposite template bases that are adjacent to 5' pyrimidines and are based on the underlying hypothesis that the deletions arise because the polymerase passes by a template base without copying it. Because the most frequent mutations are opposite Pu in the template sequence 5' Py Pu 3', a single-strand loop-out model was constructed for this sequence and proflavin was added, using structures found in crystalline oligonucleotides and their complexes with proflavin. The model seeks to rationalize the roles of the 5' pyrimidine and proflavin in facilitating the bypass. Four potential roles for proflavin in mutagenesis are described: 1) stacking on the looped-out base; 2) stacking on the base pair immediately preceding the site of mutation; 3) hydrogen bonding with the 5' pyrimidine; 4) hydrogen bonding with the phosphate backbone. These models point to the possibility that a number of proflavin-DNA interactions may be involved. In contrast, modeling does not suggest a role for classically intercalated proflavin in frameshift mutagenesis arising during in vitro DNA polymerization.     

Two Haemophilus influenzae Rd genes that complement the recA-like mutation rec-1.

Two Haemophilus influenzae Rd genes each complemented the pleiotropic defects of the recA-like mutation rec-1. One gene, fec, was isolated on a 3.6-kilobase-pair EcoRI restriction fragment by complementation of the Fec- phenotype of bacteriophage lambda. The other gene, rec, was identified on a 3.1-kilobase-pair EcoRI fragment by Southern hybridization by using recA-like gene probes from Erwinia carotovora and Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO. In a rec-1 strain of H. influenzae, the cloned genes restored resistance to UV irradiation, transformation by chromosomal DNA, and spontaneous release of HP1 prophage to wild-type levels. The fec and rec genes were located on the cloned segments by insertion and deletion mutagenesis and subcloning. The restriction endonuclease cleavage maps of the two DNAs were similar but not identical. Southern hybridization demonstrated that the two EcoRI restriction fragments contained homologous DNA sequences, but a fec gene-specific probe was prepared. Each gene encoded a 38,000-dalton polypeptide.     

The CAM-OCT plasmid enhances UV responses of Pseudomonas aeruginosa recA mutants.

The effect of the CAM-OCT plasmid on responses to UV irradiation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa recA mutants was characterized. Mutant alleles examined included rec-1, rec-2, and recA7::Tn501. The plasmid substantially enhanced both survival and mutagenesis of RecA- cells after treatment with UV light. Survival of the RecA-(CAM-OCT) cells after UV irradiation was intermediate between that seen in the wild-type P. aeruginosa PAO1 and the increased survival seen in PAO1(CAM-OCT) cells. Mutability was quantitated by the reversion to carbenicillin resistance of strains carrying a bla(Am) mutation on a derivative of plasmid RP1. UV-induced mutagenesis of CAM-OCT carrying recA mutants occurred at levels comparable to that seen in PAO1(CAM-OCT). The ability of CAM-OCT plasmid to suppress the recombination deficiency in recA mutants was tested by assaying for bacteriophage F116L-generalized transduction of a Tn7 insertion in the alkane utilization genes of CAM-OCT. Transduction of the Tn7 insertion was not detected in RecA-(CAM-OCT) strains but was easily seen in PAO1(CAM-OCT), indicating that the plasmid does not encode a recA analog. The results indicate that the CAM-OCT UV response genes are expressed in RecA- cells, which differs from results seen with other UV response-enhancing plasmids. The results suggest that CAM-OCT either encodes several UV responses genes itself or induces chromosomal UV response genes by an alternate mechanism.     

A Structural Model For Sequence-Specific Proflavin-DNA Interactions During In Vitro Frameshift Mutagenesis

Abstract

Molecular models describing intermediates that may lead to proflavin-induced 1 bp deletions during in vitro polymerization by E. coli DNA polymerase I Klenow fragment are proposed. The models provide structural explanations for the fact that the induced frameshifts always occur opposite template bases that are adjacent to 5′ pyrimidines and are based on the underlying hypothesis that the deletions arise because the polymerase passes by a template base without copying it. Because the most frequent mutations are opposite Pu in the template sequence 5′ Py Pu 3′, a single-strand loop-out model was constructed for this sequence and proflavin was added, using structures found in crystalline oligonucleotides and their complexes with proflavin. The model seeks to rationalize the roles of the 5′ pyrimidine and proflavin in facilitating the bypass. Four potential roles for proflavin in mutagenesis are described: 1) stacking on the looped-out base; 2) stacking on the base pair immediately preceding the site of mutation; 3) hydrogen bonding with the 5′ pyrimidine; 4) hydrogen bonding with the phosphate backbone. These models point to the possibility that a number of proflavin-DNA interactions may be involved. In contrast, modeling does not suggest a role for classically intercalated proflavin in frameshift mutagenesis arising during in vitro DNA polymerization.     

