Immunologic consequences of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain infection: role of the innate immune response in infection and immunity

Francisella tularensis (Ft), a Gram-negative intracellular bacterium, is the etiologic agent of tularemia. Although attenuated for humans, i.p. infection of mice with <10 Ft live vaccine strain (LVS) organisms causes lethal infection that resembles human tularemia, whereas the LD50 for an intradermal infection is >10(6) organisms. To examine the immunological consequences of Ft LVS infection on the innate immune response, the inflammatory responses of mice infected i.p. or intradermally were compared. Mice infected i.p. displayed greater bacterial burden and increased expression of proinflammatory genes, particularly in the liver. In contrast to most LPS, highly purified Ft LVS LPS (10 microg/ml) was found to be only minimally stimulatory in primary murine macrophages and in HEK293T cells transiently transfected with TLR4/MD-2/CD14, whereas live Ft LVS bacteria were highly stimulatory for macrophages and TLR2-expressing HEK293T cells. Despite the poor stimulatory activity of Ft LVS LPS in vitro, administration of 100 ng of Ft LVS LPS 2 days before Ft LVS challenge severely limited both bacterial burden and cytokine mRNA and protein expression in the absence of detectable Ab at the time of bacterial challenge, yet these mice developed a robust IgM Ab response within 2 days of infection and survived. These data suggest that prior administration of Ft LVS LPS protects the host by diminishing bacterial burden and blunting an otherwise overwhelming inflammatory response, while priming the adaptive immune response for development of a strong Ab response.     

Immunogenicity of a new lot of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain in human volunteers

Abstract A new lot of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS) was tested for immunogenicity in 19 human volunteers. Scarification vaccination induced specific cell-mediated and humoral immune responses. We noted a significant rise in antibodies against irradiation-killed LVS, formalin-killed virulent strain SCHU4, and an ether extracted antigen preparation (EEx) beginning 14 days after vaccination. A main target of the humoral immune response was lipopolysaccharide. Eighty percent of vaccinated volunteers developed a positive IgG response to EEx by day 14 and 100% of vaccinees responded positively by day 21. Background IgA titers were lower than corresponding IgG or IgM titers. No early IgM rise was noted with any antigen. By day 14 after vaccination, in vitro lymphocyte responses to LVS, the rough variant of LVS, and EEx were significantly increased compared to controls. Seventy percent of volunteers had a positive in vitro lymphocyte response to EEx within 14 days of vaccination. We predict that EEx will be a usefull antigen for diagnosing tularemia and for evaluating the immunogenicity of vaccines against tularemia. We are testing this antigen using sera from human cases of tularemia and control sera.     

Molecular immune responses to aerosol challenge with Francisella tularensis in mice inoculated with live vaccine candidates of varying efficacy

Background

Francisella tularensis is a facultative intracellular bacterial pathogen and the etiological agent of tularemia. The subspecies F. tularensis tularensis is especially virulent for humans when inhaled and respiratory tularemia is associated with high mortality if not promptly treated. A live vaccine strain (LVS) derived from the less virulent holarctica subspecies confers incomplete protection against aerosol challenge with subsp. tularensis. Moreover, correlates of protection have not been established for LVS.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In the present study we compare molecular immune responses elicited by LVS and two defined deletion mutants of clinical subsp. tularensis strain, SCHU S4, that confer enhanced protection in a mouse model. BALB/c mice were immunized intradermally then challenged with an aerosol of SCHU S4 six weeks later. Changes in the levels of a selected panel of cytokines and chemokines were examined in the lungs, spleens, and sera of vaccinated and challenged mice. Mostly, increased cytokine and chemokine levels correlated with increased bacterial burden. However, after adjusting for this variable, immunization with either of the two Schu S4 mutants resulted in higher levels of several pulmonary cytokines, versus those resulting after LVS immunization, including IL-17. Moreover, treatment of mice immunized with ΔclpB with anti-IL-17 antibodies post-challenge enhanced lung infection.

