Analysis of ribonuclease-nucleotide interactions by quantitative affinity chromatography.

Quantitative affinity chromatography on uridine-5'-(Sepharose-4-aminophenylphosphoryl)-2'(3')-phosphate was developed for the study of binding of ribonuclease species to nucleotide ligands. Elution of the native species ribonuclease-A and -S on the afffinity matrix in 0.4 M ammonium acetate, pH 5.2, containing various amounts of the soluble competing ligand 2'-cytidine monophosphate, reveals an inverse response of elution volume to concentration of soluble ligand. This response conforms to behavior expected for the competing binding equilibria enzyme-soluble ligand and enzyme-insoluble ligand. A-NALYSIS OF ELUTION DATA ALLOWS CALCULATION OF KI and KIM, the dissociation constants, respectively, for the soluble and insoluble protein-ligand complexes. The values of these chromatographically derived constants are similar to values of dissocation constants determined in solution by kinetics of inhibition by 2'-cytidine monophosphate and uridine-5'-(j-aminophenylphosphoryl)-2'(3')-phosphate. Successful competitive elution experiments with [p-F-Phe8]semisynthetic ribonuclease-S' and individual elution trials for [4-F-His12]semisynthetic ribonuclease-S' indicate the utility of the quantitative affinity chromatographic technique for determination of ligand binding properties of ribonuclease derivatives, including inactive species. Nonbiospecific aspects of the interaction of ribonuclease with the affinity matrix in ammonium acetate buffers of concentrations 0.1 M and below were noted, delinating limits of conditions allowing the biospecificity needed for ligand-binding analyses by competitive elution. The dependence of ribonuclease competitive elution behavior on the amount of protein eluted also was examined and related to theoretical considerations in the quantitative application of affinity chromatography.     

Expression of multivalency in the affinity chromatography of antibodies. Appendix: Derivation and evaluation of equations for independent bivalent interacting systems in quantitative affinity chromatography.

The expression of multivalency in the interaction of antibody with immobilized antigen was evaluated by quantitative affinity chromatography. Zones of radioisotopically labeled bivalent immunoglobulin A monomer derived from the myeloma protein TEPC 15 were eluted from columns of phosphorylcholine-Sepharose both in the absence and presence of competing soluble phosphorylcholine. At sufficient immobilized phosphorylcholine concentration, the variation of elution volume of bivalent monomer with soluble ligand was found to deviate from that observed for the univalent binding of the corresponding Fab fragment. In addition, the apparent binding affinity of the bivalent monomer increased with immobilized antigen density. Use of equations relating the variation of elution volume with free ligand concentration for a bivalent binding protein allowed calculation of microscopic single-site binding parameters for the bivalent monomeric antibody to both immobilized and soluble phosphorylcholine. The chromatographic data not only demonstrate the effect of multivalency on apparent binding affinity but also offer a relatively simple means to measure microscopic dissociation constants for proteins participating in bivalent interactions with their ligands.     

Affinity characterization-mass spectrometry methodology for quantitative analyses of small molecule protein binding in solution

Affinity characterization by mass spectrometry (AC–MS) is a novel LC–MS methodology for quantitative determination of small molecule ligand binding to macromolecules. Its most distinguishing feature is the direct determination of all three concentration terms of the equilibrium binding equation, i.e., (M), (L), and (ML), which denote the macromolecule, ligand, and the corresponding complex, respectively. Although it is possible to obtain the dissociation constant from a single mixing experiment, saturation analyses are still valuable for assessing the overall binding phenomenon based on an established formalism. In addition to providing the prerequisite dissociation constant and binding stoichiometry, the technique also provides valuable information about the actual solubility of both macromolecule and ligand upon dilution and mixing in binding buffers. The dissociation constants and binding mode for interactions of DNA primase and thymidylate synthetase (TS) with high and low affinity small molecule ligands were obtained using the AC–MS method. The data were consistent with the expected affinity of TS for these ligands based on dissociation constants determined by alternative thermal-denaturation techniques: TdF or TdCD, and also consistent enzyme inhibition constants reported in the literature. The validity of AC–MS was likewise extended to a larger set of soluble protein–ligand systems. It was established as a valuable resource for counter screen and structure–activity relationship studies in drug discovery, especially when other classical techniques could only provide ambiguous results.     

