Discrepancies between flow cytometric and cytogenetic studies in the detection of aneuploidy in human solid tumors

Parallel flow cytometric (FCM) cell DNA studies and cytogenetic studies were performed on clinical samples from twenty human solid tumors of various types and on cell lines established in tissue culture from three of these tumors. Six of twenty clinical samples (30%) showed concordance between flow cytometry and cytogenetics with respect to the presence or absence of aneuploidy. Among the fourteen cases with discrepancies between the two methods, 8 (40% of all cases) showed hypodiploidy by cytogenetics and had diploid DNA histograms. Three cases (15%) had prominent discrete peaks in the triploid to tetraploid region by cytogenetics but had only barely discernible corresponding peaks in the DNA histogram. In two cases (10%) cytogenetic studies revealed diffuse aneuploidy. Cytogenetic studies demonstrated near-tetraploidy in three samples, but only one of these was detected by FCM; all three cases exhibited other numerical chromosomal abnormalities. In one case aneuploidy was demonstrated by FCM and not by cytogenetics. Among the tumor cell lines established in culture, the DNA Index was often higher than the cytogenetic index. Overall, 13/20 or 65% of patients with solid tumors in this study had numerical chromosomal abnormalities that were not detected by flow cytometry. Eleven of these patients had distant metastases at the time of tumor sampling, and nine of these died of their disease within 1-11 months of the time of study.     

Proliferative characteristics of primary and metastatic human solid tumors by DNA flow cytometry

The percentage of cells in S-phase (S-index) was calculated from DNA histograms of 453 primary and metastatic human solid tumors (predominantly bladder, breast, colorectal, renal, prostate, ovarian and lung carcinomas, melanomas, and sarcomas). S-indices varied widely among both primary and metastatic tumors (1-48%); there was no significant difference in S-indices between primary and metastatic tumors. The S-indices for aneuploid tumors were significantly higher than for diploid tumors. When data for all aneuploid tumors were analyzed collectively, there was no significant relationship between S-index and DNA ploidy index. However, for colorectal and ovarian carcinomas S-indices increased, and for lung carcinomas S-indices decreased with elevation in the degree of DNA-ploidy. Lung carcinomas had the highest S-indices. Comparison of flow cytometry (FCM) and cytology data indicated that for most diploid tumors S-indices reflect the proportion of S-phase cells among a mixed population of normal and tumor cells. For most aneuploid tumors, the proportion of tumor cells estimated cytologically was similar to the proportion of aneuploid cells estimated by FCM. For a small proportion of aneuploid tumors a comparison of cytology and FCM data indicated the presence of a predominant diploid tumor stemline and a minor stemline with aneuploid DNA content. There was a wide spread in the values of S-indices within tumor groups defined by degree of differentiation and stage of disease at surgery.     

DNA quantitation of distal bile duct carcinoma measured by image and flow cytometry

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate discrepancies between flow cytometry (FCM) and image cytometry (ICM), ploidy incidence and relation between DNA ploidies and survival in distal bile duct carcinomas (DBDCs). STUDY DESIGN: Forty-four archival tumor samples from patients with DBDC who underwent subtotal pancreatoduodenectomy from 1985 to 1996 were examined for DNA ploidy using FCM and ICM. RESULTS: Overall, 59% (26/44) of the tumors were aneuploid by at least one of the two techniques. We detected more cases of aneuploidy with ICM than FCM in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded DBDCs, 62% (21/34) versus 33% (13/40), respectively. When results could be compared, moderate strength of agreement (kappa = .45) was demonstrated. No correlation was found between DNA ploidy by FCM, ICM or combined FCM-ICM and survival time (P = .80, P = .35, and P = .54, respectively). CONCLUSION: Approximately 59% of DNA histograms contained aneuploid cell populations. Although ICM, as compared to FCM, is more sensitive in assessing the ploidy status of DBDC, both methods were complementary. Most discrepancies between FCM and ICM were due to the dilution of aneuploid populations by non-neoplastic diploid cells. DNA ploidy assessment in DBDC did not offer the possibility of improving the ability to predict survival.     

