Responses of temporal retinal growth cones to ephrinA5-coated beads

The topographic positioning of retinal axons in the optic tectum is regulated, at least in part, by ephrinA/EphA repulsive interactions. Temporal axons, expressing high levels of EphA receptors, project to the ephrinA5-poor anterior tectum and avoid the ephrinA5-rich posterior tectum. To examine the dynamic behavior of temporal growth cones when they first encounter ephrinA, we manipulated ephrinA-coated beads with a laser tweezer into desired positions around the growth cones of chick retinal axons in culture. At high concentrations of ephrinA5 on the beads, growth cones typically collapsed on contacting the bead. At low concentrations, however, growth cones showed heterogeneous responses with some growth cones showing repulsive turning and others showing attractive turning after contacting the bead. Experiments with two beads indicate that retinal axons integrate guidance information that is provided simultaneously at two discrete locations. When a time-delay was introduced between exposure to the first and the second bead, individual axons exhibited a stereotyped response to the repeated stimuli, either responding with attraction followed by attraction, or showing repulsion followed by repulsion or collapse. Our results suggest the existence of at least two retinal subpopulations from the temporal retina, one being attracted, another being repelled by low levels of ephrinA5. These findings demonstrate that temporal retinal axons are not universally repelled by ephrinA5 and suggest that their ability to respond differentially to low concentrations may help them to map in a continuous manner over the surface of the anterior tectum.     

Modulation of EphA receptor function by coexpressed ephrinA ligands on retinal ganglion cell axons

The Eph family is thought to exert its function through the complementary expression of receptors and ligands. Here, we show that EphA receptors colocalize on retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons with EphA ligands, which are expressed in a high-nasal-to-low-temporal pattern. In the stripe assay, only temporal axons are normally sensitive for repellent axon guidance cues of the caudal tectum. However, overexpression of ephrinA ligands on temporal axons abolishes this sensitivity, whereas treatment with PI-PLC both removes ephrinA ligands from retinal axons and induces a striped outgrowth of formerly insensitive nasal axons. In vivo, retinal overexpression of ephrinA2 leads to topographic targeting errors of temporal axons. These data suggest that differential ligand expression on retinal axons is a major determinant of topographic targeting in the retinotectal projection.     

Ephrin-A6, a new ligand for EphA receptors in the developing visual system

In the embryonic visual system, EphA receptors are expressed on both temporal and nasal retinal ganglion cell axons. Only the temporal axons, however, are sensitive to the low concentrations of ephrin-A ligands found in the anterior optic tectum. The poor responsiveness of nasal axons to ephrin-A ligands, which allows them to traverse the anterior tectum and reach their targets in the posterior tectum, has been attributed to constitutive activation of the EphA4 receptor expressed in these axons. EphA4 is highly expressed throughout the retina, but is preferentially phosphorylated on tyrosine (activated) in nasal retina. In a screen for EphA4 ligands expressed in chicken embryonic retina, we have identified a novel ephrin, ephrin-A6. Like ephrin-A5, ephrin-A6 has high affinity for EphA4 and activates this receptor in cultured retinal cells. In the embryonic day 8 (E8) chicken visual system, ephrin-A6 is predominantly expressed in the nasal retina and ephrin-A5 in the posterior tectum. Thus, ephrin-A6 has the properties of a ligand that activates the EphA4 receptor in nasal retinal cells. Ephrin-A6 binds with high affinity to several other EphA receptors as well and causes growth cone collapse in retinal explants, demonstrating that it can elicit biological responses in retinal neurons. Ephrin-A6 expression is high at E6 and E8, when retinal axons grow to their tectal targets, and gradually declines at later developmental stages. The asymmetric distribution of ephrin-A6 in retinal cells, and the time course of its expression, suggest that this new ephrin plays a role in the establishment of visual system topography.     

Topographic targeting and pathfinding errors of retinal axons following overexpression of ephrinA ligands on retinal ganglion cell axons

In the retinotectal projection, the Eph receptor tyrosine kinase ligands ephrinA2 and ephrinA5 are differentially expressed not only in the tectum, but also in a high-nasal-to-low-temporal pattern in the retina. Recently, we have shown that retrovirally driven overexpression of ephrinA2 on retinal axons leads to topographic targeting errors of temporal axons in that they overshoot their normal termination zones in the rostral tectum and project onto the mid- and caudal tectum. The behavior of nasal axons, however, was only marginally affected. Here, we show that overexpression of ephrinA5 affects the topographic targeting behavior of both temporal and nasal axons. These data reinforce the idea that differential ligand expression on retinal axons contributes to topographic targeting in the retinotectal projection. Additionally, we found that ectopic expression of ephrinA2 and ephrinA5 frequently leads to pathfinding errors at the chiasm, resulting in an increased stable ipsilateral projection.     

