The role of jelly coats in sperm-egg encounters, fertilization success, and selection on egg size in broadcast spawners

Sperm limitation may be an important selective force influencing gamete traits such as egg size. The relatively inexpensive extracellular structures surrounding many marine invertebrate eggs might serve to enhance collision rates without the added cost of increasing the egg cell. However, despite decades of research, the effects of extracellular structures on fertilization have not been conclusively documented. Here, using the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus, we remove jelly coats from eggs, and we quantify sperm collisions to eggs with jelly coats, eggs without jelly coats, and inert plastic beads. We also quantify fertilization success in both egg treatment groups. We find that sperm-egg collision rates increase as a function of sperm concentration and target size and that sperm are not chemotactically attracted to eggs nor to jelly coats in this species. In fertilization assays, the presence of the jelly coat is correlated with a significant but smaller-than-expected improvement in fertilization success. A pair of optimality models predict that, despite the large difference in the energetic value of egg contents and jelly material, the presence of the jelly coat does not diminish selection for larger egg cell size when sperm are limiting.     

A general solution for optimal egg size during external fertilization, extended scope for intermediate optimal egg size and the introduction of Don Ottavio 'tango'

Egg sizes of marine invertebrates vary greatly, both within and between species. Among the proposed causes of this are a trade-off between egg size, egg number and survival probability of offspring, and a selection pressure exerted by sperm limitation during external fertilization. Although larger eggs are indeed a larger target for sperm, producing larger eggs also implies making fewer of them. There has been discussion about whether sperm limitation can (theoretically) and does (in nature) select for larger egg size than under ad libitum sperm. In one specific model, based on a particular fertilization kinetics model and an empirically derived mortality function, the theoretical possibility of a negative shift in optimal egg size with sperm concentration was demonstrated. Here we present a generalized analytical model to explore the effects of survival and fertilization probabilities on optimal egg size. It is demonstrated that incorporating fertilization kinetics greatly increases the scope for intermediate optimal egg size, as opposed to eggs of minimal or maximal size. Second, we present a general analytical qualitative solution to the question whether optimal egg size depends on sperm concentration. It is shown that, under the condition that an intermediate optimal egg size exists, this qualitative outcome of the model (positive, negative or no relation between optimal egg size and sperm limitation) depends on the structure of the fertilization kinetics part of the model. Finally, we evaluate fertilization kinetics models with respect to the general solution, using two previously published kinetics models ('Don Giovanni' and 'Don Ottavio') and a novel alteration of one of them in which sperm concentration covaries with egg concentration (Don Ottavio 'tango'). For all three models the relationship between optimal egg size and sperm concentration is shown to be always negative. This paper thus shows how biologically realistic relationships between egg size on the one hand and survival and fertilization probability on the other hand predict optimal egg size to be intermediate, and that this optimum is in general expected to increase when sperm become more limiting.     

DOES BATEMAN'S PRINCIPLE APPLY TO BROADCAST-SPAWNING ORGANISMS? EGG TRAITS INFLUENCE IN SITU FERTILIZATION RATES AMONG CONGENERIC SEA URCHINS

Evolutionary biologists generally invoke male competition and female choice as mechanisms driving sexual selection. However, in broadcast-spawning organisms sperm may be limiting and females may compete, in the Darwinian sense, for increased mating success. In this study, I investigate how species differences in egg and sperm traits result in different patterns of fertilization among three closely related sea urchins (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, S. franciscanus, and S. droebachiensis). Field studies demonstrate that all three species achieve similar percentages of eggs fertilized when eggs and sperm are released simultaneously. However, when sperm must disperse before encountering eggs, differences arise among species such that those with the smaller eggs and faster but shorter-lived sperm achieve relatively fewer fertilizations than do species with larger eggs and slower but longer-lived sperm. A field hybridization experiment, field estimates of sperm dispersal, correlations of egg size to field rates of fertilization, laboratory studies of fertilization kinetics, and a simulation model all suggest that it is attributes of the egg (probably egg size) that are responsible for the differences. These patterns of fertilization match the species' patterns of dispersion; species that do well only when sperm and eggs are released in close proximity are more aggregated, species that do relatively well when sperm and eggs are released farther apart are more dispersed. These results are consistent with the notion that eggs of different species are adapted to maximize reproductive success under different degrees of sperm limitation and suggest that male competition and female choice may not be an appropriate dichotomy in broadcast-spawning organisms.     

