Structural and biochemical studies of GH family 12 cellulases: improved thermal stability, and ligand complexes

In this review we will describe how we have gathered structural and biochemical information from several homologous cellulases from one class of glycoside hydrolases (GH family 12), and used this information within the framework of a protein-engineering program for the design of new variants of these enzymes. These variants have been characterized to identify some of the positions and the types of mutations in the enzymes that are responsible for some of the biochemical differences in thermal stability and activity between the homologous enzymes. In this process we have solved the three-dimensional structure of four of these homologous GH 12 cellulases: Three fungal enzymes, Humicola grisea Cel12A, Hypocrea jecorina Cel12A and Hypocrea schweinitzii Cel12A, and one bacterial, Streptomyces sp. 11AG8 Cel12A. We have also determined the three-dimensional structures of the two most stable H. jecorina Cel12A variants. In addition, four ligand-complex structures of the wild-type H. grisea Cel12A enzyme have been solved and have made it possible to characterize some of the interactions between substrate and enzyme. The structural and biochemical studies of these related GH 12 enzymes, and their variants, have provided insight on how specific residues contribute to protein thermal stability and enzyme activity. This knowledge can serve as a structural toolbox for the design of Cel12A enzymes with specific properties and features suited to existing or new applications.     

Structural and biochemical studies of GH family 12 cellulases: improved thermal stability,and ligand complexes

In this review we will describe how we have gathered structural and biochemical information from several homologous cellulases from one class of glycoside hydrolases (GH family 12), and used this information within the framework of a protein-engineering program for the design of new variants of these enzymes. These variants have been characterized to identify some of the positions and the types of mutations in the enzymes that are responsible for some of the biochemical differences in thermal stability and activity between the homologous enzymes. In this process we have solved the three-dimensional structure of four of these homologous GH 12 cellulases: Three fungal enzymes, Humicola grisea Cel12A, Hypocrea jecorina Cel12A and Hypocrea schweinitzii Cel12A, and one bacterial, Streptomyces sp. 11AG8 Cel12A. We have also determined the three-dimensional structures of the two most stable H. jecorina Cel12A variants. In addition, four ligand-complex structures of the wild-type H. grisea Cel12A enzyme have been solved and have made it possible to characterize some of the interactions between substrate and enzyme. The structural and biochemical studies of these related GH 12 enzymes, and their variants, have provided insight on how specific residues contribute to protein thermal stability and enzyme activity. This knowledge can serve as a structural toolbox for the design of Cel12A enzymes with specific properties and features suited to existing or new applications.     

Sequences related to the ox pancreatic ribonuclease coding region in the genomic DNA of mammalian species

Mammalian pancreatic ribonucleases form a family of homologous proteins that has been extensively investigated. The primary structures of these enzymes were used to derive phylogenetic trees. These analyses indicate that the presence of three strictly homologous enzymes in the bovine species (the pancreatic, seminal, and cerebral ribonucleases) is due to gene duplication events which occurred during the evolution of ancestral ruminants.In this paper we present evidence that confirms this finding and that suggests an overall structural conservation of the putative ribonuclease genes in ruminant species.We could also demonstrate that the sequences related to ox ribonuclease coding regions present in genomic DNA of the giraffe species are the orthologues of the bovine genes encoding the three ribonucleases mentioned above.Correspondence to: A. Furia     

Structural and evolutionary bioinformatics of the SPOUT superfamily of methyltransferases

Background  

SPOUT methyltransferases (MTases) are a large class of S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent enzymes that exhibit an unusual alpha/beta fold with a very deep topological knot. In 2001, when no crystal structures were available for any of these proteins, Anantharaman, Koonin, and Aravind identified homology between SpoU and TrmD MTases and defined the SPOUT superfamily. Since then, multiple crystal structures of knotted MTases have been solved and numerous new homologous sequences appeared in the databases. However, no comprehensive comparative analysis of these proteins has been carried out to classify them based on structural and evolutionary criteria and to guide functional predictions.     

