Adjuvant immune stimulation with Corynebacterium parvum during maintenance chemotherapy of acute myeloid leukemia

Summary Of 93 consecutively treated patients with acute myeloid leukemia 36 (39%) achieved complete remission (CR). Thirty-five patients were randomized to receive either maintenance chemotherapy alone (C) or a combination of active nonspecific immunotherapy with Corynebacterium parvum and chemotherapy (C + I). Maintenance therapy was given monthly for 1 year or until relapse. The median survival time was 21 months for patients treated with chemotherapy alone, compared with 30 months for patients treated with chemotherapy and immunotherapy. The median remission duration was 15 months for patients treated with chemotherapy, compared with 18 months for chemotherapy and immunotherapy group. While no statistically significant difference in remission duration or survival time could be attributed to the use of immune stimulation, a plateau of 40% long-term time survivors was defined in the chemotherapy and immunotherapy group. Age and sex were found to be the major prognostic factors for achivement of CR. No difference was found in remission duration or survival between the two different induction schedules. Neither did the morphological subtype of AML (FAB classification) or the leukocyte count at diagnosis correlate with remission rate or survival.     

Adjuvant immune stimulation with Corynebacterium parvum during maintenance chemotherapy of acute myeloid leukemia

Of 93 consecutively treated patients with acute myeloid leukemia 36 (39%) achieved complete remission (CR). Thirty-five patients were randomized to receive either maintenance chemotherapy alone (C) or a combination of active nonspecific immunotherapy with Corynebacterium parvum and chemotherapy (C + I). Maintenance therapy was given monthly for 1 year or until relapse. The median survival time was 21 months for patients treated with chemotherapy alone, compared with 30 months for patients treated with chemotherapy and immunotherapy. The median remission duration was 15 months for patients treated with chemotherapy, compared with 18 months for chemotherapy and immunotherapy group. While no statistically significant difference in remission duration or survival time could be attributed to the use of immune stimulation, a plateau of 40% long-term time survivors was defined in the chemotherapy and immunotherapy group. Age and sex were found to be the major prognostic factors for achievement of CR. No difference was found in remission duration or survival between the two different induction schedules. Neither did the morphological subtype of AML (FAB classification) or the leukocyte count at diagnosis correlate with remission rate or survival.     

Immunotherapy with bestatin for acute nonlymphocytic leukemia in adults

Summary In a cooperative randomized control study of immunotherapy with bestatin in combination with chemotherapy in adults with acute nonlymphocytic leukemia (ANLL), 101 patients (48 in the bestatin group and 53 in the control group) out of 115 patients registered were evaluated as eligible. The bestatin group achieved a statistically significant prolongation of survival compared with the control group in overall ANLL and acute myelogenous leukemia. In the analysis of patient age, the bestatin group achieved a statistically significant prolongation of both the remission duration and survival in patients aged 50 to 65 years, while the differences were not significant in the 15 to 49 age group. The bestatin group tended to achieve a higher rate of reinduction of remission in patients who had recurrence of leukemia. Side effects developed in only 5 (9.6%) of 52 patients treated with bestatin. None of these side effects were particularly serious in nature. It is concluded that bestatin is useful for prolongation of survival of adult patients with ANLL, making for a longer remission duration especially in elderly patients and with few side effects.     

Adjuvant immunotherapy in acute nonlymphocytic leukemia

Summary Of 112 patients (maximum age 70 years) with acute nonlymphocytic leukemia, 62 (55%) went into remission on an induction therapy of cytosine arabinoside and daunorubicin. 20 patients were randomized for maintenance treatment consisting of chemotherapy only and 22 patients for combined chemo-immunotherapy. The chemotherapy consisted in 5-day courses of daunorubicin and cytosine arabinoside and of thioguanine and cytosine arabinoside, alternating every month. The chemo-immunotherapy group also received weekly intracutaneous injections of 10⁹ allogeneic nonirradiated leukemic myeloblasts and 10⁶ BCG organisms (Glaxo) by Heaf gun.The median duration of the first remission was 164 days for the chemotherapy group and 464 days for the chemo-immunotherapy group. The corresponding median times of survival were 344 days for the first group and 734 days for the second group. The difference concerning median duration of survival is statistically significant. Thus immunotherapy seems to prolong survival.     

