Single-Leaf Resolution of the Temporal Population Dynamics of Aureobasidium pullulans on Apple Leaves

The abundance of phylloplane microorganisms typically varies over several orders of magnitude among leaves sampled concurrently. Because the methods traditionally used to sample leaves are destructive, it has remained unclear whether this high variability is due to fixed differences in habitat quality among leaves or to asynchronous temporal variation in the microbial population density on individual leaves. We developed a novel semidestructive assay to repeatedly sample the same apple leaves from orchard trees over time by removing progressively more proximal ~1-cm-wide transverse segments. Aureobasidium pullulans densities were determined by standard leaf homogenization and plating procedures and were expressed as CFU per square centimeter of segment. The A. pullulans population densities among leaves were lognormally distributed. The variability in A. pullulans population densities among subsections of a given leaf was one-third to one-ninth the variability among whole leaves harvested concurrently. Sequential harvesting of leaf segments did not result in detectable changes in A. pullulans density on residual leaf surfaces. These findings implied that we could infer whole-leaf A. pullulans densities over time by using partial leaves. When this successive sampling regimen was applied over the course of multiple 7- to 8-day experiments, the among-leaf effects were virtually always the predominant source of variance in A. pullulans density estimates. Changes in A. pullulans density tended to be synchronous among leaves, such that the rank order of leaves arrayed with respect to A. pullulans density was largely maintained through time. Occasional periods of asynchrony were observed, but idiosyncratic changes in A. pullulans density did not contribute appreciably to variation in the distribution of populations among leaves. This suggests that persistent differences in habitat (leaf) quality are primarily responsible for the variation in A. pullulans density among leaves in nature.     

The synergistic effects of stochasticity and dispersal on population densities

Using laboratory experiments, simulation models, and analytical techniques, we examined the impact of dispersal on the mean densities of patchily distributed populations. Even when dispersal leads to no net additions or removals of individuals from a population, it may nonetheless increase mean population densities if the net immigration rate is positive when populations are growing and negative when they are declining. As a model system for exploring this phenomenon, we used the yeastlike fungus Aureobasidium pullulans. In a laboratory experiment, we showed that dispersal can both ensure persistence and increase mean population densities even when dispersal among populations causes no direct addition or loss of fungal cells. From the laboratory data, we constructed a plausible model of A. pullulans dynamics among apple leaves within an orchard. This simulation model demonstrated that the effect of dispersal on mean densities is enhanced by three factors: weak density dependence of the dynamics within populations, high environmental variability affecting population growth rates, and lack of synchrony among the fluctuations of populations. Using an analytical model, we showed that the underlying mechanisms for this phenomenon are general, suggesting that a large effect of dispersal on mean population densities is possible in many natural systems.     

Population biology of Aureobasidium pullulans on apple leaf surfaces

Colonization of apple leaves by the yeast-like fungus Aureobasidium pullulans was studied in the field on eight dates over 2 years. Population densities from adaxial leaf surfaces were approximately log10 0.5-2.6 U higher when enumerated directly along line transects as microscopic counts of A. pullulans cells specifically identified by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) than indirectly as CFU obtained by plating leaf washings from comparable surfaces onto nutrient media. Site-specific mapping of the leaf landscape colonized by A. pullulans was facilitated by use of geographic information system (GIS) software. Colonization was plotted and analyzed both qualitatively (as occupancy) and quantitatively (as density). Overall, when expressed as mean occupancy per date, 22-42% of the microscope fields (each 0.196 mm2) contained > or = 1 A. pullulans cell. Occupancy on a microscope field basis was greater over the midvein (47-89%) or smaller veins (49-65%) than over interveinal regions (11-21%). Intensity of colonization, whether expressed as percentage of total A. pullulans cells associated with a particular leaf feature or as cell density per unit area, was also significantly greater (P < 0.05) over the veinal areas compared with the interveinal areas. The primary fungal morphotypes involved in colonization were blastospores, swollen cells, and chlamydospores; only infrequently were hyphae or pseudohyphae seen. Numbers of microcolonies (> or = 10 clustered cells) and percentage of total A. pullulans cells that occurred as microcolonies increased over the growing season and were significantly greater (P < 0.05) over veinal regions compared with interveinal regions. Locally high concentrations of A. pullulans were associated with naturally occurring micro-wounds in interveinal areas. We conclude that A. pullulans colonizes the phylloplane predominantly as single cells and groups thereof in a highly heterogeneous fashion and that sites exist that are relatively conducive (veins; wounds) or nonconducive (unwounded interveinal areas) for epiphytic fungal growth.     

