Applications of neutron and X-ray scattering to the study of biologically relevant model membranes

Scattering techniques, in particular electron, neutron and X-ray scattering have played a major role in elucidating the static and dynamic structure of biologically relevant membranes. Importantly, neutron and X-ray scattering have evolved to address new sample preparations that better mimic biological membranes. In this review, we will report on some of the latest model membrane results, and the neutron and X-ray techniques that were used to obtain them.     

ESR study of the interaction of cytotoxin II with model membranes

Cytotoxin II from the venom of the Central-Asian cobra Naja oxiana spin-labeled at Lys35 (SLCT II) was studied by ESR spectroscopy in aqueous solution and upon interaction with phospholipid vesicles from egg phosphatidylcholine or its mixture with dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol (molar ratio 9:1). The distribution of SLCT II between the aqueous and lipid phases depended on the toxin and lipid concentrations and on the solution ionic strength. It was analyzed using the modified Gouy-Chapman equation that takes into account different charges of the cytotoxin in solution and in membrane. The analysis revealed two states of the cytotoxin-lipid complex. The first state corresponds to monomeric SLCT II hydrophobically interacting with the lipid membrane [a binding constant of (8 +/- 3) x 10(3) M-1] and carrying the charge of 4.4 +/- 0.3. On the basis of these parameters and the spatial structure of cytotoxin II in dodecylphosphocholine micelles, we concluded that the cytotoxin is mainly incorporated into the region of polar groups of the lipid bilayer. The second state of SLCT II is realized at high cytotoxin concentrations in the membrane and corresponds to the formation of toxin-lipid complexes that destruct the membrane bilayer structure.     

Morphology of fast-tumbling bicelles: a small angle neutron scattering and NMR study

Bilayered micelles, or bicelles, which consist of a mixture of long- and short-chain phospholipids, are a popular model membrane system. Depending on composition, concentration, and temperature, bicelle mixtures may adopt an isotropic phase or form an aligned phase in magnetic fields. Well-resolved (1)H NMR spectra are observed in the isotropic or so-called fast-tumbling bicelle phase, over the range of temperatures investigated (10-40 degrees C), for molar ratios of long-chain lipid to short-chain lipid between 0.20 and 1.0. Small angle neutron scattering data of this phase are consistent with the model in which bicelles were proposed to be disk-shaped. The experimentally determined dimensions are roughly consistent with the predictions of R.R. Vold and R.S. Prosser (J. Magn. Reson. B 113 (1996)). Differential paramagnetic shifts of head group resonances of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC), induced by the addition of Eu(3+), are also consistent with the bicelle model in which DHPC is believed to be primarily sequestered to bicelle rims. Selective irradiation of the DHPC aliphatic methyl resonances results in no detectable magnetization transfer to the corresponding DMPC methyl resonances (and vice versa) in bicelles, which also suggests that DHPC and DMPC are largely sequestered in the bicelle. Finally, (1)H spectra of the antibacterial peptide indolicidin (ILPWKWPWWPWRR-NH(2)) are compared, in a DPC micellar phase and the above fast-tumbling bicellar phases for a variety of compositions. The spectra exhibit adequate resolution and improved dispersion of amide and aromatic resonances in certain bicelle mixtures.     

Phycocyanin aggregation. A small angle neutron scattering and size exclusion chromatographic study

The influence of environmental factors on the aggregation properties of phycocyanin from Synechocystis 6701 was studied by small angle neutron scattering and high-pressure size-exclusion liquid chromatography. Phycocyanin was found to exist in a reversible equilibrium between the monomer, trimer and hexamer forms. The distribution of the protein between these oligomers is determined by the pH, buffer composition and ionic strength of the medium, and protein concentration. Phycocyanin was in a stable hexameric state at pH 5.0 to 6.0 at a concentration of 1 to 10 mg/ml, and was primarily in a trimeric state at pH 8.0 at a concentration of about 5 mg/ml. Comparison of the small angle scattering data with the computed scattering curve for a hollow cylinder was used to determine the dimensions of the best-fit model by a least-squares fitting procedure. The outer radius, inner radius and height of the phycocyanin hexamer were found to be 54.1, 12.0 and 61.4 A (1 A = 0.1 nm), respectively, and the corresponding dimensions for the trimer were 54.5, 14.0 and 33.0 A. The molecular weight ratio for phycocyanin hexamer was determined to be 217,000. The dimensions and molecular weight ratios of phycocyanin from Synechocystis 6701 obtained by solution scattering are similar to the values for Mastigocladus laminosus obtained by X-ray crystallography.     

