Nucleotide Sequence Relationships of Avian RNA Tumor Viruses: Measurement of the Deletion in a Transformation-Defective Mutant of Rous Sarcoma Virus

Stocks of cloned helper-independent Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) spontaneously segregate transformation-defective (td) mutants that appear to have an RNA genome composed of smaller subunits than those of the patent virus. Differential hybridization and competitive hybridization techniques involving reactions between viral RNA and proviral sequences in host cell DNA (under conditions of initial DNA excess) were used to measure the extent of the deletion in a td mutant of Prague strain (Pr) of RSV (Pr RSV-C). Viral 60 to 70S RNA sequences labeled to 1 to 5 x 10(7) counts per min per mug with (125)I were characterized with respect to their properties in hybridization reactions and used to reinforce data obtained with [(3)H]RNA of lower specific activity. By these techniques, about 13% +/- 3% of the sequences Pr RSV-C that formed hybrids with DNA from virus-induced sarcomas appeared to be deleted from the genome of td Pr RSV-C. Studies comparing hybridization of RNA from Pr RSV-C and td Pr RSV-C with RSV-related sequences in normal cells, and competition experiments with RNA from the endogenous chicken oncornavirus Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0) provided evidence that the majority, if not all, of the RNA sequences of Pr RSV-C deleted from its transformation-defective mutant are not represented in normal chicken DNA. Competition studies with a leukosis virus, RAV-7, indicated this virus also lacks a genome segment of about the same size as the deletion in the td mutant. Finally, the genome of all three "exogenous" viruses was found to lack a small segment (about 12%) of sequences present in the endogenous provirus of RAV-O.     

Nucleotide sequence of Rous sarcoma virus RNA at the initiation site of DNA synthesis: The 102nd nucleotide is U.

The T₁ oligonucleotide in the genome Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) that corresponds to the initiation site of DNA synthesis in vitro was identified by hybridization of genome RNA with RSV strong stop DNA (the initial 101-nucleotide long fragment synthesized in endogenous reactions) and partially sequenced. The sequence of (C₂, U₂) A-U-U-U-G found corresponds to the d(A-A-T-G-A-A-G) sequence at the 5′ end of the DNA product plus the CA-OH sequence at the 3′ end of the tRNA^Trp primer. Therefore the nucleotide opposite the terminal A of the primer is the complementary U. Furthermore, no internal repetition of more than 30 nucleotides of the 5′ sequence could be detected.     

Heterogeneity of genetic loci in chickens: analysis of endogenous viral and nonviral genes by cleavage of DNA with restriction endonucleases.

Restriction endonucleases can be used to define the structure and position of genetic loci for which specific molecular hybridization reagents are available. We have used this approach to compare 18 chicken embryos with respect to several cellular genes; endogenous viral DNA related to the replicative genes of avian sarcoma virus (ASV) or to RAV-O, an endogenous virus of chickens; and sequences related to the transforming (src) gene of ASV. Each cellular gene eas remarkably homogeneous within our test population. We found little or no variation in globin and ovomucoid genes; ovalbumin and transferrin (with one exception) showed variation which is probably allelic in nature. The endogenous viral DNA which has homology with RAV-O was found at several different positions in host DNA and its structure resembled that of proviruses acquired by experimental infection, with sequences from both ends of viral RNA repeated near both ends of viral DNA. Within the population of 18 chickens, one endogenous provirus was always present, whereas the several other proviruses were each found in only a few members of this group. However, screening of additional chickens identified individuals lacking the provirus common to the initial 18 animals surveyed; in at least one embryo no RAV-O-related DNA was detected. These findings suggest that the endogenous RAV-O-related sequences have entered the germ line by relatively recent infection and are still segregating in several contemporary chicken flocks. The sequences in the chicken genome which have homology with the src gene of ASV are invariant from bird to bird and in this sense resemble a cellular gene rather than a viral sequence.     

Regulation of expression and chromosomal subunit conformation of avian retrovirus genomes.

