Carbon isotope discrimination in C3-C4 intermediates

Carbon isotope discrimination in C₃–C₄ intermediates is determined by fractionations during diffusion and the biochemical fractionations occurring during CO₂ fixation. These biochemical fractionations in turn depend on the fractionation by Rubisco in the mesophyll, the amount of CO₂ fixation. These biochemical fractionations in turn depend on the fractionation by Rubisco in the mesophyll, the amount of CO₂ fixation occurring in the bundle sheath, the extent of bundle-sheath leakiness and the contribution which C₄-cycle activity makes to the CO₂ pool there. In most instances, carbon isotope discrimination in C₃–C₄ intermediates is C₃-like because only a small fraction of the total carbon fixed is fixed in the bundle sheath. In particular, this must be the case for Flaveria intermediates which initially fix substantial amounts of CO₂ into C₄-acids. In C₃–C₄ intermediates that refix photorespiratory CO₂ alone, it is possible for carbon isotope discrimination to be greater than in C₃-species, particularly at low CO₂ pressures or at high leaf temperatures. Short-term measurements of carbon isotope discrimination and gas exchange of leaves can be used to study the photosynthetic pathways of C₃-C₄ intermediates and their hybrids as has recently been done for C₃ and C₄ species.     

An examination of the advantages of C3-C4 intermediate photosynthesis in warm environments

Abstract. The photosynthetic responses to temperature in C₃, C₃-C₄ intermediate, and C₄ species in the genus Flaveria were examined in an effort to identify whether the reduced photorespiration rates characteristic of C₃-C₄ intermediate photosynthesis result in adaptive advantages at warm leaf temperatures. Reduced photorespiration rates were reflected in lower CO₂ compensation points at all temperatures examined in the C₃-C₄ intermediate, Flaveria floridana, compared to the C₃ species, F. cronquistii. The C₃-C₄ intermediate, F. floridana, exhibited a C₃-like photosynthetic temperature dependence, except for relatively higher photosynthesis rates at warm leaf temperatures compared to the C₃ species, F. cronquistii. Using models of C₃ and C₃-C₄ intermediate photosynthesis, it was predicted that by recycling photorespired CO₂ in bundle-sheath cells, as occurs in many C₃-C₄ intermediates, photosynthesis rates at 35°C could be increased by 28%, compared to a C₃ plant. Without recycling photorespired CO₂, it was calculated that in order to improve photosynthesis rates at 35°C by this amount in C₃ plants, (1) intercellular CO₂ partial pressures would have to be increased from 25 to 31 Pa, resulting in a 57% decrease in water-use efficiency, or (2) the activity of RuBP carboxylase would have to be increased by 32%, resulting in a 22% decrease in nitrogen-use efficiency. In addition to the recycling of photorespired CO₂, leaves of F. floridana appear to effectively concentrate CO₂ at the active site of RuBP carboxylase, increasing the apparent carboxylation efficiency per unit of in vitro RuBP carboxylase activity. The CO₂-concentrating activity also appears to reduce the temperature sensitivity of the carboxylation efficiency in F. floridana compared to F. cronquistii. The carboxylation efficiency per unit of RuBP carboxylase activity decreased by only 38% in F. floridana, compared to 50% in F. cronquistii, as leaf temperature was raised from 25 to 35°C. The C₃-C₄ intermediate, F. ramosissima, exhibited a photosynthetic temperature temperature response curve that was more similar to the C₄ species, F. trinervia, than the C₃ species, F. cronquistii. The C₄-like pattern is probably related to the advanced nature of C₄-like biochemical traits in F. ramosissima The results demonstrate that reductions in photorespiration rates in C₃-C₄ intermediate plants create photosynthetic advantages at warm leaf temperatures that in C₃ plants could only be achieved through substantial costs to water-use efficiency and/or nitrogen-use efficiency.     