EphrinA1 repulsive response is regulated by an EphA2 tyrosine phosphatase

Ephrin kinases and their ephrin ligands transduce repulsion of cells in axon guidance, migration, invasiveness, and tumor growth, exerting a negative signaling on cell proliferation and adhesion. A key role of their kinase activity has been confirmed by mutant kinase inactive receptors that shift the cellular response from repulsion to adhesion. Our present study aimed to investigate the role of low molecular weight protein-tyrosine phosphatase (LMW-PTP) in ephrinA1/EphA2 signaling. LMW-PTP, by means of dephosphorylation of EphA2 kinase, negatively regulates the ephrinA1-mediated repulsive response, cell proliferation, cell adhesion and spreading, and the formation of retraction fibers, thereby confirming the relevance of the net level of tyrosine phosphorylation of Eph receptors. LMW-PTP interferes with ephrin-mediated mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling likely through inhibition of p120RasGAP binding to the activated EphA2 kinase, thereby confirming the key role of mitogen-activated protein kinase inhibition by ephrinA1 repulsive signaling. We conclude that LMW-PTP acts as a terminator of EphA2 signaling causing an efficient negative feedback loop on the biological response mediated by ephrinA1 and pointing on tyrosine phosphorylation as the main event orchestrating the repulsive response.     

On the turning of Xenopus retinal axons induced by ephrin-A5

The Eph family of receptor tyrosine kinases and their ligands, the ephrins, play important roles during development of the nervous system. Frequently they exert their functions through a repellent mechanism, so that, for example, an axon expressing an Eph receptor does not invade a territory in which an ephrin is expressed. Eph receptor activation requires membrane-associated ligands. This feature discriminates ephrins from other molecules sculpturing the nervous system such as netrins, slits and class 3 semaphorins, which are secreted molecules. While the ability of secreted molecules to guide axons, i.e. to change their growth direction, is well established in vitro, little is known about this for the membrane-bound ephrins. Here we set out to investigate--using Xenopus laevis retinal axons--the properties of substratum-bound and (artificially) soluble forms of ephrin-A5 (ephrin-A5-Fc) to guide axons. We find--as expected on the basis of chick experiments - that, when immobilised in the stripe assay, ephrin-A5 has a repellent effect such that retinal axons avoid ephrin-A5-Fc-containing lanes. Also, retinal axons react with repulsive turning or growth cone collapse when confronted with ephrin-A5-Fc bound to beads. However, when added in soluble form to the medium, ephrin-A5 induces growth cone collapse, comparable to data from chick. The analysis of growth cone behaviour in a gradient of soluble ephrin-A5 in the 'turning assay' revealed a substratum-dependent reaction of Xenopus retinal axons. On fibronectin, we observed a repulsive response, with the turning of growth cones away from higher concentrations of ephrin-A5. On laminin, retinal axons turned towards higher concentrations, indicating an attractive effect. In both cases the turning response occurred at a high background level of growth cone collapse. In sum, our data indicate that ephrin-As are able to guide axons in immobilised bound form as well as in the form of soluble molecules. To what degree this type of guidance is relevant for the in vivo situation remains to be shown.     

Behavior of fish retinal growth cones encountering chick caudal tectal membranes: A time-lapse study on growthcone collapse

In a cross species in vitro assay, growth cones from fish temporal retina elongating on laminin lanes were observed with time-lapse videomicroscopy as they encountered lanes and territories that carried membrane fragments from the chick caudal tectum. Caudal tectal membranes of adult fish and embryonic chick are known to possess a repellent guiding component for temporal retinal axons. The caudal membranes of chick exert a particularly strong influence on fish temporal axons. Contacts with chick caudal membranes by just a few filopodia and parts of the lamellipodia evoked a turning response away from the membrane lane of the entire growth cone. Contacts by filo- and lamellipodia over the entire circumference of the growth cone, however, caused invariably growth cone collapse and retraction. During growth cone turning and collapse and retraction, filopodia remained in contact with the tectal membrane fragments, suggesting strong membrane–filopodia adhesion simultaneous to growth cone repulsion by the repellent guiding component. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Fibroblast growth factors redirect retinal axons in vitro and in vivo

Growth factors have been shown previously to participate in the process of axon target recognition. We showed that fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) signaling is required for Xenopus laevis retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons to recognize their major midbrain target, the optic tectum [neuron 17 (1996), 245]. Therefore, we have hypothesized that a change in expression of a fibroblast growth factor (FGF) at the entrance of the optic tectum, the border between the diencephalon and mesencephalon, may serve as a signal to RGC axons that they have reached their target. To determine whether RGC axons can sense changes in FGF levels, we asked whether they altered their behavior upon encountering an ectopic source of FGF. We found that in vivo RGC growth cones avoided FGF-misexpressing cells along their path, and that FGF-2 directly repelled RGC growth cones in an in vitro growth cone turning assay. These data support the idea that RGC axons can sense changes in FGF levels, and as such provide a mechanism by which FGFR signaling is involved in RGC axon target recognition.     