PSO4: a novel gene involved in error-prone repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The haploid xs9 mutant, originally selected for on the basis of a slight sensitivity to the lethal effect of X-rays, was found to be extremely sensitive to inactivation by 8-methoxypsoralen (8MOP) photoaddition, especially when cells are treated in the G2 phase of the cell cycle. As the xs9 mutation showed no allelism with any of the 3 known pso mutations, it was now given the name of pso4-1. Regarding inactivation, the pso4-1 mutant is also sensitive to mono- (HN1) or bi-functional (HN2) nitrogen mustards, it is slightly sensitive to 254 nm UV radiation (UV), and shows nearly normal sensitivity to 3-carbethoxypsoralen (3-CPs) photoaddition or methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). Regarding mutagenesis, the pso4-1 mutation completely blocks reverse and forward mutations induced by either 8MOP or 3CPs photoaddition, or by gamma-rays. In the cases of UV, HN1, HN2 or MMS treatments, while reversion induction is still completely abolished, forward mutagenesis is only partially inhibited for UV, HN1, or MMS, and it is unaffected for HN2. Besides severely inhibiting induced mutagenesis, the pso4-1 mutation was found to be semi-dominant, to block sporulation, to abolish the diploid resistance effect, and to block induced mitotic recombination, which indicates that the PSO4 gene is involved in a recombinational pathway of error-prone repair, comparable to the E. coli SOS repair pathway.     

Complementation of a pKM101 derivative that decreases resistance to UV killing but increases susceptibility to mutagenesis

The drug resistance plasmid pKM101 makes Escherichia coli resistant to the lethal effects of ultraviolet (UV) irradiation and more susceptible to mutagenesis by a variety of agents. The plasmid operon responsible for increasing mutagenesis has been termed mucAB (Mutagenesis, UV and chemical). We have isolated a derivative of pKM101 called pGW1975 which makes cells more sensitive to killing by UV but which retains the ability of pKM101 to increase susceptibility to methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) mutagenesis. pGW1975 increases UV mutagenesis less than pKM101 in a uvrA⁺ strain but more than pKM101 in a uvrA⁻ strain. muc⁻ point and insertion mutants of pKM101 and pGW1975 complement to restore the plasmid-mediated: (i) ability to reactivate UV-irradiated phage, (ii) resistance to killing by UV, and (iii) level of susceptibility to UV mutagenesis. We have identified a 2.0 kb region of pKM101 which is responsible for the complementation and which maps counterclockwise of mucAB.     

Dissection of the functions of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD6 postreplicative repair group in mutagenesis and UV sensitivity.

The RAD6 postreplicative repair group participates in various processes of DNA metabolism. To elucidate the contribution of RAD6 to starvation-associated mutagenesis, which occurs in nongrowing cells cultivated under selective conditions, we analyzed the phenotype of strains expressing various alleles of the RAD6 gene and single and multiple mutants of the RAD6, RAD5, RAD18, REV3, and MMS2 genes from the RAD6 repair group. Our results show that the RAD6 repair pathway is also active in starving cells and its contribution to starvation-associated mutagenesis is similar to that of spontaneous mutagenesis. Epistatic analysis based on both spontaneous and starvation-associated mutagenesis and UV sensitivity showed that the RAD6 repair group consists of distinct repair pathways of different relative importance requiring, besides the presence of Rad6, also either Rad18 or Rad5 or both. We postulate the existence of four pathways: (1) nonmutagenic Rad5/Rad6/Rad18, (2) mutagenic Rad5/Rad6 /Rev3, (3) mutagenic Rad6/Rad18/Rev3, and (4) Rad6/Rad18/Rad30. Furthermore, we show that the high mutation rate observed in rad6 mutants is caused by a mutator different from Rev3. From our data and data previously published, we suggest a role for Rad6 in DNA repair and mutagenesis and propose a model for the RAD6 postreplicative repair group.     

Thymineless Mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

To clarify the relationship between thymineless death and thymineless mutagenesis, the induction of arginine revertants of Escherichia coli TAU-bar by thymine starvation was examined in physiological terms. Induced revertants were detectable both on minimal medium lacking arginine and minimal medium supplemented with 1 mug of arginine per ml. Substantial thymineless mutagenesis occurred during the period before the onset of thymineless death. Mutagenesis and loss of viability were observed upon incubation in medium lacking thymine and arginine, and both were inhibited upon incubation in medium lacking thymine and uracil. Mutagenesis also occurred during thymine starvation at 25 C, where there was relatively little loss of viability. At 37 C thymineless mutagenesis did not require complete thymine starvation, and the induction of revertants appeared to be initiated at the same suboptimal thymine concentration at which lethality was first detectable. Mutagenesis was found not to occur preferentially at the growing point of deoxyribonucleic acid replication. These results suggest that thymineless mutagenesis does not involve simply errors in base pairing due to the absence of thymine. The data also suggest that the induction of mutations and thymineless death are due to the same primary event but that mutagenesis is the more sensitive response.     

