The right-handed slanting of Arabidopsis thaliana roots is due to the combined effects of positive gravitropism,circumnutation and thigmotropism

When primary Arabidopsis roots grow down a tilted agar plate, they do not elongate following the gravitational vector along a straight line, but instead they slant noticeably to the right-hand. This process is seen mostly in the ecotypes Wassilewskjia and Landsberg, whereas it is attenuated in the ecotype Columbia, and in some mutants is even inverted. The origin of the slanting of Arabidopsis roots, that evidently constitutes a form of chirality, has so far not been sufficiently clarified. In the present paper we describe it as the general result of the cumulative effects of positive gravitropism, circumnutation and a thigmotropic obstacle-avoiding movement, and in particular, as the consequence of the alternating movement of circumnutation of the root to the right and to the left of the gravitational vector. This movement, which does not appear symmetrical in its nature, since the waves made to the right-hand are complete whereas those made to the left-hand are reduced or aborted, appears to be the reason for the observed slanting. In addition, evidence is furnished supporting the hypothesis that the strong left-handed cell-files torsion, seen in right-handed coiling roots, is not the consequence of a primary process, but of an artifact, and is due to the adjustment of the three dimensional root circumnutating helix to the flat two dimensional agar surface.     

Chiral and non-chiral nutations in Arabidopsis roots grown on the random positioning machine

Arabidopsis thaliana roots grown on a vertically set plate do not elongate straight down the gravitational vector, but by making waves and coils, and by conspicuously slanting towards the right-hand. This behaviour, in a previous paper, was ascribed to the simultaneous effect of three processes: circumnutation, positive gravitropism and negative thigmotropism. However, when the plants are grown on the Random Positioning Machine (RPM), in conditions that are believed to simulate space microgravitational conditions closely, the roots do not show the usual pattern. In the wild type, the roots make large loops to the right-hand side, whereas in the gravitropic and auxinic mutants aux1, eir1, rha1, they just move randomly around the initial direction. Therefore, if the movements made on the RPM are those produced by the exclusion of gravitropism and negative thigmotropism, as is apparent, the conclusion is that Arabidopsis roots are animated by a form of chiral circumnutation, that is lacking in the auxinic and gravitropic mutants aux1, eir1 and rha1. In addition, the 1 g condition appears to reduce the scatter among the circumnutating tracks produced by the roots of the wild types, but not among those of the mutants. Because there is a scarcity of literature regarding circumnutation in roots, it is not known how widely root chiral circumnutation is spread, but it is known that, in some previously studied species, just random nutations are observed. Two kinds of nutating movements seem to exist in plant roots and, whereas the random process does not seem to be connected with auxin physiology and transport, the chiral process appears to be connected in the same way as gravitropism is.     

Rha1, a new mutant of Arabidopsis disturbed in root slanting,gravitropism and auxin physiology

