Cleavage of RNA by an amphiphilic compound lacking traditional catalytic groups

Recently, in experiments with combinatorial libraries of amphiphilic compounds lacking groups, known as catalysts of transesterification reaction, we discovered novel RNA-cleaving compounds [N. Kovalev, E. Burakova, V. Silnikov, M. Zenkova, V. Vlassov, Bioorg. Chem. 34 (2006) 274-286]. In the present study, we investigate cleavage of RNA by the most active representative of these libraries, compound named Dp12. Sequence-specificity of RNA cleavage and influence of reaction conditions on cleavage rate suggested that Dp12 enormously accelerates spontaneous RNA cleavage. Light scattering experiments revealed that the RNA cleavage proceeds within multiplexes formed by assembles of RNA and Dp12 molecules, at Dp12 concentration far below critical concentration of micelle formation. Under these conditions, Dp12 is presented in the solution as individual molecules, but addition of RNA to this solution triggers formation of the multiplexes. The obtained data suggest a possible mechanism of RNA cleavage, which includes interaction of the compound with RNA sugar-phosphate backbone resulting in changing of ribose conformation. This leads to juxtaposition of the 2′-hydroxyl group and internucleotide phosphorus atom at a distance needed for the transesterification to occur.     

'In-line attack' conformational effect plays a modest role in an enzyme-catalyzed RNA cleavage: a free energy simulation study

Since the proposal of ‘in-line attack’ conformation as a possibly important intermediate in RNA cleavage, its structure has been captured in various protein and RNA enzymes; these structures strengthen the belief that this conformation plays an essential role in the catalysis of RNA cleavage. As generally discussed, this intermediate structure can be involved in energy barrier reduction in two possible ways, e.g. through either conformational effect or electrostatic effect. In order to quantitatively elucidate the contribution of conformational effect in this type of enzyme catalysis, free energy simulations were performed on the RNA structures both in a splicing endonuclease complex and in the aqueous solution. Our free energy simulation results revealed that the ‘in-line attack’ conformational effect plays a modest role in facilitating the reaction rate enhancement (~12-fold) compared with the overall 10¹²-fold rate increase. The close agreement between the present computational estimation and an experimental measurement on the spontaneous RNA cleavage in an in vitro evolved ATP aptamer motives us to realize that the conformation distribution of an enzyme substrate prior to rather than after its binding determines the upper bound of the rate enhancement ability through the conformational strategy.     

Synthesis and hybridization data of oligonucleotide analogs with triazole internucleotide linkages, potential antiviral and antitumor agents

Triazolyl-functionalized oligonucleotide (ON) analogs have received much attention as potential antitumor and antiviral agents. The most promising of such analogs are those exhibiting high binding affinity toward native DNA/RNA, since they may prove to be efficient antisense or siRNA agents. To date, relatively few ON analogs with triazole internucleotide linkages have been described. In this paper, we report an improved synthesis of a modified dinucleoside phosphoramidite and hybridization data of ON analogs with four-bond triazole internucleotide linkages. We believe these data are essential for comprehensive analysis of the relation between the length of triazole internucleotide linkages and duplex stability.     

Stereoconfiguration markedly affects the biochemical and biological properties of phosphorothioate analogs of 2-5A core, (A2'p5')2A

The diester bonds of phosphorothioate trimer analogs of (A2'p5')2A (2-5A core) of the Sp stereoconfiguration were found to be extremely stable to hydrolysis by both serum and cellular phosphodiesterases. The corresponding Rp isomers, although still more stable than parent ppp(A2'p5')2A (2-5A), were significantly more susceptible to enzymatic hydrolysis than were the Sp isomers. Utilization of these novel 2-5A trimer isomers containing various combinations of Sp or Rp configurations at the internucleotidic phosphorothioate linkages revealed a further specificity of this enzymatic hydrolysis. Thus, the stereoconfiguration of the bond adjacent to the one undergoing hydrolysis influenced the rate of enzymatic hydrolysis, as well as did the chain length of the oligomer. The most stable trimer analog, which contained both internucleotide phosphorothioate linkages of the Sp configuration, had a half-life of 30 days in serum, which is a 1500-fold increase over that of parent 2-5A core. This is the first report on biochemical stability of an oligonucleotide containing more than one phosphorothioate linkage of the Sp configuration and is the first demonstration that a phosphorothioate internucleotide bond of the Sp configuration can increase the enzymatic stability of an adjacent phosphorothioate bond. In marked contrast to all previous 2-5A core analogs of increased stability, the activity (antiproliferative and antiviral) of the stable phosphorothioate 2-5A core analogs was obtained with the intact trimer, i.e., it was not attributed to antimetabolite degradation products.     

