Characterization of long RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes with short catalytic cores: the effect of excess sequence elements on the outcome of in vitro selection

We previously conducted an in vitro selection experiment for RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes, using a combinatorial DNA library containing 80 random nucleotides. Ultimately, 110 different sequence classes were isolated, but the vast majority contained a short14-15 nt catalytic DNA motif commonly known as 8-17. Herein, we report extensive truncation experiments conducted on multiple sequence classes to confirm the suspected catalytic role played by 8-17 and to determine the effect of excess sequence elements on the activity of this motif and the outcome of selection. Although we observed beneficial, detrimental and neutral consequences for activity, the magnitude of the effect rarely exceeded 2-fold. These deoxyribozymes appear to have survived increasing selection pressure despite the presence of additional sequence elements, rather than because of them. A new deoxyribozyme with comparable activity, called G15-30, was approximately 2.5-fold larger and experienced a approximately 4-fold greater inhibitory effect from excess sequence elements than the average 8-17 motif. Our results suggest that 8-17 may be less susceptible to the potential inhibitory effects of excess arbitrary sequence than larger motifs, which represents a previously unappreciated selective advantage that may contribute to its widespread recurrence.     

Revitalization of six abandoned catalytic DNA species reveals a common three-way junction framework and diverse catalytic cores

A library containing as many as 10(16) nucleic acid candidates is typically used to isolate artificial ribozymes and deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes) in an in vitro selection experiment, with only a handful of sequences surviving many rounds of stringent selection steps. These winning species are generally the focus of interest whereas the less competitive contenders are usually not examined. Nevertheless, molecular species abandoned during the selection process might still represent a rich pool of catalytic motifs that are useful for the examination of DNA's inherent catalytic ability, and for the design of molecular tools for practical applications. Here we report a study of six RNA-cleaving, fluorescence-signaling deoxyribozymes that appeared in the early generations of a previous in vitro selection experiment, using the combined approaches of reselection, rational structural analysis, and reaction condition optimization. All six deoxyribozymes were found to use a three-way junction as a common structural framework for catalysis. However, disparities observed in the conserved nucleotide allocations, methylation interference patterns and metal-ion selectivities, pointed to distinct catalytic cores. The rate constants of the optimized deoxyribozymes fell in the range of approximately 0.2 to 1.6 min(-1), which are comparable to those of similar ribozymes. Our findings indicate that deoxyribozymes eliminated by harsh selection criteria are structurally simple molecules that can be tailored into efficient catalysts.     

Multiple occurrences of an efficient self-phosphorylating deoxyribozyme motif

The catalytic and structural characteristics of two new self-phosphorylating deoxyribozymes (referred to as deoxyribozyme kinases), denoted "Dk3" and "Dk4", are compared to those of Dk2, a previously reported deoxyribozyme kinase. All three deoxyribozymes not only utilize GTP as the source of activated phosphate and Mn(II) as the divalent metal cofactor but also share a common secondary structure with significant sequence variations. Multiple Watson-Crick helices are identified within the secondary structure, and these helical interactions confine three extremely conserved sequence elements of 8, 5, and 14 nucleotides in length, presumably for the formation of the catalytic core for GTP binding and the self-phosphorylating reaction. The locations of the conserved regions suggest that these three deoxyribozymes arose independently from in vitro selection. The existence of three sequence variants of the same deoxyribozyme from the same in vitro selection experiment implies that these catalytic DNAs may represent the simplest structural solution for the DNA self-phosphorylation reaction when GTP is used as the substrate.     

A continuous kinetic assay for RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes,exploiting ethidium bromide as an extrinsic fluorescent probe

We describe a rapid and inexpensive method to monitor the kinetics of small RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes, based on the exogenous fluorophore ethidium bromide. Ethidium binds preferentially to double-stranded nucleic acids, and its fluorescence emission increases dramatically upon intercalation. Thus, ethidium can be used in single-turnover experiments to measure both annealing of the deoxyribozyme to its substrate and release of the products. Under conditions in which dissociation of the product is fast compared with cleavage, the apparent rate of product release reflects the cleavage step. The method was developed for characterizing the so-called 8-17 catalytic DNA, but its general applicability in the deoxyribozyme field was verified using the 10-23 RNA-cleaving construct. Catalysis by both deoxyribozymes was not inhibited in the presence of substoichiometric amounts of ethidium, and the rates obtained through the ethidium assay were virtually identical to the rates determined using radiolabeled substrates. In contrast, the assay cannot be applied to the large, structured ribozymes, and its use to study the kinetics of the small hammerhead ribozyme was hampered by the presence on the catalyst of at least one high-affinity ethidium binding site.     

