Conjugational junctions: morphology of specific contacts in conjugating Escherichia coli bacteria.

F-plasmid-mediated bacterial conjugation was studied with hfr (traDts) and tra I mutant Escherichia coli donor strains. This allowed us to observe a statistically significant number of conjugation-specific contacts by video and electron microscopy. Single mating events between E. coli were observed in real time by video-enhanced light microscopy. Conjugation in vivo takes place by initial contact formation via pili, followed by direct and transient wall-to-wall contact, during which DNA is transferred and disaggregated. Electron microscopic observations of the contact zone between donor and recipient bacteria were made by thin sectioning of mating pairs that were arranged in monolayers. We defined the conjugation-specific contact found in stabilized mating pairs as the conjugational junction. Within this junction no specific substructure such as plasma bridges by fusion could be detected during transfer of DNA.     

Analysis of the sequence and gene products of the transfer region of the F sex factor.

Bacterial conjugation results in the transfer of DNA of either plasmid or chromosomal origin between microorganisms. Transfer begins at a defined point in the DNA sequence, usually called the origin of transfer (oriT). The capacity of conjugative DNA transfer is a property of self-transmissible plasmids and conjugative transposons, which will mobilize other plasmids and DNA sequences that include a compatible oriT locus. This review will concentrate on the genes required for bacterial conjugation that are encoded within the transfer region (or regions) of conjugative plasmids. One of the best-defined conjugation systems is that of the F plasmid, which has been the paradigm for conjugation systems since it was discovered nearly 50 years ago. The F transfer region (over 33 kb) contains about 40 genes, arranged contiguously. These are involved in the synthesis of pili, extracellular filaments which establish contact between donor and recipient cells; mating-pair stabilization; prevention of mating between similar donor cells in a process termed surface exclusions; DNA nicking and transfer during conjugation; and the regulation of expression of these functions. This review is a compendium of the products and other features found in the F transfer region as well as a discussion of their role in conjugation. While the genetics of F transfer have been described extensively, the mechanism of conjugation has proved elusive, in large part because of the low levels of expression of the pilus and the numerous envelope components essential for F plasmid transfer. The advent of molecular genetic techniques has, however, resulted in considerable recent progress. This summary of the known properties of the F transfer region is provided in the hope that it will form a useful basis for future comparison with other conjugation systems.     

Escherichia coli traD(Ts) mutant temperature sensitive for assembly of RNA bacteriophage MS2.

We report here a study on the temperature-sensitive conjugational transfer-deficient mutant Escherichia coli JCFL39, carrying a traD(Ts) mutation, which is also temperature sensitive for group I RNA phages (MS2, f2, and R17). It is shown that, when the mutant was infected with MS2 at 42 degrees C, phage RNA replicated; a 27S MS2 RNA and phage proteins were synthesized. However, neither PFU nor physical MS2 particles were formed, showing that phage assembly was inhibited. In addition, the high temperature affected the membranes of the host mutant: the mutant was hypersensitive to chemicals, and the electrophoretic pattern of the membranal proteins was modified. We suggest that the pleiotropic effects of the traD mutation on MS2 assembly and DNA transfer during conjugation were a result of the changes in the membrane of the mutant.     