A new Arabidopsis mutant is characterized (rha1) that shows, in the roots, reduced right-handed slanting, reduced gravitropism and resistance to 2,4-D, TIBA, NPA and ethylene. It also shows reduced length in the shoot and root, reduced number of lateral roots and shorter siliques. The gene was cloned through TAIL-PCR and resulted in a HSF. Because none of the known gravitropic and auxinic mutants result from damage in a HSF, rha1 seems to belong to a new class of this group of mutants. Quantitative PCR analysis showed that the expression of the gene is increased by heat and cold shock, and by presence of 2,4-D in the media. Study of the expression through the GUS reporter gene revealed increased expression in clinostated and gravistimulated plants, but only in adult tissues, and not in the apical meristems of shoots and roots.Key words: auxin, ethylene, slanting, gravitropism, HSFsArabidopsis primary roots, and especially those from some ecotypes (Ws, Landsberg), when grown on an agar dish, tilted on the vertical, show a wavy pattern, and a clear slanting towards a direction that has been considered the right-hand.^1–4 In the case of the mutant rha1, the right-handed slanting is notably reduced, its primary roots growing partly to the right-hand, partly straight down and partly to the left-hand, even though a slight preference for the right-hand is apparent.In addition, its roots show resistance to the inhibitory action of the auxin 2,4-D, ethylene (ACC), and the auxin transport inhibitors TIBA and NPA. These characteristics qualify the mutant as an auxinic one, and therefore a connection between the reduced slanting and the auxinic disturbances could be imagined. It is not known, however, what controls the slanting process itself, even though it appears as the consequence of a chiral circumnutational process. As reported,⁴ it seems the result of a chiral circumnutation with preference for the right-hand, transformed in a lateral slanting movement, because of the impact of the helix with the hard agar surface. This process results in the formation of waves, when the circumnutation helix impactig the agar reverses direction at every half turn, or the formation of large loops and strict loops (coils) when there is no reversion. The latter case seems to be a consequence of the fact that gravity is no longer “felt”. This has been previously noted in some mutants, or sometimes in old roots.rha1 is not the only mutant known to show reduction or increase of slanting, because other mutants were reported by Rutherford and Masson,³ and subsequent publications from the same group. Almost all show an increase of slant, with the exception of rhd3 and its alleles that show a complete suppression of the process.⁵ The mutated gene in rha1 was cloned through TAIL-PCR and shown to be a HSF. No other auxinic mutant, among those for which the gene was cloned, is known to be mutated in a HSF.HSFs, that are characteristically involved in the activation of the HSPs (heat shock proteins), which protect the cells from damage arising from high temperature and other stresses, have been shown to be involved also in different processes.^6,7 Hence, also in the case of rha1, we can well imagine other different functions, beside that of counteracting the heat shock. In particular, since the connection with auxin regulated processes is evident, we can suppose that the action could be on the PP2A phosphatase, as in the case of the rcn1 mutant, or of the human HSF2. The RCN1 protein corresponds to one unit of the PP2A,⁸ and the HSF2⁹ has been shown to substitute itself for the C subunit and alter the function of the phosphatase (Fig. 1). Experiments directed to see if a heat shock can modify the slanting of the roots in the wild-type and rha1, gave negative results, even though these experiments will need to be repeated under more widely ranging conditions. These results seem to indicate that the mechanism which induces asymmetric growth in roots is complex, and it is not controlled by a single gene.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Model proposed for the regulation of the PP2A activity by the RHA1 protein. (modified after Hong and Sarge, 1999).On the other hand, another puzzling characteristic of rha1 is the fact that its roots are resistant only to the auxin 2,4-D, and not to NAA and IAA. Differences in the response of the primary roots to different auxins have already been reported, and it was suggested that the response to NAA should be different, because this substance can penetrate passively the cell membranes.¹⁰ In the case of rha1, however, it seems that IAA can also penetrate the cells passively. This is in line with the chemiosmotic hypothesis,¹¹ but seems in contrast with the previous supposition. The resistance to ethylene, however, could indicate that the reduced inhibitory effect of 2,4-D is a consequence of the ethylene production induced by the synthetic auxin. On the other hand, the resistance to the auxin transport inhibitors TIBA and NPA, cannot be explained so easily. Possibly, in the mutant rha1, there is a reduced level of receptors for the considered substances.Using semiquantitative PCR analysis it was shown that rha1 retains the function of a HSF, the gene being clearly upregulated by heat and cold stress, and also by 2,4-D, but not by rotation on a clinostat or gravistimulation. The upregulation of the expression by 2,4-D was confirmed by a study of GUS expression in a transformed rha1, and with this technique the effects of gravity and simulated microgravity appeared clearly stimulatory too. No GUS expression however was apparent in the shoot and root meristems, and consequently we propose that the gene does not influence the first part of the graviresponse, but possibly the general transport of auxin through the plant.Thus, the mutant seems to be disturbed in root gravitropism, as well as in responses to the auxines and circumnutation. However not in the general circumnutation process, but in its chiral aspect, which is the cause of the slanting to the right-hand. Gravitropism, circumnutation and auxin physiology, thus, seem to be in some way connected in a complex integrated process, that, hopefully, will be gradually revealed in all its different aspects, through the future efforts of plant scientists.     

