FtsHi1/ARC1 is an essential gene in Arabidopsis that links chloroplast biogenesis and division

The Arabidopsis arc1 (accumulation and replication of chloroplasts 1) mutant has pale seedlings and smaller, more numerous chloroplasts than the wild type. Previous work has suggested that arc1 affects the timing of chloroplast division but does not function directly in the division process. We isolated ARC1 by map‐based cloning and discovered it encodes FtsHi1 (At4g23940), one of several FtsHi proteins in Arabidopsis. These poorly studied proteins resemble FtsH metalloproteases important for organelle biogenesis and protein quality control but are presumed to be proteolytically inactive. FtsHi1 bears a predicted chloroplast transit peptide and localizes to the chloroplast envelope membrane. Phenotypic studies showed that arc1 (hereafter ftsHi1‐1), which bears a missense mutation, is a weak allele of FtsHi1 that disrupts thylakoid development and reduces de‐etiolation efficiency in seedlings, suggesting that FtsHi1 is important for chloroplast biogenesis. Consistent with this finding, transgenic plants suppressed for accumulation of an FtsHi1 fusion protein were often variegated. A strong T‐DNA insertion allele, ftsHi1‐2, caused embryo‐lethality, indicating that FtsHi1 is an essential gene product. A wild‐type FtsHi1 transgene rescued both the chloroplast division and pale phenotypes of ftsHi1‐1 and the embryo‐lethal phenotype of ftsHi1‐2. FtsHi1 overexpression produced a subtle increase in chloroplast size and decrease in chloroplast number in wild‐type plants while suppression led to increased numbers of small chloroplasts, providing new evidence that FtsHi1 negatively influences chloroplast division. Taken together, our analyses reveal that FtsHi1 functions in an essential, envelope‐associated process that may couple plastid development with division.     

Etr1-1 Gene Expression Alters Regeneration Patterns in Transgenic Lettuce Stimulating Root Formation

We have evaluated the transformation efficiency of two lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) cultivars, LE126 and Seagreen, using Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated gene transfer. Six-day-old cotyledons were co-cultivated with Agrobacterium cultures carrying binary vectors with two different genetic constructs. The first construct contained the β-glucuronidase gene (GUS) under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter (CaMV 35S), while the second construct contained the ethylene mutant receptor etr1-1, which confers ethylene insensitivity, under the control of a leaf senescence-specific promoter (sag12). Tissues co-cultivated with the GUS construct showed strong regeneration potential with over 90% of explants developing callus masses and 85% of the calli developing shoots. Histochemical GUS assays showed that 85.7% of the plants recovered were transgenic. Very different results were observed when cotyledon explants were co-cultivated with Agrobacteria carrying the etr1-1 gene. There was a dramatic effect on the regeneration properties of the cultured explants with root formation taking place directly from the cotyledon tissue in 34% of the explants and no callus or shoots observed initially. Eventually callus formed in 10% of cotyledons and some organogenic shoots were obtained (2.86%). These results indicate that the ethylene insensitivity conferred by the etr1-1 gene alters the normal pattern of regeneration in lettuce cotyledons, inhibiting the formation of shoots and stimulating root formation during regeneration.     

Kalanchoe blossfeldiana plants expressing the Arabidopsis etr1-1 allele show reduced ethylene sensitivity

Transgenic Kalanchoe blossfeldiana Poelln. with reduced ethylene sensitivity in flowers was obtained by Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation using the plasmid pBEO210 containing the mutant ethylene receptor gene etr1-1 from Arabidopsis thaliana under the control of the flower-specific fbp1-promoter from Petunia. Three ethylene-resistent T0 lines, 300, 324 and 331, were selected and analyzed for postharvest-performance and morphological characteristics. Line 324 was found to be infertile and only slightly less ethylene-sensitive than control-plants, but lines 300 and 331 had significantly increased ethylene-resistance and were fertile. These two lines were analyzed for copy-number of the etr1-1 gene by Southern blotting and were crossed with the ethylene-sensitive cultivar ‘Celine’ to create T1 progeny. Line 300 contains two T-DNA copies per nucleus, one of which is rearranged, and these are unlinked according to segregation data from the crossing to ‘Celine’ and PCR-analysis of progeny plants. For control plants all flowers were closed after 2 days at 2 μl l⁻¹ ethylene, but for line 300 only 33% were closed after 10 days. Line 331 contains three T-DNA copies per nucleus and is more sensitive to ethylene than line 300. In the line 300 the etr1-1 gene was found by RT-PCR to be expressed in petals and stamens but not in carpels and sepals. Both lines 300 and 331, and their progeny, appear morphologically and physiologically identical to control plants except for the higher ethylene resistance. Line 300 and its progeny with only one T-DNA copy have very low ethylene sensitivity and may be useful in future breeding.     

