Characterization of global molecular shape transitions between “open” and “closed” protein conformations

Induced-fit configurational transitions in proteins can take many forms. In cases, we find small “closures” of a loop onto the substrate. In other cases, the structural changes triggered by a ligand involve large rearrangements that affect entire domains. The nature of these transitions is normally assessed by a visual analysis or in terms of simple local geometrical parameters, such as interresidue distances, backbone dihedral angles, and relative displacements between domains. This approach is limited and rather undiscriminating. In this work, we apply recently introduced ideas from macromolecular shape analysis to characterize the global shape changes accompanying “open closed” transitions in proteins. Here, we monitor two distinct properties simultaneously: molecular size and self-entanglements. The method is applied to some proteins exhibiting pairs of structurally different conformations (adenylate kinase, hexokinase, citrate synthase, alcohol dehydrogenase, triosephosphate isomerase, thioredoxin, and aspartate amino-transferase). The conformational change associated with these proteins is classified according to an order parameter that considers various molecular shape features. The results allow one to recognize, in a nonvisual fashion, the likely occurrence of local or global structural rearrangements. In addition, the technique provides an insight into folding features that may remain invariant during the configurational transitions. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

A systematic study of the energetics involved in structural changes upon association and connectivity in protein interaction networks

The study of protein binding mechanisms is a major topic of research in structural biology. Here, we implement a combination of metrics to systematically assess the cost of backbone conformational changes that protein domains undergo upon association. Through the analyses of 2090 unique unbound → bound transitions, from over 12,000 structures, we show that two-thirds of these proteins do not suffer significant structural changes upon binding, and could thus fit the lock-and-key model well. Among the remaining proteins, one-third explores the bound conformation in the unbound state (conformational selection model) and, while most transitions are possible from an energetic perspective, a few do require external help to break the thermodynamic barrier (induced fit model). We also analyze the relationship between conformational transitions and protein connectivity, finding that, in general, domains interacting with many partners undergo smaller changes upon association, and are less likely to freely explore larger conformational changes.     

Structural domains of vesicular stomatitis virus. A study by differential scanning calorimetry, thermal gel analysis, and thermal electron microscopy

Differential scanning calorimetry has been used in combination with thermal gel analysis and electron microscopy to identify and study the structural domains of the membrane-enclosed vesicular stomatitis virus and its isolated internal components. Three major endothermic transitions centered at approximately 52, 76, and 80 degrees C and at least two minor transitions are observed at pH 7.0 for the intact virion. Thermal gel analysis suggests the possibility that specific proteins of vesicular stomatitis virus are involved in two or more of the calorimetric transitions. The effect of heating to defined temperatures on the morphology of the virion was studied by negative stain electron microscopy. The results of these "thermal EM" studies show discrete irreversible morphological changes in the virion which seem to coincide with the three major calorimetric transitions.     

A Folding Insulator Defines Cryptic Domains in Tropomyosin

Multidomain proteins are the product of evolutionary selection for diversity of function through concatenation and repurposing of existing modular units of structures. In structures of proteins with multiple domains, components are often globular units stitched together with flexible linkers. Multidomain proteins often fold as multiple distinct order–disorder transitions. However, the relationship between structure and folding is not always straightforward. Tropomyosin binds to actin in muscle and cytoskeletal filaments. The structure is that of a continuous ɑ-helix lacking domain boundaries, but unfolding shows distinct transitions suggesting at least three possible domains do exist. To explore how domains might occur in a continuous structure, we used Lifson-Roig helix-coil models with sequence domains of varying helical nucleation propensities. Of these models, ones with a central folding insulator, separating folding of N- and C-terminal domains, are most consistent with experimental folding studies. The positions of domain boundaries are identified by hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry. The presence of structurally cryptic folding domains in tropomyosin could relate to its evolution and explain the uneven distribution of deleterious mutations that lead to various cardiomyopathies.     

