Biophysical characterization of the interactions of HTI-286 with tubulin heterodimer and microtubules

HTI-286 is a synthetic analogue of the natural product hemiasterlin and is a potent antimitotic agent. HTI-286 inhibits the proliferation of tumor cells during mitosis. The observed antimitotic activity is due to the binding of HTI-286 to tubulin. This report details the effects of HTI-286 on soluble tubulin and preassembled microtubules. HTI-286 binds tubulin monomer and oligomerizes it to an 18.5 S species corresponding to a discrete ring structure consisting of about 13 tubulin units as determined by sedimentation equilibrium analyses. The rate of formation of the oligomers is dependent on the concentration of HTI-286 and the time of incubation. Tubulin oligomers, specifically the 18.5 S species, form slowly. The interactions of HTI-286 with tubulin were studied by isothermal titration calorimetry. HTI-286 binds tubulin rapidly, and the initial association of HTI-286 with tubulin is enthalpically driven with a DeltaH value of -14 kcal/mol at 25 degrees C and a dissociation constant of ca. 100 nM. However, the accompanying tubulin oligomerization event does not produce measurable heats at 25 degrees C. The dissociation constant estimated from the changes in the intrinsic fluorescence of tubulin was found to be consistent with the calorimetric results. Both HTI-286 and hemiasterlin bind tubulin with nearly equal potency. However, the stability of the tubulin oligomers is not identical under size-exclusion column chromatographic conditions. The tubulin oligomers formed in the presence of HTI-286 dissociate on the column, while the corresponding oligomers formed in the presence of hemiasterlin are stable. Tubulin undergoes a change in the secondary structure in the presence of HTI-286, which is evidenced by changes in the circular dichroic absorption spectrum of tubulin. In contrast to the microtubule-stabilizing effects of paclitaxel, both HTI-286 and hemiasterlin depolymerize preassembled microtubules at micromolar concentrations.     

Tubulin inhibitors. Synthesis and biological activity of HTI-286 analogs with B-segment heterosubstituents

Modifications of the B-segment of HTI-286 (2) produced a class of analogs incorporating heteroatom-substituents. The structure-activity relationship was studied. Analogs bearing methylsulfide and fluoride groups exhibited potency comparable to that of the parent compound HTI-286 and to paclitaxel in cytotoxicity assays against KB-3-1 cell lines. These analogs were more potent than paclitaxel against P-glycoprotein expressing KB-8-5 and KB-V1 cell lines. Several analogs showed strong inhibition of tubulin polymerization.     

Structure-based identification of the binding site for the hemiasterlin analogue HTI-286 on tubulin

A binding mode of HTI-286, a synthetic analogue of the peptidic antimitotic agent hemiasterlin, to tubulin is proposed. The binding mode was derived from iterative docking experiments directed at regions of the tubulin interdimer interface that are believed to be consistent with all current experimental data regarding the HTI-286/tubulin interaction. These data include (1) competitive inhibition of the tubulin binding of the Vinca alkaloids and other antimitotic agents, (2) proximity to stretches of amino acid residues identified in two separate photoaffinity-labeling experiments, (3) structure-activity relationships for HTI-286 and its analogues, (4) saturation transfer difference nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments, and (5) NMR transfer nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (NOESY) experiments that potentially identify the bioactive conformation. The predicted binding mode thus affords a means to understand the mode of action of hemiasterlin, HTI-286, and other closely related molecules.     

Two photoaffinity analogues of the tripeptide, hemiasterlin, exclusively label alpha-tubulin