Relationship between the fertilization of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) eggs and the motility of spermatozoa

This investigation evaluated the relationship between the motility of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri ) spermatozoa and egg fertilization. When sperm:egg ratios were supraoptimal (i.e., > 200,000 sperm per egg), neither spermatozoan motility, sperm density or spermatocrit were major factors in determining the percentage of eggs reaching the stage of eye-up. At spermatozoan concentrations near the critical ratio of spermatozoa per egg (i.e., 200,000/egg), there was a significant correlation between fertilization rates and subjective motility estimates. Samples exhibiting better motility required fewer spermatozoa to ensure high fertilization rates, obtaining rates near 90% with as few as 100,000 spermatozoa per egg. Late in the reproductive season, there was a significant correlation between initial sperm density and fertilization rate.     

Evolution of egg target size: an analysis of selection on correlated characters

In broadcast-spawning marine organisms, chronic sperm limitation should select for traits that improve chances of sperm-egg contact. One mechanism may involve increasing the size of the physical or chemical target for sperm. However, models of fertilization kinetics predict that increasing egg size can reduce net zygote production due to an associated decline in fecundity. An alternate method for increasing physical target size is through addition of energetically inexpensive external structures, such as the jelly coats typical of eggs in species from several phyla. In selection experiments on eggs of the echinoid Dendraster excentricus, in which sperm was used as the agent of selection, eggs with larger overall targets were favored in fertilization. Actual shifts in target size following selection matched quantitative predictions of a model that assumed fertilization was proportional to target size. Jelly volume and ovum volume, two characters that contribute to target size, were correlated both within and among females. A cross-sectional analysis of selection partitioned the independent effects of these characters on fertilization success and showed that they experience similar direct selection pressures. Coupled with data on relative organic costs of the two materials, these results suggest that, under conditions where fertilization is limited by egg target size, selection should favor investment in low-cost accessory structures and may have a relatively weak effect on the evolution of ovum size.     

Chemically moderated gamete preferences predict offspring fitness in a broadcast spawning invertebrate

Sperm chemoattraction, where sperm locate unfertilized eggs by following a concentration gradient of egg-derived chemoattractants, has been widely documented across numerous taxa. While marine invertebrates are favoured models for understanding the underlying mechanisms of sperm chemoattraction, the evolutionary forces underpinning the process remain enigmatic. Here, we show that in mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis), chemically moderated gamete preferences promote assortative fertilizations between genetically compatible gametes. When offered the choice of egg clutches from two females, sperm exhibited consistent but differential ‘preferences’ for chemical cues secreted from conspecific eggs. Critically, our data reveal that the preferences shown by sperm during the egg-choice trials are highly predictive of early embryonic viability when eggs and sperm from the same individuals are mixed during standard (no-choice) fertilization assays. Moreover, we demonstrate that by experimentally separating chemoattractants from eggs, sperm swimming behaviour is differentially regulated by egg-derived chemoattractants, and that these changes in sperm behaviour are highly consistent with observed patterns of gamete preferences, fertilization and larval survival. Together, this integrated series of experiments reveals that the behaviour of sperm is fine-tuned to respond differentially to the chemical signals emitted from different conspecific eggs, and that these choices have measurable fitness benefits.     

Sperm velocity and longevity trade off each other and influence fertilization in the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus

The theoretical prediction that fast sperm should be more effective at fertilizing eggs has never been documented empirically. Interspecific comparisons suggest an inverse relationship between sperm velocity and sperm longevity but this trade-off has never been demonstrated within a species. Here I investigate how sperm velocity and sperm longevity influence the patterns of fertilization in the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus. In the laboratory I examined 11 male female pairs of sea urchins for variation in sperm velocity and sperm longevity, and determined the correlations of these traits with the percentage of eggs fertilized with serially diluted sperm. Males with faster sperm had higher rates of fertilization than males with slower sperm. Within individual males, as sperm aged they slowed down and showed a reduced percentage activity and lower rates of fertilization. Across males, the average velocity of freshly spawned sperm was inversely related to sperm longevity. These results establish the possibility that sperm traits are adapted for varying conditions along a continuum from sperm limitation to sperm competition.     