Comparison between slide and flow cytophotometric DNA measurements in breast tumors

Nuclear DNA analysis was performed in 37 human mammary adenocarcinomas in order to elucidate the difficulties and pitfalls connected with the interpretation of DNA histograms obtained using different methodologic approaches. For each tumor, DNA profiles were obtained by means of slide microspectrophotometry on a fine needle aspirate, slide cytophotometry on a 4-micron histologic section and flow cytometry on a suspension prepared from a cube of fresh tissue. When the DNA histograms were interpreted according to criteria usually applied to discriminate low-grade malignant tumors from high-grade malignant tumors, some tumors classified as euploid by one method were classified as aneuploid by another method. The main reasons for this weak correlation seem to be in specimen preparation and in tumor cell representation within the specimen between the methods. Another reason is that slide and flow techniques exhibit different sensitivities for malignancy-associated nuclear DNA changes: minor alterations of the DNA content of the tumor stemlines seem to be more exactly reported by means of the flow technique whereas structural alterations of the nuclear chromatin seem to be more sensitively recorded by means of the slide technique. It is suggested that thorough control of each step of the various DNA analysis procedures and the use of information obtainable by slide and flow techniques taken together may significantly improve the prognostic value of DNA measurements.     

Efficacy of combined image and flow cytometric DNA assessments in human breast cancer: a methodological study based on a routine histopathological material of 2024 excised tumour specimens

In 2024 excised specimens of malignant tumours of the female mammary gland. the nuclear DNA distribution pattern of the neoplastic cells was assessed by means of two procedures. One was image cytometry (ICM); here, all the 2024 samples were assessed. The other was flow cytometry (FCM) where 1336 specimens were analysed. In 829 of the 2024 tumour nodules the results of ICM and FCM could be compared. The efficacy of both techniques alone was about 80%; that of the combination was about 60%. In the ICM procedure the main reason for the reduction of samples was the failure to obtain representative specimens. The losses in the FCM method were due to poor quality of the histograms (too much background noise and too broad coefficients of variation). In addition, in as much as one third of all the cases, no specimens were set aside for FCM assessments. In 16% of the samples, where the results of the ICM assessment could be compared with those of the FCM analyses, completely diverging DNA ploidy patterns were obtained. The discrepancy was caused by differences in the interpretation of the histograms. In addition, the calculations of so-called S-phase fractions from the diploid FCM histograms was found to be associated with methodological errors, further contributing to differences in the DNA assessments by means of ICM and FCM. Nevertheless, it was advantageous to use combined ICM and FCM assessments, particularly in the interpretation of DNA histograms of uncommon types.     

Solid tumor preparation for clinical application of flow cytometry

Intense interest in advanced squamous cell cancers of the head and neck (SCC of H&N) has resulted from the recent progress made in tumor responses with chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Unfortunately, the response patterns and clinical outcome of such patients are not adequately predicted on an individual patient basis using clinical parameters or conventional morphology. The study of flow cytometrically determined cellular parameters in such tumors is therefore of interest, but is hindered by inadequate tumor preparative technology. The previous article (10) in this journal describes the use of a murine SCC tumor, LC12, which was employed for comparative testing and determination of optimum techniques of preparation for this tumor. This report describes the application of these techniques to 144 specimens of human SCC of H&N. The mean total yield for these specimens is 7.4 X 10(7) cells/g of tissue. The mean viable enzymatic yield (3.3 X 10(7) cells/g) was higher than the mean viable mechanical yield (2.0 X 10(7) cells/g) except when lymph nodes were the source of the specimen (5.4 X 10(7) cells/g). The mean dye exclusion viability from enzymatically dissociated specimens were above 90%. Significant aneuploidal subpopulation losses were evident in mechanically dissociated and enucleated specimens. 65% of the enzymatically dissociated specimens were successfully cultured with a mean cloning efficiency of 2.1 X 10(-3). Preparative techniques derived from comparative testing with a murine standard tumor have been successfully applied to 144 specimens of SCC of H&N with resultant high yields and excellent viability. Technical problems detected during the preliminary testing with LC12 were confirmed in the human tumors.     

