On time dependency of frequency and distribution of chromatid aberrations induced by mutagens with delayed effects. An interpretation

This paper provides a theoretical analysis of pecularities of both the frequency and intrachromosomal distribution of chromatid aberrations observed in the first post-treatment mitosis and induced by clastogenic agents showing delayed effects (S-phase dependent clastogens), as functions of recovery time. The theoretical deductions are based on the following facts: (1) DNA is the target of clastogen action. Lesions induced by clastogens showing delayed effects (e.g. mono- and polyfunctional alkylating agents, ultraviolet light) give rise to aberrations only after interference with the process(es) associated with DNA replication. (2) DNA replication occurs asynchronously with respect to the local involvement in replication of different chromatin regions and according to a highly ordered pattern. (3) Lesions may be removed from DNA (or otherwise modified) by repair processes prior to replication. The removal of lesions from DNA is a time-dependent function.Several possibilities are analysed (i.e. random or non-random distribution of DNA lesions, uniform or locally differing capacities of pre-replicative repair of lesions, uniform or locally differing rates of DNA synthesis) and the frequencies and distribution patterns of chromosome structural changes, as expressed in form of aberration yield-time curves, have been discussed. The theory presented in this paper offers a simple interpretation both of variations of aberration frequency and aberration distribution in dependence on the cell's position within the cell cycle during induction of lesions.It is shown that the intrachromosomal aberration distribution is non-random even if random distribution of lesions and uniform repair rates between chromosome regions replicating at different time periods during S are assumed. Non-random aberration distributions are a necessary consequence of at least two factors: (a) the temporal replication pattern, and (b) the repair activities acting prior to replication. Random distribution of aberrations is only to be expected for the most simplified situation (random distribution of lesions along the DNA and equal transformation probabilities of a given kind of lesion into aberrations) when no loss of lesions prior to replication takes place (no pre-replicative repair) and cells treated with the mutagen during G1 are analysed.     

Molecular mechanisms of the origin of chromosome aberrations and the structural organisation of eukaryotic DNA

Summary A new hypothesis on the appearance of exchange chromosomal aberrations has been suggested. According to this hypothesis, temporal duplex polynucleotide structure should arise during G₁ and G₂ phases during the correction of DNA. The size of the duplex, as a rule, should be restricted to the size of complementary nucleotide sequences in the regions of repetitions. Any polynucleotide break in a duplex zone would result in chromosome breakage and if complementary broken ends interact with each other, then exchange chromosome aberrations may be formed. This hypothesis would explain such previously obscure phenomena as extremely high frequencies of exchanges after mutagen treatment, the nature of mitotic crossing-over, negative interference, change of aberration types before replication, the low frequency of damaged structural genes during aberration formation, etc.     

The stage of chromosome duplication in the cell cycle as revealed by X-ray breakage and 3H-thymidine labeling

By means of combined experiments of X-irradiation and ³H-thymidine labeling of the chromosomes which are in the phase of synthesis, and the subsequent analysis at metaphase on the autoradiographs of the chromosomal damage induced during interphase, it was shown that in somatic cells from a quasi-diploid Chinese hamster line cultured in vitro the chromosomes change their response to radiation from single (chromosome type aberrations) to double (chromatid type aberrations) in late G₁. These results are interpreted to indicate that the chromosome splits into two chromatids in G₁, before DNA replication. — By extending the observations at the second metaphase after irradiation, it was also seen that cells irradiated while in G₂ or late S when they reach the second post-irradiation mitosis still exhibit, beside chromosome type aberrations, many chromatid exchanges, some of which are labeled. Two hypotheses are suggested to account for this unexpected reappearance of chromatid aberrations at the second post-irradiation division. The first hypothesis is that they arise from half-chromatid aberrations. The second hypothesis, which derives from a new interpretation of the mechanisms of production of chromosome aberrations recently forwarded by Evans, is that they arise from gaps or achromatic lesions which undergo, as the cells go through the next cycle, a two-step repair process culminating in the production of aberrations.This work was supported in part by grant No. RH-00304 from the Division of Radiological Health, Bureau of State Services, Public Health Service, U.S.A.     

