Conformation of P22 tailspike folding and aggregation intermediates probed by monoclonal antibodies.

The partitioning of partially folded polypeptide chains between correctly folded native states and off-pathway inclusion bodies is a critical reaction in biotechnology. Multimeric partially folded intermediates, representing early stages of the aggregation pathway for the P22 tailspike protein, have been trapped in the cold and isolated by nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) (speed MA, Wang DIC, King J. 1995. Protein Sci 4:900-908). Monoclonal antibodies against tailspike chains discriminate between folding intermediates and native states (Friguet B, Djavadi-Ohaniance L, King J, Goldberg ME. 1994. J Biol Chem 269:15945-15949). Here we describe a nondenaturing Western blot procedure to probe the conformation of productive folding intermediates and off-pathway aggregation intermediates. The aggregation intermediates displayed epitopes in common with productive folding intermediates but were not recognized by antibodies against native epitopes. The nonnative epitope on the folding and aggregation intermediates was located on the partially folded N-terminus, indicating that the N-terminus remained accessible and nonnative in the aggregated state. Antibodies against native epitopes blocked folding, but the monoclonal directed against the N-terminal epitope did not, indicating that the conformation of the N-terminus is not a key determinant of the productive folding and chain association pathway.     

Reconstitution of the thermostable trimeric phage P22 tailspike protein from denatured chains in vitro

Intermediates in the intracellular chain folding and association pathway of the P22 tailspike endorhamnosidase have been identified previously by physiological and genetic methods. Conditions have now been found for the in vitro refolding of this large (Mr = 215,000) oligomeric protein. Purified Salmonella phage P22 tailspikes, while very stable to urea in neutral solution, were dissociated by moderate concentrations of urea at acidic pH. The tailspike protein was denatured to unfolded polypeptide chains in 6 M urea, pH 3, as disclosed by analytical ultracentrifugation, fluorescence, and circular dichroism. Upon dilution into neutral buffer at 10 degrees C, the polypeptides fold spontaneously and associate to form trimeric tailspikes with high yield. Like native phage P22 tailspikes, the reconstitution product is resistant to denaturation by dodecyl sulfate in the cold and displays endorhamnosidase activity. Sedimentation coefficients, electrophoretic mobility, and fluorescence emission maxima of native and reconstituted tailspikes are identical within experimental error. By characterization of intermediates, localization of temperature-sensitive steps, and analysis of the effect of previously identified folding mutations, the reconstitution system described should allow comparison of in vivo and in vitro folding pathways of this large protein oligomer.     

Thermostability of temperature-sensitive folding mutants of the P22 tailspike protein

Temperature-sensitive folding mutations (tsf) of the thermostable P22 tailspike protein prevent the mutant polypeptide chain from reaching the native state at the higher end of the temperature range of bacterial growth (37-42 degrees C). At lower temperatures the mutant polypeptide chains fold and associate into native proteins. The melting temperatures of the purified native forms of seven different tsf mutant proteins have been determined by differential scanning calorimetry. Under conditions in which the wild type protein had a melting temperature of 88.4 degrees C, the melting temperatures of the mutant proteins were all above 82 degrees C, more than 40 degrees C higher than the temperature for expression of the folding defect. Because the folding defects were observed in vivo, the thermostability of the native protein was also examined with infected cells. Once matured at 28 degrees C, intracellular tsf mutant tailspikes remained native when the cells were transferred to 42 degrees C, a temperature that prevents newly synthesized tsf chains from folding correctly. These results confirm that the failure of tsf polypeptide chains to reach their native state is not due to a lowered stability of the native state. Such mutants differ from the class of ts mutations which render the native state thermolabile. The intracellular folding defects must reflect decreased stabilities of folding intermediates or alteration in the off-pathway steps leading to aggregation and inclusion body formation. These results indicate that the stability of a native protein within the cells is not sufficient to insure the successful folding of the newly synthesized chains into the native state.     

