Effect of different acetate:propionate ratios on the methanogenic community during thermophilic anaerobic digestion in batch experiments

The present study investigated the metabolism of different acetate:propionate ratios (0.25, 0.33, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0) in equimolar carbon concentration during an anaerobic decomposition process under defined laboratory conditions and evaluated the engaged methanogenic community. Significant differences on a metabolic level (gas production, gas composition, volatile fatty acid (VFA) concentration) were observed between acetate:propionate ratios ≤1 and ≥2. Generally ratios ≥2 resulted in a faster methane production and VFA decomposition compared to ratios ≤1. Regarding the composition of the methanogenic community as well as the abundance of Methanosarcinales these differences were not reflected in an appropriate manner when DNA based methods (dHPLC and qPCR) were applied. However, by a culture based approach these differences could be documented showing a significant difference in the number of cultivable methanogens between initial acetate:propionate ratios ≤1 and ≥2.     

Contribution of 13C-NMR spectroscopy to the elucidation of pathways of propionate formation and degradation in methanogenic environments

Propionate is an important intermediate in the anaerobic degradation of complex organic matter to methane and carbon dioxide. The metabolism of propionate-forming and propionate-degrading bacteria is reviewed here. Propionate is formed during fermentation of polysaccharides, proteins and fats. The study of the fate of 13C-labelled compounds by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has contributed together with other techniques to the present knowledge of the metabolic routes which lead to propionate formation from these substrates. Since propionate oxidation under methanogenic conditions is thermodynamically difficult, propionate often accumulates when the rates of its formation and degradation are unbalanced. Bacteria which are able to degrade propionate to the methanogenic substrates acetate and hydrogen can only perform this reaction when the methanogens consume acetate and hydrogen efficiently. As a consequence, propionate can only be degraded by obligatory syntrophic consortia of microorganisms. NMR techniques were used to study the degradation of propionate by defined and less defined cultures of these syntrophic consortia. Different types of side-reactions were reported, like the reductive carboxylation to butyrate and the reductive acetylation to higher fatty acids.     

Relationship between Methanogenic Cofactor Content and Maximum Specific Methanogenic Activity of Anaerobic Granular Sludges

In this study we investigated whether a relationship exists between the methanogenic activity and the content of specific methanogenic cofactors of granular sludges cultured on different combinations of volatile fatty acids in upflow anaerobic sludge blanket or fluidized-bed reactors. Significant correlations were measured in both cases between the contents of coenzyme F₄₂₀−2 or methanopterin and the maximum specific methanogenic activities on propionate, butyrate, and hydrogen, but not acetate. For both sludges the content of sarcinapterin appeared to be correlated with methanogenic activities on propionate, butyrate, and acetate, but not hydrogen. Similar correlations were measured with regard to the total content of coenzyme F₄₂₀−4 and F₄₂₀−5 in sludges from fluidized-bed reactors. The results indicate that the contents of specific methanogenic cofactors measured in anaerobic granular sludges can be used to estimate the hydrogenotrophic or acetotrophic methanogenic potential of these sludges.     

Isolation of propionate degrading bacterium in co-culture with a methanogen from a cattle dung biogas plant

Various anaerobic hydrolytic and methanogenic bacteria active in cattle dung biogas plants are reported in the literature. Anaerobic bacteria with ability to use volatile fatty acids constitute a vital bridge between hydrolytic bacteria and methanogenic bacteria. The present paper describes the isolation ofSyntrophobacter wolinii a propionate degrading bacterium in co-culture with a hydrogen utilizing methanogenviz.,Methanobacterium formicicum from the fermenting slurry of cattle dung biogas plant. Earlier studies on propionate and butyrate degradation indicatedMethanospirillum hungatei as the hydrogen utilizing partner of the co-culture whereas in the present studies this was not the case. Temperature 35° C, pH 7.5 and 20 mM of propionate were found optimal for growth and activity of co-culture.     

