Semiquantitative and quantitative analysis of protein–DNA interactions using steady-state measurements in surface plasmon resonance competition experiments

One method commonly used to characterize protein–DNA interactions is surface plasmon resonance (SPR). In a typical SPR experiment, chip-bound DNA is exposed to increasing concentrations of protein; the resulting binding data are used to calculate a dissociation constant for the interaction. However, in cases in which knowledge of the specificity of the interaction is required, a large set of DNA variants has to be tested; this is time consuming and costly, in part because of the requirement for multiple SPR chips. We have developed a new protocol that uses steady-state binding levels in SPR competition experiments to determine protein-binding dissociation constants for a set of DNA variants. This approach is rapid and straightforward and requires the use of only a single SPR chip. Additionally, in contrast to other methods, our approach does not require prior knowledge of parameters such as on or off rates, using an estimate of the wild-type interaction as the sole input. Utilizing relative steady-state responses, our protocol also allows for the rapid, reliable, and simultaneous determination of protein-binding dissociation constants of a large series of DNA mutants in a single experiment in a semiquantitative fashion. We compare our approach to existing methods, highlighting specific advantages as well as limitations.     

Surface plasmon resonance in protein-membrane interactions

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) has become one of the most important techniques for studying macromolecular interactions. The most obvious advantages of SPR over other techniques are: direct and rapid determination of association and dissociation rates of binding process, no need for labelling of protein or lipids, and small amounts of sample used in the assay (often nM concentrations of proteins). In biochemistry, SPR is used mainly to study protein-protein interactions. On the other hand, protein-membrane interactions, although crucial for many cell processes, are less well studied. Recent advances in the preparation of stable membrane-like surfaces and the commercialisation of sensor chips has enabled widespread use of SPR in protein-membrane interactions. One of the most popular is Biacore's L1 sensor chip that allows capture of intact liposomes or even subcellular preparations. Lipid specificity of protein-membrane interactions can, therefore, be easily studied by manipulating the lipid composition of the immobilised membrane. The number of published papers has increased steadily in the last few years and the examples include domains or proteins that participate in cell signalling, pore-forming proteins, membrane-interacting peptides, coagulation factors, enzymes, amyloidogenic proteins, prions, etc. This paper gives a brief overview of different membrane-mimetic surfaces that can be prepared on the surface of SPR chips, properties of liposomes on the surface of L1 chips and some selected examples of protein-membrane interactions studied with such system.     

Carbohydrate-lectin interactions assessed by surface plasmon resonance

The specificity, the strength, the kinetics and some thermodynamic parameters of sugar-protein interactions are easily assessed by surface plasmon resonance (SPR). This paper intends to present both theoretical and practical considerations. This includes: the principle of SPR, the analysis according to Langmuir and Scatchard, the problems linked either to mass transport limitation, to the heterogeneity of the immobilized ligand density or to the non-linearity due to cluster effects. The non-linearity may be taken into account by either one of two ways: the fractal or the Sips approaches that have been developed with the aim of linearizing the data. In addition, selected data obtained by using either immobilized carbohydrates or immobilized lectins are summarized. The SPR has also been found useful to collect information concerning oligosaccharide structure as well as lectin-sugar specificity and to develop new tools with medical applications. Finally, a series of practical considerations are gathered in the hope of avoiding some of the common pitfalls arising in sugar-lectin interaction studies based on the use of SPR.     