Two Agents in the Brain: Motor Control of Unimanual and Bimanual Reaching Movements

Previous studies have suggested that the left and right hands have different specialties for motor control that can be represented as two agents in the brain. This study examined how coordinated movements are performed during bimanual reaching tasks to highlight differences in the characteristics of the hands. We examined motor movement accuracy, reaction time, and movement time in right-handed subjects performing a three-dimensional motor control task (visually guided reaching). In the no-visual-feedback condition, right-hand movement had lower accuracy and a shorter reaction time than did left-hand movement, whereas bimanual movement had the longest reaction time, but the best accuracy. This suggests that the two hands have different internal models and specialties: closed-loop control for the right hand and open-loop control for the left hand. Consequently, during bimanual movements, both models might be used, creating better control and planning (or prediction), but requiring more computation time compared to the use of one hand only.     

Motor unit activity during stereotyped finger tasks and computer mouse work.

Motor unit (MU) activity pattern was examined in the right-hand extensor digitorum communis muscle (EDC) during standardised finger movements simulating actual computer mouse tasks. Intramuscular recordings were performed with a quadripolar needle electrode. Nine women performed four lifts of their right-hand index finger, middle finger or both as well as a number of double clicks. Additionally, the subjects performed contra lateral activity with their left-hand fingers and for three subjects recordings were also obtained during an interview with no physical activity. Besides the expected close coupling of MU activity with finger movement, activity was observed in three different situations with no physical requirements. Attention related activity was found before or after performance of the finger movement task, contra lateral activity in right EDC during left-hand finger tasks, and activity during mental activity without any finger movements involved. A relatively large number of doublet occurrences suggest they are a natural part of the activation pattern during performance of the rapid finger movement required to perform an efficient double click on the computer mouse.     

A pleiotropic Arabidopsis thaliana mutant with inverted root chirality

Circumnutation is an oscillating movement of a growing plant organ that is believed to result from an endogenous rhythmic process intrinsic to growth. Circumnutating organs, as they extend, describe a helical trace. In Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. circumnutation is particularly evident in primary roots and occurs, as in most plants, in a right-handed direction when viewed from above in the direction of the growing tips. We have discovered a pleiotropic mutant of Arabidopsis with left-handed root circumnutation. Major abnormalities of the mutant are: (i) a reduced size of all organs, mainly due to a defect in cell elongation or expansion; (ii) a zigzagging pattern of stem pith cells, reminiscent of the “erectoides” phenotype of the lk mutant of Pisum; (iii) roots of the mutant are gravitropic but as they grow, they form tight, left-handed coils. Genetically, the mutant depends on the presence of two independent monogenic recessive factors acting additively. The mutant alleles of both factors alter the growth of the aerial organs in a similar manner but differ at the root level: one mainly produces non-circumnutating roots, the other changes the direction of circumnutation from right to left hand. Received: 18 July 1996 / Accepted: 30 November 1996     

Influence of "prehistory" of sequential movements of the right and the left hand on reproduction: coding of positions, movements and sequence structure

The dependence of errors during reproduction of a sequence of hand movements without visual feedback on the previous right- and left-hand performance ("prehistory") and on positions in space of sequence elements (random or ordered by the explicit rule) was analyzed. It was shown that the preceding information about the ordered positions of the sequence elements was used during right-hand movements, whereas left-hand movements were performed with involvement of the information about the random sequence. The data testify to a central mechanism of the analysis of spatial structure of sequence elements. This mechanism activates movement coding specific for the left hemisphere (vector coding) in case of an ordered sequence structure and positional coding specific for the right hemisphere in case of a random sequence structure.     

The reorganization of bimanual movements during formation of a lateralized motor food skill in rats

After 48 h food deprivation adult Wistar rats were trained to obtain food from a narrow tube feeder using the forepaw under conditions of free choice of limb. At the initial stage of training animals use both paws: the grasping and extraction with one paw can be alternated with food grasping and extraction with another paw, and both paws can be alternately involved in movements preceding this grasping. Character of reorganization of bimanual movements was analyzed during training rats with different motor preference (right-handed and left-handed animals). It was shown that in the process of acquisition of both right- and left-hand skills, bimanual reactions in the anticipating attempts disappeared later than in the final successful movements. The disappearance of bimanual movements in the anticipating attempts is considered as an index of the maximum skill lateralization and acquisition of a novel lateralized movement coordination. The results suggest that left-handed rats more rapidly learn a novel movement coordination than right-handed animals.     