Methanogenic Decomposition of Ferulic Acid, a Model Lignin Derivative

Ferulic acid, a model lignin derivative, was observed to be biodegradable to methane and carbon dioxide under strict anaerobic conditions. This conversion appears to be carried out by a consortium of bacteria similar to that previously described for the methanogenic degradation of benzoic acid. A temporary buildup of acetate in these cultures indicates that it is a likely intermediate and precursor for methane formation. An analog of coenzyme M, 2-bromoethanesulfonic acid (BESA), inhibited gas production and enhanced the buildup of propionate, butyrate, isobutyrate, and isovalerate. Phenylacetate, cinnamate, 3-phenylpropionate, benzoate, cyclohexane carboxylate, adipate, and pimelate were also detected in BESA-inhibited cultures. A pathway is proposed which includes these various acids as possible intermediates in the methanogenic degradation of ferulic acid. This model overlaps previously described benzoic acid degradation pathways, suggesting that this type of anaerobic degradation may be common for aromatic compounds.     

典型煤层水微生物产甲烷潜力及其群落结构研究

内蒙古自治区二连盆地、海拉尔盆地是我国重要的煤层气产区,其中生物成因煤层气是煤层气的重要来源,但复杂物质转化产甲烷相关微生物群落结构及功能尚不清楚。【目的】研究煤层水中的微生物代谢挥发性脂肪酸产甲烷的生理特征及群落特征。【方法】以内蒙古自治区二连盆地和海拉尔盆地的四口煤层气井水作为接种物,分别添加乙酸钠、丙酸钠和丁酸钠厌氧培养;定期监测挥发性脂肪酸降解过程中甲烷和底物的变化趋势,应用高通量测序技术,分析原始煤层气井水及稳定期产甲烷菌液的微生物群落结构。【结果】除海拉尔盆地H303煤层气井微生物不能代谢丙酸外,其他样品均具备代谢乙酸、丙酸和丁酸产生甲烷的能力,其生理生态参数存在显著差异,产甲烷延滞期依次是乙酸<丁酸<丙酸;最大比产甲烷速率和底物转化效率依次是丙酸<乙酸<丁酸。富集培养后,古菌群落结构与煤层气井水的来源显著相关,二连盆地优势古菌为氢营养型产甲烷古菌Methanocalculus (相对丰度13.5%–63.4%)和复合营养型产甲烷古菌Methanosarcina (7.9%–51.3%),海拉尔盆地的优势古菌为氢营养型产甲烷古菌Methanobact...     

Effects of acetate, propionate, and butyrate on the thermophilic anaerobic degradation of propionate by methanogenic sludge and defined cultures.

The effects of acetate, propionate, and butyrate on the anaerobic thermophilic conversion of propionate by methanogenic sludge and by enriched propionate-oxidizing bacteria in syntrophy with Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum delta H were studied. The methanogenic sludge was cultivated in an upflow anaerobic sludge bed (UASB) reactor fed with propionate (35 mM) as the sole substrate for a period of 80 days. Propionate degradation was shown to be severely inhibited by the addition of 50 mM acetate to the influent of the UASB reactor. The inhibitory effect remained even when the acetate concentration in the effluent was below the level of detection. Recovery of propionate oxidation occurred only when acetate was omitted from the influent medium. Propionate degradation by the methanogenic sludge in the UASB reactor was not affected by the addition of an equimolar concentration (35 mM) of butyrate to the influent. However, butyrate had a strong inhibitory effect on the growth of the propionate-oxidizing enrichment culture. In that case, the conversion of propionate was almost completely inhibited at a butyrate concentration of 10 mM. However, addition of a butyrate-oxidizing enrichment culture abolished the inhibitory effect, and propionate oxidation was even stimulated. All experiments were conducted at pH 7.0 to 7.7. The thermophilic syntrophic culture showed a sensitivity to acetate and propionate similar to that of mesophilic cultures described in the literature. Additions of butyrate or acetate to the propionate medium had no effect on the hydrogen partial pressure in the biogas of an UASB reactor, nor was the hydrogen partial pressure in propionate-degrading cultures affected by the two acids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Relative importance of trophic group concentrations during anaerobic degradation of volatile fatty acids

