Effect of integration of a GFP reporter gene on fitness of Ralstonia eutropha during growth with 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid

Green fluorescent proteins (GFPs) are frequently used as marker and reporter systems to assess the fate and activity of microbial strains with the ability to degrade xenobiotic compounds. To evaluate the potential of this tool for tracking herbicide-degrading microorganisms in the environment a promoterless gfp was linked to the tfd C promoter, which is activated during degradation of the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), and integrated into the chromosome of the 2,4-D-degrading strain Ralstonia eutropha JMP 134. The effects of the inserted gfp gene on the kinetics of 2,4-D degradation by R. eutropha in batch and chemostat culture were compared to those of the wild-type strain. In batch culture with 2,4-D as the only carbon and energy source the maximum specific growth rate of the gfp-marked strain did not differ significantly from the wild type. However, compared to the wild type, the 2,4-D steady-state concentration in 2,4-D-limited chemostat cultures of the gfp-marked strain was higher at all dilution rates tested. The reduced competitiveness of the gfp-marked strain at low substrate concentrations was confirmed in a competition experiment for 2,4-D in continuous culture at a dilution rate of 0.075 h-1. Reproducibly, the gfp-marked strain was displaced by the wild-type strain. The study clearly demonstrates that fitness of constructs cannot be assessed by measuring micro max with selected substrates in batch cultures only but that a thorough kinetic analysis is needed, which also considers slow, carbon-limited growth conditions as they occur in the environment.     

Response of Ralstonia eutropha JMP 134 to long-term exposure to toxic substrates in nutristat cultivation as indicated by on-line fluorescence measurements

Ralstonia eutropha JMP 134 was continuously grown on phenol and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate under nutristatic conditions at elevated stationary concentrations of 90-650 mg phenol/l and 25-100 mg 2,4-D/l, respectively, in order to study the response of the bacterial population to long-term exposure to these potentially toxic substrates. The course of the cells' response over time was observed by determining distinctive growth parameters and by the on-line measurement of fluorescence spectra of intracellular and extracellular fluorophores. The latter were monitored using a modified fluorescence spectrophotometer. The results of the nutristat experiments indicate that the adaptation of the culture to long-term exposure to phenol and 2,4-D exhibited dynamic characteristics of the growth pattern determined by the individual substrates and their concentration, including enforced and reduced levels of substrate conversion. This growth pattern is interpreted as an expression of superimposing cellular events in order to withstand unfavorable environmental conditions. Finally, the growth rate attained retarded levels under stationary conditions, slowing down to almost zero for example in the case of about 100 mg 2,4-D/l. The growth rate profile within the various phases of adaptation was well reflected by the fluorescence signals. The NAD(P)H fluorescence was almost exclusively emitted by the cellular pool of NADPH and behaved inversely to the growth rate. A similar relationship was obtained for the cellular fluorescence of a flavin-containing compound. Sharply reduced growth was additionally accompanied by a rapid rise of the background fluorescence. These data indicate that fluorescence-derived signals provide a useful reflection of cellular events in inhibited growth situations.     

Adaptation of Delftia acidovorans for degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate in a microfluidic porous medium

Delftia acidovorans MC1071 can productively degrade R-2-(2,4-dichlorophenoxy)propionate (R-2,4-DP) but not 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate (2,4-D) herbicides. This work demonstrates adaptation of MC1071 to degrade 2,4-D in a model two-dimensional porous medium (referred to here as a micromodel). Adaptation for 2,4-D degradation in the 2 cm-long micromodel occurred within 35 days of exposure to 2,4-D, as documented by substrate removal. The amount of 2,4-D degradation in the adapted cultures in two replicate micromodels (~10 and 20 % over 142 days) was higher than a theoretical maximum (4 %) predicted using published numerical simulation methods, assuming instantaneous biodegradation and a transverse dispersion coefficient obtained for the same pore structure without biomass present. This suggests that the presence of biomass enhances substrate mixing. Additional evidence for adaptation was provided by operation without R-2,4-DP, where degradation of 2,4-D slowly decreased over 20 days, but was restored almost immediately when R-2,4-DP was again provided. Compared to suspended growth systems, the micromodel system retained the ability to degrade 2,4-D longer in the absence of R-2,4-DP, suggesting slower responses and greater resilience to fluctuations in substrates might be expected in the soil environment than in a chemostat.     

