Chunnel vision. Export and efflux through bacterial channel-tunnels

The Escherichia coli TolC protein is central to toxin export and drug efflux across the inner and outer cell membranes and the intervening periplasmic space. The crystal structure has revealed that TolC assembles into a remarkable α-helical trans-periplasmic cylinder (tunnel) embedded in the outer membrane by a contiguous β-barrel (channel), so providing a large duct open to the outside environment. The channel-tunnel structure is conserved in TolC homologues throughout Gram-negative bacteria, and it is envisaged that they are recruited and opened, through a common mechanism, by substrate-specific inner-membrane complexes.     

On the role of TolC in multidrug efflux: the function and assembly of AcrAB–TolC tolerate significant depletion of intracellular TolC protein

TolC channel provides a route for the expelled drugs and toxins to cross the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. The puzzling feature of TolC structure is that the periplasmic entrance of the channel is closed by dense packing of 12 α‐helices. Efflux pumps exemplified by AcrAB are proposed to drive the opening of TolC channel. How interactions with AcrAB promote the close‐to‐open transition in TolC remains unclear. In this study, we investigated in vivo the functional and physical interactions of AcrAB with the closed TolC and its conformer opened by mutations in the periplasmic entrance. We found that the two conformers of TolC are readily distinguishable in vivo by characteristic drug susceptibility, thiol modification and proteolytic profiles. However, these profiles of TolC variants respond neither to the in vivo stoichiometry of AcrAB:TolC nor to the presence of vancomycin, which is used often to assess the permeability of TolC channel. We further found that the activity and assembly of AcrAB–TolC tolerates significant changes in amounts of TolC and that only a small fraction of intracellular TolC is likely used to support efflux needs of E. coli. Our findings explain why TolC is not a good target for inhibition of multidrug efflux.     

Protein export and drug efflux through bacterial channel-tunnels.

The bacterial protein TolC assembles into an alpha-helical trans-periplasmic tunnel, which is embedded in the outer membrane by a contiguous beta-barrel channel. TolC and its homologues thus provide large exit ducts for a wide range of substrates, including protein toxins and antibacterial drugs, that are engaged by specific recognition proteins in the cytosolic membrane.     

Assembly and channel opening in a bacterial drug efflux machine

Drugs and certain proteins are transported across the membranes of Gram-negative bacteria by energy-activated pumps. The outer membrane component of these pumps is a channel that opens from a sealed resting state during the transport process. We describe two crystal structures of the Escherichia coli outer membrane protein TolC in its partially open state. Opening is accompanied by the exposure of three shallow intraprotomer grooves in the TolC trimer, where our mutagenesis data identify a contact point with the periplasmic component of a drug efflux pump, AcrA. We suggest that the assembly of multidrug efflux pumps is accompanied by induced fit of TolC driven mainly by accommodation of the periplasmic component.     

Assembly of TolC, a structurally unique and multifunctional outer membrane protein of Escherichia coli K-12

TolC is a multifunctional outer membrane protein of Escherichia coli that folds into a novel alpha-beta-barrel conformation absent in the other model outer membrane proteins used in assembly studies. The data presented in this work show that the unique folded structure of TolC reflects a unique assembly pathway. During its assembly, the newly translocated nascent TolC monomers are released in the periplasm. Maturation of these nascent monomers, and possibly their oligomerization, in the periplasm precedes their insertion in the outer membrane. The completion of the assembly process is signaled by the development of a characteristic proteinase K-resistant fragment generated by cleavage at a single, periplasmically exposed, protease-sensitive site of the membrane-anchored trimer. None of the assembly steps of TolC is affected by known folding factors, such as SurA, Skp, and lipopolysaccharide, which have profound effects on the assembly of other model trimeric outer membrane proteins. Two assembly-defective TolC mutants were isolated and characterized. One of the mutants (TolC(I106N)) was defective in the folding of nascent monomers, while the other (TolC(S350F)) was impaired in steps involving trimerization and membrane insertion of folded monomers.     