Complexes of RecA protein in solution. A study by small angle neutron scattering

RecA complexes on DNA and self-polymers were analysed by small-angle neutron scattering in solution. By Guinier analysis at small angles and by model analysis of a subsidiary peak at wider angles, we find that the filaments fall into two groups: the DNA complex in the presence of ATP gamma S, an open helix with pitch 95 A, a cross-sectional radius of gyration of 33 A and a mass per length of about six RecA units per turn, which corresponds to the state of active enzyme; and the compact form (bound to single-stranded DNA in the absence of ATP, or binding ATP gamma S in the absence of DNA, or just the protein on its own), a helical structure with pitch 70 A, cross-sectional radius of gyration 40 A and mass per length about five RecA units per turn, which corresponds to the conditions of inactive enzyme. The results are discussed in the perspective of unifying previous conflicting structural results obtained by electron microscopy.     

Use of small-angle neutron scattering to study tubulin polymers

Small-angle neutron scattering has been used to examine taxol-stabilized microtubules and other tubulin samples in both H(2)O and D(2)O buffers. Measurements were made at pH/pD values between 6.0 and 7.8, and observed scattered intensities, I(Q), have been interpreted in terms of multicomponent models of microtubules and related tubulin polymers. A semiquantitative curve fitting procedure has been used to estimate the relative amounts of the supramolecular components of the samples. At both pH and pD 7.0 and above, the tubulin polymers are seen to be predominantly microtubules. Although in H(2)O buffer the polymer distribution is little changed as the pH varies, when pD is lowered the samples appear to contain an appreciable amount of sheetlike structures and the average microtubule protofilament number increases from ca. 12.5 at pD > or = approximately 7.0 to ca. 14 at pD approximately 6.0. Such structural change indicates that analysis of microtubule solutions based on H(2)O/D(2)O contrast variation must be performed with caution, especially at lower pH/pD.     

The solution structure of recA filaments by small angle neutron scattering

The technique of small angle neutron scattering has been applied to study the structure in solution of recA self-polymers and various recA-DNA complexes. These results are compared with those recently obtained by other physical techniques.     

Formation of actin dimers as studied by small angle neutron scattering

Small angle neutron scattering has been used to study the dimensions of G-actin and the formation of low molecular weight actin oligomers under conditions where rapid polymerization does not take place. In the presence of 200 microM Ca2+, actin in solution consists of a single component with a radius of gyration (Rg) of 19.9 +/- 0.4 A, consistent with the known molecular dimensions of the G-actin molecule. In the presence of 50 microM Mg2+, however, formation of an actin species with a larger Rg occurs over a 4-h period. Multicomponent fits were tried and the data were best fit assuming two components, the monomer and a species with an Rg of 29 +/- 1 A. This latter value is consistent with the dimensions expected for certain actin dimers. The apparent dissociation constant for dimer formation is approximately 150 microM with forward and reverse rate constants of 6.0 X 10(-7) microM-1 s-1 and 8.8 X 10(-5) s-1, respectively. Kinetic fluorescence experiments show that the dimer formed in the presence of low levels of Mg2+ is a nonproductive complex which does not participate in the polymerization process. However, the addition of cytochalasin D to actin in the presence of 50 microM Mg2+ rapidly induces the formation of dimers, presumably related to cytochalasin's ability to nucleate actin polymerization.     

Physical characteristics of human transferrin from small angle neutron scattering.

The technique of small angle neutron scattering has been used to determine the molecular shape, the volume, and the molecular weight of pooled human transferrin in an aqueous solution isotonic with blood. Analysis of the measurements assuming a spheroidal molecular shape indicates that an oblate spheroid with semi-axes of length 46.6 +/- 1.4, 46.6 +/- 1.4 and 15.8 +/- 3.8 A, and a molecular volume of (144 +/- 45) X 10(3) A3 is the best simple approximation to the shape of the transferrin molecule. The radius of gyration, Rg, determined from a Guinier plot is 30.25 +/- 0.49 A, in agreement with Rg calculated for the oblate spheroidal shape. The molecular weight is determined to be (75 +/- 5) X 10(3). The shape-independent molecular volume is found to be (98 +/- 10) X 10(3) A3. The difference in the two volumes suggests that transferrin is not a uniform spheroid but may have a more complex shape.     