Surface amino acids as sites of temperature-sensitive folding mutations in the P22 tailspike protein

Temperature-sensitive folding (tsf) mutations in the gene for the thermostable P22 tailspike interfere with the polypeptide chain folding and association pathway at restrictive temperature without altering the thermostability of the protein once correctly folded and assembled at permissive temperature. Though the native proteins matured at permissive temperature are biologically active, many of them display alterations in electrophoretic mobility. The native forms of 15 of these tsf mutant proteins have been purified and characterized. The purified proteins differed in electrophoretic mobility and isoelectric point from wild type but did not show evidence of major conformational alterations. The results suggest that the electrophoretic variations conferred by the 15 tsf amino acid substitutions are due to changes in the net charge at solvent-accessible sites in the native form of the mutant protein. During the maturation of the chains at restrictive temperature, these sites influence the conformation of intermediates in chain folding and association. The amino acid sequences at these sites resemble those found at turns in polypeptide chains. The isolation of tsf mutations requires that the mature structure of the tailspike accommodates the mutant amino acid substitution without loss of function. The solvent-accessible sites are probably at the surface of this structural protein. This would explain how bulky mutant substitutions, such as arginines for glycines, are accommodated in the native tailspike structure. Such sites, stabilizing intermediates in the folding pathway and located on the surface of the mature protein, probably represent a general class of conformational substrates for tsf mutations.     

A newly synthesized, ribosome-bound polypeptide chain adopts conformations dissimilar from early in vitro refolding intermediates

Little is known about the conformations of newly synthesized polypeptide chains as they emerge from the large ribosomal subunit, or how these conformations compare with those populated immediately after dilution of polypeptide chains out of denaturant in vitro. Both in vivo and in vitro, partially folded intermediates of the tailspike protein from Salmonella typhimurium phage P22 can be trapped in the cold. A subset of monoclonal antibodies raised against tailspike recognize partially folded intermediates, whereas other antibodies recognize only later intermediates and/or the native state. We have used a pair of monoclonal antibodies to probe the conformational features of full-length, newly synthesized tailspike chains recovered on ribosomes from phage-infected cells. The antibody that recognizes early intermediates in vitro also recognizes the ribosome-bound intermediates. Surprisingly, the antibody that did not recognize early in vitro intermediates did recognize ribosome-bound tailspike chains translated in vivo. Thus, the newly synthesized, ribosome-bound tailspike chains display structured epitopes not detected upon dilution of tailspike chains from denaturant. As opposed to the random ensemble first populated when polypeptide chains are diluted out of denaturant, folding in vivo from the ribosome may begin with polypeptide conformations already directed toward the productive folding and assembly pathway.     

Cold rescue of the thermolabile tailspike intermediate at the junction between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation.

Off-pathway intermolecular interactions between partially folded polypeptide chains often compete with correct intramolecular interactions, resulting in self-association of folding intermediates into the inclusion body state. Intermediates for both productive folding and off-pathway aggregation of the parallel beta-coil tailspike trimer of phage P22 have been identified in vivo and in vitro using native gel electrophoresis in the cold. Aggregation of folding intermediates was suppressed when refolding was initiated and allowed to proceed for a short period at 0 degrees C prior to warming to 20 degrees C. Yields of refolded tailspike trimers exceeding 80% were obtained using this temperature-shift procedure, first described by Xie and Wetlaufer (1996, Protein Sci 5:517-523). We interpret this as due to stabilization of the thermolabile monomeric intermediate at the junction between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation. Partially folded monomers, a newly identified dimer, and the protrimer folding intermediates were populated in the cold. These species were electrophoretically distinguished from the multimeric intermediates populated on the aggregation pathway. The productive protrimer intermediate is disulfide bonded (Robinson AS, King J, 1997, Nat Struct Biol 4:450-455), while the multimeric aggregation intermediates are not disulfide bonded. The partially folded dimer appears to be a precursor to the disulfide-bonded protrimer. The results support a model in which the junctional partially folded monomeric intermediate acquires resistance to aggregation in the cold by folding further to a conformation that is activated for correct recognition and subunit assembly.     

