The standardization of infectivity titrations of poliovaccines--a WHO collaborative study

The reproducibility of a method for infectivity titrations of live poliovaccines using microtitre plates was investigated in a WHO collaborative study involving eight laboratories. The large variation (up to 100-fold) in estimates of infectivity observed between laboratories using their local methods of assay was reduced to no more than fourfold when a common method was used. However, expressing infectivities relative to those of the monovalent reference viruses improved the agreement between the laboratories irrespective of the titration method employed. On the basis of these results, WHO adopted the common method used in the study as its recommended method for poliovirus titrations and established the preparations studied as international reference materials for the infectivity titrations of live poliovaccines.     

Effect of genomic variation in the challenge virus on the neutralization titres of recipients of inactivated JE vaccines--report of a collaborative study on PRNT50 assays for Japanese encephalitis virus (JE) antibodies.

Japanese encephalitis (JE) viruses are grouped into four genotypes. Although currently available vaccines are derived only from viruses in genotype III, vaccines are known to protect against naturally occurring strains. Studies were undertaken to assess the suitability of a freeze-dried pool of human anti-JE plasma, collected from recipients of Biken (Nakayama-NIH) killed vaccine, to serve as an International Standard for antibodies to JE virus. Five participants in five countries submitted data from 11 assays on the candidate International Standard and seven coded samples including sera from recipients of vaccines containing a range of virus strains. The results of the study indicated that the 50% plaque reduction neutralization test (PRNT(50)titres) obtained for serum from recipients of killed vaccines, including the candidate standard, vary depending on the virus strain used in the neutralization tests, namely higher PRNT(50)titres were obtained when the challenge virus was homologous to the vaccine strain compared to use of a heterologous virus. Potencies expressed relative to the candidate standard are therefore affected by the strain of virus used in assays and the use of a standard would therefore not facilitate direct comparison of data from laboratories that have used different challenge strains.     

Round robin investigation of methods for recovering human enteric viruses from sludge.

To select a tentative standard method for detection of viruses in sludge the American Society for Testing and Materials D19:24:04:04 Subcommittee Task Group initiated round robin comparative testing of two procedures that, after initial screening of several methodologies, were found to meet the basic criteria considered essential by the task group. Eight task group member laboratories agreed to perform round robin testing of the two candidate methods, namely, The Environmental Protection Agency or low pH-AlCl3 method and the Glass or sonication-extraction method. Five different types of sludge were tested. For each particular type of sludge, a single laboratory was designated to collect the sludge in a single sampling, make samples, and ship it to the participating laboratories. In most cases, participating laboratories completed all the tests within 48 h of sample arrival. To establish the reproducibility of the methods, each laboratory tested each sludge sample in triplicate for the two candidate virus methods. Each processed sludge sample was quantitatively assayed for viruses by the procedures of each individual round robin laboratory. To attain a more uniform standard of comparison, a sample of each processed sample from all laboratories was reassayed with one cell line and passage number by a single laboratory (Environmental Protection Agency Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory, Cincinnati, Ohio). When the data were statistically analyzed, the Environmental Protection Agency method was found to yield slightly higher virus recoveries for all sludge types, except the dewatered sludge. The precisions of both methods were not significantly different.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Round robin investigation of methods for recovering human enteric viruses from sludge

To select a tentative standard method for detection of viruses in sludge the American Society for Testing and Materials D19:24:04:04 Subcommittee Task Group initiated round robin comparative testing of two procedures that, after initial screening of several methodologies, were found to meet the basic criteria considered essential by the task group. Eight task group member laboratories agreed to perform round robin testing of the two candidate methods, namely, The Environmental Protection Agency or low pH-AlCl3 method and the Glass or sonication-extraction method. Five different types of sludge were tested. For each particular type of sludge, a single laboratory was designated to collect the sludge in a single sampling, make samples, and ship it to the participating laboratories. In most cases, participating laboratories completed all the tests within 48 h of sample arrival. To establish the reproducibility of the methods, each laboratory tested each sludge sample in triplicate for the two candidate virus methods. Each processed sludge sample was quantitatively assayed for viruses by the procedures of each individual round robin laboratory. To attain a more uniform standard of comparison, a sample of each processed sample from all laboratories was reassayed with one cell line and passage number by a single laboratory (Environmental Protection Agency Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory, Cincinnati, Ohio). When the data were statistically analyzed, the Environmental Protection Agency method was found to yield slightly higher virus recoveries for all sludge types, except the dewatered sludge. The precisions of both methods were not significantly different.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Round robin investigation of methods for the recovery of poliovirus from drinking water