In vitro selection of small RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes that cleave pyrimidine-pyrimidine junctions

Herein, we sought new or improved endoribonucleases based on catalytic DNA molecules known as deoxyribozymes. The current repertoire of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes can cleave nearly all of the 16 possible dinucleotide junctions with rates of at least 0.1/min, with the exception of pyrimidine–pyrimidine (pyr–pyr) junctions, which are cleaved 1–3 orders of magnitude slower. We conducted four separate in vitro selection experiments to target each pyr–pyr dinucleotide combination (i.e. CC, UC, CT and UT) within a chimeric RNA/DNA substrate. We used a library of DNA molecules containing only 20 random-sequence nucleotides, so that all possible sequence permutations could be sampled in each experiment. From a total of 245 clones, we identified 22 different sequence families, of which 21 represented novel deoxyribozyme motifs. The fastest deoxyribozymes exhibited k_obs values (single-turnover, intermolecular format) of 0.12/min, 0.04/min, 0.13/min and 0.15/min against CC, UC, CT and UT junctions, respectively. These values represent a 6- to 8-fold improvement for CC and UC junctions, and a 1000- to 1600-fold improvement for CT and UT junctions, compared to the best rates reported previously under identical reaction conditions. The same deoxyribozymes exhibited ~1000-fold lower activity against all RNA substrates, but could potentially be improved through further in vitro evolution and engineering.     

Tracing sequence diversity change of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes under increasing selection pressure during in vitro selection

In vitro selection has been used extensively over the past 10 years to create functionally diverse DNA enzymes. The majority of in vitro selection experiments to date have focused on the outcome rather than the process itself, a process that remains to be fully elucidated. In vitro selection techniques rely on the probability that some DNA molecules in a random-sequence library will fold into an appropriate tertiary structure and catalyze a desired reaction. Thus, sufficient sequence diversity in the DNA pool (and hence more catalytic DNA sequences) is a prerequisite for the successful isolation of efficient deoxyribozymes. The catalytic sequence diversity established by in vitro selection is governed largely by the choice of selection pressures, one of which is the length of the reaction time. The objective of this study was to evaluate the sequence diversity change of a pool of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes as a function of the reaction time. Seventeen rounds of in vitro selection were performed, and the reaction time was progressively decreased from 5 h to 5 s. A representative population from each time class was subsequently cloned and sequenced. A decline in sequence diversity was observed with decreasing reaction time, and the relationship appears to be logarithmic. In contrast, a control selection performed with a constant reaction time during each round led to a linear and comparatively very slow decrease in sequence diversity. This study provides the first methodical examination of the change in catalytic sequence diversity that occurs through the course of a deoxyribozyme selection experiment. Moreover, it represents a first step toward fully understanding the intricate pathway that lies between the beginning and end of an in vitro selection experiment.     

A Complex RNA-Cleaving DNAzyme That Can Efficiently Cleave a Pyrimidine-Pyrimidine Junction

Several RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes) have been reported for efficient cleavage of purine-containing junctions, but none is able to efficiently cleave pyrimidine-pyrimidine (Pyr-Pyr) junctions. We hypothesize that a stronger Pyr-Pyr cleavage activity requires larger DNAzymes with complex structures that are difficult to isolate directly from a DNA library; one possible way to obtain such DNAzymes is to optimize DNA sequences with weak activities. To test this, we carried out an in vitro selection study to derive DNAzymes capable of cleaving an rC-T junction in a chimeric DNA/RNA substrate from DNA libraries constructed through chemical mutagenesis of five previous DNAzymes with a k_obs of ∼ 0.001 min^− 1 for the rC-T junction. After several rounds of selective amplification, DNAzyme descendants with a k_obs of ∼ 0.1 min^− 1 were obtained from a DNAzyme pool. The most efficient motif, denoted “CT10-3.29,” was found to have a catalytic core of ∼ 50 nt, larger than other known RNA-cleaving DNAzymes, and its secondary structure contains five short duplexes confined by a four-way junction. Several variants of CT10-3.29 exhibit a k_obs of 0.3-1.4 min^− 1 against the rC-T junction. CT10-3.29 also shows strong activity (k_obs  > 0.1 min^− 1) for rU-A and rU-T junctions, medium activity (> 0.01 min^− 1) for rC-A and rA-T junctions, and weak activity (> 0.001 min^− 1) for rA-A, rG-T, and rG-A junctions. Interestingly, a single-point mutation within the catalytic core of CT10-3.29 altered the pattern of junction specificity with a significantly decreased ability to cleave rC-T and rC-A junctions and a substantially increased ability to cleave rA-A, rA-T, rG-A, rG-T, rU-A, and rU-T junctions. This observation illustrates the intricacy and plasticity of this RNA-cleaving DNAzyme in dinucleotide junction selectivity. The current study shows that it is feasible to derive efficient DNAzymes for a difficult chemical task and reveals that DNAzymes require more complex structural solutions for such a task.     

