Comparison of assay technologies for a nuclear receptor assay screen reveals differences in the sets of identified functional antagonists

Many assay technologies currently exist to develop high-throughput screening assays, and the number of choices continues to increase. Results from a previous study comparing assay technologies in our laboratory do not support the common assumption that the same hits would be found regardless of which assay technology is used. To extend this investigation, a nuclear receptor antagonist assay was developed using 3 assay formats: AlphaScreen, time-resolved fluorescence (TRF), and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). Compounds ( approximately 42000) from the Novartis library were evaluated in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in dose-response experiments, and 109 compounds were confirmed active from all 3 formats. The AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies identified 104, 23, and 57 active compounds, respectively, with only 18 compounds active in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in a cell-based functional assay, and 35 compounds demonstrated activity in this cellular assay. Furthermore, 34, 11, and 16 hits that were originally identified in the dose-response experiment by AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies, respectively, were functionally active. The results of the study indicated that AlphaScreen identified the greatest number of functional antagonists.     

Two simple and generic antibody-independent kinase assays: comparison of a bioluminescent and a microfluidic assay format

In this study, the authors have compared the performance of 2 high-throughput screening assays for a serin/threonine kinase: a microplate-based, bioluminescent assay that uses the luciferin/luciferase system to monitor ATP consumption, and a microfluidic assay that measures the change in mobility in an electric field of a fluorescently labeled peptide upon phosphorylation. Both assays are homogeneous, nonradioactive, antibody independent and could be miniaturized to a reaction volume of 4 microl. The robustness of both formats was demonstrated by Z' values > 0.8. Screening of a small library (2133 compounds) showed that the results obtained with both technologies correlate very well. Although the threshold for hits was set to a comparably low value-22.2% and 13.7% inhibition for the ATP consumption and microfluidic assay, respectively, corresponding to mean plus 3 standard deviations-the overlap of active compounds identified with the 2 assay formats was greater than 94%. Thus, both assays allow the identification of even low potency inhibitors with a high level of confidence.     

High-throughput and ultra-high-throughput screening: solution- and cell-based approaches

The trend towards assay miniaturization for high-throughput and ultra-high-throughput screening continues to spur development of homogeneous, fluorescence-based assays in higher density, smaller volume microplate formats. Recently, first-generation microfluidic devices have been designed for performing continuous-flow biochemical and cell-based assays. These devices provide orders-of-magnitude reduction in reagent consumption, and offer the potential for implementing high-throughput screening in formats that integrate up-front compound handling with unique assay functionality.     

Digital Imaging as a Detection Method for a Fluorescent Protease Assay in 96-Well and Miniaturized Assay Plate Formats

The demand to increase throughput in HTS programs, without a concomitant addition to costs, has grown significantly during the past few years. One approach to handle this demand is assay miniaturization, which can provide greater throughput, as well as significant cost savings through reduced reagent costs. Currently, one of the major challenges facing assay miniaturization is the ability to detect the assay signal accurately and rapidly in miniaturized formats. Digital imaging is a detection method that can measure fluorescent or luminescent signals in these miniaturized formats. In this study, an imaging system capable of detecting the signal from a fluorescent protease assay in multiple plate formats was used to evaluate this detection method in an HTS environment. A direct comparison was made between the results obtained from the imaging system and a fluorescent plate reader by screening 8,800 compounds in a 96-well plate format. The imaging system generated similar changes in relative signal for each well in the screen, identified the same active compounds, and yielded similar IC(50) values as compared to the plate reader. When a standard protease inhibitor was evaluated in 96-, 384-, 864-, and 1536-well plates using imaging detection, similar IC(50) values were obtained. Furthermore, similar dose-response curves were generated for the compound in 96- and 384-well assay plates read in a plate reader. These results provide support for digital imaging as an accurate and rapid detection method for high-density microtiter plates.     