Six laboratories actively involved in water virology research participated in a methods evaluation study, conducted under the auspices of the American Society for Testing and Materials Committee on Viruses in the Aquatic Environment, Task Force on Drinking Water. Each participant was asked to examine the Viradel (virus adsorption-elution) method with cartridge-type Filterite filters for virus adsorption and organic flocculation and aluminum hydroxide-hydroextraction for reconcentration. Virus was adsorbed to filter media at pH 3.5 and eluted with either glycine buffer (pH 10.5) or beef extract-glycine (pHG 9.0). Considerable variation was noted in the quantity of virus recovered from four 100-liter samples of dechlorinated tapwater seeded with low (350 to 860 PFU) and high (1,837 to 4,689 PFU) doses of poliovirus type 1. To have a more uniform standard of comparison, all the test samples were reassayed in one laboratory, where titers were also determined for the virus seed. Test results of the Viradel-organic flocculation method indicated that the average percentage of virus recovery for low-input experiments was 66%, with a range of 8 to 20% in two laboratories, 49 to 63% in three laboratories, and 198% in one laboratory. For the high-input experiments, two laboratories reported recoveries of 6 to 12%, and four laboratories reported recoveries of 26 to 46%. For the Viradel aluminum hydroxide-hydroextraction procedure, two laboratories recovered 9 to 11%, whereas four obtained 17 to 34% for low-input experiments. For the high-input tests, two laboratories reported a recovery of 3 to 5%, and four recovered 11 to 18% of the seeded virus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Round robin investigation of methods for the recovery of poliovirus from drinking water.

Six laboratories actively involved in water virology research participated in a methods evaluation study, conducted under the auspices of the American Society for Testing and Materials Committee on Viruses in the Aquatic Environment, Task Force on Drinking Water. Each participant was asked to examine the Viradel (virus adsorption-elution) method with cartridge-type Filterite filters for virus adsorption and organic flocculation and aluminum hydroxide-hydroextraction for reconcentration. Virus was adsorbed to filter media at pH 3.5 and eluted with either glycine buffer (pH 10.5) or beef extract-glycine (pHG 9.0). Considerable variation was noted in the quantity of virus recovered from four 100-liter samples of dechlorinated tapwater seeded with low (350 to 860 PFU) and high (1,837 to 4,689 PFU) doses of poliovirus type 1. To have a more uniform standard of comparison, all the test samples were reassayed in one laboratory, where titers were also determined for the virus seed. Test results of the Viradel-organic flocculation method indicated that the average percentage of virus recovery for low-input experiments was 66%, with a range of 8 to 20% in two laboratories, 49 to 63% in three laboratories, and 198% in one laboratory. For the high-input experiments, two laboratories reported recoveries of 6 to 12%, and four laboratories reported recoveries of 26 to 46%. For the Viradel aluminum hydroxide-hydroextraction procedure, two laboratories recovered 9 to 11%, whereas four obtained 17 to 34% for low-input experiments. For the high-input tests, two laboratories reported a recovery of 3 to 5%, and four recovered 11 to 18% of the seeded virus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A Comparison of Two Serological Methods for Detecting the Immune Response after Rabies Vaccination in Dogs and Cats being Exported to Rabies-free Areas

Levels of rabies virus neutralizing antibody in sera from dogs and cats were titrated to endpoint by the Rapid Fluorescent Focus Inhibition Test (RFFIT) and retested by the RFFIT and the Fluorescent Antibody Virus Neutralization test (FAVN). The two tests were compared for their ability to detect the 0.5 international units/ml (I.U.) of antibody required by the World Health Organization and the Office International des Epizooties as the minimum response for proof of rabies immunization. No difference was observed in sensitivity or specificity for either method in tests of 168 sera from unvaccinated animals or 70 sera from vaccinated animals with high levels of neutralizing antibody (an initial RFFIT titre of > or = 1.0 I.U.). Test to test variation occurred for results obtained by both RFFIT and FAVN for 95 sera from vaccinated animals with low to moderate levels of neutralizing antibody (RFFIT titre < 1.0 I.U.). No significant differences were detected for the 95 sera in the frequency for one methodology more often than the other to have a positive response (> or = 0.5 I.U.), nor were significant differences detected for the symmetry (P = 0.43) or the marginal homogeneity (P = 0.39) of results obtained by the two methods. Both methods can adequately identity unvaccinated animals, but false positive and false negative results are possible for either method when a single test is used to measure the antibody response of low-responding vaccinated animals. Nucleotide sequence analysis identified several amino acid differences in stocks of the challenge rabies virus from different laboratories. The small differences in neutralizing antibody titre that may result from mutations in the challenge virus are not important for evaluating immunity induced by vaccines which are themselves prepared from a variety of different rabies virus strains, but differences in the challenge virus, rather than differences in methodology, may account for at least some of the discrepant results reported in inter-laboratory surveys. Comparative studies of serological methods for measuring rabies antibodies should use well-characterized unpassaged virus stocks obtained from a single reference laboratory.     

