Correlation between Supercoiling and Conformational Motions of the Bacterial Flagellar Filament

The bacterial flagellar filament is a very large macromolecular assembly of a single protein, flagellin. Various supercoiled states of the filament exist, which are formed by two structurally different conformations of flagellin in different ratios. We investigated the correlation between supercoiling of the protofilaments and molecular dynamics in the flagellar filament using quasielastic and elastic incoherent neutron scattering on the picosecond and nanosecond timescales. Thermal fluctuations in the straight L- and R-type filaments were measured and compared to the resting state of the wild-type filament. Amplitudes of motion on the picosecond timescale were found to be similar in the different conformational states. Mean-square displacements and protein resilience on the 0.1 ns timescale demonstrate that the L-type state is more flexible and less resilient than the R-type, whereas the wild-type state lies in between. Our results provide strong support that supercoiling of the protofilaments in the flagellar filament is determined by the strength of molecular forces in and between the flagellin subunits.     

Building the atomic model for the bacterial flagellar filament by electron cryomicroscopy and image analysis

The bacterial flagellar filament is a helical propeller for bacterial locomotion. It is a well-ordered helical assembly of a single protein, flagellin, and its tubular structure is formed by 11 protofilaments, each in either of the two distinct conformations, L- and R-type, for supercoiling. We have been studying the three-dimensional structures of the flagellar filaments by electron cryomicroscopy and recently obtained a density map of the R-type filament up to 4 angstroms resolution from an image data set containing only about 41,000 molecular images. The density map showed the features of the alpha-helical backbone and some large side chains, which allowed us to build the complete atomic model as one of the first atomic models of macromolecules obtained solely by electron microscopy image analysis (Yonekura et al., 2003a). We briefly review the structure and the structure analysis, and point out essential techniques that have made this analysis possible.     

Key Amino Acid Residues Involved in the Transitions of L- to R-Type Protofilaments of the Salmonella Flagellar Filament

The flagellar filament enables bacteria to swim by functioning as a helical propeller. The filament is a supercoiled assembly of a single protein, flagellin, and is formed by 11 protofilaments arranged in a circle. Bacterial swimming and tumbling correlate with changes of the various helical structures, called polymorphic transformation, that are determined by the ratios of two distinct forms of protofilaments, the L and R types. The polymorphic transformation is caused by transition of the protofilament between L and R types. Elucidation of this transition mechanism has been addressed by comparing the atomic structures of L- and R-type straight filaments or using massive molecular dynamic simulation. Here, we found amino acid residues required for the transition of the protofilament using fliC-intragenic suppressor analysis. We isolated a number of revertants producing supercoiled filaments from mutants with straight filaments and identified the second-site mutations in all of the revertants. The results suggest that Asp107, Gly426, and Ser448 and Ser106, Ala416, Ala427, and Arg431 are the key residues involved in inducing supercoiled filaments from the R- and the L-type straight filaments, respectively. Considering the structures of the R- and L-type protofilaments and the relationship between the rotation of the flagellar motor and the polymorphic transformation, we propose that Gly426, Ala427, and Arg431 contribute to the first stage of the transition and that Ser106, Asp107, and Ala416 play a role in propagating the transitions along the flagellar filament.     

Role of flagellar hydrogen bonding in Salmonella motility and flagellar polymorphic transition

