Permeability of lipid bilayers to water and ionic solutes

The lipid bilayer moiety of biological membranes is considered to be the primary barrier to free diffusion of water and solutes. This conclusion arises from observations of lipid bilayer model membrane systems, which are generally less permeable than biological membranes. However, the nature of the permeability barrier remains unclear, particularly with respect to ionic solutes. For instance, anion permeability is significantly greater than cation permeability, and permeability to proton-hydroxide is orders of magnitude greater than other monovalent inorganic ions. In this review, we first consider bilayer permeability to water and discuss proposed permeation mechanisms which involve transient defects arising from thermal fluctuations. We next consider whether such defects can account for ion permeation, including proton-hydroxide flux. We conclude that at least two varieties of transient defects are required to explain permeation of water and ionic solutes.     

Proton permeation of lipid bilayers

Proton permeation of the lipid bilayer barrier has two unique features. First, permeability coefficients measured at neutral pH ranges are six to seven orders of magnitude greater than expected from knowledge of other monovalent cations. Second, proton conductance across planar lipid bilayers varies at most by a factor of 10 when pH is varied from near 1 to near 11. Two mechanisms have been proposed to account for this anomalous behavior: proton conductance related to contaminants of lipid bilayers, and proton translocation along transient hydrogen-bonded chains (tHBC) of associated water molecules in the membrane. The weight of evidence suggests that trace contaminants may contribute to proton conductance across planar lipid membranes at certain pH ranges, but cannot account for the anomalous proton flux in liposome systems.Two new results will be reported here which were designed to test the tHBC model. These include measurements of relative proton/potassium permeability in the gramicidin channel, and plots of proton flux against the magnitude of pH gradients. (1) The relative permeabilities of protons and potassium through the gramicidin channel, which contains a single strand of hydrogenbonded water molecules, were found to differ by at least four orders of magnitude when measured at neutral pH ranges. This result demonstrates that a hydrogen-bonded chain of water molecules can provide substantial discrimination between protons and other cations. It was also possible to calculate that if approximately 7% of bilayer water was present in a transient configuration similar to that of the gramicidin channel, it could account for the measured proton flux. (2) The plot of proton conductance against pH gradient across liposome membranes was superlinear, a result that is consistent with one of three alternative tHBC models for proton conductance described by Nagle elsewhere in this volume.     

Conductance routes for protons across membrane barriers

Simple phospholipid bilayers show a high level of permeability to protons; in spite of this fact, large proton gradients existing across such bilayers may decay very slowly. In sealed systems, the free movement of protons across a membrane barrier is severely restricted by the coincident development of a proton diffusion potential. Using the fluorescent weak acid N-[5-(dimethylamino)naphth-1-ylsulfonyl]glycine strongly buffered systems movement of the small number of protons giving rise to this electrical potential is insufficient to perturb the proton concentration gradient; significant flux of protons (and hence significant collapse of the concentration gradient) can only occur if protons traverse the membrane as part of an electroneutral complex or if there is a balancing flow of appropriate counterions. In both instances, proton flux is obligatorily coupled to the translocation of species other than protons. In weakly buffered systems, the small initial uncoupled electrogenic flux of protons may significantly alter the concentration gradient. This initial rapid gradient collapse caused by uncoupled electrogenic proton movements is then superimposed upon the residual collapse attributable to tightly coupled proton flux. The initial uncoupled electrogenic proton flux shows a temperature dependence very similar to that demonstrated for water permeation across simple lipid bilayers; upon cooling, there is a sharp decrease in flux at the temperature coinciding with the main gel-liquid-crystalline phase transition of the lipid. The coupled proton flux shows a markedly different temperature dependence with no dramatic change in rate at the phase transition temperature and strong similarity to the behavior previously seen with solutes known to be permeating as electrically neutral compounds.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Does CO2 permeate through aquaporin-1?

