Maturation stress generation in poplar tension wood studied by synchrotron radiation microdiffraction

Tension wood is widespread in the organs of woody plants. During its formation, it generates a large tensile mechanical stress called maturation stress. Maturation stress performs essential biomechanical functions such as optimizing the mechanical resistance of the stem, performing adaptive movements, and ensuring the long-term stability of growing plants. Although various hypotheses have recently been proposed, the mechanism generating maturation stress is not yet fully understood. In order to discriminate between these hypotheses, we investigated structural changes in cellulose microfibrils along sequences of xylem cell differentiation in tension and normal wood of poplar (Populus deltoides × Populus trichocarpa 'I45-51'). Synchrotron radiation microdiffraction was used to measure the evolution of the angle and lattice spacing of crystalline cellulose associated with the deposition of successive cell wall layers. Profiles of normal and tension wood were very similar in early development stages corresponding to the formation of the S1 layer and the outer part of the S2 layer. Subsequent layers were found with a lower microfibril angle (MFA), corresponding to the inner part of the S2 layer of normal wood (MFA approximately 10°) and the G layer of tension wood (MFA approximately 0°). In tension wood only, this steep decrease in MFA occurred together with an increase in cellulose lattice spacing. The relative increase in lattice spacing was found close to the usual value of maturation strains. Analysis showed that this increase in lattice spacing is at least partly due to mechanical stress induced in cellulose microfibrils soon after their deposition, suggesting that the G layer directly generates and supports the tensile maturation stress in poplar tension wood.     

Tensile growth stress and lignin distribution in the cell walls of yellow poplar, Liriodendron tulipifera Linn.

Five specimens that contained a continuous gradient of wood, from normal to tension wood regions, were collected from an inclined yellow poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera), and the released strain of tensile growth stress was quantified. Ultraviolet (UV) microspectrophotometry was used to examine the relationship between lignin distribution in the cell wall and the intensity of tensile growth stress. The UV absorption of the secondary wall and the cell corner middle lamella decreased with increasing tensile released strain (i.e., tensile growth stress). The UV absorption in the compound middle lamella region remained virtually constant, irrespective of the tensile released strain. The absorption maximum (5_max) remained virtually constant in the secondary wall, the cell corner middle lamella, and the compound middle lamella region at 273-274, 277-278, and 275-278 nm respectively, irrespective of the tensile released strain. The ratios of the UV absorbance at 280 to 260 nm and 280 to 273 nm of the secondary wall decreased with increasing tensile released strain. The ratios in the cell corner and compound middle lamella region remained constant, irrespective of the tensile released strain. The lignin content of the secondary wall decreased, while the syringyl/guaiacyl ratio increased with increasing tensile released strain. Gelatinous fibers were not observed in the tension wood regions, but the secondary wall became gelatinous-layer-like, i.e., the lignin content and microfibrillar angle decreased and the cellulose content increased. A definite gelatinous layer seems to be important for generating greater tensile growth stress. It is concluded that a decrease in lignin and an increase in cellulose microfibrils parallel to the fiber axis in the secondary wall are necessary to produce large tensile growth stress.     

Maturation Stress Generation in Poplar Tension Wood Studied by Synchrotron Radiation Microdiffraction

