The Response of Sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum) Cultured Cells to Anoxia and the Selection of a Tolerant Cell Line

The effect of anoxia on the sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) cultured cells was studied in order to elaborate a technique for in vitro selection of cell lines, which would be tolerant to anaerobic stress. Inhibitory and lethal doses of anaerobic incubation were established from the state of the mitochondrial ultrastructure during the anaerobic incubation of cells either with or without exogenous glucose, as well as from the pattern of the post-anaerobic callus growth. An intact state of the mitochondrial ultrastructure and the viability of some cells in the presence of 3% glucose were shown to be maintained for at least 14 days of anaerobic incubation, while the index of post-anaerobic growth decreased by almost 50% even after 72-hour-long anaerobiosis. In the absence of exogenous glucose, a marked destruction of mitochondria and a twofold decrease in the callus growth index were observed as early as after six-hour-long anaerobic stress. A 48-hour-long incubation under these conditions resulted in the maintenance of the intact ultrastructure only in 7–10% of cells, while a 96-hour-long anaerobiosis brought about the complete degradation of the subcellular structure and cell death. A 48-hour-long anaerobiosis without exogenous glucose was chosen for selecting the anoxia-tolerant cell lines. After three cycles of selection, the anoxia tolerance of the selected cell line exceeded the respective index of the initial callus several-fold. In selected line, about 50% of cells retained viability and could resume growth even after 96-hour-long anaerobic incubation. The experimental results obtained were used to determine the possible causes of the heterogeneity of callus cells as regards their anoxia resistance.     

Exogenous Nitrate as a Terminal Acceptor of Electrons in Rice (Oryza sativa) Coleoptiles and Wheat (Triticum aestivum) Roots under Strict Anoxia

To elucidate the physiological role of exogenous nitrate under anaerobic conditions, we studied the effect of 10 mM KNO₃ on the mitochondrial ultrastructure in rice (Oryza sativa L.) coleoptiles and in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) roots, detached from four-day-old seedlings, under strict anoxia. In wheat roots, following 6-h-long anoxia in the absence of exogenous nitrate, the mitochondrial membranes were partially degraded and, after 9 h under anoxia, the mitochondrial membranes and the membranes of other organelles were completely destroyed. In rice coleoptiles, the partial membrane degradation was observed only after 24 h and their complete breakdown after 48 h of anaerobiosis. In the presence of exogenous nitrate, no membrane destruction was noticed even after 9 and 48 h of anaerobiosis in wheat roots and rice coleoptiles, respectively. These results indicate that exogenous nitrate exerts protective action as a terminal electron acceptor, alternative to the molecular oxygen. Our findings are compared with the results of other researchers concerning the adverse or favorable nitrate action on plant growth, metabolism, and energy status under anaerobic stress.     

Demonstration of plant adaptation syndrome in plants and possible molecular mechanisms of its realization under conditions of anaerobic stress

Electron-microscopic examination of mitochondrial membrane ultrastructure in detached leaves of four-day-old wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings incubated under conditions of strict anoxia in the presence of exogenous glucose and cycloheximide or in the absence of these compounds revealed a paradoxical phenomenon: in the absence of exogenous glucose and cycloheximide, even a short-term (15–30 min) anaerobiosis resulted in a pathological destruction of mitochondria (swelling and the loss of cristae); however, a longer uninterrupted anaerobiosis (3–4 h) did not induce further mitochondria degradation but, in contrast, resulted in the recovery of their initial ultrastructure. Irreversible mitochondria degradation was observed only during subsequent still longer leaf anaerobic treatment (24–48 h). When, under conditions of strict anoxia, leaves were fed with glucose to stimulate glycolysis and ethanolic fermentation, we did not observe any signs of early destruction of mitochondrial ultrastructure and their swelling. Blockage of anaerobic protein synthesis with cycloheximide resulted in early destruction and subsequent irreversible degradation of mitochondria without any indications of their structural recovery. Based on the results of the experiments, we concluded that cell energy metabolism controlled byboth the presence of utilizable carbohydrates and also by the induction of anaerobic protein synthesis played a key role during early mitochondria destruction under extreme conditions of anaerobic stress, their subsequent recovery, and irreversible degradation during continuous long-term strict anoxia.     