Although obligate syntrophic reactions cannot proceed without hydrogenotrophs, it has been unclear from the literature whether potential improvements are achievable with higher concentrations of hydrogenotrophs. In this study, the relative importance of formate-/H(2)-utilizing and acetate-utilizing trophic groups in the anaerobic degradation of butyrate and propionate was assessed by adding various proportions of these enriched cultures to a mixed anaerobic seed inoculum. The improvement resulting from the additional acetate-utilizing cultures was much greater than with formate/H(2) utilizers. Furthermore, formate/H(2) utilizers did not improve propionate utilization significantly, suggesting the importance of optimum utilization of hydrogenotrophic capacity. During most of the volatile fatty acid (VFA) degradation period, the system responded with characteristic hydrogen levels to maintain the Gibbs free energy of oxidation approximately constant for both butyrate (-6 kJ) and propionate (-14 kJ). These free-energy values were independent of methanogenic activity, as well as the volume of the seed inoculum and the VFA concentrations present. By comparing the experimental results with kinetic and mass transfer models, it was postulated that the diffusional transfer of reducing equivalents was the major limiting factor for efficient VFA degradation. Therefore, for optimum utilization of the hydrogenotrophs, low acetate concentrations are vital to enable the system to respond with higher formate/H(2) levels, thus leading to improved transfer of reducing equivalents. Due to the small number of propionate utilizers (and hence their limited surface area) and low bulk liquid concentrations, the additional formate/H(2) utilizers were of minimal use for improving the degradation rate further. The butyrate degradation rates strongly correlated with the cumulative activity of hydrogenotrophs and acetotrophs over the experimental range studied, indicating the need to model obligate syntrophic reactions as a dependent function of methanogenic activity.     

Fermentation pattern of methanogenic degradation of rice straw in anoxic paddy soil

The anaerobic degradation of different fractions of rice straw in anoxic paddy soil was investigated. Rice straw was divided up into stem, leaf sheath and leaf blade. The different straw fractions were mixed with paddy soil and incubated under anoxic conditions. Fermentation of straw components started immediately and resulted in transient accumulation of acetate, propionate, butyrate, isobutyrate, valerate, isovalerate and caproate with much higher concentrations in the presence than in the absence of straw. Also some unidentified compounds with UV absorption could be detected. The maximum concentrations of these compounds were different when using different straw fractions, suggesting differences in the degradation pathway of these straw fractions during the early phase of incubation, i.e. with Fe(III) and sulfate serving as oxidants. When concentrations of the intermediates decreased to background values, CH(4) production started. Rates of CH(4)unamended soil. During the methanogenic phase, the percentage contribution of fermentation products to CH(4) production was determined by inhibition with 2-bromoethanesulfonate (BES). Acetate (48-83%) and propionate (18-28%) were found to be the main intermediates of the carbon flow to CH(4), irrespective of the fraction of the rice straw or its absence. Mass balance calculations showed that 84-89% of CH(4) was formed via acetate in the various incubations. Radiotracer experiments showed that 11-27% of CH(4) was formed from H(2)/CO(2), thus confirming that acetate contributed 73-89% to methanogenesis. Our results show that the addition of rice straw and the fraction of the straw affected the fermentation pattern only in the early phase of degradation, but had no effect on the degradation pathway during the later methanogenic phase.     

High-rate anaerobic treatment of wastewater at low temperatures

Anaerobic treatment of a volatile fatty acid (VFA) mixture was investigated under psychrophilic (3 to 8 degrees C) conditions in two laboratory-scale expanded granular sludge bed reactor stages in series. The reactor system was seeded with mesophilic methanogenic granular sludge and fed with a mixture of VFAs. Good removal of fatty acids was achieved in the two-stage system. Relative high levels of propionate were present in the effluent of the first stage, but propionate was efficiently removed in the second stage, where a low hydrogen partial pressure and a low acetate concentration were advantageous for propionate oxidation. The specific VFA-degrading activities of the sludge in each of the modules doubled during system operation for 150 days, indicating a good enrichment of methanogens and proton-reducing acetogenic bacteria at such low temperatures. The specific degradation rates of butyrate, propionate, and the VFA mixture amounted to 0.139, 0.110, and 0.214 g of chemical oxygen demand g of volatile suspended solids-1 day-1, respectively. The biomass which was obtained after 1.5 years still had a temperature optimum of between 30 and 40 degrees C.     

