Natural cytotoxicity against mouse hepatitis virus-infected cells. II. A cytotoxic effector cell with a B lymphocyte phenotype

The effector cell in mouse spleen which mediates natural cytotoxicity against mouse hepatitis virus (MHV)-infected target cells was characterized. The target cells were MHV-infected BALB/c 3T3, and the assay time was 3 hr. The effector cell, designated virus killer (VK) cell for the purpose of discussion, had the following phenotype: lymphocyte morphology, plastic-nonadherent, nylon wool-adherent, nonphagocytic, cyclophosphamide-sensitive; by antibody plus complement (C) depletion studies, it was asialo GM1-, NK 1.2 alloantigen-negative, Thy-1.2-, Lyt-5-, and macrophage antigen-negative; by rosetting techniques, it was Fc receptor-positive and surface Fab+; by flow cytometry (FACS) analysis, it was Lyt-2-, MAC-1-, Ia+, IgG (gamma)+, IgM (mu)+, IgD (delta)+, and B cell lineage antibody B-220+. NK cells, measured for cytotoxicity on YAC-1 cells, were similarly tested and were found to differ from the VK cell in the following properties: nylon wool-nonadherent, asialo GM1+, NK alloantigen-positive, Lyt-5+, surface Fab-, MAC-1+, Ia-, IgG-, IgM-, IgD-, and B-220-. The VK effector cell had a phenotype highly distinguishable from NK cells, effectors most commonly associated with antiviral natural cytotoxicity. The VK cell had a phenotype identical to that of a B lymphocyte and was identified as such. Although the effector cells displayed cell surface antibody, the antibody did not appear to be involved in lysis, because lysis could not be blocked by F(ab)'2 directed against Fab, mu, or delta. Cytotoxicity was more likely associated with recognition of the B lymphocyte surface by the MHV glycoprotein E2, as shown in the accompanying companion paper. This is the first demonstration that natural cytotoxicity can be mediated by B lymphocytes.     

Human lymphocyte cytotoxicity against mumps virus-infected target cells. Requirement for non-T cells.

Subpopulations of human lymphocytes were tested for their capacity to kill mumps virus-infected target cells in a 51-chromium release asaay. Using two different cell fractionation techniques, lymphocytes were fractionated into T cell-enriched (primarily T cells) and T cell-depleted (primarily B cells) subpopulations. Filtration of lymphocytes through columns coated with human immunoglobulin and rabbit anti-human-immunoglobulin (Ig-anti-Ig) rendered the resulting T-cell preparation inactive as effector cells against target cells carrying mumps virus antigens. In the second technique, lymphocytes were fractionated by centrifugation into two fractions according to their ability to form spontaneous rosettes with sheep erythrocytes (E). The E-rosette-forming population (primarily T cells) was shown to lack cytotoxic activity against mumps virus-infected target cells. This activity was present in the nonrosetting population. The results suggest that the effector cells involved in this cytotoxic system are of a non-T variety.     

Murine antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity to herpes simplex virus-infected target cells.

Freshly collected peritoneal cells (PC) and cultured spleen cells (SC) (but not fresh SC) from nonimmune mice could mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against herpes simplex virus (HSV)-infected cells in the presence of mouse or human sera containing antibody to HSV. PC also demonstrated variable natural killer cell cytotoxicity to infected cells. Both PC and cultured SC required high concentrations of antibody and high effector to target cell ratios for optimal ADCC. The time kinetics of the reaction appeared to depend on the state of activation of the effector cells. In both PC and SC populations, ADCC activity was limited to adherent cells, and was profoundly inhibited by particulate latex or silica. The murine effector cell found in PC and SC able to mediate ADCC to HSV-infected cells appears to be a macrophage.     

Cell-mediated cytotoxicity against virus-infected target cells in humans. II. Interferon induction and activation of natural killer cells.