Density dependence in foraging habitat preference of eastern grey kangaroos

For a free‐ranging forager, the suitability of a patch is dependent on population density, resource supply, resource quality, and the costs of foraging or dispersal. We quantified differences among three foraging habitats and compared this variation to temporal patterns of habitat preference by free‐ranging eastern grey kangaroos, Macropus giganteus. We investigated selection on a fine‐grained spatial scale, and asked whether habitat preference is constrained by density‐dependent mechanisms. Variation in the quantity and quality of resources among habitats was greatest during spring, when biomass and quality were highest, and differences among habitats were most pronounced. However, consistent and discernable differences among habitats were not obtained, indicating that the system fluctuated around an equilibrium state. Using isodar regressions to examine the consumer‐density relationships among habitats, open‐woodland habitat was favoured over the two open‐forest habitats for foraging. Seasonal isodars indicated that density dependence regulated preference between the three foraging habitats during autumn, spring and summer, but not during winter, when variability in resources among habitats was lowest.     

Effects of changes in leaf height and shoot density on the abundance of two fishes,Rudarius ercodes andAcentrogobius pflaumii, in azostera bed

The effects of changes in the structural complexity of a seagrass habitat on the densities of filefish (Rudarius ercodes) and streaked gobies (Acentrogobius pflaumii), were investigated by conducting a 9 month field experiment in aZostera marina bed at Moroiso Bay, Aburatsubo, central Japan. The experimental design included a control and 7 treatments where leaf height or shoot densities were reduced. During the period of high density of filefish, the species was more abundant in quadrats with longer leaves and denser shoots, but this tendency was not observed during the period of low density. Filefish did not frequent the quadrat cleared of seagrass or the area of sandy substratum surrounding the experimental seagrass bed at any time. The abundance of streaked gobies did not differ significantly among 8 experimental quadrats, although the species seldom appeared over the surrounding sandy substratum. The results suggested that filefish, unlike gobies, were attracted to factors associated with theZostera leaves, such as epiphytic prey and/or the complex living space.     

INTERACTIONS BETWEEN CROWN STRUCTURE AND LIGHT ENVIRONMENT IN FIVE RAIN FOREST PIPER SPECIES

Measurements of light variation among leaves within crowns of five Piper species were compared with estimates of spatial variation in light within understory, forest edge, and clearing habitats to estimate the extent to which crown structure contributes to variation in leaf light environment. Daily photon flux density (PFD) varied greatly within and among crowns. Coefficients of variation for daily PFD among sensors within a single crown ranged from 26 to 79%. Within a single crown located in a clearing, the range in daily PFD among leaves was nearly as great as the range over the entire sample of plants. In the understory, localized sunfleck activity contributed to a high degree of spatial variation in instantaneous and total PFD among leaves within individual crowns. Much of the microsite variation in sunfleck activity, however, reflected environmental conditions within the understory habitat. Within an array of sensors placed next to Piper crowns in the understory, correlations were poor for light sensors spaced only 0.2 m apart, and only 8% of the variance in light readings was explained by measurements made 0.5 m away. In the clearing habitats, microsite heterogeneity among leaves was more strongly influenced by leaf positions within crowns and leaf angles than by spatial heterogeneity within the habitat.     

Variation in the guild composition of herbivorous insect assemblages among co‐occurring plant species

Variation in plant traits among plant species may promote the development of a characteristic functional assemblage of insect herbivores associated with each plant species. However, only a small number of studies have detailed the representation of several herbivore guilds among co‐occurring plant species to determine whether the functional structure of herbivorous insect assemblages varies widely and consistently among plant species. The present study provides one of the few published data sets reporting on the density of several guilds of insect herbivores among numerous plant species. Variation in guild associations with plant phenology and season are also described. Insect herbivores were divided into 10 guilds, and the representation of these guilds was examined for 18 co‐occurring plant species. Guild densities and assemblage composition varied significantly among plant species, even when variation over time was taken into account. Variation in guild densities and assemblage composition were not strongly related to the taxonomic relationships of the plants. The highest densities of several guilds occurred in spring and summer, although other guilds were not strongly seasonal. Certain guilds were strongly associated with the presence of new leaves, whereas other guilds appeared to prefer mature leaves. This resulted in assemblage differences between samples containing new and mature leaves and samples containing mature leaves only. Even though the timing and duration of leaf and flower production varied among plant species, this did not explain all variation in guild densities among plant species. It is suggested that additional factors, including plant traits, are contributing to the wide and consistent variation in herbivore assemblage composition among plant species.     

