Progress toward understanding the neurophysiological basis of predator-induced morphology in Daphnia pulex

Previous studies have demonstrated that certain pesticides, including carbaryl and endosulfan, can modulate the expression of predator-induced morphology in Daphnia. These pesticides affect the transmission of nervous impulses in vertebrates and invertebrates. The aim of this study was to determine the role of two neurotransmitter systems, excitatory cholinergic transmission and inhibitory gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-mediated transmission, in the regulation of inducible defenses of Daphnia. The effects of chemicals with four different modes of action on the expression of Chaoborus-induced neckteeth in Daphnia pulex were measured. These chemicals included chemicals that could enhance transmission at cholinergic synapses (physostigmine, nicotine), inhibit cholinergic transmission (atropine), stimulate or enhance the effects of GABA (diazepam, muscimol, cis-4-aminocrotonic acid), or antagonise the action of GABA (picrotoxin, bicuculline, SR95531). The development of Chaoborus-induced neckteeth in D. pulex was enhanced by physostigmine and picrotoxin and suppressed by atropine. It was proposed that these chemicals were acting on neurosecretory cells that release the hormones necessary to induce neckteeth development. The results also indicate mechanisms through which anthropogenic pollutants could influence the expression of inducible defenses, leading to inappropriate expression in environments with low predator intensity or to suppression in environments with high risks of predation.     

Waterborne metals impair inducible defences in Daphnia pulex: morphology, life-history traits and encounters with predators

1.  Inducible defences may be temporary and favoured where predation is intermittent and have been demonstrated in several invertebrates and vertebrates when prey detect chemical cues (kairomones) released by predators. Daphnia pulex (a water flea) exposed to Chaoborus (midge larvae) kairomones produce small neckteeth on the dorsal surface of the head as a defence against this gape-limited predator and survive better in the presence of Chaoborus . Recent studies have shown that waterborne copper (Cu) impairs the induction of neckteeth which could lead to lower survival.
2.  Here, we examined the effects of Cu on morphological changes and shifts in life-history traits in D. pulex exposed to kairomone from Chaoborus americanus . We exposed D. pulex mothers to chemical cues of C. americanus fed on either D. pulex neonates or on brine shrimp Artemia salina , the same Chaoborus cues combined with an environmentally relevant concentration of copper (10 μg L⁻¹), or dechlorinated tap water. We examined several morphological characteristics of neonates and life-historical characteristics of adults as well as assessing survival of neonates by staging encounters with predators.
3.  Neonates from mothers exposed to kairomone plus copper had fewer and shorter neckteeth than neonates from mothers exposed to kairomone alone. Moreover, neonates exposed to Cu had lower survival during encounters with predators than neonates exposed to kairomone without Cu.
4.  Adult female Daphnia exposed to kairomones released more neonates within the first 24 h of brood release and emptied their brood pouches quicker than mothers not exposed to kairomones, irrespective of the presence of Cu.
5.  Impairment by metals of morphological defences in zooplankton could lead to a decline in population density and alter community structure.     

Daphnia response to predation threat involves heat-shock proteins and the actin and tubulin cytoskeleton

Of all the environmental pressures that all organisms across all kingdoms must face, one of the greatest is the risk of predation. The unpredictability of predation events from the perspective of a single individual is one of the major components of a changing, unstable environment (Gliwicz and Pijanowska, 1989; Lampert, 1987). The panoply of antipredator defenses among terrestrial and aquatic organisms involves a variety of morphological, behavioral, and life-history adaptations that even if they are not life-saving, may enable organisms to complete reproduction before predation occurs. Most of these phenotypic changes are directly induced by cues associated with the biotic agent, in the case of aquatic organisms, the chemical compounds (kairomones) released by a predator into the water. Herein we show that exposure of Daphnia to invertebrate and vertebrate kairomones results in changes in motion, behavior, and life history and at the molecular level involves changes in heat-shock proteins (HSPs) level and the actin and tubulin cytoskeleton. In addition, some of these effects are transgenerational, i.e., they are passed on from the mother to her offspring.     

Genetic differentiation in life history between Daphnia galeata populations: an adaptation to local predation regimes?