Assembly and stability of Salmonella enterica ser. Typhi TolC protein in POPE and DMPE

In this work we assessed the suitability of two different lipid membranes for the simulation of a TolC protein from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi. The TolC protein family is found in many pathogenic Gram-negative bacteria including Vibrio cholera and Pseudomonas aeruginosa and acts as an outer membrane channel for expulsion of drug and toxin from the cell. In S. typhi, the causative agent for typhoid fever, the TolC outer membrane protein is an antigen for the pathogen. The lipid environment is an important modulator of membrane protein structure and function. We evaluated the conformation of the TolC protein in the presence of DMPE and POPE bilayers using molecular dynamics simulation. The S. typhi TolC protein exhibited similar conformational dynamics to TolC and its homologues. Conformational flexibility of the protein is seen in the C-terminal, extracellular loops, and α-helical region. Despite differences in the two lipids, significant similarities in the motion of the protein in POPE and DMPE were observed, including the rotational motion of the C-terminal residues and the partially open extracellular loops. However, analysis of the trajectories demonstrated effects of hydrophobic matching of the TolC protein in the membrane, particularly in the lengthening of the lipids and subtle movements of the protein’s β-barrel towards the lower leaflet in DMPE. The study exhibited the use of molecular dynamics simulation in revealing the differential effect of membrane proteins and lipids on each other. In this study, POPE is potentially a more suitable model for future simulation of the S. typhi TolC protein.     

Conformational flexibility in the multidrug efflux system protein AcrA

Intrinsic resistance to multiple drugs in many gram-negative bacterial pathogens is conferred by resistance nodulation cell division efflux pumps, which are composed of three essential components as typified by the extensively characterized Escherichia coli AcrA-AcrB-TolC system. The inner membrane drug:proton antiporter AcrB and the outer membrane channel TolC export chemically diverse compounds out of the bacterial cell, and require the activity of the third component, the periplasmic protein AcrA. The crystal structures of AcrB and TolC have previously been determined, and we complete the molecular picture of the efflux system by presenting the structure of a stable fragment of AcrA. The AcrA fragment resembles the elongated sickle shape of its homolog Pseudomonas aeruginosa MexA, being composed of three domains: beta-barrel, lipoyl, and alpha-helical hairpin. Notably, unsuspected conformational flexibility in the alpha-helical hairpin domain of AcrA is observed, which has potential mechanistic significance in coupling between AcrA conformations and TolC channel opening.     

Structure of TolC, the outer membrane component of the bacterial type I efflux system, derived from two-dimensional crystals

TolC is an outer membrane protein required for the export of virulence proteins and toxic compounds without a periplasmic intermediate. We show that TolC is an integral part of the translocator, interacting with inner membrane components, by demonstrating a need for TolC in protein export not only from intact cells but also from sphaeroplasts. To establish the structure of TolC, and thus gain information on how this might be achieved, the protein was purified from the Escherichia coli outer membrane, as a trimer, and crystallized in two-dimensional lattices by reconstitution in phospholipid bilayers. The projection structure at 12 Å resolution showed a threefold symmetric molecule of 58 Å outer diameter, and a single pool of stain filling its centre. Side views parallel to the membrane plane revealed an additional domain outside the membrane. Eighteen membrane-spanning β-strands were predicted for the 51.5 kDa monomer, excluding a 7 kDa C-terminal segment, and this segment was shown to contain a proteinase K-sensitive site that was exposed in reconstituted membranes and sphaeroplasts, but which was protected in intact cells. The combined data suggest that TolC is a trimeric outer membrane protein with each monomer comprising a membrane domain, predicted to be β-barrel, and a C-terminal periplasmic domain. The latter could form part of the bridge to the energized inner membrane component of the translocation complex.     