Database for three dimensional structures of pepsin-like enzymes using the internal coordinate system

A database for 3D structures of pepsin-like enzymes has been created on the basis of a novel approach using the Internal Coordinate System (ICS). It allows rapid comparison of multiple structures of pepsin-like enzymes without the need for preliminary calculations. Atomic displacements measured by this approach are very close to those estimated by the superposition procedures widely employed in comparing three-dimensional structures of proteins. Any new structure of pepsin-like enzyme converted to the ICS automatically becomes superimposed with all structures in a database. The ICS approach can be used for any class of enzymes and is especially efficient for families containing a large number of homologous structures.     

Structural studies of tri-functional human GART

Human purine de novo synthesis pathway contains several multi-functional enzymes, one of which, tri-functional GART, contains three enzymatic activities in a single polypeptide chain. We have solved structures of two domains bearing separate catalytic functions: glycinamide ribonucleotide synthetase and aminoimidazole ribonucleotide synthetase. Structures are compared with those of homologous enzymes from prokaryotes and analyzed in terms of the catalytic mechanism. We also report small angle X-ray scattering models for the full-length protein. These models are consistent with the enzyme forming a dimer through the middle domain. The protein has an approximate seesaw geometry where terminal enzyme units display high mobility owing to flexible linker segments. This resilient seesaw shape may facilitate internal substrate/product transfer or forwarding to other enzymes in the pathway.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of ATP binding residues of biotin carboxylase. Insight into the mechanism of catalysis

Acetyl-CoA carboxylase catalyzes the first committed step in fatty acid synthesis in all plants, animals, and bacteria. The Escherichia coli form is a multimeric protein complex consisting of three distinct and separate components: biotin carboxylase, carboxyltransferase, and the biotin carboxyl carrier protein. The biotin carboxylase component catalyzes the ATP-dependent carboxylation of biotin using bicarbonate as the carboxylate source and has a distinct architecture that is characteristic of the ATP-grasp superfamily of enzymes. Included in this superfamily are d-Ala d-Ala ligase, glutathione synthetase, carbamyl phosphate synthetase, N(5)-carboxyaminoimidazole ribonucleotide synthetase, and glycinamide ribonucleotide transformylase, all of which have known three-dimensional structures and contain a number of highly conserved residues between them. Four of these residues of biotin carboxylase, Lys-116, Lys-159, His-209, and Glu-276, were selected for site-directed mutagenesis studies based on their structural homology with conserved residues of other ATP-grasp enzymes. These mutants were subjected to kinetic analysis to characterize their roles in substrate binding and catalysis. In all four mutants, the K(m) value for ATP was significantly increased, implicating these residues in the binding of ATP. This result is consistent with the crystal structures of several other ATP-grasp enzymes, which have shown specific interactions between the corresponding homologous residues and cocrystallized ADP or nucleotide analogs. In addition, the maximal velocity of the reaction was significantly reduced (between 30- and 260-fold) in the 4 mutants relative to wild type. The data suggest that the mutations have misaligned the reactants for optimal catalysis.     

Plant aspartic proteinases: enzymes on the way to a function

Plant aspartic proteinases have been characterized from seeds, flowers and leaves of a number of different species. The enzymes are generally either monomeric or heterodimeric, containing two peptides processed from the same precursor protein. The plant enzymes, like their mammalian and microbial counterparts, are active at acidic pH and inhibited by a class specific inhibitor pepstatin A. Plant aspartic proteinases are generally either secreted or targeted to the vacuolar/protein storage body compartment. The primary sequences of many of these enzymes have been determined and are very homologous with each other as well as with enzymes from mammalian and microbial origins. Plant aspartic proteinases, however, have a very unique plant specific region, which is not found in mammalian, microbial, or viral aspartic proteinases. The function of this region has not been elucidated. A role for these plant enzymes in protein processing or degradation has been proposed, however, more studies are required to confirm their in vivo functions. Recent intriguing results suggest possible roles for these enzymes in programmed cell-death of tissues and in pathogen resistance.     