烟草NtFtsZ2-1基因参与叶绿体分裂和扩大的调节

叶绿体虽然是植物细胞内一种极其重要的细胞器,但其分裂的分子机制尚不很清楚。已经证明FtsZ蛋白作为真核细胞分裂装置的一个关键成分,参与叶绿体的分裂过程。烟草的FtsZ基因属于2个不同的家族,在对NtFtsZ1家族成员研究的基础上,用正义和反义表达技术研究了NtFtsZ2家族成员NtFtsZ2-1基因在转基因烟草中的功能。显微分析结果表明NtFtsZ2-1基因的表达水平异常增强或减弱都会严重干扰叶绿体的正常分裂过程,导致叶绿体在形态和数目上的异常（体积明显增大,数目显著减少）,而单个叶肉细胞中叶绿体的总表面积在正反义转基因烟草和野生型烟草之间保持了相对稳定,没有发生明显的变化。同时还证明NtFtsZ2-1基因表达的变化对叶绿素含量和叶绿体的光合作用能力没有直接的影响。据此我们认为NtFtsZ2-1基因参与叶绿体的分裂和体积的扩大,其表达水平的波动会改变植物中叶绿体的数目和大小,而且在叶绿体的数目与体积之间可能存在一种补偿机制,保证叶绿体能最大限度地吸收光能,从而使光合作用得以正常进行。     

Effect of octanoic acid on ethylene-mediated processes in Arabidopsis

We have examined whether octanoic acid (OA) one of the short chain saturated fatty acids (SCSFA), increases ethylene response in the following three ethylene-mediated processes: a) hypocotyl growth in darkness; b) formation of new flowers; c) flower abscission. These processes were examined in the presence or absence of exogenous ethylene in Arabidopsis wild type (WT) and in the ethylene-insensitive mutants, etr1-3 and ein2-1 and in the ethylene over-producer mutant eto1-1. Our results show that OA decreased hypocotyl length of WT in the absence or presence of exogenous ethylene, apparently showing that OA acts via augmentation of ethylene action. However, the hypocotyl growth inhibition could not be ascribed to increased ethylene sensitivity since application of inhibitors of ethylene synthesis (aminoethoxyvinylglycine; AVG) or action (1-methylcyclopropene;1-MCP) to WT seedlings did not prevent specifically the OA-induced growth inhibition. Also, OA inhibited hypocotyl growth in the mutants etr1-3 and ein2-1 in a similar pattern to that obtained in WT. On the other hand, OA had no effect on flower formation neither in WT, etr1-3 and eto1-1, in which ethylene reduced flower formation, nor in the ein2-1 mutant, in which ethylene had no effect. OA also did not increase flower abscission in WT or in the mutants etr1-3 and ein2-1 neither in the absence nor in the presence of ethylene. However, OA has augmented flower abscission in the mutant eto1-1 only in the absence of exogenous ethylene. This result might indicate that the effect of OA on eto1-1 is specific to this mutant and is not due to general deleterious effects inflicted by OA. Taken together, our results show that in general OA does not augment ethylene response in Arabidopsis, but it might affect ethylene action in flower abscission of the ethylene-overproducer mutant.     