The relationship between egg size and fertilization success in broadcast-spawning marine invertebrates

Egg size is a critical life-history trait because it can profoundlyinfluence offspring fitness and the number of offspring thatcan be produced. Recently, interest has grown in how egg sizeinfluences fertilization rate and in turn how sperm availabilitymight influence the evolution of egg size among broadcast-spawningmarine invertebrates. In this article I review the empiricalevidence on the ways in which egg size and egg accessory structuresinfluence fertilization and theoretical models of the ways spermavailability might influence the evolution of egg size. Evidencesuggests that egg size does influence the collision frequencywith sperm, and models suggest that sperm availability can influenceselection on egg size. Sperm availability appears to be oneof the several factors that influence optimal egg size in broadcast-spawningmarine invertebrates.     

The relative sensitivity of sperm, eggs and embryos to copper in the blue mussel (Mytilus trossulus)

Copper, an essential element, is toxic at elevated concentrations, and as a result of anthropogenic activities is becoming increasingly prevalent in marine environments. In this study, we examined the effects of copper on early life stages of the blue mussel, Mytilus trossulus. We assessed the impacts of increasing copper concentrations on embryo development, egg viability, sperm fertilization capacity and, in particular, on sperm swimming speed using computer-assisted sperm analysis. Sensitivity to copper followed the pattern: embryos > sperm > eggs. A dramatic increase in abnormal embryo development was observed following exposure to copper concentrations exceeding 10 microg/L. Sperm swimming speeds decreased significantly when exposed to 100 microg/L of copper, but lower doses did not influence sperm swimming speed. Copper exposure (at any tested concentration) did not affect sperm flagellum length, or alter egg viability. Based on our results, we suggest that exposure of sperm to copper may interfere with mitochondrial activity, which reduces sperm swimming speed during the extended duration of sperm motility in blue mussel.     

The kinetics of monospermic and polyspermic fertilization in free-spawning marine invertebrates

The equation of Vogel et al. (1982) is widely used in fertilization studies of free-spawning marine invertebrates to predict the percentage of viable eggs that will be fertilized at any specified levels of gamete concentration and contact time. Here, the random collision model that underlies the Vogel et al. equation is extended to distinguish between monospermic and polyspermic fertilization, and separate equations for the percentages of monospermic and polyspermic fertilization are obtained. These equations provide an explanation for empirical observations which have shown a decreased percentage of successful egg development at high sperm concentrations. Comparison is made with an earlier heuristic attempt (Styan, 1998) to predict the extent of polyspermic fertilization, and it is found that this earlier method can underestimate the percentage of polyspermic fertilization by up to 10 percent. Moreover, the approach used here retains the flexibility to model changes in sperm concentration due to dispersal mechanisms, and is able to model different mechanisms for the block to polyspermy.     

The parachute function of the hull in eggs of Mopalia kennerleyi (Chitonida: Mopaliidae), and swimming of its larvae through ontogeny

Free‐spawning species of chitons produce eggs enclosed in a coating known as the hull. In Chitonida, several studies have shown that the hull helps to direct sperm to specific areas of the egg surface, facilitating fertilization. One study has found evidence that this structure also serves to reduce the sinking rates of the eggs. To clarify how the presence of the hull modifies sinking rates in chiton eggs, here we compare sinking speeds and densities of eggs of Mopalia kennerleyi with and without the hull. Sinking rates of eggs with the hull were approximately one‐third of those without it. This structure acts as a flotation device because it has a density very close to that of seawater, and it increases the effective diameter and therefore the drag on the negatively buoyant egg. Since there is limited knowledge about morphology and behavior of chiton larvae, we also analyzed changes during ontogeny in behavior, swimming speeds, and body shape of larvae of M. kennerleyi. Over time, the larvae decreased their upward swimming tendency and preferred to stay near the bottom, and their bodies became elongated and dorso‐ventrally compressed. These changes may be related to preparation for settlement and metamorphosis. Further studies of these subjects are required in chitons, since movement of early stages, as eggs/embryos sinking or larvae swimming in the water column, may affect their survival.     