Influence of electrical fields and asymmetric application of mucilage on curvature of primary roots of Zea mays

Primary roots of Zea mays cv. Yellow Dent growing in an electric field curve towards the anode. Roots treated with EDTA and growing in electric field do not curve. When root cap mucilage is applied asymmetrically to tips of vertically-oriented roots, the roots curve toward the mucilage. Roots treated with EDTA curve toward the side receiving mucilage and toward blocks containing 10 mM CaCl2, but not toward "empty" agar blocks or the cut surfaces of severed root tips. These results suggest that 1) free calcium (Ca) is necessary for root electrotropism, 2) mucilage contains effector(s) that induce gravitropiclike curvature, and 3) mucilage can replace gravitropic effectors chelated by EDTA. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the downward movement of gravitropic effectors to the lower sides of tips of horizontally-oriented roots occurs at least partially in the apoplast.     

Hydrotropism in roots: sensing of a gradient in water potential by the root cap

Roots of the agravitropic pea (Pisum sativum L.) mutant, ageotropum, responded to a gradient in water potential as small as 0.5 MPa by growing toward the higher water potential. This positive response occurred when a sorbitol-containing agar block was unilaterally applied to the root cap but not when applied to the elongation region. Unilateral application of higher concentrations of sorbitol to the elongation region caused root curvature toward the sorbitol source, presumably because of growth reduction on the water-stressed side. The control blocks of plain agar applied to either the root cap or the elongation region did not cause significant curvature of the roots. These results demonstrate that hydrotropism in roots occurs following perception of a gradient in water potential by the root cap.     

The SPIRAL genes are required for directional control of cell elongation in Aarabidopsis thaliana

Cells at the elongation zone expand longitudinally to form the straight central axis of plant stems, hypocotyls and roots, and transverse cortical microtubule arrays are generally recognized to be important for the anisotropic growth. Recessive mutations in either of two Arabidopsis thaliana SPIRAL loci, SPR1 or SPR2, reduce anisotropic growth of endodermal and cortical cells in roots and etiolated hypocotyls, and induce right-handed helical growth in epidermal cell files of these organs. spr2 mutants additionally show right-handed twisting in petioles and petals. The spr1spr2 double mutant's phenotype is synergistic, suggesting that SPR1 and SPR2 act on a similar process but in separate pathways in controlling cell elongation. Interestingly, addition of a low dose of either of the microtubule-interacting drugs propyzamide or taxol in the agar medium was found to reduce anisotropic expansion of endodermal and cortical cells at the root elongation zone of wild-type seedlings, resulting in left-handed helical growth. In both spiral mutants, exogenous application of these drugs reverted the direction of the epidermal helix, in a dose-dependent manner, from right-handed to left-handed; propyzamide at 1 microM and taxol at 0.2-0.3 microM effectively suppressed the cell elongation defects of spiral seedlings. The spr1 phenotype is more pronounced at low temperatures and is nearly suppressed at high temperatures. Cortical microtubules in elongating epidermal cells of spr1 roots were arranged in left-handed helical arrays, whereas the highly isotropic cortical cells of etiolated spr1 hypocotyls showed microtubule arrays with irregular orientations. We propose that a microtubule-dependent process and SPR1/SPR2 act antagonistically to control directional cell elongation by preventing elongating cells from potential twisting. Our model may have implicit bearing on the circumnutation mechanism.     

