Disentangling CO2 fluxes: direct measurements of mesocosm‐scale natural abundance 13CO2/12CO2 gas exchange, 13C discrimination,and labelling of CO2 exchange flux components in controlled environments

A ¹³C/¹²C mass spectrometer was interfaced with a open gas exchange system including four growth chambers to investigate CO₂ exchange components of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) stands. Chambers were fed with air containing CO₂ with known δ¹³C (δ_CΟ2?2.6 or ?46.8‰). The system did not fractionate C isotopes and no extraneous CO₂ leaked into chambers. The on‐line ¹³C discrimination (Δ) of ryegrass stands in light was independent of δ_CΟ2 when δ_CΟ2 was constant. The δ of CO₂ exchanged by the stands in light (δ_Nd) and darkness (δ_Rn) differed by 0.7‰, suggesting some Δ in dark respiration at the stand‐level. However, Δ decreased by ～ 10‰ when δ_CΟ2 was switched from ?46.8 to ?2.5‰, and increased by ～ 10‰ following a shift from ?2.6 to ?46.7‰ due to isotopic disequilibria between photosynthetic and respiratory fluxes. Isotopic imbalances were used to assess (non‐photorespiratory) respiration in light and the replacement of the respiratory substrate pool(s) by new photosynthate. Respiration was partially inhibited by light, but increased during the light period and decreased in darkness, in association with temperature changes. The labelling kinetics of respiratory CO₂ indicated the existence of two major respiratory substrate pools: a fast pool which was exchanged within hours, and a slow pool accounting for ～ 60% of total respiration and having a mean residence time of 3.6 d.     

Carbon mobilization in shoot parts and roots of wheat during grain filling: assessment by 13C/12C steady-state labelling, growth analysis and balance sheets of reserves

cv, cultivar
δ, deviation of C isotope composition from a standard
Δ, C isotope discrimination
WSC, water soluble carbohydrates

Steady-state labelling of all post-anthesis photosynthate of wheat was performed to assess the mobilization of pre-anthesis C (C fixed prior to anthesis) in vegetative plant parts during grain filling. Results were compared with estimates obtained by indirect approaches to mobilization of pre-anthesis C: ‘classical’ growth analysis and balance sheets of water soluble carbohydrates (WSC) and protein. Experiments were performed with two spring wheat cultivars grown with differential nitrogen fertilizer supply in 1991 and 1992. The fraction of pre-anthesis C mobilized in above-ground vegetative biomass ranged between 24 and 34% of total C present at anthesis. Treatment effects on mobilization of pre-anthesis C in total above-ground vegetative biomass were closely related (r² = 0·89) to effects on mobilization of WSC-C plus protein-C (estimated as N mobilized × 3·15). On average, 81% of pre-anthesis C mobilization was attributable to the balance of pre-anthesis WSC (48%) and protein (33%) between anthesis and maturity. In roots, WSC and protein mobilization accounted for only 29% of the loss of pre-anthesis C. Notably, mobilization of pre-anthesis C was 1·4–2·6 times larger than the net loss of C from above-ground vegetative biomass between anthesis and maturity. This discrepancy was mainly due to post-anthesis C accumulation in glumes and stem. Post-anthesis C accumulation was related to continued synthesis of structural biomass after anthesis and accounted for a mean 15% of total C contained in above-ground vegetative plant parts at maturity. A close correspondence between net loss of C and mobilization of pre-anthesis C was only apparent in leaf blades and leaf sheaths. Although balance sheets of WSC and protein also underrated the mobilization of pre-anthesis C by ≈ 19%, they gave a much better estimate of pre-anthesis C mobilization than growth analysis.     

Incomplete 13C labelling of α-pinene content of Quercus ilex leaves and appearance of unlabelled C in α-pinene emission in the dark

α ‐Pinene is formed in and emitted by Quercus ilex leaves. The carbon emitted as α ‐pinene is rapidly and totally labelled by ¹³C in CO₂ in air, but α ‐pinene contained in the leaf shows a fraction of completely unlabelled carbon even after long exposures to air containing only ¹³CO₂. When the labelled leaf is darkened, α ‐pinene emission drops but is still measurable for about 10 h, and carbon becomes partially unlabelled. After an 11 h darkening the α ‐pinene content is still as high as in the light but the carbon is mostly unlabelled. If the leaf is re‐illuminated but photosynthesis is inhibited by removing CO₂ and lowering O₂, a burst of emission occurs and the content of α ‐pinene is depleted. Our experiments suggest that a pool of α ‐pinene which is not directly generated by photosynthesis intermediates exists. Since this pool does not contribute relevantly to the emission in the light, we hypothesize that it is inhibited in the light and spatially located in a different compartment from chloroplasts. As we discuss, glycolysis in the cytoplasm and leucine catabolism in the mitochondria are both possible extra‐chloroplasts sources of carbon for isoprenoids.     