Species of the water flea Daphnia exhibit constitutive as wellas phenotypically inducible anti-predator defence strategies,involving life history, morphological and behavioural traits.We explored the hypothesis of genetic differentiation in anti-predatordefence strategies using Daphnia clones originating from twodifferent water bodies: Tjeukemeer (the Netherlands) and FishPond (Belgium). Both water bodies are inhabited by zooplanktivorousfish. In contrast to Tjeukemeer, Fish Pond is also inhabitedby larvae of the phantom midge Chaoborus. The life history responsesof the two sets of clones to kairomones from fish (Perca), tokairomones from Chaoborus, and to a mixture of both were compared.Clones from Tjeukemeer and Fish Pond showed strong responsesto the presence of fish kairomone, with reductions in adultand neonate body length, in age at first reproduction and inthe total number of neonates produced during the first threeadult instars. Responses to Chaoborus kairomone were much lesspronounced, although there was a tendency towards an increasein the number of neonates in the first brood. Significant inter-populationgenetic differences were found for all the investigated traits.However, there was no indication for genetic adaptation of theFish Pond clones to negative size-selective predation by Chaoborus.Compared to Tjeukemeer clones, Fish Pond clones had a lowersize at first reproduction, produced smaller neonates and produceda higher number of neonates in their first brood. This suggestsadaptation to positive rather than to negative size selectivepredation. Genetic differences between populations were observedmainly for constitutive life history traits, rather than forphenotypic shifts in response to the presence of predator kairomones.     

Predation by chaoborids on typical and spined Daphnia pulex

SUMMARY. 1. In laboratory predation experiments, predation rates were determined for fourth-instar larvae of the chaoborids (Insecta: Diptera) Mochlonyx sp. and Chaoborus americanus preying on four juvenile instars and adult Daphnia pulex (clone SBL). In the case of Mochlonyx , predation was most intense on second-instar juvenile Daphnia while Chaoborus preyed equally on second and third instars.
2. Mochlonyx and Chaoborus induced an antipredator defence (neck-teeth) which was most frequently expressed in second-instar juvenile Daphnia . Expression of this antipredator phenotype was correlated with a reduced rate of Mochlonyx predation.     

Phenotypic plasticity of Daphnia life history traits: the roles of predation, food level and toxic cyanobacteria

1. We studied the life history responses of Daphnia pulex under different biotic conditions. In a factorially designed experiment, we tested the impacts of water conditioned by the invertebrate predator Chaoborus, low and high food level (10 000 and 100 000 Scenedesmus cells ml^–1), and exposure to toxic Microcystis (5000 cells ml^–1) on twelve D. pulex clones originating from different habitats. Our aim was to compare the phenotypic plasticity of different clones, and to study the interactions among biotic factors.
2. Individuals cultured in Chaoborus -conditioned water started to reproduce at a larger size than individuals cultured in water not conditioned by the predators. We found interactions between food level and Chaoborus -conditioned water on age at first reproduction and total offspring number. In addition, the impact of the Chaoborus treatment on the size at first reproduction was reduced by Microcystis exposure.
3. Clonal differences were found in the degree of phenotypic plasticity of different life history traits. However, there was no obvious connection between the original habitat of the clone and the degree of plasticity.     

Variation in the neonate size of Daphnia pulex: the effects of predator exposure and clonal origin

Daphnia pulex clones originating from twelve small pond habitats were exposed to chemical cues from a size-selective predator, larvae of the phantom midge Chaoborus. Exposure delayed the onset of reproduction and increased the size at first reproduction. On the other hand, the neonates produced by these larger mothers were slightly smaller than the neonates produced by the smaller control mothers. In cladocerans, neonate size is usually positively correlated to the size of the mother. Thus exposure to Chaoborus kairomone apparently had direct effects on neonate size counterbalancing the maternal effects. Daphnia clones collected from Chaoborus-free and Chaoborus-rich environments exhibited different responses. In first adult instar, the clones from Chaoborus inhabited environments increased their offspring size under Chaoborus exposure whereas clones from Chaoborus-free environments did not. This may reflect clonal adaptation to the predation prehistory of their original habitat since larger neonates more quickly reach a size protected from the predator.     