Surface plasmon resonance imaging analysis of protein-protein interactions using on-chip-expressed capture protein

A surface plasmon resonance (SPR) imaging system, combined with a microwell gold chip for on-chip cell cultivation, was used to monitor protein-protein interactions. In particular, we developed an on-chip microscale cell cultivation system that integrates cell culture and on-chip analysis of protein-protein interactions on a single microwell chip in a time- and labor-saving manner. To assess the performance of this system in the analysis of protein-protein interactions, we conducted a series of protein-protein interaction analyses by measuring the binding of the yeast GAL4 dimerization domain (GAL4DD) to the GAL11 protein (GAL11P). Our system was found to enable the simple and rapid analysis of protein-protein interactions, requiring no special cell culturing equipment or recombinant protein expression prior to the immobilization of the purified proteins onto the chip. Our results demonstrate that the combination of an on-chip cell cultivation system and an SPR imaging system can be a useful tool to study protein-protein interactions without the need for time-consuming and labor-intensive protein preparation steps as well as fluorescent or other labeling of the interactants.     

Surface plasmon resonance for probing quadruplex folding and interactions with proteins and small molecules

Surface plasmon resonance is a technique for detecting binding events at the surface of a thin metal film. Through the commercial availability of instrumentation and sensor chips, the technique has found widespread application for determining the affinity and kinetics of macromolecular interactions. A variety of quadruplex forming oligonucleotides have been immobilized to sensor chips to permit analysis of their binding interactions with both small molecule and protein analytes. The fold of the quadruplex must be maintained through an appropriate choice of buffer, and care must be taken to ensure that data interpretation is not hampered by non-specific binding and adsorption of the analyte to the sensor surface and instrument. Affinity constants determined by surface plasmon resonance for interactions with quadruplexes correlate meaningfully with other methods, such as UV-visible and fluorescence titrations, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, thermal melting studies and telomerase inhibition. Kinetic measurements of the association and dissociation of duplexes of quadruplex forming oligonucleotides and their complementary strands have enabled calculation of the folding and unfolding rates of the quadruplex itself, and determination of its stability as a function of buffer composition.     

Surface plasmon resonance analysis of interactions between diacylglycerol acyltransferase and its interacting molecules

To measure the interactions of diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT) by surface plasmon resonance (SPR), we immobilized Saccharomyces cerevisiae DGAT2 encoded by DGA1 on a BIACORE sensor chip surface. We used N-terminally truncated Dga1p with a FLAG tag at the C-terminus, which was purified to apparent homogeneity, maintaining significant DGAT activity (Kamisaka et al., Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 88, 105-115 (2010)). Truncated Dga1p with a FLAG tag was immobilized with an anti-FLAG antibody that had been coupled with an L1 chip surface consisting of a carboxymethyl dextran matrix with additional hydrophobic alkane groups. The Dga1p-immobilized chip surface was analyzed for interactions of Dga1p with oleoyl-CoA, its substrate, and anti-Dga1p IgG, its interacting protein, by SPR. The binding of these analytes with the Dga1p-immobilized chip surface was specific, because butyryl-CoA, which cannot be used as a substrate for DGAT, and anti-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase IgG, did not induce any signals on SPR. Furthermore, injection of organic compounds such as xanthohumol, a DGAT inhibitor, into the Dga1p-immobilized chip surface induced significant SPR signals, probably due to interaction with DGAT. Another DGAT inhibitor, piperine, did not induce SPR signals on application, but induced them due to piperine on application together with oleoyl-CoA, in which piperine can be incorporated into the micelles of oleoyl-CoA. The results indicate that the Dga1p-immobilized L1 chip surface recognized DGAT inhibitors. Taking all this together, SPR measurement using the Dga1p-immobilized L1 chip surface provided a useful system to elucidate the structure-function relationships of DGAT and screen DGAT inhibitors.     

Kinetic analysis of nanoparticle‐protein interactions using a plasmon waveguide resonance

A plasmon waveguide resonance (PWR) sensor is proposed for studying the interaction between gold nanoparticles and proteins. The ability of the PWR sensor to operate in both TM and TE Polarizations, i.e. its polarization diversity, facilitates the simultaneous spectroscopy of the nanoparticles surface reactions using both polarizations. The response of each polarization to streptavidin‐biotin binding at the surface of gold nanoparticles is investigated in real time. Finally, using the principles of multimode spectroscopy, the nanoparticle's surface reactions are decoupled from the bulk solution refractive index variations.