Growth Rates of a Pseudomonad on 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic Acid and 2,4-Dichlorophenol

The growth of a pseudomonad on 2,4-D (2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid) and 2,4-DCP (2,4-dichlorophenol) was studied in batch and continuous culture. The optimum growth rate using 2,4-D was 0.14/h at 25 C in a pH range from 6.2 to 6.9. Highest specific growth rate using 2,4-DCP was 0.12/h at 25 C in a pH range from 7.1 to 7.8. Growth was strongly inhibited by 2,4-DCP above a concentration of 25 mg/liter whereas no appreciable inhibition was observed with 2,4-D at concentrations up to 2,000 mg per liter. Growth on 2,4-DCP was described by Monod kinetics at subinhibitory concentrations but the inhibition by 2,4-DCP exhibited an unusual linear response to substrate concentration, and did not fit a model based on noncompetitive inhibition. The lag phase of batch cultures was found to depend on both 2,4-DCP concentration and prior adaptation of the inoculum. A study such as this on the kinetics of growth on related substrates may be useful as a method of finding the rate-limiting step in a metabolic sequence.     

Measurement of Growth at Very Low Rates ((mu) >= 0), an Approach To Study the Energy Requirement for the Survival of Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134

Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134 was grown in a recycling-mode fermenter with 100% biomass retention on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), phenol, and fructose. The growth pattern obtained given a constant supply of substrates exhibited three phases of linear growth on all three substrates. The transition from phase 1 to phase 2, considered to correspond to the onset of stringent (growth) control as indicated by a significant increase in guanosine 5(prm1)-bisphosphate 3(prm1)-bisphosphate (ppGpp), took place at 0.016 h(sup-1) with 2,4-D and at about 0.02 h(sup-1) with phenol and fructose. In the final phase, phase 4, which was achieved after the growth rate on the respective substrates fell below 0.003 to 0.001 h(sup-1), a constant level of biomass was obtained irrespective of further feeding of substrate at the same rate. The yield coefficients decreased by 70 to 80% from phase 1 to phase 3 and were 0 in phase 4. The stationary substrate concentrations s(infmin) in phase 4, calculated from the kinetic constants of the strain, were 1.23, 0.34, and 0.23 (mu)M for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively. These figures characterize the minimum stationary substrate concentrations required in a dynamic system to keep A. eutrophus alive. This is caused by a substrate flux which enables growth at a rate >=0 due to the provision of energy to an extent at least satisfying maintenance requirements. According to the constant feed rates of the substrates and the final and stable biomass concentrations, this maintenance energy amounts to 14.4, 4.0, and 2.4 (mu)mol of ATP (middot) mg of dry mass(sup-1) h(sup-1) for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively, after correction for the fraction of living cells. The increased energy expenditure in the case of 2,4-D is discussed with respect to uncoupling.     

Measurement of Growth at Very Low Rates ((mu) >= 0), an Approach To Study the Energy Requirement for the Survival of Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134

Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134 was grown in a recycling-mode fermenter with 100% biomass retention on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), phenol, and fructose. The growth pattern obtained given a constant supply of substrates exhibited three phases of linear growth on all three substrates. The transition from phase 1 to phase 2, considered to correspond to the onset of stringent (growth) control as indicated by a significant increase in guanosine 5(prm1)-bisphosphate 3(prm1)-bisphosphate (ppGpp), took place at 0.016 h(sup-1) with 2,4-D and at about 0.02 h(sup-1) with phenol and fructose. In the final phase, phase 4, which was achieved after the growth rate on the respective substrates fell below 0.003 to 0.001 h(sup-1), a constant level of biomass was obtained irrespective of further feeding of substrate at the same rate. The yield coefficients decreased by 70 to 80% from phase 1 to phase 3 and were 0 in phase 4. The stationary substrate concentrations s(infmin) in phase 4, calculated from the kinetic constants of the strain, were 1.23, 0.34, and 0.23 (mu)M for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively. These figures characterize the minimum stationary substrate concentrations required in a dynamic system to keep A. eutrophus alive. This is caused by a substrate flux which enables growth at a rate >=0 due to the provision of energy to an extent at least satisfying maintenance requirements. According to the constant feed rates of the substrates and the final and stable biomass concentrations, this maintenance energy amounts to 14.4, 4.0, and 2.4 (mu)mol of ATP (middot) mg of dry mass(sup-1) h(sup-1) for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively, after correction for the fraction of living cells. The increased energy expenditure in the case of 2,4-D is discussed with respect to uncoupling.     