Aquaporins facilitate water permeation across biological membranes. Additionally, glycerol and other small neutral solutes are permeated by related aquaglyceroporins. The role of aquaporins in gas permeation has been a long-standing and controversially discussed issue. We present an extensive set of atomistic molecular dynamics simulations that address the question of CO(2) permeation through human aquaporin-1. Free energy profiles derived from the simulations display a barrier of approximately 23 kJ/mol in the aromatic/arginine constriction region of the water pore, whereas a barrier of approximately 4 kJ/mol was observed for a palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylethanolamine lipid bilayer membrane. The results indicate that significant aquaporin-1-mediated CO(2) permeation is to be expected only in membranes with a low intrinsic CO(2) permeability.     

Electrostatic forces control the penetration of membranes by charged solutes

Using fluorescent, anionic dyes such as carboxyfluorescein as model solutes, it is shown that the forces allowing such solutes to be retained within sealed lipid vesicles, against a large concentration gradient, can be primarily electrostatic in nature. At temperatures distant from that of the ordered-fluid lipid phase transition a small number of the anionic dye molecules trapped within lipid vesicles are capable of traversing the lipid bilayer and establishing an electrical diffusion potential across the membrane. Further solute movement can then only occur with the concomitant permeation of ions which restore electrical balance. A significant flux of dye can be triggered by (a) increasing the permeability of the membrane to ions (for example by the addition of ionophores such as gramicidin, or by allowing the lipid to approach a phase transition) or by (b) adding lipophilic counterions such as tetraphenylborate or dinitrophenol to the system.     

Electrostatic forces control the penetration of membranes by charged solutes

Using fluorescent, anionic dyes such as carboxyfluorescein as model solutes, it is shown that the forces allowing such solutes to be retained within sealed lipid vesicles, against a large concentration gradient, can be primarily electrostatic in nature. At temperatures distant from that of the ordered-fluid lipid phase transition a small number of the anionic dye molecules trapped within lipid vesicles are capable of traversing the lipid bilayer and establishing an electrical diffusion potential across the membrane. Further solute movement can then only occur with the concomitant permeation of ions which restore electrical balance. A significant flux of dye can be triggered by (a) increasing the permeability of the membrane to ions (for example by the addition of ionophores such as gramicidin, or by allowing the lipid to approach a phase transition) or by (b) adding lipophilic counterions such as tetraphenylborate or dinitrophenol to the system.     

Quantifying reductive carboxylation flux of glutamine to lipid in a brown adipocyte cell line

We previously reported that glutamine was a major source of carbon for de novo fatty acid synthesis in a brown adipocyte cell line. The pathway for fatty acid synthesis from glutamine may follow either of two distinct pathways after it enters the citric acid cycle. The glutaminolysis pathway follows the citric acid cycle, whereas the reductive carboxylation pathway travels in reverse of the citric acid cycle from alpha-ketoglutarate to citrate. To quantify fluxes in these pathways we incubated brown adipocyte cells in [U-(13)C]glutamine or [5-(13)C]glutamine and analyzed the mass isotopomer distribution of key metabolites using models that fit the isotopomer distribution to fluxes. We also investigated inhibitors of NADP-dependent isocitrate dehydrogenase and mitochondrial citrate export. The results indicated that one third of glutamine entering the citric acid cycle travels to citrate via reductive carboxylation while the remainder is oxidized through succinate. The reductive carboxylation flux accounted for 90% of all flux of glutamine to lipid. The inhibitor studies were compatible with reductive carboxylation flux through mitochondrial isocitrate dehydrogenase. Total cell citrate and alpha-ketoglutarate were near isotopic equilibrium as expected if rapid cycling exists between these compounds involving the mitochondrial membrane NAD/NADP transhydrogenase. Taken together, these studies demonstrate a new role for glutamine as a lipogenic precursor and propose an alternative to the glutaminolysis pathway where flux of glutamine to lipogenic acetyl-CoA occurs via reductive carboxylation. These findings were enabled by a new modeling tool and software implementation (Metran) for global flux estimation.     