Schematic diagram of the NP‐modified PWR sensor     

Kinetic studies of RNA-protein interactions using surface plasmon resonance

Although structural, biochemical, and genetic studies have provided much insight into the determinants of specificity and affinity of proteins for RNA, little is currently known about the kinetics that underlie RNA-protein interactions. Protein-RNA complexes are dynamic, and the kinetics of binding and release could influence many processes, such as the ability of RNA-binding proteins to compete for binding sites, the sequential assembly of ribonucleoprotein complexes, and the ability of bound RNA to move between cellular compartments. Therefore, to attain a complete and biologically relevant understanding of RNA-protein interactions, complex formation must be studied not only in equilibrated reactions, but also as a dynamic process. BIACORE, a surface plasmon resonance-based biosensor technology, allows intermolecular interactions to be measured in real time, and can provide both equilibrium and kinetic information about complex formation. This technology is a powerful tool with which to study the dynamics of RNA-protein interactions. We have used BIACORE extensively to obtain detailed insight into the interaction between RNA and proteins carrying RNA recognition motif domains. Here we discuss the physical principles on which BIACORE is based, and the required instrumentation. We describe how to design well-controlled RNA-protein interaction experiments aimed at yielding high-quality data, and outline the steps required for data analysis. In addition, we present examples to illustrate how kinetic studies have provided us with unique insights into the interaction of the spliceosomal U1A protein and the neuronal HuD protein with their respective RNA targets.     

Surface plasmon resonance characterization of drug/liposome interactions

Using Biacore's surface plasmon resonance-based biosensor technology, we developed experimental protocols and probed test conditions required to study drugs interacting with liposome surfaces. Liposome capture on hydrophobic alkane surfaces (Pioneer L1 chip) was reproducible and stable under variable conditions of pH, temperature, lipid content, cholesterol content, and buffer dimethylsulfoxide concentration. Importantly, drug binding responses were directly proportional to the amount of lipid captured, while the kinetics of drug binding and the magnitude of the responses correlated with a drug's chemical composition. In general, anionic drugs tended to rapidly dissociate from the surface, while cationic drugs displayed heterogeneous binding, suggesting partitioning within the lipid bilayer itself. The results illustrate how surface plasmon resonance can be used to establish passive transport properties of drugs.     

Real-time analysis of antibody interactions with whole enveloped human cytomegalovirus using surface plasmon resonance

Human cytomegalovirus (CMV) is a large enveloped virus that encodes multiple glycoproteins required for virus-cell binding and fusion. To assess the binding properties of antibodies with target glycoprotein in a natural context of infection, we investigated the feasibility of using the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technique for studying the direct binding of antibodies with CMV virions. Direct immobilization of whole virions to sensor surface and a surface regeneration procedure allowed for quantitative and reproducible measurements of binding affinity and binding kinetics of antibody–whole virion interactions. The conformational and functional integrity of viral particles was not compromised by the regeneration condition as evaluated with antibodies recognizing conformational epitopes and by electron microscopy. Binding of an irrelevant antibody was not observed, indicating the high specificity of the method. A panel of anti-gB antibodies was measured and the binding affinities correlated fairly well with those determined by ELISA. These data demonstrated that the interaction of anti-gB antibody with whole virion of large enveloped CMV can be quantitatively studied using SPR. This method has been successfully applied for screening and selection of anti-CMV antibodies and can be potentially extended to study antibody–glycoprotein interactions of other related herpesviruses.     