Conclusions/Significance

This is the first report characterizing local and systemic cytokine and chemokine responses in mice immunized with vaccines with different efficacies against aerosol challenge with virulent F. tularensis subsp. tularensis. It shows that increases in the levels of most of these immunomodulators, including those known to be critical for protective immunity, do not superficially correlate with protection unless adjusted for the effects of bacterial burden. Additionally, several cytokines were selectively suppressed in the lungs of naïve mice, suggesting that one mechanism of vaccine action is to overcome this pathogen-induced immunosuppression.     

Differential requirements by CD4+ and CD8+ T cells for soluble and membrane TNF in control of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain intramacrophage growth

During primary infection with intracellular bacteria, the membrane-associated form of TNF provides some TNF functions, but the relative contributions during memory responses are not well-characterized. In this study, we determined the role of T cell-derived secreted and membrane-bound TNF (memTNF) during adaptive immunity to Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS). Although transgenic mice expressing only the memTNF were more susceptible to primary LVS infection than wild-type (WT) mice, LVS-immune WT and memTNF mice both survived maximal lethal secondary Francisella challenge. Generation of CD44(high) memory T cells and clearance of bacteria were similar, although more IFN-gamma and IL-12(p40) were produced by memTNF mice. To examine T cell function, we used an in vitro tissue coculture system that measures control of LVS intramacrophage growth by LVS-immune WT and memTNF-T cells. LVS-immune CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells isolated from WT and memTNF mice exhibited comparable control of LVS growth in either normal or TNF-alpha knockout macrophages. Although the magnitude of CD4(+) T cell-induced macrophage NO production clearly depended on TNF, control of LVS growth by both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells did not correlate with levels of nitrite. Importantly, intramacrophage LVS growth control by CD8(+) T cells, but not CD4(+) T cells, was almost entirely dependent on T cell-expressed TNF, and required stimulation through macrophage TNFRs. Collectively, these data demonstrate that T cell-expressed memTNF is necessary and sufficient for memory T cell responses to this intracellular pathogen, and is particularly important for intramacrophage control of bacterial growth by CD8(+) T cells.     

Innate and adaptive immune responses to an intracellular bacterium,Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain

The immune response to intracellular bacterium, Francisella tularensis, which causes tularemia and is proposed to be a potential bioterrorism pathogen, has been studied in mice using the attenuated live vaccine strain (LVS). Here we review this infection model, which provides a convenient means of studying protective immune mechanisms not only for Francisella, but also for the large and important class of intracellular pathogens.     

Francisella tularensis selectively induces proinflammatory changes in endothelial cells

Naturally acquired infections with Francisella tularensis, the bacterial agent of tularemia, occur infrequently in humans. However, the high infectivity and lethality of the organism in humans raise concerns that it might be exploited as a weapon of bioterrorism. Despite this potential for illicit use, the pathogenesis of tularemia is not well understood. To examine how F. tularensis interacts with cells of its mammalian hosts, we tested the ability of a live vaccine strain (LVS) to induce proinflammatory changes in cultured HUVEC. Living F. tularensis LVS induced HUVEC to express the adhesion molecules VCAM-1 and ICAM-1, but not E-selectin, and to secrete the chemokine CXCL8, but not CCL2. Stimulation of HUVEC by the living bacteria was partially suppressed by polymyxin B, an inhibitor of LPS, but did not require serum, suggesting that F. tularensis LVS does not stimulate endothelium through the serum-dependent pathway that is typically used by LPS from enteric bacteria. In contrast to the living organisms, suspensions of killed F. tularensis LVS acquired the ability to increase endothelial expression of both E-selectin and CCL2. Up-regulation of E-selectin and CCL2 by the killed bacteria was not inhibited by polymyxin B. Exposure of HUVEC to either live or killed F. tularensis LVS for 24 h promoted the transendothelial migration of subsequently added neutrophils. These data indicate that multiple components of F. tularensis LVS induce proinflammatory changes in endothelial cells in an atypical manner that may contribute to the exceptional infectivity and virulence of this pathogen.     

