Characterization of antibody binding to three cancer-related antigens using flow cytometry and cell tracking velocimetry

Proper antibody labeling is a fundamental step in the positive selection/isolation of rare cancer cells using immunomagnetic cell separation technology. Using either a two-step or single-step labeling protocol, we examined a combination of six different antibodies specific for three different antigens (epithelial specific antigen, epithelial membrane antigen, and HER-2/Neu) on two different breast cancer cell lines (HCC1954 and MCF-7). When a two-step labeling protocol was used (i.e., anti-surface marker-fluoroscein-isothiocyanate [FITC] [primary Ab], anti-FITC magnetic colloid [secondary Ab]) saturation of the primary antibody was determined using fluorescence intensity measurements from flow cytometry (FCM). The saturation of the secondary antibody (or saturation of a single-step labeling) was determined using magnetophoretic mobility measurements from cell tracking velocimetry (CTV). When the maximum magnetophoretic mobility was the primary objective, our results demonstrate that the quantities necessary for antibody saturation with respect to fluorescence intensity were generally higher than those recommended by the manufacturer. The results demonstrate that magnetophoretic mobility varies depending on the types of cell lines, primary antibodies, and concentration of secondary magnetic colloid-conjugated antibody. It is concluded that saturation studies are a vital preparatory step in any separation method involving antibody labeling, especially those that require the specificity of rare cell detection.     

Continuous flow magnetic cell fractionation based on antigen expression level

Cell separation is important in medical and biological research and plays an increasingly important role in clinical therapy and diagnostics, such as rare cancer cell detection in blood. The immunomagnetic labeling of cells with antibodies conjugated to magnetic nanospheres gives rise to a proportional relationship between the number of magnetic nanospheres attached to the cell and the cell surface marker number. This enables the potential fractionation of cell populations by magnetophoretic mobility (MM). We exploit this feature with our apparatus, the Dipole Magnet Flow Fractionator (DMFF), which consists of an isodynamic magnetic field, an orthogonally-oriented thin ribbon of cell suspension in continuous sheath flow, and ten outlet flows. From a sample containing a 1:1 mixture of immunomagnetically labeled (label+) and unlabeled (label-) cells, we achieved an increase in enrichment of the label+ cell fraction with increasing outlet numbers in the direction of the magnetic field gradient (up to 10-fold). The total recovery of the ten outlet fractions was 90.0+/-7.7%. The mean MM of label+ cells increased with increasing outlet number by up to a factor of 2.3. The postulated proportionality between the number of attached magnetic beads and the number of cell surface markers was validated by comparison of MM measured by cell tracking velocimetry (CTV) with cell florescence intensity measured by flow cytometry.     

Mobility measurements of immunomagnetically labeled cells allow quantitation of secondary antibody binding amplification.

Magnetic cell separation methods commonly utilize paramagnetic materials conjugated to antibodies that target specific cell surface molecules. The amount of magnetic material bound to a cell is directly proportional to the magnetophoretic mobility of that cell. A mathematical model has been developed which characterizes the fundamental parameters controlling the amount of magnetic material bound, and thus, the magnetophoretic mobility of an immunomagnetically labeled cell. In characterization of the paramagnetic labeling, one of the parameters of interest is the increase in magnetophoretic mobility due to the secondary antibody binding to multiple epitopes on the primary antibody, referred to as the "secondary antibody binding amplification," Psi. Secondary antibody-binding amplification has been investigated and quantitated by comparing the mobilities of lymphocytes directly labeled with anti-CD4 MACS (Miltenyi Biotec, Auburn, CA) magnetic nanoparticle antibody with the mobilities of lymphocytes from the same sample labeled with two different indirect antibody-labeling schemes. Each indirect labeling scheme incorporated a primary mouse anti-CD4 FITC antibody that provides both FITC and mouse-specific binding sites for two different secondary antibody-magnetic nanoparticle conjugates: either anti-FITC MACS magnetic nanoparticle antibody or anti-mouse MACS magnetic nanoparticle antibody. The magnetophoretic mobilities of the immunomagnetically labeled cells were obtained using Cell Tracking Velocimetry (CTV). The results indicate that an average of 3.4 anti-FITC MACS magnetic nanoparticle antibodies bind to each primary CD4 FITC antibody, Psi(1,2f) = 3.4 +/- 0.33, and that approximately one, Psi(1,2m) = 0.98 +/- 0.081, anti-mouse MACS magnetic nanoparticle antibody binds to each primary mouse CD4 FITC antibody on a CD4 positive lymphocyte. These results have provided a better understanding of the antibody-binding mechanisms used in paramagnetic cell labeling for magnetic cell separation.     