Tension wood is widespread in the organs of woody plants. During its formation, it generates a large tensile mechanical stress, called maturation stress. Maturation stress performs essential biomechanical functions such as optimizing the mechanical resistance of the stem, performing adaptive movements, and ensuring long-term stability of growing plants. Although various hypotheses have recently been proposed, the mechanism generating maturation stress is not yet fully understood. In order to discriminate between these hypotheses, we investigated structural changes in cellulose microfibrils along sequences of xylem cell differentiation in tension and normal wood of poplar (Populus deltoides × Populus trichocarpa ‘I45-51’). Synchrotron radiation microdiffraction was used to measure the evolution of the angle and lattice spacing of crystalline cellulose associated with the deposition of successive cell wall layers. Profiles of normal and tension wood were very similar in early development stages corresponding to the formation of the S1 and the outer part of the S2 layer. The microfibril angle in the S2 layer was found to be lower in its inner part than in its outer part, especially in tension wood. In tension wood only, this decrease occurred together with an increase in cellulose lattice spacing, and this happened before the G-layer was visible. The relative increase in lattice spacing was found close to the usual value of maturation strains, strongly suggesting that microfibrils of this layer are put into tension and contribute to the generation of maturation stress.Wood cells are produced in the cambium at the periphery of the stem. The formation of the secondary wall occurs at the end of cell elongation by the deposition of successive layers made of cellulose microfibrils bounded by an amorphous polymeric matrix. Each layer has a specific chemical composition and is characterized by a particular orientation of the microfibrils relative to the cell axis (Mellerowicz and Sundberg, 2008). Microfibrils are made of crystalline cellulose and are by far the stiffest constituent of the cell wall. The microfibril angle (MFA) in each layer is determinant for cell wall architecture and wood mechanical properties.During the formation of wood cells, a mechanical stress of a large magnitude, known as “maturation stress” or “growth stress” (Archer, 1986; Fournier et al., 1991), occurs in the cell walls. This stress fulfills essential biomechanical functions for the tree. It compensates for the comparatively low compressive strength of wood and thus improves the stem resistance against bending loads. It also provides the tree with a motor system (Moulia et al., 2006), necessary to maintain the stem at a constant angle during growth (Alméras and Fournier, 2009) or to achieve adaptive reorientations. In angiosperms, a large tensile maturation stress is generated by a specialized tissue called “tension wood.” In poplar (Populus deltoides × Populus trichocarpa), as in most temperate tree species, tension wood fibers are characterized by the presence of a specific layer, called the G-layer (Jourez et al., 2001; Fang et al., 2008), where the matrix is almost devoid of lignin (Pilate et al., 2004) and the microfibrils are oriented parallel to the fiber axis (Fujita et al., 1974). This type of reaction cell is common in plant organs whose function involves the bending or contraction of axes, such as tendrils, twining vines (Bowling and Vaughn, 2009), or roots (Fisher, 2008).The mechanism at the origin of tensile maturation stress has been the subject of a lot of controversy and is still not fully understood. However, several recent publications have greatly improved our knowledge about the ultrastructure, chemical composition, molecular activity, mechanical state, and behavior of tension wood. Different models have been proposed and discussed to explain the origin of maturation stress (Boyd, 1972; Bamber, 1987, 2001; Okuyama et al., 1994, 1995; Yamamoto, 1998, 2004; Alméras et al., 2005, 2006; Bowling and Vaughn, 2008; Goswami et al., 2008; Mellerowicz et al., 2008). The specific organization of the G-layer suggests a tensile force induced in the microfibrils during the maturation process. Different hypotheses have been proposed to explain this mechanism, such as the contraction of amorphous zones within the cellulose microfibrils (Yamamoto, 2004), the action of xyloglucans during the formation of microfibril aggregates (Nishikubo et al., 2007; Mellerowicz et al., 2008), and the effect of changes in moisture content stimulated by pectin-like substances (Bowling and Vaughn, 2008). A recent work (Goswami et al., 2008) argued an alternative model, initially proposed by Münch (1938), which proposed that the maturation stress originates in the swelling of the G-layer during cell maturation and is transmitted to the adjacent secondary layers, where the larger MFAs allow an efficient conversion of lateral stress into axial tensile stress. Although the proposed mechanism is not consistent with the known hygroscopic behavior of tension wood, which shrinks when it dries and not when it takes up water (Clair and Thibaut, 2001; Fang et al., 2007; Clair et al., 2008), this hypothesis focused attention on the possible role of cell wall layers other than the G-layer. As a matter of fact, many types of wood fibers lacking a G-layer are known to produce axial tensile stress, such as normal wood of angiosperms and conifers (Archer, 1986) and the tension wood of many tropical species (Onaka, 1949; Clair et al., 2006b; Ruelle et al., 2007), so that mechanisms strictly based on an action of the G-layer cannot provide a general explanation for the origin of tensile maturation stress in wood.In order to further understanding, direct observations of the mechanical state of the different cell wall layers and their evolution during the formation of the tension wood fibers are needed. X-ray diffraction can be used to investigate the orientation of microfibrils (Cave, 1966, 1997a, 1997b; Peura et al., 2007, 2008a, 2008b) and the lattice spacing of crystalline cellulose. The axial lattice spacing d₀₀₄ is the distance between successive monomers along a cellulose microfibril and reflects its state of mechanical stress (Clair et al., 2006a; Peura et al., 2007). If cellulose microfibrils indeed support a tensile stress, they should be found in an extended state of deformation. Under this assumption, the progressive development of maturation stress during the cell wall formation should be accompanied by an increase in cellulose lattice spacing. Synchrotron radiation allows a reduction in the size of the x-ray beam to some micrometers while retaining a strong signal, whereby diffraction analysis can be performed at a very local scale (Riekel, 2000). This technique has been used to study sequences of wood cell development (Hori et al., 2000; Müller et al., 2002). In this study, we report an experiment where a microbeam was used to analyze the structural changes of cellulose in the cell wall layers of tension wood and normal wood fibers along the sequence of xylem cell differentiation extending from the cambium to mature wood (Fig. 1). The experiment was designed to make this measurement in planta, in order to minimize sources of mechanical disturbance and be as close as possible to the native mechanical state (Clair et al., 2006a). The 200 and 004 diffraction patterns of cellulose were analyzed to investigate the process of maturation stress generation in tension wood.Open in a separate windowFigure 1.Schematic of the experimental setup, showing the x-ray beam passing perpendicular to the longitudinal-radial plane of wood and the contribution of the 004 and 200 crystal planes to the diffraction pattern recorded by the camera. [See online article for color version of this figure.]     