Mapping of immunoreactive antigens of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain

Francisella tularensis subsp. holarctica is the common causal agent of tularemia in Europe. Besides clinical signs, the diagnosis of the disease mostly depends on serological tests. To date, there is a lack of information about the F. tularensis antigens that induce antibody response. Therefore, we have started comprehensive mapping of immunoreactive antigens using the attenuated live vaccine strain of F. tularensis LVS originating from the European virulent strain. For this purpose, the immunoreactivity of sera collected from patients suffering from tularemia, together with the control sera of patients with Lyme disease and healthy blood donors, were examined by means of one-dimensional and two-dimensional immunoblotting. Furthermore, whole cell bacterial lysates, isolated integral membrane proteins and basic proteins were exploited as antigens. By this approach more than 80 different immunorelevant antigens were detected. Most of them came from whole cell bacterial lysate and integral membrane proteins. Conversely, only a negligible reaction was found in the case of basic proteins. Forty-five spots were further selected for mass spectrometric analyses and 22 of them were annotated. Among the spots that provided characteristic reactions with sera from patients with tularemia, 60 kDa and 10 kDa chaperonins that occurred in several charge and mass variants, predominated.     

Outer membranes of a lipopolysaccharide-protein complex (LPS-17 kDa protein) as chemical tularemia vaccines

Abstract Immunisation with outer membranes of Francisella tularensis induced an efficient protection in guinea pigs against challenge with the virulent strains 503 or 144/713 (type B biovar holarctica ), both clinical isolates, and prevented the development of typical signs of infection in hamadryads (baboons), challenged with the virulent strain Schu (type A, biovar tularensis ) of F. tularensis . Immunisation with a lipopolysaccharide protein complex isolated from the outer membranes afforded protection in CBA mice against challenge with strain 503. Another LPS-protein complex obtained by the simple mixture of LPS preparations from strain 503 and a 17-kDa membrane protein from the avirulent R-variant of the vaccine strain 15 also demonstrated protective properties against experimental tularemia in mice.     

Non-FcεR bearing mast cells secrete sufficient interleukin-4 to control Francisella tularensis replication within macrophages

Mast cells have classically been implicated in the triggering of allergic and anaphylactic reactions. However, recent findings have elucidated the ability of these cells to selectively release a variety of cytokines leading to bacterial clearance through neutrophil and dendritic cell mobilization, and suggest an important role in innate host defenses. Our laboratory has established a primary bone marrow derived mast cell-macrophage co-culture system and found that mast cells mediated a significant inhibition of Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS) uptake and replication within macrophages through contact and the secreted product interleukin-4 (IL-4). In this study, we utilized P815 mast cells and J774 macrophages to further investigate whether mast cell activation by non-FcεR driven signals could produce IL-4 and control intramacrophage LVS replication. P815 supernatants collected upon activation by the mast cell activating peptide MP7, as well as P815 cells co-cultured with J774 macrophages, exhibited marked inhibition of bacterial uptake and replication, which correlated with the production of IL-4. The inhibition noted in vitro was titratable and preserved at ratios relevant to cellular infiltration events following pulmonary challenge. Collectively, our data suggest that both primary mast cell and P815 mast cell (lacking FcεR) secreted IL-4 can control intramacrophage Francisella replication.     

Tularemia vaccine: past,present and future

Francisella tularensis is a Gram negative intracellular pathogen that causes the highly debilitating or fatal disease tularemia. F. tularensis can infect a wide range of animals and can be transmitted to humans in a variety of ways, the most common being by the bite of an infected insect or arthropod vector. The attenuated F. tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS) has been used previously under investigational new drug status to vaccinate at-risk individuals. However the history of the strain and lack of knowledge regarding the basis of attenuation has so far prevented its licensing. Therefore the focus of current research is on producing a new vaccine against tularemia that would be suitable for licensing.     