Chromosome and DNA damage and their repair in higher plants irradiated with short-wave ultraviolet light

In this review the authors present only their own results. They include the determination of the duration of the different stages of the cell cylce in UV-irradiated barley cells, the effect of different UV doses on the frequency of chromosome aberrations in barley, the increase in UV-induced chromosome aberration frequency induced in barley by caffeine and the effect of UV doses on the induction of pyrimidine dimers and sites sensitive to UV-endonuclease action (ESS) in barley cells and Nicotina tabacum protoplasts. In addition, the excision of pyrimidine dimers and ESS after irradiation with various doses of UV, unscheduled DNA synthesis in N. tabacum protoplasts and the correlation between the induction of pyrimidine dimers in DNA and the frequency of chromosome aberrations are reported. Data demonstrating that photoreactivation decrease the number of DNA lesions and chromosome aberrations induced by UV are also presented.     

UV-induced chromatid aberrations in cultured Chinese hamster cells after one, two, or three rounds of DNA replication

Synchronized G₁ or G₂ Chinese hamster cells were irradiated with UV light or X-rays and analyzed for chromosomal aberrations after one, two, or three replications. The cells were treated with Colcemid to induce polyploidy so that 2N, 4N, and 8N cells were scored. UV irradiation of G₁ cells induces mainly chromatid aberrations, whereas X-rays induce chromosome aberrations. After both types of radiation chromatid aberrations appear in the polyploid cells. These results can be interpreted as indicating that UV and X-rays induce lesions at the subchromatid level that cannot be expressed until one or two replications have occurred. Since UV can induce long-lived lesions, the UV data do not allow us to choose between mononemic and polynemic models of the chromosome. X-rays, however, are ionizing radiations that might not produce long-lived lesions. The X-ray data, therefore, are more easily interpretable in terms of lesions being induced in the subunits of a polynemic chromosome.     

Variations in Several Responses of HeLa Cells to X-Irradiation during the Division Cycle

Several responses of synchronized populations of HeLa S3 cells were measured after irradiation with 220 kev x-rays at selected times during the division cycle. (1) Survival (colony-forming ability) is maximal when cells are irradiated in the early post-mitotic (G₁) and the pre-mitotic (G₂) phases of the cycle, and minimal in the mitotic (M) and late G₁ or early DNA synthetic (S) phases. (2) Markedly different growth patterns result from irradiation in different phases: (a) Prolongation of interphase (division delay) is minimal when cells are irradiated early in G₁ and rises progressively through the remainder of the cycle. (b) Cells irradiated while in mitosis are not delayed in that division, but the succeeding division is delayed. (c) Persistence of cells as metabolizing entities does not depend on the phase of the division cycle in which they are irradiated. (3) Characteristic perturbations of the normal DNA synthetic cycle occur: (a) Cells irradiated in M suffer a small delay in the onset of S, a slight prolongation of S, and a slight depression in the rate of DNA synthesis; the major delay occurs in G₂. (b) Cells irradiated in G₁ show no delay in the onset of S, and essentially no alteration in the duration or rate of DNA synthesis; G₂ delay is minimal. (c) Cells irradiated in S suffer an appreciable S prolongation and a decreased rate of DNA synthesis; G₂ delay is shorter than S delay.     

Proceedings: Heterochromatin and chromosome aberrations: a comparative study of normal and tumour cells of mouse with various distributions of heterochromatin.

Seedlings of Crepis capillaris were irradiated after pulse-labelling with tritiated thymidine ([³H]TdR), and both chromosomal aberrations and presence of silver grains were recorded in the same metaphase cells at various intervals throughout the whole mitotic cycle. The following results were obtained: (a) irradiated roots were homogeneous with respect to the number of aberrations, and heterogenous with respect to labelling index (LI); (b) time-effect curves for labelled (L) and unlabelled (U) cells showed no significant difference from one another; (c) no significant quantitative difference of aberration spectra produced in S and G₂ stages was found. These results support the view that the major factor which determines both quantitative and qualitative variation in the production of chromosomal aberrations by radiation is the time lapse between irradiation and fixation rather than relation of the time of irradiation to the time of DNA synthesis. In addition, it was found that labelling with [³H]TdR modifies the effect of radiation on chromosomes.     

