Effects of macromolecular crowding on protein folding and aggregation

We have studied the effects of polysaccharide and protein crowding agents on the refolding of oxidized and reduced hen lysozyme in order to test the prediction that association constants of interacting macromolecules in living cells are greatly increased by macromolecular crowding relative to their values in dilute solutions. We demonstrate that whereas refolding of oxidized lysozyme is hardly affected by crowding, correct refolding of the reduced protein is essentially abolished due to aggregation at high concentrations of crowding agents. The results show that the protein folding catalyst protein disulfide isomerase is particularly effective in preventing lysozyme aggregation under crowded conditions, suggesting that crowding enhances its chaperone activity. Our findings suggest that the effects of macromolecular crowding could have major implications for our understanding of how protein folding occurs inside cells.     

Mixed macromolecular crowding accelerates the oxidative refolding of reduced, denatured lysozyme: implications for protein folding in intracellular environments

The oxidative refolding of reduced, denatured hen egg white lysozyme in the presence of a mixed macromolecular crowding agent containing both bovine serum albumin (BSA) and polysaccharide has been studied from a physiological point of view. When the total concentration of the mixed crowding agent is 100 g/liter, in which the weight ratio of BSA to dextran 70 is 1:9, the refolding yield of lysozyme after refolding for 4 h under this condition increases 24% compared with that in the presence of BSA and 16% compared with dextran 70. A remarkable increase in the refolding yield of lysozyme by a mixed crowding agent containing BSA and Ficoll 70 is also observed. Further folding kinetics analyses show that these two mixed crowding agents accelerate the oxidative refolding of lysozyme remarkably, compared with single crowding agents. These results suggest that the stabilization effects of mixed macromolecular crowding agents are stronger than those of single polysaccharide crowding agents such as dextran 70 and Ficoll 70, whereas the excluded volume effects of mixed macromolecular crowding agents are weaker than those of single protein crowding agents such as BSA. Both the refolding yield and the rate of the oxidative refolding of lysozyme in these two mixed crowded solutions with suitable weight ratios are higher than those in single crowded solutions, indicating that mixed macromolecular crowding agents are more favorable to lysozyme folding and can be used to simulate the intracellular environments more accurately than single crowding agents do.     

Mixed macromolecular crowding accelerates the refolding of rabbit muscle creatine kinase: implications for protein folding in physiological environments

The effects of four single macromolecular crowding agents, Ficoll 70, dextran 70, polyethylene glycol (PEG) 2000, and calf thymus DNA (CT DNA), and three mixed crowding agents containing both CT DNA and polysaccharide (or PEG 2000) on the refolding of guanidine hydrochloride-denatured rabbit muscle creatine kinase (MM-CK) have been examined by activity assay. When the total concentration of the mixed crowding agent is 100 g/l, in which the weight ratio of CT DNA to Ficoll 70 is 1:9, the refolding yield of MM-CK after refolding for 3 h under these conditions increases 23% compared with that in the presence of 10 g/l CT DNA, 18% compared with 100 g/l Ficoll 70, and 19% compared with that in the absence of crowding agents. A remarkable increase in the refolding yield of MM-CK by a mixed crowding agent containing CT DNA and dextran 70 (or PEG 2000) is also observed. Further folding kinetics analyses show that these three mixed crowding agents remarkably accelerate the refolding of MM-CK, compared with single crowding agents. Aggregation of MM-CK in the presence of any of the three mixed crowding agents is less serious than that in the presence of a single crowding agent at the same concentration but more serious than that in the absence of crowding agents. Both the refolding yield and the refolding rate of MM-CK in mixtures of these agents are increased relative to the individual agents by themselves, indicating that mixed macromolecular crowding agents are more favorable to MM-CK folding and can be used to reflect the physiological environment more accurately than single crowding agents.     