Aluminum speciation studies in biological fluids. Part 2. Quantitative investigation of aluminum-citrate complexes and appraisal of their potential significance in vivo

Because of the recent implications of aluminum in the pathogenesis of various disease states, its in vivo chemistry has been receiving growing attention from bioinorganic chemists over the last few years. In this context, the elucidation of the main factors that govern aluminum bioavailability constitutes an urgent objective. Clearly, prevention measures require that mechanisms of aluminum absorption be definitely characterized, whereas specific sequestering agents are needed to detoxify patients with high-aluminum-body burdens. In particular, speciation studies are necessary to discriminate among the chemical forms under which aluminum predominates in vivo. Low molecular weight (LMW) species, which are the most active in terms of bioavailability, cannot be assessed by analytical techniques, and so computer simulations must be used. In recent clinical studies as well as in preliminary simulations dealing with aluminum distribution in blood plasma, citrate has been recognized as the most important LMW ligand of aluminum. The present paper thus reports a quantitative investigation of aluminum-citrate equilibria, carried out at 37 degrees C in NaCl 0.15 mol dm-3 in accordance with the experimental protocol defined in our previous study on aluminum hydrolysis. The ML, MLH, ML2, M3L3H-4, M2L2H-2, ML2H-1, and ML2H-2 species have been characterized over the whole physiological pH range using as large reactant concentration ratios as possible. Corresponding formation constants have then been used to investigate the role of citrate towards aluminum bioavailability. Blood plasma simulations reveal that citrate can promote aluminum urinary excretion, which substantiates recent clinical observations made on mice. However, the higher plasma aluminum concentrations are, the less effective citrate is to be expected. Gastrointestinal simulations confirm that the electrically neutral ML complex does represent an important risk of aluminum absorption in the upper region of the gastrointestinal tract at usual therapeutic doses. At moderate- and low-aluminum concentrations, citrate is also capable of dissolving the aluminum trihydroxide precipitate, which may combine with the capacity of other ligands to complex Al3+ into absorbable complexes at less acidic pH.     

Effects of the administration routes and chemical forms of aluminum on aluminum accumulation in rat brain

An experimental rat model of aluminum accumulation in the brain was developed to aid in determining neurotoxity of aluminum (Al). Al was administered orally, intravenously, and intraperitoneally, in the absence or presence of citric acid or maltol. Oral administration of Al hydroxide [Al (OH)₃] or aluminum chloride (AlCl₃) with citric acid for 7 wk was not found to increase brain Al levels. Similarly, a single intravenous injection of AlCl₃ in the presence or absence of either citric acid or maltol did not alter brain Al levels after 48 h. Only daily intraperitoneal injections of AlCl₃ (8 mg Al/kg body weight) and an equimolar amount of maltol over a 14-d period enhanced accumulation of Al in rat brain. No significant increases were observed for the experimental groups receiving intraperitoneal AlCl₃ alone or with citric acid. This result suggests that the chemical form of Al strongly influences its bioavailability and that intraperitoneal administration of the Al-maltol complex appears to be useful in creating subacute model of Al accumulation in brain tissue.     

Influence of pH Modifiers and HPMC Viscosity Grades on Nicotine–Magnesium Aluminum Silicate Complex-Loaded Buccal Matrix Tablets

Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) tablets containing nicotine-magnesium aluminum silicate (NCT-MAS) complex particles and pH modifiers, namely, sodium chloride, citric acid, and magnesium hydroxide, were prepared using the direct compression method. The effects of HPMC viscosity grades and pH modifiers on NCT release and permeation of the matrix tablets were examined. The results showed that the higher the viscosity grade of HPMC that was used in the tablets, the lower was the unidirectional NCT release rate found. The unidirectional NCT permeation was not affected by the viscosity grade of HPMC because the NCT diffusion through the mucosal membrane was the rate-limiting step of the permeation. Incorporation of magnesium hydroxide could retard NCT release, whereas the enhancement of unidirectional NCT release was found in the tablets containing citric acid. Citric acid could inhibit NCT permeation due to the formation of protonated NCT in the swollen tablets at an acidic pH. Conversely, the NCT permeation rate increased with the use of magnesium hydroxide as a result of the neutral NCT that formed at a basic microenvironmental pH. The swollen HPMC tablets, with or without pH modifiers, gave sufficient adhesion to the mucosal membrane. Furthermore, the addition of magnesium hydroxide to the matrix tablets was the major factor in controlling buccal delivery of NCT. This study suggests that the NCT-MAS complex-loaded HPMC tablets, which contained magnesium hydroxide, are potential buccal delivery systems of NCT.     

Permeation of aromatic carboxylic acids across lipid bilayers: the pH-partition hypothesis revisited

According to the pH-partition hypothesis the charged species of organic compounds do not contribute to lipid bilayer permeation as they generally show negligible partitioning into n-octanol. With this assumption, membrane permeation is related to the molar fraction of the neutral species at a particular pH. A recently developed permeation assay permits us to directly determine pH-dependent permeation of aromatic carboxylic acids. Tb(3+)-loaded liposomes are incubated with aromatic carboxylic acids and upon excitation at the absorption wavelength of the acid, permeation kinetics can be measured as an increase in Tb(3+) luminescence. The anions of the tested acids permeated egg phosphatidylcholine membranes only 12 (2-hydroxynicotinic acid), 66 (salicylic acid), and 155 (dipicolinic acid) times slower than the net neutral species. The anions, therefore, controlled the total permeation already at 1-2 pH units above their pK(a). These results indicate that in contrast to the expectations of the pH-partition hypothesis, lipid bilayer permeation of an acidic compound can be completely controlled by the anion at physiological pH.     

An NMR study of the temperature dependence of the coefficient of water self-diffusion through lipid bilayer membranes

The temperature dependence of the coefficient of water self-diffusion through plane-parallel lipid multilayers of the phospholipid dioleoylphosphatidylcholine oriented on a glass support has been studied in the temperature range of 20-60 degrees C by the method of NMR with magnetic field pulse gradient. The values of the coefficients of transbilayer water diffusion are by four orders of magnitude less than for bulky water and ten times less than the coefficients of lateral diffusion of the lipid under the same conditions. The temperature dependence of the coefficient of water diffusion is described by the Arrhenius law with an apparent activation energy of about 41 kJ/mol, which far exceeds the activation energy for the diffusion of bulky water (18 kJ/mol). The experimental data were analyzed using a "dissolving-diffusion" model, by simulating the passage of water through membrane channels, and by analyzing the exchange of water molecules in states with different modes of translation mobility, including pore channels and bilayer "defects". Each of the approaches used made it possible to take the significance of bilayer permeability for the apparent energy of activation of water diffusion into account and estimate the energies of activation of water diffusion in the hydrophobic moiety of the bilayer, which were found to be close to the values for bulky water. The coefficients of water diffusion in the system under examination and the coefficients of permeation of water through the bilayer were estimated, and the effect of bilayer "defects" on the coefficients of water diffusion along and across bilayers was studied.     

Aluminum-induced lipid phase separation and membrane fusion does not require the presence of negatively charged phospholipids

