GDNF and neurturin are target-derived factors essential for cranial parasympathetic neuron development

During development, parasympathetic ciliary ganglion neurons arise from the neural crest and establish synaptic contacts on smooth and striate muscle in the eye. The factors that promote the ciliary ganglion pioneer axons to grow toward their targets have yet to be determined. Here, we show that glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and neurturin (NRTN) constitute target-derived factors for developing ciliary ganglion neurons. Both GDNF and NRTN are secreted from eye muscle located in the target and trajectory pathway of ciliary ganglion pioneer axons during the period of target innervation. After this period, however, the synthesis of GDNF declines markedly, while that of NRTN is maintained throughout the cell death period. Furthermore, both in vitro and in vivo function-blocking of GDNF at early embryonic ages almost entirely suppresses ciliary axon outgrowth. These results demonstrate that target-derived GDNF is necessary for ciliary ganglion neurons to innervate ciliary muscle in the eye. Since the down-regulation of GDNF in the eye is accompanied by down-regulation of GFRalpha1 and Ret, but not of GFRalpha2, in innervating ciliary ganglion neurons, the results also suggest that target-derived GDNF regulates the expression of its high-affinity coreceptors.     

Overexpression of ciliary neurotrophic factor in vivo rescues chick ciliary ganglion neurons from cell death

Ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons undergo target-dependent cell death during embryonic development. Although ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) was identified in vitro by its ability to support the survival of chick CG neurons, its function as a target-derived neurotrophic factor has been questioned by those working on mammalian-derived forms of CNTF. We have purified and cloned a chicken CNTF [chCNTF; formerly growth-promoting activity (GPA)] that is expressed in CG targets during the period of cell death and is secreted by cells transfected with chCNTF. In the present study we used a retroviral vector, RCASBP(A), to overexpress chCNTF in CG target tissues. Elevation of chCNTF biological activity three- to fourfold in the embryonic eye rescued an average of 31% of the neurons that would have normally died in vivo. In some individuals, nearly all of the neurons were rescued. ChCNTF had no effect on the number of neurons observed prior to cell death, nor were there any deleterious effects of either viral infection or overexpression of CNTF. These results show that chCNTF is able to function in vivo as a trophic factor for CG neurons, and suggest that limited availability of trophic support is one of the factors regulating CG neuron survival during development. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 34: 283–293, 1998     

Evidence for Multiple, Local Functions of Ciliary Neurotrophic Factor (CNTF) in Retinal Development: Expression of CNTF and Its Receptor and In Vitro Effects on Target Cells

Abstract: There is increasing, although largely indirect, evidence that neurotrophic factors not only function as target-derived survival factors for projection neurons, but also act locally to regulate developmental processes. We studied the expression of ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) and the CNTF-specific ligand-binding α-subunit of the CNTF receptor complex (CNTFRα) in the rat retina, a well-defined CNS model system, and CNTF effects on cultured retinal neurons. Both CNTF and CNTFRα (mRNA and protein) are expressed during phases of retinal neurogenesis and differentiation. Retina-specific Müller glia are immunocytochemically identified as the site of CNTF production and CNTFRα-expressing, distinct neuronal cell types as potential CNTF targets. Biological effects on corresponding neurons in culture further support the conclusion that locally supplied CNTF plays a regulatory role in the development of various retinal cell types including ganglion cells and interneurons.     

Regulation of neuronal K(+) currents by target-derived factors: opposing actions of two different isoforms of TGFbeta.

The developmental expression of macroscopic Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in chick ciliary ganglion neurons is dependent on an avian ortholog of TGFbeta1, known as TGFbeta4, secreted from target tissues in the eye. Here we report that a different isoform, TGFbeta3, is also expressed in a target tissue of ciliary ganglion neurons. Application of TGFbeta3 inhibits the functional expression of whole-cell Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents evoked by 12 hour treatment with either TGFbeta1 or beta-neuregulin-1 in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vitro. TGFbeta3 had no effect on voltage-activated Ca(2+) currents. A neutralizing antiserum specific for TGFbeta3 potentiates stimulation of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents evoked by a target tissue (iris) extract in cultured ciliary ganglion neurons, indicating that TGFbeta3 is an inhibitory component of these extracts. Intraocular injection of TGFbeta3 causes a modest but significant inhibition of the expression of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo. Further, intraocular injection of a TGFbeta3-neutralizing antiserum stimulates expression of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo, indicating that endogenous TGFbeta3 regulates the functional expression of this current. The normal developmental expression of functional Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo is therefore regulated by two different target-derived isoforms of TGFbeta, which produce opposing effects on the electrophysiological differentiation of these neurons.     