Lysozyme refolding with cyclodextrins: structure-activity relationship

Cyclodextrins (CDs), in the presence or absence of detergents, have been reported to suppress aggregate formation during the refolding of a number of proteins. A structure-activity relationship study between CD chemistry and refolding of lysozyme was performed and compared to carbonic anhydrase, in order to better understand the mechanism of CD-assisted protein refolding and to identify CDs that could function as good protein folding agents. Among the natural CDs, which have only hydroxyl groups, alpha-CD, with a smaller cavity size was more effective than the oligosaccharide with a larger cavity, gamma-CD. Replacement of the hydroxyls with other functional groups did not improve, but could seriously interfere, with the lysozyme refolding ability of alpha-CD. In case of gamma-CD, substitution of its hydroxyls with other groups either enhanced or diminished its refolding capability towards lysozyme. In general, neutral CDs were better refolding agents than the charged sugars. The presence of anionic substituents like carboxyl and phosphate groups actually promoted aggregate formation and completely abolished the sugar's refolding ability. This effect was more pronounced with lysozyme than with carbonic anhydrase. CDs with cationic functional groups did not show any significant effects on lysozyme refolding. The presence of both anionic and cationic substituents on the same CD molecule was found to partially restore its renaturation ability. Electrophoresis data indicate that CDs, which promoted lysozyme refolding, arrested aggregation at the stage of smaller soluble aggregates. Interestingly, the structure-activity relationship observed with lysozyme was quite similar to that reported for a non-disulfide protein, carbonic anhydrase. These results suggest that the effects of CDs on protein refolding are attributed to their ability to suppress aggregation of proteins. CDs may show properties similar to chaotropic agents, which may help explain their anti-aggregation and protein refolding ability. Besides alpha-CD, a number of other neutral CDs were found to be effective protein folding aids.     

Chaperone and antichaperone activities of trigger factor.

Reduced denatured lysozyme tends to aggregate at neutral pH and competition between productive folding and aggregation substantially reduces the efficiency of refolding. Trigger factor, a folding catalyst and chaperone can, depending on the concentration of trigger factor and the solution conditions, cause either a substantial increase (chaperone activity) or a substantial decrease (antichaperone activity) in the recovery of native lysozyme as compared with spontaneous refolding. When trigger factor is working as a chaperone, the reactivation rates of lysozyme are decelerated and aggregation decreases with increasing trigger factor concentrations. Under conditions where antichaperone activity of trigger factor dominates, the reactivation rates of lysozyme are accelerated and aggregation is increased. Trigger factor and lysozyme were both released from the aggregates on re-solubilization with urea indicating that trigger factor participates directly in aggregate formation and is incorporated into the aggregates. The apparently dual effect of trigger factor toward refolding of lysozyme is a consequence of the peptide binding ability and may be important in regulation of protein biosynthesis.     

Conformational changes of lysozyme refolding intermediates and implications for aggregation and renaturation

It is believed that denatured-reduced lysozyme rapidly forms aggregates during refolding process, which is often worked around by operating at low protein concentrations or in the presence of aggregation inhibitors. However, we found that low concentration buffer alone could efficiently suppress aggregation. Based on this finding, stable equilibrium intermediate states of denatured-reduced lysozyme containing eight free SH groups were obtained in the absence of redox reagents in buffer of low concentrations alone at neutral or mildly alkaline pH. Transition in the secondary structure of the intermediate from native-like to beta-sheet was observed by circular dichroism (CD) as conditions were varied. Dynamic light scattering and ANS-binding studies showed that the self-association accompanied the conformational change and the structure rich in beta-sheet was the intermediate state for aggregation, which could form either amyloid protofibril or amorphous aggregates under different conditions as detected by Electron Microscopy. Combining the results obtained from activity analysis, RP-HPLC and CD, we show that the activity recovery was closely related to the conformation of the refolding intermediate, and buffer of very low concentration (e.g. 10mM) alone could efficiently promote correct refolding by maintaining the native-like secondary structure of the intermediate state. This study reveals reasons for lysozyme aggregation and puts new insights into protein and inclusion body refolding.     