Cotranslational folding promotes beta-helix formation and avoids aggregation in vivo

Newly synthesized proteins must form their native structures in the crowded environment of the cell, while avoiding non-native conformations that can lead to aggregation. Yet, remarkably little is known about the progressive folding of polypeptide chains during chain synthesis by the ribosome or of the influence of this folding environment on productive folding in vivo. P22 tailspike is a homotrimeric protein that is prone to aggregation via misfolding of its central β-helix domain in vitro. We have produced stalled ribosome:tailspike nascent chain complexes of four fixed lengths in vivo, in order to assess cotranslational folding of newly synthesized tailspike chains as a function of chain length. Partially synthesized, ribosome-bound nascent tailspike chains populate stable conformations with some native-state structural features even prior to the appearance of the entire β-helix domain, regardless of the presence of the chaperone trigger factor, yet these conformations are distinct from the conformations of released, refolded tailspike truncations. These results suggest that organization of the aggregation-prone β-helix domain occurs cotranslationally, prior to chain release, to a conformation that is distinct from the accessible energy minimum conformation for the truncated free chain in solution.     

The interdigitated beta-helix domain of the P22 tailspike protein acts as a molecular clamp in trimer stabilization

The P22 tailspike adhesin is an elongated thermostable trimer resistant to protease digestion and to denaturation in sodium dodecyl sulfate. Monomeric, dimeric, and protrimeric folding and assembly intermediates lack this stability and are thermolabile. In the native trimer, three right-handed parallel beta-helices (residues 143-540), pack side-by-side around the three-fold axis. After residue 540, these single chain beta-helices terminate and residues 541-567 of the three polypeptide chains wrap around each other to form a three-stranded interdigitated beta-helix. Three mutants located in this region -- G546D, R563Q, and A575T -- blocked formation of native tailspike trimers, and accumulated soluble forms of the mutant polypeptide chains within cells. The substitutions R563Q and A575T appeared to prevent stable association of partially folded monomers. G546D, in the interdigitated region of the chain, blocked tailspike folding at the transition from the partially-folded protrimer to the native trimer. The protrimer-like species accumulating in the G546D mutant melted out at 42 degrees C and was trypsin and SDS sensitive. The G546D defect was not corrected by introduction of global suppressor mutations, which correct kinetic defects in beta-helix folding. The simplest interpretation of these results is that the very high thermostability (T(m) = 88 degrees C), protease and detergent resistance of the native tailspike acquired in the protrimer-to-trimer transition, depends on the formation of the three-stranded interdigitated region. This interdigitated beta-helix appears to function as a molecular clamp insuring thermostable subunit association in the native trimer.     

Multimeric intermediates in the pathway to the aggregated inclusion body state for P22 tailspike polypeptide chains.

The failure of newly synthesized polypeptide chains to reach the native conformation due to their accumulation as inclusion bodies is a serious problem in biotechnology. The critical intermediate at the junction between the productive folding and the inclusion body pathway has been previously identified for the P22 tailspike endorhamnosidase. We have been able to trap subsequent intermediates in the in vitro pathway to the aggregated inclusion body state. Nondenaturing gel electrophoresis identified a sequential series of multimeric intermediates in the aggregation pathway. These represent discrete species formed from noncovalent association of partially folded intermediates rather than aggregation of native-like trimeric species. Monomer, dimer, trimer, tetramer, pentamer, and hexamer states of the partially folded species were populated in the initial stages of the aggregation reaction. This methodology of isolating early multimers along the aggregation pathway was applicable to other proteins, such as the P22 coat protein and carbonic anhydrase II.     

Characterization of the protrimer intermediate in the folding pathway of the interdigitated beta-helix tailspike protein

P22 tailspike is a homotrimeric, thermostable adhesin that recognizes the O-antigen lipopolysaccharide of Salmonella typhimurium. The 70 kDa subunits include long beta-helix domains. After residue 540, the polypeptide chains change their path and wrap around one another, with extensive interchain contacts. Formation of this interdigitated domain intimately couples the chain folding and assembly mechanisms. The earliest detectable trimeric intermediate in the tailspike folding and assembly pathway is the protrimer, suspected to be a precursor of the native trimer structure. We have directly analyzed the kinetics of in vitro protrimer formation and disappearance for wild type and mutant tailspike proteins. The results confirm that the protrimer intermediate is an on-pathway intermediate for tailspike folding. Protrimer was originally resolved during tailspike folding because its migration through nondenaturing polyacrylamide gels was significantly retarded with respect to the migration of the native tailspike trimer. By comparing protein mobility versus acrylamide concentration, we find that the retarded mobility of the protrimer is due exclusively to a larger overall size than the native trimer, rather than an altered net surface charge. Experiments with mutant tailspike proteins indicate that the conformation difference between protrimer and native tailspike trimer is localized toward the C-termini of the tailspike polypeptide chains. These results suggest that the transformation of the protrimer to the native tailspike trimer represents the C-terminal interdigitation of the three polypeptide chains. This late step may confer the detergent-resistance, protease-resistance, and thermostability of the native trimer.     