Preferential activation of the 8-17 deoxyribozyme by Ca(2+) ions. Evidence for the identity of 8-17 with the catalytic domain of the Mg5 deoxyribozyme

The 8-17 deoxyribozyme is a small RNA-cleaving DNA molecule of potential therapeutic interest. Here, the cleavage rates of 16 variants of the 8-17 deoxyribozyme were measured in the presence of different divalent metal ions. Despite the fact that 8-17 was originally selected in vitro for activity in the presence of Mg(2+) (Santoro, S. W., and Joyce, G. F. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 94, 4262-4266) nearly all the 8-17 variants exhibited substantially higher (up to 20-fold) reaction rates in Ca(2+) as compared with Mg(2+). This preference for calcium ions critically depended on the nucleoside residues at two specific positions of the deoxyribozyme core. The Ca(2+) specificity of 8-17 is strongly reminiscent of the properties of Mg5, an RNA phosphodiester-cleaving deoxyribozyme previously isolated by Faulhammer and Famulok (Faulhammer, D., and Famulok, M. (1996) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35, 2837-2841). Indeed, analysis of the Mg5 sequence revealed the presence of a complete 8-17 motif, coincident with the conserved region of Mg5. An 8-17 deoxyribozyme modeled after the Mg5 conserved region displayed catalytic features comparable with those reported for the full-length Mg5 deoxyribozyme.     

Optimization and generality of a small deoxyribozyme that ligates RNA

In vitro evolution was previously used to identify a small deoxyribozyme, 7Q10, that ligates RNA with formation of a 2'-5' phosphodiester linkage from a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and a 5'-hydroxyl group. Ligation occurs in a convenient "binding arms" format analogous to that of the well-known 10-23 and 8-17 RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes. Here, we report the optimization and generality of 7Q10 as a 2'-5' RNA ligase. By comprehensive mutagenesis of its 16-nucleotide enzyme region, the parent 7Q10 sequence is shown to be optimal for RNA ligation yield, although several mutations are capable of increasing the ligation rate approximately fivefold at the expense of yield. The 7Q10 deoxyribozyme ligates any RNA substrates that form the sequence motif UA GR (arrowhead=ligation site and R=purine), providing at least 30% yield of ligated RNA in approximately 1-2 hours at 37 degrees C and pH 9.0. Comparable yields are obtained in approximately 12-24 hours at pH 7.5, which may be more suitable for larger RNAs that are more sensitive to non-specific degradation. For RNA substrates that form the related ligation junction UA GY (Y=pyrimidine), somewhat lower yields are obtained, but significant ligation activity is still observed. These data establish that 7Q10 is a generally applicable RNA ligase. A plot of log(k(obs)) versus pH from pH 6.9 to 9.0 has a slope of just under 1, suggesting that a single deprotonation occurs during the rate-determining reaction step. The compact 7Q10 deoxyribozyme has both practical utility and the potential for increasing our structural and mechanistic understanding of how nucleic acids can mediate chemical reactions.     

A general strategy for effector-mediated control of RNA-cleaving ribozymes and DNA enzymes

A novel and general approach is described for generating versions of RNA-cleaving ribozymes (RNA enzymes) and DNAzymes (DNA enzymes), whose catalytic activity can be controlled by the binding of activator molecules. Variants of the RNA-cleaving 10-23 DNAzyme and 8-17 DNAzyme were created, whose catalysis was activated by up to approximately 35-fold by the binding of the effector adenosine. The design of such variants was possible even though the tertiary folding of the two DNAzymes is not known. Variants of the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed, to respond to the effectors ATP and flavin mononucleotide. Whereas in conventional allosteric ribozymes, effector-binding modulates the chemical step of catalysis, here, effectors exercise their effect upon the substrate-binding step, by stabilizing the enzyme-substrate complex. Because such an approach for controlling the activity of DNAzymes/ribozymes requires no prior knowledge of the enzyme's secondary or tertiary folding, this regulatory strategy should be generally applicable to any RNA-cleaving ribozyme or DNAzyme, natural or in vitro selected, provided substrate-recognition is achieved by Watson-Crick base-pairing.     

