Pseudomonas aeruginosa for the Evaluation of Swimming Pool Chlorination and Algicides

Concentrations of ammonia and the chlorine stabilizer, cyanuric acid, which could be expected in swimming pools decreased the rate of kill by chlorine of the potential pathogen, Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The effect of cyanuric acid increased as the concentration of chlorine decreased, a fact of significance from a public health view. Quaternary ammonium algcides had little effect on the kill rate of chlorine, but an organic mercury algicide had a synergistic effect with chlorine when the chlorine activity was stressed by the addition of ammonia or the use of 100 times the normal concentration of bacteria. The effect of natural waters, rain, beaches, and swimming pools on the kill rate by 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter indicated that a treatment time of 1 hr or more was required to kill 99.9% of 10(6)Pseudomonas cells per ml. The synergism of chlorine and the organic mercury algicide was also demonstrated with these waters and with sewage treatment plant effluents. The necessity of developing and using laboratory tests which simulate conditions in swimming pools with heavy loads of swimmers, as opposed to tests in chlorine demand-free conditions, is discussed. Samples taken from well-supervised swimming pools when the swimmer load had been especially high required treatment times of 1 to 3 hr to obtain 99.9% kills of the potential pathogen, P. aeruginosa, with 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter.     

Soil amoebas as biological markers to estimate the quality of swimming pool waters

The legal biological survey of swimming pool waters is based on both the level of bacteriological contamination and the amount of material of fecal origin. The great number of soil amoebas and the occasional epidemiological risk involved led us to consider using these organisms as possible biological markers to estimate the quality of pool water and the extent of disinfection. During a 1-year survey of 54 public swimming pools, 765 superficial pool and tap water samples were collected. One portion (50 ml) drawn from 1-liter samples was filtered and cultured for amoebas. In specimens considered contaminated we detected at least 20 amoebas per liter, whereas uncontaminated samples contained fewer than 20 amoebas per liter. By keeping the threshold value voluntarily low, we were able to compare tap water with pool water and to monitor the quality of various disinfection procedures (i.e., chlorine, bromine, and Cu-Ag). The data suggest that the filters were not always protective against a high concentration of amoebas. Furthermore, these disinfection procedures were not equally efficient according to estimates based on biological criteria. In addition, the quality of swimming pool water also depends on the quality of its source tap water. Thus, the numeration of soil amoebas can be used as an additional biological marker to estimate the quality of swimming pool water.     

Soil amoebas as biological markers to estimate the quality of swimming pool waters.

The legal biological survey of swimming pool waters is based on both the level of bacteriological contamination and the amount of material of fecal origin. The great number of soil amoebas and the occasional epidemiological risk involved led us to consider using these organisms as possible biological markers to estimate the quality of pool water and the extent of disinfection. During a 1-year survey of 54 public swimming pools, 765 superficial pool and tap water samples were collected. One portion (50 ml) drawn from 1-liter samples was filtered and cultured for amoebas. In specimens considered contaminated we detected at least 20 amoebas per liter, whereas uncontaminated samples contained fewer than 20 amoebas per liter. By keeping the threshold value voluntarily low, we were able to compare tap water with pool water and to monitor the quality of various disinfection procedures (i.e., chlorine, bromine, and Cu-Ag). The data suggest that the filters were not always protective against a high concentration of amoebas. Furthermore, these disinfection procedures were not equally efficient according to estimates based on biological criteria. In addition, the quality of swimming pool water also depends on the quality of its source tap water. Thus, the numeration of soil amoebas can be used as an additional biological marker to estimate the quality of swimming pool water.     

Factors Influencing the Effectiveness of Swimming Pool Bactericides

Techniques for culturing, harvesting, and testing bacteria to evaluate bactericidal chemicals for swimming pools are described. Concentrations of 25, 50, and 100 mg of the chlorine stabilizer cyanuric acid per liter increased the time required for a 99% kill of Streptococcus faecalis by 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter at pH 7.4 and 20 C from less than 0.25 min without cyanuric acid to 4, 6, and 12 min, respectively. The effect of concentrations of ammonia nitrogen in the range found in swimming pools on the rate of kill of 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter and of chlorine plus cyanuric acid was tested. At concentrations of ammonia nitrogen greater than 0.05 mg per liter, faster rates of kill of S. faecalis were obtained with 100 mg of cyanuric acid per liter plus 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter than with 0.5 mg of chlorine per liter alone. When water samples from four swimming pools with low ammonia levels were used as test media, 0.5 mg of added chlorine per liter killed 99.9% of the added S. faecalis in less than 2 min, but water from a pool with a large number of children required 60 to 180 min of treatment.     