Effects of preganglionic denervation and postganglionic axotomy on acetylcholine receptors in the chick ciliary ganglion

The regulation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) in chick ciliary ganglia was examined by using a radiolabeled anti-AChR mAb to quantitate the amount of receptor in ganglion detergent extracts after preganglionic denervation or postganglionic axotomy. Surgical transection of the preganglionic input to the ciliary ganglion in newly hatched chicks caused a threefold reduction in the total number of AChRs within 10 d compared with that present in unoperated contralateral control ganglia. Surgical transection of both the choroid and ciliary nerves emerging from the ciliary ganglion in newly hatched chicks to establish postganglionic axotomy led to a nearly 10-fold reduction in AChRs within 5 d compared with unoperated contralateral ganglia. The declines were specific since they could not be accounted for by changes in ganglionic protein or by decreases in neuronal survival or size. Light microscopy revealed no gross morphological differences between neurons in operated and control ganglia. A second membrane component of cholinergic relevance on chick ciliary ganglion neurons is the alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha-Bgt)-binding component. The alpha-Bgt-binding component also declined in number after either postganglionic axotomy or preganglionic denervation, but appeared to do so with a more rapid time course than did ganglionic AChRs. The results imply that cell-cell interactions in vivo specifically regulate both the number of AChRs and the number of alpha-Bgt-binding components in the ganglion. Regulation of these neuronal cholinergic membrane components clearly differs from that previously described for muscle AChRs.     

Purification and characterization of a trophic factor for embryonic peripheral neurons: comparison with fibroblast growth factors

The validation of NGF as a physiologically important neurotrophic factor has led to intense efforts to identify novel polypeptide growth factors for neurons. We report here the details of a greater than 80,000-fold purification of a neurotrophic molecule, referred to as growth-promoting activity (GPA), from chicken sciatic nerves. The final product of the purification migrated as a protein band of 21.5 kd, its apparent pI was approximately 4.8, and the ED50 of the most active preparation was approximately 10 pg/ml. Amino acid sequence of a proteolytic digestion fragment of GPA revealed homology with the recently published sequences for rabbit and rat sciatic nerve CNTF. Thus this molecule may be the chicken form of CNTF. Analysis of the specificity of action of GPA showed that, in addition to E8 ciliary ganglion neurons, the factor was able to support short-term survival of E8 dorsal root ganglion and E12 sympathetic neurons. This range of specificities of biological action was also seen with both acidic and basic FGF in the presence of heparin. The biological activity of GPA differed from that of FGF in that it was not potentiated by heparin and did not stimulate mitogenesis in chick fibroblasts.     

Surface and intracellular distribution of a putative neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Chick ciliary ganglion neurons have a membrane component that shares an antigenic determinant with the main immunogenic region (MIR) of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors from skeletal muscle and electric organ. Previous studies have shown that the component has many of the properties expected for a ganglionic nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, and that its distribution on the neuron surface in vivo is restricted predominantly to synaptic membrane. Here we report the presence of a large intracellular pool of the putative receptor in embryonic neurons and demonstrate that it is associated with organelles known to comprise the biosynthetic and regulatory pathways of integral plasma membrane proteins. Embryonic chick ciliary ganglia were lightly fixed, saponin-permeabilized, incubated with an anti-MIR monoclonal antibody (mAb) followed by horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody, reacted for peroxidase activity, and examined by electron microscopy. Deposits of reaction product were associated with synaptic membrane, small portions of the pseudodendrite surface membrane, most of the rough endoplasmic reticulum, small portions of the nuclear envelope, some Golgi complexes, and a few coated pits, coated vesicles, multivesicular bodies, and smooth-membraned vacuoles. No other labeling was present in the neurons. The labeling was specific in that it was not present when the anti-MIR mAb was replaced with either nonimmune serum or mAbs of different specificity. Chick dorsal root ganglion neurons thought to lack nicotinic acetylcholine receptors were not labeled by the anti-MIR mAb. Substantial intracellular populations have also been reported for the muscle acetylcholine receptor and brain voltage-dependent sodium channel alpha-subunit. This may represent a general pattern for multisubunit membrane proteins during development.     