Genetic parameters and QTL analysis of δ13C and ring width in maritime pine

Classical quantitative genetics and quantitative trait dissection analysis (QTL) approaches were used in order to investigate the genetic determinism of wood cellulose carbon isotope composition (δ¹³C, a time integrated estimate of water use efficiency) and of diameter growth and their relationship on adult trees (15 years) of a forest tree species (maritime pine). A half diallel experimental set‐up was used to (1) estimate heritabilities for δ¹³C and ring width and (2) to decompose the phenotypic δ¹³C/growth correlation into its genetic and environmental components. Considerable variation was found for δ¹³C (range of over 3‰) and for ring width (range of over 5 mm) and significant heritabilities (narrow sense 0·17/0·19 for δ¹³C and ring width, respectively, 100% additivity). The significant phenotypic correlation between δ¹³C and ring width was not determined by the genetic component, but was attributable to environmental components. Using a genetic linkage map of a full‐sib family, four significant and four suggestive QTLs were detected for δ¹³C, the first for δ¹³C in a forest tree species, as far as known to the authors. Two significant and four suggestive QTLs were found for ring width. No co‐location of QTLs was found between δ¹³C and growth.     

13CO2/12CO2 exchange fluxes in a clamp‐on leaf cuvette: disentangling artefacts and flux components

Leaks and isotopic disequilibria represent potential errors and artefacts during combined measurements of gas exchange and carbon isotope discrimination (Δ). This paper presents new protocols to quantify, minimize, and correct such phenomena. We performed experiments with gradients of CO₂ concentration (up to ±250 μmol mol^?1) and δ¹³C_CO2 (34‰), between a clamp‐on leaf cuvette (LI‐6400) and surrounding air, to assess (1) leak coefficients for CO₂, ¹²CO₂, and ¹³CO₂ with the empty cuvette and with intact leaves of Holcus lanatus (C₃) or Sorghum bicolor (C₄) in the cuvette; and (2) isotopic disequilibria between net photosynthesis and dark respiration in light. Leak coefficients were virtually identical for ¹²CO₂ and ¹³CO₂, but ～8 times higher with leaves in the cuvette. Leaks generated errors on Δ up to 6‰ for H. lanatus and 2‰ for S. bicolor in full light; isotopic disequilibria produced similar variation of Δ. Leak errors in Δ in darkness were much larger due to small biological : leak flux ratios. Leak artefacts were fully corrected with leak coefficients determined on the same leaves as Δ measurements. Analysis of isotopic disequilibria enabled partitioning of net photosynthesis and dark respiration, and indicated inhibitions of dark respiration in full light (H. lanatus: 14%, S. bicolor: 58%).     

Estimating the contribution of leaf litter decomposition to soil CO2 efflux in a beech forest using 13C-depleted litter

The contribution of leaf litter decomposition to total soil CO₂ efflux (F_L/F) was evaluated in a beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) forest in eastern France. The Keeling‐plot approach was applied to estimate the isotopic composition of respired soil CO₂ from soil covered with either control (?30.32‰) or ¹³C‐depleted leaf litter (?49.96‰). The δ¹³C of respired soil CO₂ ranged from ?25.50‰ to ?22.60‰ and from ?24.95‰ to ?20.77‰, respectively, with depleted or control litter above the soil. The F_L/F ratio was calculated by a single isotope linear mixing model based on mass conservation equations. It showed seasonal variations, increasing from 2.8% in early spring to about 11.4% in mid summer, and decreasing to 4.2% just after leaf fall. Between December 2001 and December 2002, cumulated F and F_L reached 0.98 and 0.08 kg_C m^?2, respectively. On an annual basis, decomposition of fresh leaf litter accounted for 8% of soil respiration and 80% of total C loss from fresh leaf litter. The other fraction of carbon loss during leaf litter decomposition that is assumed to have entered the soil organic matter pool (i.e. 20%) represents only 0.02 kg_C m^?2.     