Diverse Evolutionary Trajectories Characterize a Community of RNA-Cleaving Deoxyribozymes: A Case Study into the Population Dynamics of In Vitro Selection

Two parallel in vitro selections (denoted Selection A and Selection B) were conducted under different selection-pressure regimes, yielding a diverse community of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes. In Selection A, the reaction time was reduced four times (from 5 h to 5 s) over the course of 24 generations, while in Selection B the reaction time was maintained at 5 h for 30 rounds of selective amplification. Sequence alignment was conducted on more than 800 clones assembled from 18 generations that span both selections. Many prominent catalytic sequence classes, including some that extend across both selections, were identified and used to construct fitness landscapes depicting their rise and fall over time. The landscapes from both selections exhibit similar global trends despite differences in population dynamics. Some deoxyribozymes were predominant in the early rounds of selection but gave way to other species that dominated in the middle rounds. Ultimately, these middle classes disappeared from the landscape in favor of new and presumably more fit deoxyribozyme sequence classes. The shape of these landscapes alludes to the presence of many latent deoxyribozymes in the initial library, which can only be accessed by changes in the selection pressure and/or by adaptive mutations. Basic computer simulations provide theoretical corroboration of the experimentally observed pattern of staggered sequence-class transitions across the fitness landscapes. These simulations model the influence of one or more contributing factors, including catalytic rate, folding efficiency, PCR amplification efficiency, and random mutagenesis. This is the first study which thoroughly documents the topography of a deoxyribozyme fitness landscape over many generations of in vitro selection.     

Establishing broad generality of DNA catalysts for site-specific hydrolysis of single-stranded DNA

We recently reported that a DNA catalyst (deoxyribozyme) can site-specifically hydrolyze DNA on the minutes time scale. Sequence specificity is provided by Watson-Crick base pairing between the DNA substrate and two oligonucleotide binding arms that flank the 40-nt catalytic region of the deoxyribozyme. The DNA catalyst from our recent in vitro selection effort, 10MD5, can cleave a single-stranded DNA substrate sequence with the aid of Zn(2+) and Mn(2+) cofactors, as long as the substrate cleavage site encompasses the four particular nucleotides ATG^T. Thus, 10MD5 can cleave only 1 out of every 256 (4(4)) arbitrarily chosen DNA sites, which is rather poor substrate sequence tolerance. In this study, we demonstrated substantially broader generality of deoxyribozymes for site-specific DNA hydrolysis. New selection experiments were performed, revealing the optimality of presenting only one or two unpaired DNA substrate nucleotides to the N(40) DNA catalytic region. Comprehensive selections were then performed, including in some cases a key selection pressure to cleave the substrate at a predetermined site. These efforts led to identification of numerous new DNA-hydrolyzing deoxyribozymes, many of which require merely two particular nucleotide identities at the cleavage site (e.g. T^G), while retaining Watson-Crick sequence generality beyond those nucleotides along with useful cleavage rates. These findings establish experimentally that broadly sequence-tolerant and site-specific deoxyribozymes are readily identified for hydrolysis of single-stranded DNA.     

Characterization of a catalytically efficient acidic RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme

We previously demonstrated—through the isolation of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes by in vitro selection that are catalytically active in highly acidic solutions—that DNA, despite its chemical simplicity, could perform catalysis under challenging chemical conditions [Liu,Z., Mei,S.H., Brennan,J.D. and Li,Y. (2003) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 7539–7545]. One remarkable DNA molecule therefrom is pH4DZ1, a self-cleaving deoxyribozyme that exhibits a k_obs of ~1 min⁻¹ at pH 3.8. In this study, we carried out a series of experiments to examine the sequence and catalytic properties of this acidic deoxyribozyme. Extensive nucleotide truncation experiments indicated that pH4DZ1 was a considerably large deoxyribozyme, requiring ~80 out of the original 123 nt for the optimal catalytic activity. A reselection experiment identified ten absolutely conserved nucleotides that are distributed in three catalytically crucial sequence elements. In addition, a trans deoxyribozyme was successfully designed. Comparison of the observed rate constant of pH4DZ1 with experimentally determined rate constant for the uncatalyzed reaction revealed that pH4DZ1 achieved a rate enhancement of ~10⁶-fold. This study provides valuable information about this low-pH-functional deoxyribozyme and paves way for further structural and mechanistic characterization of this unique catalytic DNA.     