We have investigated the copy number, chromosomal subunit conformation and regulation of expression of integrated avian retrovirus genomes. Our results indicate that there are approximately two copies of the endogenous viral genomes (RAV-O) per haploid cell genome in uninfected chick embryo fibroblasts (CEF) and red blood cells (RBC). The copy number and subunit conformation (as measured by DNAasel sensitivity) of the RAV-O genomes are independent of the level of expression of these viral DNA sequences. In cells isolated from embryos of the V+, gs-chf- and gs+chf+ phenotypes, approximately one of the two viral genomes is in a DNAase l-sensitive conformation. Upon infection with an exogenous Rous sarcoma virus (PR-RSV-C), one new viral genome is integrated per haploid CEF genome. The newly integrated RSV genome is completely sensitive to DNAase l, and the subunit conformation of the endogenous viral genomes is not altered by the integration of additional exogenous proviruses. Both the endogenous and newly integrated exogenous viral genomes are present in "nu-body" structures, and the selective sensitivity of these proviral DNA sequences to DNAase l is maintained in isolated nucleosomes. Our experiments revealing the DNAase l sensitivity of one of the two RAV-O genomes in gs-chf-CEF led us to reexamine the level of viral specific RNA in CEF of various GS genotypes. We find that GS/GS CEF contain approximately 100 copies of viral RNA per cell, gs/gs CEF contain no detectable viral RNA, and the heterozygote GS/gs CEF contain approximately 50 copies of viral specific RNA per cell. These results suggest that the GS gene controls production of RAV-O RNA sequences in CEF in a "cis" fashion. In RBCs, however, the expression of the RAV-O genome is independent of the GS gene, with both GS/GS and gs/gs RBCs containing roughly equivalent amounts of viral specific RNA. Our results suggest that the chromosomal structure of the endogenous viral genes is independent of the GS gene, and that the GS gene is cis-acting and tissue-specific.     

Transformation by subgenomic fragments of Rous sarcoma virus DNA

Subgenomic fragments of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) DNA, generated by Eco RI digestion of DNA of RSV-infected chicken cells, induced transformation of NIH/3T3 mouse cells with efficiencies that were 100–1000 fold lower than the efficiency of transformation by intact RSV DNA. Analysis of the DNAs of NIH cells transformed by Eco RI-digested RSV DNA indicated that these cells contained no more than 2 × 10⁶ daltons of RSV DNA, and did not contain sequences from the 5′ terminus of RSV RNA which are included in the leader sequence of subgenomic src mRNA of RSV-infected cells. The product of the RSV src gene (pp60^src), however, was produced in apparently similar quantities by NIH cells transformed by Eco RI fragments of RSV DNA and by intact RSV DNA. Thus expression of the src gene of RSV in NIH cells transformed by subgenomic fragments of RSV DNA did not require the terminal sequences of the RSV genome, which appear to be involved in synthesis and processing of src mRNA in RSV-infected cells. DNAs of NIH cells transformed by Eco RI-digested RSV DNA were found to induce transformation in secondary transfection assays with efficiencies that were similar to the efficiency of transformation by intact RSV DNA. These results suggest that transformation by subgenomic fragments of RSV DNA may be a consequence of integration of src gene-containing DNA fragments in the vicinity of a promoter site in the recipient cell genome, leading to efficient expression of the RSV src gene.     

Nucleotide sequence relationships between the genomes of an endogenous and an exogenous avian tumor virus.

We have used mapping of large T1 oligonucleotides to examine the genome of Rous-associated virus-O (RAV-O), an endogenous virus of chickens, and to compare it with that of Prague strain Rous sarcoma virus, subgroup B, (Pr-RSV-B), an exogenous sarcoma virus. To extend the sensitivity of such comparisons, we have developed a system of nucleic acid hybridization and hybridization-competition combined with fingerprinting. This method allows us to estimate the relative degree of relatedness of various portions of the viral genomes. From the results of this study, we have concluded that the genomes of Pr-RSV-B and RAV-O are related in the following way. The 5'-terminal half of the genomes (corresponding to the gag and pol regions) is virtually identical, with only scattered single nucleotide differences. This region is followed by a region comprising 25 to 30% of the genome (the env region) which contains substantial nucleotide sequence differences, most or all of which are due to single base changes. The env-coding region can be further subdivided into three regions: a more variable region probably containing sequences coding for subgroup specificity, flanked by relatively common sequences on each side. To the 3' side of the env region, the RAV-O genome contains a very short sequence not found in Pr-RSV-B, whereas the Pr-RSV-B genome contains a much longer unrelated sequence. The central portion of this sequence comprises the src gene as defined by transformation-defective mutants. Particularly striking is the absence, in the RAV-O genome, of any nucleotide sequence related to the "c region" found very near the 3' end of all exogenous tumor viruses. Both the Pr-RSV-B and RAV-O genomes contain the identical terminally redundant sequence of 21 nucleotides near each end of the genome.     

Lack of infectivity of the endogenous avian leukosis virus-related genes in the DNA of uninfected chicken cells.