Genetic analysis of involvement of ETR1 in plant response to salt and osmotic stress

The involvement of ethylene and ethylene receptor Ethylene Response 1 (ETR1) in plant stress responses has been highlighted. However, the physiological processes involved remain unclear. In this study, we have investigated the physiological response of two alleles etr1-1 and etr1-7 mutants during germination and post-germination seedling development in response to salt and osmotic stress. The etr1-1 mutants showed increased sensitivity to osmotic (200 mM or higher mannitol) and salt stress (50 mM NaCl or higher) during germination and seedling development, whereas the etr1-7 mutants displayed enhanced tolerance to the severe stresses (500 mM mannitol or 200 mM NaCl). These results provide physiological and genetic evidence that ethylene receptor ETR1 modulates plant response to abiotic stress. Furthermore, the etr1-1 and etr1-7 mutants showed different responses to exogenous abscisic acid (ABA) inhibition. The etr1-1 mutants were more sensitive to ABA than the wild type during germination, and young seedling development. In sharp contrast, the etr1-7 mutants showed enhanced insensitivity to ABA treatment (>1 μM ABA) in post-germination development including root elongation and greening of cotyledons of the treated seedlings, although the germination was not greatly altered at the tested doses of ABA. The results suggest that ETR1-modulated stress response may mediate ABA. Youning Wang and Tao Wang contributed equally to this report.     

Ethylene regulates the timing of leaf senescence in Arabidopsis

The plant hormone ethylene influences many aspects of plant growth and development, including some specialized forms of programmed senescence such as fruit ripening and flower petal senescence. To study the relationship between ethylene and leaf senescence, etr1-1, an ethylene-insensitive mutant in Arabidopsis, was used. Comparative analysis of rosette leaf senescence between etr1-1 and wild-type plants revealed that etr1-1 leaves live approximately 30% longer than the wild-type leaves. Delayed leaf senescence in etr1-1 coincided with delayed induction of senescence-associated genes (SAGs) and higher expression levels of photosynthesis-associated genes (PAGs). In wild-type plants, exogenous ethylene was able to further accelerate induction of SAGs and decrease expression of PAGs. The extended period of leaf longevity in etr1-1 was associated with low levels of photosynthetic activity. Therefore, the leaves in etr1-1 functionally senesced even though the apparent life span of the leaf was prolonged.     

The nuclei of cellular organelles and the formation of daughter organelles by the “plastid-dividing ring”

It has been established that organelles, such as mitochondria and plastids, contain organelle-specific DNA and arise from the division of pre-existing organelles (e.g., Possingham and Lawrence, 1983). We propose that organelle DNAs, such as mitochondrial DNA and plastid DNA are not naked in organellesin situ but are organized in each case to form an “organelle nucleus” with basic proteins (Kuroiwa, 1982). The concept of organelle nuclei has changed our ideas about the division of organelles. Thus, the process of organelle division must be composed of two main events: division of the organelle nucleus and organellekinesis (division of the other components of the mitochondrion or plastid). The latter term has been adopted as an appropriate analogue of cytokinesis. We were the first to identify the plastid-dividing ring (PD-ring), which is located in the cytoplasm close to the outer envelope membrane at the constricted isthmus of dividing chloroplasts in the red algaCyanidium caldirum. The PD-ring is about 60 nm in width and 25 nm in thickness, and is a circular bundle of actin-like, fine filaments, each about 4–5 nm in diameter. Since cytochalasin B, an inhibitor of polymerization of actin filaments, inhibits the formation of the PD-ring and, thus, prevents subsequent division of chloroplasts, the PD-ring is thought to be a structure that is essential for the division of plastids (plastidkinesis). The behavior of the PD-ring during a cycle of chloroplast division can be classified into the following four stages on the basis of morphological and temporal differences. The chloroplast growth stage: the small, spherical chloroplast increases in volume and becomes a football-like structure, while the PD-ring from the previous division disappears. Formation of the PD-ring: the somewhat electron-dense body (see below) is fragmented into many, somewhat electron-dense granules, which are aligned along the equatorial region of the chloroplast and fine filaments are formed from the somewhat electron-dense granules in the equatorial region. The fine filaments of the PD-ring align themselves according to the longest axis of their overall domain, i.e., circumferentially. Contraction stage: a bundle of fine filaments begins to contract and generates a deep furrow. Conversion stage: after chloroplast division, the remnants of the PD-ring are converted into somewhat electron-dense bodies. Similar events occur during the second cycle of chloroplast division. Since similar structures are observed extensively in the plastids of algae, moss and higher plants, the PD-ring appears to be an essential structure for the division of plastids in plants.     

