Plasmodiophora brassicae: a review of an emerging pathogen of the Canadian canola (Brassica napus) crop

Plasmodiophora brassicae causes clubroot disease in cruciferous plants, and is an emerging threat to Canadian canola (Brassica napus) production. This review focuses on recent studies into the pathogenic diversity of P. brassicae populations, mechanisms of pathogenesis and resistance, and the development of diagnostic tests for pathogen detection and quantification. TAXONOMY: Plasmodiophora brassicae is a soil-borne, obligate parasite within the class Phytomyxea (plasmodiophorids) of the protist supergroup Rhizaria. DISEASE SYMPTOMS: Clubroot development is characterized by the formation of club-shaped galls on the roots of affected plants. Above-ground symptoms include wilting, stunting, yellowing and premature senescence. DISEASE CYCLE: Plasmodiophora brassicae first infects the root hairs, producing motile zoospores that invade the cortical tissue. Secondary plasmodia form within the root cortex and, by triggering the expression of genes involved in the production of auxins, cytokinins and other plant growth regulators, divert a substantial proportion of plant resources into hypertrophic growth of the root tissues, resulting in the formation of galls. The secondary plasmodia are cleaved into millions of resting spores and the root galls quickly disintegrate, releasing long-lived resting spores into the soil. A serine protease, PRO1, has been shown to trigger resting spore germination. PHYSIOLOGICAL SPECIALIZATION: Physiological specialization occurs in populations of P. brassicae, and various host differential sets, consisting of different collections of Brassica genotypes, are used to distinguish among pathotypes of the parasite. DETECTION AND QUANTIFICATION: As P. brassicae cannot be cultured, bioassays with bait plants were traditionally used to detect the pathogen in the soil. More recent innovations for the detection and quantification of P. brassicae include the use of antibodies, quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) and qPCR in conjunction with signature fatty acid analysis, all of which are more sensitive than bioassays. RESISTANCE IN CANOLA: Clubroot-resistant canola hybrids, recently introduced into the Canadian market, represent an important new tool for clubroot management in this crop. Genetic resistance must be carefully managed, however, as it has been quickly overcome in other regions. At least three resistance genes and one or two quantitative trait loci are involved in conferring resistance to P. brassicae. Root hair infection still occurs in resistant cultivars, but secondary plasmodia often remain immature and unable to produce resting spores. Fewer cell wall breakages occur in resistant hosts, and spread of the plasmodium through cortical tissue is restricted. More information on the genetics of clubroot resistance in canola is needed to ensure more effective resistance stewardship. USEFUL WEBSITES: http://www.canolacouncil.org/clubroot/resources.aspx, http://tu-dresden.de/die_tu_dresden/fakultaeten/fakultaet_mathematik_und_naturwissenschaften/fachrichtung_biologie/botanik/pflanzenphysiologie/clubroot, http://www.ohio.edu/people/braselto/plasmos/     

Infection of Chinese cabbage by Plasmodiophora brassicae leads to a stimulation of plant growth: impacts on cell wall metabolism and hormone balance

The importance of plant hormones in clubroot infection has long been recognized. The morphological changes, such as cell division and cell elongation leading to gall formation are triggered in the early stages of infection. We analysed cell expansion by localizing Xyloglucan endoTransglucosylase/Hydrolase (XTH)-action and screened the endogenous concentrations of several classes of phytohormones by mass spectrometry in the early stages of Plasmodiophora brassicae infection in Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa spp. pekinensis). Infected plants showed a general transient growth promotion early in infection. Furthermore a clear XTH action was visible in the epidermal layer of infected roots. Complex changes in the endogenous phytohormone profile were observed. Initially infection resulted in an increased total auxin pool. The auxin increase, together with an increased XTH action, results in wall loosening and consequently cell expansion. When the first secondary plasmodia are formed, thirteen days after infection (DAI), can be considered a switch point in phytohormone metabolism. Twenty-one DAI the plasmodia might act as a plant hormone sink resulting in a reduction in the active cytokinin pool and a lower indole-3-acetic acid content in the infected plants.     