On the significance of C3—C4 intermediate photosynthesis to the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Abstract Evidence is drawn from previous studies to argue that C₃—C₄ intermediate plants are evolutionary intermediates, evolving from fully-expressed C₃ plants towards fully-expressed C₄ plants. On the basis of this conclusion, C₃—C₄ intermediates are examined to elucidate possible patterns that have been followed during the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. An hypothesis is proposed that the initial step in C₄-evolution was the development of bundle-sheath metabolism that reduced apparent photorespiration by an efficient recycling of CO₂ using RuBP carboxylase. The CO₂-recycling mechanism appears to involve the differential compartmentation of glycine decarboxylase between mesophyll and bundle-sheath cells, such that most of the activity is in the bundlesheath cells. Subsequently, elevated phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylase activities are proposed to have evolved as a means of enhancing the recycling of photorespired CO₂. As the activity of PEP carboxylase increased to higher values, other enzymes in the C₄-pathway are proposed to have increased in activity to facilitate the processing of the products of C₄-assimilation and provide PEP substrate to PEP carboxylase with greater efficiency. Initially, such a ‘C₄-cycle’ would not have been differentially compartmentalized between mesophyll and bundlesheath cells as is typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Such metabolism would have limited benefit in terms of concentrating CO₂ at RuBP carboxylase and, therefore, also be of little benefit for improving water- and nitrogen-use efficiencies. However, the development of such a limited C₄-cycle would have represented a preadaptation capable of evolving into the leaf biochemistry typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Thus, during the initial stages of C₄-evolution it is proposed that improvements in photorespiratory CO₂-loss and their influence on increasing the rate of net CO₂ assimilation per unit leaf area represented the evolutionary ‘driving-force’. Improved resourceuse efficiency resulting from an efficient CO₂-concentrating mechanism is proposed as the driving force during the later stages.     

C4 photosynthesis in a single C3 cell is theoretically inefficient but may ameliorate internal CO2 diffusion limitations of C3 leaves

Attempts are being made to introduce C₄ photosynthetic characteristics into C₃ crop plants by genetic manipulation. This research has focused on engineering single‐celled C₄‐type CO₂ concentrating mechanisms into C₃ plants such as rice. Herein the pros and cons of such approaches are discussed with a focus on CO₂ diffusion, utilizing a mathematical model of single‐cell C₄ photosynthesis. It is shown that a high bundle sheath resistance to CO₂ diffusion is an essential feature of energy‐efficient C₄ photosynthesis. The large chloroplast surface area appressed to the intercellular airspace in C₃ leaves generates low internal resistance to CO₂ diffusion, thereby limiting the energy efficiency of a single‐cell C₄ concentrating mechanism, which relies on concentrating CO₂ within chloroplasts of C₃ leaves. Nevertheless the model demonstrates that the drop in CO₂ partial pressure, pCO₂, that exists between intercellular airspace and chloroplasts in C₃ leaves at high photosynthetic rates, can be reversed under high irradiance when energy is not limiting. The model shows that this is particularly effective at lower intercellular pCO₂. Such a system may therefore be of benefit in water‐limited conditions when stomata are closed and low intercellular pCO₂ increases photorespiration.     

Carbon: terrestrial C4 plants

The carbon isotope composition of terrestrial C₄ plants depends on the primary carboxylation of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) and on the diffusion of CO₂ to the carboxylation sites, but is also influenced by the final carboxylation of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP). Several models have been used for reproducing this complex situation. In the present review, a particular model is applied as a means to interpret the effects of environmental and genetically determined factors on carbon isotope discrimination during C₄ photosynthesis. As a new feature, the model considers four types of limitation of the overall CO₂ assimilation rate. Both carboxylation reactions are assumed to be limited by either maximum enzyme activity or maximum substrate regeneration rate. The model is applied to experimental data on the effects of CO₂, irradiance and water stress on short-term discrimination by leaves of several C₄ species measured simultaneously with CO₂ gas exchange characteristics. In particular, different patterns of the influence of low irradiances on carbon isotope discrimination are interpreted as due to variations in that irradiance at which a transition from limitation by PEP regeneration rate and RuBP carboxylase activity to limitation by the regeneration rates of both substrates occurs. After discussing literature data on the effects of environmental conditions on carbon isotope discrimination by C₄ plants seasonal and developmental changes in carbon isotope composition, studies on the systematic and geographic distribution of C₄ plants, evolutionary and genetical aspects, and some ecological implications are reviewed.     