Analysis of chloroplast and mitochondrial DNA in asymmetric somatic hybrids betweenSolanum tuberosum and irradiatedS. brevidens

Organellar DNA of asymmetric somatic hybrids betweenSolanum tuberosum and irradiatedS. brevidens were analysed by DNA hybridization methods using the spinach chloroplast probepSBD, wheat mitochondrial genenad5 and petunia mitochondrial geneorf25. Eight of the 12 asymmetric hybrid plants hadS. tuberosum chloroplast DNA and the remaining fourS. brevidens chloroplast DNA. A novel mitochondrial hybridization pattern was present in eight out of the 17 hybrids tested. In six hybrids, novel combinations of chloroplasts and mitochondria were found, indicating that both organelle types sorted out independently.     

The distinctive roles of five different ARC genes in the chloroplast division process in Arabidopsis

ARC (accumulation and replication of chloroplasts) genes control different aspects of the chloroplast division process in higher plants. In order to establish the hierarchy of the ARC genes in the chloroplast division process and to provide evidence for their specific roles, double mutants were constructed between arc11, arc6, arc5, arc3 and arc1 in all combinations and phenotypically analysed. arc11 is a new nuclear recessive mutant with 29 chloroplasts compared with 120 in wild type. All the phenotypes of the double mutants are unambiguous. ARC1 down-regulates proplastid division but is on a separate pathway from ARC3, ARC5, ARC6 and ARC11. ARC6 initiates both proplastid and chloroplast division. ARC3 controls the rate of chloroplast expansion and ARC11 the central positioning of the final division plane in chloroplast division. ARC5 facilitates separation of the two daughter chloroplasts. ARC5 maps to chromosome 3 and ARC11 and ARC6 map approximately 60 cM apart on chromosome 5.     

UV-B stress-induced ABA production in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> mutants defective in ethylene signal transduction pathway

In this study, we examined the influence of UV-B radiation (280–320 nm) on ABA accumulation in 14-day-old Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh plants of wild type (WT), ethylene receptor mutant (etr1-1), and mutant with a constitutively active ethylene signal transduction pathway (ctr1-1). ABA content in nonirradiated WT plants was twice higher than in each mutant. UV-B irradiation caused dose-dependent ABA accumulation in WT plants. In the etr1-1 mutant, the amount of accumulated ABA was significantly less. In the ctr1-1 mutant, ABA content didn’t increase after UV-B irradiation. These data suggest that start of stress-induced ABA formation requires the adjustable ethylene signal pathway. In the ctr1-1 mutant, a constitutively active (nonadjustable) ethylene signal pathway blocks stress-induced ABA accumulation.     

Plant FtsZ1 and FtsZ2 expressed in a eukaryotic host: GTPase activity and self-assembly

Plants and algae contain the FtsZ1 and FtsZ2 protein families that perform specific, non-redundant functions in plastid division. In vitro studies of chloroplast division have been hampered by the lack of a suitable expression system. Here we report the expression and purification of FtsZ1-1 and FtsZ2-1 from Arabidopsis thaliana using a eukaryotic host. Specific GTPase activities were determined and found to be different for FtsZ1-1 vs. FtsZ2-1. The purified proteins readily assembled into previously unreported assembly products named type-I and -II filaments. In contrast to bacterial FtsZ, the Arabidopsis proteins do not form bundled sheets in the presence of Ca²⁺.     

Expression of Brassica oleracea FtsZ1-1 and MinD alters chloroplast division in Nicotiana tabacum generating macro- and mini-chloroplasts

FtsZ1-1 and MinD plastid division-related genes were identified and cloned from Brassica oleracea var. botrytis. Transgenic tobacco plants expressing BoFtsZ1-1 or BoMinD exhibited cells with either fewer but abnormally large chloroplasts or more but smaller chloroplasts relative to wild-type tobacco plants. An abnormal chloroplast phenotype in guard cells was found in BoMinD transgenic tobacco plants but not in BoFtsZ1-1 transgenic tobacco plants. Transgenic tobacco plants bearing the macro-chloroplast phenotype had 10 to 20-fold increased levels of total FtsZ1-1 or MinD, whilst the transgenic tobacco plants bearing the mini-chloroplast phenotype had lower increased FtsZ1-1 or absence of detectable MinD. We also described for the first time, plastid transformation of macro-chloroplast bearing tobacco shoots with a gene cassette allowing for expression of green fluorescent protein (GFP). Homoplasmic plastid transformants from normal chloroplast and macro-chloroplast tobacco plants expressing GFP were obtained. Both types of transformants accumulated GFP at ~6% of total soluble protein, thus indicating that cells containing macro-chloroplasts can regenerate shoots in tissue culture and can stably integrate and express a foreign gene to similar levels as plant cells containing a normal chloroplast size and number.     