The supposed lack of trade-off among Daphnia galeata life history traits is explained by increased adult mortality in Chaoborus conditioned treatments

In recent years, some studies addressing the modification of phenotypically plastic traits of Daphnia in the presence of chemical cues (kairomones) from invertebrate predators have reported a lack of trade-off among resource allocation of traditional life history traits (growth and reproduction) (Spitze, 1991; Black, 1993; Weber & Declerck, 1997). In this study, we term this finding the `Chaoborus paradox'. The Chaoborus paradox contrasts with the generally accepted theory that facultative changes in life history traits are associated with costs or a modification in resource allocation. In order to unravel the Chaoborus paradox, we have tested four groups of traits that may explain resource allocation. These were (1) the trade-off between present and future reproduction, (2) reduced growth of morphological features (body length, helmet length, spine length, carapace width) prior to maturity (pre-maturity) or (3) during the first adult instar (at maturity), and (4) an increase in feeding and assimilation rates to fuel the amount of resources available to the organism. As experimental animal we used Daphnia galeata (Cladocera) and to simulate invertebrate predation we used the Chaoborus (phantom midge larvae) kairomone. A clear trade-off existed between present and future reproduction. Survival was less in the presence of Chaoborus kairomone and therefore more resources could be channelled into growth and reproduction early in life at the cost of dying younger when compared to control animals. The other groups of traits (reduced growth of morphological features and an increase the amount of resources) offer partial solutions to the Chaoborus paradox for single clones only and not for the whole population.     

Salamander predation and vertical distributions of zooplankton

SUMMARY. 1. The impact of different predation regimes of zooplanktivorous larval tiger salamanders, Ambystoma tigrinum nebulosum , on the vertical temporal distributions of Daphnia pulex, Diaptomus nudus and larval Chaoborus flavicans was studied in limnetic enclosures in a pond in east-central Arizona. Zooplankton densities were monitored 1-2 h before sunset, at sunset, and 1-2 h after sunset at three depths (0-0.4, 1.0 and 2.0 m) in four salamander treatments (0, 20, 40 salamanders per enclosure, and unenclosed limnetic areas).
2. Densities and body size of Daphnia pulex were consistently greater in salamander-free enclosures than in other treatments. More Daphnia were generally nearer the surface (0-1.0 m) than along the bottom before and at sunset than after sunset in enclosures without salamanders. After sunset, Daphnia was by far most dense along the bottom. Densities were uniform among depths and sample times in treatments with salamanders. Salamanders moved throughout the water column. Frequencies of D. pulex spined morphs (with prominent dorsal crest) did not differ among salamander treatments.
3. Chaoborus densities were positively correlated with D. pulex distributions among depths and sample times in treatments. Spatio-temporal distributions of Chaoborus were influenced more by their daphnid prey than by risk of predation from larval salamanders.
4. Densities of Diaptomus nudus were highest in open water controls and lowest in enclosures without salamanders. Diaptomus was generally more dense between 0 and 1 m than at 2.0 m depths in all treatments, and vertical distributions were not dependent on salamander density.     

Predator-induced phenotypic plasticity in the exotic cladoceran Daphnia lumholtzi

1. The exotic cladoceran Daphnia lumholtzi has recently invaded freshwater systems throughout the United States. Daphnia lumholtzi possesses extravagant head spines that are longer than those found on any other North American Daphnia. These spines are effective at reducing predation from many of the predators that are native to newly invaded habitats; however, they are plastic both in nature and in laboratory cultures. The purpose of this experiment was to better understand what environmental cues induce and maintain these effective predator‐deterrent spines. We conducted life‐table experiments on individual D. lumholtzi grown in water conditioned with an invertebrate insect predator, Chaoborus punctipennis, and water conditioned with a vertebrate fish predator, Lepomis macrochirus. 2. Daphnia lumholtzi exhibited morphological plasticity in response to kairomones released by both predators. However, direct exposure to predator kairomones during postembryonic development did not induce long spines in D. lumholtzi. In contrast, neonates produced from individuals exposed to Lepomis kairomones had significantly longer head and tail spines than neonates produced from control and Chaoborus individuals. These results suggest that there may be a maternal, or pre‐embryonic, effect of kairomone exposure on spine development in D. lumholtzi. 3. Independent of these morphological shifts, D. lumholtzi also exhibited plasticity in life history characteristics in response to predator kairomones. For example, D. lumholtzi exhibited delayed reproduction in response to Chaoborus kairomones, and significantly more individuals produced resting eggs, or ephippia, in the presence of Lepomis kairomones.     