A synthetic analogue of the tripeptide hemiasterlin, designated HTI-286, depolymerizes microtubules, is a poor substrate for P-glycoprotein, and inhibits the growth of paclitaxel-resistant tumors in xenograft models. Two radiolabeled photoaffinity analogues of HTI-286, designated 4-benzoyl-N,beta,beta-trimethyl-l-phenylalanyl-N(1)-[(1S,2E)-3-carboxy-1-isopropylbut-2-enyl]-N(1),3-dimethyl-l-valinamide (probe 1) and N,beta,beta-trimethyl-l-phenylalanyl-4-benzoyl-N-[(1S,2E)-3-carboxy-1-isopropyl-2-butenyl]-N,beta,beta-trimethyl-l-phenylalaninamide (probe 2), were made to help identify HTI-286 binding sites in tubulin. HTI-286, probe 1, and probe 2 had similar affinities for purified tubulin [apparent K(D(app)) = 0.2-1.1 microM], inhibited polymerization of purified tubulin approximately 80%, and were potent inhibitors of cell growth (IC(50) = 1.0-22 nM). Both radiolabeled probes labeled exclusively alpha-tubulin. Labeling by [(3)H]probe 1 was inhibited by probe 1, HTI-286, vinblastine, or dolastatin 10 (another peptide antimitotic agent that depolymerizes microtubules) but was either unaffected or enhanced (at certain temperatures) by colchicine or paclitaxel. [(3)H]Probe 1 also labeled exclusively tubulin in cytosolic extracts of whole cells. The major, if not exclusive, contact site for probe 1 was mapped to residues 314-339 of alpha-tubulin and corresponds to the sheet 8 and helix 10 region. This region is known to (1) have longitudinal interactions with beta-tubulin across the interdimer interface, (2) have lateral interactions with adjacent protofilaments, and (3) contact the N-terminal region of stathmin, a protein that induces depolymerization of tubulin. Binding of probe 1 to this region may alter the conformation of tubulin outside the labeling domain, since enzymatic removal of the C-terminus of only alpha-tubulin by subtilisin after, but not before, photolabeling is blocked by probe 1. These results suggest that hemiasterlin is in close contact with alpha-tubulin and may span the interdimer interface so that it contacts the vinblastine- and dolastatin 10-binding sites believed to be in beta-tubulin. In addition, we speculate that antimitotic peptides mimic the interaction of stathmin with tubulin.     

Tubulysin analogs incorporating desmethyl and dimethyl tubuphenylalanine derivatives

A series of tubulysin analogs in which one of the stereogenic centers of tubuphenylalanine was eliminated were synthesized. All compounds were tested for antiproliferative activity towards ovarian cancer cells and for inhibition of tubulin polymerization. The dimethyl analogs were generally more active than the desmethyl analogs, and four analogs have tubulin polymerization IC₅₀ values similar to combretastatin A4 and the hemiasterlin analog HTI-286.     

Mapping the bound conformation and protein interactions of microtubule destabilizing peptides by STD-NMR spectroscopy

Using the hemiasterlin analogs taltobulin (I, HTI-286), II, and III as model compounds, we demonstrate that relaxation-compensated STD-NMR can be used as an effective tool to efficiently provide a qualitative epitope map for microtubule destabilizing peptides. Due to the disparate relaxation behavior of the protons in these model compounds, it was essential to collect STD with very short saturation times to render an accurate picture of the binding interaction. The conformation of HTI-286 (I) in complex with the protein was determined from TRNOESY/ROESY experiments and is similar to the X-ray crystal structure conformation observed for hemiasterlin methyl ester in the absence of protein.     

Synthesis of spiro-1,2-dioxolanes and their activity against Plasmodium falciparum

Artemisinin-derived compounds play an integral role in current malaria chemotherapy. Given the virtual certainty of emerging resistance, we have investigated spiro-1,2-dioxolanes as an alternative scaffold. The endoperoxide functionality was generated by the SnCl(4)-mediated annulation of a bis-silylperoxide and an alkene. The first set of eight analogs gave EC(50) values of 50-150 nM against Plasmodium falciparum 3D7 and Dd2 strains, except for the carboxylic acid analog. A second series, synthesized by coupling a spiro-1,2-dioxolane carboxylic acid to four separate amines, afforded the most potent compound (EC(50) approximately 5 nM).     

A new class of non-thiazolidinedione, non-carboxylic-acid-based highly selective peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) γ agonists: design and synthesis of benzylpyrazole acylsulfonamides

Herein, we describe the design, synthesis, and structure-activity relationships of novel benzylpyrazole acylsulfonamides as non-thiazolidinedione (TZD), non-carboxylic-acid-based peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) γ agonists. Docking model analysis of in-house weak agonist 2 bound to the reported PPARγ ligand binding domain suggested that modification of the carboxylic acid of 2 would help strengthen the interaction of 2 with the TZD pocket and afford non-carboxylic-acid-based agonists. In this study, we used an acylsulfonamide group as the ring-opening analog of TZD as an isosteric replacement of carboxylic acid moiety of 2; further, preliminary modification of the terminal alkyl chain on the sulfonyl group gave the lead compound 3c. Subsequent optimization of the resulting compound gave the potent agonists 25c, 30b, and 30c with high metabolic stability and significant antidiabetic activity. Further, we have described the difference in binding mode of the carboxylic-acid-based agonist 1 and acylsulfonamide 3d.     