In vitro folding pathway of phage P22 tailspike protein.

The intracellular chain folding and association pathway of the thermostable, trimeric phage P22 tailspike endorhamnosidase has been the subject of a previous detailed study employing temperature-sensitive folding mutants. Recently, reconstitution of native tailspikes from completely unfolded polypeptides has been accomplished, providing a model system to compare protein folding pathways in vivo and in vitro. The in vitro reconstitution pathway of the protein after dilution from guanidine hydrochloride or acid-urea solutions at 10 degrees C was characterized by spectroscopic and hydrodynamic techniques, and may be summarized as an ordered sequence of folding, association, and folding reactions. Multiphasic folding of monomers was indicated by changes in circular dichroism and fluorescence, with a rate constant of k = 1.6 X 10(-3) s-1 for the slowest phase observed spectroscopically. Trimerization of structured monomers was followed by size-exclusion HPLC and was completed within 1.5 h at a protein concentration of 20 micrograms/mL. Although at this time trimers did not exchange subunits, they were readily dissociable by dodecyl sulfate in the cold. Formation of native, detergent-resistant trimers was only completed after 3 days of reconstitution at 10 degrees C. The reconstitution pathway of the tailspike protein closely resembles its intracellular maturation path. Thus, the in vitro reconstitution system, as a valid model of chain folding and association in vivo, should provide the tools to localize the steps or intermediates on the pathway that are the targets of temperature-sensitive folding mutations.     

Dissociation of intermolecular disulfide bonds in P22 tailspike protein intermediates in the presence of SDS

Each chain of the native trimeric P22 tailspike protein has eight cysteines that are reduced and buried in its hydrophobic core. However, disulfide bonds have been observed in the folding pathway and they are believed to play a critical role in the registration of the three chains. Interestingly, in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) only monomeric chains, rather than disulfide-linked oligomers, have been observed from a mixture of folding intermediates. Here we show that when the oligomeric folding intermediates were separated from the monomer by native gel electrophoresis, the reduction of intermolecular disulfide bonds did not occur in the subsequent second-dimension SDS-gel electrophoresis. This result suggests that when tailspike monomer is present in free solution with SDS, the partially unfolded tailspike monomer can facilitate the reduction of disulfide bonds in the tailspike oligomers.     

Monoclonal antibody epitope mapping describes tailspike beta-helix folding and aggregation intermediates

There is growing interest in understanding how the cellular environment affects protein folding mechanisms, but most spectroscopic methods for monitoring folding in vitro are unsuitable for experiments in vivo or in other complex mixtures. Monoclonal antibody binding represents a sensitive structural probe that can be detected against the background of other cellular components. A panel of antibodies has been raised against Salmonella typhimurium phage P22 tailspike. In this report, nine alpha-tailspike antibody binding epitopes were characterized by measuring the binding of these monoclonal antibodies to tailspike variants bearing surface point mutations. These results reveal that the antibody epitopes are distributed throughout the tailspike structure, with several clustered in the central parallel beta-helix domain. The ability of each antibody to distinguish between tailspike conformational states was assessed by measuring antibody binding to tailspike in vitro refolding intermediates. Interestingly, the binding of all but one of the nine antibodies is sensitive to the tailspike conformational state. Whereas several antibodies bind preferentially to the tailspike native structure, the structural features that comprise the binding epitopes form with different rates. In addition, two antibodies preferentially recognize early refolding intermediates. Combined with the epitope mapping, these results indicate portions of the beta-helix form early during refolding, perhaps serving as a scaffold for the formation of additional structure. Finally, three of the antibodies show enhanced binding to non-native, potentially aggregation-prone tailspike conformations. The refolding results indicate these non-native conformations form early during the refolding reaction, long before the appearance of native tailspike.     