Chromosome aberrations and radiation-induced cell death. I. Transmission and survival parameters of aberrations

Synchronous cultures of V₇₉ Chinese hamster cells were irradiated in G₁ with 300 rad of X-rays. Cells were collected for 2-h intervals after synchronization to include the first three post-irradiation divisions and were scored for chromosome aberrations. After the first post-irradiation division, asymmetrical exchanges were distributed according to the Poisson formula and both the asymmetrical exchange frequency and the acentric fragment frequency exhibited significant variations with collection time. Formulae derived from a previous mathematical analysis were used in conjunction with the aberration frequencies observed at the first, second, and third post-irradiation divisions to predict transmission and survival parameters for specific chromosomal aberrations.The probability, 2T, that an acentric fragment will be transmitted to a daughter cell at anaphase was found to be 0.57. The probability, W, that a two-break aberration (asymmetrical exchange) will be transmitted and observed at the next division was 0.56. Finally, the probability, P, that a cell will survive to a subsequent mitosis after losing a single acentric fragment was about 1.0 for one post-irradiation generation but somewhat less for two generations.     

The induction of chromosome-type aberrations in G1 by methyl methanesulfonate and 4-nitroquinoline-N-oxide,and the non-requirement of an S-phase for their production

Human lymphocyte were treated in G₁ with 4-nitroquinoline-N-oxide (4NQO) and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) and then incubated in the presence or absence of cytosine arabinoside (ara-C). There was an increase in aberration frequency in those cells incubated with ara-C compared with those treated with 4NQO or MMS alone. This increase was restricted to chromosome-type aberrations. When cells were treated in G₂ with 4NQO and then incubated with ara-C until fixation, there was an increase in deletions compared with cells treated with 4NQO alone. No exchange aberrations were observed following any treatment even when deletion frequencies were high, as in the case with 4NQO plus ara-C treatment. These results suggest that ara-C can inhibit the repair of DNA damage induced by 4NQO and MMS that is converted into aberrations. They also show that the terms “S-dependent” and “S-independent” used to describe the modes of action of chemical clastogens are not valid.     

Molecular mechanisms involved in the production of cromosomal aberrations II. Utilization of neurospora endonuclease for the study of aberration production by X-rays in G1 and G2 stages of the cell cycle

Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO) were X-irradiated in G₁ and G₂ stages of the cell cycle and subsequently Neurospora endonuclease (NE) (E.C.3.1.4), an enzyme which is specific in cleaving single-stranded DNA, was introduced into the cells, after making the cells permeable by treatment with inactivated Sendai virus. With this treatment all classes of X-ray-induced chromatid aberrations increased in G₂ cells, whereas in G₁ cells an increase in cromosome type of aberrations was found, associated with a profound induction of chromatid type of aberrations as well. Duration of the availability of single-strand gaps for the action of NE has been studied in G₂ cells following X-irradiation and the influence of different parts of the G₂ stage on the type and frequencies of chromatid aberrations was discerned. While the increase in chromosome type of aberrations by NE in X-irradiated G₁ cells has been interpreted as due to the conversion of DNA single-strand breaks or gaps to double-strand breaks by NE, the induction of chromatid aberrations in G₁ has been assumed to be due to conversion of some of the damaged bases strand breaks by NE. Biochemical evidence is presented for the conversion by NE of DNA single-strand breaks induced by X-rays into double-strand breaks using neutral sucrose gradient centrifugation.     

Influence of caffeine and 3-aminobenzamide in G2 on the frequency of chromosomal aberrations induced by thiotepa,mitomycin C and N-methyl-N-nitro-N′-nitrosoguanidine in human lymphocytes

The effects of post-treatments with caffeine in G₂ on the frequency of chromosomal aberrations induced by thiotepa, mitomycin C and N-methyl-N-nitro-N′-nitrosoguanidine were studied in human lymphocytes. Caffeine was found to potentiate the frequency of chromatid aberrations induced by all 3 S-dependent agents tested; the most striking enhancement being obtained when caffeine was present during the last 1.5 h before harvesting. Post-treatments in G₂ with 3-aminobenzamide had no influence on the aberration frequency induced by thiotepa and N-methyl-N-nitro-N′-nitrosoguanidine.     