Absolute configurations of tubulin inhibitors taltobulin (HTI-286) and HTI-042 characterized by X-ray diffraction analysis and NMR studies

The stereochemistry of the tubulin inhibitors taltobulin HTI-286 (2) and HTI-042 (3) was determined by utilizing the DPFGSE 1D NOE experiment. Single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis further confirmed the absolute configuration of these two compounds, which carry the (S,S,S)-configuration necessary for biological activity.     

Tumor cells resistant to a microtubule-depolymerizing hemiasterlin analogue, HTI-286, have mutations in alpha- or beta-tubulin and increased microtubule stability

Hemiasterlins are sponge-derived tripeptides that inhibit cell growth by depolymerizing existing microtubules and inhibiting microtubule assembly. Since hemiasterlins are poor substrates for P-glycoprotein, they are attractive candidates for cancer therapy and have been undergoing clinical trials. The basis of resistance to a synthetic analogue of hemiasterlin, HTI-286 (HTI), was examined in cell populations derived from ovarian carcinoma (A2780/1A9) cells selected in HTI-286. 1A9-HTI-resistant cells (1A9-HTI(R) series) were 57-89-fold resistant to HTI. Cross-resistance (3-186-fold) was observed to other tubulin depolymerizing drugs, with collateral sensitivity (2-14-fold) to tubulin polymerizing agents. Evaluation of the percentage of polymerized and soluble tubulin in 1A9 parental and 1A9-HTI(R) cells corroborated the HTI cytotoxicity data. At 22 degrees C or 37 degrees C, in the absence of any drug, the percentage of polymerized microtubules for each of the 1A9-HTI(R) populations was greater than that in the 1A9 parental cells, consistent with more stable microtubules. Furthermore, microtubules in the 1A9-HTI(R) populations were also more resistant to depolymerization at 4 degrees C and had more acetylated and detyrosinated (Glu-tubulin) alpha-tubulin, all characteristic of more stable microtubules. The 1A9-HTI(R) cell populations exhibited either a single nucleotide change in the M40 beta-tubulin isotype, S172A, or in two cell populations where no beta-tubulin mutation was detected, mutations in the Kalpha-1 alpha-tubulin isotype, S165P and R221H in one resistant cell population and I384V in another. Unlike reports of mutations resulting in reduced drug affinity, the experimental data and location of mutations are consistent with resistance to HTI-286 mediated by microtubule-stabilizing mutations in beta- or alpha-tubulin.     

Configuration of the vitamin E analogue garcinoic acid extracted from Garcinia Kola seeds

Vitamin E derivatives bearing a carboxylic group have recently gained great attention because of their antitumoral properties. Garcinoic acid (trans-13'-carboxy-delta-tocotrienol) is a vitamin E analog extracted from Garcinia Kola seeds in which the carboxylic group is at the end of the aliphatic side chain and reported to be a racemate based on the optical rotation measurements. However, CD determination of a sample of the acid analyzed by us gave a positive peak at 208 nm, indicating that it is not a racemate. To assess the enantiomeric composition of garcinoic acid, it was thus transformed to alpha-tocopherol and analyzed by chiral HPLC on column OD-H. On the basis of the elution order of alpha-tocopherol stereoisomers, the garcinoic acid sample resulted to be enantiopure with R configuration at carbon 2 of the chroman ring. Moreover, in a preliminary test, the acid and some of its derivatives showed a marked antiproliferative effect on glioma C6 cancer cells.     