Automated high throughput screening for serine kinase inhibitors using a LEADseeker scintillation proximity assay in the 1536-well format

High-throughput screening in the 1536-well format has been largely restricted to solution-based and cell-based screens. In this article, we show the feasibility of a completely automated, robust scintillation proximity assay in the 1536-well format that is suitable to identify inhibitors for a serine/threonine kinase from a compound library. The introduction of [(33)P]phosphate into a biotinylated peptide substrate mirrors the activity of the kinase. The peptide is immobilized on streptavidin-coated LEADseeker imaging beads and [(33)P]phosphate incorporation is detected with the LEADseeker imaging system of Amersham Pharmacia Biotech. To improve the liquid handling procedures for imaging bead suspensions in the low microliter range, we developed a novel trough with an integrated stirring function. A comparison of the 1536-well assay to a 384-well assay revealed a comparable assay quality with Z' factors of about 0.7 for the 384-well format and 0.6 for the 1536-well format. In an automated screen of a random compound collection, 94.4% of the inhibitory compounds could be identified with both assay formats. Dose-response curves were performed for a selection of identified kinase inhibitors and revealed similar IC(50) values for both assay formats.     

Comparison of miniaturized time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer and enzyme-coupled luciferase high-throughput screening assays to discover inhibitors of Rho-kinase II (ROCK-II)

Kinases are important drug discovery targets for a wide variety of therapeutic indications; consequently, the measurement of kinase activity remains a common high-throughput screening (HTS) application. Recently, enzyme-coupled luciferase-kinase (LK) format assays have been introduced. This format measures luminescence resulting from metabolism of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) via a luciferin/luciferase-coupled reaction. In the research presented here, 1536-well format time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) and LK assays were created to identify novel Rho-associated kinase II (ROCK-II) inhibitors. HTS campaigns for both assays were conducted in this miniaturized format. It was found that both assays were able to consistently reproduce the expected pharmacology of inhibitors known to be specific to ROCK-II (fasudil IC50: 283 +/- 27 nM and 336 +/- 54 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively; Y-27632 IC50: 133 +/- 7.8 nM and 150 +/- 22 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively). In addition, both assays proved robust for HTS efforts, demonstrating excellent plate Z' values during the HTS campaign (0.84 +/- 0.03; 0.72 +/- 0.05 for LK and TR-FRET campaigns, respectively). Both formats identified scaffolds of known and novel ROCK-II inhibitors with similar sensitivity. A comparison of the performance of these 2 assay formats in an HTS campaign was enabled by the existence of a subset of 25,000 compounds found in both our institutional and the Molecular Library Screening Center Network screening files. Analysis of the HTS campaign results based on this subset of common compounds showed that both formats had comparable total hit rates, hit distributions, amount of hit clusters, and format-specific artifact. It can be concluded that both assay formats are suitable for the discovery of ROCK-II inhibitors, and the choice of assay format depends on reagents and/or screening technology available.     

Miniaturized receptor binding assays: complications arising from ligand depletion

The advent of miniaturized assay formats has made possible the screening of large numbers of compounds against a single target, known as high-throughput screening. Despite this clear advantage, assay miniaturization also increases the risk of ligand depletion, where the actual concentration of free ligand is significantly lower than that added. This, in turn, complicates the interpretation of data from such assays, potentially introducing significant error if not recognized. In this study, the effects of reducing assay volume on radioligand Kd and competitor Ki values have been investigated, using the muscarinic M(3) receptor as a model system. It was found that assay miniaturization caused dramatic effects, with up to a 30-fold underestimation of ligand affinity. A theoretical model was developed and shown to accurately predict both the degree of ligand depletion in any given assay volume and the effect of this depletion on affinity estimates for competing ligands. Importantly, it was found that in most cases, errors introduced by ligand depletion could be largely corrected for by the use of appropriate analysis methods. In addition to those previously described by others, the authors propose a simple method capable of correcting errors in competition binding experiments performed in conditions of ligand depletion.     

Further comparison of primary hit identification by different assay technologies and effects of assay measurement variability

High-throughput screening (HTS) has grown rapidly in the past decade, with many advances in new assay formats, detection technologies, and laboratory automation. Recently, several studies have shown that the choice of assay technology used for the screening process is particularly important and can yield quite different primary screening outcomes. However, because the screening assays in these previous studies were performed in a single-point determination, it is not clear to what extent the difference observed in the screening results between different assay technologies is attributable to inherent assay variability and day-to-day measurement variation. To address this question, a nuclear receptor coactivator recruitment assay was carried out in 2 different assay formats, namely, AlphaScreen and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer, which probed the same biochemical binding events but with different detection technologies. For each assay format, 4 independent screening runs in a typical HTS setting were completed to evaluate the run-to-run screening variability. These multiple tests with 2 assay formats allow an unambiguous comparison between the discrepancies of different assay formats and the effects of the variability of assay and screening measurements on the screening outcomes. The results provide further support that the choice of assay format or technology is a critical factor in HTS assay development.     