The occurrence of free and bound cytokinins in plasmodia of Plasmodiophora brassicae isolated from tissue cultures of clubroots

Plasmodia have been isolated from Brassica campestris tissue infected with Plasmodiophora brassicae. Cytokinins were extracted from plasmodia and from the remaining host cytoplasm. Fractions were separated in a butanol soluble fraction containing free cytokinins and a water soluble fraction containing bound forms, presumably glucose-6-phosphate derivatives of zeatin and zeatin riboside. The butanol fraction was analysed by high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC). The different glucosides were determined after treatment of the water fraction with -glucosidase.Plasmodia contained zeatin riboside and its glucose derivative (175 and 1600 ng/g dry weight, respectively). Host cytoplasm contained zeatin riboside (132 ng/g dry weight) and small amounts of the glucose-6-phosphate derivatives of zeatin and zeatin riboside. The results suggest that plasmodia synthesize cytokinins which are released into the host cytoplasm inducing host cell division.     

A hormone and proteome approach to picturing the initial metabolic events during Plasmodiophora brassicae infection on Arabidopsis

We report on the early response of Arabidopsis thaliana to the obligate biotrophic pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae at the hormone and proteome level. Using a CYCB1;1::GUS construct, the re-initiation of infection-related cell division is shown from 4 days after inoculation on. Sensitivity to cytokinins and auxins as well as the endogenous hormone levels are evaluated. Both an enhanced cytokinin gene response and an accumulation of isopentenyl adenine and adenosine precede this re-initiation of cell division, whereas an enhanced auxin gene response is observed from 6 days after inoculation on. The alhl mutant, impaired in the cross talk between ethylene and auxins, is resistant to P. brassicae. A differential protein analysis of infected versus noninfected roots and hypocotyls was performed using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and quantitative image analysis, coupled to matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight-time of flight mass spectrometry-based protein identification. Of the visualized proteins, 12% show altered abundance compared with the noninfected plants, including proteins involved in metabolism, cell defense, cell differentiation, and detoxification. Combining the hormone and proteome data, we postulate that, at the very first stages of Plasmodiophora infection, plasmodial-produced cytokinins trigger a local re-initiation of cell division in the root cortex. Consequently, a de novo meristematic area is established that acts as a sink for host-derived indole-3-acetic acid, carbohydrates, nitrogen, and energy to maintain the pathogen and to trigger gall development.     

Expression and localization of nitrilase during symptom development of the clubroot disease in Arabidopsis

The expression of nitrilase in Arabidopsis during the development of the clubroot disease caused by the obligate biotroph Plasmodiophora brassicae was investigated. A time course study showed that only during the exponential growth phase of the clubs was nitrilase prominently enhanced in infected roots compared with controls. NIT1 and NIT2 are the nitrilase isoforms predominantly expressed in clubroot tissue, as shown by investigating promoter-beta-glucuronidase fusions of each. Two peaks of beta-glucuronidase activity were visible: an earlier peak (21 d post inoculation) consisting only of the expression of NIT1, and a second peak at about 32 d post inoculation, which predominantly consisted of NIT2 expression. Using a polyclonal antibody against nitrilase, it was shown that the protein was mainly found in infected cells containing sporulating plasmodia, whereas in cells of healthy roots and in uninfected cells of inoculated roots only a few immunosignals were detected. To determine which effect a missing nitrilase isoform might have on symptom development, the P. brassicae infection in a nitrilase mutant (nit1-3) of Arabidopsis was investigated. As a comparison, transgenic plants overexpressing NIT2 under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter were studied. Root galls were smaller in nit1-3 plants compared with the wild type. The phenotype of smaller clubs in the mutant was correlated with a lower free indole-3-acetic acid content in the clubs compared with the wild type. Overexpression of nitrilase did not result in larger clubs compared with the wild type. The putative role of nitrilase and auxins during symptom development is discussed.     

Nitrilase activity in clubroot diseased plants

Nitrilase activity was detected in desalted extracts of leaves, hypocotyls and roots of swede ( Brassica napus ) but was considerably higher in leaves than in roots. After inoculation with Plasmodiophora brassicae infected roots and hypocotyls showed an increase in nitrilase activity beginning at the early stages of club development before total protein increased significantly. Enzyme activity of infected tissue was partially purified by DEAE ion exchange chromatography and compared to the enzyme extracted from non infected seedlings. It appears that the increase in nitrilase activity is due to an increase of the plant enzyme which is initially present with lower activity. K_m values for the artificial substrate 3-cyanopyridine and for indole-3-acetonitrile were 2.1 × 10⁻³ M and 6.2 × 10⁻⁴M, respectively. The role of nitrilase activity for IAA biosynthesis is discussed.     