A Mucosal Subunit Vaccine Protects against Lethal Respiratory Infection with Francisella tularensis LVS

Francisella tularensis (FT) is a highly virulent pathogen for humans and other mammals. Severe morbidity and mortality is associated with respiratory FT infection and there are concerns about intentional dissemination of this organism. Therefore, FT has been designated a category A biothreat agent and there is a growing interest in the development of a protective vaccine. In the present study, we determine the protective potential of a subunit vaccine comprised of the FT heat shock protein DnaK and surface lipoprotein Tul4 against respiratory infection with the live vaccine strain (LVS) of FT in mice. First, we establish an optimal intranasal immunization regimen in C57BL/6 mice using recombinant DnaK or Tul4 together with the adjuvant GPI-0100. The individual immunization regimens induced robust salivary IgA, and vaginal and bronchoalveolar IgA and IgG antigen-specific antibodies. Serum IgG1 and IgG2c antibody responses were also induced, indicative of a mixed type 2 and type 1 response, respectively. Next, we show that immunization with DnaK and Tul4 induces mucosal and systemic antibody responses that are comparable to that seen following immunization with each antigen alone. This immunization regimen also induced IFN-γ, IL-10 and IL-17A production by splenic CD4⁺ T cells in an antigen-specific manner. Importantly, over 80% of the mice immunized with DnaK and Tul4, but not with each antigen alone, were protected against a lethal respiratory challenge with FT LVS. Protection correlated with reduced bacterial burden in the lung, liver and spleen of mice. This study demonstrates the potential of DnaK and Tul4 as protective antigens and lends support to the notion of combining distinct, immunodominant antigens into an effective multivalent tularemia vaccine.     

J774 macrophage-like cell line cytokine and chemokine patterns are modulated by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Francisella tularensis</Emphasis> LVS strain infection

Mutual interactions were investigated between intracellular parasitic bacterium Francisella tularensis (F.t.; highly virulent bacterium responsible for tularemia, replicating within the host macrophages) and murine macrophage-like cell line J774. Recombinant murine lymphokine INF-γ and/or LPS derived from E. coli were determined to stimulate in vitro antimicrobial activity of macrophage-like J774 cell line against the live vaccine strain (LVS) of F.t. through their ability to produce proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines. F.t. infection up-regulated IL-12 p40 production and down-regulated TNF-α production by stimulated macrophages; on the other hand, F.t. infection did not affect the production of IL-8, IL-6, MCP-5, and RANTES by stimulated macrophages. This showed that F.t. infection modulates the cytokine synthesis by J774 macrophage cell line.     

Intranasal immunization with an archaeal lipid mucosal vaccine adjuvant and delivery formulation protects against a respiratory pathogen challenge

Archaeal lipid mucosal vaccine adjuvant and delivery (AMVAD) is a safe mucosal adjuvant that elicits long lasting and memory boostable mucosal and systemic immune responses to model antigens such as ovalbumin. In this study, we evaluated the potential of the AMVAD system for eliciting protective immunity against mucosal bacterial infections, using a mouse model of intranasal Francisella tularensis LVS (LVS) challenge. Intranasal immunization of mice with cell free extract of LVS (LVSCE) adjuvanted with the AMVAD system (LVSCE/AMVAD) induced F. tularensis-specific antibody responses in sera and bronchoalveolar lavage fluids, as well as antigen-specific splenocyte proliferation and IL-17 production. More importantly, the AMVAD vaccine partially protected the mice against a lethal intranasal challenge with LVS. Compared to LVSCE immunized and naïve mice, the LVSCE/AMVAD immunized mice showed substantial to significant reduction in pathogen burdens in the lungs and spleens, reduced serum and pulmonary levels of proinflammatory cytokines/chemokines, and longer mean time to death as well as significantly higher survival rates (p<0.05). These results suggest that the AMVAD system is a promising mucosal adjuvant and vaccine delivery technology, and should be explored further for its applications in combating mucosal infectious diseases.     