Protective effect of exogenous nitrate on the mitochondrial ultrastructure ofOryza sativa coleoptiles under strict anoxia

Summary The effect of exogenous KNO₃, the terminal acceptor of electrons in oxygen-free medium, on mitochondrial ultrastructure and on the growth rate of 4-day-old rice coleoptiles under strictly anoxic conditions was studied. Exogenous nitrate (10 mM) did not exert any significant effect on the growth rate of coleoptiles of intact seedlings compared to their growth in KNO₃-free medium. Anaerobic incubation of detached coleoptiles in KNO₃-free medium for 48 h resulted in the complete destruction of mitochondrial and other cell membranes. In the presence of KNO₃, no mitochondrial-membrane destruction was observed even after 48 h anoxia although the mitochondrial ultrastructure was modifed. Cristae were arranged in parallel rows and elongated dumbbell-shaped mitochondria appeared in some cells. The data obtained indicate a protective role of exogenous nitrate as electron acceptors in oxygen-free medium. The results of the present investigation are discussed and compared with reports of either markedly damaging or favorable effects of exogenous nitrate on the growth, metabolism, and energetics of rice and other plants under hypoxic and anoxic conditions.     

Functional Electron Microscopy in Studies of Plant response and adaptation to Anaerobic Stress

This article reviews the contribution made by functional electronmicroscopy towards identifying and understanding the reactionsof plant roots and shoots to anaerobic stress. Topics examinedinclude: (1) unexpected hypersensitivity, rather than hyper-resistance,to anoxia of root tips of flooding-tolerant plants; (2) protective,rather than damaging, effects of a stimulated energy metabolism(glycolysis and fermentation) under anaerobic conditions; (3)the concept of two main strategies of plant adaptation to anaerobicenvironments, namely avoidance of anaerobiosis on the wholeplant level, termed ‘apparent’ tolerance, and metabolicadaptation at the cellular and molecular levels, termed ‘true’tolerance; (4) the importance of protein synthesis during hypoxiaand anoxia for enhanced energy production and metabolic adaptation;(5) a general adaptive syndrome in plants to stress at the ultrastructurallevel and a possible molecular mechanism for its realizationunder anoxia; (6) the physiological role of anaerobically synthesizedlipids and nitrate as alternative electron acceptors in an oxygen-freemedium; and (7) the selection of cell lines derived from calluscultures that possess enhanced tolerance to anoxia and can regeneratewhole plants with improved tolerance of soil waterlogging.     

Selection and characterization of cadmium tolerant cells in tomato

Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum cv. VFNT-Cherry)cell lines tolerant of to 5 mM cadmium (Cd) were selected by progressively elevating the level of CdCl₂ in the culture medium (the lethal concentration of Cd for unselected tomato cells is 400 μM). Cd tolerance was not lost during long-term culture (up to 12 months) in the absence of Cd stress. In all the cell lines examined, Cd uptake was rapid and Cd concentration within the cells exceeded that in the culture medium by several fold. While Cd included the synthesis and accumulation of phytochelatins (PCs) [poly[γ-glutamyl-cysteiny)glycine], little change has been observed in protein synthesis during short term Cd stress. PCs formed complexes with Cd. However, uptake and accumulation of Cd was not affected if PC synthesis was inhibited by treatment with buthionine sulfoximine. Selected and unselected cells were compared for their growth characteristics in the presence of various other metal ions. Cd tolerant cells showed a slightly higher tolerance of copper but not of mercury, zinc, lead or silver.     