Bacterial flagellar filaments are assembled by tens of thousands flagellin subunits, forming 11 helically arranged protofilaments. Each protofilament can take either of the two bistable forms L‐type or R‐type, having slightly different conformations and inter‐protofilaments interactions. By mixing different ratios of L‐type and R‐type protofilaments, flagella adopt multiple filament polymorphs and promote bacterial motility. In this study, we investigated the hydrogen bonding networks at the flagellin crystal packing interface in Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium (S. typhimurium) by site‐directed mutagenesis of each hydrogen bonded residue. We identified three flagellin mutants D108A, N133A and D152A that were non‐motile despite their fully assembled flagella. Mutants D108A and D152A trapped their flagellar filament into inflexible right‐handed polymorphs, which resemble the previously predicted 3L/8R and 4L/7R helical forms in Calladine’s model but have never been reported in vivo. Mutant N133A produces floppy flagella that transform flagellar polymorphs in a disordered manner, preventing the formation of flagellar bundles. Further, we found that the hydrogen bonding interactions around these residues are conserved and coupled to flagellin L/R transition. Therefore, we demonstrate that the hydrogen bonding networks formed around flagellin residues D108, N133 and D152 greatly contribute to flagellar bending, flexibility, polymorphisms and bacterial motility.     

Filaments from Ignicoccus hospitalis Show Diversity of Packing in Proteins Containing N-Terminal Type IV Pilin Helices

Bacterial motility is driven by the rotation of flagellar filaments that supercoil. The supercoiling involves the switching of coiled-coil protofilaments between two different states. In archaea, the flagellar filaments responsible for motility are formed by proteins with distinct homology in their N-terminal portion to bacterial Type IV pilins. The bacterial pilins have a single N-terminal hydrophobic α-helix, not the coiled coil found in flagellin. We have used electron cryo-microscopy to study the adhesion filaments from the archaeon Ignicoccus hospitalis. While I. hospitalis is non-motile, these filaments make transitions between rigid stretches and curved regions and appear morphologically similar to true archaeal flagellar filaments. A resolution of ~ 7.5 Å allows us to unambiguously build a model for the packing of these N-terminal α-helices, and this packing is different from several bacterial Type IV pili whose structure has been analyzed by electron microscopy and modeling. Our results show that the mechanism responsible for the supercoiling of bacterial flagellar filaments cannot apply to archaeal filaments.     

Mesoscopic modeling of bacterial flagellar microhydrodynamics

A particle-based hybrid method of elastic network model and smooth-particle hydrodynamics has been employed to describe the propulsion of bacterial flagella in a viscous hydrodynamic environment. The method explicitly models the two aspects of bacterial propulsion that involve flagellar flexibility and long-range hydrodynamic interaction of low-Reynolds-number flow. The model further incorporates the molecular organization of the flagellar filament at a coarse-grained level in terms of the 11 protofilaments. Each of these protofilaments is represented by a collection of material points that represent the flagellin proteins. A computational model of a single flexible helical segment representing the filament of a bacterial flagellum is presented. The propulsive dynamics and the flow fields generated by the motion of the model filament are examined. The nature of flagellar deformation and the influence of hydrodynamics in determining the shape of deformations are examined based on the helical filament.     

A three-start helical sheath on the flagellar filament of Caulobacter crescentus.

An unusual feature in preparations of the Caulobacter crescentus flagellar filaments is that some filaments are surrounded by a set of three windings that form a sheath. We provide evidence that the sheath is composed of subunits having a molecular mass of 24,000 Da. We suggest that the sheath could be composed of protofilaments of flagellin wound around the filament.     

Excretion of flagellin by a short-flagella mutant of Salmonella typhimurium.

A nonmotile mutant of Salmonella typhimurium, SJW1254, has very short flagella (less than 0.1 micron long) due to a mutation in the structural gene of flagellin (H2). When ammonium sulfate was added to the culture medium of SJW1254 grown to the late-log phase, a large amount of protein precipitated. Gel electrophoresis and immunodiffusion showed that more than 90% (wt/wt) of the precipitated protein was flagellin. The mutant flagellin appeared to be excreted in the monomeric form, in an amount comparable to the amount in the flagellar filaments of wildtype bacteria. No such precipitate was obtained from the medium of wild-type bacteria. The mutant flagellin had the same apparent molecular weight (55,000) and isoelectric point (5.3) as the wild-type flagellin, but differed in mobility in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under nondenaturing conditions. Moreover, the mutant flagellin did not polymerize in vitro under various conditions in which wild-type flagellin polymerized. These results suggested that the mutant bacteria excreted flagellin because the flagellin polymerized poorly and therefore could not be trapped at the tip of the flagellar filament. This short-flagella mutant should be useful for studying the mechanism of flagellin transport.     