Comparison of conformational features of staphylococcal nuclease in ternary complexes with pdTp, pdGp, and nitrophenyl-pdTp.

The conformations of wild-type staphylococcal nuclease (SNase) in the ternary complexes with thymidine 3',5'-bisphosphate (pdTp), 2'-deoxyguanine 3',5'-bisphosphate (pdGp), and thymidine 3'-phosphate 5'-(p-nitrophenylphosphate) (NpdTp) with Ca2+ were examined by two-dimensional NMR NOESY and ROESY experiments. The results of these experiments indicate that the conformational features of the SNase are quite similar in the three ternary complexes. This suggests that the conformational features of SNase, in these ternary complexes, are not strongly dependent on whether the 5'-phosphate is a mono- or diester. This is in contrast to our prior studies on substitutions of active site charged amino acids which indicated that the conformational features of SNase in the ternary complex are quite sensitive to substitutions for active site charged amino acids (Hibler et al., 1987; Wilde et al., 1988; Pourmotabbed et al., 1990). The similarity of the SNase conformational features in the ternary complexes with pdTp and pdGp indicates that the features of the nucleotide bound at the active site are not strong determinants of the enzyme conformation in the ternary complexes. These conclusions are in general agreement with the results on pdApdT ternary complexes with SNase which suggested that it is the conformational features of the bound nucleic acid which determine the differences in catalysis observed for SNase with different substrates (Weber et al., 1991), more so than the conformational features of the enzyme.     

Co-operative binding interactions in affinity chromatography: Theoretical considerations

A theoretical relationship has been developed to allow the effect of free ligand concentration on the capacity of an affinity Chromatography matrix to be determined where the protein adsorbed shows co-operative binding. Computer simulations using literature values for association constants show that under optimal conditions resin capacity can be increased significantly in the presence of a small but finite concentration of free ligand. The model also allows prediction of the soluble ligand concentration required for biospecific elution. The results obtained suggest the possibility of a new elution technique, "reverse biospecific elution," that reduces the amount of free ligand required to effect elution.     

An extended Scatchard analysis for competitively bound ligands and its application to cyclic adenosine-3',5'-monophosphate and cyclic 5'-amido-5'-deoxyadenosine-3', 5'-monophosphate binding to beef skeletal muscle protein.

A method for determining the dissociation constants of ligands and ligand analogs is described. It is based on competition binding studies in the presence of an isotope-labeled, or otherwise measurable, ligand and suitable analog concentrations.The steps used are determination of (1) the maximal amount of radioactive ligand that can be bound, (2) the slopes and intercepts from Scatchard plots at different analog concentrations and (3) the values for the dissociation constants of radioactive ligand and ligand analog from replots of the reciprocals of the slopes and intercepts obtained from the Scatchard plots. Application of the method to a cyclic AMP-binding protein from beef muscle is demonstrated, yielding dissociation constants of 2.10-9 M for cyclic (3H) AMP and cyclic AMP, and 3.10-5 M for cyclic 5'-amido-5'-deoxyadenosine-3', 5'-monophosphate.     

Affinity chromatography of nucleases

The review concerns isolation and purification of nucleases by affinity chromatography. Different stationary ligands and the methods for their immobilization on supports are described, along with diverse eluents and various procedures for a nuclease detachment from the affinity sorbents. The data on the affinity chromatography application for measuring the dissociation constants of the enzyme complexes with either immobilized or soluble ligands are compiled.     