Atmospheric CO2 mole fraction affects stand‐scale carbon use efficiency of sunflower by stimulating respiration in light

Plant carbon‐use‐efficiency (CUE), a key parameter in carbon cycle and plant growth models, quantifies the fraction of fixed carbon that is converted into net primary production rather than respired. CUE has not been directly measured, partly because of the difficulty of measuring respiration in light. Here, we explore if CUE is affected by atmospheric CO₂. Sunflower stands were grown at low (200 μmol mol^?1) or high CO₂ (1000 μmol mol^?1) in controlled environment mesocosms. CUE of stands was measured by dynamic stand‐scale ¹³C labelling and partitioning of photosynthesis and respiration. At the same plant age, growth at high CO₂ (compared with low CO₂) led to 91% higher rates of apparent photosynthesis, 97% higher respiration in the dark, yet 143% higher respiration in light. Thus, CUE was significantly lower at high (0.65) than at low CO₂ (0.71). Compartmental analysis of isotopic tracer kinetics demonstrated a greater commitment of carbon reserves in stand‐scale respiratory metabolism at high CO₂. Two main processes contributed to the reduction of CUE at high CO₂: a reduced inhibition of leaf respiration by light and a diminished leaf mass ratio. This work highlights the relevance of measuring respiration in light and assessment of the CUE response to environment conditions.     

Evidence of changing intrinsic water‐use efficiency under rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations in Boreal Fennoscandia from subfossil leaves and tree ring δ13C ratios

Investigating the many internal feedbacks within the climate system is a vital component of the effort to quantify the full effects of future anthropogenic climate change. The stomatal apertures of plants tend to close and decrease in number under elevated CO₂ concentrations, increasing water‐use efficiency (WUE) and reducing canopy evapotranspiration. Experimental and modelling studies reveal huge variations in these changes such that the warming associated with reduced evapotranspiration (known as physiological forcing) is neither well understood or constrained. Palaeo‐observations of changes in stomatal response and plant WUE under rising CO₂ might be used to better understand the processes underlying the physiological forcing feedback and to link measured changes in plant WUE to a specific physiological change in stomata. Here we use time series of tree ring (Pinus sylvestris L.) δ¹³C and subfossil leaf (Betula nana L.) measurements of stomatal density and geometry to derive records of changes in intrinsic water‐use efficiency (iWUE) and maximum stomatal conductance in the Boreal zone of northern Finland and Sweden. We investigate the rate of change in both proxies, over the recent past. The independent lines of evidence from these two different Boreal species indicate increased iWUE and reduced maximum stomatal conductance of similar magnitude from preindustrial times (ca. ad 1850) to around ad 1970. After this maximum stomatal conductance continues to decrease to ad 2000 in B. nana but iWUE in P. sylvestris reaches a plateau. We suggest that northern boreal P. sylvestris might have reached a threshold in its ability to increase WUE as CO₂ rises.     

Acquisition and within-plant allocation of 13C and 15N in CO2-enriched Quercus robur plants

We assessed the effects of doubling atmospheric CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], on C and N allocation within pedunculate oak plants (Quercus robur L.) grown in containers under optimal water supply. A short-term dual ¹³CO₂ and ¹⁵NO₃^? labelling experiment was carried out when the plants had formed their third growing flush. The 22-week exposure to 700 μl l^?1 [CO₂] stimulated plant growth and biomass accumulation (+53% as compared with the 350 μl l^?1 [CO₂] treatment) but decreased the root/shoot biomass ratio (-23%) and specific leaf area (-18%). Moreover, there was an increase in net CO₂ assimilation rate (+37% on a leaf dry weight basis; +71% on a leaf area basis), and a decrease in both above- and below-ground CO₂ respiration rates (-32 and -26%, respectively, on a dry mass basis) under elevated [CO₂]. ¹³C acquisition, expressed on a plant mass basis or on a plant leaf area basis, was also markedly stimulated under elevated [CO₂] both after the 12-h ¹³CO₂ pulse phase and after the 60-h chase phase. Plant N content was increased under elevated CO₂ (+36%), but not enough to compensate for the increase in plant C content (+53%). Thus, the plant C/N ratio was increased (+13%) and plant N concentration was decreased (-11%). There was no effect of elevated [CO₂] on fine root-specific ¹⁵N uptake (amount of recently assimilated ¹⁵N per unit fine root dry mass), suggesting that modifications of plant N pools were merely linked to root size and not to root function. N concentration was decreased in the leaves of the first and second growing flushes and in the coarse roots, whereas it was unaffected by [CO₂] in the stem and in the actively growing organs (fine roots and leaves of the third growth flush). Furthermore, leaf N content per unit area was unaffected by [CO₂]. These results are consistent with the short-term optimization of N distribution within the plants with respect to growth and photosynthesis. Such an optimization might be achieved at the expense of the N pools in storage compartments (coarse roots, leaves of the first and second growth flushes). After the 60-h ¹³C chase phase, leaves of the first and second growth flushes were almost completely depleted in recent ¹³C under ambient [CO₂], whereas these leaves retained important amounts of recently assimilated ¹³C (carbohydrate reserves?) under elevated [CO₂].     