Electrophoretic similarity of the ciliary ganglion survival factors from different tissues and species

The survival of dissociated ciliary ganglion neurons is promoted by extracts of several different embryonic and adult tissues from two species. The survival-promoting activity in each of these extracts survives exposure to sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and sulfhydryl-reducing agent and can, therefore, be subjected to SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Upon electrophoresis, the survival-promoting activity is recovered in a discrete peak at an apparent molecular weight of approximately 21,800 for all of the tissues examined. These results suggest that a similar molecule in each of these different tissues and species may be responsible for their ability to promote the survival of ciliary ganglion nerve cells in culture.     

Cholinergic neuronotrophic factors: III. Developmental increase of trophic activity for chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons in their intraocular target tissues

Between stages 34 and 40 in the chick embryo, the ciliary ganglion (CG) undergoes a 50% loss of neurons. Such neuronal death is a common feature in neural development and it has been proposed that neurons are dependent for survival on trophic support from their target tissues. Using an in vitro bioassay it was previously shown in this laboratory that trophic activity for CG neurons is highly concentrated in eye structures containing CG target tissues. In the present study we have found that trophic activity in the eye increases markedly between stages 37 and 39, the time when neuronal death in the ciliary ganglion is ending. Thus, a developmental increase in trophic activity within the eye may be involved in determining neuronal survival in the CG. Furthermore, this study provides the first indication that the trophic content of target tissue is itself developmentally regulated.     

Ciliary ganglion neurons in cell culture: high affinity choline uptake and autoradiographic choline labeling

Chick ciliary ganglion neurons grown in dissociated cell culture have a high affinity uptake mechanism for choline that has the properties expected for cholinergic neurons. The uptake has an apparent K_m of ca. 0.3 μM and is blocked by addition of 10 μM hemicholinium-3 or replacement of Na⁺ by Li⁺ in the uptake medium. When the choline uptake mechanism is used to label ciliary ganglion neuron-myotube cultures autoradiographically, over 99% of the neurons are labeled. A few cells with neuronal morphologies in such cultures (<1%) are labeled by γ-[³H]aminobutyric acid uptake. The number of [³H]choline-labeled neurons and the amount of Na⁺-dependent choline uptake is the same for ciliary ganglion neurons grown with and without skeletal myotubes. Rat superior cervical ganglion neurons, grown in cell culture under conditions that induce them to synthesize acetylcholine and form cholinergic synapses, are labeled by [³H]choline uptake, though not as heavily as ciliary ganglion neurons. In contrast, chick dorsal root ganglion neurons, a presumed population of noncholinergic neurons, are not labeled by [³H]choline uptake. Thus high affinity choline uptake can be used to label autoradiographically the cholinergic neurons tested, while at least one population of noncholinergic neurons remains unlabeled.     

Formation of calyx-like contacts preferentially on appropriate target neurons in culture

The availability of culture systems for both Edinger Westphal and ciliary ganglion neurons has made it possible to examine the interactions in culture between two populations of vertebrate neurons that synapse in vivo. In the chick, Edinger Westphal neurons provide the sole presynaptic input to the ciliary ganglion and, through this projection, are responsible for the control of lens curvature (accommodation), iris constriction, and possibly smooth muscle function in the choroid layer of the eye. When embryonic chick Edinger Westphal and ciliary ganglion neurons were combined in culture and stained for enkephalin-like immunoreactivity to visualize Edinger Westphal terminals, stained calyx-like contacts were observed that resemble the calyciform terminals formed between Edinger Westphal processes and ciliary neurons in the ciliary ganglion in vivo. Although stained calyx-like contacts could also be found in Edinger Westphal-alone and ciliary ganglion-alone cultures, many more were observed when the two cell types were cultured together. The increase depended specifically on the ciliary ganglion neurons since substitution of either dorsal root ganglion or sympathetic ganglion neurons for them in the cocultures did not increase the number of calyx-like contacts staining positive for enkephalin over those present in cultures of Edinger Westphal neurons alone. When Edinger Westphal neurons were grown simultaneously with dorsal root and ciliary ganglion neurons, calyx-like contacts with enkephalin-like immunoreactivity were found to terminate preferentially on the latter. These findings suggest that vertebrate neurons can form morphologically specific contacts preferentially on appropriate target cells in culture in the absence of many of the potential cues present in the intact tissue.     