Early Stages of Conjugation in Escherichia coli

We initiated these studies to learn more about the initial events during bacterial conjugation and to optimize conditions for their occurrence. We found that cells in donor cultures grown anaerobically prior to mating have (i) a higher mean number of F pili per cell, (ii) longer F pili, (iii) a higher probability of forming specific pairs with F(-) cells, and (iv) a faster rate of initiation of chromosome transfer than cells grown aerobically. The growth medium for the donor culture also influences these same parameters: a rich medium is superior to a completely synthetic medium. Starvation of donor cells in buffered saline or for a required amino acid results in (i) a loss of F pili, (ii) a loss in the ability of donor-specific phages to adsorb, (iii) a loss of ability to form specific pairs with F(-) cells and to yield recombinants, and (iv) an increase in recipient ability. These changes occur as a function of starvation time, and at rates which are dependent on the conditions of prior growth and starvation of the donor culture. Either treatment provides a rapid method for the production of F(-) phenocopies from donor cultures. Resynthesis of F pili by cells within a starved donor culture commences very soon after restoration of normal growth conditions, but full restoration of donor ability, as measured by recombinant yield, occurs at a slower rate. We found, along with other investigators, that F pili are essential for specific pair formation. We also found, however, that the presence of F pili is not sufficient for display of donor ability, nor is the absence of F pili enough for cells to exhibit recipient ability. This suggests, therefore, that one or more components, in addition to F pili, are necessary for the conversion of specific pairs to effective pairs (or for chromosome mobilization, or both) and for preventing donor cells from acting as recipients. On the basis of our results, we suggest optimal conditions for achieving high mating efficiencies.     

Role of Pili in Bacterial Conjugation

We describe techniques for isolating individual pairs of mating Escherichia coli and observing them under the light microscope. Some pairs achieved close cell-to-cell contact, whereas others remained loosely connected by invisible connections which may be F pili. After 30 min of mating, the pairs were separated and allowed to grow into clones. That many exconjugants derived from "loose"-mating pairs produced recombinants suggests that F pili are involved in the transfer of genetic material. The frequency of formation of recombinants from "close"-mating pairs, however, was significantly higher than that from loose-mating pairs, indicating that a close cell-to-cell contact facilitates chromosome transfer. Death rates of exconjugants from close pairs were also higher than those from loose pairs. Hfr x F(-) matings produced higher death rates than F(+) x F(-) matings. Male cells were found capable of transferring genetic markers to two F(-) cells simultaneously. We conclude that F pili play at least three roles in mating: (i) they initiate contacts between mating pairs; (ii) they facilitate the transfer of genetic material; and (iii) they draw mating cells into a close contact which increases the fertility of the union.     

Structure and function of conjugative pili: monoclonal antibodies as probes for structural variants of F pili.

The lac-tra operon fusion plasmid pTG801 contains the known F plasmid DNA transfer (tra) genes required by Escherichia coli to elaborate functional F pili (T. Grossman and P. M. Silverman, J. Bacteriol. 171:650-656, 1989). Here, we show that these pili are actually structural variants of normal F pili and that the F plasmid must contain additional genes that affect pilus structure and function. We confirmed a previous report that two monoclonal antibodies that recognize epitopes at and near the amino terminus of F pilin do not decorate the sides of normal F pili, as determined by immunogold electron microscopy. However, both antibodies laterally decorated pTG801 pili. The epitope for one of the antibodies has been shown to include the amino-terminal acetyl group of F pilin, which must therefore also be present on pTG801 pilin. Normal antibody staining was restored to pTG801 pili when cells contained, in addition to pTG801, the compatible plasmid pRS31, which must therefore include at least one gene affecting F-pilus structure. One candidate, traD, was excluded as the sole such gene, since traD+ derivatives of a pTG801 strain still elaborated pili that could be laterally decorated with antibody. Moreover, although traD alone restored RNA bacteriophage R17 infectivity to pTG801 cells, as expected, it did not mimic pRS31 in restoring to pTG801 pili other characteristics of normal F pili. We conclude that pRS31 contains as yet uncharacterized genes required for elaboration of structurally normal F pili. Finally, we identified vesicular material, especially abundant in cultures of pTG801 transformants, that stained heavily with the anti-F-pilin monoclonal antibodies. This material may reflect the inner membrane pool of F pilin.     

Escherichia coli mutant temperature sensitive for group I RNA bacteriophages.