The infectivity of the avian leukosis virus-related genes in the DNA of four genetically distinct types of chicken cells was determined. Infectious DNA of Rous-associated virus-O(RAV-O) was obtained from V- chicken cells which were experimentally infected with RAV-O and from V+tvbs chicken cells, which spontaneously produced RAV-O and were sensitive to exogenous RAV-O infection. However, infectious DNA of RAV-O was not obtained from uninfected V- chicken cells or from V+tvbr chicken cells, which spontaneously produced a low titer of RAV-O but were resistant to exogenous RAV-O infection. No detectable amplification of the RAV-O related DNA sequences in the V+tvbs cells was found by hybridization of RAV-O 125I-labeled RNA to the DNAs of V+tvbs and uninfected V- cells. These results indicate that the endogenous avian leukosis virus-related genes in uninfected V- and V+tvbr cells differ from the RAV-O proviruses in RAV-O-infected V- and V+tvbs cells. The lack of infectivity of the DNA of V+tvbr cells is consistent with the hypothesis that the endogenous RAV-O genome in V+tvbr cells is linked to a cis-acting control element, which results in its inefficient expression.     

The distribution of endogenous chicken retrovirus sequences in the DNA of galliform birds does not coincide with avian phylogenetic relationships.

The chicken is a domesticated form of Red Jungle-fowl (Gallus gallus), which belongs to the Pheasant family (Phasianidae) within the order Galliformes. Domestic chickens carry the genome of the endogenous retrovirus RAV-O as DNA sequences integrated into host chromosomes transmitted through the germ line. We have examined the presence and distribution of RAV-O-related sequences in the DNA of Red Junglefowl and other closely related species of Junglefowl, as well as more distantly related Pheasants and Quail. DNA sequences homologous to RAV-O were analyzed by molecular hybridization in liquid and after electrophoresis of restriction endonuclease fragments. The presence of RAV-O-related sequences in avian DNA does not correlate with phylogenetic relationships. Under stringent conditions of hybridization in liquid, DNA sequences homologous to RAV-O cDNA were detected at high levels (greater than 80% homology( only in the genomes of the domestic chicken and its phylogenetic ancestor, the Red Junglefowl (Gallus gallus). The DNA of two other species of Gallus (G. sonnerati, Sonnerat's Junglefowl and G. varius, Green Junglefowl), of Ring-necked Pheasant and of Japanese Quail contained sequences with less than 10% homology to RAV-O cDNA. Under conditions permitting mismatching, however, Ring-necked Pheasant DNA hybridized up to 50% of the RAV-O cDNA, and Quail DNA 24%, whereas the extent of hybridization to Sonnerat's and Green Junglefowl DNA was not markedly increased. Analysis of restriction enzyme digests revealed several distinct fragments of DNA hybridizing to chick retrovirus cDNA in both Red Junglefowl and domestic chicken, and multiple fragments in DNA from two species of Phasianus. No fragments with sequences related to chicken retroviruses were found, however, in digests of DNA prepared from Sonnerat's, Ceylonese and Green Junglefowl, from two other Pheasant genera (Chrysolophus and Lophura), or from one Quail genus (Coturnix). Thus the DNA of three Junglefowl species closely related to Gallus gallus lacked RAV-O sequences while the DNA of more distantly related Phasianus species showed significant homology. These results show that RAV-O-related sequences have not diverged together with the normal host genes during the evolution of the Phasianidae. Although RAV-O sequences are endogenous in all domestic chickens and Red Junglefowl studied thus far, it appears that the RAV-O genome has been introduced relatively recently into the germ line of Gallus gallus, following speciation but before domestication, and independently of the related sequences found in members of the genus Phasianus.     

Chicken leukosis virus genome sequences in DNA from normal chick cells and virus-induced bursal lymphomas.

Genome sequences of two recent field isolates of avian leukosis viruses in the DNA of normal and neoplastic chicken cells were studied by DNA-RNA hybridization under conditions of DNA excess. Comparisons were made between 60-70S RNA from these viruses and that of a chicken endogenous type C virus (RAV-0), and of a series of "laboratory" leukosis and sarcoma viruses, by competitive hybridization analysis. A minimum of 18% of the genome sequences of both ALV isolates detected in DNA from lymphomas they induced were not detected in normal chicken DNA. The vast majority of the fraction of RNA sequences from ALV which do form hybrids with normal chick DNA appear to be reacting with the endogenous provirus of RAV-0. The genomic representation of a variety of avian leukosis and sarcoma viruses in normal chicken cells could not be distinguished by these methods (except that 13% of the RAV-0 genome was not shared with any of the other viruses). In contrast, the portion of the ALV genome exogenous to the normal chicken geome showed significant divergence from that of two sarcoma viruses (Pr RSV-C and B-77). The increased hybridization of ALV RNA with lymphoma DNA was used to detect the appearance of ALV specific sequences in the bursa of Fabricius following infection.increased hybridization was correlated with both the time after infection and the extent of replacement of the bursa by lymphoma. About one half of the increase in hybridization preceded histologic evidence of transformation.     