Amino acids responsible for flagellar shape are distributed in terminal regions of flagellin

The shape of the flagellar filaments of the bacterium Salmonella typhimurium under ordinary conditions is a left-handed helix. In addition to the normal wild-type filament, non-helical (i.e. straight), right-handed helical (early), or circular (semi-coiled and coiled) filaments and filament with small amplitude (fl-type) have been found in mutants or in filaments reconstituted in vitro. We analysed wild-type flagellin and flagellins from 17 flagellar-shape mutants (6 with straight filaments, 6 with curly filaments, 4 with coiled filaments and 1 with fl-type filament) by amino acid sequencing to identify the mutational sites. All mutant flagellins except that of the fl-type filament had single mutations; the fl-type flagellin had two mutations in the molecule. The sites of these mutations were localized in alpha-helical segments of the terminal regions of flagellin. A possible mechanism of the polymorphism of the flagellar filament is discussed.     

Variation in bacterial flagellins: from sequence to structure

Bacterial motility relies chiefly on the rotation of a molecular propeller, the flagellar filament, which is constructed from the protein flagellin. Here, flagellin sequence conservation and diversity is examined in the light of the recently determined flagellar filament structure. As expected, the surface-exposed domains are not conserved. However, the sequences that mediate filament assembly show remarkable conservation, which indicates that all bacterial flagellins are likely to pack into filaments in a similar manner. Flagellins provide a striking illustration of the twin evolutionary themes of conservation and variability.     

Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations of a rotating bacterial flagellum

Many types of bacteria propel themselves using elongated structures known as flagella. The bacterial flagellar filament is a relatively simple and well-studied macromolecular assembly, which assumes different helical shapes when rotated in different directions. This polymorphism enables a bacterium to switch between running and tumbling modes; however, the mechanism governing the filament polymorphism is not completely understood. Here we report a study of the bacterial flagellar filament using numerical simulations that employ a novel coarse-grained molecular dynamics method. The simulations reveal the dynamics of a half-micrometer-long flagellum segment on a timescale of tens of microseconds. Depending on the rotation direction, specific modes of filament coiling and arrangement of monomers are observed, in qualitative agreement with experimental observations of flagellar polymorphism. We find that solvent-protein interactions are likely to contribute to the polymorphic helical shapes of the filament.     

Gap compression/extension mechanism of bacterial flagellar hook as the molecular universal joint

Bacterial flagellar hook acts as a molecular universal joint, transmitting torque produced by the flagellar basal body, a rotary motor, to the flagellar filament. The hook forms polymorphic supercoil structures and can be considered as an assembly of 11 circularly arranged protofilaments. We investigated the molecular mechanism of the universal joint function of the hook by a approximately two-million-atom molecular dynamics simulation. On the inner side of the supercoil, protein subunits are highly packed along the protofilament and no gaps remain for further compression, whereas subunits are slightly separated and are hydrogen bonded through one layer of water molecules on the outer side. As for the intersubunit interactions between protofilaments, subunits are packed along the 6-start helix in a left-handed supercoil whereas they are highly packed along the 5-start helix in a right-handed supercoil. We conclude that the supercoiled structures of the hook in the left- and right-handed forms make maximal use of the gaps between subunits, which we call "gap compression/extension mechanism". Mutual sliding of subunits at the subunit interface accompanying rearrangements of intersubunit hydrogen bonds is interpreted as a mechanism to allow continuous structural change of the hook during flagellar rotation at low energy cost.     

Role of two flagellin genes in Campylobacter motility.