Multiparametric evaluation of flow cytometric synthesis phase fraction determination in dual-labelled breast carcinomas.

Multiparametric, two-color DNA and cell cycle analyses were performed on 112 consecutive mechanically dissociated, ethanol-fixed breast carcinomas using a dual-label method with monoclonal antibodies (CAM 5.2) to cytokeratin (CK) and leukocyte common antigen (LCA) with propidium iodide (PI) staining. There was marked intertumoral variation of CK-positive (range, 3-87%; mean, 40%) and LCA-positive (range, 1-28%; mean, 6.5%) events in DNA histograms. Approximately 70% of DNA aneuploid cells were CK positive. CAM 5.2-stained (avidin-biotin technique) Cytospin preparations correlated with flow cytometric (FCM) detection of CK-positive cells in 15/21 (71%) cases. In each discrepant case, FCM detected greater numbers of CK-positive cells. Cytospin controls of tumor suspensions revealed that cytoplasmic loss was the major cause of decreased CK staining. Synthesis phase fraction (SPF) calculation from CK-gated histograms resulted in kinetic indices (mean ungated, 12.3%, vs. mean CK-gated, 16.8%; P less than .01) with improved statistical correlations with tumor grade and estrogen receptor (ER) status. Differences between ungated vs. CK-gated SPF were greatest in cases having less than 20% CK-positive events (P less than .05). Cases with lower CK staining events generally had higher SPF and were more often high grade (below median CK staining, 61% high grade, vs. above median CK staining, 31% high grade) and ER-negative (below median CK staining, 55% ER negative, vs. above median CK staining, 12% ER negative).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Methodologic aspects of nuclear DNA assessment of gliomas with astrocytic and/or oligodendrocytic differentiation. Correlation of image and flow cytometric studies on paraffin-embedded specimens

A total of 239 samples from paraffin-embedded, formalin-fixed astrocytic and/or oligodendrocytic gliomas from 111 patients were deparaffinized and disaggregated for image cytometric (ICM) and flow cytometric (FCM) DNA assessments. Each measurement technique produced evaluable histograms in about 85% of the samples analyzed. In the 10% that could not be analyzed by FCM, the background counts were too high and the coefficients of variation were too broad for precise evaluation. The failures with ICM were due to a shortage of Feulgen-stained tumor cell nuclei after the deparaffinization and disaggregation procedures. The results obtained were identical in 77% of the samples evaluable by both methods and practically identical (i.e., euploid versus aneuploid) in an additional 18%. The reasons for completely divergent DNA ploidy patterns in 5% of the samples could not be clarified. About 80% of the histopathologically highly malignant gliomas were found to consist of neoplastic cells with an aneuploid or tetraploid nuclear DNA distribution pattern. The results show that cytometric DNA assessments can be reliably performed on paraffin-embedded specimens of gliomas with astrocytic and/or oligodendrocytic differentiation by means of FCM and ICM on deparaffinized and disaggregated specimens.     