Distribution and sampling of the whiteflies Aleurothrixus floccosus, Dialeurodes citri, and Parabemisia myricae (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) in citrus in Spain

From 1993 to 1995 data sets were collected from four citrus groves in Valencia, Spain, to determine the distribution patterns of eggs and nymphs of Aleurothrixus floccosus (Maskell), Dialeurodes citri (Ashmead), and Parabemisia myricae (Kuwana) on leaves, and to develop reliable sampling plans for estimating densities of immature whiteflies. A. floccosus showed higher aggregation than the other two species. The dispersion index b from the Taylor power law did not vary between different developing stages for A. floccosus and D. citri, reaching overall values of 1.70 and 1.53, respectively. In P. myricae, b was 1.60 for eggs and N1, and 1.46 for the remaining nymphs. The minimum number of leaves to estimate the population density with a coefficient of variation of 0.25 for densities above 10 immature whiteflies per leaf was 40 for D. citri and P. myricae, and 250 for A. floccosus. Binomial sampling programs for the three species were rejected for pest management purposes due to the high sample sizes required. The enumerative procedure of counting the number of insects per leaf appears to be the most suitable method for D. citri and P. myricae. For A. floccosus an index of occupation (from 0 to 10) linearly related to the proportion of the leaf undersurface occupied by this insect was found to be reliable and time-saving. Examining 150 leaves with this index achieves the desired relative variation level of 0.25 for most population densities usually found in commercial groves.     

Population Sizes, Immigration, and Growth of Epiphytic Bacteria on Leaves of Different Ages and Positions of Field-Grown Endive (Cichorium endivia var. latifolia)

Total, fluorescent, and pectolytic epiphytic bacterial population sizes were quantified on leaves of different age groups of broad-leaved endive during field cultivation from leaf emergence until harvest. Greater bacterial population densities (log(inf10) CFU per square centimeter) were observed on outer leaves than on inner leaves of the plants throughout the growing season. These differences were statistically significant for total bacterial populations at all sampling times and were often significant for fluorescent and pectolytic bacterial populations. At harvest, a linear gradient of decreasing densities of epiphytic bacteria from outer (older) to inner (younger) leaves of the head was significant. Leaf age influenced the frequency distribution and variability of bacterial population sizes associated with leaves of broad-leaved endive. Total bacterial population sizes were greater at leaf emergence for leaves emerging during the second half of the cultivation period than for leaves emerging earlier. The size of fluorescent and pectolytic bacterial populations on newly emerged leaves increased throughout the season as plants aged. To assess the importance of plant age on bacterial immigration at leaf emergence, bacterial densities were quantified on leaves emerging simultaneously on plants of different ages. In two of the three experiments, greater bacterial population sizes were observed on leaves emerging on younger plants. This indicates that factors other than an increase in concentration of airborne bacteria can lead to increases in population sizes at leaf emergence as plants age in the field. Results of leaf pruning experiments suggested that adjacent leaves may act as a barrier for immigration of fluorescent bacteria on newly emerged leaves. Survival of an inoculated strain of Pseudomonas fluorescens on newly emerged leaves generally did not vary with the age of plants. However, these effects were not consistent among experiments, suggesting that interactions among micro- and macroenvironmental conditions, physiological condition of leaves, and accessibility of leaves to airborne bacteria are important in controlling epiphytic bacterial population sizes.     