The mechanisms by which human lymphocytes lyse virus-infected allogeneic fibroblast cultures were analyzed with particular consideration of the role of anti-viral antibodies and interferon. Human cells infected with viruses were able to induce high levels of interferon upon contact with human lymphocytes. Interferon, whether produced by lymphocytes after direct infection with virus or induced upon exposure of lymphocytes to virus-infected fibroblasts, appeared to be responsible for enhancing the cytotoxic efficiency of the natural killer cell against the infected target. Activation of cytotoxic lymphocytes occurred as early as 6 hr after addition of interferon and increased up to 24 hr. Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (Ab-CMC) could be easily induced by sensitization of infected target cells with antiviral antibodies and could be detected at 4 hr from the beginning of the cytotoxic test, before the effect of interferon on the natural killer cell was evident. However, the antibody-dependent effector cell was inactive after 4 hr of incubation. F(ab')2 fragments of rabbit anti-human IgG completely inhibited Ab-CMC but did not at all affect the spontaneous cytotoxic activity of the effector cells against virus-infected target.     

Lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity to cells infected with measles virus: I. Use of in vitro infected leukocytes as autologous target cells; absence of virus-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes

We investigated lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity in humans to autologous cells infected with measles virus. Mononuclear leukocytes, isolated from peripheral blood, were stimulated by phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and infected with measles virus. At 72 hr after infection, about 80% of the cells could be lysed by antibodies against measles virus and human complement, which meant that at that time the expression of virus-specific antigens on the cell surface was maximal. Such PHA-stimulated, infected leukocytes were used as target cells in an assay for lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity. Effector lymphocytes were obtained from the same donor who had provided the target cells, and were tested for their cytotoxicity directly after isolation.Lymphocytes obtained from adult humans, with a history of natural measles infection contracted during childhood, were not found to be cytotoxic to autologous infected cells, unless antibodies against measles virus were present during the assay. The same response, though to a lesser extent, was observed with cord blood lymphocytes obtained from healthy neonates. This indicates that the observed cytotoxicity does not reflect acquired cellular immunity but rather antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC).     

The mononuclear cell in human blood which mediates antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity to virus-infected target cells. I. Identification of the population of effector cells.

Mononuclear cells (MC) from human blood were fractionated by a variety of physical and immunologic techniques, and the cellular subpopulations generated were assessed for their capacity to lyse herpes simplex virus (HSV)-infected target cells in the presence of IgG antibody to HSV. Latex phagocytosis and surface marker studies were performed in parallel in order to identify the major effector cells by their phagocytic properties and their possession of surface immunoglobulin and receptors for either sheep erythrocytes, C3, or the Fc fragment of IgG. Cytotoxic effector cell activity was unaffected or slightly enhanced after the removal of plastic-adherent or carbonyl iron-adherent MC, indicating that the major effector cell is not a classical monocyte. Similar results were obtained after removal of more than 90% of the T cells by depletion of rosette-forming cells. Likewise, effector cell activity was generally unchanged when more than 95% of the B cells were removed by filtering MC on nylon wool columns. Effector cell function was also found to be normal in three patients with B cell-deficient X-linked agammaglobulinemia. These observations strongly suggest that the effector cells are not T cells or B cells. A 4- to 5-fold enrichment in effector cells, however, was consistently found in a subpopulation, consisting of 5% of the unfractionated MC, that was dramatically enriched both for nonphagocytic cells with only Fc receptor (K cells) and for nonphagocytic cells with no detectable surface markers (null cells). Since, as is demonstrated in the accompanying report, effector surface Fc receptors play a critical role in the mediation of antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity directed at HSV-infected target cells, the major mononuclear effector cell in human blood is a K cell.     

Antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity to virus-infected target cells: role of nylon wool-adherent T cells as effectors

This study was designed to elucidate whether populations of human blood lymphocytes other than non-T, non-B, Fc receptor-positive K cells can mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against target cells acutely infected with type 1 herpes simplex virus. With appropriate technical precautions, a subset of E rosette-positive, nylon wool-adherent T cells were found to be effective in killing antibody-coated target cells. Thus, there appears to be at least two relatively distinct populations of lymphocytes in human peripheral blood that function as effectors in ADCC: one that consists of E rosette-negative cells, the other of E rosette-positive cells. These findings suggest a possible relationship between “classical” E rosette-negative K cells and E rosette-positive T cells.     

Human monocyte-macrophage-mediated antibody-dependent cytotoxicity to herpes simplex virus-infected cells.

Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells which mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against herpes simplex virus- (HSV) infected target cells consist of both adherent (MA) and nonadherent (MNA) effector cell populations. These two cell populations can be distinguished by their different phagocytic properties and morphologic appearance, their requirement for antibody in the ADCC reaction, and the rapidity with which they lyse target cells in the presence of immune serum. The MA cells are predominantly phagocytic and have the morphologic characteristics of monocyte-macrophages, whereas the MNA cells are nonphagocytic and appear to be small to medium-sized lymphocytes. Optimal expression of ADCC by MA cells requires higher concentrations of immune serum than does MNA cell-mediated ADCC. MA-mediated cell killing is first detectable by 8 hr and reaches completion after 24 hr of incubation. In contrast, MNA-mediated ADCC produces target cell damage by 2 hr and reaches completion at 8 hr of incubation. Unlike MNA effector cells, the MA effector cells are profoundly inhibited after preincubation with either latex or silica particles. The HSV immune status of the donor had no effect on the ability of either cell population to mediate ADCC. These data demonstrate the participation of both nonadherent mononuclear cells, presumably K cells, and monocyte-macrophages, in ADCC directed against HSV-infected target cells.     

Genetic resistance to mouse hepatitis virus correlates with absence of virus-binding activity on target tissues.

The molecular mechanism of genetic resistance of inbred mouse strains to mouse hepatitis virus, a murine coronavirus, was studied by comparing virus binding to plasma membranes of intestinal epithelium or liver from susceptible BALB/c and resistant SJL/J mice with a new solid-phase assay for virus-binding activity. Virus bound to isolated membranes from susceptible mice, but not to membranes from resistant mice. F1 progeny of SJL/J X BALB/c mice had an intermediate level of virus-binding activity on their enterocyte and hepatocyte membranes. This correlated well with previous studies showing that susceptibility to mouse hepatitis virus strain A59 is controlled by a single autosomal dominant gene (M. S. Smith, R. E. Click, and P. G. W. Plagemann, J. Immunol. 133:428-432). Because virus binding was not prevented by treating membranes with sodium dodecyl sulfate, the virus-binding molecule could be identified by a virus overlay protein blot assay. Virus bound to a single broad band of Mr 100,000 to 110,000 in membranes from hepatocytes or enterocytes of susceptible BALB/c and semisusceptible C3H mice, but no virus-binding band was detected in comparable preparations of resistant SJL/J mouse membranes. Therefore, SJL/J mice may be resistant to mouse hepatitis virus A59 infection because they lack a specific virus receptor which is present on the plasma membranes of target cells from genetically susceptible BALB/c and semisusceptible C3H mice.     

Demonstration of binding of dengue virus envelope protein to target cells.

The nature of the initial interaction of dengue virus with target cells and the extent to which this interaction defines tropism are unknown. Infection of some cells may involve antidengue antibody-mediated immune adherence to cells bearing immunoglobulin Fc receptors; however, this mechanism does not explain primary infection or the infection of cells without Fc receptors. We hypothesized that dengue virus envelope protein mediates initial binding to target cells. To test this hypothesis, a recombinant chimeric form of dengue type 2 virus envelope protein was used as a probe to investigate binding to the surfaces of potential target cells. Envelope protein was expressed amino terminal to the heavy-chain constant region of human immunoglobulin G containing the Fc receptor binding motif; the binding mediated by envelope determinants was distinguishable from the binding mediated by immunoglobulin Fc determinants. We found that the recombinant chimera bound to Vero, CHO, endothelial, and glial cells through envelope protein determinants and to monocytes and U937 cells by Fc-Fc receptor interactions. The highest level of binding was to Vero cells; binding was dose and time dependent and saturable. Examination of partial-length recombinant envelope proteins indicated that the binding motif was expressed between amino acids 281 and 423. Recombinant envelope protein inhibited infection of Vero cells by dengue virus, indicating the functional significance of the interaction of envelope protein and target cells in infectivity. These results suggest that envelope protein binding to a non-Fc receptor could explain the cell and tissue tropism of primary dengue virus infection.     

IgM and IgG response to sheep red blood cells in mouse hepatitis virus-infected nude mice.

In nude mice which originally had no ability to respond to sheep red blood cells, an enhanced response to the same antigen with IgM-IgG switching was demonstrated during subacute infection with mouse hepatitis virus. IgM antibody-producing cells in the spleen were detected at days 2 to 6 after the antigen injection and IgG antibody-producing cells appeared at day 6 or later. The secondary IgG response, though not remarkable, was recognized after reinjection of the antigen 10 days after the first injection.     

Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity to target cells infected with type 1 and type 2 herpes simplex virus.

The phenomenon of antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytoxicity (ADCC) has been extended to include target cells acutely infected with herpes simplex type 1 virus (HSV-1) or herpes simplex type 2 virus (HSV-2) in an in vitro system that employs immune human serum and human blood mononuclear cells. The cytotoxic reaction was detectable after 1 hr of incubation and was complete between 4 and 8 hr. The amount of ADCC noted was directly proportional to the logarithm(10) of the effector: target cell ratio (E:T), and ADCC was noted at E:T as low as 1:1. The mononuclear effector cell was present in the blood of both HSV immune and non-immune individuals. The immune serum factor was demonstrated to be an antibody with specificity for HSV membrane antigen(s) and was reactive with target cells infected with either of the two HSV types. The antibody rendered the mononuclear cell cytotoxic by sensitization of the target cell rather than by direct attachment to or "arming" of the mononuclear cell. The physiochemical properties of the antibody as well as its presence in cord blood demonstrated that it is an immunoglobulin on the IgG class.     

Reduced antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity to herpes simplex virus-infected cells of salivary polymorphonuclear leukocytes and inhibition of peripheral blood polymorphonuclear leukocyte cytotoxicity by saliva

Blood polymorphonuclear leukocytes (BPMN) have been shown to mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against HSV-infected cells. Although HSV infections are frequently found in the oral cavity, the ADCC capacity of salivary PMN (SPMN) has not been studied, mainly because methods to isolate SPMN were not available. We have recently developed a method to isolate SPMN, and in this study have evaluated their ADCC activity against HSV-infected cells. SPMN were obtained by repeated washings of the oral cavity, and separated from epithelial cells by nylon mesh filtration. ADCC was quantitatively determined by 51Cr release from HSV-infected Chang liver cells. SPMN in the presence of antibody were able to destroy HSV-infected cells, but SPMN were much less effective in mediating ADCC than BPMN (3.4% vs 40.7%, p less than 0.0001). In the presence of antiviral antibody, SPMN were able to adhere to HSV-infected cells, but less so than BPMN (34% vs 67%), and specific antibody-induced adherence was significantly lower in SPMN (p less than 0.04). The spontaneous adherence to HSV-infected cells was higher for SPMN than BPMN. SPMN demonstrated up-regulation of the adhesion glycoprotein CD18, but down-regulation of the FcRIII receptor. Incubation with saliva decreased ADCC capacity of BPMN, up-regulated CD18 expression, and down-regulated FcRIII expression.     

Fc receptors on mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells.

Mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells have been previously thought to be lymphocytes that lack any detectable cell surface markers. The present study presents evidence for receptors for the Fc portion of IgG on these cells. By adsorption of cytotoxic spleen cells on monolayers of sheep erythrocytes (E) plus IgG antibodies to sheep erythrocytes (EA), 50 to 96% of the total cytotoxic reactivity could be removed. Parallel adsorption of cells on E monolayers or on EA monolayers coated with protein A, to block the Fc portion of IgG, resulted in little or no depletion of cytotoxic activity. The presence of Fc receptors on the NK cells was confirmed by combining EA rosette formation with velocity sedimentation at unit gravity. Peak cytotoxicity occurred at the same sedimentation velocity as the peak of Fc-positive cells. After EA rosette formation, there was a shift to a higher sedimentation velocity in the Fc-positive cells and in the natural cytotoxic activity. The increase in sedimentation velocity of NK activity that was observed in these experiments indicated that most of the cells had only bound a small number (three or four) of antibody-coated erythrocytes. Together, these data indicate that cells with Fc receptors account for most of the total lytic activity of normal mouse spleen cells.     

Human monocyte cytotoxicity to tumor cells. I. Antibody-dependent cytotoxicity.