Comparative thermodynamic analysis of DNA--protein interactions using surface plasmon resonance and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

We report a kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of interactions between ssDNA and replication protein A (RPA) using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) at variable temperature. The two methods yield different values for the Gibbs free energy but nearly the same value for the reaction enthalpy of ssDNA-RPA complex formation. The Gibbs free energy was determined by SPR and FCS to be -62.6 and -54.7 kJ/mol, respectively. The values for the reaction enthalpy are -64.4 and -66.5 kJ/mol. It is concluded that the difference in Gibbs free energy measured by the two methods is due to different reaction entropies. The entropic contribution to the free energy at 25 degrees C is -1.8 kJ/mol for SPR and -11.8 kJ/mol for FCS. In SPR, the reaction is restricted to two dimensions because of immobilization of the DNA molecules to the sensor surface. In contrast, FCS is able to follow complex formation without spatial restrictions. In consequence, the reaction entropy determined from SPR experiments is lower than for FCS experiments.     

Label-enhanced surface plasmon resonance applied to label-free interaction analysis of small molecules and fragments

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is a well-established method for studying interactions between small molecules and biomolecules. In particular, SPR is being increasingly applied within fragment-based drug discovery; however, within this application area, the limited sensitivity of SPR may constitute a problem. This problem can be circumvented by the use of label-enhanced SPR that shows a 100-fold higher sensitivity as compared with conventional SPR. Truly label-free interaction data for small molecules can be obtained by applying label-enhanced SPR in a surface competition assay format. The enhanced sensitivity is accompanied by an increased specificity and inertness toward disturbances (e.g., bulk refractive index disturbances). Label-enhanced SPR can be used for fragment screening in a competitive assay format; the competitive format has the added advantage of confirming the specificity of the molecular interaction. In addition, label-enhanced SPR extends the accessible kinetic regime of SPR to the analysis of very fast fragment binding kinetics. In this article, we demonstrate the working principles and benchmark the performance of label-enhanced SPR in a model system—the interaction between carbonic anhydrase II and a number of small-molecule sulfonamide-based inhibitors.     

Investigation of pH-dependent DNA-metal ion interactions by surface plasmon resonance

Ni(II) and Zn(II) M-DNA formation and denaturation of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) by Cd(2+) were monitored by surface plasmon resonance (SPR). When exposed to immobilized 30 bp 50% GC dsDNA, Zn(2+) and Ni(2+) were found to give signals indicative of a conformational change at pH 8.5 but not 7.5, while Mg(2+) and Ca(2+) caused small changes at both pHs. The concentrations that gave 50% of the maximum responses were 0.06 and 0.50 mM for Zn(2+) and Ni(2+), respectively. At pH 8.5, Cd(2+) denatured over 40% of the dsDNA, while other metals denatured less than 5% of the DNA. Smaller pH-dependent signals were induced by Zn(2+), Ni(2+) or Cd(2+) with 50% GC single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), and with a homopolymer of d(T)30. Homopolymers d(A)30 and d(C)30 showed small signals that were largely independent of pH in the presence of Zn(2+) or Ni(2+).     

Surface plasmon resonance imaging for real-time, label-free analysis of protein interactions with carbohydrate microarrays

Plant lectin recognition of glycans was evaluated by SPR imaging using a model array of N-biotinylated aminoethyl glycosides of β-d-glucose (negative control), α-d-mannose (conA-responsive), β-d-galactose (RCA₁₂₀-responsive) and N-acetyl-β-d-glucosamine (WGA-responsive) printed onto neutravidin-coated gold chips. Selective recognition of the cognate ligand was observed when RCA₁₂₀ was passed over the array surface. Limited or no binding was observed for the non-cognate ligands. SPR imaging of an array of 40 sialylated and unsialylated glycans established the binding preference of hSiglec7 for α2-8-linked disialic acid structures over α2-6-sialyl-LacNAcs, which in turn were recognized and bound with greater affinity than α2-3-sialyl-LacNAcs. Affinity binding data could be obtained with as little as 10–20 μg of lectin per experiment. The SPR imaging technique was also able to establish selective binding to the preferred glycan ligand when analyzing crude culture supernatant containing 10–20 μg of recombinant hSiglec7-Fc. Our results show that SPR imaging provides results that are in agreement with those obtained from fluorescence based carbohydrate arrays but with the added advantage of label-free analysis.     