Energetics of syntrophic fatty acid oxidation

Abstract: Fatty acids are key intermediates in methanogenic degradation of organic matter in sediments as well as in anaerobic reactors. Conversion of butyrate or propionate to acetate, (CO₂), and hydrogen is endergonic under standard conditions, and becomes possible only at low hydrogen concentrations (10^-4-10^-5 bar). A model of energy sharing between fermenting and methanogenic bacteria attributes a maximum amount of about 20 kJ per mol reaction to each partner in this syntrophic cooperation system. This amount corresponds to synthesis of only a fraction (one-third) of an ATP to be synthesized per reaction. Recent studies on the biochemistry of syntrophic fatty acid-oxidizing bacteria have revealed that hydrogen release from butyrate by these bacteria is inhibited by a protonophore or the ATPase inhibitor DCCD ( N , N '-dicyclohexyl carbodiimide), indicating that a reversed electron transport step is involved in butyrate or propionate oxidation. Hydrogenase, butyryl-CoA dehydrogenase, and succinate dehydrogenase acitivities were found to be partially associated with the cytoplasmic membrane fraction. Also glycolic acid is degraded to methane and CO₂ by a defined syntrophic coculture. Here the most difficult step for hydrogen release is the glycolate dehydrogenase reaction ( E '₀=−92 mV). Glycolate dehydrogenase, hydrogenase, and ATPase were found to be membrane-bound enzymes. Membrane vesicles produced hydrogen from glycolate only in the presence of ATP; protonophores and DCCD inhibited this hydrogen release. This system provides a suitable model to study reversed electron transport in interspecies hydrogen transfer between fermenting and methanogenic bacteria in methanogenic biomass degradation.     

Anaerobic biodegradation ofPara-cresol under three reducing conditions

The anaerobic degradation ofp-cresol was studied with one sediment source under three reducing conditions—denitrifying, sulfidogenic, and methanogenic. Loss ofp-cresol (1 mM) in all the anaerobic systems took initially 3 to 4 weeks. In acclimated culturesp-cresol was degraded in less than a week.p-Cresol was completely metabolized under denitrifying, sulfidogenic, and methanogenic conditions, with formation of nitrogen gas, loss of sulfate, and formation of methane and carbon dioxide, respectively.p-Cresol metabolism proceeded throughp-hydroxybenzal-dehyde andp-hydroxybenzoate under denitrifying and methanogenic conditions. These compounds were rapidly degraded in cultures acclimated top-cresol under all three reducing conditions. These results suggest that the initial pathway ofp-cresol degradation is the same under denitryfying, sulfidogenic, and methanogenic conditions and proceeds via oxidation of the methyl substituent top-hydroxybenzaldehyde andp-hydroxybenzoate. The initial rate ofp-hydroxybenzaldehyde degradation was high in both the unacclimated cultures and in the cultures acclimated top-cresol, suggesting that this step is nonspecific. Benzoate was additionally detected as a metabolite followingp-hydroxybenzoate in the methanogenic cultures, but not in the denitrifying or sulfidogenic cultures. The degradation pathway therefore may diverge afterp-hydroxybenzoate formation depending on which electron acceptor is available.     

Influence of waste water composition on biofilm development in laboratory methanogenic fluidized bed reactors

Summary The influence of the volatile fatty acid composition of waste waters on biofilm development and on the time course of reactor start-up was investigated in laboratory scale fluidized bed reactors. It was found that biofilm development proceeded in a similar way with either acetate, butyrate, propionate or a mixture of these compounds as carbon source in the waste water. Startup was retarded, however, with propionate as sole carbon source. Scanning electron microscopic examination revealed that immobilization of bacteria on the sand used as adhesive support initially occurred in crevices and that thereupon the surface of the sand particles became colonized. The composition of the newly developed biomass was determined when reactors reached steady state. Significant differences in the relative substrate spectra and in the amounts of hydrogenotrophic and acetotrophic methanogenic bacteria were measured. The differences reflected the differences in the composition of the waste waters. The results obtained emphasize the role of the structure of the carrier surface in start-up of methanogenic fluidized bed reactors.Abbreviations used Aw ash weight - COD chemical oxygen demand - EB fluidized bed - hbi vitamin B₁₂-HBI - spt sarcinapterin - UASB upflow anaerobic sludge blanket - VFA volatile fatty acid - VSS volatile suspended solids - Ww wet weight     

Relative Importance of Trophic Group Concentrations during Anaerobic Degradation of Volatile Fatty Acids