The infected root-hair count for estimating the activity of Plasmodiophora brassicae Woron. in the soil

A method is described for estimating the relative numbers of Plasmodiophora brassicae spores germinating in different soils, by counting infected root hairs. Cabbage seedlings are grown for 1 week at 25C. in glass tumblers of the infected soils; after washing out, the tap roots are stained in 1% aceto-carmine and a count is made of the number of root hairs containing zoosporangia of P. brassicae , along 2 cm. of root. It is shown that by this method it is possible to study, for example, the action of different bases in inhibiting root-hair infection; the main inhibiting factor was found to be soil alkalinity, however produced. Other factors were found to influence infection in lesser degree; thus the number of infected root hairs was reduced in soils receiving N /10 sodium and potassium chlorides in place of distilled water. Root-hair infection was also inhibited by low soil-moisture content.     

The host range of Plasmodiophora brassicae and its relationship to endogenous glucosinolate content

The host range of the soilborne obligate biotroph, Plasmodiophora brassicae was investigated. Evidence is presented that infection by P. brassicae might occur in non- Brassica species, leading to the potential formation of resting spores. Structures resembling P. brassicae were found in the root cortex of Tropaeolum majus , Carica papaya , Reseda alba and Beta vulgaris as demonstrated by scanning electron microscopy. Inoculation of Brassica rapa roots with spores extracted from either T. majus or B. vulgaris roots which had been previously inoculated with P. brassicae led to development of clubroot in the roots of B. rapa . It was also shown that the development of the symptom might be correlated with glucosinolate content, although other host factors are implicated in the B. vulgaris interaction with P. brassicae . In the glucosinolate-containing non-Brassicas, T. majus and C. papaya , the concentrations of benzylglucosinolate increased markedly in roots inoculated with P. brassicae , compared with the controls. There were also increases in concentrations of benzylglucosinolate in leaves of T. majus after P. brassicae infection. However, in R. alba roots, the total glucosinolate content decreased after inoculation with P. brassicae compared with the controls. High root concentrations of 2-OH-2-phenylethylglucosinolate (glucobarbarin) compared with low root indole glucosinolates in this species might limit P. brassicae infection and development. The importance of our investigations in relation to cultivation of non- Brassica species on fields infested with P. brassicae is discussed.     

Indole-3-methylglucosinolate biosynthesis and metabolism in clubroot diseased plants

lndole-3-methylglucosinolate biosynthesis and metabolism in roots of Brassica napus (swede, cv. Danestone II) infected with Plasmodiophora brassicae Wor. were investigated with a pulse feeding technique developed to infiltrate intact tissue segments with labelled substrates. Infected root tissue metabolized [¹⁴C]-L-tryptophan to indole-3-methylglucosinolate, indole-3-acetonitrile, and some other lipophilic indole compounds. The incorporation of radioactivity into these compounds was significantly enhanced in infected tissue compared with control tissue. A time course study showed a high turnover of indole-3-methylglucosinolate and indole-3-acetonitrile in infected tissue. However, thioglucoside glucohydrolase activity was not changed in infected tissue compared with control tissue. Disc electrophoresis revealed the same isoenzyme in both tissues. Control and infected tissues both rapidly hydrolyzed [¹⁴C]-indole-3-acetonitrile in vivo. The possibility of a disease specific biosynthesis of indole-3-acetic acid from indole-3-methylglucosinolate as the result of a changed compartmentation is discussed.     

Induction of trehalase in Arabidopsis plants infected with the trehalose-producing pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae

Various microorganisms produce the disaccharide trehalose during their symbiotic and pathogenic interactions with plants. Trehalose has strong effects on plant metabolism and growth; therefore, we became interested to study its possible role in the interaction of Arabidopsis thaliana with Plasmodiophora brassicae, the causal agent of clubroot disease. We found that trehalose accumulated strongly in the infected organs (i.e., the roots and hypocotyls) and, to a lesser extent, in the leaves and stems of infected plants. This accumulation pattern of trehalose correlated with the expression of a putative trehalose-6-phosphate synthase (EC 2.4.1.15) gene from P. brassicae, PbTPS1. Clubroot formation also resulted in an induction of the Arabidopsis trehalase gene, ATTRE1, and in a concomitant increase in trehalase (EC 3.2.1.28) activity in the roots and hypocotyls, but not in the leaves and stems of infected plants. Thus, induction of ATTRE1 expression was probably responsible for the increased trehalase activity. Trehalase activity increased before trehalose accumulated; therefore, it is unlikely that trehalase was induced by its substrate. The induction of trehalase may be part of the plant's defense response and may prevent excess accumulation of trehalose in the plant cells, where it could interfere with the regulation of carbon metabolism.     