Structural memory of natively unfolded tau protein detected by small-angle X-ray scattering

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a universal low-resolution method to study size and shape of globular proteins in solution but recent developments facilitate the quantitative characterization of the structure and structural transitions of metastable systems like partially or completely unfolded proteins. We present here a study of temperature induced transitions in tau, a natively unfolded protein involved in Alzheimer's disease. Previous studies on full length tau and several disease-related mutants provided information about the residual structure in different domains revealing a specific role and extended conformations of the so-called repeat domains, which are considered to be responsible for the formation of amyloid-like fibrils ("paired helical filaments"). Here, we employ SAXS to investigate the temperature dependent properties of tau. Slow heating/cooling of the full length protein from 10°C to 50°C did not lead to detectable changes in the overall size. Surprisingly, quick heating/cooling caused tau to adopt a significantly more compact conformation, which was stable over up to 3 h and represents a structural "memory" effect. This compaction is not observed for the shorter tau constructs containing largely the repeat domains. The structural and functional implications of the observed unusual behavior of tau under nonequilibrium conditions are discussed.     

Equilibrium unfolding and conformational plasticity of troponin I and T.

The structures and stabilities of recombinant chicken muscle troponin I (TnI) and T (TnT) were investigated by a combination of bis-ANS binding and equilibrium unfolding studies. Unlike most folded proteins, isolated TnI and TnT bind the hydrophobic fluorescent probe bis-ANS, indicating the existence of solvent-exposed hydrophobic domains in their structures. Bis-ANS binding to binary or ternary mixtures of TnI, TnT and troponin C (TnC) in solution is significantly lower than binding to the isolated subunits, which can be explained by burial of previously exposed hydrophobic domains upon association of the subunits to form the native troponin complex. Equilibrium unfolding studies of TnT and TnI by guanidine hydrochloride and urea monitored by changes in far-UV CD and bis-ANS fluorescence revealed noncooperative folding transitions for both proteins and the existence of partially folded intermediate states. Taken together, these results indicate that isolated TnI and TnT are partially unstructured proteins, and suggest that conformational plasticity of the isolated subunits may play an important role in macromolecular recognition for the assembly of the troponin complex.     

Conformational transitions of the three recombinant domains of human serum albumin depending on pH

Human serum albumin (HSA) is a protein of 66.5 kDa that is composed of three homologous domains, each of which displays specific structural and functional characteristics. HSA is known to undergo different pH-dependent structural transitions, the N-F and F-E transitions in the acid pH region and the N-B transition at slightly alkaline pH. In order to elucidate the structural behavior of the recombinant HSA domains as stand-alone proteins and to investigate the molecular and structural origins of the pH-induced conformational changes of the intact molecule, we have employed fluorescence and circular dichroic methods. Here we provide evidence that the loosening of the HSA structure in the N-F transition takes place primarily in HSA-DOM III and that HSA-DOM I undergoes a structural rearrangement with only minor changes in secondary structure, whereas HSA-DOM II transforms to a molten globule-like state as the pH is reduced. In the pH region of the N-B transition of HSA, HSA-DOM I and HSA-DOM II experience a tertiary structural isomerization, whereas with HSA-DOM III no alterations in tertiary structure are observed, as judged from near-UV CD and fluorescence measurements.     

Conformational studies of wheat flour high relative molecular mass glutenin subunits by circular dichroism spectroscopy

Conformational studies of 1Dx2, 1Bx7, and 1Dy12 high relative molecular mass glutenin subunits, extracted from Alisei 1 flour, are reported. Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is employed to study their conformational polymorphism induced by urea and by urea in the presence of 1% sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). The CD spectra indicate that SDS promotes ordered structures. The addition of urea to the SDS-acetate solution of 1Dx2, 1Bx7, and 1Dy12 subunits eliminates the effect of SDS. Its addition to the acetate solution of proteins induces conformational transitions to form a poly-L-proline II-like structure. All the changes induced by urea follow a multistep transition process that is typical of proteins consisting of different domains.     

Compressibility of protein transitions

We review the results of compressibility studies on proteins and low molecular weight compounds that model the hydration properties of these biopolymers. In particular, we present an analysis of compressibility changes accompanying conformational transitions of globular proteins. This analysis, in conjunction with experimental compressibility data on protein transitions, were used to define the changes in the hydration properties and intrinsic packing associated with native-to-molten globule, native-to-partially unfolded, and native-to-fully unfolded transitions of globular proteins. In addition, we discuss the molecular origins of predominantly positive changes in compressibility observed for pressure-induced denaturation transitions of globular proteins. Throughout this review, we emphasize the importance of compressibility data for characterizing protein transitions, while also describing how such data can be interpreted to gain insight into role that hydration and intrinsic packing play in modulating the stability of and recognition between proteins and other biologically important compounds.     