Egg jelly influences sperm motility in the externally fertilizing frog,Crinia georgiana

Recent in vitro fertilization studies have revealed female and male × female interaction effects on the probability of fertilization. These findings suggest a mechanism of cryptic female choice via sperm–egg interactions. The egg jelly of anuran amphibians contains proteins that facilitate the chemoattraction and binding of sperm for fertilization. Here we show that egg jelly also influences the onset of motility and swimming velocity of motile sperm in the frog Crinia georgiana. Moreover, we found significant among female variation in the effects of egg jelly on sperm motility. We discuss this finding with respect to male and female effects on nonrandom fertilization observed in this species.     

Does egg competition occur in marine broadcast‐spawners?

When the availability of sperm limits female reproductive success, competition for sperm, may be an important broker of sexual selection. This is because sperm limitation can increase the variance in female reproductive success, resulting in strong selection on females to compete for limited fertilization opportunities. Sperm limitation is probably common in broadcast-spawning marine invertebrates, making these excellent candidates for investigating scramble competition between broods of eggs and its consequences for female reproductive success. Here, we report our findings from a series of experiments that investigate egg competition in the sessile, broadcast-spawning polychaete Galeolaria caespitosa. We initially tested whether the order in which eggs encounter sperm affects their fertilization success at two ecologically relevant current regimes. We used a split-clutch-split--ejaculate technique to compare the fertilization success of eggs from individual females that had either first access (competition-free treatment) or second access (egg competition treatment) to a batch of sperm. We found that fertilization success depended on the order in which eggs accessed sperm; eggs that were assigned to the competition-free treatment exhibited significantly higher fertilization rates than those assigned to the egg competition treatment at both current speeds. In subsequent experiments we found that prior exposure of sperm to eggs significantly reduced both the quantity and quality of sperm available to fertilize a second clutch of eggs, resulting in reductions in fertilization success at high and low sperm concentrations. These findings suggest that female traits that increase the likelihood of sperm-egg interactions (e.g. egg size) will respond to selection imposed by egg competition.     

Sperm Swimming Velocity Predicts Competitive Fertilization Success in the Green Swordtail Xiphophorus helleri

Sperm competition is expected to favour the evolution of traits that influence the performance of sperm when they compete to fertilize a female''s eggs. While there is considerable evidence that selection favours increases in sperm numbers, much less is known about how sperm quality contributes towards competitive fertilization success. Here, we determine whether variation in sperm quality influences competitive fertilization success in the green swordtail Xiphophorus helleri, a highly promiscuous livebearing fish. We use artificial insemination as a method of controlled sperm delivery and show that sperm swimming velocity is the primary determinant of fertilization success when ejaculates from two males compete to fertilize a female''s eggs. By contrast, we found no evidence that sperm length had any effect on siring success. We also found no evidence that pre- and postcopulatory sexual traits were phenotypically integrated in this species, suggesting that the previous observation that reproductive skew favours males with high mating rates is unlikely to be due to any direct association between sperm quality and male sexual ornamentation.     

Comparison of sperm velocity, motility and fertilizing ability between firstly and secondly activated spermatozoa of common carp (Cyprinus carpio)

The objective of the study was to compare carp sperm motility performances (sperm velocity and motility rates) from 10 males including fertilizing ability (hatching rates from 10 males and eight females) as a function of time elapsed after sperm exposure to activation medium in two situations: firstly activated sperm and sperm which had terminated swimming and was ‘re‐activated’ after incubation in a K⁺ rich (200 mm KCl) non‐swimming solution. In case of both initial (first) and secondly activated spermatozoa, the motility was triggered in hatchery solution (HAS, 11.2 mOsmol) and in carp activation solution (CAS, 128.9 mOsmol) containing 45 mm NaCl, 5 mm KCl, 30 mm Tris–HCl while also adjusted to a pH of 8.0. First time activated sperm showed significantly higher relative motility, sperm velocity and fertilizing ability compared to re‐activated sperm. The carp spermatozoa (in either first or second activation) rapidly lost their fertilizing ability as a function of exposure time of sperm to diluents prior to addition to eggs: this shows that spermatozoa must be in contact with eggs as soon as their motility is triggered. When sperm was firstly activated in CAS and also activated a second time in CAS (labeled CASCAS) the hatching rate was significantly higher at egg contact after 10, 20, 30, and 120 s of activation. Also at 20 s after the second activation of the sperm higher sperm motility was observed compared to the first activation. This study showed that incubation of spermatozoa in a K⁺‐rich incubation medium can mitigate the affects of structural damages occurring in re‐activated sperm, which may help spermatozoa to increase their motility and fertilization. To our knowledge, the results presented in this study document for the first time that fertilization can be achieved with sperm re‐activated a second time while being exposed to a incubation medium that permits ATP reloading within the flagellum. Previous studies have show the potential for recovery of motility, however, the effect on possible fertilization is hitherto unknown. It critical outcome of the study clearly indicated the need for avoiding the use of different, subsequent activation media (e.g. first and second activation) but only on the same medium for both steps (see above CASCAS).     