Photosynthesis, immediate export and carbon partitioning in source leaves of C3, C3-C4 intermediate, and C4Panicum and Flaveria species at ambient and elevated CO2 levels

Immediate export in leaves of C₃‐C₄ intermediates were compared with their C₃ and C₄ relatives within the Panicum and Flaveria genera. At 35 Pa CO₂, photosynthesis and export were highest in C₄ species in each genera. Within the Panicum, photosynthesis and export in ‘type I’ C₃‐C₄ intermediates were greater than those in C₃ species. However, ‘type I’ C₃‐C₄ intermediates exported a similar proportion of newly fixed ¹⁴C as did C₄ species. Within the Flaveria, ‘type II’ C₃‐C₄ intermediate species had the lowest export rather than the C₃ species. At ambient CO₂, immediate export was strongly correlated with photosynthesis. However, at 90 Pa CO₂, when photosynthesis and immediate export increased in all C₃ and C₃‐C₄ intermediate species, proportionally less C was exported in all photosynthetic types than that at ambient CO₂. All species accumulated starch and sugars at both CO₂ levels. There was no correlation between immediate export and the pattern of ¹⁴C‐labelling into sugars and starch among the photosynthetic types within each genus. However, during CO₂ enrichment, C₄Panicum species accumulated sugars above the level of sugars and starch normally made at ambient CO₂, whereas the C₄Flaveria species accumulated only additional starch.     

Naturally low carbonic anhydrase activity in C4 and C3 plants limits discrimination against C18OO during photosynthesis

The ¹⁸O content of CO₂ is a powerful tracer of photosynthetic activity at the ecosystem and global scale. Due to oxygen exchange between CO₂ and ¹⁸O-enriched leaf water and retrodiffusion of most of this CO₂ back to the atmosphere, leaves effectively discriminate against ¹⁸O during photosynthesis. Discrimination against ¹⁸O ( Δ ¹⁸O) is expected to be lower in C₄ plants because of low c_i and hence low retrodiffusing CO₂ flux. C₄ plants also generally show lower levels of carbonic anhydrase (CA) activities than C₃ plants. Low CA may limit the extent of ¹⁸O exchange and further reduce Δ ¹⁸O. We investigated CO₂–H₂O isotopic equilibrium in plants with naturally low CA activity, including two C₄ (Zea mays, Sorghum bicolor) and one C₃ (Phragmites australis) species. The results confirmed experimentally the occurrence of low Δ ¹⁸O in C₄, as well as in some C₃, plants. Variations in CA activity and in the extent of CO₂–H₂O isotopic equilibrium ( θ _eq) estimated from on-line measurements of Δ ¹⁸O showed large range of 0–100% isotopic equilibrium ( θ _eq = 0–1). This was consistent with direct estimates based on assays of CA activity and measurements of CO₂ concentrations and residence times in the leaves. The results demonstrate the potential usefulness of Δ ¹⁸O as indicator of CA activity in vivo. Sensitivity tests indicated also that the impact of θ _eq < 1 (incomplete isotopic equilibrium) on ¹⁸O of atmospheric CO₂ can be similar for C₃ and C₄ plants and in both cases it increases with natural enrichment of ¹⁸O in leaf water.     

Stomatal mechanism as the basis of the evolution of CAM and C4 photosynthesis

Abstract. The similarities between the component reactions of the presently known variants of photosynthetic carbon metabolism (crassulacean acid metabolism, the acid metabolism of Tillandsia usneoides , aquatic acid metabolism, and C₄ photosynthesis) when considered along with their widely scattered taxonomic distribution strongly suggest polyphyletic origins resulting from evolutionary modification of a common, universally distributed metabolic sequence. The synthesis and consumption of four-carbon acids in the cation-balancing reactions involved in the regulation of stomatal aperture appear to exhibit all of the characteristics likely to be displayed by such a metabolic progenitor.
The present status of the proposal that the expression of aspects of stomatal metabolism in photosynthetic mesophyll cells represents the basis for the evolution of the variant of photosynthetic carbon metabolism is discussed. The prospects of experimental approaches which may yield information relevant to the proposal are also explored.     

Lack of C4 photosynthetic metabolism in ears of C3 cereals

There is continuing controversy over whether a degree of C₄ photosynthetic metabolism exists in ears of C₃ cereals. In this context, CO₂ exchange and the initial products of photosynthesis were examined in flag leaf blades and various ear parts of two durum wheat (Triticum durum Desf.) and two six-rowed barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) cultivars. Three weeks after anthesis, the CO₂ compensation concentration at 210 mmol mol^?1 O₂ in durum wheat and barley ear parts was similar to or greater than that in flag leaves. The O₂ dependence of the CO₂ compensation concentration in durum wheat ear parts, as well as in the flag leaf blade, was linear, as expected for C₃ photosynthesis. In a complementary experiment, intact and attached ears and flag leaf blades of barley and durum wheat were radio-labelled with ¹⁴CO₂ during a 10s pulse, and the initial products of fixation were studied in various parts of the ears (awns, glumes, inner bracts and grains) and in the flag leaf blade. All tissues assimilated CO₂ mainly by the Calvin (C₃) cycle, with little fixation of ¹⁴CO₂ into the C₄ acids malate and aspartate (about 10% or less). These collective data support the conclusion that in the ear parts of these C₃ cereals C₄ photosynthetic metabolism is nil.     