Homogeneous suspensions of individualized microfibrils from TEMPO-catalyzed oxidation of native cellulose

Never-dried native celluloses (bleached sulfite wood pulp, cotton, tunicin, and bacterial cellulose) were disintegrated into individual microfibrils after oxidation mediated by the 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) radical followed by a homogenizing mechanical treatment. When oxidized with 3.6 mmol of NaClO per gram of cellulose, almost the totality of sulfite wood pulp and cotton were readily disintegrated into long individual microfibrils by a treatment with a Waring Blendor, yielding transparent and highly viscous suspensions. When observed by transmission electron microscopy, the wood pulp and cotton microfibrils exhibited a regular width of 3-5 nm. Tunicin and bacterial cellulose could be disintegrated by sonication. A bulk degree of oxidation of about 0.2 per one anhydroglucose unit of cellulose was necessary for a smooth disintegration of sulfite wood pulp, whereas only small amounts of independent microfibrils were obtained at lower oxidation levels. This limiting degree of oxidation decreased in the following order: sulfite wood pulp > cotton > bacterial cellulose, tunicin.     

Lattice images from ultrathin sections of cellulose microfibrils in the cell wall of Valonia macrophysa Kütz.

The crystalline ultrastructure and orientation of cellulose microfibrils in the cell wall of Valonia macrophysa were investigated by means of high-resolution electron microscopy of ultrathin (approx. 28 nm) sections. With careful selection of imaging conditions, ultrastructural aspects of the cell wall that had remained unresolved in previous studies were worked out by direct imaging of crystal lattice of cellulose microfibrils. It was confirmed that each microfibril is a single crystal having a lateral dimension of 20·20 nm², because lattice images of 0.39 nm resolution were clearly recorded with no major disruption in the whole area of the cross section of the microfibril. There was no evidence for the existence of 3.5-nm elementary fibrils which have been considered to be basic crystallographic and morphological units of cellulose in general. It was also confirmed that the axial directions (crystallographic fiber direction) of adjacent microfibrils in each single lamella of the cell wall are opposite to each other.     

Electron diffraction from the primary wall of cotton fibers

Summary Electron diffraction patterns have been obtained from selected areas of disencrusted microfibrils isolated from the primary cell wall of cotton fibers. The resultant fiber diagram has the same meridional repeat distance as a corresponding pattern of secondary wall microfibrils but differs markedly in the equatorial reflections. The primary wall diagram displays only two strong equatorial reflections centered at 0.570 nm and 0.416 nm. The similarity of these spacings with those of cellulose IV suggests that the crystalline structure of the primary wall cellulose is similar to that of cellulose IV_I and is best explained in term of native cellulose I crystals having good longitudinal coherence (i.e., coherence along the length of the microfibrils) but with poor lateral organization of the network of inter chain hydrogen bonds. Similar results were also obtained for other primary wall specimens.     