Homogeneous proximity tyrosine kinase assays: scintillation proximity assay versus homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence

Two homogeneous proximity assays for tyrosine kinases, scintillation proximity assay (SPA) and homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF), have been developed and compared. In both formats, the kinase assay was performed using biotinylated peptide substrate, ATP ([33P]ATP in the case of SPA), and tyrosine kinase in a 96-well assay format. After the kinase reaction was stopped, streptavidin-coated SPA beads or europium cryptate-labeled anti-phosphotyrosine antibody and streptavidin-labeled allophycocyanin were added as detection reagents for SPA or HTRF assays, respectively. Since the assay signal was detected only when the energy donor (radioactivity for SPA, Eu for HTRF) and the energy acceptor molecules (SPA beads for SPA, allophycocyanin for HTRF) were in close proximity, both assays required no wash or liquid transfer steps. This homogeneous ("mix-and-measure") nature allows these assays to be much simpler, more robust, and easier to automate than traditional protein kinase assays, such as a filter binding assay or ELISA. Both assays have been miniaturized to a 384-well format to reduce the assay volume, thereby saving the valuable screening samples as well as assay reagents, and automated using automated pipetting stations to increase the assay throughput. Several advantages and disadvantages for each assay are described.     

A fluorescence lifetime based binding assay to characterize kinase inhibitors

The authors present a fluorescence lifetime-based kinase binding assay that identifies and characterizes compounds that bind to the adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-binding pocket of a range of tyrosine and serine/threonine kinases. The assay is based on displacement of an Alexa Fluor 647 conjugate of staurosporine from the ATP-binding site of a kinase, which is detected by a change in the fluorescence lifetime of the probe between the free (displaced) and kinase-bound states. The authors screened 257 kinases for specific binding and displacement of the Alexa Fluor 647-staurosporine probe and found that approximately half of the kinases tested could potentially be assayed with this method. They present inhibitor binding data against 4 selected serine/threonine kinases and 4 selected tyrosine kinases, using 6 commonly used kinase inhibitors. Two of these kinases were chosen for further studies, in which inhibitor binding data were compared to inhibition of kinase activity using 2 separate activity assay formats. Rank-order potencies of compounds were similar, but not identical, between the binding and activity assays. It was postulated that these differences could be caused by the fact that the assays are measuring distinct phenomena, namely, activity versus binding, and in a purified recombinant kinase preparation, there can exist a mixture of active and nonactivated kinases. To explore this possibility, the authors compared binding affinity for the probe using 2 kinases in their respective nonactivated and activated (phosphorylated) forms and found a kinase-dependent difference between the 2 forms. This assay format therefore represents a simple method for the identification and characterization of small-molecule kinase inhibitors that may be useful in screening a wide range of kinases and may be useful in identifying small molecules that bind to kinases in their active or nonactivated states.     

Data concordance from a comparison between filter binding and fluorescence polarization assay formats for identification of ROCK-II inhibitors

The Rho-associated coiled-coil-containing protein serine/threonine kinases ROCK-I and ROCK-II are thought to play a major role in cytoskeletal dynamics by serving as downstream effectors of the Rho/Rac family of cytokine- and growth factor-activated small GTPases. As such, the ROCK family members are attractive intervention targets for a variety of pathologies, including cancer and cardiovascular disease. The authors developed a high-throughput screen to identify ROCK-II inhibitors and report results from a direct comparison of 2 screening campaigns for ROCK-II inhibitors using fluorescence polarization (FP) and filter binding (FB). Screening protocols to identify inhibitors of ROCK-II were developed in FB and FP formats under similar assay and kinetic conditions. A 30,000-member compound library was screened using FB ((33)P) and FP detection systems, and compounds that were active in either assay were retested in 5-point curve confirmation assays. Analysis of these data showed an approximate 95% agreement of compounds identified as active in both assay formats. Also, compound potency determinations from FB and FP had a high degree of correlation and were considered equivalent. These data suggest that the assay methodology has little impact on the quality and productivity of the screen, provided that the assays are developed to standardize kinetic conditions.     