A comparison of d-inositol 1:2-cyclic phosphate 2-phosphohydrolase with other phosphodiesterases of kidney

1. The ability to hydrolyse various phosphodiesterase substrates was examined in subcellular fractions of rat kidney and in serial slices of the kidneys of mouse, rat, guinea pig and ox cut from the cortex perimeter inwards. 2. d-Inositol 1:2-cyclic phosphate 2-phosphohydrolase could be clearly distinguished from phosphodiesterases which hydrolyse 2':3'- and 3':5'-cyclic AMP and p-nitrophenyl thymidine 5'-phosphate (phosphodiesterase I). The hydrolysis of sn-glycero-3-phosphorylcholine showed a distribution identical with that of particle-bound d-inositol 1:2-cyclic phosphate 2-phosphodiesterase, but there was a 30-fold difference in the ratio of enzyme activities between the rat and guinea pig. 3. In rat and mouse kidney, d-inositol 1:2-cyclic phosphate 2-phosphohydrolase is virtually all membrane bound and in the outer cortex, whereas in guinea-pig kidney the enzyme is almost entirely soluble and located throughout the kidney tissue. Some properties of the soluble enzyme are described. 4. Distribution and histochemical studies indicated that in the rat and mouse, phosphodiesterase I is associated with the brush borders of the straight portion (pars recta) of the proximal tubule, whereas inositol 1:2-cyclic phosphate 2-phosphohydrolase and probably glycerylphosphorylcholine diesterase are associated with the brush borders of the convoluted part of the tubule (pars convoluta).     

Thermal denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease

The fully reversible thermal denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease in the absence and presence of Ca2+ and/or thymidine 3',5'-diphosphate (pdTp) from pH 4 to 8 has been studied by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. In the absence of ligands, the denaturation is accompanied by an enthalpy change of 4.25 cal g-1 and an increase in specific heat of 0.134 cal K-1 g-1, both of which are usual values for small globular proteins. The temperature (tm) of maximal excess specific heat is 53.4 degrees C. Each of the ligands, Ca2+ and pdTp, by itself has important effects on the unfolding of the protein which are enhanced when both ligands are present. Addition of saturating concentrations of these ligands raises the denaturational enthalpy to 5.74 cal g-1 in the case of Ca2+ and to 6.72 cal g-1 in the case of pdTp. The ligands raise the tm by as much as 11 degrees C depending on ligand concentration. From the variation of the denaturational enthalpies with ligand concentrations, binding constants at 53 degrees C equal to 950 M-1 and 1.4 X 10(4) M-1 are estimated for Ca2+ and pdTp, respectively, and from the enthalpies at ligand saturation, binding enthalpies at 53 degrees C of -15.0 and -19.3 kcal mol-1.     

Affinity chromatography of trypsin and related enzymes. V. Basic studies of quantitative affinity chromatography.

A detailed study of the quantitative affinity chromatography of trypsin [EC 3.4.21.4] is reported here. Frontal chromatography using an enzyme solution of very low concentration on an affinity adsorbent gave the dissociation constant of the enzyme-immobilized ligand complex (Kd). Kd values determined under various conditions enabled us to discuss in detail the interaction of trypsin and affinity adsorbents (mainly Gly-Gly-Arg Sepharose). The pH dependence of Kd was consistent with that of the interaction of trypsin and product-type compounds. The effects of changes in temperature, ionic strength, dielectric constant, etc., were also studied. The Ki values of soluble competitive inhibitors can be determined by analysis of their effects on the elution volume of the enzyme. The values obtained were in good agreement with those obtained by kinetic analysis. The present method proved to be useful as a general procedure to investigate the interaction of a protein and a specific ligand.     