Three amino acids that are critical to formation and stability of the P22 tailspike trimer

The P22 tailspike protein folds by forming a folding competent monomer species that forms a dimeric, then a non-native trimeric (protrimer) species by addition of folding competent monomers. We have found three residues, R549, R563, and D572, which play a critical role in both the stability of the native tailspike protein and assembly and maturation of the protrimer. King and colleagues reported previously that substitution of R563 to glutamine inhibited protrimer formation. We now show that the R549Q and R563K variants significantly delay the protrimer-to-trimer transition both in vivo and in vitro. Previously, variants that destabilize intermediates have shown wild-type chemical stability. Interestingly, both the R549Q and R563K variants destabilize the tailspike trimer in guanidine denaturation studies, indicating that they represent a new class of tailspike folding variants. R549Q has a midpoint of unfolding at 3.2M guanidine, compared to 5.6M for the wild-type tailspike protein, while R563K has a midpoint of unfolding of 1.8 M. R549Q and R563K also denature over a broader pH range than the wild-type tailspike protein and both proteins have increased sensitivity to pH during refolding, suggesting that both residues are involved in ionic interactions. Our model is that R563 and D572 interact to stabilize the adjacent turn, aiding the assembly of the dimer and protrimer species. We believe that the interaction between R563 and D572 is also critical following assembly of the protrimer to properly orient D572 in order to form a salt bridge with R549 during protrimer maturation.     

Thermal unfolding pathway for the thermostable P22 tailspike endorhamnosidase

The conditions in which protein stability is biologically or industrially relevant frequently differ from those in which reversible denaturation is studied. The trimeric tailspike endorhamnosidase of phage P22 is a viral structural protein which exhibits high stability to heat, proteases, and detergents under a range of environmental conditions. Its intracellular folding pathway includes monomeric and trimeric folding intermediates and has been the subject of detailed genetic analysis. To understand the basis of tailspike thermostability, we have examined the kinetics of thermal and detergent unfolding. During thermal unfolding of the tailspike, a metastable unfolding intermediate accumulates which can be trapped in the cold or in the presence of SDS. This species is still trimeric, but has lost the ability to bind to virus capsids and, unlike the native trimer, is partially susceptible to protease digestion. Its N-terminal regions, containing about 110 residues, are unfolded whereas the central regions and the C-termini of the polypeptide chains are still in the folded state. Thus, the initiation step in thermal denaturation is the unfolding of the N-termini, but melting of the intermediate represents a second kinetic barrier in the denaturation process. This two-step unfolding is unusually slow at elevated temperature; for instance, in 2% SDS at 65 degrees C, the unfolding rate constant is 1.1 x 10(-3) s-1 for the transition from the native to the unfolding intermediate and 4.0 x 10(-5) s-1 for the transition from the intermediate to the unfolded chains. The sequential unfolding pathway explains the insensitivity of the apparent Tm to the presence of temperature-sensitive folding mutations [Sturtevant, J. M., Yu, M.-H., Haase-Pettingell, C., & King, J. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 10693-10698] which are located in the central region of the chain. The metastable unfolding intermediate has not been detected in the forward folding pathway occurring at lower temperatures. The early stage of the high-temperature thermal unfolding pathway is not the reverse of the late stage of the low-temperature folding pathway.     

Protein folding in the cell: reshaping the folding funnel

Models of protein folding have historically focused on a subset of 'well-behaved' proteins that can be successfully refolded from denaturants in vitro. Energy landscapes, including folding funnel 'cartoons', describe the largely uncomplicated folding of these isolated chains at infinite dilution. However, the frequent failure of many polypeptides to fold to their native state requires more comprehensive models of folding to accommodate the crucial role of interactions between partially folded intermediates. By incorporating additional deep minima, which reflect off-pathway interchain interactions, the folding funnel concept can be extended to describe the behavior of a more diverse set of proteins under more physiologically relevant conditions. In particular, the effects of ribosomes (translation), molecular chaperones and other aspects of the cellular environment on early chain conformations can be included to account for the folding behavior of polypeptide chains in cells.     

Formation of fibrous aggregates from a non-native intermediate: the isolated P22 tailspike beta-helix domain.