Identification of a Novel Small RNA Modulating Francisella tularensis Pathogenicity

Francisella tularensis is a highly virulent bacterium responsible for the zoonotic disease tularemia. It is a facultative intracellular pathogen that replicates in the cytoplasm of host cells, particularly in macrophages. Here we show that F. tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS) expresses a novel small RNA (sRNA), which modulates the virulence capacities of the bacterium. When this sRNA, designated FtrC (for Francisella tularensisRNA C), is expressed at high levels, F. tularensis replicates in macrophages less efficiently than the wild-type parent strain. Similarly, high expression of FtrC reduces the number of viable bacteria recovered from the spleen and liver of infected mice. Our data demonstrate that expression of gene FTL_1293 is regulated by FtrC. Furthermore, we show by in vitro gel shift assays that FtrC interacts specifically with FTL_1293 mRNA and that this happens independently of the RNA chaperone Hfq. Remarkably, FtrC interacts only with full-length FTL_1293 mRNA. These results, combined with a bioinformatic analysis, indicate that FtrC interacts with the central region of the mRNA and hence does not act by sterically hindering access of the ribosome to the mRNA. We further show that gene FTL_1293 is not required for F. tularensis virulence in vitro or in vivo, which indicates that another unidentified FtrC target modulates the virulence capacity of the bacterium.     

Alternative Activation of Macrophages and Induction of Arginase Are Not Components of Pathogenesis Mediated by Francisella Species

Virulent Francisella tularensis ssp tularensis is an intracellular, Gram negative bacterium that causes acute lethal disease following inhalation of fewer than 15 organisms. Pathogenicity of Francisella infections is tied to its unique ability to evade and suppress inflammatory responses in host cells. It has been proposed that induction of alternative activation of infected macrophages is a mechanism by which attenuated Francisella species modulate host responses. In this report we reveal that neither attenuated F. tularensis Live Vaccine Strain (LVS) nor virulent F. tularensis strain SchuS4 induce alternative activation of macrophages in vitro or in vivo. LVS, but not SchuS4, provoked production of arginase1 independent of alternative activation in vitro and in vivo. However, absence of arginase1 did not significantly impact intracellular replication of LVS or SchuS4. Together our data establish that neither induction of alternative activation nor expression of arginase1 are critical features of disease mediated by attenuated or virulent Francisella species.     

NK cells activated in vivo by bacterial DNA control the intracellular growth of Francisella tularensis LVS

We demonstrated previously that mice treated with bacterial or oligonucleotide DNA containing unmethylated CpG motifs are transiently protected against lethal parenteral challenge with the intracellular bacterium Francisella tularensis Live Vaccine Strain (LVS). Here we explore the cellular basis of this protection. Wild-type mice that were treated with CpG oligonucleotide DNA and challenged with a lethal dose of LVS survived, while mice lacking TLR9 did not. In vitro, treatment of LVS-infected macrophages and/or naive splenocytes with oligo DNA had no impact on intracellular bacterial replication. In contrast, in vitro co-culture of LVS-infected macrophages with splenocytes obtained from mice treated with oligo DNA in vivo resulted in control of intracellular LVS growth. Control was reversed by antibodies to interferon-gamma or to tumor necrosis factor-alpha and by inhibition of nitric oxide, and to a lesser degree by antibodies to Interleukin-12. Further, splenocytes from DNA-primed normal, T cell KO, B cell KO, lymphocyte-deficient scid, or perforin KO mice all controlled intra-macrophage LVS growth. Enriched DNA-primed natural killer cells, but not B cells, clearly controlled intracellular LVS growth. Thus, NK cells contribute to DNA-mediated protection by production of cytokines including IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha, resulting in nitric oxide production and control of intracellular Francisella replication.     

A ΔclpB Mutant of Francisella tularensis Subspecies holarctica Strain,FSC200, Is a More Effective Live Vaccine than F. tularensis LVS in a Mouse Respiratory Challenge Model of Tularemia