Transcriptome analysis of Arabidopsis clubroots indicate a key role for cytokinins in disease development

The clubroot disease of the family Brassicaceae is caused by the obligate biotrophic protist Plasmodiophora brassicae. Infected roots undergo a developmental switch that results in the formation of aberrant roots (clubs). To investigate host gene expression during the development of the disease, we have used the Arabidopsis ATH1 genome array. Two timepoints were chosen, an early timepoint at which the pathogen has colonized the root but has induced only very limited change of host cell and root morphology and a later timepoint at which more than 60% of the host root cells were colonized and root morphology was drastically altered. At both timepoints, more than 1,000 genes were differentially expressed in infected versus control roots. These included genes associated with growth and cell cycle, sugar phosphate metabolism, and defense. The involvement of plant hormones in club development was further supported; genes involved in auxin homeostasis, such as nitrilases and members of the GH3 family, were upregulated, whereas genes involved in cytokinin homeostasis (cytokinin synthases and cytokinin oxidases/dehydrogenases) were already strongly downregulated at the early timepoint. Cytokinin oxidase/dehydrogenase overexpressing lines were disease resistant, clearly indicating the importance of cytokinin as a key factor in clubroot disease development.     

Arginase induction represses gall development during clubroot infection in Arabidopsis

Arginase induction can play a defensive role through the reduction of arginine availability for phytophageous insects. Arginase activity is also induced during gall growth caused by Plasmodiophora brassicae infection in roots of Arabidopsis thaliana; however, its possible role in this context has been unclear. We report here that the mutation of the arginase-encoding gene ARGAH2 abrogates clubroot-induced arginase activity and results in enhanced gall size in infected roots, suggesting that arginase plays a defensive role. Induction of arginase activity in infected roots was impaired in the jar1 mutant, highlighting a link between the arginase response to clubroot and jasmonate signaling. Clubroot-induced accumulation of the principal amino acids in galls was not affected by the argah2 mutation. Because ARGAH2 was previously reported to control auxin response, we investigated the role of ARGAH2 in callus induction. ARGAH2 was found to be highly induced in auxin/cytokinin-triggered aseptic plant calli, and callus development was enhanced in argah2 in the absence of the pathogen. We hypothesized that arginase contributes to a negative control over clubroot symptoms, by reducing hormone-triggered cellular proliferation.     

Translocation of 14C-labelled assimilates in cabbage during club root development

The effects of infection of root systems by Plasmodiophora brassicae on the translocation of ¹⁴C-labelled assimilates from the first and third leaves of cabbage seedlings were investigated. During the early phases of Plasmodium development, there were small differences in the distribution patterns of ¹⁴C-labelled assimilate between healthy and infected seedlings. At the end of growth of plasmodia and during resting spore formation, both first and third leaves exported more assimilates than corresponding leaves of healthy seedlings. When the infected roots were dissected into various regions after exposure of the fed leaves to ¹⁴CO₂, more assimilate accumulated in the club root region than in any other part.     

The shoot controls zeatin riboside export from pea roots. Evidence from the branching mutant rms4

The rms4 mutant of pea ( Pisum sativum L.) was used in grafting studies and cytokinin analyses of the root xylem sap to provide evidence that, at least for pea, the shoot can modify the import of cytokinins from the root. The rms4 mutation, which confers a phenotype with increased branching in the shoot, causes a very substantial decrease (down to 40-fold less) in the concentration of zeatin riboside (ZR) in the xylem sap of the roots. Results from grafts between wild-type (WT) and rms4 plants indicate that the concentration of cytokinins in the xylem sap of the roots is determined almost entirely by the genotype of the shoot. WT scions normalize the cytokinin concentration in the sap of rms4 mutant roots, whereas mutant scions cause WT roots to behave like those of self-grafted mutant plants. The mechanism whereby rms4 shoots of pea cause a down-regulation in the export of cytokinins from the roots is unknown at this time. However, our data provide evidence that the shoot transmits a signal to the roots and thereby controls processes involved in the regulation of cytokinin biosynthesis in the root.     