Shift in nucleotide conformational equilibrium contributes to increased rate of catalysis of GpAp versus GpA in barnase

The microbial ribonuclease barnase exhibits low catalytic activity toward GpN dinucleotides, where G is guanosine, p is phosphate and N represents any nucleoside. When a phosphate is added to the 3'-end, as in GpNp, substrate affinity is enhanced by one order of magnitude, and the catalytic rate by two. In order to gain insight into this phenomenon, we analyzed the nucleotide conformations and protein-nucleotide interactions of 4 ns molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories of complexes of barnase with guanylyl(3'-5') adenosine (GpA) and guanylyl(3'-5') adenosine 3'-monophosphate (GpAp), respectively, in the presence of solvent and counter ions. We found that, in a majority of the bound GpA conformations, the guanine base was firmly bound to the recognition site. The phosphate and adenosine moieties pointed into the solvent, and interactions with key catalytic residues were absent. In contrast, the bound GpAp adopted conformations in which all of the nucleotide portions remained tightly bound to the enzyme and interactions with key catalytic residues were maintained. These observations indicate that, for GpA, a significant proportion of the bound nucleotide adopts non-productive conformations and that adding the terminal phosphate as in GpAp shifts the equilibrium of the bound conformations towards structures capable of undergoing catalysis. Incorporating this property into the kinetic equations yields an increase in both the apparent rate constant (kcat) and the apparent dissociation constant (K(M)) for GpAp versus GpA. The increase in K(M), caused by the presence of additional non-productive binding modes for GpA, should however be counterbalanced by the propensity of free GpA to adopt folded conformations in solution, which are unable to bind the enzyme and by the tighter binding of GpAp (Giraldo J, Wodak SJ, Van Belle D. Conformational analysis of GpA and GpAp in aqueous solution by molecular dynamics and statistical methods. J Mol Biol 1998; 283:863-882). Addition of the terminal phosphate is shown to significantly influence the collective motion of the enzyme in a manner that fosters interactions with key catalytic residues, representing a further likely contribution to the catalytic rate enhancement.     

Interactions of iron bleomycin, phosphate or cyanide, and DNA: sequence-dependent conformations and reactions

The hypothesis was investigated that axial ligands bound to Fe(III)-bleomycin [Fe(III)Blm] are destabilized at specific 5'-guanine-pyrimidine-3' binding sites but are stable at nonselective dinucleotides. DNA oligomers and calf-thymus DNA were used in reactions with L-Fe(III)Blm, where phosphate and cyanide served as examples of large and small ligands (L). Both ligands underwent dissociation when L-Fe(III)Blm was bound to d(GGAAGCTTCC)2 (I) but not d(GGAAATTTCCC)2 (II) and at large ratios of calf-thymus DNA to drug. Fe(III)Blm is high spin in 20 mM phosphate buffer, signifying the presence of a phosphate adduct. In the titration of HPO4-Fe(III)Blm with calf-thymus DNA, a large excess of DNA was needed to reach the low-spin state, consistent with an equilibrium competition between phosphate and DNA for Fe(III)Blm. Equilibrium constants for binding Fe(III)Blm and CN-Fe(III)Blm to calf-thymus DNA (6.8x10(5) M(-1) and 5.9x10(4) M(-1), respectively, in HEPES buffer at 25 degrees C and pH 7.4) showed that the CN- ligand also reduced the affinity of DNA for the drug. The kinetics of dissociation of CN- from CN-Fe(III)Blm-DNA were slow and first order in bound drug. The reversible nature of these dissociation reactions was shown using 1H NMR spectroscopy of Fe(III)Blm-I in the absence and presence of large excesses of CN- or phosphate. The results are discussed in terms of a two-state hypothesis for the binding of L-Fe(III)Blm to specific and nonspecific dinucleotides. It is proposed that steric restrictions at specific sites inhibit binding of these ligands.     