Multidomain structure of a recombinant streptokinase. A differential scanning calorimetry study

The temperature dependence of the heat capacity function of a recombinant streptokinase (rSK) has been studied by high-sensitivity differential scanning microcalorimetry and circular dichroism as a function of pH in low- and high-ionic strength buffers. At low ionic strength it is found that this protein, between pH 7 and 10, undergoes four reversible and independent two-state transitions during its unfolding, suggesting the existence of four domains in the native structure of the protein. This result reconciles previous conflicting reports about the number of domains of this protein obtained by differential scanning calorimetry and small-angle X-ray scattering. The number of two-state transitions decreases when the pH of the medium is decreased, without noticeable changes in its circular dichroism spectrum. A plausible localization of the four domains in the streptokinase sequences is proposed and their thermodynamic parameters are given. Increase of ionic strength to 200 mM NaCl affects positively the protein stability and confirms the existence of four reversible two-state transitions. Above 200 mM NaCl the protein stability decreases, resulting in low percentage of reversibility, and even irreversible transitions.     

Tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis in the alphaM3 transmembrane domain of the muscle-type acetylcholine receptor. A spring model revealed

Membrane proteins constitute a large fraction of all proteins, yet very little is known about their structure and conformational transitions. A fundamental question that remains obscure is how protein domains that are in direct contact with the membrane lipids move during the conformational change of the membrane protein. Important structural and functional information of several lipid-exposed transmembrane domains of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) and other ion channel membrane proteins have been provided by the tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis. Here, we use the tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis to monitor the conformational change of the alphaM3 domain of the muscle-type AChR. The perturbation produced by the systematic tryptophan substitution along the alphaM3 domain were characterized through two-electrode voltage clamp and 125I-labeled alpha-bungarotoxin binding. The periodicity profiles of the changes in AChR expression (closed state) and ACh EC50 (open-channel state) disclose two different helical structures; a thinner-elongated helix for the closed state and a thicker-shrunken helix for the open-channel state. The existence of two different helical structures suggest that the conformational transition of the alphaM3 domain between both states resembles a spring motion and reveals that the lipid-AChR interface plays a key role in the propagation of the conformational wave evoked by agonist binding. In addition, the present study also provides evidence about functional and structural differences between the alphaM3 domains of the Torpedo and muscle-type receptors AChR.     

Gamma S-crystallin of bovine and human eye lens: solution structure, stability and folding of the intact two-domain protein and its separate domains

Human and bovine gammaS-crystallin (HgammaS and BgammaS) and their isolated N- and C-terminal domains were cloned and expressed as recombinant proteins in E. coli. HgammaS and BgammaS are found to be authentic according to their spectral and hydrodynamic properties. Both full-length proteins and isolated domains are monomeric and exhibit high thermal and pH stabilities. The thermodynamic characterization made use of chemically and thermally-induced equilibrium unfolding transitions at varying pH. In spite of its exemplary two-domain structure, gammaS-crystallin does not show bimodal unfolding characteristics. In the case of BgammaS, at pH 7.0, the C-terminal domain is less stable than the N-terminal one, whereas for HgammaS the opposite holds true. Differential scanning calorimetry confirms the results of chemically-induced equilibrium unfolding transitions. Over the whole pH range between 2.0 and 11.5, HgammaS-crystallin and its isolated domains (HgammaS-N and HgammaS-C) follow the two-state model. The two-state unfolding of the intact two-domain protein points to the close similarity of the stabilities of the constituent domains. Obviously, interactions between the domains do not contribute significantly to the overall stability of gammaS-crystallin. In contrast, the structurally closely related gammaB-crystallin owes much of its extreme stability to domain interactions.     