Consistent handedness of microtubule helical arrays in maize and Arabidopsis primary roots

Summary The orientation of cortical microtubules in plant cells has been extensively studied, in part because of their influence on the expansion of most plant cell types. Cortical microtubules are often arranged in helical arrays, which are well known to occur with a specific pitch as a function of development or experimental treatment; however, it is not known if the handedness of helical arrays can also be specified. We have studied the handedness of helical arrays by using Vibratome sectioning of maize primary roots and confocal microscopy of Arabidopsis primary roots. In cortical cells of maize roots, the helical array was found to have the same handedness at a given position, not only for the cells of a single root, but also for the cells of more than one hundred roots examined. Quantification of angular distribution of apparent individual microtubules showed that defined regions of the root were composed of cells with highly uniform microtubule orientation. In the region between transverse and longitudinal microtubules (5–10.5 mm from the tip), the array formed a right-handed helix, and basal of cells with longitudinal microtubules (11.5–15 mm from the tip), the array formed a left-handed helix. Similarly, in epidermal cells of Arabidopsis roots right-handed helical arrays were found in the region between transverse and longitudinal microtubules. These results suggest that, in addition to the orientation of microtubules, the handedness of helical microtubule arrays is under cellular control.Abbreviations Cy3 indocarbocyanine - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - PIPES piperazine-N,N-bis-[2-ethanesulfonic acid]     

Gravity-Induced Polar Transport of Calcium across Root Tips of Maize

Calcium movement across primary roots of maize (Zea mays, L.) was determined by application of ⁴⁵Ca²⁺ to one side of the root and collection of radioactivity in an agar receiver block on the opposite side. Ca movement across the root tip was found to be at least 20 times greater than movement across the elongation zone. The rapid movement of Ca across the tip was severely inhibited in roots from which the root cap had been removed. Ca movement across the tip was also strongly retarded in roots pretreated with 2,4-dinitrophenol or potassium cyanide. Orientation of roots horizontally had no effect on Ca movement across the elongation zone but caused a strong asymmetry in the pattern of Ca movement across the tip. In gravistimulated roots, the movement of Ca from top to bottom increased while movement from bottom to top decreased. The data indicate that gravistimulation induces polar movement of Ca toward the lower side of the root cap. An earlier report (Lee, Mulkey, Evans 1983 Science 220: 1375-1376) from this laboratory showed that artificial establishment of calcium gradients at the root tip can cause gravitropic-like curvature. Together, the two studies indicate that Ca plays a key role in linking gravistimulation to the gravitropic growth response in roots.     

Polar Transport of Auxin across Gravistimulated Roots of Maize and Its Enhancement by Calcium

The effect of Ca on the polar movement of [³H]indoleacetic acid ([³H] IAA) in gravistimulated roots was examined using 3-day-old seedlings of maize (Zea mays L.). Transport of label was measured by placing an agar donor block containing [³H]IAA on one side of the elongation zone and measuring movement of label across the root into an agar receiver block on the opposite side. In vertically oriented roots, movement of label across the elongation zone into the receiver was slight and was not enhanced by incorporating 10 millimolar CaCl₂ into the receiver block. In horizontally oriented roots, movement of label across the root was readily detectable and movement to a receiver on the bottom was about 3-fold greater than movement in the opposite direction. This polarity was abolished in roots from which the caps were removed prior to gravistimulation. When CaCl₂ was incorporated into the receivers, movement of label across horizontally oriented intact roots was increased about 3-fold in both the downward and upward direction. The ability of Ca to enhance the movement of label from [³H]IAA increased with increasing Ca concentration in the receiver up to 5 to 10 millimolar CaCl₂. With the inclusion of CaCl₂ in the receiver blocks, gravity-induced polar movement of label into receiver blocks from applied [³H]IAA was detectable within 30 minutes, and asymmetric distribution of label within the tissue was detectable within 20 minutes. The results indicate that gravistimulation induces a physiological asymmetry in the auxin transport system of maize roots and that Ca increases the total transport of auxin across the root.     

Movement of calcium across tips of primary and lateral roots of Phaseolus vulgaris

Calcium (Ca) movement across tips of primary and lateral roots of Phaseolus vulgaris was determined by applying 45Ca2+ to one side of the root and collecting radioactivity in an agar receiver block on the opposite side of the root. The ratios of cpm in receiver blocks on the bottom of primary roots : cpm in receiver blocks on the top of the primary roots were 1.87 and 2.47 after 1 and 2 hr, respectively. This polar transport of Ca across tips of primary roots correlated positively with a graviculture of 43 degrees after 2 hr. The ratio of cpm in receiver blocks on the bottom of lateral roots : cpm in receiver blocks on the top of lateral roots was 1.20 after 2 hr. The decreased polar movement of Ca across tips of lateral roots correlated positively with lateral roots being nongraviresponsive. These data 1) support the suggestion that gravistimulation induces polar movement Ca toward the lower side of tips of primary roots, and 2) suggest that the reduced polar movement of Ca across tips of lateral roots may be involved in uncoupling gravistimulation from gravicurvature in lateral roots.     