Cell kinetic studies in mouse tongue mucosa by autoradiographic, immunohistochemical and flow cytometric techniques

Abstract. A number of techniques, including autoradiography after in vivo administration of tritiated thymidine ([³H]dT), immunohistochemistry after in vivo administration of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd), and flow cytometry (FCM) with and without BrdUrd detection were compared in the epithelium of ventral mouse tongue. Investigation of the diurnal proliferative rhythm by immunohistochemical detection of incorporated BrdUrd with different primary antibodies in combination with the alkaline-phosphatase-anti-alkaline-phosphatase technique, the peroxidase-anti-perox-idase method, and an indirect method with a polyclonal peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody yielded results similar to standard autoradiography. Preparation of single cell suspensions for flow cytometry was not successful. A maximum yield of about 8.5% of the original cell number was achieved by ultrasound disintegration in combination with trypsin and dithioerythrol treatment, but neither a GdG, peak nor a G₂+ M peak was observed in DNA histograms. A better yield of about 38% of the original nuclei number was obtained by preparation of suspensions of nuclei using citric acid and the detergent Tween 20 in combination with magnetic stirring. Both S-phase index and BrdUrd labelling index could be determined by FCM and showed the normal diurnal variations. However, the BrdUrd labelling index in suspensions of nuclei was significantly higher than the labelling index determined after immunohistochemistry. The FCM S-phase index at times of day with low DNA synthesizing activity was higher than the BrdUrd index, indicating a fraction of unlabelled S-phase cells. In conclusion, detection of incorporated BrdUrd in oral mucosa by immunohistochemical techniques or flow cytometry is feasible and provides a useful tool for fast measurements of proliferation.     

Numerical chromosomal changes in DNA hypodiploid solid tumors: restricted loss and gain of certain chromosomes.

BACKGROUND: DNA hypodiploidy is a unique and rare finding associated with aggressive behavior in solid tumors. Identifying the chromosomal changes underlying this feature may provide important information on the development and progression of these neoplasms. METHODS: Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis using alpha-satellite probes for nine autosomes and the two sex chromosomes was performed on interphase cells from 27 solid tumors which had been shown to be DNA hypodiploid by flow cytometry. The chromosomal abnormalities were correlated with the DNA index and tumor subtypes. RESULTS: The data show mutually exclusive loss of certain chromosomes and compensatory gain of other chromosomes in different tumors. The net loss was slightly more than the net gain for the chromosomes tested. Polysomy of chromosome 7 and monosomy of chromosomes 17, X and loss Y were found in most tumors. Significant differential loss of chromosomes 6,10, and 12 among DNA hypodiploid breast, kidney and lung carcinomas was noted. CONCLUSIONS: Our study shows (i) gain of chromosome 7 and loss chromosome 17 in most DNA hypodiploid tumors, (ii) specific chromosomal loss was noted in breast and renal cell carcinomas, and (iii) that different mechanisms for DNA hypodiploid and hyperdiploid development may exist.     

Two-color multiparametric method for flow cytometric DNA analysis of carcinomas using staining for cytokeratin and leukocyte-common antigen

Solid tumors contain heterogenous cell populations, resulting in flow cytometric (FCM) DNA quantitations of a mixture of tumor and host cells. Such mixed populations can result in dilution of the tumor cells by the host cells, in difficulty defining the diploid reference mean and in histogram peak overlap, precluding cell-cycle analysis. In this study, epithelial (tumor) cells and contaminating host cells in 100 consecutively accessioned human mammary and colorectal carcinomas were segregated in a multiparametric two-color FCM DNA analysis of intact, ethanol-fixed cells. These two carcinomas and bladder carcinomas contain a cytoskeleton of simple epithelium that is selectively stained with an FITC-labeled monoclonal antibody (MAb) to cytokeratin (CK: CAM 5.2-FITC). This MAb detects the CK 8, CK 18 and CK 19 consistently present in all layers of normal and neoplastic urothelium, colonic epithelium and mammary epithelium. Gating on CK in these tumors enables the nonstaining leukocytes, stromal fibroblasts and endothelial cells to be excluded from DNA analysis. A separate aliquot of each tumor evaluated was labeled with an MAb to leukocyte-common antigen (LCA-FITC) to serve as a patient-specific intrinsic diploid reference standard. Both the CK-labeled and LCA-labeled cells were then dual labeled for DNA with propidium iodide. This method (1) correctly identified the intrinsic diploid (LCA-positive) channel, allowing an accurate definition of normal cell DNA content for calculation of the DNA index; and (2) resulted in an increased sensitivity in the identification of both diploid and abnormal hyperdiploid tumor cell populations. It also (3) limited DNA cell cycle analysis to urothelial, colonic and mammary epithelial cells, the majority of which were neoplastic in carefully selected tumor samples. In addition, this method (4) clarified near-tetraploid populations that overlap the normal nonepithelial G2M region by diminishing the normal G2M peak and accentuating the aneuploid tetraploid G0G1 peak and (5) deconvoluted overlapping histograms composed of normal host and diploid-range or aneuploid tumor cells by gating on tissue-specific markers. This exclusion of host cells in both classes of tumors resulted in more accurate cell-cycle calculations in the former and allowed calculation of the S-phase fractions in the latter.     