Results of randomized trials of immunotherapy for acute leukemia

Summary For more than a decade clinical trials have attempted to define the role of immunotherapy in the treatment of patients with acute leukemia. Based on animal studies which indicated that non-specific immune stimulation had an antitumor effect if the tumor burden was small, the use of immunotherapy during remission in patients with acute leukemia seemed appropriate following the initial report of the success of bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) in prolonging remission duration and survival in acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Therefore a series of randomized clinical trials was initiated to confirm these original observations. In four studies comparing BCG inoculations, with or without allogeneic leukemia cells, and chemotherapy or no therapy, no advantage of immunotherapy was noted. Immunotherapy appeared to be equally as good as chemotherapy. A combination of BCG and chemotherapy showed some advantage in one study, but no advantage was noted in two other studies.In acute myeloblastic leukemia several randomized trials suggested that BCG or one of its derivatives when given alone, in combination with allogeneic cells, or with chemotherapy had a marginal effect in prolonging remission duration and survival when compared to chemotherapy or rno therapy.In conclusion, immunotherapy during remission has marginal activity in acute leukemia.     

Results in children of acute lymphoid leukaemia protocol ICIG-ALL 9 consisting of chemotherapy for only nine months followed by active immunotherapy

Summary Protocol ICIG-ALL 9 with only nine months' remission chemotherapy followed by active immunotherapy has given a proportion of about 50% of the patients on the plateau of the first remission curve, while 60% of the children are on the plateau of survival curve.These results do not differ from those of another protocol (ICIG-ALL 10) conducted on an identical population of patients and comprising a 25 month remission chemotherapy before immunotherapy.This observation, confirmed by a randomized trial of the EORTC Haemopathy Working Party, suggests that between the 9th and the 25th month, active immunotherapy is as efficient as maintenance chemotherapy.The overall results of this protocol with short chemotherapy followed by active immunotherapy have been compared with those of another prolonged maintenance chemotherapy before immunotherapy protocol (ICIG-ALL 11), and with published protocols comprising only long maintenance chemotherapy: protocol 9 is, as far as the first remission plateau and the survival plateau are concerned, superior to most of these protocols (if not all their branches).Lethal toxicity of active immunotherapy is nil, in contrast to the proportion of deaths (4–28%) occurring during remission in the patients submitted to maintenance chemotherapy.However, not all patients with so-called acute lymphoid leukaemias should be treated identically: our early prognosis parameters (WHO cytological types and volume of the tumour, in this study) allow us to distinguish a good prognosis group in which protocol 9 gave an 80% cure expectancy.The patients with a poor prognosis should be the object of further research for a more efficient therapy. Even if this should be more intensive, the risk is justified in this group, while it is not so for the good prognosis group.     

Serial immunologic assessment during a randomized trial of chemoimmunotherapy in acute myelogenous leukemia

Summary Thirty-one adults who had acute myelogenous leukemia and in whom remission had been induced and consolidated with chemotherapy were randomized to receive one of three maintenance schedules: (A) BCG + chemotherapy [1, 3-bis-(2-chlorethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU) and cytosine arabinoside]; (B) splenectomy, followed 1 week later with BCG and chemotherapy; or (C) allogeneic leukemic cells, BCG, and chemotherapy. Serial immunologic assessments were performed at the onset of maintenance and every 3 months.No differences were found in duration of remission (median 209 days) or survival (median 454 days) among the three schedules. Six patients remain in remission after from 2–4 + years. Skin test responses, mitogen responses, mixed lymphocyte culture responses, antibody responses, and T and B lymphocyte numbers were depressed at the onset of maintenance therapy. Therapy clearly improved the state of anergy as defined by recall antigen responsiveness, and induced in vivo and in vitro PPD reactivity. However, immunotherapy resulted in a reduction of the number of T or B cells and of the in vitro lymphocyte response to mitogens and allogeneic cells. Serum obtained at diagnosis and during remission inhibited in vitro blastogenic responses in more than half the patients. These data indicate that chemoimmunotherapy given as described tended to be more immunosuppressive than stimulatory.     