Neuronal differentiation from postmitotic precursors in the ciliary ganglion

In the chick ciliary ganglion, neuronal number is kept constant between St. 29 and St. 34 (E6-E8) despite a large amount of cell death. Here, we characterize the source of neurogenic cells in the ganglion as undifferentiated neural crest-derived cells. At St. 29, neurons and nonneuronal cells in the ciliary ganglion expressed the neural crest markers HNK-1 and p75(NTR). Over 50% of the cells were neurons at St. 29; of the nonneuronal cells, a small population expressed glial markers, whereas the majority was undifferentiated. When placed in culture, nonneuronal cells acquired immunoreactivity for HuD, suggesting that they had commenced neuronal differentiation. The newly differentiated neurons arose from precursors that did not incorporate bromodeoxyuridine. To test whether these precursors could undergo neural differentiation in vivo, purified nonneuronal cells from St. 29 quail ganglia were transplanted into chick embryos at St. 9-14. Subsequently, quail cells expressing neuronal markers were found in the chick ciliary ganglion. The existence of this precursor pool was transient because nonneuronal cells isolated from St. 38 ganglia failed to form neurons. Since all ciliary ganglion neurons are born prior to St. 29, these results demonstrate that there are postmitotic neural crest-derived precursors in the developing ciliary ganglion that can differentiate into neurons in the appropriate environment.     

A ciliary neuronotrophic factor from peripheral nerve and smooth muscle which is not retrogradely transported

We have found that a CNTF-like molecule which supports ciliary and sympathetic neurons is not retrogradely transported in either sympathetic or parasympathetic nerves. The factor has an apparent M_r of 21 kDa, a pI of 4.9, and is present in peripheral nerves and smooth muscle of the chick. Our experiments indicate that CNTF-like activity does not accumulate on the distal side of ligated chickexpansor nerves. In contrast, there is a clear accumulation of NGF. The activity further differs from NGF in that it is not removed from a smooth muscle of the chick wing by innervating sympathetic fibers. Transection of these fibers does not lead to an accumulation of ciliary activity in theexpansor secundariorum muscle, suggesting that neurons do not actively deplete the muscle of factor by retrograde transport. Finally, recombinant CNTF or semi-purified preparations of CNTF-like activity labelled with¹²⁵I were not transported to the ciliary ganglion of chicks following injection of biologically active material into the eye. Our results suggest either that endogenous CNTF does not act as a survival factorin vivo, or that retrograde transport is not a property inherent to all neuronotrophic molecules.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Lawrence Austin     

An 82-Kilodalton Membrane Protein that Inhibits the Activity of Neurite Outgrowth Factor

Neurite outgrowth factor (NOF), an extracellular matrix glycoprotein of 700 kilodaltons (kDa), promoted neurite outgrowth from cultured ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons of chicken embryo. A fraction solubilized with Nonidet P-40 of chicken gizzard muscle membranes inhibited the neurite-promoting activity of NOF in a dose-dependent manner, but not that of laminin. Binding of CG neurons to the substratum and their survival were not affected by the extract. The inhibitory activity of the extract was abolished by treatment with trypsin or heat. The molecular size was determined to be about 82 kDa by ligand blotting. The active component was partially purified by column chromatography. It is suggested that this molecule interacts with the domain of NOF responsible for its neurite-promoting activity and may modulate NOF activity during development in vivo.     

Nerve growth-promoting activity in the chick embryo: quantitative aspects

Nerve growth-promoting activity in organ extracts from the chick embryo was titrated using ganglia explanted to a collagen gel. Fibre outgrowth responses evoked in ciliary, sympathetic and spinal ganglia were well correlated. At embryonic day 8, 66% of the activity was localized in the yolk sac, 19% to the chorioallantois and the remaining 15% was widespread in the embryo. At day 18, total activity had increased 27-fold, the carcass now accounting for 90%. In parallel, the embryo extracts also promoted survival and neurite extension in dissociated ganglionic neurons seeded at low density in the gel. It is suggested that the observed effects are due to one active substance widely distributed in the embryo and increasing in amount during development. The substance has a molecular weight of over 10,000 and is distinct from nerve growth factor (NGF). A function of it may be to regulate axonal growth and survival of autonomic and sensory neurons.     