Effects of antibody concentration on the separation of human natural killer cells in a commercial immunomagnetic separation system.

BACKGROUND: The magnetic separation of a cell population based on cell surface markers is a critical step in many biological and clinical laboratories. In this study, the effect of antibody concentration on the separation of human natural killer cells in a commercial, immunomagnetic cell separation system was investigated. METHODS: Specifically, the degree of saturation of antibody binding sites using a two-step antibody sandwich was quantified. The quantification of the first step, a primary anti-CD56-PE antibody, was achieved through fluorescence intensity measurements using a flow cytometer. The quantification of the second step, an anti-PE-microbeads antibody reagent, was achieved through magnetophoretic mobility measurements using cell tracking velocimetry. RESULTS: From the results of these studies, two different labeling protocols were used to separate CD56+ cells from human, peripheral blood by a Miltenyi Biotech MiniMACS cell separation system. The first of these two labeling protocols was based on company recommendations, whereas the second was based on the results of the saturation studies. The results from these studies demonstrate that the magnetophoretic mobility is a function of both primary and secondary antibody concentrations and that mobility does have an effect on the performance of the separation system. CONCLUSIONS: As the mobility increased due to an increase in bound antibodies, the positive cells were almost completely eliminated from the negative eluent. However, with an increase in bound antibodies, and thus mobility, the total amount of positive cells recovered decreases. It is speculated that these cells are irreversibly retained in the column. These results demonstrate the complexity of immunomagnetic cell separation and the need to further optimize the cell separation process.     

Magnetic cell sorting is a fast and effective method of enriching viable spermatogonia from Djungarian hamster, mouse, and marmoset monkey testes.

Germ cell transplantation, which offers promising new approaches for research and clinical applications, has focused interest on spermatogonia. This paper describes a procedure that permits the isolation of large quantities of viable spermatogonia. The immunomagnetic isolation procedure was applied to testicular cell suspensions from photoinhibited and photostimulated Djungarian hamsters, mice, and marmoset monkeys. The cells were incubated with a polyclonal rabbit anti-c-kit IgG, binding of which was characterized by immunohistochemical staining. For magnetic labeling, a secondary anti-rabbit IgG conjugated to ferromagnetic microbeads was used. Separation columns allowed the retention of magnetically labeled cells within the matrix. The magnetic fractions were eluted after removal of the column from the magnetic field. All fractions were analyzed for cellular morphology and by flow cytometry. The final enrichment of c-kit-positive cells in the magnetic fraction using fully active testes was in the range of 25-55% with a viability rate of 80-90%. The magnetic fractions of all three species were characterized by high numbers of diploid cells. Cytological analysis revealed a strong enrichment of spermatogonia. No haploid cells were retained in the magnetic fraction. In comparison to conventional procedures, magnetic cell separation is an efficient and fast approach for isolation of spermatogonia.     

Capture antibody targeted fluorescence in situ hybridization (CAT-FISH): dual labeling allows for increased specificity in complex samples