Methodologies and special considerations for environmental risk analysis of genetically modified aquatic biocontrol organisms

Genetic biocontrol of invasive aquatic species proposes to introduce, for control purposes, a genetically modified (GM) version of an invasive fish species to a targeted aquatic environment. Safe deployment and long term use of such technologies will depend on identifying and managing possible unintended effects to the natural environment. Environmental risk analysis (ERA) is a method for identifying the likelihood and consequences of unintended impacts, and for developing risk management strategies. For the unique situation of genetically modified biocontrol organisms (GMBOs), we review the latest thinking in ERA methodologies for GM fish and explore how terminology and assumptions from ERAs of traditional, non-modified biocontrol organisms and GM fish will need to be recast in ERAs of GMBOs. We also outline some special considerations that an ERA of a GMBOs will have to contend with: non-intuitive potential hazards; uncertainty introduced by extrapolating from domestic systems to natural ecosystems; redundancy in risk management options; and challenges of stakeholder engagement related to new technologies.     

Activated sludge treatment of a xenobiotic with or without a biogenic substrate during start-up and shocks

Lab-scale continuous flow activated sludge systems that were acclimated to 2,4-dichlorphenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) under sole 2,4-D influent and without sludge wastage, were able to maintain successful 2,4-D treatment when both 2,4-D and a biogenic substrate were fed and the systems operated with finite mean cell residence times (theta(c)). When the systems were fed dual 2,4-D and biogenic substrates and operated with finite theta(c) from the start, treatment of 2,4-D fluctuated noticeably long after acclimation. At the reintroduction of 2,4-D after its absence from the influent for a period of time (2,4-D shock), the systems under both the sole and dual substrate conditions suffered similar treatment losses; the extent of treatment losses was related to the length of 2,4-D absence time. When shocked, systems with sole 2,4-D influent had a slight advantage over dual substrates by showing a faster recovery from shocks with the help of re-acclimation.     

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841 Adapts to 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic Acid with “Auxin-Like” Morphological Changes,Cell Envelope Remodeling and Upregulation of Central Metabolic Pathways

There is a growing need to characterize the effects of environmental stressors at the molecular level on model organisms with the ever increasing number and variety of anthropogenic chemical pollutants. The herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), as one of the most widely applied pesticides in the world, is one such example. This herbicide is known to have non-targeted undesirable effects on humans, animals and soil microbes, but specific molecular targets at sublethal levels are unknown. In this study, we have used Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841 (Rlv) as a nitrogen fixing, beneficial model soil organism to characterize the effects of 2,4-D. Using metabolomics and advanced microscopy we determined specific target pathways in the Rlv metabolic network and consequent changes to its phenotype, surface ultrastructure, and physical properties during sublethal 2,4-D exposure. Auxin and 2,4-D, its structural analogue, showed common morphological changes in vitro which were similar to bacteroids isolated from plant nodules, implying that these changes are related to bacteroid differentiation required for nitrogen fixation. Rlv showed remarkable adaptation capabilities in response to the herbicide, with changes to integral pathways of cellular metabolism and the potential to assimilate 2,4-D with consequent changes to its physical and structural properties. This study identifies biomarkers of 2,4-D in Rlv and offers valuable insights into the mode-of-action of 2,4-D in soil bacteria.     