The interaction of Aluminum with phosphatidyl serine lipid vesicles containing variable amounts of phosphatidyl ethanolamine, phosphatidyl choline and cholesterol has been studied by lipid phase separation monitored by fluorescence quenching. The interaction of Al3+ with neutral phospholipid membranes has also been investigated. Maximal lipid phase separation can be demonstrated in mixed phosphatidyl ethanolamine-cholesterol vesicles when using concentrations of aluminum between 87.5 and 125 microM. Millimolar concentrations of Ca2+, Mn2+, Cd2+ and Zn2+ were without any effect. Aluminum also induced fusion of phospholipid membranes monitored by resonance energy transfer between N-(7-nitro-2,1,3, benzoxadiazol-4 yl) phosphatidyl ethanolamine and N-(lissamine Rhodamine B-sulfonyl) phosphatidyl ethanolamine, either when containing low amounts of phosphatidyl serine (12.5%) or without any negatively charged phospholipid. Aluminum-induced fusion of liposomes was also monitored by the fluorescence of the terbium-dipicolinic acid complex (Tb-DPA3-) formed during fusion of vesicles containing either Tb-(citrate)6- complex or sodium salt of dipicolinic acid.     

Permeation of protons, potassium ions, and small polar molecules through phospholipid bilayers as a function of membrane thickness.

Two mechanisms have been proposed to account for solute permeation of lipid bilayers. Partitioning into the hydrophobic phase of the bilayer, followed by diffusion, is accepted by many for the permeation of water and other small neutral solutes, but transient pores have also been proposed to account for both water and ionic solute permeation. These two mechanisms make distinctively different predictions about the permeability coefficient as a function of bilayer thickness. Whereas the solubility-diffusion mechanism predicts only a modest variation related to bilayer thickness, the pore model predicts an exponential relationship. To test these models, we measured the permeability of phospholipid bilayers to protons, potassium ions, water, urea, and glycerol. Bilayers were prepared as liposomes, and thickness was varied systematically by using unsaturated lipids with chain lengths ranging from 14 to 24 carbon atoms. The permeability coefficient of water and neutral polar solutes displayed a modest dependence on bilayer thickness, with an approximately linear fivefold decrease as the carbon number varied from 14 to 24 atoms. In contrast, the permeability to protons and potassium ions decreased sharply by two orders of magnitude between 14 and 18 carbon atoms, and leveled off, when the chain length was further extended to 24 carbon atoms. The results for water and the neutral permeating solutes are best explained by the solubility-diffusion mechanism. The results for protons and potassium ions in shorter-chain lipids are consistent with the transient pore model, but better fit the theoretical line predicted by the solubility-diffusion model at longer chain lengths.     

Reduction of Aluminum Toxicity by Addition of a Conditioned Medium from Aluminum-Tolerant Cells of Carrot

The toxic effect of aluminum (Al) on the growth of Carrot cells(SO-l) decreased to a greater degree with addition of a mediumconditioned by Al-tolerant carrot cells (TA-l) than with a mediumconditioned by SO-l cells. The toxic effect of Al was reducedgreatly by adding an acidic fraction of the conditioned media,but little or not at all by a neutral or basic fraction. Offour organic acids detected in the acidic fraction, the majorone was citric acid which was present in a much greater amountin the conditioned medium of TA-l cells than in that of SO-lcells. The toxic effect of Al was reduced by adding citric or malicacid instead of the conditioned medium, but not by succinicor fumaric acid. Chelating abilities of the organic acids wereevaluated by shifts in their titration curves, and were foundto be closely correlated with the detoxification effects. Thus,the Al tolerance of TA-l cells may in fact be due to the chelatingeffect of citric acid which is abundantly released into themedium by the Al-tolerant carrot cells. (Received July 9, 1984; Accepted November 22, 1984)     

The kinetic mechanism of action of an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation.

The chemiosmotic hypothesis predicts that the mechanism by which weak acids uncouple oxidative phosphorylation in mitochondria is identical to the mechanism by which they transport hydrogen ions across artificial bilayer membranes. We report here the results of a kinetic study of uncoupler-mediated hydrogen ion transport across bilayer membranes. We made electrical relaxation measurements on black lipid membranes exposed to the substituted benzimidazole 5,6-dichloro-2-trifluoromethylbenzimidazole. The simplest model consistent with our experimental data allowed us to deduce values for adsorption coefficients and rate constants. Our major conclusions are that the back diffusion of the neutral species is the rate limiting step for the steady state transport of hydrogen ions, that both the neutral and charged forms of the uncoupler adsorb strongly to the interfaces, and that the reactions at the membrane-solution interfaces occur sufficiently rapidly for equilibrium to be maintained. Independent measurements of the adsorption coefficients of both the neutral and anionic forms of the weak acid and also of the permeability of the membrane to the neutral form agreed well with the values deduced from the kinetic study.     