Sensitivity enhancement of surface plasmon resonance biosensing of small molecules

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor formats using gold nanoparticle or protein signal amplification for the sensitive assay of small molecules were developed using progesterone as a model compound. Progesterone was immobilized to a dextran surface in the Biacore biosensor through in situ covalent immobilization using an oligoethylene glycol linker attached to the 4 position of the steroid. This surface produced stable antibody binding for in excess of 1100 assay cycles. Using this surface, assays were developed for progesterone using 10- and 20-nm gold-streptavidin labels attached to biotinylated monoclonal antibody in both label prebinding and sequential binding formats. Prelabeling formats gave no signal enhancement but produced assays with limits of detection of 143 pg/ml, compared with approximately 1 ng/ml in previous studies. Sequential binding formats gave signal enhancements of 2.2-fold over the monoclonal antibody and a limit of detection of 23.1 pg/ml. It was found that secondary antibody labeling gave 8.1-fold signal enhancements and a limit of detection of 20.1 pg/ml, whereas use of secondary antibody-25 nm gold complexes provided more signal enhancement (13-fold) and a further improvement in limit of detection of 8.6 pg/ml.     

Advances in surface plasmon resonance biosensor analysis

The number and diversity of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor applications continue to increase. Evolutions in instrument and sensor chip technology, experimental methodology, and data analysis are making it possible to examine a wider variety of biomolecular interactions in greater mechanistic detail. SPR biosensors are poised to make a significant impact in basic research and pharmaceutical discovery.     

Evaluation of alpha-D-mannopyranoside glycolipid micelles-lectin interactions by surface plasmon resonance method

It is established that achieving higher binding affinities in carbohydrate-protein interactions requires multivalent presentations of the sugar ligands at the receptor binding site. Several inhibition, calorimetric, mass balance, and other studies have reiterated the beneficial effects of molecular level clustering of the sugar ligands for tight binding to the receptors. We have undertaken an effort to study the multivalent effects involving larger assemblies, represented by micelles, and their lectin interactions. The micelles were constituted with monomer bearing one- or two-sugar moieties at the monomolecular level and with varying the distances between the sugar moieties. Micellar aggregation studies and dynamic light scattering (DLS) studies afforded details of the aggregation numbers and the hydrodynamic diameters of various glycolipid (GL) micelles. The GL micelles were used as analytes of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) experiments on a lectin concanavalin A (Con A)-immobilized surface. SPR studies of the micelle-lectin interactions demonstrate that the ligand-receptor binding can be fit into the bivalent analyte model of interaction. Furthermore, micelles formed from two-sugar containing GLs are able to elicit favorable kinetic association rate constants in comparison to the micelles constituted with one-sugar containing GLs. The kinetic rate constants across the micelles and the effect of the sugar valencies in the GLs are discussed.     

Antibody-antigen interactions measured by surface plasmon resonance: global fitting of numerical integration algorithms

The interactions between adenylate kinase (AK) and a monoclonal antibody against AK (McAb3D3) were examined by means of optical biosensor technology, and the sensograms were fitted to four models using numerical integration algorithms. The interaction of a solution of McAb3D3 with immobilized AK follows a double exponential function and the data fitted well to an inhomogeneous ligand model. The interaction of a solution AK with immobilized McAb3D3 follows a single exponential function and the data fitted well to a pseudo-first order reaction model. The true association constants of AK binding to McAb3D3 in solution were obtained from competition BIAcore measurements. The difference in results obtained with solid-phase BIAcore and competition BIAcore may be due to rebinding of the dissociated analyte to the immobilized surface. The results obtained with BIAcore are compared to those obtained by ELISA methods. We suggest that the best method for analysis of BIAcore data is direct, global fitting of sensorgrams to numerical integration algorithms corresponding to the different possible models for binding.