Ion-exchange resins greatly facilitate refolding of like-charged proteins at high concentrations

Protein refolding is a crucial step for the production of therapeutic proteins expressed in bacteria as inclusion bodies. In vitro protein refolding is severely impeded by the aggregation of folding intermediates during the folding process, so inhibition of the aggregation is the most effective approach to high‐efficiency protein refolding. We have herein found that electrostatic repulsion between like‐charged protein and ion exchange gel beads can greatly suppress the aggregation of folding intermediates, leading to the significant increase of native protein recovery. This finding is extensively demonstrated with three different proteins and four kinds of ion‐exchange resins when the protein and ion‐exchange gel are either positively or negatively charged at the refolding conditions. It is remarkable that the enhancing effect is significant at very high protein concentrations, such as 4 mg/mL lysozyme (positively charged) and 2 mg/mL bovine serum albumin (negatively charged). Moreover, the folding kinetics is not compromised by the presence of the resins, so fast protein refolding is realized at high protein concentrations. It was not realistic by any other approaches. The working mechanism of the like‐charged resin is considered due to the charge repulsion that could induce oriented alignment of protein molecules near the charged surface, leading to the inhibition of protein aggregation. The molecular crowding effect induced by the charge repulsion may also contribute to accelerating protein folding. The refolding method with like‐charged ion exchangers is simple to perform, and the key material is easy to separate for recycling. Moreover, because ion exchangers can work as adsorbents of oppositely charged impurities, an operation of simultaneous protein refolding and purification is possible. All the characters are desirable for preparative refolding of therapeutic proteins expressed in bacteria as inclusion bodies. Bioeng. 2011; 108:1068–1077. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Refolding kinetics of denatured-reduced lysozyme in the presence of folding aids

The refolding kinetic behavior of denatured-reduced lysozyme in the presence of folding aids (acetamide, acetone, thiourea, L-arginine or glycerol) was studied utilizing a simplified model describing the competition between first-order folding reaction and third-order aggregation. It was found that the protein folding aids could be categorized into two groups. One of them at proper concentrations, such as acetamide, acetone, thiourea and L-arginine, stabilized unfolded protein or folding intermediates. In the presence of these additives, the folding rate decreased with increasing their concentration, and there existed a concentration where the aggregation rate constant was minimized. So, there was an optimum concentration for the folding aids to produce a high yield. The other group was protein stabilizers such as glycerol. In the presence of this kind of folding aids, both the refolding rate and yield were enhanced by increasing their concentration to a proper value. Moreover, their effect on improving protein refolding was additive to those of the first group. So the cooperative application of the two kinds of folding aids could result in favorable refolding rate and yield of protein.     

Highly nonexponential kinetics in the early-phase refolding of proteins at low temperatures

Theory and simulations predict that the folding kinetics of protein-like heteropolymers become nonexponential and glassy (i.e., controlled by escape from different low-energy misfolded states) at low temperatures, but there was little experimental evidence for such behavior of proteins. We have developed a stopped-flow instrument working reliably down to -40 degrees C with high mixing capability and applied it to study the refolding kinetics of horse cytochrome c (cyt c) and hen egg white lysozyme at temperatures below 0 degrees C in the presence of antifreeze NaCl, LiCl, or ethylene glycol and above 0 degrees C in the presence and absence of antifreeze. The refolding was initiated by rapid dilution of the guanidine hydrochloride unfolded proteins, and the kinetics were monitored by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. Highly nonexponential kinetics extended over 3 decades in time (0.01-10 s) were observed in the early phases of the refolding of cyt c and lysozyme in the temperature range of -35 to 5 degrees C. These results are in agreement with the theoretical prediction, suggesting that the folding energy landscapes of these proteins are rugged in the upper portions.     

Refolding of denatured/reduced lysozyme at high concentrations by artificial molecular chaperone‐ion exchange chromatography

Development of high efficiency and low cost protein refolding methods is a highlighted research focus in biotechnology. Artificial molecular chaperone (AMC) and protein folding liquid chromatography (PFLC) are two attractive refolding methods developed in recent years. In the present work, AMC and one branch of PFLC, ion exchange chromatography (IEC), are integrated to form a new refolding method, artificial molecular chaperone‐ion exchange chromatography (AMC‐IEC). This new method is applied to the refolding of a widely used model protein, urea‐denatured/dithiothreitol‐reduced lysozyme. Many factors influencing the refolding of lysozyme, such as urea concentration, β‐cyclodextrin concentration, molar ratio of detergent to protein, mobile phase flow rate, and type of detergent, were investigated, respectively, to optimize the conditions for lysozyme refolding by AMC‐IEC. Compared with normal IEC refolding method, the activity recoveries of lysozyme obtained by AMC‐IEC were much higher in the investigated range of initial protein concentrations. Moreover, the activity recoveries obtained by using this newly developed refolding method were still quite high for denatured/reduced lysozyme at high initial concentrations. When the initial protein concentration was 200 mg mL^?1, the activity recovery was over 60%. In addition, the lifetime of the chromatographic column during AMC‐IEC was much longer than that during protein refolding by normal IEC. Therefore, AMC‐IEC is a high efficient and low cost protein refolding method. © 2010 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Proline inhibits aggregation during protein refolding