Locked on one side only: ground state dynamics of the outer membrane efflux duct TolC

Playing a major role in the expulsion of antibiotics and the secretion of cell toxins in conjunction with inner membrane transporters of three protein superfamilies, the outer membrane channel TolC occurs in at least two states blocking or permitting the passage of substrates. The details of the underlying gating mechanism are not fully understood. Addressing the questions of extracellular access control and periplasmic gating mechanism, we conducted a series of independent, unbiased 150-300 ns molecular dynamics simulations of wild-type TolC in a phospholipid membrane/150 mM NaCl water environment. We find that TolC opens and closes freely on the extracellular side, suggesting the absence of a gating mechanism on this side in the isolated protein. On the periplasmic side, we observe the outer periplasmic bottleneck region adopting in all simulations a conformation more open than the TolC wild-type crystal structures until in one run the successive binding of two sodium ions induces the transition to a conformation more closed than any of the available TolC X-ray structures. Concurrent with a heightened sodium residence probability near Asp374, the inner periplasmic bottleneck region at Asp374 remains closed throughout the simulations unless all NaCl is removed from the system, inducing a reopening of the outer and inner bottleneck. Our findings suggest that TolC is locked only on the periplasmic side in a sodium-dependent manner.     

Carboxy-Terminal Region Involved in Activity of Escherichia coli TolC

The Escherichia coli TolC acts as a channel tunnel in the transport of various molecules across the outer membrane. Partial-deletion studies of tolC revealed that the region extending from the 50th to the 60th amino acid residue from the carboxy terminus plays an important role in this transport activity of TolC.     

Evaluation of a structural model of Pseudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane protein OprM, an efflux component involved in intrinsic antibiotic resistance

The outer membrane protein OprM of Pseudomonas aeruginosa is involved in intrinsic and mutational multiple-antibiotic resistance as part of two resistance-nodulation-division efflux systems. The crystal structure of TolC, a homologous protein in Escherichia coli, was recently published (V. Koronakis, A. Sharff, E. Koronakis, B. Luisl, and C. Hughes, Nature 405:914-919, 2000), demonstrating a distinctive architecture comprising outer membrane beta-barrel and periplasmic helical-barrel structures, which assemble differently from the common beta-barrel-only conformation of porins. Based on their sequence similarity, a similar content of alpha-helical and beta-sheet structure determined by circular dichroism spectroscopy, and our observation that OprM, like TolC, reconstitutes channels in planar bilayer membranes, OprM and TolC were considered to be structurally homologous, and a model of OprM was constructed by threading its sequence to the TolC crystal structure. Residues thought to be important for the TolC structure were conserved in space in this OprM model. Analyses of deletion mutants and previously isolated insertion mutants of OprM in the context of this model allowed us to propose roles for different protein domains. Our data indicate that the helical barrel of the protein is critical for both the function and the integrity of the protein, while a C-terminal domain localized around the equatorial plane of this helical barrel is dispensable. Extracellular loops appear to play a lesser role in substrate specificity for this efflux protein compared to classical porins, and there appears to be a correlation between the change in antimicrobial activity for OprM mutants and the pore size. Our model and channel formation studies support the "iris" mechanism of action for TolC and permit us now to form more focused hypotheses about the functional domains of OprM and its related family of efflux proteins.     

The Enterobacter aerogenes outer membrane efflux proteins TolC and EefC have different channel properties

The outer membrane proteins TolC and EefC from Enterobacter aerogenes are involved in multidrug resistance as part of two resistance-nodulation-division efflux systems. To gain more understanding in the molecular mechanism underlying drug efflux, we have undertaken an electrophysiological characterization of the channel properties of these two proteins. TolC and EefC were purified in their native trimeric form and then reconstituted in proteoliposomes for patch-clamp experiments and in planar lipid bilayers. Both proteins generated a small single channel conductance of about 80 pS in 0.5 M KCl, indicating a common gated structure. The resultant pores were stable, and no voltage-dependent openings or closures were observed. EefC has a low ionic selectivity (P(K)/P(Cl)= approximately 3), whereas TolC is more selective to cations (P(K)/P(Cl)= approximately 30). This may provide a possible explanation for the difference in drug selectivity between the AcrAB-TolC and EefABC efflux systems observed in vivo. The pore-forming activity of both TolC and EefC was severely inhibited by divalent cations entering from the extracellular side. Another characteristic of the TolC and EefC channels was the systematic closure induced by acidic pH. These results are discussed in respect to the physiological functions and structural models of TolC and EefC.     