CRYPTIC CHOICE OF CONSPECIFIC SPERM CONTROLLED BY THE IMPACT OF OVARIAN FLUID ON SPERM SWIMMING BEHAVIOR

Despite evidence that variation in male–female reproductive compatibility exists in many fertilization systems, identifying mechanisms of cryptic female choice at the gamete level has been a challenge. Here, under risks of genetic incompatibility through hybridization, we show how salmon and trout eggs promote fertilization by conspecific sperm. Using in vitro fertilization experiments that replicate the gametic microenvironment, we find complete interfertility between both species. However, if either species’ ova were presented with equivalent numbers of both sperm types, conspecific sperm gained fertilization precedence. Surprisingly, the species’ identity of the eggs did not explain this cryptic female choice, which instead was primarily controlled by conspecific ovarian fluid, a semiviscous, protein‐rich solution that bathes the eggs and is released at spawning. Video analyses revealed that ovarian fluid doubled sperm motile life span and straightened swimming trajectory, behaviors allowing chemoattraction up a concentration gradient. To confirm chemoattraction, cell migration tests through membranes containing pores that approximated to the egg micropyle showed that conspecific ovarian fluid attracted many more spermatozoa through the membrane, compared with heterospecific fluid or water. These combined findings together identify how cryptic female choice can evolve at the gamete level and promote reproductive isolation, mediated by a specific chemoattractive influence of ovarian fluid on sperm swimming behavior.     

Influence of sperm density and contact time on herring egg fertilization

In order to standardize fish egg incubation techniques for bioassay application, fertilization procedures need to be included into the protocols. Nothing is known about the necessary sperm concentrations required to achieve optimal fertilization rates. The tests described here for the herring Clupea harengus L. include trials with 10 different sperm densities and 4 contact times (15, 30, 60 and 120 seconds). The variability of fertilization rates in eggs from different females was also investigated. Fertilization success was mainly influenced by sperm density and less by the actual contact time between unfertilized eggs and sperm containingmedia. Dilution in sperm density to 9.6 × 10⁶ cells ml^-1 or less resulted in reduced fertilization success. There was considerable variability in fertilization rates between females.     

Assessing the potential for egg chemoattractants to mediate sexual selection in a broadcast spawning marine invertebrate

In numerous species, egg chemoattractants play a critical role in guiding sperm towards unfertilized eggs (sperm chemotaxis). Until now, the known functions of sperm chemotaxis include increasing the effective target size of eggs, thereby promoting sperm-egg encounters, and facilitating species recognition. Here, we report that in the broadcast spawning mussel, Mytilus galloprovincialis, egg chemoattractants may play an unforeseen role in sexual selection by enabling sperm to effectively 'choose' between the eggs of different conspecific females. In an initial experiment, we confirmed that sperm chemotaxis occurs in M. galloprovincialis by showing that sperm are attracted towards unfertilized eggs when given the choice of eggs or no eggs in a dichotomous chamber. We then conducted two cross-classified mating experiments, each comprising the same individual males and females crossed in identical male × female combinations, but under experimental conditions that offered sperm 'no-choice' (each fertilization trial took place in a Petri dish and involved a single male and female) or a 'choice' of a female's eggs (sperm were placed in the centre of a dichotomous choice chamber and allowed to choose eggs from different females). We show that male-by-female interactions characterized fertilization rates in both experiments, and that there was remarkable consistency between patterns of sperm migration in the egg-choice experiment and fertilization rates in the no-choice experiment. Thus, sperm appear to exploit chemical cues to preferentially swim towards eggs with which they are most compatible during direct sperm-to-egg encounters. These results reveal that sperm differentially select eggs on the basis of chemical cues, thus exposing the potential for egg chemoattractants to mediate mate choice for genetically compatible partners. Given the prevalence of sperm chemotaxis across diverse taxa, our findings may have broad implications for sexual selection in other mating systems.     