The in vitro refolding of hen egg-white lysozyme is studied in the presence of various osmolytes. Proline is found to prevent aggregation during protein refolding. However, other osmolytes used in this study fail to exhibit a similar property. Experimental evidence suggests that proline inhibits protein aggregation by binding to folding intermediate(s) and trapping the folding intermediate(s) into enzymatically inactive, "aggregation-insensitive" state(s). However, elimination of proline from the refolded protein mixture results in significant recovery of the bacteriolytic activity. At higher concentrations (>1.5 M), proline is shown to form loose, higher-order molecular aggregate(s). The supramolecular assembly of proline is found to possess an amphipathic character. Formation of higher-order aggregates is believed to be crucial for proline to function as a protein folding aid. In addition to its role in osmoregulation under water stress conditions, the results of this study hint at the possibility of proline behaving as a protein folding chaperone.     

Interactions of lysozyme in guanidinium chloride solutions from static and dynamic light-scattering measurements

The interactions of partially unfolded proteins provide insight into protein folding and protein aggregation. In this work, we studied partially unfolded hen egg lysozyme interactions in solutions containing up to 7 M guanidinium chloride (GdnHCl). The osmotic second virial coefficient (B(22)) of lysozyme was measured using static light scattering in GdnHCl aqueous solutions at 20 degrees C and pH 4.5. B(22) is positive in all solutions, indicating repulsive protein-protein interactions. At low GdnHCl concentrations, B(22) decreases with rising ionic strength: in the absence of GdnHCl, B(22) is 1.1 x 10(-3) mLmol/g(2), decreasing to 3.0 x 10(-5) mLmol/g(2) in the presence of 1 M GdnHCl. Lysozyme unfolds in solutions at GdnHCl concentrations higher than 3 M. Under such conditions, B(22) increases with ionic strength, reaching 8.0 x 10(-4) mLmol/g(2) at 6.5 M GdnHCl. Protein-protein hydrodynamic interactions were evaluated from concentration-dependent diffusivity measurements, obtained from dynamic light scattering. At moderate GdnHCl concentrations, lysozyme interparticle interactions are least repulsive and hydrodynamic interactions are least attractive. The lysozyme hydrodynamic radius was calculated from infinite-dilution diffusivity and did not change significantly during protein unfolding. Our results contribute toward better understanding of protein interactions of partially unfolded states in the presence of a denaturant; they may be helpful for the design of protein refolding processes that avoid protein aggregation.     

Folding of the alphaII-spectrin SH3 domain under physiological salt conditions

The SH3 domain has often been used as a model for protein folding due to its typical two-state behaviour. However, recent experimental data at low pH as well as molecular dynamic simulations have indicated that the folding process of SH3 probably is more complicated, and may involve intermediate states. Using both kinetic and equilibrium measurements we have obtained evidence that under native-like conditions the folding of the spectrin SH3 domain does not follow a classic two-state behaviour. The curvature we observed in the Chevron plots is a strong indication of a non-linear activation energy relationship due to the presence of high-energy intermediates. In addition, circular dichroism measurements indicated that refolding after thermal denaturation did not follow the same pattern as thermal unfolding but rather implied less cooperativity and that the refolding transition increased with increasing protein concentration. Further, NMR experiments indicated that upon refolding the SH3 domain gave rise to more than one conformation. Therefore, our results suggest that the folding of the SH3 domain of αII-spectrin does not follow a classical two-state process under high-salt conditions and neutral pH. Heterogeneous folding pathways, which can include folding intermediates as well as misfolded intermediates, might give a more reasonable insight into the folding behaviour of the αII-spectrin SH3 domain.     