Limax Amoebae in Public Swimming Pools of Albany, Schenectady, and Rensselaer Counties, New York: Their Concentration, Correlations, and Significance

A survey was conducted on 30 halogenated public swimming pools, located in Albany, Schenectady, and Rensselaer counties, to determine their open-water limax amoeba densities. Six were outdoor pools. Other variables measured were the standard plate count, total seston, free residual chlorine or bromine, total alkalinity, total hardness, orthophosphate, total soluble phosphorus, specific conductance, pH, temperature, and several engineering parameters including the rate and type of filtration as well as a saturation index. Amoebae were isolated on agar plates at 37°C using heat-killed bacterial suspensions of Enterobacter cloacae or Escherichia coli. Most probable number estimates of amoebic densities ranged from not detectable (<0.01) to 110 amoebae per liter. The median concentration of amoebae was 0.9/liter. Eighty percent of the pools examined had less than 5 amoebae per liter. Significant correlations (P < 0.05) were found between amoebic densities and the log₁₀ of the standard plate count, orthophosphate, and total soluble phosphorus. No significant difference was found between amoebic densities in outdoor and indoor pools. Preliminary tests for the presence of the human pathogen Naegleria fowleri were inconclusive.     

Determinants of the microbiological characteristics of South Australian swimming pools.

A survey of 100 swimming pools has been conducted to assess the effectiveness of disinfection practices against various microorganisms and to check compliance with recommended chlorine levels and pH. Microbiological quality was assessed from densities of total coliforms, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, total colony counts, and the presence or absence of amoebae, including the pathogen Naegleria fowleri. Although a free chlorine residual of 1.0 mg/liter and a pH range of 7.0 to 7.6 are recommended by local health authorities, 41 pools had a lower free chlorine residual and 37 had a pH outside this range. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to test the association of field measurements with the microbiological data. The analysis demonstrated a strong positive association of free chlorine with bacteriological quality and the absence of Naegleria spp. No other field measurement was predictive in this regard, although the absence of all amoebae was associated with a relatively low water temperature and pH. Using a mathematical model derived from this analysis, it was estimated that 99% of pools would have acceptable bacteriological quality and 94% would be free of Naegleria spp. at a free chlorine residual of 1.0 mg/liter. However, at the mean water temperature (23 degrees C) and pH (7.5) seen in this study, other amoebae would still be detectable in 500-ml samples taken from 40% of pools at this chlorine level.     

Determinants of the microbiological characteristics of South Australian swimming pools

A survey of 100 swimming pools has been conducted to assess the effectiveness of disinfection practices against various microorganisms and to check compliance with recommended chlorine levels and pH. Microbiological quality was assessed from densities of total coliforms, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, total colony counts, and the presence or absence of amoebae, including the pathogen Naegleria fowleri. Although a free chlorine residual of 1.0 mg/liter and a pH range of 7.0 to 7.6 are recommended by local health authorities, 41 pools had a lower free chlorine residual and 37 had a pH outside this range. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to test the association of field measurements with the microbiological data. The analysis demonstrated a strong positive association of free chlorine with bacteriological quality and the absence of Naegleria spp. No other field measurement was predictive in this regard, although the absence of all amoebae was associated with a relatively low water temperature and pH. Using a mathematical model derived from this analysis, it was estimated that 99% of pools would have acceptable bacteriological quality and 94% would be free of Naegleria spp. at a free chlorine residual of 1.0 mg/liter. However, at the mean water temperature (23 degrees C) and pH (7.5) seen in this study, other amoebae would still be detectable in 500-ml samples taken from 40% of pools at this chlorine level.     

A note on legionellas in whirlpools

Water samples from 52 whirlpools (jacuzzi), water temperature 35–40°C, and from 50 swimming pools, water temperature 8–30°C, were investigated for the presence of Legionella pneumophila. This was isolated from 11 of 28 whirlpools with free available chlorine less than 0.3 mg/1. No legionellas were detected in 23 whirlpools with free available chlorine over 0.3 mg/l. Legionella pneumophila was found in two swimming pools. The results indicate that 0.3 mg/l of free available chlorine is sufficient to eliminate legionellas from whirlpools.     

Comparison of Vogel-Johnson and Baird-Parker media for membrane filtration recovery of staphylococci in swimming pool water.