Gene expression in Eucalyptus branch wood with marked variation in cellulose microfibril orientation and lacking G-layers

In response to gravitational stresses, angiosperm trees form tension wood in the upper sides of branches and leaning stems in which cellulose content is higher, microfibrils are typically aligned closely with the fibre axis and the fibres often have a thick inner gelatinous cell wall layer (G-layer). Gene expression was studied in Eucalyptus nitens branches oriented at 45 degrees using microarrays containing 4900 xylem cDNAs, and wood fibre characteristics revealed by X-ray diffraction, chemical and histochemical methods. Xylem fibres in tension wood (upper branch) had a low microfibril angle, contained few fibres with G-layers and had higher cellulose and decreased Klason lignin compared with lower branch wood. Expression of two closely related fasciclin-like arabinogalactan proteins and a beta-tubulin was inversely correlated with microfibril angle in upper and lower xylem from branches. Structural and chemical modifications throughout the secondary cell walls of fibres sufficient to resist tension forces in branches can occur in the absence of G-layer enriched fibres and some important genes involved in responses to gravitational stress in eucalypt xylem are identified.     

Immunocytochemical characterization of tension wood: Gelatinous fibers contain more than just cellulose

Gelatinous fibers (G-fibers) are the active component of tension wood. G-fibers are unlike traditional fiber cells in that they possess a thick, nonlignified gelatinous layer (G-layer) internal to the normal secondary cell wall layers. For the past several decades, the G-layer has generally been presumed to be composed nearly entirely of crystalline cellulose, although several reports have appeared that disagreed with this hypothesis. In this report, immunocytochemical techniques were used to investigate the polysaccharide composition of G-fibers in sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua; Hamamelidaceae) and hackberry (Celtis occidentalis; Ulmaceae) tension wood. Surprisingly, a number of antibodies that recognize arabinogalactan proteins and RG I-type pectin molecules bound to the G-layer. Because AGPs and pectic mucilages are found in other plant tissues where swelling reactions occur, we propose that these polymers may be the source of the contractile forces that act on the cellulose microfibrils to provide the tension force necessary to bend the tree trunk.     

The diversity of lectin-detectable sugar residues on root hair tips of selected legumes correlates with the diversity of their host ranges for rhizobia

Summary Glomerulocyte cellulosic bundles ofPolyzoa vesiculiphora were investigated by microdiffraction and high-resolution electron microscopy. In each bundle, hundreds of cellulose microfibrils, having a rectangular cross-sectional shape, are packed regularly with their 0.6 nm lattice planes parallel to each other. Lattice images reveal that the 0.6 nm plane is parallel to the longer edge of the cross section which is similar to the lattice organization of cellulose with a squarish cross section inValonia spp. More interestingly, all the microfibrils in a bundle have the same directionality of crystallographic c-axis, which suggests that the biosynthesis of the microfibrils within particular bundle occurs unidirectionally.     

Homofusion of Golgi secretory vesicles in flax phloem fibers during formation of the gelatinous secondary cell wall

The gelatinous type of secondary cell wall is present in tension wood and in phloem fibers of many plants. It is characterized by the absence of xylan and lignin, a high cellulose content and axially orientated microfibrils in the huge S2 layer. In flax phloem fiber, the major non-cellulosic component of such cell walls is tissue-specific galactan, which is tightly bound to cellulose. Ultrastructural analysis of flax fiber revealed that initiation of gelatinous secondary cell wall formation was accompanied by the accumulation of specific Golgi vesicles, which had a characteristic bicolor (dark-light) appearance and were easily distinguishable from vesicles made in different tissues and during the other stages of fiber development. Many of the bicolor vesicles appeared to fuse with each other, forming large vacuoles. The largest observed was 4 mum in diameter. Bicolor vesicles and vacuoles fused with the plasma membrane and spread their content in a characteristic "syringe-like" manner, covering a significant area of periplasm and forming "dark" stripes on the inner wall surface. Both Golgi derivatives and cell wall layers were labeled by LM5 antibody, indicating the presence of tissue- and stage-specific (1-->4)-beta-galactan. We suggest that this specific type of galactan secretion, which allows coverage of a large area of periplasm, is designed to increase the chance of the galactan meeting the cellulose microfibrils while they are still in the process of construction. The membrane fusion machinery of flax fiber must possess special components, which may be crucial for the formation of the gelatinous type cell wall.     