Effect of ethanol on folding of hen egg-white lysozyme under acidic condition

The equilibrium and kinetics of folding of hen egg-white lysozyme were studied by means of CD spectroscopy in the presence of varying concentrations of ethanol under acidic condition. The equilibrium transition curves of guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding in 13 and 26% (v/v) ethanol have shown that the unfolding significantly deviates from a two-state mechanism. The kinetics of denaturant-induced refolding and unfolding of hen egg-white lysozyme were investigated by stopped-flow CD at three ethanol concentrations: 0, 13, and 26% (v/v). Immediately after dilution of the denaturant, the refolding curves showed a biphasic time course in the far-UV region, with a burst phase with a significant secondary structure and a slower observable phase. However, when monitored by the near-UV CD, the burst phase was not observed and all refolding kinetics were monophasic. To clarify the effect of nonnative secondary structure induced by the addition of ethanol on the folding/unfolding kinetics, the kinetic m values were estimated from the chevron plots obtained for the three ethanol concentrations. The data indicated that the folding/unfolding kinetics of hen lysozyme in the presence of varying concentrations of ethanol under acidic condition is explained by a model with both on-pathway and off-pathway intermediates of protein folding.     

Oxidative renaturation of lysozyme at high concentrations

Newly synthesized cloned gene proteins expressed in bacteria frequently accumulate in insoluble aggregates or inclusion bodies. Active protein can be recovered by solubilization of inclusion bodies followed by renaturation of the solubilized (unfolded) protein. The recovery of active protein is highly dependent on the renaturation conditions chosen. The renaturation process is generally conducted at low protein concentrations (0.01-0.2 mg/mL) to avoid aggregation. We have investigated the potential of successfully refolding reduced and denatured hen egg white lysozyme at high concentrations (1 and 5 mg/mL). By varying the composition of the renaturation media, optimum conditions which kinetically favor proper folding over inactivation were found. Solubilizing agents such as guanidinium chloride (GdmCl) and folding aids such as L-arginine present in low concentrations during refolding effectively enhanced renaturation yields by suppressing aggregation resulting in reactivation yields as high as 95%. Quantitatively the kinetic competition between lysozyme folding and aggregation can be described using first-order kinetics for the renaturation reaction and third-order kinetics for the overall aggregation pathway. The rate constants for both reactions have been found to be strongly dependent on denaturant and thiol concentration. This strategy supercedes the necessity to reactivate proteins at low concentrations using large renaturation volumes. The marked increase in volumetric productivity makes this a viable option for recovering biologically active protein efficiently and in high yield in vitro from proteins produced as inclusion bodies within microbial cells. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 54: 221-230, 1997.     

Mechanism of Gemini Disulfide Detergent Mediated Oxidative Refolding of Lysozyme in a New Artificial Chaperone System

Gemini surfactants are a new class of surfactants that consist of two hydrophilic head groups and two hydrophobic tails separated by a spacer group. As the properties of geminis are different to their monomeric counterparts, a large number of applications have been investigated. Here we report on the use of a new class of gemini detergents containing a disulfide bond in the spacer (Det-SS-Det) for protein refolding. Using lysozyme as a model protein we could demonstrate that the disulfide gemini detergents allow oxidative refolding of the protein in the absence of any external redox system in an “artificial chaperone system”. Refolding kinetics using gemini disulfide detergents differing in their hydrophobicity were analysed to determine the folding and aggregation rate constants. The results point to an important role of the transiently formed mixed disulfides between the protein and the detergent (Prot-SS-Det) in the oxidative refolding process of lysozyme.     