Previous studies have indicated that the coagulase-positive Staphylococcus (Staphylococcus aureus) has potential as a useful indicator of the infection hazard associated with the use of swimming pools and other recreational waters. However, before this indicator system can be used effectively, a recovery system that is sufficiently selective, accurate, and reliable for the enumeration of S. aureus must be developed. In this study, Vogel-Johnson (VJ) and Baird-Parker (BP) agars were compared for efficacy in the primary isolation and recovery of S. aureus from swimming pool water. For equal sample volumes of pool water containing adequate free chlorine residual, VJ agar was found to be more selective for staphylococcal species and less inhibitory to general cell growth than was BP agar. However, neither medium was found to be sufficiently differential to permit the accurate identification of S. aureus. In contrast, water samples obtained from a swimming pool containing very low levels of chlorine (none of which was in the free form) showed abundant growth of staphylococci on both test media, with both VJ and BP agars showing increased sensitivity for the detection of S. aureus. Thus, VJ and BP agars show increased sensitivity for the detection of coagulase-positive staphylococci from unchlorinated versus chlorinated waters.     

Comparison of Vogel-Johnson and Baird-Parker media for membrane filtration recovery of staphylococci in swimming pool water

Previous studies have indicated that the coagulase-positive Staphylococcus (Staphylococcus aureus) has potential as a useful indicator of the infection hazard associated with the use of swimming pools and other recreational waters. However, before this indicator system can be used effectively, a recovery system that is sufficiently selective, accurate, and reliable for the enumeration of S. aureus must be developed. In this study, Vogel-Johnson (VJ) and Baird-Parker (BP) agars were compared for efficacy in the primary isolation and recovery of S. aureus from swimming pool water. For equal sample volumes of pool water containing adequate free chlorine residual, VJ agar was found to be more selective for staphylococcal species and less inhibitory to general cell growth than was BP agar. However, neither medium was found to be sufficiently differential to permit the accurate identification of S. aureus. In contrast, water samples obtained from a swimming pool containing very low levels of chlorine (none of which was in the free form) showed abundant growth of staphylococci on both test media, with both VJ and BP agars showing increased sensitivity for the detection of S. aureus. Thus, VJ and BP agars show increased sensitivity for the detection of coagulase-positive staphylococci from unchlorinated versus chlorinated waters.     

Specimen housing unit for cinemicrographic studies in the vertical plane.

The destructive action of chlorine on the pathogenic Naegleria fowleri and Acanthamoeba culbertsoni, the nonpathogenic N. gruberi, and an avirulent Acanthamoeba isolate was investigated. N fowleri is somewhat more sensitive to chlorine than N. gruberi, whereas the two Acanthamoeba strains are very resistant. This study yields information needed for the destruction of amoebic cysts in drinking water and swimming pools. It also gives some explanation for the occurence of Acanthamoeba strains in these waters.     

Comparison of Chlorine, Bromine, and Iodine as Disinfectants for Swimming Pool Water

Studies on the germicidal activity of chlorine, bromine, and iodine were made by use of the Association of Official Agricultural Chemists official first action method for determining effectiveness of swimming pool water disinfectants. In this procedure, 0.3 ppm of available chlorine as chlorine gas has activity equivalent to 0.6 ppm of available chlorine in the buffered sodium hypochlorite control when Escherichia coli is used as the test organism. With Streptococcus faecalis as the test organism, 0.45 ppm of available chlorine as gaseous chlorine gives activity equivalent to the control. Liquid bromine at 1.0 ppm is as effective as the 0.6 ppm of available chlorine hypochlorite control with E. coli as the test organism, but 2.0 ppm of liquid bromine is necessary to provide activity equivalent to the 0.6 ppm of available chlorine control when S. faecalis is employed. With iodine as metallic iodine, 2.0 ppm is necessary to provide a result equivalent to the 0.6 ppm of available chlorine control with both E. coli and S. faecalis. In the various systems tested, gaseous chlorine was the most active form of available chlorine; liquid bromine provided the most active form of bromine, and metallic iodine provided the most active form of iodine.     

A note on legionellas in whirlpools

Water samples from 52 whirlpools (jacuzzi), water temperature 35-40 degrees C, and from 50 swimming pools, water temperature 8-30 degrees C, were investigated for the presence of Legionella pneumophila. This was isolated from 11 of 28 whirlpools with free available chlorine less than 0.3 mg/l. No legionellas were detected in 23 whirlpools with free available chlorine over 0.3 mg/l. Legionella pneumophila was found in two swimming pools. The results indicate that 0.3 mg/l of free available chlorine is sufficient to eliminate legionellas from whirlpools.     