Efficacy of adjuvant immunochemotherapy with polysaccharide K for patients with curative resections of gastric cancer

Non-specific immunopotentiators, such as polysaccharide K (PSK), also known as OK-432, induce anti-tumor effects via immunological responses. The efficacy of combination immunochemotherapy using these immunopotentiators has been examined by multiple previous studies. The survival benefits of immunochemotherapy for patients with curative resections of gastric cancers are not widely accepted. To clarify this issue, we performed a meta-analysis to evaluate the effect of immunochemotherapy on survival in patients with curative resections of gastric cancer. For this study, we compared the results of chemotherapy and immunotherapy using the biological response modifier PSK as an immunopotentiator. The meta-analysis included 8,009 patients from eight randomized controlled trials after central randomization. The overall hazard ratio for eligible patients was 0.88 (95% confidence interval, 0.79–0.98; P = 0.018) with no significant heterogeneity [χ ²(8) for heterogeneity = 11.7; P = 0.16]. The results of this meta-analysis suggest that adjuvant immunochemotherapy with PSK improves the survival of patients after curative gastric cancer resection.     

Various uses of BCG and allogeneic acute leukemia cells to treat patients with acute myelogenous leukemia

Summary Ninety-six remission patients with acute myelogenous leukemia have been treated with various forms of immunotherapy and chemotherapy in three distinct studies and the clinical outcome of these patients has been reported. In the first study 22 patients were maintained on chemotherapy alone and 28 patients were given the same chemotherapy and additional immunotherapy consisting of BCG and irradiated allogeneic AML cells given at separate sites weekly. It was found that there was a significant increase in survival time of the patients who received immunotherapy (median 510 days) compared with the chemotherapy alone patients (270 days). The p value for this was 0.03. The reason for this prolongation of survival was mainly due to a markedly increased survival time of immunotherapy patients after they relapsed when compared with the chemotherapy patients (165 days compared with 75 days median, p equal to 0.0005). In the second sequential study 24 patients were given immunotherapy alone consisting of irradiated allogeneic AML cells and BCG given at separate sites, and this was compared with unirradiated allogeneic cells and BCG given to 22 patients. There was no difference in the remission length or survival between these two groups. In the third study 13 patients received irradiated cells and BCG as in Study 1 and a further 11 patients received the same immunotherapy but also received a mixture of cells and BCG given during the first three months. There was no difference in the remission and survival of these two groups. The significance of these results is discussed.     

1975 current results of the first 100 cytologically typed acute lymphoid leukemia submitted to BCG active immunotherapy

Summary The first 100 acute lymphoid (and undifferentiated) leukemias, (of which the smears at the first presentation of the disease are still available for typing), treated successively with remission induction chemotherapy, complementary cell-reducing chemoradiotherapy and then active immunotherapy with irradiated pooled allogeneic leukemic cells and fresh Pasteur Institute BCG applied on scarifications, have been reviewed, especially in connection with BCG application.Tolerance of BCG has been good. Its application had to be stopped due to a side effect (choroiditis) in only one patient. This toxic cost is negligible compared to that of so-called maintenance chemotherapy.No subject of our first control trial started in 1963 has relapsed between 3 and 13 years.In the overall group of the 100 patients studied, no relapse has been observed after 48 months, which is quite different to the observations of frequent relapses after that time in patients submitted to maintenance chemotherapy.Moreover, second remissions are obtained in 94% of the patients who relapsed early under immunotherapy, and their life expectancy after a second remission is as high as it is after the first remission.The median of survival is longer than 5 years.The action of active immunotherapy on the immune machinery has been followed by several assays, of which the increase of null cells (which include K-cells) may be the most interesting.Several prognostic factors have been demonstrated among which are sex, the volume of the neoplasia, meningeal localizations, and the cytological types. Age has no prognostic value in immunotherapy patients, contrary to maintenance chemotherapy patients. Also the cytological types behave differently under immunotherapy and under maintenance chemotherapy. The disease-free survival of more than 85% of the microlymphoblastic patients submitted to immunotherapy is not observed in J. Bernard's patients submitted to maintenance chemotherapy, which suggests that this high cure rate is due to active immunotherapy. Hence, these prognostic factors are probably factors of sensitivity to active immunotherapy. A statistical computerized study has shown that there is a link between the cytological types and other prognostic factors and that they all depend on the cytological type.Hence, our present protocol is adapted to this immunotherapy sensitivity factor. It comprises a nonrisk preimmunotherapy chemotherapy for the microlymphoblastic type, and a longer and more intensive chemotherapy for less immunotherapy sensitive types.     