Differences between the endogenous and exogenous DNA sequences of Rous-associated virus-O.

DNA sequences related to the endogenous retrovirus of chickens, Rous-associated virus-O (RAV-O), have been examined using site-specific DNA endonuclease analysis of cellular DNA derived from line 15 and line 100 chickens. Individual embryos from both inbred lines were used as a source of embryonic fibroblasts from which cellular DNA was isolated. Analysis of DNA containing either endogenous RAV-O sequences alone or both endogenous and exogenous RAV-O sequences produced identical patterns of RAV-O-specific DNA fragments after digestion with the endonucleases Eco RI, Hind III, BgI II, Bam HI or Xho I. Similar analysis with endonucleases Hinc II or Hha I, however, produced several RAV-O-specific DNA fragments which were derived from cellular DNA containing both endogenous and exogenous RAV-O sequences but not from cellular DNA containing only endogenous sequences. Although some differences exist between the DNA fragments specific for the endogenous viral sequences of line 15 and line 100 cellular DNA, the DNA fragments specific for the exogenous viral sequences were identical between the two inbred lines. Cleavage of an unintegrated linear RAV-O DNA molecule with Hinc II or Hha I produced DNA fragments identical to those specific for the exogenously acquired RAV-O provirus. This suggests that these characteristic fragments contain no cellular DNA. The potential DNA junction fragments containing both viral and cellular DNA, identified after analysis of DNA that contains both endogenous and exogenous viral sequences, were identical to those observed after analysis of DNA containing only endogenous viral sequences. These results support the following conclusions. First, exogenous proviral sequences are integrated into chicken cell DNA following an interaction between viral and cellular DNA that is specific with respect to the virus and nonspecific with respect to the cell. Second, both the free linear RAV-O DNA intermediate and the newly integrated exogenous provirus contain specific endonuclease sites that are not found in endogenous RAV-O DNA sequences. These results suggest that the formation of the exogenous DNA provirus involves specific alteration of the endogenous viral DNA sequences before reinsertion of the sequences as the exogenous RAV-O DNA provirus. It is possible that newly integrated exogenous RAV-O sequences are characterized by specific differences in the pattern of base methylation and a limited sequence arrangement.     

Retroviruses as mutagens: Insertion and excision of a nontransforming provirus alter expression of a resident transforming provirus

Integration of retroviral DNA appears to occur randomly in host genomes, suggesting that retroviruses can act as insertion mutagens. We have confirmed this prediction by showing that the nontransforming retrovirus, Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV), can insert its provirus within the selectable target provided by a single provirus in a clonal rat cell line (B31) transformed by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV). Analysis of over 60 morphological revertants of M-MuLV-superinfected B31 cells revealed two lines with inserts of M-MuLV proviruses within the RSV provirus but outside the transforming gene of RSV (src), at sites 0.6 and 4.0 kb from the 5′ end. The inserts did not inactivate initiation of RSV RNA synthesis but did affect elongation or processing, or both, generating species with the 5′ end of RSV RNA linked to sequences that presumably derive from the inserted M-MuLV DNA. In one mutant line, most of the insert was excised at low frequency, apparently by homologous recombination between repeated sequences at the ends of M-MuLV DNA. After excision, RSV src mRNA was present in normal amounts, and the cells resumed a transformed appearance. In at least four independent lines, large portions of the left end of the RSV provirus (from 1 to 6 kb) and variable amounts of leftward flanking cellular DNA (from 0.5 to 10–15 kb or more) were deleted, without nearby insertions of M-MuLV DNA. The deletions removed the putative promoter for synthesis of RSV RNA; in the two cases examined, no RSV RNA was detected. These deletions may represent a second mutational effect of the superinfection by M-MuLV.     

Alignment of the peptides derived from acid-catalyzed cleavage of an aspartylprolyl bond in the major internal structural polypeptide of avian retroviruses

The major internal structural polypeptide (p27) of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), and the analogous polypeptide (P27(0)) OF Rous-associated virus-O (RAV-O), an endogenous virus released spontaneously by some chicken cells) have been cleaved selectively at a single aspartylprolyl peptide bond to yield two fragments. The NH2- and COOH-terminal amino acid sequences of p27 and p27(0) and their mild acid-cleavage fragments have been determined. These results show the existence of an identical cleavage site and a similar NH2- and COOH-terminal amino acid sequence in both the polypeptides. Furthermore they indicate that the difference in the molecular weights of p27 and p27(0) results from an insertion of amino acids in the COOH-terminal peptide of p27(0) rather than a shift in the scission site of the precursor molecule.     