Although obligate syntrophic reactions cannot proceed without hydrogenotrophs, it has been unclear from the literature whether potential improvements are achievable with higher concentrations of hydrogenotrophs. In this study, the relative importance of formate-/H₂-utilizing and acetate-utilizing trophic groups in the anaerobic degradation of butyrate and propionate was assessed by adding various proportions of these enriched cultures to a mixed anaerobic seed inoculum. The improvement resulting from the additional acetate-utilizing cultures was much greater than with formate/H₂ utilizers. Furthermore, formate/H₂ utilizers did not improve propionate utilization significantly, suggesting the importance of optimum utilization of hydrogenotrophic capacity. During most of the volatile fatty acid (VFA) degradation period, the system responded with characteristic hydrogen levels to maintain the Gibbs free energy of oxidation approximately constant for both butyrate (−6 kJ) and propionate (−14 kJ). These free-energy values were independent of methanogenic activity, as well as the volume of the seed inoculum and the VFA concentrations present. By comparing the experimental results with kinetic and mass transfer models, it was postulated that the diffusional transfer of reducing equivalents was the major limiting factor for efficient VFA degradation. Therefore, for optimum utilization of the hydrogenotrophs, low acetate concentrations are vital to enable the system to respond with higher formate/H₂ levels, thus leading to improved transfer of reducing equivalents. Due to the small number of propionate utilizers (and hence their limited surface area) and low bulk liquid concentrations, the additional formate/H₂ utilizers were of minimal use for improving the degradation rate further. The butyrate degradation rates strongly correlated with the cumulative activity of hydrogenotrophs and acetotrophs over the experimental range studied, indicating the need to model obligate syntrophic reactions as a dependent function of methanogenic activity.     

Kinetic parameters and relative turnovers of some important catabolic reactions in digesting sludge.

The kinetics of propionate degradation, acetate splitting, and hydrogen consumption in digesting sludge were investigated in a lab-scale digester. At natural steady-state conditions, the acetate-splitting systems in well-digested sludge were about half saturated. Propionate-degrading systems were saturated to only 10 to 15%, and hydrogen removal was less than 1% of the maximum possible rate. It was concluded that acetate splitting rather than "methanogenesis from fatty acids" is the rate-limiting reaction in the anaerobic degradation of dissolved organic matter and that a methoanogenic anaerobic ecosystem is stabilized by its large unused capacity of hydrogen consumption which is "buffering" the partial pressure of dissolved hydrogen in the system at sufficiently low values to permit rapid fatty acid oxidation. A tentative scheme of the substrate flow in sludge digestion is presented. It suggests that acid formation coupled with hydrogen formation via pyridine dinucleotide oxidation yields the immediate substrates, namely acetate and hydrogen, for about 54% of the total methanogenesis.     

Sulfate reduction in methanogenic bioreactors

Abstract: In the anaerobic treatment of sulfate-containing wastewater, sulfate reduction interferes with methanogenesis. Both mutualistic and competitive interactions between sulfate-reducing bacteria and methanogenic bacteria have been observed. Sulfate reducers will compete with methanogens for the common substrates hydrogen, formate and acetate. In general, sulfate reducers have better growth kinetic properties than methanogens, but additional factors which may be of importance in the competition are adherence properties, mixed substrate utilization, affinity for sulfate of sulfate reducers, relative numbers of bacteria, and reactor conditions such as pH, temperature and sulfide concentration. Sulfate reducers also compete with syntrophic methanogenic consortia involved in the degradation of substrates like propionate and butyrate. In the absence of sulfate these methanogenic consortia are very important, but in the presence of sulfate they are thought to be easily outcompeted by sulfate reducers. However, at relatively low sulfate concentrations, syntrophic degradation of propionate and butyrate coupled to HZ removal via sulfate reduction rather than via methanogenesis may become important. A remarkable feature of some sulfate reducers is their ability to grow fermentatively or to grow in syntrophic association with methanogens in the absence of sulfate.     