Regulation of Membrane-Shape Transitions Induced by I-BAR Domains

I-BAR proteins are well-known actin-cytoskeleton adaptors and have been observed to be involved in the formation of plasma membrane protrusions (filopodia). I-BAR proteins contain an all-helical, crescent-shaped IRSp53-MIM domain (IMD) dimer that is believed to be able to couple with a membrane shape. This coupling could involve the sensing and even the generation of negative plasma membrane curvature. Indeed, the in vitro studies have shown that IMDs can induce inward tubulation of liposomes. While N-BAR domains, which generate positive membrane curvature, have received a considerable amount of attention from both theory and experiments, the mechanisms of curvature coupling through IMDs are comparatively less studied and understood. Here we used a membrane-shape stability assay developed recently in our lab to quantitatively characterize IMD-induced membrane-shape transitions. We determined a membrane-shape stability diagram for IMDs that reveals how membrane tension and protein density can comodulate the generation of IMD-induced membrane protrusions. From comparison to analytical theory, we determine three key parameters that characterize the curvature coupling of IMD. We find that the curvature generation capacity of IMDs is significantly stronger compared to that of endophilin, an N-BAR protein known to be involved in plasma membrane shape transitions. Contrary to N-BAR domains, where amphipathic helix insertion is known to promote its membrane curvature generation, for IMDs we find that amphipathic helices inhibit membrane shape transitions, consistent with the inverse curvature that IMDs generate. Importantly, in both of these types of BAR domains, electrostatic interactions affect membrane-binding capacity, but do not appear to affect the curvature generation capacity of the protein. These two types of BAR domain proteins show qualitatively similar membrane shape stability diagrams, suggesting an underlying ubiquitous mechanism by which peripheral proteins regulate membrane curvature.     

Mechanistic Inferences From Analysis of Measurements of Protein Phase Transitions in Live Cells

The combination of phase separation and disorder-to-order transitions can give rise to ordered, semi-crystalline fibrillar assemblies that underlie prion phenomena namely, the non-Mendelian transfer of information across cells. Recently, a method known as Distributed Amphifluoric Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (DAmFRET) was developed to study the convolution of phase separation and disorder-to-order transitions in live cells. In this assay, a protein of interest is expressed to a broad range of concentrations and the acquisition of local density and order, measured by changes in FRET, is used to map phase transitions for different proteins. The high-throughput nature of this assay affords the promise of uncovering sequence-to-phase behavior relationships in live cells. Here, we report the development of a supervised method to obtain automated and accurate classifications of phase transitions quantified using the DAmFRET assay. Systems that we classify as undergoing two-state discontinuous transitions are consistent with prion-like behaviors, although the converse is not always true. We uncover well-established and surprising new sequence features that contribute to two-state phase behavior of prion-like domains. Additionally, our method enables quantitative, comparative assessments of sequence-specific driving forces for phase transitions in live cells. Finally, we demonstrate that a modest augmentation of DAmFRET measurements, specifically time-dependent protein expression profiles, can allow one to apply classical nucleation theory to extract sequence-specific lower bounds on the probability of nucleating ordered assemblies. Taken together, our approaches lead to a useful analysis pipeline that enables the extraction of mechanistic inferences regarding phase transitions in live cells.     

Protein structure: evolutionary bridges to new folds

The question of whether novel, structurally different protein folds might have arisen from existing ones is crucial to understanding protein evolution. Recent work on cysteine-rich domains in Hydra proteins illuminates how evolutionary transitions between dramatically different structures might occur.     

Gradual regime shifts in spatially extended ecosystems

Ecosystem regime shifts are regarded as abrupt global transitions from one stable state to an alternative stable state, induced by slow environmental changes or by global disturbances. Spatially extended ecosystems, however, can also respond to local disturbances by the formation of small domains of the alternative state. Such a response can lead to gradual regime shifts involving front propagation and the coalescence of alternative-state domains. When one of the states is spatially patterned, a multitude of intermediate stable states appears, giving rise to step-like gradual shifts with extended pauses at these states. Using a minimal model, we study gradual state transitions and show that they precede abrupt transitions. We propose indicators to probe gradual regime shifts, and suggest that a combination of abrupt-shift indicators and gradual-shift indicators might be needed to unambiguously identify regime shifts. Our results are particularly relevant to desertification in drylands where transitions to bare soil take place from spotted vegetation, and the degradation process appears to involve step-like events of local vegetation mortality caused by repeated droughts.     