Evaluation of Methods for Sampling, Recovery, and Enumeration of Bacteria Applied to the Phylloplane

Determining the fate and survival of genetically engineered microorganisms released into the environment requires the development and application of accurate and practical methods of detection and enumeration. Several experiments were performed to examine quantitative recovery methods that are commonly used or that have potential applications. In these experiments, Erwinia herbicola and Enterobacter cloacae were applied in greenhouses to Blue Lake bush beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) and Cayuse oats (Avena sativa). Sampling indicated that the variance in bacterial counts among leaves increased over time and that this increase caused an overestimation of the mean population size by bulk leaf samples relative to single leaf samples. An increase in the number of leaves in a bulk sample, above a minimum number, did not significantly reduce the variance between samples. Experiments evaluating recovery methods demonstrated that recovery of bacteria from leaves was significantly better with stomacher blending, than with blending, sonication, or washing and that the recovery efficiency was constant over a range of sample inoculum densities. Delayed processing of leaf samples, by storage in a freezer, did not significantly lower survival and recovery of microorganisms when storage was short term and leaves were not stored in buffer. The drop plate technique for enumeration of bacteria did not significantly differ from the spread plate method. Results of these sampling, recovery, and enumeration experiments indicate a need for increased development and standardization of methods used by researchers as there are significant differences among, and also important limitations to, some of the methods used.     

Diffusive conductances of adaxial and abaxial epidermes: Response to photon flux density during development of water stress in primary bean leaves

Maximum diffusive conductance of abaxial epidermis of primary bean leaves was considerably higher than that of adaxial epidermis. While conductances of both epidermes responded parallel to a decrease in leaf water potential (they increased slightly, reached maxima and decreased to very low values), differences in their response to photon flux density were found. The conductance of abaxial epidermis increased rapidly over lower photon flux densities and gradually over higher photon flux densities, on the other hand the conductance of adaxial epidermis increased only gradually over the whole range. The observed parallel or different response of adaxial and abaxial epidermes to leaf water potential or photon flux density did not change with changes in experimental conditions.     

Effects of discharge and local density on the growth of juvenile Atlantic salmon Salmo salar

The study explored the combined effects of density, physical habitat and different discharge levels on the growth of juvenile Atlantic salmon Salmo salar in artificial streams, by manipulating flow during both summer and winter conditions. Growth was high during all four summer trials and increased linearly with discharge and mean velocity. Differences in fish densities (fish m^?3) due to differences in stream volume explained a similar proportion of the variation in mean growth among discharge treatments. Within streams, the fish aggregated in areas of larger sediment size, where shelters were probably abundant, while growth decreased with increasing densities. Fish appeared to favour the availability of shelter over maximization of growth. Mean growth was negative during all winter trials and did not vary among discharge treatments. These results suggest that increased fish densities are a major cause of reduced summer growth at low discharge, and that habitat‐mediated density differences explain the majority of the growth variation across habitat conditions both during summer and winter.     

Components of breeding performance in two competing species: habitat heterogeneity, individual quality and density-dependence

Density‐dependent breeding performance due to habitat heterogeneity has been shown to regulate populations of territorial species, since the progressive occupation of low quality territories as breeding density increases may cause a decline in the mean per capita fecundity of a population while variation in fecundity increases. Although the preemptive use of sites may relegate low quality individuals to sites of progressively lower suitability, few studies on density dependence have tried to separate the effects of territory quality from individual quality, and none have simultaneously considered the effects of heterospecific competitors. Using two long‐term monitored populations, we assessed the relative contribution of habitat heterogeneity and bird quality (in terms of age) on the productivity of sympatric golden Aquila chrysaetos and Bonelli's eagles Hieraaetus fasciatus under different scenarios of intra‐ and inter‐specific competition. Productivity (number of offspring fledged) varied among territories and average annual productivity was negatively related to its variability in both species and populations, thus giving some support to the habitat heterogeneity hypothesis. However, the effect of habitat heterogeneity on productivity became non‐significant when parental age and local density estimators were included in multivariate analyses. Therefore, temporal changes in bird quality (age) combined with intra‐ and interspecific competition explained variability in territory productivity rather than habitat heterogeneity among territories per se. The recruitment of subadult breeders, a surrogate of mortality in eagles, strongly varied among territories. Habitat heterogeneity in productivity may thus arise not because sites differ in suitability for reproduction but because of differences in factors affecting survival. Territories associated with high mortality risks have a higher probability of being occupied by young birds, whose lower quality, interacting with the density competitors, leads to a reduction of productivity. Site‐dependent variability in adult survival and interspecific competition may be extensive, but so far largely overlooked, factors to be seriously considered for the site‐dependent population regulation framework.     