In vitro experiments on axon guidance demonstrating an anterior-posterior gradient on the tectum.

Axonal growth cones originating from explants of embryonic chick retina were simultaneously exposed to two different cell monolayers and their preference for particular monolayers as a substrate for growth was determined. These experiments show that: (1) nasal retinal axons can distinguish between retinal and tectal cells; (2) temporal retinal axons can distinguish between tectal cells that originated from different positions within the tectum along the antero-posterior axis; (3) axons originating from nasal parts of the retina have different recognizing capabilities from temporal axons; (4) the property of the tectal cells, which is attractive for temporal axons, has a graded distribution along the antero-posterior axis of the tectum; and (5) this gradient also exists in non-innervated tecta.     

Opposing gradients of ephrin-As and EphA7 in the superior colliculus are essential for topographic mapping in the mammalian visual system

During development of the retinocollicular projection in mouse, retinal axons initially overshoot their future termination zones (TZs) in the superior colliculus (SC). The formation of TZs is initiated by interstitial branching at topographically appropriate positions. Ephrin-As are expressed in a decreasing posterior-to-anterior gradient in the SC, and they suppress branching posterior to future TZs. Here we investigate the role of an EphA7 gradient in the SC, which has the reverse orientation to the ephrin-A gradient. We find that in EphA7 mutant mice the retinocollicular map is disrupted, with nasal and temporal axons forming additional or extended TZs, respectively. In vitro, retinal axons are repelled from growing on EphA7-containing stripes. Our data support the idea that EphA7 is involved in suppressing branching anterior to future TZs. These findings suggest that opposing ephrin-A and EphA gradients are required for the proper development of the retinocollicular projection.     

Endocytosis of EphA receptors is essential for the proper development of the retinocollicular topographic map

Endocytosis of Eph-ephrin complexes may be an important mechanism for converting cell-cell adhesion to a repulsive interaction. Here, we show that an endocytosis-defective EphA8 mutant forms a complex with EphAs and blocks their endocytosis in cultured cells. Further, we used bacterial artificial chromosome transgenic (Tg) mice to recapitulate the anterior>posterior gradient of EphA in the superior colliculus (SC). In mice expressing the endocytosis-defective EphA8 mutant, the nasal axons were aberrantly shifted to the anterior SC. In contrast, in Tg mice expressing wild-type EphA8, the nasal axons were shifted to the posterior SC, as predicted for the enhanced repellent effect of ephrinA reverse signalling. Importantly, Rac signalling was shown to be essential for EphA-ephrinA internalization and the subsequent nasal axonal repulsion in the SC. These results indicate that endocytosis of the Eph-ephrin complex is a key mechanism by which axonal repulsion is generated for proper guidance and topographic mapping.     

Two homeobox genes define the domain of EphA3 expression in the developing chick retina

Graded expression of the Eph receptor EphA3 in the retina and its two ligands, ephrin A2 and ephrin A5 in the optic tectum, the primary target of retinal axons, have been implicated in the formation of the retinotectal projection map. Two homeobox containing genes, SOHo1 and GH6, are expressed in a nasal-high, temporal-low pattern during early retinal development, and thus in opposing gradients to EphA3. Retroviral misexpression of SOHo1 or GH6 completely and specifically repressed EphA3 expression in the neural retina, but not in other parts of the central nervous system, such as the optic tectum. Under these conditions, some temporal ganglion cell axons overshot their expected termination zones in the rostral optic tectum, terminating aberrantly at more posterior locations. However, the majority of ganglion cell axons mapped to the appropriate rostrocaudal locations, although they formed somewhat more diffuse termination zones. These findings indicate that other mechanisms, in addition to differential EphA3 expression in the neural retina, are required for retinal ganglion axons to map to the appropriate rostrocaudal locations in the optic tectum. They further suggest that the control of topographic specificity along the retinal nasal-temporal axis is split into several independent pathways already at a very early time in development.     