Predicting leaf wax n‐alkane 2H/1H ratios: controlled water source and humidity experiments with hydroponically grown trees confirm predictions of Craig–Gordon model

The extent to which both water source and atmospheric humidity affect δ²H values of terrestrial plant leaf waxes will affect the interpretations of δ²H variation of leaf waxes as a proxy for hydrological conditions. To elucidate the effects of these parameters, we conducted a long‐term experiment in which we grew two tree species, Populus fremontii and Betula occidentalis, hydroponically under combinations of six isotopically distinct waters and two different atmospheric humidities. We observed that leaf n‐alkane δ²H values of both species were linearly related to source water δ²H values, but with slope differences associated with differing humidities. When a modified version of the Craig–Gordon model incorporating plant factors was used to predict the δ²H values of leaf water, all modelled leaf water values fit the same linear relationship with n‐alkane δ²H values. These observations suggested a relatively constant biosynthetic fractionation factor between leaf water and n‐alkanes. However, our calculations indicated a small difference in the biosynthetic fractionation factor between the two species, consistent with small differences calculated for species in other studies. At present, it remains unclear if these apparent interspecies differences in biosynthetic fractionation reflect species‐specific biochemistry or a common biosynthetic fractionation factor with insufficient model parameterization.     

Changes in vegetation phenology are not reflected in atmospheric CO2 and 13C/12C seasonality

Northern terrestrial ecosystems have shown global warming‐induced advances in start, delays in end, and thus increased lengths of growing season and gross photosynthesis in recent decades. The tradeoffs between seasonal dynamics of two opposing fluxes, CO₂ uptake through photosynthesis and release through respiration, determine the influence of the terrestrial ecosystem on the atmospheric CO₂ and ¹³C/¹²C seasonality. Here, we use four CO₂ observation stations in the Northern Hemisphere, namely Alert, La Jolla, Point Barrow, and Mauna Loa Observatory, to determine how changes in vegetation productivity and phenology, respiration, and air temperature affect both the atmospheric CO₂ and ¹³C/¹²C seasonality. Since the 1960s, the only significant long‐term trend of CO₂ and ¹³C/¹²C seasonality was observed at the northern most station, Alert, where the spring CO₂ drawdown dates advanced by 0.65 ± 0.55 days yr^?1, contributing to a nonsignificant increase in length of the CO₂ uptake period (0.74 ± 0.67 days yr^?1). For Point Barrow station, vegetation phenology changes in well‐watered ecosystems such as the Canadian and western Siberian wetlands contributed the most to ¹³C/¹²C seasonality while the CO₂ seasonality was primarily linked to nontree vegetation. Our results indicate significant increase in the Northern Hemisphere soil respiration. This means, increased respiration of ¹³C depleted plant materials cancels out the ¹²C gain from enhanced vegetation activities during the start and end of growing season. These findings suggest therefore that parallel warming‐induced increases both in photosynthesis and respiration contribute to the long‐term stability of CO₂ and ¹³C/¹²C seasonality under changing climate and vegetation activity. The summer photosynthesis and the soil respiration in the dormant seasons have become more vigorous which lead to increased peak‐to‐through CO₂ amplitude. As the relative magnitude of the increased photosynthesis in summer months is more than the increased respiration in dormant months, we have the increased overall carbon uptake rates in the northern ecosystems.     