Development of left/right handedness in the chick heart.

The chick heart tube develops from the fusion of the right and left areas of precardiac mesoderm and in almost all cases loops to the embryo's right-hand side. We have investigated whether any intrinsic difference exists in the right and left areas of precardiac mesoderm, that influences the direction of looping of the heart tube. Chick embryos incubated to stages 4,5 and 6 were cultured by the New method. Areas of precardiac mesoderm were exchanged between donor and host embryos of the same stage and different stages to form control, double-right and double-left sided embryos. Overall, double-right sided embryos formed many more left-hand loops than double-left sided embryos. At stages 4 and 5 a small percentage of double-right embryos formed left-hand loops (13%) whereas at stage 6 almost 50% of hearts had left-hand loops. Control embryos formed right-hand loops in 97% of cases. The stability of right-hand heart looping by double-left sided embryos, may be related to the process of 'conversion', whereas the direction of looping by double-right sided embryos has become randomised. There is some indication that an intrinsic change occurred in the precardiac mesoderm between stages 5 and 6 that later influenced the direction of looping of the heart tube. The direction of body turning is suggested to be linked to the direction of heart looping.     

Coordinated, long-range, solid substrate movement of the purple photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus

The long-range movement of Rhodobacter capsulatus cells in the glass-agar interstitial region of borosilicate Petri plates was found to be due to a subset of the cells inoculated into plates. The macroscopic appearance of plates indicated that a small group of cells moved in a coordinated manner to form a visible satellite cluster of cells. Satellite clusters were initially separated from the point of inoculation by the absence of visible cell density, but after 20 to 24 hours this space was colonized by cells apparently shed from a group of cells moving away from the point of inoculation. Cell movements consisted of flagellum-independent and flagellum-dependent motility contributions. Flagellum-independent movement occurred at an early stage, such that satellite clusters formed after 12 to 24 hours. Subsequently, after 24 to 32 hours, a flagellum-dependent dispersal of cells became visible, extending laterally outward from a line of flagellum-independent motility. These modes of taxis were found in several environmental isolates and in a variety of mutants, including a strain deficient in the production of the R. capsulatus acyl-homoserine lactone quorum-sensing signal. Although there was great variability in the direction of movement in illuminated plates, cells were predisposed to move toward broad spectrum white light. This predisposition was increased by the use of square plates, and a statistical analysis indicated that R. capsulatus is capable of genuine phototaxis. Therefore, the variability in the direction of cell movement was attributed to optical effects on light waves passing through the plate material and agar medium.     

Analysis of the possible helical structures of nucleic acids and polynucleotides. Application of (n-h) plots.

The two helical parameters n and h where n is the number of nucleotide residues per turn and h is the height per nucleotide residue have been evaluated for single stranded helical polynucleotide chains comprising C(3') -endo and C(2') endo class of nucleotides. The helical parameters are found to be especially sensitive to the C(4')-C(3') (sugar pucker) and the C(4')-C(5') torsions. The (n-h) plots display only one important helix forming domain for each class of nucleotides characterized by the sugar pucker and the C(4')-C(5') torsion. A correlation between the (n-h) plots and the known RNA (A,A') and DNA (A,B,C) helical forms has been established. It is found that all forms of helices except the C-DNA possess a favorable combination of P-O torsions. The analysis of the (n-h) plots suggests that C-DNA can have a conformation very similar to B-DNA. Although the (n-h) plots predict the stereochemical possibility of both right-handed and left-handed helices, nucleic acids apparently prefer right-handed conformation because of the energetics associated with the sugar-phosphate backbone and the base.