Proximity and orientation underlie signaling by the non-receptor tyrosine kinase ZAP70.

Signaling by the antigen receptor of T lymphocytes initiates different developmental transitions, each of which require the tyrosine kinase ZAP70. Previous studies with agonist and antagonist peptides have indicated that ZAP70 might respond differently to different structures of the TCR-CD3 complex induced by bound peptides. The roles of membrane proximity and orientation in activation of ZAP70 signaling were explored using synthetic ligands and their binding proteins designed to produce different architectures of membrane-bound complexes composed of ZAP70 fusion proteins. Transient membrane recruitment of physiological levels of ZAP70 with the membrane-permeable synthetic ligand FK1012A leads to rapid phosphorylation of ZAP70 and activation of the ras/MAPK and Ca2+/calcineurin signaling pathways. ZAP70 SH2 domains are not required for signaling when the kinase is artifically recruited to the membrane, indicating that the SH2 domains function solely in recruitment and not in kinase activation. Using additional synthetic ligands and their binding proteins that recruit ZAP70 equally well but orient it at the cell membrane in different ways, we define a requirement for a specific presentation of ZAP70 to its downstream targets. These results provide a mechanism by which ZAP70, bound to the phosphorylated receptor, could discriminate between conformational changes induced by the binding of different MHC-peptide complexes to the antigen receptor and introduce an approach to exploring the role of spatial orientation of signaling complexes in living cells.     

Effect of pH on the stability and structure of yeast hexokinase A. Acidic amino acid residues in the cleft region are critical for the opening and the closing of the structure

pH and salts have a marked effect on the stability, structure, and function of many globular proteins due to their ability to influence the electrostatic interactions. In this work, calorimetry, CD, and fluorescence studies have been carried out to understand the pH-dependent conformational changes of the two-domain protein yeast hexokinase A. In conjunction with the crystal structural data available, the present results have enabled the complete characterization and analysis of the pH-dependent conformational changes of the enzyme that have strong implications in understanding its structure-function relationship. The calorimetric profiles show a single thermal transition in the acidic pH range, whereas two independent transitions were observed in the alkaline pH range, suggesting the structural merger of the domains at the acidic pH. Comparison of the thermal transitions at pH 8.5 studied by different techniques suggests that the first transition corresponds to the smaller domain, and the second transition corresponds to the larger domain. The acid-denatured state of hexokinase A has high secondary structure content with little or no tertiary interactions and binds to the hydrophobic dye 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid, suggesting that it is a molten globule-like state, whereas the alkali-denatured state is less structured than the acid-denatured state but more structured than the urea-denatured state, suggestive of a premolten globule-like state. Structural analysis using the published hexokinase B structure as well as the hexokinase A structure with the revised amino acid sequence in conjunction with the results obtained by us suggests that the ionization state of the acidic residues at the active site could regulate domain movements that are responsible for the opening and the closure of the cleft between the two domains and in turn affect the structure and function of the enzyme.     

Environmentally modulated phosphorylation and dynamics of proteins in photosynthetic membranes

Recent advances in vectorial proteomics of protein domains exposed to the surface of photosynthetic thylakoid membranes of plants and the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii allowed mapping of in vivo phosphorylation sites in integral and peripheral membrane proteins. In plants, significant changes of thylakoid protein phosphorylation are observed in response to stress, particularly in photosystem II under high light or high temperature stress. Thylakoid protein phosphorylation in the algae is much more responsive to the ambient redox and light conditions, as well as to CO(2) availability. The light-dependent multiple and differential phosphorylation of CP29 linker protein in the green algae is suggested to control photosynthetic state transitions and uncoupling of light harvesting proteins from photosystem II under high light. The similar role for regulation of the dynamic distribution of light harvesting proteins in plants is proposed for the TSP9 protein, which together with other recently discovered peripheral proteins undergoes specific environment- and redox-dependent phosphorylation at the thylakoid surface. This review focuses on the environmentally modulated reversible phosphorylation of thylakoid proteins related to their membrane dynamics and affinity towards particular photosynthetic protein complexes.