Isolation of zeatin riboside from the chicory root

Summary From 250 kg of fresh chicory roots about 2 mg of a crystalline cytokinin were obtained. This substance was identified as ribosylzeatin (trans isomer). From the procedure employed it seems unlikely that the isolated cytokinin comes from the degradation of tRNAs; rather, it may constitute a separate pool of cytokinins.     

Metabolism and Plant Hormone Action During Clubroot Disease

Infection of Brassicaceae with the obligate biotrophic pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae results in the development of root galls (clubroots). During the transformation of a healthy root to a root gall a plethora of changes in primary and secondary metabolism occur. The upper part of an infected plant is retarded in growth due to redirection of assimilates from the shoot to the root. In addition, changes in the levels of plant growth regulators, especially auxins and cytokinins, contribute to the hypertrophy of infected roots. Also, defense reactions are manipulated after inoculation of suitable host plants with P. brassicae. This review summarizes our current knowledge on the changes in these parameters. A model is presented for how primary metabolism and secondary metabolism, including plant hormones, interact to induce clubroot formation.     

Arabidopsis thaliana, a new tool to investigate Polymyxa betae-host interactions

Little is known about the genome of Polymyxa betae and its interactions with sugar beet, due partly to the obligate nature of the protist and the patents on Beta vulgaris sequences. The identification of an ecotype of Arabidopsis thaliana compatible with the protist would help to improve this knowledge. The infection and development of P. betae in 14 worldwide ecotypes of A. thaliana were studied. The detection of plasmodia and resting spores and the production of zoospores in the roots of A. thaliana were obtained in three bioassays, using automatic immersion systems and individual glass tubes. Detection was done using molecular detection and microscopy. Compatible interactions were established between 13 A. thaliana ecotypes of the 14 that were tested and the monosporosoric Belgian strain of P. betae, A26-41. The ecotype Cvi-0 (N1096), from the Cape Verde Islands, was the most compatible with the protist. This ecotype is also susceptible to Plasmodiophora brassicae, another plasmodiophorid. Polymyxa betae infection in A. thaliana was relatively very low compared with B. vulgaris, but every stage of the life cycle of the protist was present. The spore-forming phase was promoted at the expense of the sporangial phase, probably caused by the stress of this new environment. In addition, the protist revealed a new phenotype. This new model study will allow molecular tools available for A. thaliana to be used in order to gain a better understanding of the P. betae-plant interaction during the spore-forming phase.     

茎瘤芥异戊烯基转移酶家族基因全基因组鉴定及表达分析北大核心CSCD

该研究以茎瘤芥栽培品种‘永安小叶’为实验材料,在全基因组水平对茎瘤芥基因组中异戊烯基转移酶(IPT)家族基因成员进行鉴定;通过荧光定量PCR检测各基因在不同组织、盐胁迫和根肿菌胁迫条件下的表达模式。结果显示:(1)在茎瘤芥基因组中共鉴定到27个IPT家族基因,分布在14条染色体上,它们在系统进化树中可聚类为7个分支。(2)大部分IPT家族基因主要在茎瘤芥的根和茎中表达,在叶片、花和种荚中表达量相对较低。BjuB006281在茎中的表达水平最高,BjuA027211、BjuB010173、BjuB010174和BjuA001839在根中的表达水平较高。(3)大部分的IPT基因表达受盐胁迫抑制,BjuB006281、BjuA036403、BjuB010173、BjuB026254在盐胁迫12~48 h显著下调表达;BjuB022918和BjuB007352则在盐胁迫24~48 h显著下调表达。(4)大部分茎瘤芥IPT基因在12 h受到根肿菌侵染的显著诱导,其中BjuB006281、BjuA014415、BjuB022918在侵染后12 h的表达水平为0 h对照的15倍以上。该研究鉴定出多个响应盐胁迫和根肿菌胁迫的IPT基因,为进一步研究他们的基因功能奠定了基础。     

Stimulation by caffeic acid,coumalic acid,and corilagin of the germination of resting spores of the clubroot pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae

Some chemicals were examined for their effects on the germination of resting spores of the clubroot pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae, and on the control of clubroots in Chinese cabbage. Caffeic acid, coumalic acid, and corilagin stimulated the germination of Plasmodiophora spores and prevented the formation of clubroots in Chinese cabbage. Clubroot might be controlled by agents with germination-stimulating effects.