Comparison of assay technologies for a tyrosine kinase assay generates different results in high throughput screening

In today's high-throughput screening (HTS) environment, an increasing number of assay detection technologies are routinely utilized in lead finding programs. Because of the relatively broad applicability of several of these technologies, one is often faced with a choice of which technology to utilize for a specific assay. The aim of this study was to address the question of whether the same compounds would be identified from screening a set of samples in three different versions of an HTS assay. Here, three different versions of a tyrosine kinase assay were established using scintillation proximity assay (SPA), homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (HTR-FRET), and fluorescence polarization (FP) technologies. In this study, 30,000 compounds were evaluated in each version of the kinase assay in primary screening, deconvolution, and dose-response experiments. From this effort, there was only a small degree of overlap of active compounds identified subsequent to the deconvolution experiment. When all active compounds were then profiled in all three assays, 100 and 101 active compounds were identified in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, respectively. In contrast, 40 compounds were identified in the SPA version of the kinase assay, whereas all of these compounds were detected in the HTR-FRET assay only 35 were active in the FP assay. Although there was good correlation between the IC(50) values obtained in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, poor correlations were obtained with the IC(50) values obtained in the SPA assay. These findings suggest that significant differences can be observed from HTS depending on the assay technology that is utilized, particularly in assays with high hit rates.     

Screening for antiviral inhibitors of the HIV integrase-LEDGF/p75 interaction using the AlphaScreen luminescent proximity assay

Small-molecule inhibitors of HIV integrase (HIV IN) have emerged as a promising new class of antivirals for the treatment of HIV/AIDS. The compounds currently approved or in clinical development specifically target HIV DNA integration and were identified using strand-transfer assays targeting the HIV IN/viral DNA complex. The authors have developed a second biochemical assay for identification of HIV integrase inhibitors, targeting the interaction between HIV IN and the cellular cofactor LEDGF/p75. They developed a luminescent proximity assay (AlphaScreen) designed to measure the association of the 80-amino-acid integrase binding domain of LEDGF/p75 with the 163-amino-acid catalytic core domain of HIV IN. This assay proved to be quite robust (with a Z' factor of 0.84 in screening libraries arrayed as orthogonal mixtures) and successfully identified several compounds specific for this protein-protein interaction.     

Miniaturization of a Mammalian Cell-Based Assay: Luciferase Reporter Gene Readout in a 3 Microliter 1536-Well Plate

The combined efforts of the fields of combinatorial chemistry and genomics have significantly increased the number of compounds and therapeutic targets available for screening. The number of compounds will reach into the million range in the near future and provide vast chemical diversity for drug discovery. However, this reservoir of chemical diversity creates downstream hurdles for any screening effort. Properly examining this number of compounds increases investments dramatically, both in the number of dollars spent and amount of limited reagents depleted. Traditional HTS techniques, such as the use of 96-well microtiter plates, have paved the way for faster processing speeds, but are being rapidly overwhelmed by screening demands. Miniaturization of such assays will allow for greater throughput, while concurrently reducing cost. To date, miniaturization efforts have been most successfully applied to bacterial and soluble protein based assays. Questions about the ability to deliver microquantities of mammalian cells without disruption of the cell membrane and/or activation of stress responses have been raised. An assay has been developed in which a human T-cell screen has been adapted to a 1536-well plate format. Through the use of a luciferase reporter gene system, it is shown that a mammalian cell-based assay may be successfully performed in 3 μl and potent inhibitors of the target of interest identified.     

Three mechanistically distinct kinase assays compared: Measurement of intrinsic ATPase activity identified the most comprehensive set of ITK inhibitors