Flow cytometric DNA content of fresh tumor specimens using keratin-antibody as second stain for two-parameter analysis.

Studies concerning flow cytometric assessed DNA content reveal problems in interpretating DNA histograms of tumor specimens. The main problems are histograms with a broad coefficient of variation in the G0/G1 fraction; a high G2M fraction and samples with a low percentage of tumor cells. Therefore, in the present study, 382 fresh tumor specimens of carcinomas were analysed routinely, double labeled with, on the one hand, propidium-iodide for assessing DNA content and, on the other, a monoclonal keratin-antibody for marking epithelial and tumor cells. Of the 311 tumor samples, using single parameter analysis 165 (54%) were classified as DNA aneuploid and 146 (46%) as DNA "euploid." By double parameter analysis, 224 (72%) samples were keratin positive and 87 (27%) keratin negative and, of the 224 keratin positive tumors, 175 (78%) were DNA aneuploid and 49 (22%) DNA euploid. The DNA histograms of single and double parameter analysis were compared and it was concluded that in 24 cases (11%) keratin labeling was necessary to recognize DNA aneuploidy. In another 23 (10%) cases, keratin labeling was helpful in assessing DNA aneuploidy. Finally when the results of the 311 samples were combined, 215 (68%) were scored as DNA aneuploid and 99 (32%) DNA euploid. Thus the overall gain in assessing DNA aneuploidy using the double labeling technique is 14%. In conclusion, it is shown that keratin labeling on fresh tumor cell suspensions of epithelial tumors is of additional value in establishing DNA content. Because single parameter DNA assessment is adequate in approximately 60% of the tested samples, the double labeling technique can be performed routinely, or after initial single parameter DNA assessment. Histograms having a broad CV and/or a high G2M are good candidates for the double labeling technique. Using this technique, DNA-content assessment becomes more reliable.     

Progesterone receptor detection and quantification in breast tumors by bivariate immunofluorescence/DNA flow cytometry

A method was developed for the detection of progesterone receptors (PgR) by flow cytometry (FCM) in cell suspensions obtained from mechanically dispersed fragments of operated breast cancers. Two monoclonal antibodies were tested for sensitivity and specificity on four breast cancer cell lines of known PgR expression and a calibration curve thus established. A simple procedure was used to calculate the level of PgR expression, taking into account the relative displacement of total cellular fluorescence compared to nonspecific fluorescence for each sample and the average DNA content of the cells derived from the corresponding histograms. The PgR-specific immunofluorescence of the tumor specimens measured in arbitrary units (channels) was then transformed to fmoles/mg DNA by comparison with the calibration curve. The FCM-derived results were compared with those of a conventional immunoenzymatic PgR assay on 30 surgical samples. PgR content ranged from 10 to 22,000 fmoles/mg DNA and linear regression analysis yielded a good correlation (r = 0.86). With a threshold of positivity of 300 fmoles/mg DNA, the two methods concurred for 28 of 30 tumors (93%). Nine specimens were analyzed repeatedly, showing good reproducibility. This method could prove to be more useful than the biochemical assays on homogenates, since it allows the simultaneous analysis of receptor expression in individual cells and of DNA index (ploidy).     