Nitrate reductase regulation in tomato roots by exogenous nitrate: a possible role in tolerance to long-term root anoxia

The mechanism of nitrate reductase (NR) regulation under long-term anoxia in roots of whole plants and the putative role of nitrate in anoxia tolerance have been addressed. NR activity in tomato roots increased significantly after 24 h of anaerobiosis and increased further by 48 h, with a concomitant release of nitrite into the culture medium. Anoxia promoted NR activation through dissociation of the 14-3-3 protein inhibitor and NR dephosphorylation. After 24 h of anoxia, the total amount of NR increased slightly up to 48 h. However, NR-mRNA levels remained constant between 0 h and 24 h of root anoxia and decreased after 48 h. This is probably due to the inhibition of NR degradation and the accumulation of its native form. NR was slightly dephosphorylated in the absence of oxygen and nitrate. Under anoxia, NR dephosphorylation was modulated by nitrate-controlled NR activity. In addition, the presence of nitrate prevents anoxic symptoms on leaves and delays wilting by 48 h during root anoxia. In the absence of nitrate, plants withered within 24 h, as they did with tungstate treatment, an inhibitor of NR activity. Thus, anoxia tolerance of tomato roots could be enhanced by nitrate reduction.     

Phytochelatin accumulation and cadmium tolerance in selected tomato cell lines

Four cell lines of tomato, Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv VFNT-Cherry, were selected for their ability to grow in the presence of up to 6 millimolar CdCl₂. The intracellular Cd concentration in these cells was at least 2.3 times higher than in the medium. Growth in media containing higher concentrations of Cd was accompanied by increased production of Cd-binding phytochelatins and a trend toward accumulation of higher molecular weight phytochelatins. At least 90% of the Cd in the most tolerant cells was associated with Cd-phytochelatin complexes. Cell lines maintained an increased tolerance of Cd in the absence of continuous selection pressure.     

Relationship between the Accumulation of Putrescine and the Tolerance to Oxygen-Deficit Stress in Gramineae Seedlings

The accumulation of putrescine under anoxia was studied in seedlingsof 6 Gramineae species showing tolerance to the stress in thefollowing order: rice, barnyard grass>maize>rye, barleyand wheat. The accumulation of putrescine in shoots and rootsduring 6 h of oxygen deprivation was different among the speciesand correlated with their tolerance to anaerobic conditions.In both tissues, rice and barnyard grass accumulated more than0.6 µmol/g fresh weight. The lower increase in the putrescinetiter was observed in wheat tissues with less than 0.1 µmol/gfresh weight. Feeding experiments with [^l4C]arginine showedthat rice tissues have a greater capacity than wheat tissuesto synthesize putrescine under anoxia. The better tolerant speciesto anaerobic conditions showed high arginine decarboxylase activityin shoots and roots than the sensitive species. The presenceof exogenous Put partially increased the survival of wheat rootsafter 7.5 h of oxygen-deficit stress. The role of putrescinein determining differences in the tolerance to anoxia in Gramineaeseedlings is discussed. (Received December 20, 1989; Accepted March 12, 1990)     

Mitochondrial ultrastructure in roots of mesophyte and hydrophyte at anoxia and after glucose feeding

Summary In order to investigate the nature of the tolerance of mesophytes and hydrophytes to root anaerobiosis, changes in the mitochondrial ultrastructure of excised roots (with and without added glucose under anoxia) were studied in plants from two ecologically opposite types-pumpkin and rice.A 12-hour exposure to anoxia led to mitochondrial degradation in roots of adult rice and pumpkin plants. The addition of glucose preserved cell ultrastructure for up to 72–96 hours. During this period mitochondrial ultrastructure changed. In rice roots this primarily involved an increased number of cristae and a change in their arrangement into parallel rows. Cells of pumpkin roots displayed long mitochondria (up to 55 m) of different profiles which fused to form a complex mitochondrial network that was in close association with parts of the endoplasmic reticulum carrying a large number of ribosomes. This may be regarded as an adaptive development that facilitates the transport of glycolytic energy along mitochondrial membranes to the sites of protein synthesis.It is concluded that root cells of a hydrophyte are not more tolerant to anoxia than mesophyte. Thus, the ability of hydrophytes to grow on anaerobic soils should be attributed not so much to peculiar features of the roots' metabolism but to the ability of these plants to perform an easy transport of O₂ from leaves to roots. With respect to mesophytes it is stressed that the supply of assimilates is important for the resistance of roots to soil anaerobiosis.     