Numerous assay methods have been developed to identify small-molecule effectors of protein kinases, but no single method can be applied to all isolated kinases. The authors developed a set of 3 high-throughput screening (HTS)-compatible biochemical assays that can measure 3 mechanistically distinct properties of a kinase active site, with the goal that at least 1 of the 3 would be applicable to any kinase selected as a target for drug discovery efforts. Two assays measure catalytically active enzyme: A dissociation-enhanced lanthanide fluoroimmuno assay (DELFIA) uses an antibody to quantitate the generation of phosphorylated substrate; a second assay uses luciferase to measure the consumption of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) during either phosphoryl-transfer to a peptide substrate or to water (intrinsic ATPase activity). A third assay, which is not dependent on a catalytically active enzyme, measures the competition for binding to kinase between an inhibitor and a fluorescent ATP binding site probe. To evaluate the suitability of these assays for drug discovery, the authors compared their ability to identify inhibitors of a nonreceptor protein tyrosine kinase from the Tec family, interleukin-2-inducible T cell kinase (ITK). The 3 assays agreed on 57% of the combined confirmed hit set identified from screening a 10,208-compound library enriched with known kinase inhibitors and molecules that were structurally similar. Among the 3 assays, the one measuring intrinsic ATPase activity produced the largest number of unique hits, the fewest unique misses, and the most comprehensive hit set, missing only 2.7% of the confirmed inhibitors identified by the other 2 assays combined. Based on these data, all 3 assay formats are viable for screening and together provide greater options for assay design depending on the targeted kinase.     

Utilization of microarrayed compound screening (microARCS) to identify inhibitors of p56lck tyrosine kinase

Protein tyrosine kinases play critical roles in cell signaling and are considered attractive targets for drug discovery. The authors have applied microARCS (microarrayed compound screening) technology to develop a high-throughput screen for finding inhibitors of the p56lck tyrosine kinase. Initial assay development was performed in a homogeneous time-resolved (LANCE) format in 96-well microplates and then converted into the gel-based microARCS format. The microARCS methodology is a well-less screening format in which 8640 compounds are arrayed on a microplate-sized piece of polystyene and subsequently assayed by placing reagents cast in agarose gels in contact with these compound sheets. A blotting paper soaked with adenosine triphosphate is applied on the gel to initiate the kinase reaction in the gel. Using this screening methodology, 300,000 compounds were screened in less than 40 h. Substantial reagent reduction was achieved by converting this tyrosine kinase assay from a 96-well plate assay to microARCS, resulting in significant cost savings.     

A cost-effective solution to reduce dead volume of a standard dispenser system by a factor of 5

A key trend in high-throughput screening is assay miniaturization to control reagent costs and increase throughput. For this purpose, liquid-handling devices are used that transfer nano-to low-microliter volumes into all currently used microtiter well plates. One drawback of many available dispenser and pipetting systems are high dead volumes. Therefore, the authors were looking for an easy and simple solution to modify their standard liquid-handling device, PerkinElmer's FlexDrop Precision IV, allowing for a dead volume reduction to receive maximum benefit from miniaturized assay formats. Internal reservoirs were developed and constructed by Schering's Technical Development Laboratory (TDL), which are directly connected to the dispenser banks of FlexDrop without tubing. Using these newly built reservoirs, the dead volume was decreased by a factor of 5 in comparison to the manufacturer's reservoirs without compromising liquid-handling parameters such as accuracy and precision. The modified system displayed a high robustness and reliability under routine high-throughput screening conditions.     

High-throughput screen for Escherichia coli heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70/DnaK): ATPase assay in low volume by exploiting energy transfer

Members of the heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70) family of molecular chaperones are emerging as potential therapeutic targets. Their ATPase activity has classically been measured using colorimetric phosphate detection reagents, such as quinaldine red (QR). Although such assays are suitable for 96-well plate formats, they typically lose sensitivity when attempted in lower volume due to path length and meniscus effects. These limitations and Hsp70's weak enzymatic activity have combined to create significant challenges in high-throughput screening. To overcome these difficulties, the authors have adopted an energy transfer strategy that was originally reported by Zuck et al. (Anal Biochem 2005;342:254-259). Briefly, white 384-well plates emit fluorescence when irradiated at 430 nm. In turn, this intrinsic fluorescence can be quenched by energy transfer with the QR-based chromophore. Using this more sensitive approach, the authors tested 55,400 compounds against DnaK, a prokaryotic member of the Hsp70 family. The assay performance was good (Z' ~0.6, coefficient of variation ~8%), and at least one promising new inhibitor was identified. In secondary assays, this compound specifically blocked stimulation of DnaK by its co-chaperone, DnaJ. Thus, this simple and inexpensive adaptation of a colorimetric method might be suitable for screening against Hsp70 family members.