Beyond CO2-fixation by Rubisco – an interpretation of 13C/12C variations in tree rings from novel intra-seasonal studies on broad-leaf trees

Evidence is presented for a very specific, seasonally recurring tri‐phase carbon isotope pattern in tree rings of broad‐leaf deciduous tree species. It is derived from highly resolved intra‐annual measurements of ¹³C/¹²C ratios of wood and cellulose from tree rings of Fagus sylvatica, Populus nigra, Quercus petraea and Morus alba. Investigations on δ¹³C from buds and leaves of Fagus sylvatica revealed a similar tri‐phase δ¹³C pattern. At the very beginning of a growing season, the δ¹³C trend of tree rings and foliage shows a marked increase of up to 5‰. The maximum δ¹³C‐value of each vegetation period always occurs in young heterotrophic leaves shortly after bud burst and persistently in the early wood of each tree ring, when growth depends on carbon reserves. Thereafter, δ¹³C profiles represent the autotrophic stage of the leaves, which show different patterns of variation, by and large characterized by a decline. The minimum δ¹³C‐value always shows up in the late wood of each tree ring. At the very end of each tree ring δ¹³C‐values start rising again. This increase in δ¹³C marks the gradual switch‐over to storage‐dependent growth and can also be observed in senescent leaves. Seasonal changes of more than 4‰ were measured, whereas contiguous δ¹³C values rarely differed from each other by more than 0.3‰. This tri‐phase pattern cannot be explained by the common model of carbon isotope fractionation during photosynthesis. It appears to be primarily an indication of seasonal changes in down‐stream processes of the carbohydrate metabolism. Environmental influences on the carbon isotope fractionation during photosynthesis are presumably of secondary importance and expressed by certain peculiarities showing up during the autotrophic phase, i.e. the mid‐section of the seasonal δ¹³C pattern.     

Canopy-scale δ13C of photosynthetic and respiratory CO2 fluxes: observations in forest biomes across the United States

The δ¹³C values of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) can be used to partition global patterns of CO₂ source/sink relationships among terrestrial and oceanic ecosystems using the inversion technique. This approach is very sensitive to estimates of photosynthetic ¹³C discrimination by terrestrial vegetation (Δ_A), and depends on δ¹³C values of respired CO₂ fluxes (δ¹³C_R). Here we show that by combining two independent data streams – the stable isotope ratios of atmospheric CO₂ and eddy‐covariance CO₂ flux measurements – canopy scale estimates of Δ_A can be successfully derived in terrestrial ecosystems. We also present the first weekly dataset of seasonal variations in δ¹³C_R from dominant forest ecosystems in the United States between 2001 and 2003. Our observations indicate considerable summer‐time variation in the weekly value of δ¹³C_R within coniferous forests (4.0‰ and 5.4‰ at Wind River Canopy Crane Research Facility and Howland Forest, respectively, between May and September). The monthly mean values of δ¹³C_R showed a smaller range (2–3‰), which appeared to significantly correlate with soil water availability. Values of δ¹³C_R were less variable during the growing season at the deciduous forest (Harvard Forest). We suggest that the negative correlation between δ¹³C_R and soil moisture content observed in the two coniferous forests should represent a general ecosystem response to the changes in the distribution of water resources because of climate change. Shifts in δ¹³C_R and Δ_A could be of sufficient magnitude globally to impact partitioning calculations of CO₂ sinks between oceanic and terrestrial compartments.     