Site specific functionalization of oligonucleotides for attaching two different reporter groups.

The synthesis of an oligonucleotide functionalized to attach two different reporter groups at specific internucleotide linkages is described. To incorporate the amine specific reporter group the internucleotide linkage is modified to phosphoramidate (N-1-aminoalkyl) and for a thiol specific reporter group the internucleotide linkage is modified to a phosphorothioate diester. The synthetic cycle for introducing the modified internucleotide linkages at specific sites can be carried out using an automated DNA synthesizer. Combination of reporter groups have been attached successfully.     

E. coli RNase HI and the phosphonate-DNA/RNA hybrid: molecular dynamics simulations

A model for the complex between E. coli RNase HI and the DNA/RNA hybrid (previously refined by molecular dynamics simulations) was used to determine the impact of the internucleotide linkage modifications (either 3-O-CH2-P-O-5' or 3-O-P-CH2-O-5) on the ability of the modified-DNA/RNA hybrid to create a complex with the protein. Modified internucleotide linkages were incorporated systematically at different positions close to the 3-end of the DNA strand to interfere with the DNA binding site of RNase H. Altogether, six trajectories were produced (length 1.5ns). Mutual hydrogen bonds connecting both strands of the nucleic acids hybrid, DNA with RNase H, RNA with RNase H, and the scissile bond with the Mg++. 4H2O chelate complex (bound in the active site) were analyzed in detaiL Many residues were involved in binding of the DNA (Arg88, Asn84, Trp85, Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, Asn100, Thr43, and Asn 16) and RNA (Gln76, Gln72, Tyr73, Lys122, Glu48, Asn44, and Cys13) strand to the substrate-binding site of the RNase H enzyme. The most remarkable disturbance of the hydrogen bonding net was observed for structures with modified internucleotide linkages positioned in a way to interact with the Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, and Asn100 residues (situated in the middle of the DNA binding site, where a cluster of Trp residues forms a rigid core of the protein structure).     

Activation of human RNase L by 2'- and 5'-O-methylphosphonate-modified oligoadenylates

To determine the influence of internucleotide linkage and sugar ring conformation, and the role of 5'-terminal phosphate, on the activation of human RNase L, a series of 2'- and 5'-O-methylphosphonate-modified tetramers were synthesized from appropriate monomeric units and evaluated for their ability to activate human RNase L. Tetramers pAAAp(c)X modified by ribo, arabino or xylo 5'-phosphonate unit p(c)X activated RNase L with efficiency comparable to that of natural activator. Moreover, incorporation of phosphonate linkages ensured the stability against cleavage by nucleases. The substitution of 5'-terminal phosphate for 5'-terminal phosphonate in tetramer p(c)XAAA afforded tetramers with excellent activation efficiency and with complete stability against cleavage by phosphomonoesterases.     

Interactions of oligonucleotide analogs containing methylphosphonate internucleotide linkages and 2'-O-methylribonucleosides.