GDNF acts as a chemoattractant to support ephrinA-induced repulsion of limb motor axons

Despite the abundance of guidance cues in vertebrate nervous systems, little is known about cooperation between them. Motor axons of the lateral motor column (LMC(L)) require two ligand/receptor systems, ephrinA/EphA4 and glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF)/Ret, to project to the dorsal limb. Deletion of either EphA4 or Ret in mice leads to rerouting of a portion of LMC(L) axons to the ventral limb, a phenotype enhanced in EphA4;Ret double mutants. The guidance errors in EphA4 knockouts were attributed to the lack of repulsion from ephrinAs in the ventral mesenchyme. However, it has remained unclear how GDNF, expressed dorsally next to the choice point, acts on motor axons and cooperates with ephrinAs. Here we show that GDNF induces attractive turning of LMC(L) axons. When presented in countergradients, GDNF and ephrinAs cooperate in axon turning, indicating that the receptors Ret and EphA4 invoke opposite effects within the same growth cone. GDNF also acts in a permissive manner by reducing ephrinA-induced collapse and keeping the axons in a growth-competent state. This is the first example of two opposing cues promoting the same trajectory choice at an intermediate target.     

BMP gradients steer nerve growth cones by a balancing act of LIM kinase and Slingshot phosphatase on ADF/cofilin

Bone morphogenic proteins (BMPs) are involved in axon pathfinding, but how they guide growth cones remains elusive. In this study, we report that a BMP7 gradient elicits bidirectional turning responses from nerve growth cones by acting through LIM kinase (LIMK) and Slingshot (SSH) phosphatase to regulate actin-depolymerizing factor (ADF)/cofilin-mediated actin dynamics. Xenopus laevis growth cones from 4-8-h cultured neurons are attracted to BMP7 gradients but become repelled by BMP7 after overnight culture. The attraction and repulsion are mediated by LIMK and SSH, respectively, which oppositely regulate the phosphorylation-dependent asymmetric activity of ADF/cofilin to control the actin dynamics and growth cone steering. The attraction to repulsion switching requires the expression of a transient receptor potential (TRP) channel TRPC1 and involves Ca2+ signaling through calcineurin phosphatase for SSH activation and growth cone repulsion. Together, we show that spatial regulation of ADF/cofilin activity controls the directional responses of the growth cone to BMP7, and Ca2+ influx through TRPC tilts the LIMK-SSH balance toward SSH-mediated repulsion.     

Recognition of position-specific properties of tectal cell membranes by retinal axons in vitro

In order to test the preference of growing axons for membrane-associated positional specificity a new in vitro assay was developed. In this assay, membrane fragments of two different sources are arranged as a carpet of very narrow alternating strips. Axons growing on such striped carpets are simultaneously confronted with the two substrates at the stripe borders. If there is a preference of axons for one or the other substrate they become oriented by the stripes and grow within the lanes of the preferred substrate. Such preferential growth could, in principle, be due to affinity to attractive factors on the preferred stripes or avoidance of repulsive factors on the alternate stripes. This assay system was used to investigate growth of chick retinal axons on tectal membranes. Tissue strips cut from various areas of the retina were explanted and the extending axons were confronted with stripes of cell membranes from various areas within the optic tectum. Tectal cell membranes prove to be an excellent substrate for the growth of retinal axons. Nasal and temporal axons can grow well on membranes of both posterior and anterior tectal cells. If, however, temporal axons are given a choice and encounter the border between anterior and posterior membranes they show a marked preference for growth on membranes of the anterior tectum, their natural target area. Nasal axons do not show a preference in this assay system. The transition from nasal to temporal properties within the retina is abrupt. In contrast, the transition from anterior to posterior properties of the tectal cell membranes occurs as a smooth gradient. Significantly, the positional differences of tectal membrane properties are only seen during the period of development of the retinotectal projection and are independent of tectal innervation by retinal axons. These anterior-posterior differences disappear by embryonic day 14.     

Axonal guidance by an avoidance mechanism

1. On a substrate consisting of alternating lanes of anterior and posterior tectal membranes, temporal retinal axons have a strong tendency to grow on the lanes of anterior membranes and to avoid the lanes of posterior membranes. 2. Temporal axons do extend neurites on posterior material, and in equivalent numbers and lengths to that of anterior membranes if the substrate consists of pure anterior or posterior membranes. 3. Inactivation of posterior membranes by heat or the enzyme phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) abolishes their ability to induce the avoidance reaction of temporal axons. It is concluded that the posterior membranes contain a repulsive component for temporal retinal axons. 4. Growth cones growing on anterior membranes, which encounter posterior membranes at the strip boundary, in general do not become reduced in their growth rate. 5. These results are most easily explained by a "gradient-reading model" similar to chemotaxis where the steering of a growth cone is independent on the growth rate. 6. According to the model, a gradient of a guiding component outside the growth cone is transformed into an internal gradient which gives the growth cone its directionality. 7. Other models like growth inhibition cannot be ruled out but need at least two additional assumptions like habituation for growth on the putative posterior inhibitory substrate and a strong local restriction of the inhibitory effect within the growth cone which contacts the posterior material.     