Quantitative affinity chromatography of alpha-chymotrypsin

Affinity chromatography on a column of 4-phenylbutylamine, immobilized on succinylated polyacrylic hydrazide agarose, has been employed to study binding of ligands to α-chymotrypsin. In contrast to earlier studies of competitive elution phenomena, where an added soluble ligand interferes with enzyme binding to an affinity matrix, benzyloxycarbonyl derivatives of aromatic acids have been shown to facilitate binding of chymotrypsin to this matrix. This behavior has been analyzed in terms of an expanded binding scheme for affinity chromatography including the formation of a ternary complex (α-chymotrypsin · benzyloxycarbonyl-amino acid · 4-phenylbutylamine · matrix) where the soluble ligand and immobilized ligand bind to different sites. Equations to describe the phenonema have been derived and utilized to quantitate equilibrium constants for dissociation of the binary and ternary complexes. Benzyloxycarbonyl-Ala-Ala was found to promote earlier elution of the enzyme from its affinity matrix. Other ligands known to bind to the active site do not alter the binding to the 4-phenylbutylamine affinity matrix. These results illustrate the conclusion that binding of a small molecule can alter affinity retention in positive, negative, or neutral modes. This suggests that affinity chromatography could be “fine-tuned” by appropriate selection of cosolutes and illustrates the value of relatively weakly binding affinity matrices in enzyme studies.     

Detection and characterization of an additional site for binding of substrate and its analogs by inorganic pyrophosphatase

Phosphate, pyrophosphate, imidodiphosphate, EDTA and tripolyphosphate increase the rate constant for dissociation of the inorganic pyrophosphatase-substrate intermediate formed after cessation of the reaction by fluoride. The effect is enhanced in the given order 19-fold, the dependence of this effect on ligand concentration being hyperbolic. The values of the dissociation constants of the enzyme-ligand complexes lie within the concentration range of 0.16-1.0 mM. At high concentrations of Na2+ added simultaneously with the ligands this effect is decreased. The value of tau 1/2 for Pi binding to the enzyme-substrate compound is 0.15 min. The data obtained suggest that pyrophosphatase contains an anion ligand binding site, differing from that of the active one. This site does not affect the hydrolytic function of pyrophosphatase, as can be evidenced from the fact that Pi (9.5 mM) does not change the rate of enzymatic cleavage of PPi.     

The molecular dissociation of ferrihemoglobin derivatives.

Measurement of the dissociation constants of ferrihemoglobin by light scattering indicates that the quaternary structure is altered by the type of heme ligand. Fluoromethemoglobin and aquomethemoglobin, high spin derivatives with weak ligands, have tetramer-dimer dissociation constants of 80 and 50 muM, respectively. For low spin cyanmethemoglobin the dissociation constants were 1 muM (pH 6.0) and 3 muM (pH 9.0) under the general conditions of 0.1 ionic strength and 25 degrees. Of the ferrihemoglobins studied, alkaline methemoglobin (pH 9.0) has the lowest dissociation constant (0.2 muM). Dissociation constants of mixtures of alkaline and fluoromethemoglobin were significantly higher than that of the alkaline form alone. At pH 9.0 the 55 and 78% fluoride-bound derivatives had tetramer-dimer dissociation constants of 0.7 and 2 muM, respectively. The cyanmethemoglobin quaternary conformation was found to be less affected by pH than the fluoromethemoglobin and aquomethemoglobin conformations. Measurement of the dissociation constant (0.2 muM) for aquomethemoglobin-inositol hexaphosphate indicates stabilization of the tetramer by this organic phosphate. The extent of stabilization by inositol hexaphosphate does not appear to be that found for deoxyhemoglobin as suggested by Perutz (Perutz, M. F. (1972) Nature 237, 495-499) even though inducement of higher spin and iron-heme plane displacement may occur.     

Determination of rate constants for nucleotide dissociation from Na,K-ATPase.