Comparative ecophysiology of C3 and C4 plants

Abstract. In this review we relate the physiological significance of C₄ photosynthesis to plant performance in nature. We begin with an examination of the physiological consequences of the C₄ pathway on photosynthesis, then discuss the ecophysiological performance of C₄ plants in contrasting environments. We then compare the performance of C₃ and C₄ plants when they occur together in similar habitats, and finally discuss the distribution of C₄ photosynthesis with respect to the physical environment, phylogeny, and life form.     

Seasonal water availability predicts the relative abundance of C3 and C4 grasses in Australia

Aim Numerous studies have examined the climatic factors that influence the abundance of C₄ species within the grass flora (C₄ relative species richness) in various regions throughout the world, but very few have examined the relative abundance of C₄ vs. C₃ grasses (C₄ relative abundance). We sought to determine the climatic factors that influence C₄ relative abundance throughout Australia. Location Australia (including Tasmania). Methods We measured C₄ relative abundance at 168 locations and measured δ¹³C (the abundance of ¹³C relative to ¹²C) of the bone collagen of 779 kangaroos collected throughout Australia, as bone collagen δ¹³C was assumed to be proportional to the relative abundance of C₄ grasses in the diet. Results Both C₄ relative abundance and kangaroo bone collagen δ¹³C were found to have a strong positive relationship with seasonal water availability, i.e. the distribution of rainfall in the C₄ vs. C₃ growing seasons (76% and 69% of deviance explained, respectively). There was clear evidence that seasonal water availability was a better predictor of both C₄ relative abundance and bone collagen δ¹³C than other climate variables such as mean annual temperature and January daily minimum temperature. However, seasonal water availability appeared to be a relatively poor predictor of C₄ relative species richness, which was most closely related to January daily minimum temperature (90% of deviance explained). Main conclusions Our results highlight the relatively poor relationship between C₄ relative abundance and C₄ relative species richness, and suggest that these two variables may be related to different climatic factors. They also suggest that caution is required when using C₄ relative species richness to infer the relative biomass and productivity of C₄ grasses on a global scale.     

The sensitivity of C3 photosynthesis to increasing CO2 concentration: a theoretical analysis of its dependence on temperature and background CO2 concentration

The atmospheric CO₂ concentration has increased from the pre-industrial concentration of about 280 μmol mol⁻¹ to its present concentration of over 350 μmol mol⁻¹, and continues to increase. As the rate of photosynthesis in C₃ plants is strongly dependent on CO₂ concentration, this should have a marked effect on photosynthesis, and hence on plant growth and productivity. The magnitude of photo-synthetic responses can be calculated based on the well-developed theory of photosynthetic response to intercellular CO₂ concentration. A simple biochemically based model of photosynthesis was coupled to a model of stomatal conductance to calculate photosynthetic responses to ambient CO₂ concentration. In the combined model, photosynthesis was much more responsive to CO₂ at high than at low temperatures. At 350 μmol mol⁻¹, photosynthesis at 35°C reached 51% of the rate that would have been possible with non-limiting CO₂, whereas at 5°C, 77% of the CO₂ non-limited rate was attained. Relative CO₂ sensitivity also became smaller at elevated CO₂, as CO₂ concentration increased towards saturation. As photosynthesis was far from being saturated at the current ambient CO₂ concentration, considerable further gains in photosynthesis were predicted through continuing increases in CO₂ concentration. The strong interaction with temperature also leads to photosynthesis in different global regions experiencing very different sensitivities to increasing CO₂ concentrations.     