Permeation of halide anions through phospholipid bilayers occurs by the solubility-diffusion mechanism.

Two alternative mechanisms are frequently used to describe ionic permeation of lipid bilayers. In the first, ions partition into the hydrophobic phase and then diffuse across (the solubility-diffusion mechanism). The second mechanism assumes that ions traverse the bilayer through transient hydrophilic defects caused by thermal fluctuations (the pore mechanism). The theoretical predictions made by both models were tested for halide anions by measuring the permeability coefficients for chloride, bromide, and iodide as a function of bilayer thickness, ionic radius, and sign of charge. To vary the bilayer thickness systematically, liposomes were prepared from monounsaturated phosphatidylcholines (PC) with chain lengths between 16 and 24 carbon atoms. The fluorescent dye MQAE (N-(ethoxycarbonylmethyl)-6-methoxyquinolinium bromide) served as an indicator for halide concentration inside the liposomes and was used to follow the kinetics of halide flux across the bilayer membranes. The observed permeability coefficients ranged from 10(-9) to 10(-7) cm/s and increased as the bilayer thickness was reduced. Bromide was found to permeate approximately six times faster than chloride through bilayers of identical thickness, and iodide permeated three to four times faster than bromide. The dependence of the halide permeability coefficients on bilayer thickness and on ionic size were consistent with permeation of hydrated ions by a solubility-diffusion mechanism rather than through transient pores. Halide permeation therefore differs from that of a monovalent cation such as potassium, which has been accounted for by a combination of the two mechanisms depending on bilayer thickness.     

How do protons cross the membrane-solution interface? Kinetic studies on bilayer membranes exposed to the protonophore S-13 (5-chloro-3-tert-butyl-2′-chloro-4′ nitrosalicylanilide)

Summary A simple carrier model describes adequately the transport of protons across lipid bilayer membranes by the weak acid S-13. We determined the adsorption coefficients of the anionic, A^–, and neutral, HA, forms of the weak acid and the rate constants for the movement of A^– and HA across the membrane by equilibrium dialysis, electrophoretic mobility, membrane potential, membrane conductance, and spectrophotometric measurements. These measurements agree with the results of voltage clamp and charge pulse kinetic experiments. We considered three mechanisms by which protons can cross the membranesolution interface. An anion adsorbed to the interface can be protonated by (i) a H⁺ ion in the aqueous phase (protolysis), (ii) a buffer molecule in the aqueous phase or (iii) water molecules (hydrolysis). We demonstrated that the first reaction cannot provide the required flux of protons: the rate at which H⁺ must combine with the adsorbed anions is greater than the rate at which diffusion-limited reactions occur in the bulk aqueous phase. We also ruled out the possibility that the buffer is the main source of protons: the rate at which buffers must combine with the adsorbed anions is greater than the diffusion-limited rate when we reduced the concentration of polyanionic buffer adjacent to the membrane-solution interface by using membranes with a negative surface charge. A simple analysis demonstrates that a hydrolysis reaction can account for the kinetic data. Experiments at acid pH demonstrate that the transfer of H⁺ from the membrane to the aqueous phase is limited by the rate at which OH combines with adsorbed HA and that the diffusion coefficient of OH^– in the water adjacent to the bilayer has a value characteristic of bulk water. Our experimental results demonstrate that protons are capable of moving rapidly across the membrane-solution interface, which argues against some mechanisms of local chemiosmosis.