Statistical optimization and multiple objective programming of lysozyme refolding catalyzed by recombinant DsbA in vitro

DsbA (disulfide bond formation protein A) is essential for disulfide bond formation directly affecting the nascent peptides folding to the correct conformation in vivo. In this paper, recombinant DsbA protein was employed to catalyze denatured lysozyme refolding and inhibit the aggregation of folding intermediates in vitro. Statistical methods, i.e., Plackett–Burman design and small central composite design, were adopted to screen out important factors affecting the refolding process and correlating these parameters with the refolding efficiency including both protein recovery and specific activity of refolded lysozyme. Four important parameters: initial lysozyme concentration, urea concentration, KCl concentration and GSSG (glutathione disulfide) concentration were picked out and operating conditions were optimized by introducing the effectiveness coefficient method and transforming the multiple objective programming into an ordinary constrained optimization issue. Finally, 99.7% protein recovery and 25,600 U/mg specific activity of lysozyme were achieved when 281.35 μg/mL denatured lysozyme refolding was catalyzed by an equivalent molar of DsbA at the optimal settings. The results indicated that recombinant DsbA protein could effectively catalyze the oxidized formation and reduced isomerization of intramolecular disulfide bonds in the refolding of lysozyme in vitro.     

A photochemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization study of denatured states of lysozyme

Photochemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization (photo-CIDNP) techniques have been used to examine denatured states of lysozyme produced under a variety of conditions. 1H CIDNP difference spectra of lysozyme denatured thermally, by the addition of 10 M urea, or by the complete reduction of its four disulfide bonds were found to differ substantially not only from the spectrum of the native protein but also from that expected for a completely unstructured polypeptide chain. Specifically, denatured lysozyme showed a much reduced enhancement of tryptophan relative to tyrosine than did a mixture of blocked amino acids with the same composition as the intact protein. By contrast, the CIDNP spectrum of lysozyme denatured in dimethyl sulfoxide solution was found to be similar to that expected for a random coil. It is proposed that nonrandom hydrophobic interactions are present within the denatured states of lysozyme in aqueous solution and that these reduce the reactivity of tryptophan residues relative to tyrosine residues. Characterization of such interactions is likely to be of considerable significance for an understanding of the process of protein folding.     

Organic cosolvents and hen egg white lysozyme folding

Studies on the influence of organic cosolvents on lysozyme folding have been reported. As most of the researches are confined to a few specific molecules and focus on equilibrium states, less is known about the effect on folding dynamics. We have studied the influence of six soluble organic cosolvents on hen egg white lysozyme heat induced denaturation and refolding dynamics. It was found that trifluoroethanol (TFE) can change the folding pathway significantly. With the presence of TFE, the overshot phenomenon generally observed in lysozyme folding at 222 nm disappears. The common mechanism of how organic cosolvents influence folding is analyzed. The heat induced denaturation temperature was found to have a quantitative relationship with the slow phase rate constant during folding. We discuss this finding and hypothesize that it is due to the similar influence of organic cosolvent on the transition state of heat denaturation and refolding.     

Folding pathway of FKBP12 and characterisation of the transition state.

The folding pathway of human FKBP12, a 12 kDa FK506-binding protein (immunophilin), has been characterised. Unfolding and refolding rate constants have been determined over a wide range of denaturant concentrations and data are shown to fit to a two-state model of folding in which only the denatured and native states are significantly populated, even in the absence of denaturant. This simple model for folding, in which no intermediate states are significantly populated, is further supported from stopped-flow circular dichroism experiments in which no fast "burst" phases are observed. FKBP12, with 107 residues, is the largest protein to date which folds with simple two-state kinetics in water (kF=4 s(-1)at 25 degrees C). The topological crossing of two loops in FKBP12, a structural element suggested to cause kinetic traps during folding, seems to have little effect on the folding pathway.The transition state for folding has been characterised by a series of experiments on wild-type FKBP12. Information on the thermodynamic nature of, the solvent accessibility of, and secondary structure in, the transition state was obtained from experiments measuring the unfolding and refolding rate constants as a function of temperature, denaturant concentration and trifluoroethanol concentration. In addition, unfolding and refolding studies in the presence of ligand provided information on the structure of the ligand-binding pocket in the transition state. The data suggest a compact transition state relative to the unfolded state with some 70 % of the surface area buried. The ligand-binding site, which is formed mainly by two loops, is largely unstructured in the transition state. The trifluoroethanol experiments suggest that the alpha-helix may be formed in the transition state. These results are compared with results from protein engineering studies and molecular dynamics simulations (see the accompanying paper).