Chemoimmunotherapy of advanced breast cancer: prolongation of remission and survival with BCG.

Forty-five patients with disseminated breast cancer were given a trial of combination chemotherapy consisting of fluorouracil, adriamycin, and cyclophosphamide (FAC) and immunotherapy with BCG given by scarification. The results were compared with those in a comparable group of 44 patients treated with FAC alone immediately before the chemoimmunotherapy study. The remission rates (73% and 76% for FAC and FAC-BCG respectively) were similar in both studies. The durations of remission for patients on FAC-BCG (medium 12 months) were longer than remissions achieved for patients given FAC alone (median 8 months) (P = 0.068). The most notable effect of BCG was on survival. Thus 21 out of 34 patients achieving remission on FAC-BCG were alive at the time of the last follow-up examination (median over 22 months) compared with 11 out of 32 patients achieving remission on FAC (median 15 months) (P = 0.01). Twenty-six of the 45 patients given FAC-BCG were alive at the time of the last follow-up examination (median over 22 months) compared with 12 of the 44 patients given FAC (median 15 months) (P = 0.005). Although the apparent benefit of BCG could be explained by a maldistribution of some prognostic factors, the data suggest that further trial of chemoimmunotherapy of breast cancer should be carried out.     

Significant prolongation of disease-free period gained by oral polysaccharide K (PSK) administration after curative surgical operation of colorectal cancer

Summary To examine the clinical efficacy and the mechanism of action of polysaccharide K (PSK), a proteinbound polysaccharide extracted from a Basidiomycetes fungus, a randomized double-blind trial was performed by administering PSK to 56 patients and a placebo to another group of 55 patients after surgical operations on their colorectal cancers. The rate of patients in remission (or disease-free) was significantly higher in the PSK group than in the placebo group; the difference between both groups was statistically significant atP <0.05 by the logrank test. The survival rate of patients was also significantly (P <0.05) higher in the PSK group than in the control group. The most significant laboratory finding was that polymorphonuclear leukocytes from PSK-treated patients showed remarkable enhancement in their activities, such as random and/or chemotactic locomotion, and phagocytic activity, when compared with those in the control group. In conclusion, PSK was useful as a maintenance therapy for patients after their curative surgical operations for colorectal cancer. The beneficial effects were probably due to the activation of leukocyte functions as one of the many biological-response-modifying (activities induced by PSK).     

Immunotherapy of breast cancer,malignant melanoma,and acute leukemia with BCG: Prolongation of disease free interval and survival