Francisella tularensis subsp. tularensis is a highly virulent pathogen for humans especially if inhaled. Consequently, it is considered to be a potential biothreat agent. An experimental vaccine, F. tularensis live vaccine strain, derived from the less virulent subsp. holarctica, was developed more than 50 years ago, but remains unlicensed. Previously, we developed a novel live vaccine strain, by deleting the chaperonin clpB gene from F. tularensis subsp. tularensis strain, SCHU S4. SCHU S4ΔclpB was less virulent for mice than LVS and a more effective vaccine against respiratory challenge with wild type SCHU S4. In the current study, we were interested to determine whether a similar mutant on the less virulent subsp. holarctica background would also outperform LVS in terms of safety and efficacy. To this end, clpB was deleted from clinical holarctica strain, FSC200. FSC200ΔclpB had a significantly higher intranasal LD₅₀ than LVS for BALB/c mice, but replicated to higher numbers at foci of infection after dermal inoculation. Moreover, FSC200ΔclpB killed SCID mice more rapidly than LVS. However, dermal vaccination of BALB/c mice with the former versus the latter induced greater protection against respiratory challenge with SCHU S4. This increased efficacy was associated with enhanced production of pulmonary IL-17 after SCHU S4 challenge.     

Francisella novicida LPS has greater immunobiological activity in mice than F. tularensis LPS,and contributes to F. novicida murine pathogenesis

To further understand the role of LPS in the pathogenesis of Francisella infection, we characterized murine infection with F. novicida, and compared immunobiological activities of F. novicida LPS and the LPS from F. tularensis live vaccine strain (LVS). F. novicida had a lower intradermal LD(50) in BALB/cByJ mice than F. tularensis LVS, and mice given a lethal F. novicida dose intraperitoneally died faster than those given the same lethal F. tularensis LVS dose. However, the pattern of in vivo dissemination was similar, and in vitro growth of both bacteria in bone marrow-derived macrophages was comparable. F. novicida LPS stimulated very modest in vitro proliferation of mouse splenocytes at high doses, but F. tularensis LVS LPS did not. Murine bone marrow macrophages treated in vitro with F. novicida LPS produced IL12 and TNF-alpha, but did not produce detectable interferon-gamma, IL10, or nitric oxide; in contrast, murine macrophages treated with F. tularensis LVS LPS produced none of these mediators. In contrast to clear differences in stimulation of proliferation and especially cytokines, both types of purified LPS stimulated early protection against lethal challenge of mice with F. tularensis LVS, but not against lethal challenge with F. novicida. Thus, although LPS recognition may not be a major factor in engendering protection, the ability of F. novicida LPS to stimulate the production of proinflammatory cytokines including TNF-alpha likely contributes to the increased virulence for mice of F. novicida compared to F. tularensis LVS.     

Preclinical Testing of a Vaccine Candidate against Tularemia

Tularemia is caused by a gram-negative, intracellular bacterial pathogen, Francisella tularensis (Ft). The history weaponization of Ft in the past has elevated concerns that it could be used as a bioweapon or an agent of bioterrorism. Since the discovery of Ft, three broad approaches adopted for tularemia vaccine development have included inactivated, live attenuated, or subunit vaccines. Shortcomings in each of these approaches have hampered the development of a suitable vaccine for prevention of tularemia. Recently, we reported an oxidant sensitive mutant of Ft LVS in putative EmrA1 (FTL_0687) secretion protein. The emrA1 mutant is highly sensitive to oxidants, attenuated for intramacrophage growth and virulence in mice. We reported that EmrA1 contributes to oxidant resistance by affecting the secretion of antioxidant enzymes SodB and KatG. This study investigated the vaccine potential of the emrA1 mutant in prevention of respiratory tularemia caused by Ft LVS and the virulent SchuS4 strain in C57BL/6 mice. We report that emrA1 mutant is safe and can be used at an intranasal (i. n.) immunization dose as high as 1x10⁶ CFU without causing any adverse effects in immunized mice. The emrA1 mutant is cleared by vaccinated mice by day 14–21 post-immunization, induces minimal histopathological lesions in lungs, liver and spleen and a strong humoral immune response. The emrA1 mutant vaccinated mice are protected against 1000–10,000LD₁₀₀ doses of i.n. Ft LVS challenge. Such a high degree of protection has not been reported earlier against respiratory challenge with Ft LVS using a single immunization dose with an attenuated mutant generated on Ft LVS background. The emrA1 mutant also provides partial protection against i.n. challenge with virulent Ft SchuS4 strain in vaccinated C57BL/6 mice. Collectively, our results further support the notion that antioxidants of Ft may serve as potential targets for development of effective vaccines for prevention of tularemia.