Plant anaerobic stress as a novel trend in ecological physiology, biochemistry, and molecular biology: 2. Further development of the problem

This review is a logical development of a previous publication, which summarized the main results of the early period of the systematic and active studying of hypoxic and anoxic stresses in plants. These studies laid a foundation for a new scientific discipline in biology, the investigation relevant to plant anaerobic stress. This review considers a further development of this trend when the investigations embraced a wider set of topics and the discipline acquired an international recognition. The results obtained during last decades by physiologists, biochemists, and molecular biologists engaged in the problem of plant anaerobic stress confirmed the correctness of a concept of the two principal strategies of plant adaptation to hypoxia and anoxia conditions. They are “true” tolerance manifesting at the molecular level under conditions of oxygen deficiency or its absence and “apparent” tolerance, which is realized by avoidance of anaerobiosis due to the long-distance oxygen transport. Therefore, experimental material available now is considered and discussed in this review mainly in the light of these principal notions. Especial attention is paid to the role of stress proteins, which synthesis is induced under hypoxia and anoxia. The results of these experiments confirmed earlier conclusions about the key role of energy (glycolysis and alcoholic fermentation) and carbohydrate (mobilization and utilization of reserved carbohydrates) metabolism in plant adaptation to oxygen deficiency or its absence from the environment. The phenomenon of hypoxic acclimation and its role in plant adaptation to anoxia are also considered. Along with these topics, a further development of pH-stat theory is discussed. A special attention is paid to plant strategy realized by the formation of the net of air-filled spaces (aerenchyma) and long-distance oxygen transport from aerated plant parts to those located in anaerobic environment (apparent tolerance). Among other important aspects, we consider (1) post-anaerobic plant injury by free oxygen radicals; (2) the physiological role of alternative pathways of plant adaptation (nitrate reduction and lipid synthesis); (3) the phenomenon of the adaptation syndrome in plants and possible molecular mechanisms of its realization; and (4) some biotechnological advances in the field of genetic and cell engineering used for the creation of plants more tolerant to anaerobic stress.     

Selection of Glyphosate-Tolerant Tobacco Calli and the Expression of this Tolerance in Regenerated Plants

From nonmutagenized haploid suspensions of Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Wisconsin 38 cells, 51 cell lines capable of growth in the presence of 1 millimolar glyphosate (N-phosphonomethyl glycine) were initially isolated at a frequency of 2.3 × 10⁻⁸. Eighteen cell lines retained tolerance when grown on selective medium for 3 years. Tolerance persisted for at least 14 months in six cell lines cultured in the absence of glyphosate. Some plants regenerated from four glyphosate-tolerant cell lines were tolerant. Glyphosate-tolerant tissue was isolated from some sensitive as well as some tolerant regenerated plants. Six of the tolerant cell lines were also tolerant to the herbicide amitrole (3-amino-1,2,4-triazole). Five cell lines selected for amitrole tolerance were glyphosate tolerant. Some plants regenerated from three of these five cell lines were glyphosate tolerant and glyphosate-tolerant tissue was obtained from several of these regenerated plants. Amitrole uptake in suspension cultures of several variants was assessed in terms of influx rate constants. This parameter was not sufficiently different indicating that altered membrane properties could not account for the herbicide tolerance.     