Ephective endocytosis

Two important new reports identify endocytosis of EphB-ephrinB complexes as a mechanism for switching between cell-cell adhesion and repulsion following plasma membrane contact. Together with the previously described shedding of ephrinA following EphA engagement, these findings resolve the paradox of how an adhesive receptor-ligand interaction generates a repulsive cellular response.     

Ephrin A/EphA controls the rostral turning polarity of a lateral commissural tract in chick hindbrain

Most post-crossing commissural axons turn into longitudinal paths to make synaptic connections with their targets. Mechanisms that control their rostrocaudal turning polarity are still poorly understood. We used the hindbrain as a model system to investigate the rostral turning of a laterally located commissural tract, identified as the caudal group of contralateral cerebellar-projecting second-order vestibular neurons (cC-VC). We found that the caudal hindbrain possessed a graded non-permissive/repulsive activity for growing cC-VC axons. This non-permissiveness/repulsion was in part mediated by glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored ephrin A. We further demonstrated that ephrin A2 was distributed in a caudal-high/rostral-low gradient in the caudolateral hindbrain and cC-VC axons expressed EphA receptors. Finally, perturbing ephrin A/EphA signalling both in vitro and in vivo led to rostrocaudal pathfinding errors of post-crossing cC-VC axons. These results suggest that ephrin A/EphA interactions play a key role in regulating the polarity of post-crossing cC-VC axons as they turn into the longitudinal axis.     

Convergent and divergent signaling mechanisms of growth cone collapse by ephrinA5 and slit2

EphrinA5 and slit2 are important repulsive guidance cues in the developing retinotectal system. Both ephrinA5 and slit2 cause growth cone collapse of embryonic chick retinal ganglion growth cones cultured on EHS laminin. However, the signaling mechanism that these guidance cues initiate to cause collapse remains unclear. Here we provide evidence that while both ephrinA5 and slit2 cause collapse in morphologically similar ways, the intracellular signaling leading to the collapse involves shared as well as divergent paths. Pharmacological inhibition of either phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) or src family kinases prevented both ephrinA5-mediated and slit2-mediated growth cone collapse. In contrast, the inhibition of nonclassical protein kinase C (PKC) isoforms blocked ephrinA5-mediated collapse, but did not interfere with slit2-mediated collapse. PI3K was copurified by affinity chromatography with either the ephrinA5 receptors (ephAs) or the slit2 receptor (roundabout). Colocalization studies have also shown that src family kinase members are recruited to the ephA and roundabout receptors upon activation. In contrast, PKC members are recruited to the ephA receptors, but not to the roundabout receptors, upon activation. This demonstrates distinct points of convergence and divergence between the two signaling molecules, ephrinA5 and slit2, and their repulsive guidance in the chick retinotectal system.     

Expression patterns of Ephs and ephrins throughout retinotectal development in Xenopus laevis

The Eph family of receptor tyrosine kinases and their ligands the ephrins play an essential role in the targeting of retinal ganglion cell axons to topographically correct locations in the optic tectum during visual system development. The African claw-toed frog Xenopus laevis is a popular animal model for the study of retinotectal development because of its amenability to live imaging and electrophysiology. Its visual system undergoes protracted growth continuing beyond metamorphosis, yet little is known about ephrin and Eph expression patterns beyond stage 39 when retinal axons first arrive in the tectum. We used alkaline phosphatase fusion proteins of EphA3, ephrin-A5, EphB2, and ephrin-B1 as affinity probes to reveal the expression patterns of ephrin-As, EphAs, ephrin-Bs, and EphBs, respectively. Analysis of brains from stage 40 to adult frog revealed that ephrins and Eph receptors are expressed throughout development. As observed in other species, staining for ephrin-As displayed a high caudal to low rostral expression pattern across the tectum, roughly complementary to the expression of EphAs. In contrast with the prevailing model, EphBs were found to be expressed in the tectum in a high dorsal to low ventral gradient in young animals. In animals with induced binocular tectal innervation, ocular dominance bands of alternating input from the two eyes formed in the tectum; however, ephrin-A and EphA expression patterns were unmodulated and similar to those in normal frogs, confirming that the segregation of axons into eye-specific stripes is not the consequence of a respecification of molecular guidance cues in the tectum.