Photosynthetic carbon metabolism in Panicum milioides, a C3-C4 intermediate species: Evidence for a limited C4 dicarboxylic acid pathway of photosynthesis

Panicum milioides, a naturally occurring species with C₄-like Kranz leaf anatomy, is intermediate between C₃ and C₄ plants with respect to photorespiration and the associated oxygen inhibition of photosynthesis. This paper presents direct evidence for a limited degree of C₄ photosynthesis in this C₃-C₄ intermediate species based on:

1. (a) the appearance of 24% of the total ¹⁴C fixed following 4 s photosynthesis in ¹⁴CO₂-air by excised leaves in malate and aspartate and the complete transfer of label from the C₄ acids to Calvin cycle intermediates within a 15 s chase in ¹²CO₂-air;

2. (b) pyruvate- or alanine-enhanced light-dependent CO₂ fixation and pyruvate stimulation of oxaloacetate- or 3-phosphoglycerate-dependent O₂ evolution by illuminated mesophyll protoplasts, but not bundle sheath strands; and

3. (c) NAD-malic enzyme-dependent decarboxylation of C₄ acids at the C-4 carboxyl position, C₄ acid-dependent O₂ evolution, and ¹⁴CO₂ donation from [4-¹⁴C]C₄ acids to Calvin cycle intermediates during photosynthesis by bundle sheath strands, but not mesophyll protoplasts.

However, P. milioides differs from C₄ plants in that the activity of the C₄ cycle enzymes is only 15 to 30% of a C₄ Panicum species and the Calvin cycle and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase are present in both cell types. From these and related studies (Rathnam, C.K.M. and Chollet, R. (1979) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 193, 346–354; (1978) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 85, 801–808) we conclude that reduced photorespiration in P. milioides is due to a limited degree of NAD-malic enzyme-type C₄ photosynthesis permitting an increase in pCO₂ at the site of bundle sheath, but not mesophyll, ribulosebisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase.     

Climate controls on C3 vs. C4 productivity in North American grasslands from carbon isotope composition of soil organic matter

We analyzed the δ¹³C of soil organic matter (SOM) and fine roots from 55 native grassland sites widely distributed across the US and Canadian Great Plains to examine the relative production of C₃ vs. C₄ plants (hereafter %C₄) at the continental scale. Our climate vs. %C₄ results agreed well with North American field studies on %C₄, but showed bias with respect to %C₄ from a US vegetation database (statsgo ) and weak agreement with a physiologically based prediction that depends on crossover temperature. Although monthly average temperatures have been used in many studies to predict %C₄, our analysis shows that high temperatures are better predictors of %C₄. In particular, we found that July climate (average of daily high temperature and month's total rainfall) predicted %C₄ better than other months, seasons or annual averages, suggesting that the outcome of competition between C₃ and C₄ plants in North American grasslands was particularly sensitive to climate during this narrow window of time. Root δ¹³C increased about 1‰ between the A and B horizon, suggesting that C₄ roots become relatively more common than C₃ roots with depth. These differences in depth distribution likely contribute to the isotopic enrichment with depth in SOM where both C₃ and C₄ grasses are present.     

C3 grasses have higher nutritional quality than C4 grasses under ambient and elevated atmospheric CO2

Grasses with the C₃ photosynthetic pathway are commonly considered to be more nutritious host plants than C₄ grasses, but the nutritional quality of C₃ grasses is also more greatly impacted by elevated atmospheric CO₂ than is that of C₄ grasses; C₃ grasses produce greater amounts of nonstructural carbohydrates and have greater declines in their nitrogen content than do C₄ grasses under elevated CO₂. Will C₃ grasses remain nutritionally superior to C₄ grasses under elevated CO₂ levels? We addressed this question by determining whether levels of protein in C₃ grasses decline to similar levels as in C₄ grasses, and whether total carbohydrate : protein ratios become similar in C₃ and C₄ grasses under elevated CO₂. In addition, we tested the hypothesis that, among the nonstructural carbohydrates in C₃ grasses, levels of fructan respond most strongly to elevated CO₂. Five C₃ and five C₄ grass species were grown from seed in outdoor open‐top chambers at ambient (370 ppm) or elevated (740 ppm) CO₂ for 2 months. As expected, a significant increase in sugars, starch and fructan in the C₃ grasses under elevated CO₂ was associated with a significant reduction in their protein levels, while protein levels in most C₄ grasses were little affected by elevated CO₂. However, this differential response of the two types of grasses was insufficient to reduce protein in C₃ grasses to the levels in C₄ grasses. Although levels of fructan in the C₃ grasses tripled under elevated CO₂, the amounts produced remained relatively low, both in absolute terms and as a fraction of the total nonstructural carbohydrates in the C₃ grasses. We conclude that C₃ grasses will generally remain more nutritious than C₄ grasses at elevated CO₂ concentrations, having higher levels of protein, nonstructural carbohydrates, and water, but lower levels of fiber and toughness, and lower total carbohydrate : protein ratios than C₄ grasses.