Recent investigations examining mononuclear cell antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity against tumor cell lines suggest that K lymphocytes and not monocytes are active in this cytotoxic reaction. We have found, however, that in an allogeneic assay system, human monocyte monolayers as well as lymphocytes mediate substantial lysis of 51Cr-labeled antibody-coated CEM lymphoblast tumor cells. This cytotoxicity is temperature-dependent and rapid, with most 51Cr release occurring in the first 4 hr of co-incubation. Interaction between target cell-bound antibody and the monocyte Fc receptor is necessary as demonstrated by the marked fall in antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) produced by staphylococcal protein A, high concentrations of nonspecific immunoglobulin, and dilution of the target cell antiserum. Morphologic and functional characteristics of the monocyte-monolayer preparations establish their relative purity (greater than 95%) and indicate that monocytes and not contaminating lymphocytes are responsible for tumor cell lysis. Furthermore, preincubation of monocyte and lymphocyte preparations with latex particles or low concentrations of immunoglobulin distinguished monocyte from lymphocyte ADCC. Thus, normal human monocytes have the capacity to carry out antibody-dependent cytotoxicity against nucleated malignant target cells.     

Lysis of virus-infected target cells by antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. I. General requirements of the reaction and temporal relationship between lethal hits and cytolysis.

The effect of various physical and chemical parameters on the cytotoxic reaction was studied in a ⁵¹Cr-release assay in order to analyze the mechanism by which human blood mononuclear cells (MC) damage antibody-sensitized target cells infected with herpes simplex virus. Centrifugation of the target cell-MC mixture consistently increased the velocity of the reaction. In addition, uncentrifuged target cell-MC cultures showed a sigmoidal kinetic curve of ⁵¹Cr release with an initial lag phase of at least 10 min, whereas ⁵¹Cr release in centrifuged cultures followed a linear pattern with time without an initial lag. These findings indicate that direct contact between target and effector cells is necessary for cytotoxicity to occur. The reaction as a whole was temperature dependent, proceeding well at 37 °C and not at all at 4 °C. Incubation of the MC at 46 °C for 10 min abolished their cytotoxic potential without affecting their viability; similar heating of the target cells did not affect their background isotope release or sensitivity to the lytic process. Heating target cell-MC mixtures at 46 °C for 10 min thus provided a tool by which the temporal relationship between the mounting of “lethal hits” and specific isotope release, or cell lysis, could be studied. Using this technique, we observed virtually simultaneous occurrence of lethal hits and cell lysis, measured at various intervals between 10 and 360 min postincubation. Likewise, we were unable to demonstrate a transient period of increased osmotic fragility in target cells after contact with MC but before actual cell lysis. Taken together, these findings imply either that cell lysis, as indicated by ⁵¹Cr release, results from a sudden nonosmotic injury to the target cell membrane or, alternatively, osmotic damage leading to ⁵¹Cr release occurs too rapidly to be detected by the methods employed in this study. These findings imply either a qualitative or a quantitative difference between antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) mediated by K cells and cytotoxicity mediated by sensitized T cells.The cytotoxic reaction was completely inhibited by 10 mM EDTA and did not occur in a Ca²⁺- and Mg²⁺-free medium. Neither Ca²⁺ nor Mg²⁺ alone produced as much cytotoxicity as the two cations in tandem; in addition, when added to the culture medium in suboptimal amounts, the two cations were either additive or synergistic. These observations suggest that both cations are necessary in ADCC and also that there may be separate Ca²⁺- and Mg²⁺-dependent events in the lytic pathway.     

Pathogenesis of mouse hepatitis virus infection. The role of nasal epithelial cells as a primary target of low-virulence virus, MHV-S.

The pathogenesis of mouse hepatitis virus (MHV-S) infection in suckling and weanling mice was comparatively studied after intranasal inoculation. In sucklings, infectious virus as well as specific antigen was first detected in the nasal mucosa at 12 hr, then in the nerve cells of the olfactory bulbs. At this stage viral particles were demonstrated both in the supporting cells and olfactory cells of the nasal mucosa. In the posterior part of the brain and spinal cord, virus was detected on days 3 to 4 postinoculation when viral growth was clearly demonstrable in the liver, spleen and intestines. In weanlings too, infection was first established in the nasal mucosa, shedding infectious virus in the nasal washing until day 6 postinoculation, and later infection spread to the brain and spinal cord. In weanling mice, however, neither infectious virus nor viral antigen was detected in the liver or other visceral organs, while serum neutralizing antibody became detectable on day 5 postinoculation, increasing in titer thereafter. Histopathologically degenerative and necrotic changes were observed in the nasal mucosa and central nervous system of both age groups of animals coincidentally with the presence of viral specific antigen, while inflammatory response was much less prominent in sucklings. In the liver, spleen and intestines, however, some lesions were observed only in sucklings.