From inducible defences to population dynamics: modelling refuge use and life history changes in Daphnia

We investigated the relative importance of a behavioural defence (refuge use through diel vertical migration) and a life history change (a reduced size at first reproduction) that are used by daphnids to decrease the risk of predation by visually hunting fish. We used an individual based model of a Daphnia population in a stratified lake to quantify the effects of these inducible defences on Daphnia predation-mortality and the resulting Daphnia population dynamics. Our analysis shows that diel vertical migration (DVM) confers a much stronger protection against fish predation than a reduced size at first reproduction (SFR). DVM allows daphnids to withstand a higher predation pressure in the epilimnion and it decelerates a Daphnia population decline more strongly than a reduced SFR. DVM effectively reduces the (P/B) flow of carbon from daphnids to fish.
Many theoretical studies have only considered the fitness benefits of DVM above 'staying up' in the epilimnion of a lake. Our results suggest that 'staying down' in the hypolimnion would confer an even stronger fitness benefit to Daphnia than DVM at times of peak predation risk. Daphnids that remain in the hypolimnion avoid the predation suffered by migrating daphnids around dusk and dawn. Staying down could prevent a Daphnia population decline, while DVM and a reduced SFR can only decelerate the decrease of Daphnia population densities under heavy fish predation. Staying down at high concentrations of fish infochemicals has in fact been observed within a variety of Daphnia clones and species, both in the laboratory and in stratified lakes.     

Vertical distribution of pelagial zooplankton in a middle-sized dimictic valley reservoir

Our observations indicate the vertical distribution of zooplankton and its seasonal changes in Dubník II reservoir (Slovakia) are determined mainly by the thermal regime of the reservoir, by transparency, and by fish and invertebrate predation. During periods of circulation, zooplankton vertical distribution in the whole water column was more homogeneous, whilst during summer temperature stratification zooplankton concentrated in the epilimnion — rotifers in higher layers than crustaceans. During summer stagnation a steep thermal gradient occurred at the boundary of the epi-and hypolimnion and low temperature and low dissolved oxygen in hypolimnion offered a refuge for Chaoborus flavicans larvae against fish, enabling coexistence of vertebrate and invertebrate predation. This evidence supports our previous findings concerning dominance of rotifers in zooplankton and representation of crustaceans by small-bodied species in the study reservoir. Steep thermal gradient and the presence of Chaoborus larvae caused very low zooplankton abundance in the lower part of the water column and a reduction of cladocerans refuges against fish to layers of thermocline or closely under thermocline where Daphnia cucullata and Daphnia parvula were found. Our previous assumptions about the high density of zooplanktivorous fish in Dubník II reservoir are supported by the fact that these small cladocerans are represented by smaller individuals in the upper layers and bigger individuals in deeper layers.     

Components of additive variance in life-history traits of Daphnia hyalina: seasonal differences in the response to predator signals

We attempted to separate the additive variance of life-history parameters (size at first reproduction (SFR), proportion of total production allocated to reproduction) of Daphnia hyalina in a mesotrophic lake during different seasons into genetic components and phenotypic plasticity. Every month we randomly isolated juveniles of 20 clones from the lake and measured their life-history parameters immediately after isolation, i.e., under the influence of all modifying factors in the lake. The measurements were repeated after the clones had been kept in the laboratory for at least six generations without predator signals (controls) and with the addition of fish and Chaoborus kairomones. SFR increased monotonously from July to December in fresh field isolates. Laboratory controls showed always much larger SFR, but approached field value in December. Most of the size difference was due to maternal effects. Reproductive allocation showed a different pattern than SFR with a minimum in September both in field samples and laboratory controls. Fish kairomone reduced SFR in July and August when fish predation is high, but not later in the year. On the contrary, Chaoborus kairomone increased SFR in September and October when Chaoborus larvae are abundant in the lake, but not in summer. This indicates a seasonal shift in the clonal composition of D. hyalina populations towards clones adapted to the specific predation pressure. Reproductive allocation changed in response to fish kairomone in July and August, but not in response to Chaoborus kairomone. In this mesotrophic lake, fish have a stronger direct and indirect impact on Daphnia life history than Chaoborus larvae.     