Determination of haloacetic acids in human urine by headspace gas chromatography–mass spectrometry

Haloacetic acids (HAAs) are water disinfection byproducts (DBPs) formed by the reaction of chlorine oxidizing compounds with natural organic matter in water containing bromine. HAAs are second to trihalomethanes as the most commonly detected DBPs in surface drinking water and swimming pools. After oral exposure (drinking, showering, bathing and swimming), HAAs are rapidly absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract and excreted in urine. Typical methods used to determine these compounds in urine (mainly from rodents) only deal with one or two HAAs and their sensitivity is inadequate to determine HAA levels in human urine, even those manual sample preparation protocols which are complex, costly, and neither handy nor amenable to automation. In the present communication, we report on a sensitive and straightforward method to determine the nine HAAs in human urine using static headspace (HS) coupled with GC–MS. Important parameters controlling derivatisation and HS extraction were optimised to obtain the highest sensitivity: 120 μl of dimethylsulphate and 100 μl of tetrabutylammonium hydrogen sulphate (derivatisation regents) were selected, along with an excess of Na₂SO₄ (6 g per 12 ml of urine), an oven temperature of 70 °C and an equilibration time of 20 min. The method developed renders an efficient tool for the precise and sensitive determination of the nine HAAs in human urine (RSDs ranging from 6 to 11%, whereas LODs ranged from 0.01 to 0.1 μg/l). The method was applied in the determination of HAAs in urine from swimmers in an indoor swimming pool, as well as in that of non-swimmers. HAAs were not detected in the urine samples from non-swimmers and those of volunteers before their swims; therefore, the concentrations found after exposure were directly related to the swimming activity. The amounts of MCAA, DCAA and TCAA excreted from all swimmers are related to the highest levels in the swimming pool water.     

Influence of Stabilizer Concentration on Effectiveness of Chlorine as an Algicide

Cyanuric acid, used as chlorine stabilizer in swimming pool waters, has a relatively minor effect on the algicidal efficiency of free chlorine. The toxicity of free chlorine to three swimming pool algae was reduced slightly by 25 mg of cyanuric acid per liter if inhibiting, but less than algicidal, concentrations of chlorine were employed. Higher stabilizer concentrations (50, 100, and 200 mg/liter) generally resulted in no further reduction in the algicidal efficiency of free chlorine beyond that observed at 25 mg/liter.     

Respiratory Function and Changes in Lung Epithelium Biomarkers after a Short-Training Intervention in Chlorinated vs. Ozone Indoor Pools

Background

Swimming in indoor pools treated with combined chemical treatments (e.g. ozone) may reduce direct exposure to disinfection byproducts and thus have less negative effects on respiratory function compared to chlorinated pools. The aim of this study is to analyze the effects of a short-term training intervention on respiratory function and lung epithelial damage in adults exercising in indoor swimming pool waters treated with different disinfection methods (chlorine vs. ozone with bromine).

Methods

Lung permeability biomakers [surfactant protein D (SP-D) and Clara cell secretory protein (CC16) in plasma] and forced expiratory volumes and flow (FEV1, FVC and FEF_25–75) were measured in 39 healthy adults. Thirteen participants swam during 20 sessions in a chlorinated pool (CP), 13 performed and equivolumic intervention in an ozone pool (OP) and 13 were included in a control group (CG) without exposition.

Results

Median plasma CC16 levels increased in CP swimmers (4.27±3.29 and 6.62±5.51 µg/L, p = 0.01, pre and post intervention respectively) while no significant changes in OP and CG participants were found. No significant changes in median plasma SP-D levels were found in any of the groups after the training period. FVC increased in OP (4.26±0.86 and 4.43±0.92 L, p<0.01) and CP swimmers (4.25±0.86 and 4.35±0.85 L, p<0.01). FEV1 only increased in OP swimmers (3.50±0.65 and 3.59±0.67, p = 0.02) and FEF_25–75 decreased in CP swimmers (3.70±0.87 and 3.37±0.67, p = 0.02).

Conclusion

Despite lung function being similar in both groups, a higher lung permeability in CP compared to OP swimmers was found after a short-term swimming program. Combined chemical treatments for swimming pools such as ozone seem to have less impact on lung epithelial of swimmers compared to chlorinated treated pools.     