Target site selection for an RNA-cleaving catalytic DNA.

A small catalytic DNA, known as the 10-23 DNA enzyme or deoxyribozyme, has been shown to efficiently hydrolyze RNA at purine-pyrimidine (R-Y) junctions in vitro. Although these potentially cleavable junctions are ubiquitous, they are often protected from deoxyribozyme activity by RNA secondary structure. We have developed a multiplex cleavage assay for screening the entire length of a target RNA molecule for deoxyribozyme cleavage sites that are efficient, both in terms of kinetics and accessibility. This strategy allowed us to simultaneously compare the RNA cleaving activity of 80 deoxyribozymes for a model target gene (HPV16 E6), and an additional 60 deoxyribozymes against the rat c-myc target. The human papilloma virus (HPV) target was used primarily to characterize the multiplex system and determine its validity. The c-myc target, coupled with a smooth muscle cell proliferation assay, allowed us to assess the relationship between in vitro cleavage efficiency and c-myc gene suppression in cell culture. The multiplex reaction approach streamlines the process of revealing effective deoxyribozymes in a functional assay and provides accessibility data that may also be applicable to site selection for other hybridization-based agents.     

脱氧核酶的研究进展

具有RNA裂解活性的DNA分子称为脱氧核酶。它是经过体外选择技术经多次筛选获得的。脱氧核酶在切割与其互补的RNA底物分子时具有极高的特异性和切割效率,有望成为新的RNA灭活工具。     

脱氧核酶研究进展

运用体外分子进化技术,从人工合成的随机序列DNA库中筛选出多种不同结构的脱氧核酶,其催化活性已扩展到RNA切割、DNA激酶、DNA连接、DNA切割、DNA过氧化、金属螯合等多种酶活性。主要论述脱氧核酶的体外筛选,催化特性和影响因素,以及应用研究等 。     

An Efficient Catalytic DNA that Cleaves L-RNA

Many DNAzymes have been isolated from synthetic DNA pools to cleave natural RNA (D-RNA) substrates and some have been utilized for the design of aptazyme biosensors for bioanalytical applications. Even though these biosensors perform well in simple sample matrices, they do not function effectively in complex biological samples due to ubiquitous RNases that can efficiently cleave D-RNA substrates. To overcome this issue, we set out to develop DNAzymes that cleave L-RNA, the enantiomer of D-RNA, which is known to be completely resistant to RNases. Through in vitro selection we isolated three L-RNA-cleaving DNAzymes from a random-sequence DNA pool. The most active DNAzyme exhibits a catalytic rate constant ~3 min^-1 and has a structure that contains a kissing loop, a structural motif that has never been observed with D-RNA-cleaving DNAzymes. Furthermore we have used this DNAzyme and a well-known ATP-binding DNA aptamer to construct an aptazyme sensor and demonstrated that this biosensor can achieve ATP detection in biological samples that contain RNases. The current work lays the foundation for exploring RNA-cleaving DNAzymes for engineering biosensors that are compatible with complex biological samples.     

Directing the outcome of deoxyribozyme selections to favor native 3'-5' RNA ligation

Previous experiments have identified numerous RNA ligase deoxyribozymes, each of which can synthesize either 2',5'-branched RNA, linear 2'-5'-linked RNA, or linear 3'-5'-linked RNA. These products may be formed by reaction of a 2'-hydroxyl or 3'-hydroxyl of one RNA substrate with the 5'-triphosphate of a second RNA substrate. Here the inherent propensities for nucleophilic reactivity of specific hydroxyl groups were assessed using RNA substrates related to the natural sequences of spliceosome substrates and group II introns. With the spliceosome substrates, nearly half of the selected deoxyribozymes mediate a ligation reaction involving the natural branch-point adenosine as the nucleophile. In contrast, mostly linear RNA is obtained with the group II intron substrates. Because the two sets of substrates differ at only three nucleotides, we conclude that the location of the newly created ligation junction in DNA-catalyzed branch formation depends sensitively on the RNA substrate sequences. During the experiment that led primarily to branched RNA, we abruptly altered the selection strategy to demand that the deoxyribozymes create linear 3'-5' linkages by introducing an additional selection step involving the 3'-5'-selective 8-17 deoxyribozyme. Although no 3'-5' linkages (相似文献