The temperature-sensitive conjugational transfer-deficient mutant Escherichia coli JCFL39, carrying a traD(Ts) mutation, is herein described as also being temperature sensitive for group I RNA phages (MS2, f2, and R17) but not for Q beta. Temperature shift experiments showed that the growth of group I phage MS2 in the mutant could be inhibited by a post-penetration event at high temperature. A possible role for the traD cistron of sex factor F in the intracellular development of MS2 is suggested.     

Bacterial conjugative transfer: visualization of successful mating pairs and plasmid establishment in live Escherichia coli

We used the LacO/GFP-LacI system to label and visualize the IncP beta plasmid R751 fluorescently during conjugative transfer between live donor and recipient bacteria. Comparisons of R751 in conjugative and non-conjugative conditions have allowed us to identify key localizations and movements associated with the initiation of conjugative transfer in the donor and the establishment of R751 in the recipient. A survey of successful mating pairs demonstrates that close physical contact between donor and recipient bacteria is required for DNA transfer and that regions of intimate contact can occur at any location on the donor or recipient cell membrane. The transferred DNA is positioned at the characteristic centre or quarter-cell position after conversion to a double-stranded molecule in the recipient cell. Initial duplication of plasmids often results in an asymmetric distribution of plasmid foci. Symmetric localization (either at centre or at 1/4 and 3/4 cell lengths) occurs only after a significant lag, presumably reflecting the time required to synthesize the plasmid-encoded partitioning proteins.     

Inhibition of Formation of Escherichia coli Mating Pairs by f1 and MS2 Bacteriophages as Determined with a Coulter Counter

The effect of male-specific filamentous deoxyribonucleic acid (f1) and isometric ribonucleic acid (MS2) bacteriophages on the formation of mating pairs in Escherichia coli conjugation was examined directly in the Coulter counter. When a sufficient multiplicity of infection (MOI) was used, the f1 phage immediately and completely inhibited the formation of mating pairs. On the other hand, the MS2 phage at a relatively high MOI also inhibited the formation of mating pairs significantly although not completey. The inhibitory effect of MS2 phage was dependent on the time of addition and the MOI used. At relatively low MOI (<20), the MS2 phage showed some inhibitory effect when added to a male culture prior to mixing with females, whereas no effect was observed when phages were added after mating pair formation had already commenced. At a high MOI (>400) MS2 phage disrupted the mating pairs already formed. Some preformed mating pairs were resistant to the high MOI of MS2 phages, however, and the "sensitive" (to high MOI) mating pairs seem to mature into "resistant" mating pairs as a function of time. We conclude that the tip of an F pilus is the specific attachment site for mating. The following process of mating pair formation has been formulated by deduction. (i) The sides of F pili weakly contact female cells, (ii) then the tips of F pili attach to the specific receptor sites to form initial mating pairs, and (iii) those pairs mature into mating pairs that are resistant to the high MOI of MS2 phages. The high MOI of MS2 prevents the first step, whereas f1 phages affect the second step-the binding between the tips of F pili and the receptor sites.     

Transfer of genetic information from agrobacteria to bacterial and plant cells: membrane and supramembrane structures involved in transfer

The review deals with the supramembrane and membrane structures involved in the initial contact (attachment) of an agrobacterial cell with a bacterial or plant cell during the transfer of the agrobacterial genetic information. The relationships between the donor cell attachment to the recipient cell surface and the infection and conjugation processes are discussed. Experimental data on the recently found agrobacterial pili and surface protein rhicadhesin, which are involved in the conjugative transfer of the plasmid between agrobacteria, are considered. The role of adhesive and conjugative pili of E. coli in the initial and tight contacts is analyzed in the context of the recently proved similarity between the mechanisms of agrobacterial transformation in plants and conjugative transfer in bacteria. Possible involvement of the pilus in the conjugative transfer of agrobacterial DNA across the membranes of donor and recipient (bacterial and plant) cells is discussed.     

A traC mutant that retains sensitivity to f1 bacteriophage but lacks F pili.