CLA1, a novel gene required for chloroplast development, is highly conserved in evolution

An albino mutant designated cla1-1 (for ‘c loroplastos a lterado’, or ‘altered chloroplasts’) has been isolated from a T-DNA-generated library of Arabidopsis thaliana. In cla11 plants, chloroplast development is arrested at an early stage. cla1-1 plants behave like wild-type in their capacity to etiolate and produce anthocyanins indicating that the light signal transduction pathway seems to be unaffected. Genetic and molecular analyses show that the disruption of a single gene, CLA1, by the T-DNA insertion is responsible for the mutant phenotype. RNA expression patterns indicate that CLA1 is positively regulated by light and that it has different effects on the steady-state RNA levels of some nuclear- and chloroplast-encoded photosynthetic genes. Although the specific function of the CLA1 gene is still unknown, it encodes a novel protein conserved in evolution between photosynthetic bacteria and plants which is essential for chloroplast development in Arabidopsis.     

ARC6 is a J-domain plastid division protein and an evolutionary descendant of the cyanobacterial cell division protein Ftn2

Replication of chloroplasts is essential for achieving and maintaining optimal plastid numbers in plant cells. The plastid division machinery contains components of both endosymbiotic and host cell origin, but little is known about the regulation and molecular mechanisms that govern the division process. The Arabidopsis mutant arc6 is defective in plastid division, and its leaf mesophyll cells contain only one or two grossly enlarged chloroplasts. We show here that arc6 chloroplasts also exhibit abnormal localization of the key plastid division proteins FtsZ1 and FtsZ2. Whereas in wild-type plants, the FtsZ proteins assemble into a ring at the plastid division site, chloroplasts in the arc6 mutant contain numerous short, disorganized FtsZ filament fragments. We identified the mutation in arc6 and show that the ARC6 gene encodes a chloroplast-targeted DnaJ-like protein localized to the plastid envelope membrane. An ARC6-green fluorescent protein fusion protein was localized to a ring at the center of the chloroplasts and rescued the chloroplast division defect in the arc6 mutant. The ARC6 gene product is related closely to Ftn2, a prokaryotic cell division protein unique to cyanobacteria. Based on the FtsZ filament morphology observed in the arc6 mutant and in plants that overexpress ARC6, we hypothesize that ARC6 functions in the assembly and/or stabilization of the plastid-dividing FtsZ ring. We also analyzed FtsZ localization patterns in transgenic plants in which plastid division was blocked by altered expression of the division site-determining factor AtMinD. Our results indicate that MinD and ARC6 act in opposite directions: ARC6 promotes and MinD inhibits FtsZ filament formation in the chloroplast.     

The chloroplastic DEVH‐box RNA helicase INCREASED SIZE EXCLUSION LIMIT 2 involved in plasmodesmata regulation is required for group II intron splicing

INCREASED SIZE EXCLUSION LIMIT 2 (ISE2) encodes a putative DEVH‐box RNA helicase originally identified through a genetic screening for Arabidopsis mutants altered in plasmodesmata (PD) aperture. Depletion of ISE2 also affects chloroplasts activity, decreases accumulation of photosynthetic pigments and alters expression of photosynthetic genes. In this work, we show the chloroplast localization of ISE2 and decipher its role in plastidic RNA processing and, consequently, PD function. Group II intron‐containing RNAs from chloroplasts exhibit defective splicing in ise2 mutants and ISE2‐silenced plants, compromising plastid viability. Furthermore, RNA immunoprecipitation suggests that ISE2 binds in vivo to several splicing‐regulated RNAs. Finally, we show that the chloroplast clpr2 mutant (defective in a subunit of a plastidic Clp protease) also exhibits abnormal PD function during embryogenesis, supporting the idea that chloroplast RNA processing is required to regulate cell–cell communication in plants.     