Complementing structural information of modular proteins with small angle neutron scattering and contrast variation

Many macromolecules in the cell function by forming multi-component assemblies. We have applied the technique of small angle neutron scattering to study a nucleic acid-protein complex and a multi-protein complex. The results illustrate the versatility and applicability of the method to study macromolecular assemblies. The neutron scattering experiments, complementing X-ray solution scattering data, reveal that the conserved catalytic domain of RNase E, an essential ribonuclease in Escherichia coli (E. coli), undergoes a marked conformational change upon binding a 5'monophosphate-RNA substrate analogue. This provides the first evidence in support of an allosteric mechanism that brings about RNA substrate cleavage. Neutron contrast variation of the multi-protein TIM10 complex, a mitochondrial chaperone assembly comprising the subunits Tim9 and Tim10, has been used to determine a low-resolution shape reconstruction of the complex, highlighting the integral subunit organization. It shows characteristic features involving protrusions that could be assigned to the six subunits forming the complex.     

Domain interaction in rabbit muscle pyruvate kinase. II. Small angle neutron scattering and computer simulation

The effects of ligands on the structure of rabbit muscle pyruvate kinase were studied by small angle neutron scattering. The radius of gyration, RG, decreases by about 1 A in the presence of the substrate phosphoenolpyruvate, but increases by about the same magnitude in the presence of the allosteric inhibitor phenylalanine. With increasing pH or in the absence of Mg2+ and K+, the RG of pyruvate kinase increases. Hence, there is a 2-A difference in RG between two alternative conformations. Length distribution analysis indicates that, under all experimental conditions which increase the radius of gyration, there is a pronounced increase observed in the probability for interatomic distance between 80 and 110 A. These small angle neutron scattering results indicate a "contraction" and "expansion" of the enzyme when it transforms between its active and inactive forms. Using the alpha-carbon coordinates of crystalline cat muscle pyruvate kinase, a length distribution profile was calculated, and it matches the scattering profile of the inactive form. These observations are expected since the crystals were grown in the absence of divalent cations (Stuart, D. I., Levine, M., Muirhead, H., and Stammers, D. K. (1979) J. Mol. Biol. 134, 109-142). Hence, results from neutron scattering, x-ray crystallographic, and sedimentation studies (Oberfelder, R. W., Lee, L. L.-Y., and Lee, J.C. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 3813-3821) are totally consistent with each other. With the aid of computer modeling, the crystal structure has been manipulated in order to effect changes that are consistent with the conformational change described by the solution scattering data. The structural manipulation involves the rotation of the B domain relative to the A domain, leading to the closure of the cleft between these domains. These manipulations resulted in the generation of new sets of atomic (C-alpha) coordinates, which were utilized in calculations, the result of which compared favorably with the solution data.     

Solution structure of human von Willebrand factor studied using small angle neutron scattering

von Willebrand factor (VWF) binding to platelets under high fluid shear is an important step regulating atherothrombosis. We applied light and small angle neutron scattering to study the solution structure of human VWF multimers and protomer. Results suggest that these proteins resemble prolate ellipsoids with radius of gyration (R(g)) of approximately 75 and approximately 30 nm for multimer and protomer, respectively. The ellipsoid dimensions/radii are 175 x 28 nm for multimers and 70 x 9.1 nm for protomers. Substructural repeat domains are evident within multimeric VWF that are indicative of elements of the protomer quarternary structure (16 nm) and individual functional domains (4.5 nm). Amino acids occupy only approximately 2% of the multimer and protomer volume, compared with 98% for serum albumin and 35% for fibrinogen. VWF treatment with guanidine.HCl, which increases VWF susceptibility to proteolysis by ADAMTS-13, causes local structural changes at length scales <10 nm without altering protein R(g). Treatment of multimer but not protomer VWF with random homobifunctional linker BS(3) prior to reduction of intermonomer disulfide linkages and Western blotting reveals a pattern of dimer and trimer units that indicate the presence of stable intermonomer non-covalent interactions within the multimer. Overall, multimeric VWF appears to be a loosely packed ellipsoidal protein with non-covalent interactions between different monomer units stabilizing its solution structure. Local, and not large scale, changes in multimer conformation are sufficient for ADAMTS-13-mediated proteolysis.     