Deoxyribonucleic Acid Repair in Bacteriophage T4: Observations on the Roles of the x and v Genes and of Host Factors

Studies were carried out to determine the effect of mutation in the host pol I gene on survival of ultraviolet (UV)-irradiated bacteriophage T4. Whereas a slightly reduced survival was observed in Escherichia coli strain P-3478 (pol A(1)) compared to strain W-3110 (pol A(+)), no such difference was observed in two strains isogenic except for the pol A gene. It was also shown that, whereas bacteriophage T4x is sensitive to UV irradiation, X irradiation, and treatment with methyl-methanesulfonate (MMS), phage T4v(1) is sensitive only to UV irradiation. The survival of damaged phage T4x is neither affected by the presence of the rec A, rec B, or pol A mutations in the host, nor is there evidence that phage T4 effects repair of rec A or pol A mutants previously treated with either UV or MMS.     

Nature of the Repair of Methyl Methanesulfonate-Induced Damage in Bacillus subtilis

A nuclease present in extracts of Bacillus subtilis inserts breaks in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) treated with the monofunctional alkylating agent, methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), but the nature of the sites within the alkylated macromolecule at which these breaks occur is not known. DNA extracted from B. subtilis cells that have recovered from MMS damage has lost its susceptibility to enzyme action. The recovery process is accompanied by some DNA breakdown and by the incorporation of thymidine. Some recovery from ultraviolet irradiation (UV) and MMS occurred in organisms starved for thymine or adenine, but UV recovery was stimulated by their addition. It is possible that MMS recovery proceeds by a process of excision and repair similar to, but not identical with, UV repair.     

Misincorporation in DNA synthesis after modification of template or polymerase by MNNG, MMS and UV radiation

The synthetic DNA polymers, poly(dG-dC), poly(dC), poly(dA-dT), poly(dA) and poly(dT), were treated with N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) and UV irradiation. The modified polymers were used as templates to examine the incorporation of non-complementary nucleotides by E. coli DNA polymerase I. Methylation of poly(dG-dC) by MNNG predominantly induced the misincorporation of dTMP, whereas methylation by MMS induced that of dAMP. Treatment of poly(dT) with MNNG caused the misincorporation of dGMP to a considerable extent, but MMS did not enhance the error on poly(dT). The misincorporation of dAMP on poly(dC) and that of dGMP on poly(dA) were also increased by these chemicals. UV irradiation of poly(dT) and poly(dC) induced the error of dGMP and dAMP, respectively. These data on MNNG and MMS in vitro were in fair agreement with the directions of mutation in vivo. But the predominant induction of transitions by UV in vitro did not agree with the UV-induced transversions in E. coli. This inconsistency suggested the participation of other factors than direct mispairing in UV-induced transversion. Modification of DNA polymerase I by MNNG changed the ratio of polymerase to 3' leads to 5' exonuclease activity altering the fidelity of this enzyme, whereas MMS and UV-irradiation did not alter the fidelity of the enzyme.     

Mutagen sensitivities and mutator effects of MMS-sensitive mutants in Neurospora

7 mus (mutagen-sensitive) mutants of Neurospora crassa, which are more sensitive to the toxic effects of MMS (methyl methanesulfonate) than wild-type, were investigated for cross-sensitivities to other mutagens and inhibitors. These mutants have recently been mapped in 5 new genes, mus-7 to mus-11, and mutant alleles from each gene were checked for their effects on mutation frequencies. It was found that mutants in 3 of these 5 genes showed radiation-induced mutation frequencies similar to wild-type. These included 2 alleles of the gene mus-10, which were cross-sensitive only to UV and were the only mutants that produced some viable ascospores in homozygous crosses. The mutant of the second gene, mus-8, was especially sensitive to UV and mitomycin C and produced slightly reduced frequencies of spontaneous mutation. In contrast, the mutant of the third gene, mus-7, was not UV-sensitive but showed some cross-sensitivity to X-rays; mus-7 was highly sensitive to MMS and also to histidine, which inhibits various repair-defective mutants at concentrations well below those that reduce wild-type growth. None of these mus resemble mutants previously found in Neurospora, nor do they conform clearly to mutant types identified in E. coli or yeast. On the other hand mutants in 2 further genes, mus-11, and especially 2 alleles of mus-9, are very similar to uvs-3 of Neurospora and generally resemble mutants that are considered to be defective in "error-prone" repair. They were UV- as well as X-ray-sensitive, and showed strong spontaneous mutator effects but almost no increase in recessive lethal frequencies in heterokaryons after UV-treatments.