Phylogenetics of pond and lake lifestyles in Chaoborus midge larvae

Abstract . Aquatic invertebrates experience strong trade-offs between habitats due to the selective effects of different predators. Diel vertical migration and small body size are thought to be effective strategies against fish predation in lakes. In the absence of fish in small ponds, migration is ineffective against invertebrate predators and large body size is an advantage. Although widely discussed, this phenomenon has never been tested in a phylogenetic context. We reconstructed a mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) tree to investigate the phylogenetic distribution of pond and lake lifestyles among 10 species of northern temperate Chaoborus midge larvae. The mtDNA tree is similar to previous morphological trees for Chaoborus , the only difference being the disruption of the subgenus Chaoborus sensu stricto. At least three shifts have occurred between pond and lake lifestyles, each time associated with evolution of diel vertical migration in the lake taxon. The trend in larval body size with habitat type is sensitive to tree and character reconstruction methods, only weakly consistent with the effects of fish predation. Despite long time periods over which adaptation to each habitat type could have occurred, there remains significant phylogenetic heritability in larval body size. The tree provides a framework for comparative studies of the metapopulation genetic consequences of pond and lake lifestyles.     

Reciprocity in predator–prey interactions: exposure to defended prey and predation risk affects intermediate predator life history and morphology

A vast body of literature exists documenting the morphological, behavioural and life history changes that predators induce in prey. However, little attention has been paid to how these induced changes feed back and affect the predators’ life history and morphology. Larvae of the phantom midge Chaoborus flavicans are intermediate predators in a food web with Daphnia pulex as the basal resource and planktivorous fish as the top predator. C. flavicans prey on D. pulex and are themselves prey for fish; as D. pulex induce morphological defences in the presence of C. flavicans this is an ideal system in which to evaluate the effects of defended prey and top predators on an intermediate consumer. We assessed the impact on C. flavicans life history and morphology of foraging on defended prey while also being exposed to the non-lethal presence of a top fish predator. We tested the basic hypothesis that the effects of defended prey will depend on the presence or absence of top predator predation risk. Feeding rate was significantly reduced and time to pupation was significantly increased by defended morph prey. Gut size, development time, fecundity, egg size and reproductive effort respond to fish chemical cues directly or significantly alter the relationship between a trait and body size. We found no significant interactions between prey morph and the non-lethal presence of a top predator, suggesting that the effects of these two biological factors were additive or singularly independent. Overall it appears that C. flavicans is able to substantially modify several aspects of its biology, and while some changes appear mere consequences of resource limitation others appear facultative in nature.     

Alternative antipredator responses of two coexisting Daphnia species to negative size selection by YOY perch

Our study showed for the first time in nature that two coexistingDaphnia adopted alternative life history and behavioural strategiesto cope with negative size-selection predation by gape-limitedyoung-of-the-year (YOY) perch. We evaluated the phenotypic plasticityin life history and behavioural traits of two coexisting Daphniaspecies, D. pulicaria (2 mm) and D. galeata mendotae (1.4 mm),in response to seasonal changes in predation by YOY yellow perch(Perca flavescens) in a mesotrophic lake. We expected that thelarge-sized D. pulicaria, the most likely subjected to size-selectivepredation by YOY perch, will show stronger antipredator responsesthan the small-sized D. galeata mendotae. To test this hypothesis,we examined changes in life history and behavioural traits injuveniles and adults of both species during four YOY fish predationperiods that were selected based on the presence of YOY perchin the pelagic zone and the relative abundance of Daphnia preyin their gut contents. Our study supports the scenario of negativesize-selective predation by gape-limited YOY perch on both Daphniaspecies. The electivity index indicated that no daphnids witha body length > 1.75 mm were predated by YOY yellow perch.Coexisting Daphnia exhibited phenotypic plasticity in theirantipredator defenses based on their vulnerability to seasonalchanges in size-selective predation of YOY perch. Juvenile Daphniawere the targeted prey and they responded by a decreased bodylength. Behavioural defenses were the dominant strategy usedby both adult Daphnia populations to withstand high predation.A decreased size at maturity was not employed by Daphnia, exceptat the very end of the predation period. Behavioural defensesare short-term strategy adopted to avoid predation. Both antipredatordefenses became unnecessary expenses and were no longer sustainedafter the predation period.     