Genetic Divergence and Fitness Convergence under Uniform Selection in Experimental Populations of Bacteria

Replicate populations of bacteria were propagated for 1000 generations in the laboratory. The growth substrate was periodically renewed, so that during most generations (cell doublings) it was not limiting. The final clones demonstrated about a 40% fitness increase when competed against their common ancestor. This increase was uniform both among and within populations despite extensive differentiation in correlated traits: cell size, resistance to starvation and dry mass of culture. It is suggested that genetic diversity developed because selection promoted any changes directing cell activity toward a higher maximum growth rate. Evolution of this trait halted at a similar level when some basic constraints on bacterial metabolism were met. The selective values of emerging mutations must have depended on the genetic background. They would be beneficial early in evolution but ineffective near the limit of adaptation. This hypothesis was tested for one mutation that affected both fitness and colony morphology. In some clones it was the first adaptive mutation and provided a third of the total fitness increase, but it was not assimilated by the clones that reached the adaptive ceiling in some other way. Near the limit of adaptation, epistasis levels off the fitnesses of genetically variable clones.     

Dynamics of biodegradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate in the presence of glucose

It has been observed experimentally that the biodegradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate (2,4-D) is inhibited by the presence of glucose. However, this effect is masked by the fact that larger concentrations of active biomass are produced when glucose is available. The implication of such a "mixed" growth in a continuous flow system is that much higher dilution rates can be applied for an efficient chlorinated-organic removal when other conventional substrates are present. The mean cell residence time is reduced and the area of stability of the process is extended into higher dilution rates, as well as into higher influent concentrations. Finally, the presence of the mixed substrate changes dramatically the "washout" conditions for both substrates. All these facts point out that the biodegradation of chlorinated organics is more efficient in a mixed substrate environment.     

Physiological and toxicological characterization of an engineered whole-cell biosensor

Bioluminescence-based bacterial biosensors are often reported as reliable and efficient tools for risk assessment and environmental monitoring. However, there are few data comparing the metabolism of genetically engineered strains to the corresponding wild type. A pollutant-degrading bacterium capable of mineralising 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), Burkholderia sp. strain RASC c2, was genetically engineered to produce light constitutively and tested for assessing the main causes of biodegradation constraint affected by growth rates, toxicity, bioavailability and metal speciation in complex environments. This research focuses on such aspects by characterizing two pollutant-degrading isolates, the wild type and the genetically engineered biosensor (lux-marked). Degradation and growth rates of both isolates were assessed with different concentrations of 2,4-D as the sole carbon source. Kinetic rates were affected by initial concentration of substrate and isolates showed distinct growth rates at different 2,4-D concentrations. Toxic effects of zinc and copper were also comparatively assessed using a dehydrogenase assay and light output. The isolates were sensitive to both metals and at similar EC(50) values. Therefore, bioluminescence response of the lux-marked isolate accurately reflected the toxic response of the parental organism towards zinc and copper, making it an ideal test-organism for assessing toxicity in the context of pollutant mineralization.     

Effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on biodegradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid.

Batch experiments were conducted to examine the effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on the degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) by an enrichment culture of 2,4-D-utilizing bacteria. A modified Monod equation was found to describe the relationship between the specific growth rate and the concentrations of both the organic substrate and dissolved oxygen. Values for the maximum specific growth rate, yield, and Monod coefficient for growth on 2,4-D were 0.09 h-1, 0.14 g/g, and 0.6 mg/liter, respectively. The half-saturation constant for dissolved oxygen was estimated to be 1.2 mg/liter. These results suggest that dissolved oxygen concentrations below 1 mg/liter may be rate limiting for the biodegradation of chlorinated aromatic compounds such as 2,4-D, which have a requirement for molecular oxygen as a cosubstrate for metabolism.     

Effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on biodegradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid

Batch experiments were conducted to examine the effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on the degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) by an enrichment culture of 2,4-D-utilizing bacteria. A modified Monod equation was found to describe the relationship between the specific growth rate and the concentrations of both the organic substrate and dissolved oxygen. Values for the maximum specific growth rate, yield, and Monod coefficient for growth on 2,4-D were 0.09 h-1, 0.14 g/g, and 0.6 mg/liter, respectively. The half-saturation constant for dissolved oxygen was estimated to be 1.2 mg/liter. These results suggest that dissolved oxygen concentrations below 1 mg/liter may be rate limiting for the biodegradation of chlorinated aromatic compounds such as 2,4-D, which have a requirement for molecular oxygen as a cosubstrate for metabolism.     