Hierarchical structure of juvenile hybrid aspen xylem revealed using X-ray scattering and microtomography

X-ray scattering and microtomography (μCT) are useful techniques to reveal the structure of wood at the nano- and micrometer scales. The nanostructure of xylem in greenhouse-grown 2.5- to 3.5-month-old Populus tremula L.?×?tremuloides Michx. trees was characterized using wide-angle X-ray scattering (WAXS), and the cellular structure was investigated using μCT. For comparison, the nanostructure of wood in 2-year-old silver birch, Norway spruce and Scots pine saplings was determined. Based on the μCT results, the lengths of fiber lumina of the hybrid aspen saplings were shorter than any previous results on the lengths of wood fibers. The mean microfibril angles of the hybrid aspen saplings were significantly lower (8°–14°) than those of the birch, spruce and pine saplings (27°–35°) implicating that cellulose microfibrils were oriented nearly parallel to the cell axis in the young hybrid aspen saplings. Hybrid aspen saplings were found to contain tension wood based on the histochemical analysis and μCT images. However, typical tension wood properties, i.e. larger crystallite width and higher crystallinity than in normal wood, were detected only in a few hybrid aspen samples, while in most of the hybrid aspen saplings, the crystallite widths (3.0?±?0.1?nm) and the crystallinities (30?±?5?%) corresponded to those of normal wood. The deformations of cellulose crystallites were determined using WAXS in situ upon dehydration of the never-dried samples. In all the species studied, the cellulose unit cell dimension decreased and disorder of cellulose chains increased parallel to the chains upon drying. Also, the transverse disorder of chains increased in birch, spruce and pine, while no changes were detected in this direction in hybrid aspen. The crystallite widths and drying deformation results might indicate that the gelatinous layer has not fully developed in the young hybrid aspen saplings.     

Lignification and tension wood

Hardwood trees are able to reorient their axes owing to tension wood differentiation. Tension wood is characterised by important ultrastructural modifications, such as the occurrence in a number of species, of an extra secondary wall layer, named gelatinous layer or G-layer, mainly constituted of cellulose microfibrils oriented nearly parallel to the fibre axis. This G-layer appears directly involved in the definition of tension wood mechanical properties. This review gathers the data available in the literature about lignification during tension wood formation. Potential roles for lignin in tension wood formation are inferred from biochemical, anatomical and mechanical studies, from the hypotheses proposed to describe tension wood function and from data coming from new research areas such as functional genomics.     

Ultra-structural organisation of cell wall polymers in normal and tension wood of aspen revealed by polarisation FTIR microspectroscopy

Polarisation Fourier transform infra-red (FTIR) microspectroscopy was used to characterize the organisation and orientation of wood polymers in normal wood and tension wood from hybrid aspen (Populus tremula × Populus tremuloides). It is shown that both xylan and lignin in normal wood are highly oriented in the fibre wall. Their orientation is parallel with the cellulose microfibrils and hence in the direction of the fibre axis. In tension wood a similar orientation of lignin was found. However, in tension wood absorption peaks normally assigned to xylan exhibited a 90° change in the orientation dependence of the vibrations as compared with normal wood. The molecular origin of these vibrations are not known, but they are abundant enough to mask the orientation dependence of the xylan signal from the S₂ layer in tension wood and could possibly come from other pentose sugars present in, or associated with, the gelatinous layer of tension wood fibres.     

Gibberellin-induced formation of tension wood in angiosperm trees

After gibberellin had been applied to the vertical stems of four species of angiosperm trees for approximately 2 months, we observed eccentric radial growth that was due to the enhanced growth rings on the sides of stems to which gibberellin had been applied. Moreover, the application of gibberellin resulted in the formation of wood fibers in which the thickness of inner layers of cell walls was enhanced. These thickened inner layers of cell walls were unlignified or only slightly lignified. In addition, cellulose microfibrils on the innermost surface of these thickened inner layers of cell walls were oriented parallel or nearly parallel to the longitudinal axis of the fibers. Such thickened inner layers of cell walls had features similar to those of gelatinous layers in the wood fibers of tension wood, which are referred to as gelatinous fibers. Our anatomical and histochemical investigations indicate that the application of gibberellin can induce the formation of tension wood on vertical stems of angiosperm trees in the absence of gravitational stimulus.     