Extent of excision repair before DNA synthesis determines the mutagenic but not the lethal effect of UV radiation

Excision repair-proficient diploid fibroblasts from normal persons (NF) and repair-deficient cells from a xeroderma pigmentosum patient (XP12BE, group A) were grown to confluence and allowed to enter the G₀ state. Autoradiography studies of cells released from G₀ after 72 h and replated at lower densities (3?9 × 10³ cells/cm²) in fresh medium containing 15% fetal bovine serum showed that semiconservative DNA synthesis (S phase) began ～24 h after the replating. To determine whether the time available for DNA excision repair between ultraviolet irradiation (254 nm) and the onset of DNA synthesis was critical in determining the cytotoxic and/or mutagenic effect of UV in human fibroblasts, we released cultures of NF or XP12BE cells from G₀, allowed them to reattach at lower densities, irradiated them in early G₁ (～18 h prior to the onset of S) or just prior to S phase, and assayed the frequency of mutations to 6-thioguanine resistance and the survival of colony-forming ability. The XP12BE cells, which are virtually incapable of excising UV-induced DNA lesions, showed approximately the same frequency of mutations and survival regardless of the time of UV irradiation. In NF cells, the slope of the dose response for mutations induced in cells irradiated just prior to S was about 7-fold steeper than that of cells irradiated 18 h earlier. However, the two sets of NF cells showed no significant difference in survival. Neither were there significant differences in the survival of NF cells released from G₀, plated at cloning densities and irradiated as soon as they had attached and flattened out (～20 h prior to S) or 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 or 24 h later. We conclude that the frequency of mutations induced by UV is dependent upon the number of unexcised lesions remaining at the time of semi-conservative DNA replication. However, the amount of time available for excision of potentially cytotoxic lesions is not determined primarily by the period between irradiation and the onset of S phase.     

Mammalian cell fusion

The behaviour of heterochromatin during premature chromosome condensation (PCC) was studied in a cell line of Microtus agrestis after fusion with mitotic HeLa cells. In the G₁- and G₂-PCC, the heterochromatic nature of the X-chromosomes was detectable by their intense staining. The pulverized appearance of the S-phase PCC was correlated with incorporation of ³H TdR into the DNA. Three types of S-PCC were observed. PCC with a pulverized appearance of: (a) only the autosomes (early S); (b) autosomes and X-chromosomes (mid S); and (c) only the X-chromosomes (late S). The behaviour of heterochromatin during replication, as observed by the PCC method, was no different from that of euchromatin. The data on the sequence of chromosome replication indicate that the centromeric regions of the X-chromosomes were the last segments to replicate. The completion of DNA synthesis in the X-chromosomes appears to be followed by progressive chromosome condensation during G₂ even before the actual initiation of prophase.     

Factors Limiting the Number of Radiation-Induced Chromosome Exchanges : I. Distance: Evidence from Non-Interaction of x-Ray— and Neutron-Induced Breaks

Soaked seeds of Vicia faba were exposed to fractionated doses of x-rays or x-rays and fast neutrons. When the two-hit (exchange) chromosome aberrations were scored at the first mitosis of the root tip, it was observed that with short fractionation times the radiation-induced breaks from the two x-ray doses could rejoin with one another to form exchanges in proportion to the square of the total dose. If, however, one dose was x-rays and the second neutrons, then no quantitatively determinable interaction occurred between the breaks induced by each of the doses, and the aberration yield was simply the sum of that induced by each fraction. The phenomenon of non-interaction as observed by these dose fractionation studies and also by the linear dose response curve for two-break aberrations induced by neutrons has led to calculations of the distance over which two breaks can rejoin. The distance is evidently much smaller than the previously accepted value of 1 µ.     

The cytogenetic effects of aflatoxin and gamma-rays on human leukocytes in vitro

Chromosomes from human leukocyte cultures in vitro were treated with γ-rays (200 R), aflatoxin (50 μg/ml, dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)) and with a combination of both. At the time of treatment (48 h) cells were in all stages of interphase but G₁ cells were evidently predominant. All types of chromosome aberration were observed. Frequencies of chromosome-type aberrations were much higher than those of chromatid type after γ-ray treatment, but these types of chromosome aberration did not differ greatly when the cultures were treated with aflatoxin. Apparently the cytogenetic effect of aflatoxin was delayed longer than was that of irradiation. The present data also suggest the additive effect of γ-rays and aflatoxin in the combined treatment.     