Fermentation of 2,3-butanediol by Pelobacter carbinolicus sp. nov. and Pelobacter propionicus sp. nov., and evidence for propionate formation from C2 compounds

From anaerobic enrichments with 2,3-butanediol as sole substrate pure cultures of new Gram-negative, strictly anaerobic, non-sporeforming bacteria were isolated. Similar isolates were obtained with acetoin as substrate. From marine muds in saltwater medium a short rod (strain Gra Bd 1) was isolated which fermented butanediol, acetoin and ethylene glycol to acetate and ethanol. The DNA base ratio of this strain was 52.3 mol% guanine plus cytosine.From freshwater sediments and sewage sludge, a different type of short rod (strain Ott Bd 1) was isolated in freshwater medium, which fermented butanediol, acetoin, ethanol, lactate and pyruvate stoichiometrically to acetate and propionate. Propanol and butanol were oxidized to the respective fatty acids with concomitant reduction of acetate and bicarbonate to propionate. The DNA base ratio of strain Ott Bd 1 was 57.4 mol% guanine plus cytosine. No other substrates were used by the isolates, and no other products could be detected. In cocultures with Acetobacterium woodii or Methanospirillum hungatei, strain Gra Bd 1 also grew on ethanol, propanol, and butanol by fermenting these alcohols to the respective fatty acids and molecular hydrogen. Cytochromes could not be detected in any of the new isolates. Since both types of bacteria can not be affiliated to any of the existing genera and species, the new species Pelobacter carbinolicus and Pelobacter propionicus are proposed. The mechanism of butanediol degradation and propionate formation from acetate as well as the ecological importance of both processes are discussed.     

Survey of the Anaerobic Biodegradation Potential of Organic Chemicals in Digesting Sludge

The degradation potential of 77 organic chemicals under methanogenic conditions was examined with an anaerobic digesting sludge from the United Kingdom. Degradation was assessed in terms of net total gas (CH₄ plus CO₂) produced, expressed as a percentage of the theoretical production (ThGP). The compounds tested were selected from various chemical groups and included substituted phenols and benzoates, pesticides, phthalic acid esters, homocyclic and heterocyclic ring compounds, glycols, and monosubstituted benzenes. The results obtained were in good agreement with published surveys of biodegradability in U.S. digesting sludges and other methanogenic environments. In general, the presence of chloro or nitro groups inhibited anaerobic gas production, while carboxyl and hydroxyl groups facilitated biodegradation. The relationship between substituent position and susceptibility to methanogenic degradation was compound dependent. The following chemicals were completely degraded (≥80% ThGP) at a concentration of 50 mg of carbon per liter: phenol, 2-aminophenol, 4-cresol, catechol, sodium benzoate, 4-aminobenzoic acid, 3-chlorobenzoic acid, phthalic acid, ethylene glycol, diethylene glycol, triethylene glycol, sodium stearate, and quinoline. 3-Cresol, 4-chlorobenzoic acid, dimethyl phthalate, and pyridine were partially degraded. Although the remaining chemicals tested were either persistent or toxic, their behavior may differ at more environmentally realistic chemical-to-biomass ratios. Our findings suggest that biodegradability assessments made with sludge from one source can be extrapolated to sludge from another source with a reasonable degree of confidence and should help in predicting the fate of an organic chemical during the anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge.     

13C-NMR Study of propionate metabolism by sludges from bioreactors treating sulfate and sulfide rich wastewater

Applications of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to study a variety of physiological and biochemical aspects of bacteria with a role in the sulfur cycle are reviewed. Then, a case-study of high resolution¹³ C-NMR spectroscopy on sludges from bioreactors used for treating sulfate and sulfide rich wastewaters is presented.¹³ C-NMR was used to study the effect of sulfate and butyrate on propionate conversion by mesophilic anaerobic (methanogenic and sulfate reducing) granular sludge and microaerobic (sulfide oxidizing) flocculant sludge. In the presence of sulfate, propionate was degraded via the randomising pathway in all sludge types investigated. This was evidenced by scrambling of [3-¹³C]propionate into [2-¹³C]propionate and the formation of acetate equally labeled in the C₁ and C₂ position. In the absence of sulfate, [3-¹³C]propionate scrambled to a lesser extend without being degraded further. Anaerobic sludges converted [2,3-¹³C]propionate partly into the higher fatty acid 2-methyl[2,3-¹³C]butyrate during the simultaneous degradation of [2,3-¹³C]propionate and butyrate. [4,5-¹³C]valerate was also formed in the methanogenic sludges. Up to 10% of the propionate present was converted via these alternative degradation routes. Labeled butyrate was not detected in the incubations, suggesting that reductive carboxylation of propionate does not occur in the sludges.