An F lac pro mutant which was temperature sensitive for infection by the filamentous bacteriophage f1 but resistant to the F-specific icosahedral RNA phage f2 was isolated. Cells carrying the F' mutation failed to elaborate F pili at all temperatures. Mutant cells were able to pair with recipient cells during bacterial conjugation, but transfer of conjugal DNA occurred at a greatly reduced frequency. Complementation analyses showed the F' mutation to be in the traC gene. When a plasmid carrying traC was introduced into hosts harboring the F' mutation, phage sensitivity, the ability to elaborate F pili, and conjugation efficiency were restored. The mutation was named traC1044. The F lac pro traC1044 mutant appears to be unique among traC mutants in retaining host sensitivity to the filamentous phage f1 in the absence of expression of extended F pili. Phage f1 attachment sites appeared to be present at the cell surface in traC1044 mutants. The reduced accessibility of these sites may account for the reduced efficiency of phage f1 infection of traC1044 hosts, although the possibility that a defect was present in the receptor site itself was not eliminated. Membranes of hosts carrying the F' mutation contained a full complement of mature F-pilin subunits, so the product of traC is presumably required for pilus assembly but not for pilin processing. This, together with the deficiency in conjugal DNA transfer, suggests that traC may be part of a membrane-spanning tra protein complex responsible for pilus assembly and disassembly and conjugal DNA transmission.     

Functions of F pili in mating-pair formation and male bacteriophage infection studies by blending spectra and reappearance kinetics

The extent of removal at various blending speeds (blending spectrum) and the kinetics of reappearance after blending of the ability of male Escherichia coli bacteria to form mating pairs, to adsorb and be infected by ribonucleic acid male phage, and to adsorb and be infected by deoxyribonucleic male phage were identical to the blending spectrum and reappearance kinetics of microscopically visible F pili. The same results were obtained with an Hfr (high-frequency recombinant), F', or resistance transfer factor (RTF) fi(+) mating system. Blending did not affect the viability, growth rate, ability to adsorb T4 phage, or ability to produce new F pili at any of the speeds used. It can be concluded that microscopically visible F pili are an absolute requirement for all three functions. Three classes of F pili have been found in bacterial cultures: attached, adsorbed, and free. Bacteria with adsorbed F pili in addition to attached ones were proportionately more susceptible to male phage infection, suggesting that adsorbed F pili may be at least partially functional. Free F pili did not compete with bacteria for phage. Some implications of the virus-like nature of F-pilus outgrowth for the mechanisms of mating and male phage infection are discussed.     

Type IV secretion: the Agrobacterium VirB/D4 and related conjugation systems

The translocation of DNA across biological membranes is an essential process for many living organisms. In bacteria, type IV secretion systems (T4SS) are used to deliver DNA as well as protein substrates from donor to target cells. The T4SS are structurally complex machines assembled from a dozen or more membrane proteins in response to environmental signals. In Gram-negative bacteria, the conjugation machines are composed of a cell envelope-spanning secretion channel and an extracellular pilus. These dynamic structures (i) direct formation of stable contacts-the mating junction-between donor and recipient cell membranes, (ii) transmit single-stranded DNA as a nucleoprotein particle, as well as protein substrates, across donor and recipient cell membranes, and (iii) mediate disassembly of the mating junction following substrate transfer. This review summarizes recent progress in our understanding of the mechanistic details of DNA trafficking with a focus on the paradigmatic Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB/D4 T4SS and related conjugation systems.     