Formation of a Hybrid Enzyme between Echinoderm Arginine Kinase and Mammalian Creatine Kinase

MOST intracellular enzymes are composed of more than one subunit. Where this is so, specificity in the interaction between subunits must be as important as specificity for substrates and the integrity of the catalytic structures of the molecule. All these features of enzyme proteins arise from their specific primary structures and may be modified during evolution as a result of changes in amino-acid sequence. The problem is posed as to whether the chemical structures within a subunit enabling it to combine with others are conserved during evolution or, on the other hand, whether they are modified during the divergence of homologous enzymes and isoenzymes.     

The crystal structure of NADPH:ferredoxin reductase from Azotobacter vinelandii.

NADPH:ferredoxin reductase (AvFPR) is involved in the response to oxidative stress in Azotobacter vinelandii. The crystal structure of AvFPR has been determined at 2.0 A resolution. The polypeptide fold is homologous with six other oxidoreductases whose structures have been solved including Escherichia coli flavodoxin reductase (EcFldR) and spinach, and Anabaena ferredoxin:NADP+ reductases (FNR). AvFPR is overall most homologous to EcFldR. The structure is comprised of a N-terminal six-stranded antiparallel beta-barrel domain, which binds FAD, and a C-terminal five-stranded parallel beta-sheet domain, which binds NADPH/NADP+ and has a classical nucleotide binding fold. The two domains associate to form a deep cleft where the NADPH and FAD binding sites are juxtaposed. The structure displays sequence conserved motifs in the region surrounding the two dinucleotide binding sites, which are characteristic of the homologous enzymes. The folded over conformation of FAD in AvFPR is similar to that in EcFldR due to stacking of Phe255 on the adenine ring of FAD, but it differs from that in the FNR enzymes, which lack a homologous aromatic residue. The structure of AvFPR displays three unique features in the environment of the bound FAD. Two features may affect the rate of reduction of FAD: the absence of an aromatic residue stacked on the isoalloxazine ring in the NADPH binding site; and the interaction of a carbonyl group with N10 of the flavin. Both of these features are due to the substitution of a conserved C-terminal tyrosine residue with alanine (Ala254) in AvFPR. An additional unique feature may affect the interaction of AvFPR with its redox partner ferredoxin I (FdI). This is the extension of the C-terminus by three residues relative to EcFldR and by four residues relative to FNR. The C-terminal residue, Lys258, interacts with the AMP phosphate of FAD. Consequently, both phosphate groups are paired with a basic group due to the simultaneous interaction of the FMN phosphate with Arg51 in a conserved FAD binding motif. The fourth feature, common to homologous oxidoreductases, is a concentration of 10 basic residues on the face of the protein surrounding the active site, in addition to Arg51 and Lys258.     

Crystal structures of two aminoglycoside kinases bound with a eukaryotic protein kinase inhibitor

Antibiotic resistance is recognized as a growing healthcare problem. To address this issue, one strategy is to thwart the causal mechanism using an adjuvant in partner with the antibiotic. Aminoglycosides are a class of clinically important antibiotics used for the treatment of serious infections. Their usefulness has been compromised predominantly due to drug inactivation by aminoglycoside-modifying enzymes, such as aminoglycoside phosphotransferases or kinases. These kinases are structurally homologous to eukaryotic Ser/Thr and Tyr protein kinases and it has been shown that some can be inhibited by select protein kinase inhibitors. The aminoglycoside kinase, APH(3')-IIIa, can be inhibited by CKI-7, an ATP-competitive inhibitor for the casein kinase 1. We have determined that CKI-7 is also a moderate inhibitor for the atypical APH(9)-Ia. Here we present the crystal structures of CKI-7-bound APH(3')-IIIa and APH(9)-Ia, the first structures of a eukaryotic protein kinase inhibitor in complex with bacterial kinases. CKI-7 binds to the nucleotide-binding pocket of the enzymes and its binding alters the conformation of the nucleotide-binding loop, the segment homologous to the glycine-rich loop in eukaryotic protein kinases. Comparison of these structures with the CKI-7-bound casein kinase 1 reveals features in the binding pockets that are distinct in the bacterial kinases and could be exploited for the design of a bacterial kinase specific inhibitor. Our results provide evidence that an inhibitor for a subset of APHs can be developed in order to curtail resistance to aminoglycosides.     