An international collaborative study on foot and mouth disease virus assay methods. 1. Virus infectivity and neutralizing antibody assays

In a collaborative study sponsored by the European Commission for the Control of Foot and Mouth Disease, workers in 19 laboratories participated in the early phases (1, 2 and 4). All three phases were devoted to assessments of virus infectivity and the neutralizing activity of sera. Virus preparations and antisera distributed from one laboratory were tested either by 'in house' or suggested methods. Analyses of the results clearly showed that whilst 'within' laboratory variation in the results of replicate tests was low, there were significant differences in the results from various laboratories. By attempting to standardize test conditions with distributed materials, e.g. media and cells, etc., the 'between' laboratory variation was reduced.     

A single-blind, placebo-controlled comparison of the reactivity and antigenicity of trivalent oral poliomyelitis vaccine prepared in monkey kidney or human diploid cell substrates

Vaccination with a single dose of trivalent oral poliomyelitis vaccine elicited fourfold or greater antibody responses to one or more poliomyelitis virus types in 59% of volunteers (16/27) receiving vaccine prepared from virus grown in monkey kidney cells and in 69% of volunteers (16/23) receiving vaccine prepared from virus grown in MRC5 human diploid cells. Type for type the antibody titres and percentages of volunteers responding to the two vaccines were broadly equivalent. The clinical reactivities of both vaccines were similar to that of a placebo in terms of the overall incidence, duration and severity of reactions. The nature of the reactions observed did, however, vary, in that headaches were more frequently reported by recipients of vaccine prepared from virus grown in monkey kidney cells. This difference was not, however, statistically significant.     

First External Quality Assessment of Molecular and Serological Detection of Rift Valley Fever in the Western Mediterranean Region

Rift Valley fever (RVF) is a mosquito-borne viral zoonosis which affects humans and a wide range of domestic and wild ruminants. The large spread of RVF in Africa and its potential to emerge beyond its geographic range requires the development of surveillance strategies to promptly detect the disease outbreaks in order to implement efficient control measures, which could prevent the widespread of the virus to humans. The Animal Health Mediterranean Network (REMESA) linking some Northern African countries as Algeria, Egypt, Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Tunisia with Southern European ones as France, Italy, Portugal and Spain aims at improving the animal health in the Western Mediterranean Region since 2009. In this context, a first assessment of the diagnostic capacities of the laboratories involved in the RVF surveillance was performed. The first proficiency testing (external quality assessment—EQA) for the detection of the viral genome and antibodies of RVF virus (RVFV) was carried out from October 2013 to February 2014. Ten laboratories participated from 6 different countries (4 from North Africa and 2 from Europe). Six laboratories participated in the ring trial for both viral RNA and antibodies detection methods, while four laboratories participated exclusively in the antibodies detection ring trial. For the EQA targeting the viral RNA detection methods 5 out of 6 laboratories reported 100% of correct results. One laboratory misidentified 2 positive samples as negative and 3 positive samples as doubtful indicating a need for corrective actions. For the EQA targeting IgG and IgM antibodies methods 9 out of the 10 laboratories reported 100% of correct results, whilst one laboratory reported all correct results except one false-positive. These two ring trials provide evidence that most of the participating laboratories are capable to detect RVF antibodies and viral RNA thus recognizing RVF infection in affected ruminants with the diagnostic methods currently available.     

Multilaboratory evaluation of methods for detecting enteric viruses in soils.