The ideal free distribution and bacterial growth on two substrates

A population dynamical model describing growth of bacteria on two substrates is analyzed. The model assumes that bacteria choose substrates in order to maximize their per capita population growth rate. For batch bacterial growth, the model predicts that as the concentration of the preferred substrate decreases there will be a time at which both substrates provide bacteria with the same fitness and both substrates will be used simultaneously thereafter. Preferences for either substrate are computed as a function of substrate concentrations. The predicted time of switching is calculated for some experimental data given in the literature and it is shown that the fit between predicted and observed values is good. For bacterial growth in the chemostat, the model predicts that at low dilution rates bacteria should feed on both substrates while at higher dilution rates bacteria should feed on the preferred substrate only. Adaptive use of substrates permits bacteria to survive in the chemostat at higher dilution rates when compared with non-adaptive bacteria.     

The adaptive potential of genetically engineered organisms in nature

Most genetically engineered organisms are unlikely to pose any threat to the environment because they are already highly selected for survival under restricted conditions. Engineering for new traits in natural or semi-natural populations, however, may entail greater risks. Genetic novelty, i.e. mutation, is an important component of the evolutionary process; a small but significant proportion of natural mutations lead to improved fitness and increased competitiveness. The artificial insertion of a new trait may produce a similar effect, setting an organism on a new and unpredictable evolutionary track. The current challenge is to attain the capacity to identify the small proportion of genetically engineered organisms in which such events might occur.     

Alternative substrates of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate/α-ketoglutarate dioxygenase

2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetate/α-ketoglutarate dioxygenase (TfdA), the first enzyme in the catabolic pathway for the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), oxidizes α-ketoglutarate (α-kG) to CO₂ and succinate while hydroxylating 2,4-D to yield an unstable hemiacetal that decomposes into 2,4-dichlorophenol and glyoxylate. In an effort to extend the potential biotechnological utility of this enzyme, a variety of non-phenoxyacetate compounds were examined as potential substrates. 2-Naphthoxyacetic acid was the best alternative substrate tested, followed by benzofuran-2-carboxylic acid, 2,4-dichlorocinnamic acid, 2-chlorocinnamic acid, 1-naphthoxyacetic acid, and 4-chlorocinnamic acid. TfdA appeared to oxidize the olefin bond of the cinnamic acids and benzofuran-2-carboxylate to form the corresponding epoxides. Whole cells were observed to also catalyze a TfdA-dependent oxidation of 2,4-dichlorocinnamic acid. Based on the ability of TfdA to metabolize chlorinated cinnamic acids, we speculate that tfdA-like sequences present in 2,4-D non-degrading natural isolates may function in metabolism of substituted cinnamic acids. These results support the use of TfdA and related enzymes in the specific oxidation of non-phenoxyacetate substrates.     

NONADAPTIVE PROCESSES CAN CREATE THE APPEARANCE OF FACULTATIVE CHEATING IN MICROBES

Adaptations to social life may take the form of facultative cheating, in which organisms cooperate with genetically similar individuals but exploit others. Consistent with this possibility, many strains of social microbes like Myxococcus bacteria and Dictyostelium amoebae have equal fitness in single‐genotype social groups but outcompete other strains in mixed‐genotype groups. Here we show that these observations are also consistent with an alternative, nonadaptive scenario: kin selection‐mutation balance under local competition. Using simple mathematical models, we show that deleterious mutations that reduce competitiveness within social groups (growth rate, e.g.) without affecting group productivity can create fitness effects that are only expressed in the presence of other strains. In Myxococcus, mutations that delay sporulation may strongly reduce developmental competitiveness. Deleterious mutations are expected to accumulate when high levels of kin selection relatedness relax selection within groups. Interestingly, local resource competition can create nonzero “cost” and “benefit” terms in Hamilton's rule even in the absence of any cooperative trait. Our results show how deleterious mutations can play a significant role even in organisms with large populations and highlight the need to test evolutionary causes of social competition among microbes.