The interactions of oligonucleotide analogs, 12-mers, which contain deoxyribo- or 2'-O-methylribose sugars and methylphosphonate internucleotide linkages with complementary 12-mer DNA and RNA targets and the effect of chirality of the methylphosphonate linkage on oligomer-target interactions was studied. Oligomers containing a single Rp or Sp methylphosphonate linkage (type 1) or oligomers containing a single phosphodiester linkage at the 5'-end followed by 10 contiguous methylphosphonate linkages of random chirality (type 2) were prepared. The deoxyribo- and 2'-O-methylribo- type 1 12-mers formed stable duplexes with both the RNA and DNA as determined by UV melting experiments. The melting temperatures, Tms, of the 2'-O-methylribo-12-mer/RNA duplexes (49-53 degrees C) were higher than those of the deoxyribo-12mer/RNA duplexes (31-36 degrees C). The Tms of the duplexes formed by the Rp isomers of these oligomers were approximately 3-5 degrees C higher than those formed by the corresponding Sp isomers. The deoxyribo type 2 12-mer formed a stable duplex, Tm 34 degrees C, with the DNA target and a much less stable duplex with the RNA target, Tm < 5 degrees C. In contrast, the 2'-O-methylribo type 2 12-mer formed a stable duplex with the RNA target, Tm 20 degrees C, and a duplex of lower stability with the DNA target, Tm < 5 degrees C. These results show that the previously observed greater stability of oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleotide/RNA duplexes versus oligodeoxyribonucleotide/RNA duplexes extends to oligomers containing methylphosphonate linkages and that the configuration of the methylphosphonate linkage strongly influences the stability of the duplexes.     

Chemical and enzymatic properties of bridging 5'-S-phosphorothioester linkages in DNA.

We describe physicochemical and enzymatic properties of 5' bridging phosphorothioester linkages at specific sites in DNA oligonucleotides. The susceptibility to hydrolysis at various pH values is examined and no measurable hydrolysis is observed at pH 5-9 after 4 days at 25 degrees C. The abilities of three 3'- and 5'-exonuclease enzymes to hydrolyze the DNA past this linkage are examined and it is found that the linkage causes significant pauses at the sulfur linkage for T4 DNA polymerase and calf spleen phosphodiesterase, but not for snake venom phosphodiesterase. Restriction endonuclease (Nsi I) cleavage is also attempted at a 5'-thioester junction and strong resistance to cleavage is observed. Also tested is the ability of polymerase enzymes to utilize templates containing single 5'-S-thioester linkages; both Klenow DNA polymerase and T7 RNA polymerase are found to synthesize complementary strands successfully without any apparent pause at the sulfur linkage. Finally, the thermal stabilities of duplexes containing such linkages are measured; results show that T m values are lowered by a small amount (2 degrees C) when one or two thioester linkages are present in an otherwise unmodified duplex. The chemical stability and surprisingly small perturbation by the 5' bridging sulfur make it a good candidate as a physical and mechanistic probe for specific protein or metal interactions involving this position in DNA.     

E. COLI RNASE HI AND THE PHOSPHONATE-DNA/RNA HYBRID: MOLECULAR DYNAMICS SIMULATIONS

A model for the complex between E. coli RNase HI and the DNA/RNA hybrid (previously refined by molecular dynamics simulations) was used to determine the impact of the internucleotide linkage modifications (either 3′–O–CH₂–P–O–5′ or 3′–O–P–CH₂–O–5′) on the ability of the modified-DNA/RNA hybrid to create a complex with the protein. Modified internucleotide linkages were incorporated systematically at different positions close to the 3′-end of the DNA strand to interfere with the DNA binding site of RNase H. Altogether, six trajectories were produced (length 1.5). Mutual hydrogen bonds connecting both strands of the nucleic acids hybrid, DNA with RNase H, RNA with RNase H, and the scissile bond with the Mg⁺⁺ · 4H₂O chelate complex (bound in the active site) were analyzed in detail. Many residues were involved in binding of the DNA (Arg88, Asn84, Trp85, Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, Asn100, Thr43, and Asn16) and RNA (Gln76, Gln72, Tyr73, Lys122, Glu48, Asn44, and Cys13) strand to the substrate-binding site of the RNase H enzyme. The most remarkable disturbance of the hydrogen bonding net was observed for structures with modified internucleotide linkages positioned in a way to interact with the Trp104, Tyr73, Lys99, and Asn100 residues (situated in the middle of the DNA binding site, where a cluster of Trp residues forms a rigid core of the protein structure).     