Multidrug-exporting secondary transporters

The major cause of intrinsic drug resistance in Gram-negative bacteria is a resistance nodulation division type multidrug exporter, which couples with an outer membrane channel and a membrane fusion protein and exports drugs out of the cell, bypassing the periplasm; this process is driven by proton motive force. A recent crystal structure determination of a major resistance nodulation division type multidrug exporter, AcrB in Escherichia coli, greatly advances our understanding of the multidrug export mechanism. The most striking feature of the AcrB trimer is the presence of three vestibules open to the periplasm at the boundary between the periplasmic headpiece and the transmembrane region. Substrates can gain access to the central cavity from the periplasmic surface of the cytoplasmic membrane and are then actively transported through the extramembrane pore into the outer membrane channel TolC, via the funnel at the top of the AcrB headpiece.     

Gating at both ends and breathing in the middle: conformational dynamics of TolC

Drug extrusion via efflux through a tripartite complex (an inner membrane pump, an outer membrane protein, and a periplasmic protein) is a widely used mechanism in Gram-negative bacteria. The outer membrane protein (TolC in Escherichia coli; OprM in Pseudomonas aeruginosa) forms a tunnel-like pore through the periplasmic space and the outer membrane. Molecular dynamics simulations of TolC have been performed, and are compared to simulations of Y362F/R367S mutant, and to simulations of its homolog OprM. The results reveal a complex pattern of conformation dynamics in the TolC protein. Two putative gate regions, located at either end of the protein, can be distinguished. These regions are the extracellular loops and the mouth of the periplasmic domain, respectively. The periplasmic gate has been implicated in the conformational changes leading from the closed x-ray structure to a proposed open state of TolC. Between the two gates, a peristaltic motion of the periplasmic domain is observed, which may facilitate transport of the solutes from one end of the tunnel to the other. The motions observed in the atomistic simulations are also seen in coarse-grained simulations in which the protein tertiary structure is represented by an elastic network model.     

Functional implications of an intermeshing cogwheel-like interaction between TolC and MacA in the action of macrolide-specific efflux pump MacAB-TolC

Macrolide-specific efflux pump MacAB-TolC has been identified in diverse gram-negative bacteria including Escherichia coli. The inner membrane transporter MacB requires the outer membrane factor TolC and the periplasmic adaptor protein MacA to form a functional tripartite complex. In this study, we used a chimeric protein containing the tip region of the TolC α-barrel to investigate the role of the TolC α-barrel tip region with regard to its interaction with MacA. The chimeric protein formed a stable complex with MacA, and the complex formation was abolished by substitution at the functionally essential residues located at the MacA α-helical tip region. Electron microscopic study delineated that this complex was made by tip-to-tip interaction between the tip regions of the α-barrels of TolC and MacA, which correlated well with the TolC and MacA complex calculated by molecular dynamics. Taken together, our results demonstrate that the MacA hexamer interacts with TolC in a tip-to-tip manner, and implies the manner by which MacA induces opening of the TolC channel.     

MacB ABC transporter is a dimer whose ATPase activity and macrolide-binding capacity are regulated by the membrane fusion protein MacA

Gram-negative bacteria utilize specialized machinery to translocate drugs and protein toxins across the inner and outer membranes, consisting of a tripartite complex composed of an inner membrane secondary or primary active transporter (IMP), a periplasmic membrane fusion protein, and an outer membrane channel. We have investigated the assembly and function of the MacAB/TolC system that confers resistance to macrolides in Escherichia coli. The membrane fusion protein MacA not only stabilizes the tripartite assembly by interacting with both the inner membrane protein MacB and the outer membrane protein TolC, but also has a role in regulating the function of MacB, apparently increasing its affinity for both erythromycin and ATP. Analysis of the kinetic behavior of ATP hydrolysis indicated that MacA promotes and stabilizes the ATP-binding form of the MacB transporter. For the first time, we have established unambiguously the dimeric nature of a noncanonic ABC transporter, MacB that has an N-terminal nucleotide binding domain, by means of nondissociating mass spectrometry, analytical ultracentrifugation, and atomic force microscopy. Structural studies of ABC transporters indicate that ATP is bound between a pair of nucleotide binding domains to stabilize a conformation in which the substrate-binding site is outward-facing. Consequently, our data suggest that in the presence of ATP the same conformation of MacB is promoted and stabilized by MacA. Thus, MacA would facilitate the delivery of drugs by MacB to TolC by enhancing the binding of drugs to it and inducing a conformation of MacB that is primed and competent for binding TolC. Our structural studies are an important first step in understanding how the tripartite complex is assembled.     