A method for determining individual rate constants for nucleotide binding to and dissociation from membrane bound pig kidney Na,K-ATPase is presented. The method involves determination of the rate of relaxation when Na,K-ATPase in the presence of eosin is mixed with ADP or ATP in a stopped-flow fluorescence apparatus. It is shown that the nucleotide dependence of this rate of relaxation--taken together with measured equilibrium binding values for eosin and ADP--makes possible a reasonably reliable determination of the rate constant for dissociation of nucleotide, i.e., determination of the rate constant k-1 in the following model (where E denotes Na,K-ATPase): [formula: see text] All experiments are carried out at about 4 degrees C in a buffer containing 200 mM sucrose, 10 mM EDTA, 25 mM Tris and 73 mM NaCl (pH 7.4). Values obtained for the rate constants for dissociation are about 6 s-1 for ADP and 2-3 s-1 for ATP.     

Fluorescence study of the ligand stereospecificity for binding to lumazine protein.

6,7-Dimethyllumazine derivatives, substituted at the 8-position with aldityls or monohydroxyalkyl groups, have been examined for their binding ability to lumazine apo-protein from two strains of Photobacterium phosphoreum using fluorescence dynamics techniques. On the protein the lumazine has a nearly monoexponential decay of fluorescence with lifetime 13.8 ns (20 degrees C). In free solution the lifetime is 9.6 ns. The concentration of free and bound lumazine in an equilibrium mixture can be recovered readily by analysis of the fluorescence decay. Only the aldityl derivatives D-xylityl and 3'-deoxy-D-ribityl, having stereoconfigurations at the 2' and 4' positions identical to the natural ligand, 8-(1'-D-ribityl), show comparable dissociation constants (0.3 microM, 20 degrees C, pH 7.0). D-Erythrityl and L-arabityl have dissociation constants of 1-2 microM. All other ligands show no interaction at all or have dissociation constants in the range 6-80 microM, which can still be determined semi-quantitatively using the fluorescence decay technique. In the case of these very weakly bound ligands, unambiguous detection of bound ligand can be shown by a long correlation time (23 ns, 2 degrees C) for the fluorescence anisotropy decay. Examination of the bound D-xylityl compound's fluorescence anisotropy decay at high time resolution (< 100 ps) shows rigid association, i.e. no mobility independent of the macromolecule. All bound ligands appear to be similarly positioned in the binding site. The influence of the stereoconfiguration at the 8-position found for lumazine protein parallels that previously observed for the enzyme riboflavin synthase, where the lumazines are substrates or inhibitors. This is consistent with the finding of significant sequence similarity between these proteins. The binding rigidity may have implications for the mechanism of the enzyme.     

The crystal structure of staphylococcal nuclease refined at 1.7 A resolution

The crystal structure of staphylococcal nuclease has been determined to 1.7 A resolution with a final R-factor of 16.2% using stereochemically restrained Hendrickson-Konnert least-squares refinement. The structure reveals a number of conformational changes relative to the structure of the ternary complex of staphylococcal nuclease 1,2 bound with deoxythymidine-3',5'-diphosphate and Ca2+. Tyr-113 and Tyr-115, which pack against the nucleotide base in the nuclease complex, are rotated outward creating a more open binding pocket in the absence of nucleotide. The side chains of Ca2+ ligands Asp-21 and Asp-40 shift as does Glu-43, the proposed general base in the hydrolysis of the 5'-phosphodiester bond. The significance of some changes in the catalytic site is uncertain due to the intrusion of a symmetry related Lys-70 side chain which hydrogen bonds to both Asp-21 and Glu-43. The position of a flexible loop centered around residue 50 is altered, most likely due to conformational changes propagated from the Ca2+ site. The side chains of Arg-35, Lys-84, Tyr-85, and Arg-87, which hydrogen bond to the 3'- and 5'-phosphates of the nucleotide in the nuclease complex, are unchanged in conformation, with packing interactions with adjacent protein side chains sufficient to fix the geometry in the absence of ligand. The nuclease structure presented here, in combination with the stereochemically restrained refinement of the nuclease complex structure at 1.65 A, provides a wealth of structural information for the increasing number of studies using staphylococcal nuclease as a model system of protein structure and function.