TraC of IncN Plasmid pKM101 Associates with Membranes and Extracellular High-Molecular-Weight Structures in Escherichia coli

Conjugative transfer of IncN plasmid pKM101 is mediated by the TraI-TraII region-encoded transfer machinery components. Similar to the case for the related Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-complex transfer apparatus, this machinery is needed for assembly of pili to initiate cell-to-cell contact preceding DNA transfer. Biochemical and cell biological experiments presented here show extracellular localization of TraC, as suggested by extracellular complementation of TraC-deficient bacteria by helper cells expressing a functional plasmid transfer machinery (S. C. Winans, and G. C. Walker, J. Bacteriol. 161:402-410, 1985). Overexpression of TraC and its export in large amounts into the periplasm of Escherichia coli allowed purification by periplasmic extraction, ammonium sulfate precipitation, and column chromatography. Whereas TraC was soluble in overexpressing strains, it partly associated with the membranes in pKM101-carrying cells, possibly due to protein-protein interactions with other components of the TraI-TraII region-encoded transfer machinery. Membrane association of TraC was reduced in strains carrying pKM101 derivatives with transposon insertions in genes coding for other essential components of the transfer machinery, traM, traB, traD, and traE but not eex, coding for an entry exclusion protein not required for DNA transfer. Cross-linking identified protein-protein interactions of TraC in E. coli carrying pKM101 but not derivatives with transposon insertions in essential tra genes. Interactions with membrane-bound Tra proteins may incorporate TraC into a surface structure, suggested by its removal from the cell by shearing as part of a high-molecular-weight complex. Heterologous expression of TraC in A. tumefaciens partly compensated for the pilus assembly defect in strains deficient for its homolog VirB5, which further supported its role in assembly of conjugative pili. In addition to its association with high-molecular-weight structures, TraC was secreted into the extracellular milieu. Conjugation experiments showed that secreted TraC does not compensate transfer deficiency of TraC-deficient cells, suggesting that extracellular complementation may rely on cell-to-cell transfer of TraC only as part of a bona fide transfer apparatus.     

H-pilus assembly kinetics determined by electron microscopy.

The kinetics of pilus outgrowth were examined for Escherichia coli containing pDT1942, a TnlacZ insertion derivative of the IncHI1 plasmid R27, which was derepressed for transfer. IncHI1 plasmids are thermosensitive for transfer. The pili specified by pDT1942 were examined by transmission electron microscopy after the pilus had been labeled with the H-pilus-specific bacteriophage Hgal, which had been inactivated with RNase A. H pili were extended by extrusion from the cell surface and not by the addition of pilin subunits to the pilus tip. After pili were removed by vortexing, the outgrowth of full-length pili (2 microns long) required 20 min. H pili expressed at the transfer optimal temperature (27 degrees C) remained stable after incubation at the transfer inhibitory temperature (37 degrees C), but the formation of mating aggregates was inhibited at 37 degrees C. Within 1 min of exposure of the host cell to a heat stimulus of 50 degrees C, pili vanished. Pili were observed in straight and flexible forms with a field emission scanning electron microscope, which may indicate a dynamic role for the pilus in conjugation.     

Regulation of transfer of the Enterococcus faecalis pheromone-responding plasmid pAD1: temperature-sensitive transfer mutants and identification of a new regulatory determinant, traD.

The enterococcal, conjugative, cytolysin plasmid pAD1 confers a mating response to the peptide sex pheromone cAD1 secreted by plasmid-free strains of Enterococcus faecalis. Cells carrying pAM714, a pAD1::Tn917 derivative with wild-type conjugation properties, were mutagenized with ethyl methanesulfonate to obtain variants that were induced (in the absence of pheromone) to transfer plasmid DNA upon shifting from 32 to 42 degrees C. Of 31 such mutants generated, the results of analyses of 7 are presented in detail. All seven strains were thermosensitive in the E. faecalis host FA2-2; colony morphology, clumping, and DNA transfer correlated well with each other at the two temperatures. In the nonisogenic host E. faecalis OG1X, however, only one derivative (pAM2725) exhibited correlation of all three traits at both temperatures. Three (pAM2700, pAM2703, and pAM2717) clumped and had colonies characteristic of pheromone-induced cells at 32 degrees C but transferred plasmid DNA at a higher frequency only at the elevated temperature. The other three (pAM2708, pAM2709, and pAM2712) were derepressed at both temperatures for all three characteristics. Four of the mutations, including that of pAM2725, mapped within the traA determinant, whereas two mapped identically in a previously unnoted open reading frame (designated traD) putatively encoding a short (23-amino-acid) peptide downstream of the inhibitor peptide determinant iad and in the opposite orientation. One mutant could not be located in the regions sequenced. Studies showed that the traA and traD mutations could be complemented in trans with a DNA fragment carrying the corresponding regions.     