TolC--the bacterial exit duct for proteins and drugs

The TolC structure has unveiled a common mechanism for the movement of molecules, large and small, from the bacterial cell cytosol, across two membranes and the intervening periplasm, into the environment. Trimeric TolC is a remarkable cell exit duct that differs radically from other membrane proteins, comprising a 100-A long alpha-barrel that projects across the periplasmic space, anchored by a 40-A long beta-barrel spanning the outer membrane. The periplasmic entrance of TolC is closed until recruitment by substrate-specific translocases in the inner membrane triggers its transition to the open state, achieved by an iris-like 'untwisting' of the tunnel alpha-helices. TolC-dependent machineries present ubiquitous exit routes for virulence proteins and antibacterial drugs, and their conserved structure, specifically the electronegative TolC entrance constriction, may present a target for inhibitors of multidrug-resistant pathogens.     

Electrophysiological Behavior of the TolC Channel-Tunnel in Planar Lipid Bilayers

Escherichia coli TolC assembles into the unique channel-tunnel structure spanning the outer membrane and periplasmic space. The structure is constricted only at the periplasmic entrance of the tunnel and this must be opened to allow export of substrates bound by cognate inner membrane complexes. We have investigated the electrophysiological behavior of TolC reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers, in particular the influence of the membrane potential, the electrolyte concentration and pH. TolC inserted in one orientation into the membrane. The resultant pores were stable and showed no voltage-dependent opening or closing. Nevertheless, TolC could adopt up to three conductance substates. The pores were cation-selective with a permeability ratio of potassium to chloride ions of 16.5. The single-channel conductance was higher when the protein was inserted from the side with negative potential. It showed a nonlinear dependence on the concentration of the electrolyte in the bulk solution and decreased as the pH was lowered. The calculated pK of the apparent closing was 4.5. The electrophysiological characterization is discussed in relation to the TolC structure, in particular the periplasmic entrance.     

Channel-tunnels

TolC and its many homologues comprise an alpha-helical transperiplasmic tunnel embedded in the bacterial outer membrane by a contiguous beta-barrel channel, providing a large exit duct for diverse substrates. The 'channel-tunnel' is closed at its periplasmic entrance, but can be opened by an 'iris-like' mechanism when recruited by substrate-engaged proteins in the cytosolic membrane.     

Differential effects of yfgL mutation on Escherichia coli outer membrane proteins and lipopolysaccharide

YfgL together with NlpB, YfiO, and YaeT form a protein complex to facilitate the insertion of proteins into the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Without YfgL, the levels of OmpA, OmpF, and LamB are significantly reduced, while OmpC levels are slightly reduced. In contrast, the level of TolC significantly increases in a yfgL mutant. When cells are depleted of YaeT or YfiO, levels of all outer membrane proteins examined, including OmpC and TolC, are severely reduced. Thus, while the assembly pathways of various nonlipoprotein outer membrane proteins may vary through the step involving YfgL, all assembly pathways in Escherichia coli converge at the step involving the YaeT/YfiO complex. The negative effect of yfgL mutation on outer membrane proteins may in part be due to elevated sigma E activity, which has been shown to downregulate the synthesis of various outer membrane proteins while upregulating the synthesis of periplasmic chaperones, foldases, and lipopolysaccharide. The data presented here suggest that the yfgL effect on outer membrane proteins also stems from a defective assembly apparatus, leading to aberrant outer membrane protein assembly, except for TolC, which assembles independent of YfgL. Consistent with this view, the simultaneous absence of YfgL and the major periplasmic protease DegP confers a synthetic lethal phenotype, presumably due to the toxic accumulation of unfolded outer membrane proteins. The results support the hypothesis that TolC and major outer membrane proteins compete for the YaeT/YfiO complex, since mutations that adversely affect synthesis or assembly of major outer membrane proteins lead to elevated TolC levels.