Pathogen detection using biosensors is commonly limited due to the need for sensitivity and specificity in detecting targets within mixed populations. These issues were addressed through development of a dual labeling method that allows for both liquid-phase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and capture antibody targeted detection (CAT-FISH). CAT-FISH was developed using Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Staphylococcus aureus as representative bacteria, and processing techniques were evaluated with regard to FISH intensities and antibody recognition. The alternative fixative solution, methacarn, proved to be superior to standard solid-phase paraformaldehyde fixation procedures, allowing both FISH labeling and antibody recognition. CAT-FISH treated cells were successfully labeled with FISH probes, captured by immunomagnetic separation using fluorescent cytometric array beads, and detected using a cytometric array biosensor. CAT-FISH treated cells were detectable with LODs comparable to the standard antibody-based technique, (~ 10³ cells/ml in PBS), and the technique was also successfully applied to two complex matrices. Although immunomagnetic capture and detection using cytometric arrays were demonstrated, CAT-FISH is readily applicable to any antibody-based fluorescence detection platform, and further optimization for sensitivity is possible via inclusion of fluorescently tagged antibodies. Since the confidence level needed for positive identification of a detected target is often paramount, CAT-FISH was developed to allow two separate levels of specificity, namely nucleic acid and protein signatures. With proper selection of FISH probes and capture antibodies, CAT-FISH may be used to provide rapid detection of target pathogens from within complex matrices with high levels of confidence.     

Magnetophoretic mobilities correlate to antibody binding capacities

METHODS: A methodology and a mathematical theory have been developed, which allow quantitation of the expression levels of cellular surface antigens using immunomagnetic labels and cell tracking velocimetry (CTV) technology. RESULTS: Quantum Simply Cellular (QSC) microbeads were immunomagnetically labeled with anti-CD2 fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) antibodies and anti-FITC MACS paramagnetic nanoparticles. Magnetophoretic mobility has been defined as the magnetically induced velocity of the labeled cell or microbead divided by the magnetophoretic driving force, proportional to the magnetic energy density gradient. DISCUSSION: Using computer imaging and processing technology, the mobility measurements were accomplished by microscopically recording and calculating the velocity of immunomagnetically labeled QSC microbeads in a nearly constant magnetic energy gradient. A calibration curve correlating the measured magnetophoretic mobility of the immunomagnetically labeled microbeads to their antibody binding capacities (ABC) has been obtained. CONCLUSION: The results, in agreement with theory, indicate a linear relationship between magnetophoretic mobility and ABC for microbeads with less than 30,000 ABC. The mathematical relationships and QSC standardization curve obtained allow determination of the number of surface antigens on similarly immunomagnetically labeled cells.     

Fractionation of bovine spermatozoa for sex selection: A rapid immunomagnetic technique to remove spermatozoa that contain the H-Y antigen

A study was conducted to rapidly fractionate bovine spermatozoa on the basis of cell-surface H-Y antigen (i.e., Y chromosome-bearing spermatozoa). A novel, rapid immunomagnetic method was developed for removal of spermatozoa that bound to anti-H-Y IgG. Fluorescent labeling and flow cytometry were used to measure the efficiency with which spermatozoa binding to anti-H-Y were removed by the immunomagnetic technique. Washed bovine spermatozoa (n=7 bulls) were treated with a mouse monoclonal IgG antibody to H-Y antigen (MoAb 12/49). Fluorescent labeled goat antibody against mouse IgG was added to label those spermatozoa with cell-surface H-Y antigens. Supermagnetized polymer beads coated with an anti-antibody to the MoAb 12/49 were then added to the spermatozoa. After 20 min of incubation, spermatozoa were exposed for 2 min to a magnet, causing the magnetized particles to adhere to the sides of the tube. Nonmagnetized spermatozoa in the supernatent were aspirated and analyzed for fluorescent label by flow cytometry. Approximately 50% of spermatozoa not subjected to immunomagnetic separation were fluorescent labeled, and about one-half of the spermatozoa were observed microscopically to be bound to the magnetized polymer beads prior to magnetic separation (P<0.05). Following magnetic separation, only 1.2% (P<0.05) of the spermatozoa in the magnetic supernatent were fluorescent labeled. Assuming that only Y chromosome-bearing spermatozoa have cell-surface H-Y antigens, the present immunomagnetic fractionation removed almost all of the Y chromosome-bearing spermatozoa, leaving a population that was greater than 98% X chromosome-bearing spermatozoa.     