The reliability of microspectrophotometric and flow cytometric nuclear DNA measurements in adenocarcinomas of the breast

The reliability of microspectrophotometric (MSP) and flow cytometric (FCM) nuclear DNA measurements has been studied in 50 human breast adenocarcinomas. The tumor material was obtained by means of fine-needle aspiration biopsy, and all samples except one were found to be highly representative. The results confirm earlier observations that a good correlation exists between modal value (MV) determined by MSP and DNA index (DI) determined by FCM. However, when tumors were classified into low and high malignant variants according to FCM/DI, FCM/S-phase percentages, and MSP histogram types, the concordance was less pronounced. This was found to be due mainly to the fact that in near-diploid tumors a discrepancy exists between MSP and FCM ploidy, as well as between MSP distribution pattern and the estimated percentages of cells in the S-phase region. Another source of discrepancy was observed in tumors with stemlines in the normal tetraploid region, including cells with highly scattered aneuploid DNA values. These tumors were judged by MSP as aneuploid/high malignant and by FCM as euploid/low malignant. In view of this discrepancy, we conclude that the simple determination of the stemline position by MSP/MV or FCM/DI is not sufficient for adequate cytochemical malignancy grading of breast carcinomas. We suggest that a combination of ploidy and percentage of cells scattered outside the modal peaks is a more sensitive method for optimal cytochemical malignancy grading in breast carcinomas.     

Diagnostic value of flow cytometric DNA determination combined with fine needle aspiration biopsy in thyroid tumors

The nuclear DNA content and the numbers of cells in the S and G2M phases of the cell cycle were determined by flow cytometry (FCM) in fine needle aspirates of 187 thyroid tumors to evaluate the diagnostic value of nuclear DNA content determination in combination with aspiration cytology. DNA aneuploidy was present in 4 of 5 follicular carcinomas, 2 of 3 anaplastic carcinomas, 5 of 15 excised follicular adenomas and 2 of 20 excised adenomatous goiters; all 7 papillary carcinomas and 4 lymphomas were diploid in the aspirate. Aneuploid carcinomas had easily distinguishable S and/or G2M phases, unlike the benign aneuploid tumors. None of the histologically benign tumors or the nonexcised tumors had greater than 6% S-phase cells, and only one benign tumor had greater than 9% G2M-phase cells. In contrast, all lymphomas had greater than 10% S-phase cells and four of seven papillary carcinomas had greater than 9% G2M-phase cells. The use of FCM determination in combination with fine needle aspiration biopsy cytology improved the diagnostic potential of the latter technique.     

Analysis of flow cytometric data of irradiated cell populations

Summary Flow cytometry (FCM) and autoradiography have been applied to determine changes in the cell kinetics of irradiated cells. Synchronized L-929 cells were irradiated with 10 Gy of X-rays when progressing from G₁-to S-phase of the cell cycle. In this study three methods to analyse DNA histograms were tested for applicability on FCM data obtained from cell populations blocked or retarded in the cycle: A) the Gaussian integral method, B) the peak-half-reflection method, and C) the rectangle method. Since histograms from synchronized cells are heavily distorted as compared to those obtained from exponentially growing cells and are quite similar to histograms from irradiated cells, they were used to test the suitability of the evaluation methods. Comparing the evaluated FCM data with the autoradiographic results from the same experimental series, the Gaussian integral method proved to be superior to the two other relatively simple approximation methods. The FCM histograms of irradiated cells were therefore analyzed only by the Gaussian integral method. It was shown that a considerable fraction of cells is still in the S-phase 25 h post irradiation, the DNA synthesis of which has ceased, as shown by autoradiography. This indicated that parallel measurements using FCM and autoradiography yield additional information on cell kinetic changes that cannot be obtained from applying one of the two methods used.     

In vivo effects of 5-fluorouracil and ftorafur[1-(tetrahydrofuran-2-yl)-5-fluorouracil] on murine mammary tumors and small intestine.