Analysis of restriction enzyme-induced DNA double-strand breaks in Chinese hamster ovary cells by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis: implications for chromosome damage.

Restriction enzymes can be electroporated into mammalian cells, and the induced DNA double-strand breaks can lead to aberrations in metaphase chromosomes. Chinese hamster ovary cells were electroporated with PstI, which generates 3' cohesive-end breaks, PvuII, which generates blunt-end breaks, or XbaI, which generates 5' cohesive-end breaks. Although all three restriction enzymes induced similar numbers of aberrant metaphase cells, PvuII was dramatically more effective at inducing both exchange-type and deletion-type chromosome aberrations. Our cytogenetic studies also indicated that enzymes are active within cells for only a short time. We used pulsed-field gel electrophoresis to investigate (i) how long it takes for enzymes to cleave DNA after electroporation into cells, (ii) how long enzymes are active in the cells, and (iii) how the DNA double-strand breaks induced are related to the aberrations observed in metaphase chromosomes. At the same concentrations used in the cytogenetic studies, all enzymes were active within 10 min of electroporation. PstI and PvuII showed a distinct peak in break formation at 20 min, whereas XbaI showed a gradual increase in break frequency over time. Another increase in the number of breaks observed with all three enzymes at 2 and 3 h after electroporation was probably due to nonspecific DNA degradation in a subpopulation of enzyme-damaged cells that lysed after enzyme exposure. Break frequency and chromosome aberration frequency were inversely related: The blunt-end cutter PvuII gave rise to the most aberrations but the fewest breaks, suggesting that it is the type of break rather than the break frequency that is important for chromosome aberration formation.     

Induction of meiosis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae at different points in the mitotic cycle

Summary Saccharomyces cells induced to undergo meiosis when in late G ₁ or early S-phase, proceed mitotically until a point between completion of the S-phase and nuclear division. From that point, the cells start meiotic development without intervention of a round of premeiotic DNA replication. Cells induced at any other point in the cell cycle, enter meiosis from G ₁.     

Effects of Caffeine on Radiation-Induced Phenomena Associated with Cell-Cycle Traverse of Mammalian Cells

Caffeine induced a state of G₁ arrest when added to an exponentially growing culture of Chinese hamster cells (line CHO). In addition to its effect on cell-cycle traverse, caffeine ameliorated a number of the responses of cells to ionizing radiation. The duration of the division delay period following X-irradiation of caffeine-treated cells was reduced, and the magnitude of reduction was dependent on caffeine concentration. Cells irradiated during the DNA synthetic phase in the presence of caffeine were delayed less in their exit from S, measured autoradiographically, and the radiation-induced reduction of radioactive thymidine incorporation into DNA was lessened. Cells synchronized by isoleucine deprivation, while being generally less sensitive to the effects of ionizing radiation than mitotically synchronized cells, were equally responsive to the effects of caffeine. The X-ray-induced reduction of phosphorylation of lysine-rich histone F1 was less in caffeine-treated cells than in untreated cells. Finally, survival after irradiation was only slightly reduced in caffeine-treated cells. A possible role of cyclic AMP in cell-cycle traverse of irradiated cells is discussed.     

Types and frequencies of chromosomal aberrations induced by irradiation of different parts of interphase in Crepis capillaris

Quantitative and qualitative estimates of chromosomal damage in roots of Crepis capillaris were made in metaphase cells at many time intervals after irradiation with 200 or 400 rad of ⁶⁰Co gamma-rays. The results have confirmed the general pattern described for cells of other organisms, and have revealed in addition the following new facts. (1) The formation of aberrations of chromosome and chromatid type is not determined by the time of chromosome duplication alone. (2) The relative frequencies of different types of discontinuity form peaks with the following time succession: single gaps, chromatid breaks, isolocus breaks. (3) The location of peaks does not depend on the radiation dose, and shows no correlation which the time of synthesis. (4) Irradiation of G₂ induces a significant number of chromosome-type exchanges in Crepis. (5) Higher doses of radiation in G₂ favour the formation of chromatid over chromosome exchanges and of isochromatid breaks over chromosome breaks. A new interpretation of the production of certain types of aberration is discussed.