Pan-European δ13C values of air and organic matter from forest ecosystems

We present carbon stable isotope, δ¹³C, results from air and organic matter samples collected during 98 individual field campaigns across a network of Carboeuroflux forest sites in 2001 (14 sites) and 2002 (16 sites). Using these data, we tested the hypothesis that δ¹³C values derived from large‐scale atmospheric measurements and models, which are routinely used to partition carbon fluxes between land and ocean, and potentially between respiration and photosynthesis on land, are consistent with directly measured ecosystem‐scale δ¹³C values. In this framework, we also tested the potential of δ¹³C in canopy air and plant organic matter to record regional‐scale ecophysiological patterns. Our network estimates for the mean δ¹³C of ecosystem respired CO₂ and the related ‘discrimination’ of ecosystem respiration, δ_er and Δ_er, respectively, were ?25.6±1.9‰ and 17.8 ±2.0‰ in 2001 and ?26.6±1.5‰ and 19.0±1.6‰ in 2002. The results were in close agreement with δ¹³C values derived from regional‐scale atmospheric measurement programs for 2001, but less so in 2002, which had an unusual precipitation pattern. This suggests that regional‐scale atmospheric sampling programs generally capture ecosystem δ¹³C signals over Europe, but may be limited in capturing some of the interannual variations. In 2001, but less so in 2002, there were discernable longitudinal and seasonal trends in δ_er. From west to east, across the network, there was a general enrichment in ¹³C (～3‰ and ～1‰ for the 2 years, respectively) consistent with increasing Gorczynski continentality index for warmer and drier conditions. In 2001 only, seasonal ¹³C enrichment between July and September, followed by depletion in November (from about ?26.0‰ to ?24.5‰ to ?30.0‰), was also observed. In 2001, July and August δ_er values across the network were significantly related to average daytime vapor pressure deficit (VPD), relative humidity (RH), and, to a lesser degree, air temperature (T_a), but not significantly with monthly average precipitation (P_m). In contrast, in 2002 (a much wetter peak season), δ_er was significantly related with T_a, but not significantly with VPD and RH. The important role of plant physiological processes on δ_er in 2001 was emphasized by a relatively rapid turnover (between 1 and 6 days) of assimilated carbon inferred from time‐lag analyses of δ_er vs. meteorological parameters. However, this was not evident in 2002. These analyses also noted corresponding diurnal cycles of δ_er and meteorological parameters in 2001, indicating a rapid transmission of daytime meteorology, via physiological responses, to the δ_er signal during this season. Organic matter δ¹³C results showed progressive ¹³C enrichment from leaves, through stems and roots to soil organic matter, which may be explained by ¹³C fractionation during respiration. This enrichment was species dependent and was prominent in angiosperms but not in gymnosperms. δ¹³C values of organic matter of any of the plant components did not well represent short‐term δ_er values during the seasonal cycle, and could not be used to partition ecosystem respiration into autotrophic and heterotrophic components.     

Kinetics and relative significance of remobilized and current C and N incorporation in leaf and root growth zones of Lolium perenne after defoliation: assessment by 13C and 15N steady-state labelling

The contribution of pre-defoliation reserves and current assimilates to leaf and root growth was examined in Lolium perenne L. during regrowth after defoliation. Differential steady-state labelling with ¹³C (CO₂ with δ¹³C = -0.0281 and -0.0088) and ¹⁵N (NO₃^? with 1.0 and 0.368 atom percentage, i.e. δ¹⁵N = 1.742 and 0.0052, respectively) was applied for 2 weeks after defoliation. Rapidly growing tissues were isolated, i.e. the basal elongation and maturation zones of the most rapidly expanding leaves and young root tips, with a biomass turnover rate > 1 d^?1. C and N weights of the elongation zone showed a transient decline. The dry matter and C concentration in fresh biomass of leaf growth zones transiently decreased by up to 25% 2 d after defoliation, while the N concentration remained constant. This ‘dilution’ of growth zone C indicates a decreased net influx of carbohydrates relative to growth-related influx of water and N in expanding cells, immediately after defoliation. Recovery of the total C and N weights of the leaf elongation zone coincided with net incorporation of currently absorbed C and N, as shown by the kinetics of δ¹³C and atom percentage ¹⁵N in the growth zones after defoliation. C isotope discrimination (Δ¹³C) in leaf growth zones was about 23‰, 1–2‰ higher than the Δ in root tips. Δ¹⁵N in the leaf and root growth zones was 10±3‰. The leaf elongation zones (at 0–0.03 m from the tiller base) and the distant root tips (about 0.2 m from the base) exhibited similar kinetics of current C and N incorporation. The amount of pre-defoliation C and N in the growth zones, expressed as a fraction of total C and N, decreased from 1.0 to 0.5 at 3 (C) and 5 (N) d after defoliation, and to 0.1 at 5 (C) and 14 (N) d after defoliation. Thus, the dependence of growth zones on current assimilate supply was significant, and stronger for C than for N. The important roles of current assimilates (as compared to pre-defoliation reserves) and ‘dilution’ of dry matter in regrowth after defoliation are discussed in relation to the method of labelling and the functional and morphological heterogeneity of shoot tissues.