Numerical study of how creep and progressive stiffening affect the growth stress formation in trees

It is not fully understood how much growth stresses affect the final quality of solid timber products in terms of, e.g. shape stability. It is, for example, difficult to predict the internal growth stress field within the tree stem. Growth stresses are progressively generated during the tree growth and they are highly influenced by climate, biologic and material-related factors. To increase the knowledge of the stress formation, a finite element model was created to study how the growth stresses develop during the tree growth. The model is an axisymmetric general plane strain model where material for all new annual rings is progressively added to the tree during the analysis. The material model used is based on the theory of small strains (where strains refer to the undeformed configuration which is good approximation for strains less than 4%) where so-called biological maturation strains (growth-related strains that form in the wood fibres during their maturation) are used as a driver for the stress generation. It is formulated as an incremental material model that takes into account elastic strain, maturation strain, viscoelastic strain and progressive stiffening of the wood material. The results clearly show how the growth stresses are progressively generated during the tree growth. The inner core becomes more and more compressed, whereas the outer sapwood is subjected to slightly increased tension. The parametric study shows that the growth stresses are highly influenced by the creep behaviour and evolution of parameters such as modulus of elasticity, micro-fibril angle and maturation strain.     

Variations in the fibre repeat between samples of cellulose I from different sources

A powder X-ray diffractometer was used to measure the fibre repeat in cellulose I with sufficient precision to detect variations between samples from different sources. The variations were correlated with the lateral dimensions of the crystallites and were attributed to different minimum-energy fibre repeats for chains in the interiors and on the surfaces of crystallites. Results were interpreted in terms of a model for internal mechanical stress in which the interior chains were under compression and the surface chains under tension to ensure identical fibre repeats for all chains. The model was used to extrapolate the fibre repeat to a value of 1.043 nm for a hypothetical, infinitely large crystal, and to 1.029 nm for a crystallite so narrow that all chains were exposed on surfaces.     

Xylem-specific and tension stress-responsive coexpression of KORRIGAN endoglucanase and three secondary wall-associated cellulose synthase genes in aspen trees

In nature, angiosperm trees develop tension wood on the upper side of their leaning trunks and drooping branches. Development of tension wood is one of the straightening mechanisms by which trees counteract leaning or bending of stem and resume upward growth. Tension wood is characterized by the development of a highly crystalline cellulose-enriched gelatinous layer next to the lumen of the tension wood fibers. Thus experimental induction of tension wood provides a system to understand the process of cellulose biosynthesis in trees. Since KORRIGAN endoglucanases (KOR) appear to play an important role in cellulose biosynthesis in Arabidopsis, we cloned PtrKOR, a full-length KOR cDNA from aspen xylem. Using RT-PCR, in situ hybridization, and tissue-print assays, we show that PtrKOR gene expression is significantly elevated on the upper side of the bent aspen stem in response to tension stress while KOR expression is significantly suppressed on the opposite side experiencing compression stress. Moreover, three previously reported aspen cellulose synthase genes, namely, PtrCesA1, PtrCesA2, and PtrCesA3 that are closely associated with secondary cell wall development in the xylem cells exhibited similar tension stress-responsive behavior. Our results suggest that coexpression of these four proteins is important for the biosynthesis of highly crystalline cellulose typically present in tension wood fibers. Their simultaneous genetic manipulation may lead to industrially relevant improvement of cellulose in transgenic crops and trees.Suchita Bhandari and Takeshi Fujino contributed equally to this research.     

Ultrafine cellulose fibers produced by Asaia bogorensis, an acetic acid bacterium

The ability to synthesize cellulose by Asaia bogorensis, a member of the acetic acid bacteria, was studied in two substrains, AJ and JCM. Although both strains have identical 16S rDNA sequence, only the AJ strain formed a solid pellicle at the air-liquid interface in static culture medium, and we analyzed this pellicle using a variety of techniques. In the presence of cellulase, glucose and cellobiose were released from the pellicle suggesting that it is made of cellulose. Field emission electron microscopy allowed the visualization of a 3D knitted structure with ultrafine microfibrils (approximately 5-20 nm in width) in cellulose from A. bogorensis compared with the 40-100 nm wide microfibrils observed in cellulose isolated from Gluconacetobacter xylinus, suggesting differences in the mechanism of cellulose biosynthesis or organization of cellulose synthesizing sites in these two related bacterial species. Identifying these differences will lead to a better understanding of cellulose biosynthesis in bacteria.