Modular structure of solubilized human apolipoprotein B-100. Low resolution model revealed by small angle neutron scattering

Being intimately involved in cholesterol transport and lipid metabolism human low density lipoprotein (LDL) plays a prominent role in atherogenesis and cardiovascular diseases. The receptor-mediated cellular uptake of LDL is triggered by apolipoprotein B-100 (apoB-100), which represents the single protein moiety of LDL. Due to the size and hydrophobic nature of apoB-100, its structure is not well characterized. Here we present a low resolution structure of solubilized apoB-100. We have used small angle neutron scattering in combination with advanced shape reconstruction algorithms to generate a three-dimensional model of lipid-free apoB-100. Our model clearly reveals that apoB-100 is composed of distinct domains connected by flexible regions. The apoB-100 molecule adopts a curved shape with a central cavity. In comparison to LDL-associated apoB-100, the lipid-free protein is expanded, whereas according to spectroscopic data the secondary structure is widely preserved. Finally, the low resolution model was used as a template to reconstruct a hypothetical domain organization of apoB-100 on LDL, including information derived from a secondary structure prediction.     

Structure-specific DNA-induced conformational changes in Taq polymerase revealed by small angle neutron scattering

The DNA polymerase I from Thermus aquaticus (Taq polymerase) performs lagging-strand DNA synthesis and DNA repair. Taq polymerase contains a polymerase domain for synthesizing a new DNA strand and a 5'-nuclease domain for cleaving RNA primers or damaged DNA strands. The extended crystal structure of Taq polymerase poses a puzzle on how this enzyme coordinates its polymerase and the nuclease activities to generate only a nick. Using contrast variation solution small angle neutron scattering, we have examined the conformational changes that occur in Taq polymerase upon binding "overlap flap" DNA, a structure-specific DNA substrate that mimics the substrate in strand replacement reactions. In solution, apoTaq polymerase has an overall expanded equilibrium conformation similar to that in the crystal structure. Upon binding to the DNA substrate, both the polymerase and the nuclease domains adopt more compact overall conformations, but these changes are not enough to bring the two active sites close enough to generate a nick. Reconstruction of the three-dimensional molecular envelope from small angle neutron scattering data shows that in the DNA-bound form, the nuclease domain is lifted up relative to its position in the non-DNA-bound form so as to be in closer contact with the thumb and palm subdomains of the polymerase domain. The results suggest that a form of structure sensing is responsible for the coordination of the polymerase and nuclease activities in nick generation. However, interactions between the polymerase and the nuclease domains can assist in the transfer of the DNA substrate from one active site to the other.     

Differential interaction of equinatoxin II with model membranes in response to lipid composition

Equinatoxin II is a 179-amino-acid pore-forming protein isolated from the venom of the sea anemone Actinia equina. Large unilamellar vesicles and lipid monolayers of different lipid compositions have been used to study its interaction with membranes. The critical pressure for insertion is the same in monolayers made of phosphatidylcholine or sphingomyelin (approximately 26 mN m(-1)) and explains why the permeabilization of large unilamellar vesicles by equinatoxin II with these lipid compositions is null or moderate. In phosphatidylcholine-sphingomyelin (1:1) monolayers, the critical pressure is higher (approximately 33 mN m(-1)), thus permitting the insertion of equinatoxin II in large unilamellar vesicles, a process that is accompanied by major conformational changes. In the presence of vesicles made of phosphatidylcholine, a fraction of the protein molecules remains associated with the membranes. This interaction is fully reversible, does not involve major conformational changes, and is governed by the high affinity for membrane interfaces of the protein region comprising amino acids 101-120. We conclude that although the presence of sphingomyelin within the membrane creates conditions for irreversible insertion and pore formation, this lipid is not essential for the initial partitioning event, and its role as a specific receptor for the toxin is not so clear-cut.     

Structural organization of guanosine derivatives in dilute solutions: small angle neutron scattering analysis

Guanosine derivatives, dissolved in water, can form cholesteric and hexagonal mesophases. The common structural unit is a chiral rod-shaped aggregate consisting of a stack of Hoogsten-bonded guanosine tetrameric disks. In order to elucidate the self-association process, we decided to investigate, by small-angle neutron scattering, the structural properties of d(pG), d(GpG), d(GpGpG), d(GpGpGpG) and d(GpGpGpGpGpG) derivatives in very dilute solutions. Under our experimental conditions only d(pG) seems not to form detectable particles. On the other hand, the results for the other derivatives indicate that cylindrical aggregates, having a 10 cross-section gyration radius and a length of about 70 Å, exist in the isotropic phase. According to the structure of the hexagonal and cholesteric phases, we fitted the experimental data by using a model of rod-shaped aggregates formed by stacking about 18 to 20 guanosine tetramers. Moreover, from the measurement of the concentration of scattering particles, we deduced that guanosine derivatives are only partially aggregated, depending on their ability to form mesophases. Correspondence to: P. Mariani