Characterization of a local folding event of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme: effects of oligonucleotide substrate length, pH, and temperature on the two substrate binding steps

Binding of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme's oligonucleotide substrate occurs in two steps: P1 duplex formation with the ribozyme's internal guide sequence which forms an "open complex" is followed by docking of the P1 duplex into tertiary interactions within the catalytic core which forms a "closed complex". By systematically varying substrate length, pH, and temperature, we have identified conditions under which P1 duplex formation, P1 docking, or the chemical cleavage step limits the rate of the ribozyme reaction. This has enabled characterization of the individual steps as a function of substrate length, pH, and temperature, leading to several conclusions. (1) The rate constant for formation of the open complex is largely independent of substrate length, pH, and temperature, analogous to that of duplex formation in solution. This extends previous results suggesting that open complex formation entails mainly secondary structure formation and strengthens the view that the second binding step, P1 docking, represents a simple transition from secondary to tertiary structure in the context of an otherwise folded RNA. (2) The temperature dependence of the rate constant for P1 docking yields a negative activation entropy, in contrast to the positive entropy change previously observed for the docking equilibrium. This suggests a model in which tertiary interactions are not substantially formed in the transition state for P1 docking. (3) Shortening the substrate by three residues decreases the equilibrium constant for P1 docking by 200-fold, suggesting that the rigidity imposed by full-length duplex formation facilitates formation of tertiary interactions. (4) Once docked, shortened substrates are cleaved at rates within 3-fold of that for the full-length substrate. Thus, all the active site interactions required to accelerate the chemical cleavage event are maintained with shorter substrates. (5) The rate constant of approximately 10(3) min(-1) obtained for P1 docking is significantly faster than the other steps previously identified in the tertiary folding of this RNA. Nevertheless, P1 docking presumably follows other tertiary folding steps because the P1 duplex docks into a core that is formed only upon folding of the rest of the ribozyme.     

Long-range tertiary interactions in single hammerhead ribozymes bias motional sampling toward catalytically active conformations

Enzymes generally are thought to derive their functional activity from conformational motions. The limited chemical variation in RNA suggests that such structural dynamics may play a particularly important role in RNA function. Minimal hammerhead ribozymes are known to cleave efficiently only in ～ 10-fold higher than physiologic concentrations of Mg(2+) ions. Extended versions containing native loop-loop interactions, however, show greatly enhanced catalytic activity at physiologically relevant Mg(2+) concentrations, for reasons that are still ill-understood. Here, we use Mg(2+) titrations, activity assays, ensemble, and single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) approaches, combined with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, to ask what influence the spatially distant tertiary loop-loop interactions of an extended hammerhead ribozyme have on its structural dynamics. By comparing hammerhead variants with wild-type, partially disrupted, and fully disrupted loop-loop interaction sequences we find that the tertiary interactions lead to a dynamic motional sampling that increasingly populates catalytically active conformations. At the global level the wild-type tertiary interactions lead to more frequent, if transient, encounters of the loop-carrying stems, whereas at the local level they lead to an enrichment in favorable in-line attack angles at the cleavage site. These results invoke a linkage between RNA structural dynamics and function and suggest that loop-loop interactions in extended hammerhead ribozymes-and Mg(2+) ions that bind to minimal ribozymes-may generally allow more frequent access to a catalytically relevant conformation(s), rather than simply locking the ribozyme into a single active state.     

X-ray crystallographic observation of "in-line" and "adjacent" conformations in a bulged self-cleaving RNA/DNA hybrid

The RNA strand in an RNA/DNA duplex with unpaired ribonucleotides can undergo self-cleavage at bulge sites in the presence of a variety of divalent metal ions (Hüsken et al., Biochemistry, 1996, 35:16591-16600). Transesterification proceeds via an in-line mechanism, with the 2'-OH of the bulged nucleotide attacking the 3'-adjacent phosphate group. The site-specificity of the reaction is most likely a consequence of the greater local conformational freedom of the RNA backbone in the bulge region. A standard A-form backbone geometry prohibits formation of an in-line arrangement between 2'-oxygen and phosphate. However, the backbone in the region of an unpaired nucleotide appears to be conducive to an in-line approach. Therefore, the bulge-mediated phosphoryl transfer reaction represents one of the simplest RNA self-cleavage systems. Here we focus on the conformational features of the RNA that underlie site-specific cleavage. The structures of an RNA/DNA duplex with single ribo-adenosyl bulges were analyzed in two crystal forms, permitting observation of 10 individual conformations of the RNA bulge moiety. The bulge geometries cover a range of relative arrangements between the 2'-oxygen of the bulged nucleotide and the P-O5' bond (including adjacent and near in-line) and give a detailed picture of the conformational changes necessary to line up the 2'-OH nucleophile and scissile bond. Although metal ions are of crucial importance in the catalysis of analogous cleavage reactions by ribozymes, it is clear that local strain or conformational flexibility in the RNA also affect cleavage selectivity and rate (Soukup & Breaker, RNA, 1999, 5:1308-1325). The geometries of the RNA bulges frozen out in the crystals provide snapshots along the reaction pathway prior to the transition state of the phosphoryl transfer reaction.     