Messenger RNA induction in cellular salt tolerance of Alfalfa (Medicago sativa)

A salt tolerant alfalfaMedicago sativa L. cell line (HG2-N1) has been selected for growth in 171 mM NaCl. The salt tolerance characteristic is stable and is retained after growth in absence of salt selection for two months.In vitro translation was used to compare mRNA composition from the salt tolerant HG2-N1 and parent salt sensitive HG2 cell lines grown in the presence and absence of 171 mM NaCl. The results suggest that the mRNA composition differs between HG2-N1 and HG2 in a number of RNA species. The salt tolerant HG2-N1 shows both increases and decreases in specific polypeptides as compared to HG2. Many of the enhanced polypeptide bands from mRNA in the salt tolerant HG2-N1 variant appear to be constitutively expressed, since they can be detected from HG2-N1 cells grown in presence and absence of NaCl, but the expression of a few bands may depend on the presence of added NaCl. Most enhanced polypeptides, which are detected from mRNA in the salt tolerant variant HG2-N1 (grown on NaCl) are different from polypeptide bands enhanced in the salt sensitive HG2 line as a result of 24 hour salt stress. Similar results were obtained from two dimensional analysis ofin vivo labeled polypeptides. At least one isolated cDNA clone shows selective expression of mRNA in salt tolerant cells grown in NaCl. These results indicate that adaptive mechanisms for salt tolerance may differ in some aspects from acute stress mechanisms.     

Effects of anoxia on mitochondrial biogenesis in rice shoots: modification of in organello translation characteristics

Shoots of germinating rice (Oryza sativa L.) seedlings are able to grow under anoxia and to withstand long periods of anoxic treatment. Mitochondria were purified from aerobically germinated and anaerobically treated rice shoots by differential and isopycnic centrifugation and were found to consist of two subpopulations. The mitochondrial subpopulation of higher density was used for further characterization. Ultrastructural studies showed anaerobic mitochondria to be significantly different from aerobic mitochondria, with a matrix of lower density and more developed cristae. Aerobic and anaerobic mitochondria also differed in their specific activities for fumarase and succinate dehydrogenase, which were significantly lower after the anoxic treatment. In vivo labeling of seedlings with l-[³⁵S]methionine and subsequent isolation of the mitochondria indicated that anoxia induced a drastic decrease, but not a total inactivation, of the synthesis of mitochondrial proteins. In organello protein synthesis showed that anaerobic mitochondria were able to synthesize most of the polypeptides synthesized by aerobic mitochondria, although only in the presence of exogenous ATP, as would occur under anoxia. Anaerobic mitochondria, but not aerobic mitochondria, could carry out protein synthesis without a functional respiratory chain. Thus, mitochondrial protein synthesis was found to be potentially functional in the rice shoot under anoxia.     

Clonal variation for tolerance to polyethylene glycol-induced water stress in cultured tomato cells

Cell clones were isolated from a population of cultured tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill cv VFNT-cherry) cells and their tolerance to polyethylene glycol (PEG)-induced water stress was measured. Considerable variation for tolerance among the clones was found. Tolerance differences between clones appeared to be spontaneous and were different from tolerance differences between adapted and unadapted cells. Unlike adapted (selected by exposure to PEG) cells, cell clones retained their relative tolerance for many generations in the absence of selection pressure, and tolerance of both relatively tolerant and intolerant clones was very dependent on growth cycle stage and inoculum density. Analysis of subclones isolated from relatively tolerant and intolerant parent clones revealed that each parent clone gives rise to progeny with tolerances near the mean tolerance of both parents. However, progeny populations of both tolerant and intolerant parents are enriched with individuals with phenotypes nearer the mean response of their respective parent populations. When exposed to PEG, relatively tolerant and intolerant clones alike become adapted to the level of PEG to which they are exposed, and have the same phenotypic level of tolerance. Thus, selection by exposure to stress is unable to discriminate (on the basis of growth) between the innately tolerant and intolerant cell types within the population. This is indicated also by the fact that clones isolated from a population of cells adjusted to growth on 25% PEG do not show an enriched frequency of tolerant phenotypes when grown in the absence of PEG compared to the nonselected normal cell population which has never been adjusted to growth on PEG.     