Effects of Density and Extinction Coefficient on Size Variability in Plant Populations

The effects of density and extinction coefficient on size variability,as measured by the coefficient of variation of plant weightin even-aged monocultures, were investigated theoretically usinga diffusion model of growth and size distribution and a canopyphotosynthesis model over the range of densities at which self-thinning(size-dependent mortality) does not occur. Size inequality (thecoefficient of variation of plant weight) increases with increasingdensity or leaf area index at each growth stage. Plants witherect leaves are prone to lower size inequality than plantswith horizontal leaves. These results agree well with existingobservations on even-aged plant monocultures and suggest thatcompetition between plants is mainly one-sided (competitionfor light). One sided competition affects size variability througha G(t, x) function (mean growth of plants of size x at timet per unit time). Two-sided competition (including competitionfor nutrients) affects size variability through a D(t, x) function(variance of growth of plants of size x at time t per unit time).In this case, size inequality decreases with increasing density.The importance of studying size variability is emphasized. Helianthus annus L., size variability, size inequality, coefficient of variation, competition, density effect, extinction coefficient, diffusion model, canopy photosynthesis model     

刺槐叶片可塑生长的密度依赖性

为了探明刺槐叶片性状对种植密度的依赖性,通过刺槐田间栽培试验,研究了刺槐叶片可塑生长的密度依赖性以及主要叶片性状因子之间的关系.结果表明,不同种植密度条件下刺槐叶片厚度均无显著差异,但叶面积、叶绿素含蜃、叶片干重、比叶面积、叶干物质含量和叶片N含量差异显著,表明不同种植密度条件下刺槐叶性因子参数的变异较大,刺槐叶片性状对密度的依赖性较强.叶干重、叶厚度和叶片干物质含量均随种植密度的降低而呈增加趋势,叶片干物质含量与种植密度的相关性达到显著水平(P<0.01),而叶干重、叶厚度与种植密度的相关性不显著(P>0.05).比叶而积和叶片N含鼍均随种植密度的降低而降低,表明刺槐各叶性因子之间对种植密度的依赖性差异明显.对刺槐各叶性因子的相关分析表明,不同种植密度条件下各叶性因子之间的相关性及其强弱均存在差别,表明种植密度是影响刺槐叶性因子变异及叶性因子之间关系的因素之一.叶性特征对种植密度响应存在差异的主要原因是叶性因子之间的协同变化、刺槐生长微环境的差异和刺槐间竞争强度的差异,刺槐不同叶性因子之间的协调平衡和对种植密度响应程度与方向的差异表明了刺槐对其生长环境的适应.     

Food preference and performance of the larvae of a specialist herbivore: variation among and within host-plant populations

Specialist herbivores are suggested to be unaffected by or attracted to the defense compounds of their host-plants, and can even prefer higher levels of certain chemicals. Abrostola asclepiadis is a specialist herbivore whose larvae feed on the leaves of Vincetoxicum hirundinaria, which contains toxic alkaloids and is unpalatable to most generalist herbivores. The food choice, leaf consumption and growth of A. asclepiadis larvae were studied to determine whether there is variation among and within host-plant populations in their suitability for this specialist herbivore. There was significant variation in food preference and leaf consumption among host-plant populations, but no differences were found in larval growth and feeding on different host-plant populations. A. asclepiadis larvae preferred host-plant populations with higher alkaloid concentrations, but did not consume more leaf material from plants originating from such populations in a no-choice experiment. There was also some variation in food preference of larvae among host-plant individuals belonging to the same population, suggesting that there was variability in leaf chemistry also within populations. Such variation in larval preference among host-plant genotypes and populations may create potential for coevolutionary dynamics in a spatial mosaic.     

Detectability of landscape effects on recolonization increases with regional population density

Variation in population size over time can influence our ability to identify landscape‐moderated differences in community assembly. To date, however, most studies at the landscape scale only cover snapshots in time, thereby overlooking the temporal dynamics of populations and communities. In this paper, we present data that illustrate how temporal variation in population density at a regional scale can influence landscape‐moderated variation in recolonization and population buildup in disturbed habitat patches. Four common insect species, two omnivores and two herbivores, were monitored over 8 years in 10 willow short‐rotation coppice bio‐energy stands with a four‐year disturbance regime (coppice cycle). The population densities in these regularly disturbed stands were compared to densities in 17 undisturbed natural Salix cinerea (grey willow) stands in the same region. A time series approach was used, utilizing the natural variation between years to statistically model recolonization as a function of landscape composition under two different levels of regional density. Landscape composition, i.e. relative amount of forest vs. open agricultural habitats, largely determined the density of re‐colonizing populations following willow coppicing in three of the four species. However, the impact of landscape composition was not detectable in years with low regional density. Our results illustrate that landscape‐moderated recolonization can change over time and that considering the temporal dynamics of populations may be crucial when designing and evaluating studies at landscape level.     

