Kin selection and frequency dependence: a game theoretic approach

Game theory models show that the evolution of interactions between relatives is determined by two kinds of fitness effects: Hamilton's inclusive fitness effect, and a frequency-dependent synergistic effect. The latter arises when an individual's behaviour has different effects on the fitness of interactants, depending on whether or not they perform the same behaviour. Knowing the sign of the synergistic effect is sufficient to understand most of the qualitative features of genetic models that show departures from Hamilton's rule. Since this synergistic effect does not depend on the interactants being related, it is best viewed as something distinct from kin selection. In this view, Hamilton's rule is basically correct for describing kin selection, and most deviations from it are due to the distinct process of synergistic selection.     

Independent evolution of the sexes promotes amphibian diversification

Classic ecological theory predicts that the evolution of sexual dimorphism constrains diversification by limiting morphospace available for speciation. Alternatively, sexual selection may lead to the evolution of reproductive isolation and increased diversification. We test contrasting predictions of these hypotheses by examining the relationship between sexual dimorphism and diversification in amphibians. Our analysis shows that the evolution of sexual size dimorphism (SSD) is associated with increased diversification and speciation, contrary to the ecological theory. Further, this result is unlikely to be explained by traditional sexual selection models because variation in amphibian SSD is unlikely to be driven entirely by sexual selection. We suggest that relaxing a central assumption of classic ecological models—that the sexes share a common adaptive landscape—leads to the alternative hypothesis that independent evolution of the sexes may promote diversification. Once the constraints of sexual conflict are relaxed, the sexes can explore morphospace that would otherwise be inaccessible. Consistent with this novel hypothesis, the evolution of SSD in amphibians is associated with reduced current extinction threat status, and an historical reduction in extinction rate. Our work reconciles conflicting predictions from ecological and evolutionary theory and illustrates that the ability of the sexes to evolve independently is associated with a spectacular vertebrate radiation.     

Masculine voices signal men's threat potential in forager and industrial societies

Humans and many non-human primates exhibit large sexual dimorphisms in vocalizations and vocal anatomy. In humans, same-sex competitors and potential mates attend to acoustic features of male vocalizations, but vocal masculinity especially increases perceptions of physical prowess. Yet, the information content of male vocalizations remains obscure. We therefore examined relationships between sexually dimorphic acoustic properties and men's threat potential. We first introduce a new measure of the structure of vocal formant frequencies, 'formant position' (Pf), which we show is more sexually dimorphic and more strongly related to height than is the most widely used measure of formant structure, 'formant dispersion', in both a US sample and a sample of Hadza foragers from Tanzania. We also show large sexual dimorphisms in the mean fundamental frequency (F0) and the within-utterance standard deviation in F0 (F0-s.d.) in both samples. We then explore relationships between these acoustic parameters and men's body size, strength, testosterone and physical aggressiveness. Each acoustic parameter was related to at least one measure of male threat potential. The most dimorphic parameters, F0 and Pf, were most strongly related to body size in both samples. In the US sample, F0 predicted testosterone levels, Pf predicted upper body strength and F0-s.d. predicted physical aggressiveness.     

Mating system affects population performance and extinction risk under environmental challenge

Failure of organisms to adapt to sudden environmental changes may lead to extinction. The type of mating system, by affecting fertility and the strength of sexual selection, may have a major impact on a population''s chances to adapt and survive. Here, we use experimental evolution in bulb mites (Rhizoglyphus robini) to examine the effects of the mating system on population performance under environmental change. We demonstrate that populations in which monogamy was enforced suffered a dramatic fitness decline when evolving at an increased temperature, whereas the negative effects of change in a thermal environment were alleviated in polygamous populations. Strikingly, within 17 generations, all monogamous populations experiencing higher temperature went extinct, whereas all polygamous populations survived. Our results show that the mating system may have dramatic effects on the risk of extinction under environmental change.     

Mechanisms for frequency-dependent mating success

We consider ways in which non-frequency-dependent processes could generate negatively frequency-dependent male mating success (the rare male effect). Various forms of male competition and female preference could produce the phenomenon, and further experiments are needed to examine their occurrence. We conclude that the rare male effect is likely to be of limited evolutionary relevance.     