In the assembly pathway of the trimeric P22 tailspike protein, the protein conformation critical for the partitioning between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation is a monomeric folding intermediate. The central domain of tailspike, a large right-handed parallel beta-helix, is essentially structured in this species. We used the isolated beta-helix domain (Bhx), expressed with a hexahistidine tag, to investigate the mechanism of aggregation without the two terminal domains present in the complete protein. Although Bhx has been shown to fold reversibly at low ionic strength conditions, increased ionic strength induced aggregation with a maximum at urea concentrations corresponding to the midpoint of urea-induced folding transitions. According to size exclusion chromatography, aggregation appeared to proceed via a linear polymerization mechanism. Circular dichroism indicated a secondary structure content of the aggregates similar to that of the native state, but at the same time their tryptophan fluorescence was largely quenched. Microscopic analysis of the aggregates revealed a variety of morphologies; among others, fibrils with fine structure were observed that exhibited bright green birefringence if viewed under cross-polarized light after staining with Congo red. These observations, together with the effects of folding mutations on the aggregation process, indicate the involvement of a partially structured intermediate distinct from both unfolded and native Bhx.     

Hydrostatic pressure rescues native protein from aggregates.

Misfolding and misassembly of proteins are major problems in the biotechnology industry, in biochemical research, and in human disease. Here we describe a novel approach for reversing aggregation and increasing refolding by application of hydrostatic pressure. Using P22 tailspike protein as a model system, intermediates along the aggregation pathway were identified and quantitated by size-exclusion high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Tailspike aggregates were subjected to hydrostatic pressures of 2.4 kbar (35,000 psi). This treatment dissociated the tailspike aggregates and resulted in increased formation of native trimers once pressure was released. Tailspike trimers refolded at these pressures were fully active for formation of infectious viral particles. This technique can facilitate conversion of aggregates to native proteins without addition of chaotropic agents, changes in buffer, or large-scale dilution of reagents required for traditional refolding methods. Our results also indicate that one or more intermediates at the junction between the folding and aggregation pathways is pressure sensitive. This finding supports the hypothesis that specific determinants of recognition exist for protein aggregation, and that these determinants are similar to those involved in folding to the native state. An increased understanding of this specificity should lead to improved refolding methods.     

Secondary structure and thermostability of the phage P22 tailspike. XX. Analysis by Raman spectroscopy of the wild-type protein and a temperature-sensitive folding mutant

The thermostable tailspike endorhamnosidase of bacteriophage P22 has been investigated by laser Raman spectroscopy to determine the protein's secondary structure and the basis of its thermostability. The conformation of the native tailspike, determined by Raman amide I and amide III band analyses, is 52 to 61% beta-sheet, 24 to 27% alpha-helix, 15 to 21% beta-turn and 0 to 10% other structure types. The secondary structure of the wild-type tailspike, as monitored by the conformation-sensitive Raman amide bands, was stable to 80 degrees C, denatured reversibly between 80 and 90 degrees C, and irreversibly above 90 degrees C. The purified native form of a temperature-sensitive folding mutant (tsU38) contains secondary structures virtually identical to those in the wild-type in aqueous solution at physiological conditions (0.05 M-Na+ (pH 7.5], at both permissive (20 degrees C) and restrictive (40 degrees C) temperatures. This supports previous results showing that the mutational defect at 40 degrees C affects intermediates in the folding pathway rather than the native structure. At temperatures above 60 degrees C the wild-type and mutant forms were distinguishable: the reversible and irreversible denaturation thresholds were approximately 15 to 20 degrees C lower in the mutant than in the wild-type protein. The irreversible denaturation of the mutant tailspikes led to different aggregation/polymerization products from the wild-type, indicating that the mutation altered the unfolding pathway. In both cases only a small percentage of the native secondary structure was altered by irreversible thermal denaturation, indicating that the aggregated states retain considerable native structure.     

Protein folding and chaperonins

The folding of polypeptide chains in cells, following either translation or translocation through membranes, must take place under conditions of extremely high protein concentrations. In addition, folding into a correct structure must occur in the presence of other rapidly folding species, and at temperatures known to destabilize aggregation-prone folding intermediates. To facilitate folding in vivo, molecular chaperones have evolved that stabilize protein folding intermediates, thus partitioning them towards a pathway leading to the native state rather than forming inactive aggregated structures.