High-efficiency immunomagnetic isolation of solid tissue-originated integrin-expressing adult stem cells

Isolation of highly pure specific cell types is crucial for successful adult stem cell-based therapy. As the number of such cells in adult tissue is low, an extremely efficient method is needed for their isolation. Here, we describe cell-separation methodologies based on magnetic-affinity cell sorting (MACS) MicroBeads with monoclonal antibodies against specific membrane proteins conjugated to superparamagnetic particles. Cells labeled with MACS MicroBeads are retained in a magnetic field within a MACS column placed in a MACS separator, allowing fast and efficient separation. Both positively labeled and non-labeled fractions can be used directly for downstream applications as the separated cell fractions remain viable with no functional impairment. As immunomagnetic separation depends on the interaction between a cell's membrane and the magnetically labeled antibody, separation of specific cells originating from solid tissues is more complex and demands a cell-dissociating pretreatment. In this paper, we detail the use of immunomagnetic separation for the purpose of regenerating damaged salivary gland (SG) function in animal and human models of irradiated head and neck cancer. Each year 500,000 new cases of head and neck cancer occur worldwide. Most of these patients lose SG function following irradiation therapy. SGs contain integrin α6β1-expressing epithelial stem cells. We hypothesized that these cells can be isolated, multiplied in culture and auto-implanted into the irradiated SGs to regenerate damaged SG function.     

Magnetophoretic cell sorting is a function of antibody binding capacity

Antibody binding capacity (ABC) is a term representing a cell's ability to bind antibodies, correlating with the number of specific cellular antigens expressed on that cell. ABC allows magnetically conjugated antibodies to bind to the targeted cells, imparting a magnetophoretic mobility on each targeted cell. This enables sorting based on differences in the cell magnetophoretic mobility and, potentially, a magnetic separation based on the differences in the cell ABC values. A cell's ABC value is a particularly important factor in continuous magnetic cell separation. This work investigates the relationship between ABC and magnetic cell separation efficiency by injection of a suspension of immunomagnetically labeled quantum simply cellular calibration microbeads of known ABC values into fluid flowing through a quadrupole magnetic sorter. The elution profiles of the outlet streams were evaluated using UV detectors. Optimal separation flow rate was shown to correlate with the ABC of these microbeads. Comparing experimental and theoretical results, the theory correctly predicted maximum separation flow rates but overestimated the separation fractional recoveries.     

Magnetic field design for selecting and aligning immunomagnetic labeled cells

BACKGROUND: Recently we introduced the CellTracks cell analysis system, in which samples are prepared based on a combination of immunomagnetic selection, separation, and alignment of cells along ferromagnetic lines. Here we describe the underlying magnetic principles and considerations made in the magnetic field design to achieve the best possible cell selection and alignment of magnetically labeled cells. Materials and Methods Computer simulations, in combination with experimental data, were used to optimize the design of the magnets and Ni lines to obtain the optimal magnetic configuration. RESULTS: A homogeneous cell distribution on the upper surface of the sample chamber was obtained with a magnet where the pole faces were tilted towards each other. The spatial distribution of magnetically aligned objects in between the Ni lines was dependent on the ratio of the diameter of the aligned object and the line spacing, which was tested with magnetically and fluorescently labeled 6 microm polystyrene beads. The best result was obtained when the line spacing was equal to or smaller than the diameter of the aligned object. CONCLUSIONS: The magnetic gradient of the designed permanent magnet extracts magnetically labeled cells from any cell suspension to a desired plane, providing a homogeneous cell distribution. In addition, it magnetizes ferro-magnetic Ni lines in this plane whose additional local gradient adds to the gradient of the permanent magnet. The resultant gradient aligns the magnetically labeled cells first brought to this plane. This combination makes it possible, in a single step, to extract and align cells on a surface from any cell suspension.     

Automated kinetic exclusion assays to quantify protein binding interactions in homogeneous solution.

A method was developed for the quantification of protein-ligand interactions in which the free protein present in homogeneous reaction mixtures was separated and quantified using a KinExA immunoassay instrument. Separation was achieved by rapid percolation of the reaction mixture over a column of microbeads whose surfaces were coated with an immobilized form of the ligand. The protein thus captured was quantified using a fluorescently labeled anti-protein antibody. The features of this new method were illustrated using a model system in which each of the principal reagents was covalently labeled with a different fluorescent molecule: mouse monoclonal anti-biotin primary antibody (fluorescein), biotin (B-phycoerythrin), and goat anti-mouse polyclonal secondary antibody (indodicarbocyanin). Values for the equilibrium and kinetic rate constants for the binding between the anti-biotin antibody and biotin conjugated with B-phycoerythrin were determined and shown to be independent of whether the fluorescent label was located on the primary or secondary antibody. Equilibrium binding experiments conducted with (F(AB))(2) and corresponding F(AB) fragments showed that the valency of the binding protein had no influence on the value of the dissociation constant. The values of the equilibrium and rate constants obtained by this new method are those for the binding reaction in homogeneous solution; the immobilized ligand is only a tool exploited for the separation and quantification of the free protein.     