Tree leaf wettability as passive bio-indicator of urban habitat quality

This study evaluated the effect of urban habitat quality on the wettability of tree leaves. We measured leaf wettability of five common tree species, i.e., Alnus glutinosa, Acer pseudoplatanus, Betula pendula, Quercus robur and Sambucus nigra, in semi-natural and industrial urban habitats in the city of Gent (Belgium). Possible seasonal variation was taken into account by measuring in late spring and in late summer. Drop contact angle (DCA), and height over width ratio were measured on the abaxial and the adaxial leaf surface as proxies for leaf wettability. The relative standard deviation for the height over width ratio was higher than for the DCA, so that only the latter was considered further.Habitat type significantly influenced leaf wettability: the DCA values of Q. robur leaves were significantly lower in the industrial than in the semi-natural areas, in both June and September while, for S. nigra, the DCA was in both sampling events significantly higher in the industrial areas. For the adaxial leaf side, the differences between the considered habitats were more pronounced in June than in September. The adaxial DCA of A. pseudoplatanus was significantly higher in June compared to September, while the opposite held for abaxial values of A. glutinosa. We conclude that leaf wettability is potentially a good indicator to point out differences in urban habitat quality, but selection of the most sensitive tree species and the appropriate time of measuring is an important prerequisite.     

Nutritional Differences between Two Orangutan Habitats: Implications for Population Density

Bottom-up regulatory factors have been proposed to exert a strong influence on mammalian population density. Studies relating habitat quality to population density have typically made comparisons among distant species or communities without considering variation in food quality among localities. We compared dietary nutritional quality of two Bornean orangutan populations with differing population densities in peatland habitats, Tuanan and Sabangau, separated by 63 km. We hypothesized that because Tuanan is alluvial, the plant species included in the orangutan diet would be of higher nutritional quality compared to Sabangau, resulting in higher daily caloric intake in Tuanan. We also predicted that forest productivity would be greater in Tuanan compared to Sabangau. In support of these hypotheses, the overall quality of the diet and the quality of matched dietary items were higher in Tuanan, resulting in higher daily caloric intake compared to Sabangau. These differences in dietary nutritional quality may provide insights into why orangutan population density is almost two times greater in Tuanan compared to Sabangau, in agreement with a potentially important influence of diet quality on primate population density.     

The role of foliar microfungi in mountain birch - insect herbivore relationships

We studied the effects of epiphytic and endophytic phyllosphere fungi and pathogenic birch rust fungus infection of mountain birch Betula pubescens ssp czerepanovit trees on the larval performance of leaf beetle Phratora potaris We assessed the effects of epiphytic fungi by growing larvae on leaves from trees with manipulated fungal densities We also monitored larval perfonnance and endophytic fungal densities among tree groups classified by herbivory or rust fungus densities The differences in expenmentally manipulated epiphytic fungal densities did not affect larval relative growth rates (RGR) of the species, instead we found significant tree effects Phratora polaris RGR was higher on trees with high level of herbivory than on trees with low herbivory, nevertheless, endophyte densities between these groupings did not differ In the rust fungus expenment, P polarts performance was lowest on trees with low infection compared to no and high infection trees We also did not find correlations among tree-specific endophyte densities and P polaris performance on high and low herbivory trees and trees classified by rust fungus infection Although antagonism among fungi and induction of tree defences cannot be excluded, we suggest that epiphytic and endophytic fungi of mountain birch have negligible effects on P polaris larval performance under natural conditions, probably due to mountain birch variability and a loose ecological connection between mountain birch and its epi- and endophytes Mountain birch and pathogenic birch rust have a more tightly linked relationship, which may also affect insect herbivores Still, leaf properties may play an important role and the effects will depend on the relative timing of the rust infection, herbivore development and changes in leaf quality