Superoxide Dismutase as an Anaerobic Polypeptide : A Key Factor in Recovery from Oxygen Deprivation in Iris pseudacorus?

The perennating organ, the rhizome, was chosen for examination of response to anoxia in the species Iris pseudacorus L., Iris germanica L. var Quechei, and Glyceria maxima (Hartm.) Holmberg. These monocots are known to differ in their tolerance of anoxia. Intact rhizomes were subjected to periods of prolonged anoxia of up to 28 days and superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity was determined in a 48 hour postanoxic recovery phase. Tests were performed to ensure the accuracy of the measured enzyme activities. In the most anoxia tolerant species, I. pseudacorus, SOD activity rose continuously during the period of imposed anoxia, and levels were maintained in the postanoxic recovery phases: 28 days brought about a 13-fold increase to 1576 U SOD per milligram protein. Small increases were found in the less anoxia tolerant I. germanica during anoxic/postanoxic phases, while a drop in activity was recorded in the least anoxia tolerant G. maxima. However, initial levels in G. maxima were more than twice as high as in the other two species. Experiments applying cycloheximide to anoxic rhizome slices of I. pseudacorus inhibited the increase in SOD activity. This indicates that SOD is, paradoxically, induced under anoxia and we suggest that in this species SOD is one of the enzymes identified as anaerobic polypeptides. The significance of the induction of an `oxygen-protecting' enzyme during complete oxygen deprivation is discussed with regard to a possible critical role during recovery from anoxic stress.     

Nitrite reduces cytoplasmic acidosis under anoxia

The ameliorating effect of nitrate on the acidification of the cytoplasm during short-term anoxia was investigated in maize (Zea mays) root segments. Seedlings were grown in the presence or absence of nitrate, and changes in the cytoplasmic and vacuolar pH in response to the imposition of anoxia were measured by in vivo (31)P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Soluble ions and metabolites released to the suspending medium by the anoxic root segments were measured by high-performance liquid chromatography and (1)H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and volatile metabolites were measured by gas chromatography and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. The beneficial effect of nitrate on cytoplasmic pH regulation under anoxia occurred despite limited metabolism of nitrate under anoxia, and modest effects on the ions and metabolites, including fermentation end products, released from the anoxic root segments. Interestingly, exposing roots grown and treated in the absence of nitrate to micromolar levels of nitrite during anoxia had a beneficial effect on the cytoplasmic pH that was comparable to the effect observed for roots grown and treated in the presence of nitrate. It is argued that nitrate itself is not directly responsible for improved pH regulation under anoxia, contrary to the usual assumption, and that nitrite rather than nitrate should be the focus for further work on the beneficial effect of nitrate on flooding tolerance.     

Mitochondrial Ultrastructure of Three Hygrophyte Species at Anoxia and in Anoxic Glucose-Supplemented Medium

Mitochondrial ultrastructure of excised roots of Alisma plantago-aqisaticaL., Lycopus europaeus L and Glyceria fluitans L. were electron-microscopicallystudied at anoxia and in anoxic glucose- supplemented mediumin order to find Out if the roots of the three hygrophytes growingon water-logged anaerobic soils have an increased resistanceto anoxia. Irreversible destruction of mitochondrial membranes and othersubcellular structures was shown to occur in the above plants'roots after 24 h at anoxia or in anoxic glucose-supplementedmedium. Only in roots of Glyceria had exogenous glucose a protectiveaction, yet in this case, too, a 48 h anacrobic exposure resultedin a deep-going degradation of cell ultrastructure. It is concluded that though the plants in question grow on soilsdevoid of O₂ their roots avoid anaerobiosis through translocationof O₂ from aerated parts, which appears to explain why theseplants have not developed a biochemical mechanism of adaptationto anaerobiosis in the process of evolution. Key words: Anaerobiosis, hygrophytes, mitochondrial ultrastructure