Summary Results of immunotherapy with BCG in patients with malignant melanoma, breast cancer, and acute leukemia are described. The first study demonstrated that high doses of living BCG organisms (6×10⁸ viable units) delivered by scarification in the upper arms and legs prolonged the disease-free interval and survival of 52 malignant melanoma patients with regional lymph node metastases compared to 218 comparable surgical control patients. Patients with trunk and extremity, but not head and neck melanoma, benefited from BCG, suggesting the importance of the delivery of BCG into the tumor-involved lymphatics.The second study evaluated the therapeutic efficacy of living BCG organisms by scarification in a group of adult acute leukemia patients after the cessation of chemotherapy. Thirty-seven patients had been in remission on intermittent chemotherapy for 12–24 months. Following late intensive consolidation chemotherapy, 7 consecutive patients received no further therapy and then 30 consecutive patients received BCG. Patients maintained on BCG have had a prolonged disease-free interval compared to those given on no further therapy (P=0.07) or compared to a group of similar patients maintained on chemotherapy alone (P=0.001). Similarly, the survival has been improved for patients maintained on BCG compared to those left unmaintained (P=0.009), or those maintained on chemotherapy (P=0.001).The principles of intermittent chemotherapy combined with BCG immunotherapy, first developed in patients with disseminated melanoma and acute myelogenous leukemia, have been confirmed in a series of patients with disseminated breast cancer. Forty-five patients treated with a combination of 5-FU, adriamycin, and cyclophosphamide (FAC) plus BCG by scarification showed prolongation of remission as well as survival compared to a comparable group of 44 patients treated with FAC chemotherapy without immunotherapy. Thus, 23/44 patients treated with FAC have died (median=14 months) compared to only 5/45 patients on FAC-BCG (median=12⁺ months), P=0.005. The limitations of BCG immunotherapy as well as speculations for future developments of immunotherapy are discussed.This work was supported by Contract No1-CB 33888 from the National Institutes of Health, Public Health Service, Bethesda, Maryland 20014. Drs. Gutterman and Mavligit are the recipients of Career Development Awards (Ca 71007-02 and CA 00130-01, respectively) from the National Institutes of Health, Education, and Welfare, Bethesda, Maryland 20014.     

Immunotherapy of lung cancer with Corynebacterium parvum

Summary Thirty-one patients with inoperable carcinoma of the lung, excluding oat-cell carcinoma, were randomized to receive either chemotherapy alone, with methyl CCNU and vinblastine every 6–8 weeks (15 Pts) or such chemotherapy plus immunotherapy with IV infusions of Corynebacterium parvum (16 Pts). Prior duration of the disease was longer, and more patients had received previous therapy, in the immunotherapy group; these groups were otherwise very similar. In vitro lymphocyte response to phytohemagglutinin did not change significantly in either group, but the weaker response to Varidase declined in both groups after chemotherapy. An increased baseline level of circulating B lymphocytes was sharply reduced in the C. parvum group. There were no differences in -globulins or delayed skin test responses between immunotherapy and control patients at entry into this study or on follow-up. Median survival from entry was longer in the immunotherapy group (6 months) than in the control group (3 months), but this difference was not statistically significant and only two patients in each group lived for more than 11 months. It is conceivable that more benefit from C. parvum might have been recorded had more effective chemotherapy been available.     

CFU-gm colony formation of peripheral blood and bone marrow in adult acute leukemia at presentation, during remission, and at relapse

Granulocyte/macrophage colony-forming unit (CFU-gm) formation was studied simultaneously in bone marrow and peripheral blood of 52 previously untreated adult patients with acute non-lymphocytic (ANLL) and 36 with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). They were followed during induction therapy at monthly intervals while in remission and in 19 ANLL and 22 ALL cases, until relapse. Patients showing a decreased colony number in the marrow but normal or increased colony numbers in the peripheral blood had a high probability of entering remission. Non-responding patients displayed an opposite pattern. The higher the degree of marrow repopulation with granulocytic progenitor cells after induction treatment, the longer remission duration and survival for ANLL patients and the longer survival for ALL patients. CFU-gm formation returned to normal in the early stages of complete remission, but then declined progressively. At ANLL and ALL relapse, colony growth was reduced markedly while cluster formation remained normal. The number of marrow colonies and clusters in ANLL were significantly higher at first and second relapse compared to the growth pattern at first presentation. A similar trend had been observed in ALL, suggesting a selection advantage.     