Two candidate methods for the recovery and detection of viruses in soil were subjected to round robin comparative testing by members of the American Society for Testing and Materials D19:24:04:04 Subcommittee Task Group. Selection of the methods, designated "Berg" and "Goyal," was based on results of an initial screening which indicated that both met basic criteria considered essential by the task group. Both methods utilized beef extract solutions to achieve desorption and recovery of viruses from representative soils: a fine sand soil, an organic muck soil, a sandy loam soil, and a clay loam soil. One of the two methods, Goyal, also used a secondary concentration of resulting soil eluants via low-pH organic flocculation to achieve a smaller final assay volume. Evaluation of the two methods was simultaneously performed in replicate by nine different laboratories. Each of the produced samples was divided into portions, and these were respectively subjected to quantitative viral plaque assay by both the individual, termed independent, laboratory which had done the soil processing and a single common reference laboratory, using a single cell line and passage level. The Berg method seemed to produce slightly higher virus recovery values; however, the differences in virus assay titers for samples produced by the two methods were not statistically significant (P less than or equal to 0.05) for any one of the four soils. Despite this lack of a method effect, there was a statistically significant laboratory effect exhibited by assay titers from the independent versus reference laboratories for two of the soils, sandy loam and clay loam.     

三种提取RNA的方法对汉滩病毒检测敏感性影响的研究

分别采用标准法、ＧＰ法和ＭＢＰ法抽提汉滩病毒ＲＮＡ,结合套式ＰＣＲ比较这三种方法的敏感性。结果表明,所用引物对这两株病毒具有相同的特异性。这三种提取ＲＮＡ的敏感性差异不大,敏感性从高到低依次为：ＧＰ、ＭＢＰ和标准法,检测汉滩病毒的效价分别为０．０１、０．０１和０．１ＴＣＩＤ５０／２００μｌ;提取ＲＮＡ的时间长短分别为：标准法为２．５ｈ,ＧＰ为１ｈ,ＭＢＰ为０．５ｈ,可见ＭＢＰ用时最少。使用ＧＰ和ＭＢＰ提取ＲＮＡ时,可以在室温下进行,不需要低温离心。所以,ＭＢＰ最适合于实验室和临床病原体的快速检测,特别是对采集的环境样品的快速检测     

Multilaboratory evaluation of methods for detecting enteric viruses in soils.

Two candidate methods for the recovery and detection of viruses in soil were subjected to round robin comparative testing by members of the American Society for Testing and Materials D19:24:04:04 Subcommittee Task Group. Selection of the methods, designated "Berg" and "Goyal," was based on results of an initial screening which indicated that both met basic criteria considered essential by the task group. Both methods utilized beef extract solutions to achieve desorption and recovery of viruses from representative soils: a fine sand soil, an organic muck soil, a sandy loam soil, and a clay loam soil. One of the two methods, Goyal, also used a secondary concentration of resulting soil eluants via low-pH organic flocculation to achieve a smaller final assay volume. Evaluation of the two methods was simultaneously performed in replicate by nine different laboratories. Each of the produced samples was divided into portions, and these were respectively subjected to quantitative viral plaque assay by both the individual, termed independent, laboratory which had done the soil processing and a single common reference laboratory, using a single cell line and passage level. The Berg method seemed to produce slightly higher virus recovery values; however, the differences in virus assay titers for samples produced by the two methods were not statistically significant (P less than or equal to 0.05) for any one of the four soils. Despite this lack of a method effect, there was a statistically significant laboratory effect exhibited by assay titers from the independent versus reference laboratories for two of the soils, sandy loam and clay loam.     

An international collaborative study of an anti-infectious bursal disease virus reference serum

Fourteen laboratories participated in a collaborative study of a freeze-dried preparation of anti-infectious bursal disease virus serum to assess the suitability of the serum as a standard for use in the infectious bursal disease virus neutralization test. Ten laboratories carried out micro-virus neutralization tests and six carried out plaque reduction tests, two laboratories carrying out both tests. When titres were expressed as a proportion of that obtained for a reference preparation there was a marked reduction in variation between results from different laboratories. The use of a reference preparation was therefore of value when comparing results from different laboratories. It is proposed that the reference preparation used in this study be used as a standard to facilitate the comparison of results from different laboratories. The proposed standard contains by definition 10,000 UK units.     