A series of nonsecosteroidal vitamin D receptor agonists for osteoporosis therapy

In an extension of our study on gamma hydroxy carboxylic acid analogs, we explored a series of nonsecosteroidal vitamin D receptor (VDR) agonists in which 1,3-diol of 1,25(OH)₂D₃ had been replaced by aryl acetic acid. These analogs showed very potent activity in vitro compared with 1,25(OH)₂D₃. An X-ray analysis of 8d showed that the inserted phenyl ring well mimicked the folded methylene linker of the gamma hydroxy carboxylic acid moiety but the carboxylic acid of 8d interacted with VDR in a different manner from gamma hydroxy carboxylic acids. Through our in vivo screening in an osteoporosis rat model using immature rats, we identified a potent active vitamin D₃ analog, compound 7e. In mature rats of the same model, compound 7e also showed good PK profiling and excellent ability to prevent bone mineral density loss without severe hypercalcemia. Our nonsecosteroidal VDR agonist 7e (CH5036249) could be a possible new drug candidate for treating osteoporosis in human.     

Synthesis and activity of novel analogs of hemiasterlin as inhibitors of tubulin polymerization: modification of the A segment

Analogs of hemiasterlin (1) and HTI-286 (2), which contain various aromatic rings in the A segment, were synthesized as potential inhibitors of tubulin polymerization. The structure-activity relationships related to stereo- and regio-chemical effects of substituents on the aromatic ring in the A segment were studied. Analogs, which carry a meta-substituted phenyl ring in the A segment show comparable activity for inhibition of tubulin polymerization to 2, as well as in the cell proliferation assay using KB cells containing P-glycoprotein, compared to those of 1 and 2.     

Novel nonsecosteroidal vitamin D3 carboxylic acid analogs for osteoporosis, and SAR analysis

Novel vitamin D(3) analogs with carboxylic acid were explored, focusing on a nonsecosteroidal analog, LG190178, with a bisphenyl skeleton. From X-ray analysis of these analogs with vitamin D receptor (VDR), the carboxyl groups had very unique hydrogen bonding interactions in VDR and mimicked 1α-hydroxy group and/or 3β-hydroxy group of 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3). A highly potent analog, 6a, with good in vitro activity and pharmacokinetic profiles was identified from an SAR study. Compound 6a showed significant prevention of bone loss in a rat osteoporosis model by oral administration.     

Structure-activity relationship analyses of fusidic acid derivatives highlight crucial role of the C-21 carboxylic acid moiety to its anti-mycobacterial activity

Fusidic acid (FA) is a potent congener of the fusidane triterpenoid class of antibiotics. Structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies suggest the chemical structure of FA is optimal for its antibacterial activity. SAR studies from our group within the context of a drug repositioning approach in tuberculosis (TB) suggest that, as with its antibacterial activity, the C-21 carboxylic acid group is indispensable for its anti-mycobacterial activity. Further studies have led to the identification of 16-deacetoxy-16β-ethoxyfusidic acid (58), an analog which exhibited comparable activity to FA with an in vitro MIC₉₉ value of 0.8 µM. Preliminary SAR studies around the FA scaffold suggested that the hydrophobic side chain at C-20, like the C-11 OH group, was required for activity. The C-3 OH group, however, can be functionalized to obtain more potent compounds.     

The inactivation of bovine cathepsin B by novel N-chloro-acetyl-dipeptides: application of the Houghten 'tea bag' methodology to inhibitor synthesis

In this study, a series of N-chloro-acetylated dipeptides were synthesised by the application of Houghten's methodology of multiple analog peptide syntheses (MAPS). The peptides, all of which contain a C-terminal free acid, were tested as inactivators of bovine cathepsin B, in an attempt at exploiting the known and, amongst the cysteine proteinases, unique carboxy dipeptidyl peptidase activity of the protease. We have succeeded in obtaining a number of effective inactivators, the most potent of which-chloroacetyl-Leu-Leu-OH, inactivates the enzyme with an apparent second-order rate constant of 3.8 x 10(4)M(-1)min(-1). In contrast, the esterified analog, chloroacetyl-Leu-Leu-OMe, inactivates the enzyme some three orders of magnitude less efficiently, lending credence to our thesis that a free carboxylic acid moiety is an important determinant for inhibitor effectiveness. This preliminary study has highlighted a number of interesting features about the specificity requirements of the bovine proteinase and we believe that our approach has great potential for the rapid delineation of the subsite specificities of cathepsin B-like proteases from various species.     