Genetic Analysis of the Role of the Transfer Gene, traN, of the F and R100-1 Plasmids in Mating Pair Stabilization during Conjugation

Mating pair stabilization occurs during conjugative DNA transfer whereby the donor and recipient cells form a tight junction which requires pili as well as TraN and TraG in the donor cell. The role of the outer membrane protein, TraN, during conjugative transfer was examined by introduction of a chloramphenicol resistance cassette into the traN gene on an F plasmid derivative, pOX38, to produce pOX38N1::CAT. pOX38N1::CAT was greatly reduced in its ability to transfer DNA, indicating that TraN plays a greater role in conjugation than previously thought. F and R100-1 traN were capable of complementing pOX38N1::CAT transfer equally well when wild-type recipients were used. F traN, but not R100-1 traN, supported a much lower level of transfer when there was an ompA mutation or lipopolysaccharide (LPS) deficiency in the recipient cell, suggesting receptor specificity. The R100-1 traN gene was sequenced, and the gene product was found to exhibit 82.3% overall similarity with F TraN. The differences were mainly located within a central region of the proteins (amino acids 162 to 333 of F and 162 to 348 of R100-1). Deletion analysis of F traN suggested that this central portion might be responsible for the receptor specificity displayed by TraN. TraN was not responsible for TraT-dependent surface exclusion. Thus, TraN, and not the F pilus, appears to interact with OmpA and LPS moieties during conjugation, resulting in mating pair stabilization, the first step in efficient mobilization of DNA.     

Lethal zygosis in recombination-deficient mutants of Escherichia coli.

Use of nonselective medium for plating cells following mating has revealed that Rec recipient strains of E. coli may be killed as a result of conjugation. Sensitivity of RecA-, RecB-, and RecC- recipients increases with ratio of donor: recipient cells in mating mixtures and with time of mating. A Rec+ recipient shows no lethal zygosis in these experiments performed without aeration. Cell contact does not seem to be responsible for the sensitivity of Rec- strains, since lethality is prevented when cell contact is permitted but DNA transfer is not. Thus, an event(s) occuring subsequent to entry of donor DNA appears to cause lethality in Rec- recipients.     

Identification of the origin of transfer (oriT) and DNA relaxase required for conjugation of the integrative and conjugative element ICEBs1 of Bacillus subtilis

Integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs), also known as conjugative transposons, are mobile genetic elements that can transfer from one bacterial cell to another by conjugation. ICEBs1 is integrated into the trnS-leu2 gene of Bacillus subtilis and is regulated by the SOS response and the RapI-PhrI cell-cell peptide signaling system. When B. subtilis senses DNA damage or high concentrations of potential mating partners that lack the element, ICEBs1 excises from the chromosome and can transfer to recipients. Bacterial conjugation usually requires a DNA relaxase that nicks an origin of transfer (oriT) on the conjugative element and initiates the 5'-to-3' transfer of one strand of the element into recipient cells. The ICEBs1 ydcR (nicK) gene product is homologous to the pT181 family of plasmid DNA relaxases. We found that transfer of ICEBs1 requires nicK and identified a cis-acting oriT that is also required for transfer. Expression of nicK leads to nicking of ICEBs1 between a GC-rich inverted repeat in oriT, and NicK was the only ICEBs1 gene product needed for nicking. NicK likely mediates conjugation of ICEBs1 by nicking at oriT and facilitating the translocation of a single strand of ICEBs1 DNA through a transmembrane conjugation pore.