Changes in intracellular content of glutathione and thiols associated with gamma-glutamyl cycle during sperm penetration and pronuclear formation in rat oocytes

The content of glutathione and other thiols in rat eggs was examined during sperm penetration and pronuclear formation by high-performance liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection. Reduced glutathione (GSH) content was higher in unfertilized oocytes (8.50 +/- 0.29 pmol/egg) and penetrated eggs with a decondensed sperm nucleus (DSH eggs; 7.72 +/- 0.56 pmol/egg) than eggs at the pronuclear stage (PN eggs; 5.93 +/- 0.10 pmol/egg). The content of oxidised glutathione (GSSG) was not different among experimental groups (152.6 +/- 74.1 nmol/egg in unfertilized eggs, 146.0 +/- 50.0 nmol/egg in DSH eggs and 39.7 +/- 17.3 nmol/egg in PN eggs). The GSSG/GSH ratio did not change during fertilization. Although the reduced cysteinylglycine content of eggs did not change among experimental groups, the oxidised form of cysteinylglycine increased (p < 0.025) between sperm decondensation (6.9 +/- 1.5 nmol/egg in unfertilized oocytes and 10.1 +/- 2.1 nmol/egg in DSH eggs) and pronuclear formation (40.5 +/- 11.5 nmol/egg in PN eggs). Low contents of cystine were detected during fertilization but cysteine and gamma-glutamylcysteine were not detected in any treatment groups. These results demonstrate that GSH content in rat eggs decreases between sperm decondensation and pronuclear formation, probably due to the increased activity of gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase.     

Post-thawed motility and fertility from Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) sperm frozen with four cryodiluents in straws or pellets

The cryopreservation of salmonid sperm is a complex process involving the interplay of many factors. Although cryopreservation protocols can be evaluated through a range of responses at various stages in the process, the number of progeny is the ultimate indicator of success. We compared reproductive success from freezing Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) sperm using the eight combinations of (1) the penetrating cryoprotectants, 10% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or methanol (MeOH); (2) the nonpenetrating cryoprotectants glucose (0.3 M) or sucrose (0.6 M), and freezing in 0.1 mL pellets or 0.25 mL straws. All cryodiluents were supplemented with 10% (v/v) of hen's egg yolk. Response variables were the percentage and degree of motility of thawed and activated sperm using computer assisted sperm analysis (CASA), and rates of eyed embryos, hatch and egg sac larvae. Growth rates of alevins were assessed to two months post hatch. Atlantic salmon milt cryopreserved in straws had higher spermatozoa motility and fertilization success than milt cryopreserved in pellets (P < 0.05). Type of sugar tested did not significantly affect the response variables. In the MeOH treatment, thawed spermatozoa achieved higher speed and a higher fertilization rate evaluated at the eyed embryo stage than spermatozoa subjected to the DMSO treatment. Higher mortality rate (especially before hatching) of MeOH offspring than DMSO offspring led to equal numbers of progeny for the two treatments from the swimming stage to the end of the study. Moreover, during feeding fish from the MeOH group produced significantly lower weight larvae than the DMSO and control groups. Even so, the weight of the MeOH group was satisfactory. Length and the condition factors did not differ significantly among the larvae groups. Significant positive correlations were found between fertilization success (measured in number of eyed eggs) and both motility (rs = 0.81), and velocity (rs = 0.49). Freezing in straws gave betters results than freezing in pellets for cryopreservation of salmon milt; whereas type of sugar tested (glucose vs sucrose) did not have significant effects. Penetrating cryoprotectants DMSO and MeOH differed in their effect on post-thawed sperm velocity, fertilization rate and mortality rate of progeny, suggesting the need for further research on the influence of these cryoprotectants on frozen sperm and and post-fertilization devopmental processes.