Cleavage properties of an oligonucleotide containing a bridged internucleotide 5'-phosphorothioate RNA linkage.

An oligonucleotide has been synthesized that contains a single bridging 5'-phosphorothioate at an RNA linkage (5'-ApCpGpGpTpCpTprCpsApCpGpApGpC-3'). This new phosphodiester linkage is found to be particularly susceptible to cleavage when compared with the corresponding oxo, deoxy and thiodeoxy derivatives. Divalent metal cations were observed to dramatically increase the cleavage rate. The products of the cleavage under a variety of conditions are a 5'-thiol-containing fragment (6mer) and a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate-containing fragment (8mer). The pseudo-first order rate constant, kobs, for cleavage at pH 7.5 (50 mM Tris-HCI) in the presence of 5 mM EDTA is 1.5 x 10(-4)/min. In the presence of 5 mM metal dichloride and 50 mM Tris-HCI, pH 7.5, the relative cleavage rate enhancements are 10, 24, 71, 98, 370 and 3400 for Mg2+, Ca2+, Mn2+, Co2+, Zn2+ and Cd2+ respectively. The rate enhancements correlate well with Pearson's HSAB principle, suggesting that cleavage is mediated in part by coordination of the metal to the 5'-mercapto leaving group. RNA linkages containing bridging 5'-phosphorothioates should prove valuable for studying the mechanistic details of a variety of RNA cleaving agents, such as ribozymes.     

Direct structural analysis of modified RNA by fluorescent in-line probing

Chemical probing is a common method for the structural characterization of RNA. Typically, RNA is radioactively end-labelled, subjected to probing conditions, and the cleavage fragment pattern is analysed by gel electrophoresis. In recent years, many chemical modifications, like fluorophores, were introduced into RNA, but methods are lacking that detect the influence of the modification on the RNA structure with single-nucleotide resolution. Here, we first demonstrate that a 5'-terminal (32)P label can be replaced by a dye label for in-line probing of riboswitch RNAs. Next, we show that small, highly structured FRET-labelled Diels-Alderase ribozymes can be directly probed, using the internal or terminal FRET dyes as reporters. The probing patterns indeed reveal whether or not the attachment of the dyes influences the structure. The existence of two dye labels in typical FRET constructs is found to be beneficial, as 'duplexing' allows observation of the complete RNA on a single gel. Structural information can be derived from the probing gels by deconvolution of the superimposed band patterns. Finally, we use fluorescent in-line probing to experimentally validate the structural consequences of photocaging, unambiguously demonstrating the intentional destruction of selected elements of secondary or tertiary structure.     

Hammerhead cleavage of the phosphorodithioate linkage

Under standard reaction conditions, a hammerhead ribozyme with a phosphorodithioate linkage at the cleavage site cleaved to the expected products with a rate about 500-fold slower than the corresponding phosphodiester linkage. When the greater stability of the dithioate linkage to nonenzymatic nucleophilic attack is taken into account, the hammerhead is remarkably effective at cleaving the dithioate linkage considering that the R(P)-phosphoromonothioate linkage is virtually inactive. On the basis of experiments determining the Mg(2+) concentration dependence of the cleavage rate and the stimulation of cleavage by thiophilic Cd(2+) ion, the lesser catalytic rate enhancement of the dithioate linkage is primarily due to the loss of a single Mg(2+) ion bound near the cleavage site. These results are qualitatively similar to, but quantitatively different from, similar experiments examining the hammerhead cleavage properties of the R(P)-phosphoromonothioate linkage. The dithioate linkage thus promises to be a valuable alternative phosphate analogue to the monothioate linkage in studying the mechanisms of RNA catalysis.