Estrogen receptor affinity and effects on MCF-7 cell growth of triarylethylene carboxylic acids related to tamoxifen.

The estrogen receptor binding, and growth suppressant and stimulating effects in MCF-7 human breast cancer cells, of four structural variants of the triarylethylene antiestrogen tamoxifen (1) were studied. In these analogs, the dialkylaminoethoxy side chain of 1 was replaced by carboxylic acid or oxyacetic acid substituents. The presence of a p-hydroxy group in the ring geminal to the one bearing the side chain resulted in ligands with estrogen receptor affinities greater than that of 1 but less than that of estradiol. Compared to 1, none of the test compounds were effective suppressants of cell growth. To the contrary, the phenolic oxyacetic acid analog effectively reversed the growth suppressive effect of 1. Also, it was as effective as estradiol, though less potent, in stimulating growth of cells grown in estrogen depleted medium, suggestive of full estrogen agonist activity. Its carboxylic acid counterpart had little or no effect on proliferation. Because the phenolic oxyacetic acid is a metabolite of 1 in animals, its estrogenicity may have therapeutic implications of concern, depending on the extent to which it is formed and distributed in tissues of patients receiving 1.     

Inhibitors of sterol synthesis. Chemical syntheses and spectral properties of 26-oxygenated derivatives of 3 beta-hydroxy-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-15-one and their effects on 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase activity in CHO-K1 cells.

26-Oxygenated derivatives of delta 8(14)-15-ketosterols have been synthesized from (25R)-3 beta,26-diacetoxy-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-15-one (IX) as part of a program to prepare potential metabolites and analogs of 3 beta-hydroxy-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-15-one (I), a potent regulator of cholesterol metabolism. Partial hydrolysis of IX gave a mixture, from which the 3 beta,26-diol II and the 26-acetate (XI) and 3 beta-acetate (X) monoesters were isolated. Mitsunobu reaction of XI followed by hydrolysis gave (25R)-3 alpha,26-dihydroxy-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-15-one (VI). Oxidation of XI with pyridinium chlorochromate followed by hydrolysis of the acetate gave (25R)-26-hydroxy-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-ene-3,15-dione (VII). Oxidation of X with Jones reagent followed by hydrolysis of the acetate gave (25R)-3 beta-hydroxy-15-keto-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-26-oic acid (IVa). Jones oxidation of II gave (25R)-3,15-diketo-5 alpha-cholest-8(14)-en-26-oic acid (VII). 1H and 13C nuclear magnetic resonance assignments and analyses of mass spectral fragmentation data are presented for each of the new compounds and their derivatives. The 3,15-diketone VII was found to be highly active in lowering the levels of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase activity in CHO-K1 cells, with a potency comparable to that of I. In contrast, 3 alpha,26-diol VI was less potent than I or VII. The two carboxylic acid analogs IVa and VIII were considerably less potent than VI in lowering the levels of HMG-CoA reductase activity.     

Synthesis of Novel Peptidyl Adenosine Antibiotic Analogs

A small library of peptidyl adenosine antibiotic analogs was synthesized, under the Pilot Scale Library Program of the NIH Roadmap initiative, from 2′,3′-O-isoproylideneadenosine-5′-carboxylic acid 2 in excellent yield. The coupling of the amino terminus of L-2-aminophenylbutyric methyl ester to a free 5′-carboxylic acid moiety of 2 followed by sodium hydroxide treatment led to carboxylic acid analog 4. Hydrolysis of this latter gave unprotected nucleoside analog 5. Intermediate 4 served as the precursor for the preparation of novel peptidyl adenosine analogs 6–18 in good yields and high purity through peptide coupling reactions to diverse amine derivatives. No marked anticancer and antimalaria activity was noted on preliminary cellular testing; however these analogs should be useful candidates for other types of biological activity.     

Influence of acid surrogates toward potency of VLA-4 antagonist

A series of VLA-4 antagonist were synthesized wherein carboxylic acid was replaced by various acid surrogates. The effect of these acid surrogates toward potency was evaluated in a binding assay. A number of acid surrogates were potent antagonist of VLA-4, albeit significantly less potent than the corresponding carboxylic acid. Heterocyclic acid surrogate, oxadiazolidinone 3, demonstrated an improved pharmacokinetic property when dosed intravenously.