Frequency-dependent competitive abilities and differential resource use in competition between Drosophila hydei and D. melanogaster

Several experiments, each involving competition between Drosophila melanogaster and D. hydei in population cages, were set up and allowed to run for up to 50 weeks. The population sizes of both species, and hence the species frequencies, were monitored once a fortnight, i.e. approximately once per generation. Coexistence of the two species was observed in cages containing resource bottles with 5 g of food medium; cages whose resource bottles contained only 1.5 g resulted in competitive exclusion of D. hydei. Competitive abilities were frequency-dependent in the former case but not in the latter. Tests of larval depth distributions revealed that D. hydei larvae feed at a deeper level in the food medium than larvae of D. melanogaster. The explanation of the contrasting results of competition when bottles contained 5 g and 1.5 g of resources lies in the production of frequency-dependent competitive abilities by larval resource partitioning in the bottles with 5 g, and the preclusion of such partitioning in the 1.5 g bottles because of the very limited depth of food medium then available. The relevance of these results to a model of competition is discussed, and the potential generality of differential resource use as a stabilizing mechanism in both interspecific and intergenotypic competition is noted.     

Female genital mutilation and monandry in an orb-web spider

Monandry, in which a female has only one mating partner during the reproductive period, is established when a female spontaneously refrains from re-mating, or when a partner male interferes with the attempts of a female to mate again. In the latter case, however, females often have countermeasures against males, which may explain why polyandry is ubiquitous. Here, I demonstrate that the genital appendage, or scape, of the female orb-web spider (Cyclosa argenteoalba) is injured after her first mating, possibly by her first male partner. This female genital mutilation (FGM) permanently precludes copulation, and females appear to have no countermeasures. FGM is considered to confer a strong advantage to males in sexual conflicts over the number of female matings, and it may widely occur in spiders.     

刈割频度对普通野生稻实验种群的影响

本文通过考察普通野生稻(Oryza rufipogon)实验种群对不同频度刈割的反应,揭示刈割对该种群的密度、株高、生物量、单枝生物量和有性生殖份额等有明显的抑制作用,对累积株高增长和光合系统份额则有一定的促进作用。刈割频度越大,作用越大。但对后两者的促进是以消耗地下部分的物质和能量为前提的,超过一定频度的刈割不仅可使其有性生殖份额降至零,还可导致种群消亡。提示过频破坏普遍野生稻地上部分是该种部分种群发生地方性绝灭的重要原因之一。     

Frequency-dependent selection in hermaphrodites: the rule rather than the exception

It is shown for simple assumptions that frequency-dependent selection in seed plants may have at least three causes, namely: (a) sexual asymmetry; (b) differential genotypic selfing rates; and (c) gene-cytoplasm fertility interactions. Sexual asymmetry is defined as the situation where the ratio of pollen: ovule fertility is not the same for all genotypes or phenotypes in a population. A review of the literature suggests that all three causes of frequency-dependent selection probably occur in nature, and that at least the first cause, sexual asymmetry, is probably widespread in hermaphrodites. It is shown that resource-allocation theory leads to the expectation that sexual asymmetry and, therefore, frequency-dependent selection should be almost universal in hermaphrodite populations which are not largely selfed. A method for obtaining frequency-dependent fitness values is presented and applied to a population of Scots pine ( Pinus sylvestris ) showing strong sexual asymmetry.     

Increase in song frequency decreases spermatophore size: correlative evidence of a macroevolutionary trade-off in katydids (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae)

In many katydids, the male feeds his mate with a large gelatinous spermatophore. Males of most species also produce elaborate calling songs. We predicted a negative relationship between spermatophore size and call frequency because of trade-offs between these two costly traits. Our comparative analysis controlling phylogeny and body size supported this prediction. Although call frequency is expected to decrease with increasing body size, after controlling for phylogeny, both variables were not related. Finally, given that song frequency and spermatophore size are likely targets of sexual selection, we examined the relationship between these variables and sexual size dimorphism (SSD) which can be influenced by sexual selection on body size. We found that only female body size was positively related to SSD, suggesting that natural and/or sexual selection on female body size may be stronger than sexual selection on male and spermatophore size.