Behavioural response of Daphnia to olfactory cues from food, competitors and predators

The behavioural response of the freshwater zooplankter Daphniato chemicals from its food, the green alga Scenedesmus, to algalcells, to the green colour from chlorophyll, to chemicals releasedfrom congeners and conspecifics, and to chemicals released frominvertebrate (Chaoborus) and vertebrate predators (Leuciscus)was investigated in a Y-tube olfactometer. No preference wasobserved either for medium that had contained algae, or formedium with algal cells or with the green colour of algae, offeredas alternatives to clean medium. In contrast, swimming speedwas significantly reduced at high algal concentrations and inthe presence of green colour. Moreover, starved animals hadlost their rheotaxis. Neither Daphnia magna nor Daphnia pulexhad a preference for either clean medium or medium that hadcontained conspecifics, but D. magna significantly chose cleanmedium when medium which had been inhabited by D. pulex wasthe alternative. No avoidance of medium from Chaoborus cultureswas found, but D. magna significantly avoided medium that hadbeen inhabited by ides (Leuciscus idus L.). The responses observedcould result in aggregation of animals by reduced swimming speedat high algal densities and by avoidance of areas with predators.When these cues have become less important due to food depletionand decreased predation pressure, the interspecific-competitor-relatedcues might result in desegregation.     

Embryological aspects of inducible morphological defenses in Daphnia

Many cases of predator-induced morphological plasticity in daphnids are well studied examples of inducible defenses. However, little is known about the early development of these sometimes conspicuous traits. We compared for the first time in five different Daphnia species the embryonic development of predator-induced and noninduced animals using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). We observed significant morphological changes in the last embryonic stage in helmet formation in Daphnia cucullata and in neck-pedestal development in Daphnia pulex. In contrast, no morphological changes could be found during embryogenesis between induced and noninduced Daphnia lumholtzi, D. longicephala, and D. ambigua. Strategies for initiating the defensive traits differ among Daphnia species because of trade-offs between environmental requirements and developmental constraints. Some general features of Daphnia embryonic development are described using SEM. All Daphnia embryos have to shed at least three different membranes before leaving the brood pouch of the mother. After the embryos shed the third membrane, chemosensillae that are likely able to detect predator-released chemicals are exposed to the olfactory environment.     

Effects of turbidity on life history parameters of two species of Daphnia

SUMMARY. 1. Life table experiments were carried out in a range of turbidities on D. pulex , representing a 'clear-water', and on D. barbata , representing a 'turbid-water' species.
2. In contrast to predictions based on seasonal occurrence patterns, D. pulex had a higher intrinsic rate of increase ( r _c)s over most of the turbidity range than D. barbata. Consistent differences in life history between the two species were found, but life history characteristics were rather insensitive to turbidity levels. Although turbidity per se appears to have little direct effect on life history parameters, it could influence the seasonal succession of these two species by interacting with other factors.
3. It is suggested that visual predation by fish rather than turbidity per se probably influenced the seasonality of Daphnia species. During the warmer months, selective removal of D. pulex by visually foraging fishes may allow D. barbata to gain dominance. Effects of temperature and nutrition also merit further study.     

Cyclomorphosis in Daphnia galeata mendotae Birge and D. retrocurva Forbes as a predator-induced response

SUMMARY. 1. Populations of Daphnia galeata mendotae and D. retrocurva were exposed for one generation to predators enclosed in mesh bags. The exposed Daphnia showed adaptive morphological changes that mimic cyclomorphosis in nature. The invertebrate predators Chaoborus and Notonecta induced longer helmets, while the fish Lepomis induced shorter bodies but had no effect on helmet length. Longer tail spines (relative to body length) were induced by Notonecta and Lepomis.
2. The responses of D. retrocurva were influenced by algae concentration, with the more extreme responses occurring at a higher food concentration and higher lipid index.