Differential effects of ret and TRKB on axonal branching and survival of parasympathetic neurons

Interactions between neurons and their targets of innervation influence many aspects of neural development. To examine how synaptic activity interacts with neurotrophic signaling, we determined the effects of blocking neuromuscular transmission on survival and axonal outgrowth of ciliary neurons from the embryonic chicken ciliary ganglion. Ciliary neurons undergo a period of cell loss due to programmed cell death between embryonic Days (E) 8 and 14 and they innervate the striated muscle of the iris. The nicotinic antagonist d‐tubocurarine (dTC) induces an increase in branching measured by counting neurofilament‐positive voxels (NF‐VU) in the iris between E14‐17 while reducing ciliary neuron survival. Blocking ganglionic transmission with dihyro‐β‐erythroidin and α‐methyllycacontine does not mimic dTC. At E8, many trophic factors stimulate neurite outgrowth and branching of neurons placed in cell culture; however, at E13, only GDNF stimulates branching selectively in cultured ciliary neurons. The GDNF‐induced branching at E13 could be inhibited by BDNF. Blocking ret signaling in vivo with a dominant negative (dn)ret decreases survival of ciliary and choroid neurons at E14 and prevents dTC induced increases in NF‐VU in the iris at E17. Blocking TRKB signaling with dn TRKB increases NF‐VU in the iris at E17 and decreases neuronal survival at E17, but not at E14. Thus, RET promotes survival during programmed cell death in the ciliary ganglion and contributes to promoting branching when synaptic transmission is blocked while TRKB inhibits branching and promotes maintenance of neuronal survival. These studies highlight the multifunctional nature of trophic molecule function during neuronal development. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Develop Neurobiol, 2013     

3H]acetylcholine synthesis in cultured ciliary ganglion neurons: effects of myotube membranes

Avian ciliary ganglion neurons in cell culture were examined for the capacity to synthesize acetylcholine (ACh) from the exogenously supplied precursor, choline. Relevant kinetic parameters of the ACh synthetic system in cultured neurons were found to be virtually the same as those of the ganglionic terminals in the intact iris. Neurons were cultured in the presence of and allowed to innervate pectoral muscle; this results in an capacity for ACh synthesis. In particular, the ability to increase ACh synthesis upon demand after stimulation is affected by interaction with the target. This effect is shown to be an acceleration of the maturation of the cultured neurons. Lysed and washed membrane remnants of the muscle target were able to duplicate, in part, this effect of live target tissue on neuronal transmitter metabolism. Culture medium conditioned by muscle, and by the membrane remnants of muscle, was without significant effect. Thus, substances secreted into the medium do not play a major role in this interaction. Neurons cultured with either muscle or muscle membrane remnants formed large, elongate structures on the target membrane surface. These were not seen in the absence of the target at the times examined. This morphological difference in terminal-like structures may parallel the developmental increases in size and vesicular content of ciliary ganglion nerve terminals in the chick iris, and may relate to the increased ACh synthetic activity. The results suggest that direct contact with an appropriate target membrane has a profound, retrograde influence upon neuronal metabolic and morphological maturation.     

Cholinergic enzymes in the ciliary ganglia of the chicken and pigeon

In the present paper we have comparatively analyzed acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and cholinacetyltransferase (ChAT) activity in chick and pigeon ciliary ganglion. AChE specific activity in the pigeon ciliary ganglion is remarkably higher than the one occurring in the chick; conversely the ChAT specific activity is similar in the chick as well as in the pigeon. Higher AChE activity found in the pigeon ciliary ganglion can be partially attributed to a selective accumulation of the enzyme in already described membrane-limited formations typical of the choroid neurons. After post-ganglionic axotomy such formations undergo a progressive disappearance which parallels the decrease of AChE activity. The present data suggest the hypothesis that the structures under investigation as well as ganglionic AChE are possibly controlled through a retrograde mechanism by their target organ.