Comparing recovering efficiency of immunomagnetic separation and centrifugation of mycobacteria in metalworking fluids

The accurate detection and enumeration of Mycobacterium immunogenum in metalworking fluids (MWFs) is imperative from an occupational health and industrial fluids management perspective. We report here a comparison of immunomagnetic separation (IMS) coupled to flow-cytometric enumeration, with traditional centrifugation techniques for mycobacteria in a semisynthetic MWF. This immunolabeling involves the coating of laboratory-synthesized nanometer-scale magnetic particles with protein A, to conjugate a primary antibody (Ab), specific to Mycobacterium spp. By using magnetic separation and flow-cytometric quantification, this approach enabled much higher recovery efficiency and fluorescent light intensities in comparison to the widely applied centrifugation technique. This IMS technique increased the cell recovery efficiency by one order of magnitude, and improved the fluorescence intensity of the secondary Ab conjugate by 2-fold, as compared with traditional techniques. By employing nanometer-scale magnetic particles, IMS was found to be compatible with flow cytometry (FCM), thereby increasing cell detection and enumeration speed by up to two orders of magnitude over microscopic techniques. Moreover, the use of primary Ab conjugated magnetic nanoparticles showed better correlation between epifluorescent microscopy counts and FCM analysis than that achieved using traditional centrifugation techniques. The results strongly support the applicability of the flow-cytometric IMS for microbial detection in complex matrices.     

Comparing recovering efficiency of immunomagnetic separation and centrifugation of mycobacteria in metalworking fluids

The accurate detection and enumeration of Mycobacterium immunogenum in metalworking fluids (MWFs) is imperative from an occupational health and industrial fluids management perspective. We report here a comparison of immunomagnetic separation (IMS) coupled to flow-cytometric enumeration, with traditional centrifugation techniques for mycobacteria in a semisynthetic MWF. This immunolabeling involves the coating of laboratory-synthesized nanometer-scale magnetic particles with protein A, to conjugate a primary antibody (Ab), specific to Mycobacterium spp. By using magnetic separation and flow-cytometric quantification, this approach enabled much higher recovery efficiency and fluorescent light intensities in comparison to the widely applied centrifugation technique. This IMS technique increased the cell recovery efficiency by one order of magnitude, and improved the fluorescence intensity of the secondary Ab conjugate by 2-fold, as compared with traditional techniques. By employing nanometer-scale magnetic particles, IMS was found to be compatible with flow cytometry (FCM), thereby increasing cell detection and enumeration speed by up to two orders of magnitude over microscopic techniques. Moreover, the use of primary Ab conjugated magnetic nanoparticles showed better correlation between epifluorescent microscopy counts and FCM analysis than that achieved using traditional centrifugation techniques. The results strongly support the applicability of the flow-cytometric IMS for microbial detection in complex matrices.

     

Probing functionalized gold colloids for single particle tracking experiments

Functionalized submicroscopic particles are currently used to label proteins or lipids at the surface of living cells for single particle tracking experiments. In many cases, it can be of crucial importance for the particle to be anchored to a single molecule. We have addressed this question for the labeling at the plasma membrane of NRK cells of the mu-opioid receptor bearing a T7 epitope at the N-terminus. Using biophysical methods we were able to prepare quasi-monovalent anti-T7 antibody conjugated gold colloids (40 nm diameter) leading to stable and specific binding to the receptor. The rational method, we report here, can be extended to design customized probes for the labeling of various tagged molecules.     