Evolution of the chloroplast division machinery

Chloroplasts are photosynthetic organelles derived from endosymbiotic cyanobacteria during evolution. Dramatic changes occurred during the process of the formation and evolution of chloroplasts, including the large-scale gene transfer from chloroplast to nucleus. However, there are still many essential characters remaining. For the chloroplast division machinery, FtsZ proteins, Ftn2, SulA and part of the division site positioning system—MinD and MinE are still conserved. New or at least partially new proteins, such as FtsZ family proteins FtsZ1 and ARC3, ARC6H, ARC5, PDV1, PDV2 and MCD1, were introduced for the division of chloroplasts during evolution. Some bacterial cell division proteins, such as FtsA, MreB, Ftn6, FtsW and FtsI, probably lost their function or were gradually lost. Thus, the chloroplast division machinery is a dynamically evolving structure with both conservation and innovation.     

The influence of ethylene perception on sex expression in melon (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cucumis melo </Emphasis>L.) as assessed by expression of the mutant ethylene receptor, <Emphasis Type="Italic">At-etr1-1</Emphasis>, under the control of constitutive and floral targeted promoters

Sexual diversity expressed by Curcurbitaceae species is a primary example of developmental plasticity in plants. Ethylene, which promotes femaleness (carpel development), plays a key role in sex determination. We sought to determine the critical location for ethylene perception in developing floral primodia. The dominant negative Arabidopsis ethylene response mutant gene, etr1-1, was introduced into melon (Cucumis melo L.) plants under control of the constitutive cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter, or floral-targeted Apetela3 (AP3) and Crab’s Claw (CRC) promoters, which in Arabidopsis, promote expression in petal and stamen, and carpel and nectary primordia, respectively. Based on effects of exogenous ethylene, it was predicted that inhibition of ethylene perception by carpel primordia would inhibit carpel development. Constitutive expression of etr1-1 caused several phenotypes associated with ethylene insensitivity, verifying that etr1-1 inhibits ethylene perception in the heterologous melon system. Carpel-bearing bud production was essentially abolished in 35S::etr1-1 melons, providing direct demonstration of the requirement for ethylene perception for carpel development. CRC::etr1-1 plants, however, showed enhanced femaleness as manifested by earlier and increased number of carpel-bearing buds, and production of female (rather than bisexual) buds. Despite increased carpel-bearing bud formation, a greater proportion of the CRC::etr1-1 carpel-bearing buds aborted before anthesis. AP3::etr1-1 plants showed increased maleness by nearly exclusive staminate flower production, and poorly developed carpels in the rare bisexual flowers. These results indicate that ethylene perception by the stamen (or petal) primordia plays a critical role in promoting carpel development at the time of sex determination, while ethylene perception by the carpel is important for maturation of carpel-bearing flowers to anthesis.     

EVIDENCE THAT THE NUCLEOMORPHS OF CHLORARACHNION REPTANS (CHLORARACHNIOPHYCEAE) ARE VESTIGIAL NUCLEI: MORPHOLOGY,DIVISION AND DNA-DAPI FLUORESCENCE1

Chlorarachnion reptans Geitler shows affinities to both the Chlorophyceae and the chloroplast endoplasmic reticulum-containing chromophyte algae in possessing chlorophyll b and chloroplasts which are limited by four membranes, respectively. In the periplastidal compartment surrounding each of the four to eight chloroplasts of a C. reptans cell are putative eukaryotic-sized ribosomes, scattered tubules and vesicles, and a small double-membrane-limited nucleus-like organelle named the nucleomorph. The nucleomorphs display 4′-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI)fluorescence which is sensitive to DNase digestion, but not to treatment with RNase. The nucleomorphs also contain a fibrillogranular body which resembles a nucleolus. Nucleomorph division occurs by the sequential infolding of the inner and outer envelope membranes and subsequent constriction in two, with no involvement of microtubules. In all these characteristics, the nucleomorphs of C. reptans are similar to the cryptomonad nucleomorph which has been hypothesized to be the vestigial nucleus of an ancestral red alga which gave rise to the chloroplasts of the Cryptophyceae. The presence of chlorophyll b and the contents and morphology of C. reptans chloroplast compartments suggest a green algal origin for the chloroplasts of these cells. The discovery of a second organism with a DNA-containing, nucleus-like organelle in its chloroplast compartment lends strong support to the hypothesis that the chloroplasts of many algae have evolved from eukaryotic endosymbionts.