单纯疱疹病毒的PCR直接基因分型

本文利用ＰＣＲ技术建立一种对ＨＳＶ直接基因分型的方法。在ＨＳＶ－Ⅰ、Ⅱ两型的ＤＮＡ多聚酶基因上设计了一条两型共同的上游引物（ＨＤＰ－Ｂ）和两条型特异的下游引物（ＨＤＰ－１、ＨＤＰ－２）。三条引物共同组成一个扩增反应体系,在ＨＳＶ－Ⅰ产生５４３ｂｐ条带,ＨＳＶ－Ⅱ产生３７２ｂｐ条带,据此在基因水平上对ＨＳＶ进行分型。５株不同来源的ＨＳＶ（２株Ⅰ型,３株Ⅱ型）分型结果与病毒分离及血清学方法完全一致。该反应体系与其它来源的ＤＮＡ不产生特异反应,敏感性可达１ｆｇ。应用该法对１５１份临床可疑ＨＳＶ感染的标本进行检测并分型,结果与免疫学方法完全一致。     

Variation in susceptibility to Bacillus thuringiensis toxins among unselected strains of Plutella xylostella

So far, the only insect that has evolved resistance in the field to Bacillus thuringiensis toxins is the diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella). Documentation and analysis of resistant strains rely on comparisons with laboratory strains that have not been exposed to B. thuringiensis toxins. Previously published reports show considerable variation among laboratories in responses of unselected laboratory strains to B. thuringiensis toxins. Because different laboratories have used different unselected strains, such variation could be caused by differences in bioassay methods among laboratories, genetic differences among unselected strains, or both. Here we tested three unselected strains against five B. thuringiensis toxins (Cry1Aa, Cry1Ab, Cry1Ac, Cry1Ca, and Cry1Da) using two bioassay methods. Tests of the LAB-V strain from The Netherlands in different laboratories using different bioassay methods yielded only minor differences in results. In contrast, side-by-side comparisons revealed major genetic differences in susceptibility between strains. Compared with the LAB-V strain, the ROTH strain from England was 17- to 170-fold more susceptible to Cry1Aa and Cry1Ac, respectively, whereas the LAB-PS strain from Hawaii was 8-fold more susceptible to Cry1Ab and 13-fold more susceptible to Cry1Da and did not differ significantly from the LAB-V strain in response to Cry1Aa, Cry1Ac, or Cry1Ca. The relative potencies of toxins were similar among LAB-V, ROTH, and LAB-PS, with Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac being most toxic and Cry1Da being least toxic. Therefore, before choosing a standard reference strain upon which to base comparisons, it is highly advisable to perform an analysis of variation in susceptibility among field and laboratory populations.     

Rapid and sensitive detection of Taura syndrome virus using nucleic acid-based amplification

Requiring only simple heating devices, isothermal nucleic acid-based amplification (NASBA) is a potential detection platform to be developed for on-site diagnosis of aquaculture pathogens. In this report, an NASBA assay has been developed for the Taura syndrome virus (TSV), one of the most devastating RNA virus pathogens for several penaeid shrimp species. The NASBA amplicons were detected by agarose gel electrophoresis and confirmed by Northern-blotting and dot-blotting analysis, using a biotinylated TSV-specific primer. The sensitivity of the TSV NASBA coupled with dot-blotting detection was approximately 5-fold less sensitive than that of the commercially available RT-nested, PCR-based IQ2000 TSV Detection and Prevention System that was also confirmed to be more sensitive than the RT-PCR-based TSV detection protocol recommended by the OIE (Office International des Epizooties). The specificity of the TSV NASBA reaction was substantiated by the results that RNA of non-target viruses did not generate any signals. Furthermore, a simple colorimetric microtiter plate assay employing TSV-specific capture and detection primers was developed as a simple alternative approach for the detection of NASBA amplicons. Taken together, the combination of the isothermal NASBA and colorimetric solid phase-based assays should allow sensitive, straightforward, and speedy on-site detection of TSV.     

Improved efficiency in determining the titer of the Autographa californica baculovirus nonoccluded virus.

An economical and time-efficient method for titering the Autographa californica multiple-embedded nuclear polyhedrosis virus (AcMNPV) by the endpoint method is described. The method uses an electronic pipetting device to perform dilutions in the same 60-well microplate as is used for the assay, thus eliminating the need for test tubes or vials for making dilutions. Additionally, since small volumes are used for the dilutions, a substantial savings in medium is achieved. The effect of using three different lepidopteran cell lines in this assay for AcMNPV is also described. This test revealed that one line (the Trichoplusia ni IPLB-TN-R2 line) is at least 1.5 logs more sensitive to AcMNPV when using occlusion body formation as the measure of infection. The titer was about 6- to 12-fold higher in the IPLB-TN-R2 cell line than the other two lines when plaque assay procedures were used. The titer of a recombinant baculovirus with a bacterial beta-galactosidase gene was also measured in the three cell lines using X-gal as an indicator and showed the IPLB-TN-R2 line to be fourfold more sensitive to this virus.