Immunocytochemical demonstration of the binding and internalization of growth hormone in GERL of Chang hepatoma cells

Summary The binding and internalization of endogenous growth hormone in Chang hepatoma cells were localized on the cell surface and in the Golgi-endoplasmic reticulum-lysosome (GERL) area by various indirect immunocytochemical labeling techniques, namely, peroxidase or colloidal gold conjugated to secondary antibody, and avidin-biotin complex methods. Rabbit antiserum and monoclonal antibodies raised against HPLC-purified porcine growth hormone were used in this study. In fixed material, antigen-antibody complexes were found to be homogeneously distributed along the cell membrane. Control groups showed negative binding on the cell surface. Trypsin treatment before immunolabeling removed antibody binding completely, but hyaluronidase was ineffective. Pretreatment of lectins did not block the recognition of primary antibody to antigen molecules on cell surface. Internalization of the antigen-antibody peroxidase or gold complexes was demonstrated in the cells, which were immunolabeled at 4°C, and then reincubated for 0–30 min at 37°C before fixation. After reincubation, the internalized ligand complexes were found in vesicles near the cell surface or in the GERL area near the Golgi apparatus which, however, did not label for peroxidase. These findings suggest that the trypsin-sensitive growth hormone, specifically bound and internalized into Chang hepatoma cells, is localized in the GERL instead of the Golgi apparatus and might be involved in the mechanism of tumor cell growth.     

Binding affinities/avidities of antibody-antigen interactions: quantification and scale-up implications

Bioaffinity interactions have been, and continue to be, successfully adapted from nature for use in separation and detection applications. It has been previously reported that the magnetophoretic mobility of labeled cells show a saturation type phenomenon as a function of the concentration of the free antibody-magnetic nanoparticle conjugate which is consistent with other reports of antibody-fluorophore binding. Starting with the standard antibody-antigen relationship, a model was developed which takes into consideration multi-valence interactions, and various attributes of flow cytometry (FCM) and cell tracking velocimetry (CTV) measurements to determine both the apparent dissociation constant and the antibody-binding capacity (ABC) of a cell. This model was then evaluated on peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) labeled with anti CD3 antibodies conjugated to FITC, PE, or DM (magnetic nanoparticles). Reasonable agreements between the model and the experiments were obtained. In addition, estimates of the limitation of the number of magnetic nanoparticles that can bind to a cell as a result of steric hinderance was consistent with measured values of magnetophoretic mobility. Finally, a scale-up model was proposed and tested which predicts the amount of antibody conjugates needed to achieve a given level of saturation as the total number of cells reaches 10(10), the number of cells needed for certain clinical applications, such as T-cell depletions for mismatched bone marrow transplants.     

Horseradish peroxidase-driven fluorescent labeling of nanotubes with quantum dots

We describe the first enzyme-driven technique for fluorescent labeling of single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs). The labeling was performed via enzymatic biotinylation of nanotubes in the tyramide-horseradish peroxidase (HRP) reaction. Both direct and indirect fuorescent labeling of SWNTs was achieved using either biotinyl tyramide or fluorescently tagged tyramides. Biotinylated SWNTs later reacted with streptavidin-conjugated fluorophores. Linking semiconductor nanocrystals, quantum dots (Q-dots), to the surface of nanotubes resulted in their fluorescent visualization, whereas conventional fluorophores bound to SWNTs directly or through biotin-streptavidin linkage, were completely quenched. Enzymatic biotinylation permits fluorescent visualization of carbon nanotubes, which could be useful for a number of biomedical applications. In addition, other organic molecules such as proteins, antibodies, or DNA can be conjugated to biotinylated SWNTs using this approach.     

Antibody-magnetite method for selective concentration of Giardia lamblia cysts from water samples.

An antibody-magnetite method was developed in order to selectively concentrate Giardia cysts from water samples. The indirect technique employed a mouse immunoglobulin G anti-Giardia antibody as a primary antibody and an anti-mouse immunoglobulin G antibody-coated magnetite particle as a secondary labeling reagent. The magnetically labeled cysts were then concentrated by high-gradient magnetic separation. Ninety percent of the seeded cysts were recovered from buffer when this method was employed. An average of 82% of the seeded cysts were recovered from water samples with various turbidities. Significantly higher cyst recoveries were obtained from water samples with turbidities below 600 nephelometric turbidity units.