Campylobacter coli VC167 T2 has two flagellin genes, flaA and flaB, which share 91.9% sequence identity. The flaA gene is transcribed from a o-28 promoter, and the flaB gene from a o-54 promoter. Gene replacement mutagenesis techniques were used to generate flaA+ flaB and flaA flaB+ mutants. Both gene products are capable of assembling independently into functional filaments. A flagellar filament composed exclusively of the flaA gene product is indistinguishable in length from that of the wild type and shows a slight reduction in motility. The flagellar filament composed exclusively of the flaB gene product is severely truncated in length and greatly reduced in motility. Thus, while both flagellins are not necessary for motility, both products are required for a fully active flagellar filament. Although the wild-type flagellar filament is a heteropolymer of the flaA and flaB gene products, immunogold electron microscopy suggests that flaB epitopes are poorly surface exposed along the length of the wild-type filament.     

Identification and localization of flagellins FlaA and FlaB3 within flagella of Methanococcus voltae

Methanococcus voltae possesses four flagellin genes, two of which (flaB1 and flaB2) have previously been reported to encode major components of the flagellar filament. The remaining two flagellin genes, flaA and flaB3, are transcribed at lower levels, and the corresponding proteins remained undetected prior to this work. Electron microscopy examination of flagella isolated by detergent extraction of whole cells revealed a curved, hook-like region of varying length at the end of a long filament. Enrichment of the curved region of the flagella resulted in the identification of FlaB3 by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and N-terminal sequencing, and the localization of this flagellin to the cell-proximal portion of the flagellum was confirmed through immunoblotting and immunoelectron microscopy with FlaB3-specific antibodies, indicating that FlaB3 likely composes the curved portion of the flagella. This could represent a unique case of a flagellin performing the role of the bacterial hook protein. FlaA-specific antibodies were used in immunoblotting to determine that FlaA is found throughout the flagellar filament. M. voltae cells were transformed with a modified flaA gene containing a hemagglutinin (HA) tag introduced into the variable region. Transformants that had replaced the wild-type copy of the flaA gene with the HA-tagged version incorporated the HA-tagged version of FlaA into flagella which appeared normal by electron microscopy.     

Evidence that subcellular flagellin pools in Caulobacter crescentus are precursors in flagellum assembly

To study the assembly of the Caulobacter crescentus flagellar filament, we have devised a fractionation protocol that separates the cellular flagellin into three compartments: soluble, membrane, and assembled. Radioactive labeling in pulse-chase and pulse-labeling experiments has demonstrated for the first time that both soluble and membrane-associated flagellin pools are precursors in the assembly of the flagellar filament. The results of these experiments also indicate that flagellar filament assembly occurs via the translocation of newly synthesized flagellins from the soluble pool to the membrane pool to the assembled flagellar filaments. It is not possible to conclude whether the soluble flagellin fraction is synthesized cytoplasmically or as a loosely associated membrane intermediate which is released during lysis. It is clear, however, that the soluble and membrane flagellins are in physically and functionally distinct pools. The implications of these findings for the study of protein secretion from cells and the invariant targeting of flagellar proteins to the stalk-distal pole of the dividing cell during flagellum morphogenesis are discussed.     

The archaeabacterial flagellar filament: a bacterial propeller with a pilus-like structure