Kinesin and myosin ATPases: variations on a theme.

The enzymes kinesin and myosin are examples of molecular motors which couple ATP hydrolysis to directed movement of biological structures. Myosin has been extensively studied and its structure and mechanism of coupling are known in detail. Much less is known about kinesin, but many of its major properties are similar to those of myosin. Both enzymes have two catalytic head groups at the end of a long alpha-helical rod. The head groups contain the sites for ATP hydrolysis and interaction with their respective partners for movement (microtubules or F-actin). In each case the binding and hydrolysis of ATP is rapid and the steady state ATPase rate is limited by a slow step in the region of product release. This slow release of product is accelerated by interaction with actin or microtubules coupled to changes in binding affinity. As there is no evidence for a close evolutionary link between kinesin and myosin, these and other similarities may represent convergence to set of common functional properties which are constrained by the requirements of protein structure and the use of ATP hydrolysis as a source of energy. It will be of particular interest to determine if these common properties are also shared by the large number of divergent proteins which have recently been discovered to possess a domain which is homologous to the head group of kinesin.     

M. tuberculosis Pantothenate Kinase: Dual Substrate Specificity and Unusual Changes in Ligand Locations

Kinetic measurements of enzyme activity indicate that type I pantothenate kinase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis has dual substrate specificity for ATP and GTP, unlike the enzyme from Escherichia coli, which shows a higher specificity for ATP. A molecular explanation for the difference in the specificities of the two homologous enzymes is provided by the crystal structures of the complexes of the M. tuberculosis enzyme with (1) GMPPCP and pantothenate, (2) GDP and phosphopantothenate, (3) GDP, (4) GDP and pantothenate, (5) AMPPCP, and (6) GMPPCP, reported here, and the structures of the complexes of the two enzymes involving coenzyme A and different adenyl nucleotides reported earlier. The explanation is substantially based on two critical substitutions in the amino acid sequence and the local conformational change resulting from them. The structures also provide a rationale for the movement of ligands during the action of the mycobacterial enzyme. Dual specificity of the type exhibited by this enzyme is rare. The change in locations of ligands during action, observed in the case of the M. tuberculosis enzyme, is unusual, so is the striking difference between two homologous enzymes in the geometry of the binding site, locations of ligands, and specificity. Furthermore, the dual specificity of the mycobacterial enzyme appears to have been caused by a biological necessity.     

An analysis of structural similarity in the iron and manganese superoxide dismutases based on known structures and sequences

There are two types of homologous enzymes catalysing the dismutationof the superoxide radical – Cu–Zn superoxide dismutases, and manganese oriron superoxide dismutases. In the latter two forms there is a highpercentage of identity in the primary structures, and the tertiarystructures are very similar particu-larly in the areas of the activesite and in the residues responsible for the formation of the dimer.The quaternary structure of the dimer is also highly conserved.However, it has been found that despite this conservation thereis strong metal ion specificity and many enzymes in the familywill only be active if the correct metal ion is present. The purposeof this study has been to analyse solved X-ray structures forinter-actions common in both the manganese and iron forms andthose that are specific to each, which may indi-cate reasonsfor the metal ion specificity. Initial analysis points to theprobability that it is a combination of a number of residues,and not necessarily the same ones in every instance, which conferthe specificity. In addition we have identified some anomalies inthe currently available Fe/MnSOD structures which may require furtherremodelling and refinement. © Rapid Science 1998     

Changes in zinc ligation promote remodeling of the active site in the zinc hydrolase superfamily.