Efficacy of adjuvant Immunochemotherapy with polysaccharide K for patients with curatively resected colorectal cancer: a meta-analysis of centrally randomized controlled clinical trials

The benefits of immunochemotherapy employing the biological response modifier polysaccharide K (PSK) for patients with curatively resected colorectal cancer was reassessed by means of a meta-analysis of data with center randomization from 1,094 patients enrolled in three clinical trials. In all three trials, patients were followed up for at least 5 years after surgery and enrollment of the last patient and outcomes for standard chemotherapy were compared with those for chemotherapy plus PSK. The endpoints were overall survival and disease-free survival; and intent-to-treat analysis was performed without patient exclusion. Data were analyzed using the weighted average of the individual log hazard ratios. The overall survival risk ratio for all eligible patients was 0.71 (95% confidence interval (CI) : 0.55–0.90; P=0.006), and the disease-free survival risk ratio was 0.72 (95% CI: 0.58–0.90; P=0.003). The results of this meta-analysis suggest that adjuvant immunochemotherapy with PSK can improve both survival and disease-free survival of patients with curatively resected colorectal cancer.     

Postoperative adjuvant immunotherapy of gastric cancer with BCG-cell wall skeleton

The clinical effectiveness of immunotherapy with the cell wall skeleton of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin was assessed in a study involving 140 consecutive patients with gastric cancer, who were gastrectomized at a single institution from January 1976 through December 1978. These patients were randomized by an envelope method after operation and divided into three treatment groups: 'control', 'chemotherapy', and 'chemotherapy plus immunotherapy with BCG-CWS.' Only two patients who died during surgery were excluded, and a survey of survival periods was made on the remaining 138 patients in January 1982. As a result, statistically significant differences in the survival rate curve were observed between the control and chemotherapy plus immunotherapy groups (P less than 0.01), and between the chemotherapy and chemotherapy plus immunotherapy groups (P less than 0.05). These results emphasize effectiveness of BCG-CWS as an adjuvant immunotherapeutic agent in gastrectomized cancer patients.     

Bacille Calmette-Guérin as maintenance therapy for non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

Following complete remission of non-Hodgkin''s lymphoma by chemotherapy, irradiation or both, 44 patients were studied to assess the value of bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) as maintenance therapy. Patients with stage LI, EI or EII disease were allocated at random to receive BCG or no further maintenance therapy, and those with stage LII, LIII, EIII or IV disease received BCG therapy or orally administered cyclophosphamide. BCG had no effect on the duration of remission or the overall survival from the time of randomization. However, after the first recurrence there was a significant improvement in survival in the patients who had received BCG maintenance therapy.     

Remission induction and remission maintenance in adult acute nonlymphocytic leukemia employing a modified cytostatic (COAP) regimen.

Thirty adult patients suffering from acute nonlymphocytic leukemia (ANLL) were treated according to a modified COAP regimen. Vincristine, cyclophosphamide, and prednisone were given by push injection, while cytosine arabinoside was infused over periods of 8 h. Nineteen patients (63%) achieved complete remission. Remission maintenance therapy consisted of 6-mercaptopurine daily and methotrexate twice weekly. Later in the study, COAP consolidation and reinduction was added, which improved the median duration of complete remission from 7 to 24 months. Comparison of the results with the literature shows that the modified COAP regimen is one of the most effective treatment schedules for adult ANLL.     

Non-cytotoxic asialo-GM1-positive cells exert antimetastatic activity

Summary We examined the results of discontinuing therapy in Japanese children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Of the 209 patients in the chemoimmunotherapy study, 120 (57.4%) had all chemotherapy stopped after 3 years of complete remission, and 72 (34.4%) reached the point of discontinuing immunotherapy after 5 years of complete remission. Of the 120 children removed from chemotherapy, 14 (11.7%) have relapsed, mainly in the extramedullary sites (5: testis, 5: bone marrow, 3: central nervous system, 1: bone); relapses occurred 1–23 months after cessation of chemotherapy (median 11 months). Boys had higher post-chemotherapy relapse rate than girls (0.21 versus 0.08, P<0.05). None of the 72 children removed from immunotherapy have yet relapsed. Long-term remission and possibly cure can be expected in approximately one-half of newly diagnosed Japanese patients. Although the active immunotherapy had no beneficial effect on the overall outcome for leukemic children, it could be of benefit to the elimination of bone marrow relapses after cessation of chemotherapy.