Comparative assessment of different biocides in swimming pool water

For disinfection of swimming pool water chlorine of chlorine-based products are normally used. In practice, these products have proven their worth regarding killing of pathogenic micro-organisms. Detailed values of their biocidal activity in swimming pool water were not found in literature. In the given study the efficacy of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) versus five micro-organisms was investigated.It is known that chlorination of swimming pool water may lead to formation of specific unwanted products like haloform. Nowadays, the concentration of those by-products in swimming pool water is limited and specific measures exist to minimize their formation. Nevertheless, there is increasing interest in alternative methods without by-product formation like e.g. hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) treatment.In the given study the antimicrobial activity of sodium hypochlorite was compared with that of different hydrogen peroxide-based products. The test procedure used was specifically designed to simulate practical conditions in a swimming pool but at the same time to lead to adequate reproducibility. Five test organisms were selected being relevant for the swimming pool area: Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, Legionella pneumophila, Staphylococcus aureus and Candida albicans.The swimming pool water for the test was artificially prepared. Water hardness, temperature and pH value were adjusted to a defined level. Regarding simulation of organic load it was found that a mixture of urea, creatinine and several amino acids was most appropriate.Addition of the test organisms was done in three portions: one big in the beginning and two smaller after 10 and 20 min to simulate recontamination by bathers. Total test period was 30 min. The number of surviving cells was determined after 30 s as well as after 10, 20 and 30 min.Sodium hypochlorite was tested at a concentration of 1 ppm active chlorine. Compared to that three products based on hydrogen peroxide were investigated: pure hydrogen peroxide, hydrogen peroxide + silver nitrate and a trade product based on hydrogen peroxide.Sodium hypochlorite resulted in total kill of the inoculated organisms after 10, 20 and 30 min corresponding to a log 4 reduction. In contrast to that the biocidal effect achieved by the hydrogen peroxide-based products was significantly lower than one log cycle notwithstanding a very high concentration of up to 150 ppm.The test results confirm the very good killing activity of sodium hypochlorite versus micro-organisms relevant for the swimming pool area. Products based on hydrogen peroxide, with or without silver ions, are from a microbiological point of view no real alternative to chlorine disinfection in swimming pools.     

Algicidal and Sanitizing Properties of Armazide

Algicidal and sanitizing properties of Armazide, a new swimming pool additive, consisting of 12% w/v each of dodecylamine hydrochloride, trimethyl alkyl ammonium chloride, and methyl alkyl dipolyoxypropylene ammonium methyl sulfate in solution, were evaluated by laboratory techniques against algae and sewage. Results indicated it to be highly effective in low concentrations especially in conjunction with low concentrations of chlorine. Swimming pool field tests were found to confirm the laboratory findings. Various treatment levels and methods are described for swimming pools using treatments based upon the actual condition of the pool and water. The use of the product permitted a reduction in chlorine residual in pools resulting in greatly reduced requirements for chlorinating chemicals along with absence of irritation, odor, and other undesirable results usually associated with standard pool chlorination methods.     

Interaction of bromine with iodine in the rat thyroid gland at enhanced bromide intake

In experiments with rats, we have found that at enhanced intake of bromide, bromine does not replace chlorine in the thyroid; it replaces iodine. Under our experimental conditions, more than onethird of the iodine content in the thyroid was replaced by bromine. In the thyroid, bromine probably remained in the form of bromide and, in proportional to its increased concentration, the production of iodinated thyronines decreased, with the sum of the iodine and bromine concentrations being constant at the value of 20.51±1.16 μmol/g dry wt of the thyroid. In contrast to other organs, the biological behavior of bromine in the thyroid is not similar to the biological behavior of chlorine but resembles more that of iodine.     

Colonization of abandoned swimming pools by larval mosquitoes and their predators following Hurricane Katrina

Thousands of flooded swimming pools were abandoned in New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina and provided a natural experiment to examine colonization of a novel aquatic habitat by mosquito larvae and their aquatic predators. We conducted a randomized survey of flooded swimming pools in two neighborhoods in January 2006 and found that 64% contained mosquito larvae, 92% contained predatory invertebrates, and 47% contained fishes. We collected 12,379 immature mosquitoes representing five species, primarily Culiseta inornata, and secondarily, the arboviral vector Culex quinquefasciatus. Dragonfly nymphs in the families Aeshnidae and Libellulidae were the most common predatory invertebrates collected among a total of 32 non-mosquito invertebrate species. Eleven species of fishes were collected, with Gambusia affinis accounting for 76% of the catch. Diversity of fishes in swimming pools was positively correlated with proximity to a levee breach and the fish assemblage found in swimming pools was similar to that found along shorelines of Lake Pontchartrain and drainage canals that flooded the study area. Mosquito larvae were rare or absent from pools containing fishes; however, path analysis indicated that the presence of top predators or abundant competitors may somewhat mitigate the effect of Gambusia affinis on mosquito presence.