Hybridization of Rous Sarcoma Virus Deoxyribonucleic Acid Polymerase Product and Ribonucleic Acids from Chicken and Rat Cells Infected with Rous Sarcoma Virus

Rous sarcoma virus (RSV)-specific ribonucleic acid (RNA) in virus-producing chicken cells and non-virus-producing rat cells infected with RSV was studied by hybridization with the endogenous deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) product of the RSV virion DNA polymerase system. By hybridizing the total DNA product with excess virion RNA, the product DNA was separated into hybridized (“minus”) and nonhybridized (“plus”) DNA. The “minus” DNA was complementary to at least 20% of the RNA from RSV which remained of high molecular weight after denaturation. A maximum of approximately 65% hybridization was observed between “minus” DNA and RSV RNA or RSV-infected chicken cell RNA. A maximum of about 60% hybridization was observed between “minus” DNA and RSV-infected rat cell RNA. RSV-infected chicken cells contained RSV-specific RNA equivalent to about 6,000 virions per cell. RSV-infected rat cells contained RSV-specific RNA equivalent to approximately 400 virions per cell. Neither cell type contained detectable RNA complementary to virion RNA. The RSV-specific RNA in RSV-infected rat cells did not appear to be qualitatively different from that in RSV-infected chicken cells.     

Localization of N6-methyladenosine in the Rous sarcoma virus genome.

The 10,000-nucleotide RNA genome of the Prague strain, subgroup B (PR-B) of Rous sarcoma virus, was found to contain 11.6 ± 0.5 residues of m⁶Ap by quantitative analysis of ³²P-labeled virion RNA after complete RNAase digestion. Approximately ten of the m⁶Ap residues are located, without obvious clustering, in that region of the genome between 500 and 4000 nucleotides from the 3′ poly(A) end. The src gene, which is required for transformation, and part of the env gene, which codes for the major viral envelope glycoprotein, have previously been mapped in this region of the viral genome. A transformation-defective deletion mutant of PR-B Rous sarcoma virus, which lacks the src gene, has 7.0 ± 0.2 m⁶Ap residues per RNA subunit. This supports our mapping of a portion of the m⁶A residues in src and suggests that this methylation is specific to certain regions of the genome. The possible significance of this result for Rous sarcoma virus RNA processing and translation is discussed.     

Homology between avian oncornavirus RNAs and DNA from several avian species.

3H-labeled 35S RNA from avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV), Rous associated virus (RAV)-0, RAV-60, RAV-61, RAV-2, or B-77(w) was hybridized with an excess of cellular DNA from different avian species, i.e., normal or leukemic chickens, normal pheasants, turkeys, Japanese quails, or ducks. Approximately two to three copies of endogenous viral DNA were estimated to be present per diploid of normal chicken cell genome. In leukemic chicken myeloblasts induced by AMV, the number of viral sequences appeared to have doubled. The hybrids formed between viral RNA and DNA from leukemic chicken cells melted with a Tm 1 to 6 C higher than that of hybrids formed between viral RNA and normal chicken cell DNA. All of the viral RNAs tested, except RAV-61, hybridized the most with DNA from AMV-infected chicken cells, followed by DNA from normal chicken cells, and then pheasant DNA. RAV-61 RNA hybridized maximally (39%) with pheasant DNA, followed by DNA from leukemic (34%), and then normal (29%) chicken cells. All viral RNAs tested hybridized little with Japanese quail DNA (2 to 5%), turkey DNA (2 to 4%), or duck DNA (1%). DNA from normal chicken cells contained only 60 to 70% of the RAV-60 genetic information, and normal pheasant cells lacked some RAV-61 DNA sequences. RAV-60 and RAV-61 genomes were more homologous to the RAV-0 genome than to the genome of RAV-2, AMV, or B-77(s). RAV-60 and RAV-61 appear to be recombinants between endogenous and exogenous viruses.     

Cell Cycle-Dependent Activation of Rous Sarcoma Virus-Infected Stationary Chicken Cells: Avian Leukosis Virus Group-Specific Antigens and Ribonucleic Acid

Stationary chicken embryo fibroblasts exposed to Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) remained stably infected for at least 5 days, but they did not release infectious virus or become transformed until after cell division. These infected stationary cells did not contain avian leukosis virus group-specific antigens or ribonucleic acid (RNA) hybridizable to deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) made by the RSV endogenous RNA-directed DNA polymerase activity.