The zinc hydrolase superfamily is a group of divergently related proteins that are predominantly enzymes with a zinc-based catalytic mechanism. The common structural scaffold of the superfamily consists of an eight-stranded beta-sheet flanked by six alpha-helices. Previous analyses, while acknowledging the likely divergent origins of leucine aminopeptidase, carboxypeptidase A and the co-catalytic enzymes of the metallopeptidase H clan based on their structural scaffolds, have failed to find any homology between the active sites in leucine aminopeptidase and the metallopeptidase H clan enzymes. Here we show that these two groups of co-catalytic enzymes have overlapping dizinc centers where one of the two zinc atoms is conserved in each group. Carboxypeptidase A and leucine aminopeptidase, on the other hand, no longer share any homologous zinc-binding sites. At least three catalytic zinc-binding sites have existed in the structural scaffold over the period of history defined by available structures. Comparison of enzyme-inhibitor complexes show that major remodeling of the substrate-binding site has occurred in association with each change in zinc ligation in the binding site. These changes involve re-registration and re-orientation of the substrate. Some residues important to the catalytic mechanism are not conserved amongst members. We discuss how molecules acting in trans may have facilitated the mutation of catalytically important residues in the active site in this group.     

Common elements on the surface of glycolytic enzymes from Trypanosoma brucei may serve as topogenic signals for import into glycosomes.

In Trypanosoma brucei, a major pathogenic protozoan parasite of Central Africa, a number of glycolytic enzymes present in the cytosol of other organisms are uniquely segregated in a microbody-like organelle, the glycosome, which they are believed to reach post-translationally after being synthesized by free ribosomes in the cytosol. In a search for possible topogenic signals responsible for import into glycosomes we have compared the amino acid sequences of four glycosomal enzymes: triosephosphate isomerase (TIM), glyceraldehyde-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) and aldolase (ALDO), with each other and with their cytosolic counterparts. Each of these enzymes contains a marked excess of positive charges, distributed in two or more clusters along the polypeptide chain. Modelling of the three-dimensional structures of TIM, PGK and GAPDH using the known structural coordinates of homologous enzymes from other organisms indicates that all three may have in common two 'hot spots' about 40 A apart, which themselves include a pair of basic amino acid residues separated by a distance of about 7 A. The sequence of glycosomal ALDO, for which no three-dimensional information is available, is compatible with the presence of the same configuration on the surface of this enzyme. We propose that this feature plays an essential role in the import of enzymes into glycosomes.     

Patterns of gene expression: homology or homocracy?

Numerous papers over the years have stated that the original meaning of the term homology is historical and morphological and denotes organs/structures in two or more species derived from the same structure in their latest common ancestor. However, several more recent papers have extended the use of the term to cover organs/structures which are organised through the expression of homologous genes. This usage has created an ambiguity about the meaning of the term, and we propose to remove this by proposing a new term, homocracy, for organs/structures which are organised through the expression of identical patterning genes. We want to emphasise that the terms homologous and homocratic are not mutually exclusive. Many homologous structures are in all probability homocratic, whereas only a small number of homocratic structures are homologous.     

Fusion-type lycopene beta-cyclase from a thermoacidophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus

Examination of the sequence of a hypothetical gene with an unknown function included in the carotenogenic gene cluster in the genome of a thermoacidophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus led to the prediction that the gene encodes a novel-type lycopene beta-cyclase, whose N- and C-terminal halves are homologous to the subunits of the bacterial heterodimeric enzymes. The recombinant expression of the gene in lycopene-producing Escherichia coli resulted in the accumulation of beta-carotene in the cells, which verifies the function of the gene. Homologues of the archaeal lycopene beta-cyclase from various organisms such as bacteria, archaea, and fungi have been reported. Although their primary structures are clearly specific to the biological taxa, a phylogenetic analysis revealed the unexpected complicity of the evolutional route of these enzymes.