The in vivo anti-tumour and toxic effects of ftorafur (FT) and 5-fluorouracil (FU) were studied in the C3H mouse. On a molar basis, FU was two to three times more potent than FT with respect to growth inhibition of murine mammary adenocarcinomas. However, FT produced less host toxicity than FU when both drugs were compared at dose levels which produced equivalent anti-tumor effects. The differences between FT and FU with respect to tumor growth inhibition and host toxicity were reflected in their ability to suppress deoxyuridine incorporation into tumor cell and intestinal DNA, respectively. Flow cytometry (FCM) studies indicated that FT and FU were capable of producing pertubations in the DNA distribution of tumour cells. Both drugs induced an initial accumulation of cells in S phase following their administration at equivalent anti-tumour dose levels. At later intervals, an apparent block of cell progression at the G1/S boundary was observed. Drug-induced perturbations in the DNA distribution of tumour cells as detected by FCM correlated with results obtained by classical autoradiographic techniques using tritiated thymidine. Both procedures showed that tumor cells were capable of moving through S phase even in the presence of an apparently near complete inhibition of deoxyuridine incorporation into DNA. That such cells were, in fact, capable of synthesizing DNA at moderate rates was shown by their ability to incorporate 32P into DNA. The possible relationship of these findings to the therapeutic and toxic activities of FT and FU is discussed.     

Evaluation of tumor heterogeneity of prostate carcinoma by flow- and image DNA cytometry and histopathological grading.

BACKGROUND: Heterogeneity of prostate carcinoma is one of the reasons for pretreatment underestimation of tumor aggressiveness. We studied tumor heterogeneity and the probability of finding the highest tumor grade and DNA aneuploidy with relation to the number of biopsies. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Specimens simulating core biopsies from five randomly selected tumor areas from each of 16 B?cking's grade II and 23 grade III prostate carcinomas were analyzed for tumor grade and DNA ploidy by flow- and fluorescence image cytometry (FCM, FICM). Cell cycle composition was measured by FCM. RESULTS: By determination of ploidy and cell cycle composition, morphologically defined tumors can further be subdivided. Heterogeneity of tumor grade and DNA ploidy (FCM) was 54% and 50%. Coexistence of diploid tumor cells in aneuploid specimens represents another form of tumor heterogeneity. The proportion of diploid tumor cells decreased significantly with tumor grade and with increase in the fraction of proliferating cell of the aneuploid tumor part. The probability of estimating the highest tumor grade or aneuploidy increased from 40% for one biopsy to 95% for 5 biopsies studied. By combining the tumor grade with DNA ploidy, the probability of detecting a highly aggressive tumor increased from 40% to 70% and 90% for one and two biopsies, respectively. CONCLUSION: Specimens of the size of core biopsies can be used for evaluation of DNA ploidy and cell cycle composition. Underestimation of aggressiveness of prostate carcinoma due to tumor heterogeneity is minimized by simultaneous study of the tumor grade and DNA ploidy more than by increasing the number of biopsies. The biological significance of coexistent diploid tumor cell in aneuploid lesions remains to be evaluated.     

Comparison of DNA ploidy in routine fine needle aspiration biopsy samples and paraffin-embedded tissue samples

The nuclear DNA content was determined by flow cytometry (FCM) from unfixed fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy samples of 31 human tumors, and from the same tumors after their excision, fixation with formalin and embedding in paraffin. The ploidy of the histograms was the same in 29 (94%) of the 31 cases. The disagreement in two cases may be explained by clonal heterogeneity of the tumors. The DNA index of the aneuploid cases was identical in fresh and fixed samples. The coefficient of variation of the diploid peaks (P less than .001) and the mean percentage of S-phase cells (P = .06) were larger in the fixed samples. It is concluded that routine FNA biopsy is a practical and reliable method for collecting cells for FCM DNA ploidy determination.