Common prokaryotic motility modes are swimming by means of rotating internal or external flagellar filaments or gliding by means of retracting pili. The archaeabacterial flagellar filament differs significantly from the eubacterial flagellum: (1) Its diameter is 10-14 nm, compared to 18-24 nm for eubacterial flagellar filaments. (2) It has 3.3 subunits/turn of a 1.9 nm pitch left-handed helix compared to 5.5 subunits/turn of a 2.6 nm pitch right-handed helix for plain eubacterial flagellar filaments. (3) The archaeabacterial filament is glycosylated, which is uncommon in eubacterial flagella and is believed to be one of the key elements for stabilizing proteins under extreme conditions. (4) The amino acid composition of archaeabacterial flagellin, although highly conserved within the group, seems unrelated to the highly conserved eubacterial flagellins. On the other hand, the archaeabacterial flagellar filament shares some fundamental properties with type IV pili: (1) The hydrophobic N termini are largely homologous with the oligomerization domain of pilin. (2) The flagellin monomers follow a different mode of transport and assembly. They are synthesized as pre-flagellin and have a cleavable signal peptide, like pre-pilin and unlike eubacterial flagellin. (3) The archaeabacterial flagellin, like pilin, is glycosylated. (4) The filament lacks a central channel, consistent with polymerization occurring at the cell-proximal end. (5) The diameter of type IV pili, 6-9 nm, is closer to that of the archaeabacterial filament, 10-14 nm. A large body of data on the biochemistry and molecular biology of archaeabacterial flagella has accumulated in recent years. However, their structure and symmetry is only beginning to unfold. Here, we review the structure of the archaeabacterial flagellar filament in reference to the structures of type IV pili and eubacterial flagellar filaments, with which it shares structural and functional similarities, correspondingly.     

Role of the 25-, 27-, and 29-kilodalton flagellins in Caulobacter crescentus cell motility: method for construction of deletion and Tn5 insertion mutants by gene replacement.

Caulobacter crescentus incorporates two distinct, but related proteins into the polar flagellar filament: a 27-kilodalton (kDa) flagellin is assembled proximal to the hook and a 25-kDa flagellin forms the distal end of the filament. These two proteins and a third, related flagellin protein of 29 kDa are encoded by three tandem genes (alpha-flagellin cluster) in the flaEY gene cluster (S.A. Minnich and A. Newton, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84: 1142-1146, 1987). Since point mutations in flagellin genes had not been isolated their requirement for flagellum function and fla gene expression was not known. To address these questions, we developed a gene replacement protocol that uses cloned flagellin genes mutagenized by either Tn5 transposons in vivo or the replacement of specific DNA fragments in vitro by the antibiotic resistance omega cassette. Analysis of gene replacement mutants constructed by this procedure led to several conclusions. (i) Mutations in any of the three flagellin genes do not cause complete loss of motility. (ii) Tn5 insertions in the 27-kDa flagellin gene and a deletion mutant of this gene do not synthesize the 27-kDa flagellin, but they do synthesize wild-type levels of the 25-kDa flagellin, which implies that the 27-kDa flagellin is not required for expression and assembly of the 25-kDa flagellin; these mutants show slightly impaired motility on swarm plates. (iii) Mutant PC7810, which is deleted for the three flagellin genes in the flaEY cluster, does not synthesize the 27- or 29-kDa flagellin, and it is significantly more impaired for motility on swarm plates than mutants with defects in only the 27-kDa flagellin gene. The synthesis of essentially normal levels of 25-kDa flagellin by strain PC7810 confirms that additional copies of the 25-kDa flagellin map outside the flaEY cluster (beta-flagellin cluster) and that these flagellin genes are active. Thus, while the 29- and 27-kDa flagellins are not absolutely essential for motility in C. crescentus, their assembly into the flagellar structure is necessary for normal flagellar function.     

Biochemical and Immunological Analyses of the Flagellin of Clostridium tyrobutyricum ATCC 25755

The monoclonal antibody 21E7-B12 (IgG₃) can be used in a direct method of Clostridium tyrobutyricum detection based on an immunoenzymatic assay. Immunoelectron microscopy demonstrated that the 21E7-B12 antibody recognized the surface-exposed epitopes on the flagellar filaments of C. tyrobutyricum. After flagellar extraction, the purified flagellin showed an apparent molecular mass of 46 kDa with an isoelectric point of 3.6. Sugar staining, mild periodate oxidation and é-elimination experiments showed that the flagellin was glycosylated and that the 21E7-B12 epitope was located in the sugar moiety. Amino acid composition showed that the flagellar filament protein contained a high percentage of serine and threonine, while proline was absent. The first 23 residues of the N-terminal were determined and sequence homology with other flagellins was found.