Physiology of PSI cyclic electron transport in higher plants

Having long been debated, it is only in the last few years that a concensus has emerged that the cyclic flow of electrons around Photosystem I plays an important and general role in the photosynthesis of higher plants. Two major pathways of cyclic flow have been identified, involving either a complex termed NDH or mediated via a pathway involving a protein PGR5 and two functions have been described-to generate ATP and to provide a pH gradient inducing non-photochemical quenching. The best evidence for the occurrence of the two pathways comes from measurements under stress conditions-high light, drought and extreme temperatures. In this review, the possible relative functions and importance of the two pathways is discussed as well as evidence as to how the flow through these pathways is regulated. Our growing knowledge of the proteins involved in cyclic electron flow will, in the future, enable us to understand better the occurrence and diversity of cyclic electron transport pathways. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Regulation of Electron Transport in Chloroplasts.     

Competition between linear and cyclic electron flow in plants deficient in Photosystem I

Photosynthetic electron transport can involve either a linear flow from water to NADP, via Photosystems (PS) II and I or a cyclic flow just involving PSI. Little is known about factors regulating the relative flow through each of these pathways. We have examined photosynthetic electron transport through each system in plants of Arabidopsis thaliana in which either the PSI-D1 or PSI-E1 subunits of PSI have been knocked out. In both cases, this results in an imbalance in the turnover of PSI and PSII, such that PSII electron transport is limited by PSI turnover. Phosphorylation of light-harvesting complex II (LHCII) and its migration to PSI is enhanced but only partially reversible and not sufficient to balance photosystem turnover. In spite of this, cyclic electron flow is able to compete efficiently with PSI across a range of conditions. In dark-adapted leaves, the efficiency of cyclic relative to linear flow induced by far-red light is increased, implying that the limiting step of cyclic flow lies in the re-injection of electrons into the electron transport chain. Illumination of leaves with white light resulted in transient induction of a significant non-photochemical quenching in knockout plants which is probably high energy state quenching induced by cyclic electron flow. At high light and at low CO(2), non-photochemical quenching was greater in the knockout plants than in the wildtype. Comparison of PSI and PSII turnover under such conditions suggested that this is generated by cyclic electron flow around PSI. We conclude that, when the concentration of PSI is limiting, cyclic electron flow is still able to compete effectively with linear flow to maintain a high DeltapH to regulate photosynthesis.     

还原型二(三)磷酸吡啶核苷酸[NAD(P)H]脱氢酶复合体及叶绿体呼吸研究进展

除了经过光系统II和光系统I的非循环电子传递以外,围绕光系统I的循环电子传递对维持高效率的光合作用也是不可缺少的,其中叶绿体还原型二(三)磷酸吡啶核苷酸[NAD(P)H]脱氢酶复合体(NDH复合体)介导的循环电子传递是目前研究的热点。随着质体末端氧化酶(PTOX)的发现,NDH参与的循环电子传递与叶绿体呼吸在补充光合作用所需能量以及抵御光氧化胁迫过程中的作用正日渐引起研究者的重视。文章根据近年的研究进展就叶绿体NDH复合体及其介导的循环电子传递与叶绿体呼吸的生理功能做了综述。     

Competition between linear and cyclic electron flow in plants deficient in Photosystem I

Photosynthetic electron transport can involve either a linear flow from water to NADP, via Photosystems (PS) II and I or a cyclic flow just involving PSI. Little is known about factors regulating the relative flow through each of these pathways. We have examined photosynthetic electron transport through each system in plants of Arabidopsis thaliana in which either the PSI-D1 or PSI-E1 subunits of PSI have been knocked out. In both cases, this results in an imbalance in the turnover of PSI and PSII, such that PSII electron transport is limited by PSI turnover. Phosphorylation of light-harvesting complex II (LHCII) and its migration to PSI is enhanced but only partially reversible and not sufficient to balance photosystem turnover. In spite of this, cyclic electron flow is able to compete efficiently with PSI across a range of conditions. In dark-adapted leaves, the efficiency of cyclic relative to linear flow induced by far-red light is increased, implying that the limiting step of cyclic flow lies in the re-injection of electrons into the electron transport chain. Illumination of leaves with white light resulted in transient induction of a significant non-photochemical quenching in knockout plants which is probably high energy state quenching induced by cyclic electron flow. At high light and at low CO₂, non-photochemical quenching was greater in the knockout plants than in the wildtype. Comparison of PSI and PSII turnover under such conditions suggested that this is generated by cyclic electron flow around PSI. We conclude that, when the concentration of PSI is limiting, cyclic electron flow is still able to compete effectively with linear flow to maintain a high ΔpH to regulate photosynthesis.     

Kinetics of nucleosome unfolding at low ionic strength

The kinetics of a conformational change which occurs in nucleosome core particles at about 1 mM ionic strength have been studied by observing changes in the fluorescence of labeled histone H3. The unfolding reaction is intramolecular since no concentration dependence is observed. However, the kinetics are unexpectedly complicated and reveal evidence of at least three relaxation times. It is possible to fit the kinetics observed under several conditions to a consistent four-state cyclic mechanism in which folded and unfolded forms can inter-convert by two parallel pathways, each involving a distinct intermediate. While the data are not sufficient to establish this mechanism as a unique choice, they exclude many simpler possibilities. The cyclic mechanism is quite reasonable in view of what is currently known about the structures of the folded and unfolded forms.     

A strain of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 without photosynthetic oxygen evolution and respiratory oxygen consumption: implications for the study of cyclic photosynthetic electron transport

Cyclic electron transport around photosystem (PS) I is believed to play a role in generation of ATP required for adaptation to stress in cyanobacteria and plants. However, elucidation of the pathway(s) of cyclic electron flow is difficult because of low rates of this electron flow relative to those of linear photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport. We have constructed a strain of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 that lacks both PSII and respiratory oxidases and that, consequently, neither evolves nor consumes oxygen. However, this strain is still capable of cyclic electron flow around PSI. The photoheterotrophic growth rate of this strain increased with light intensity up to an intensity of about 25 mumol photons m-2 s-1, supporting the notion that cyclic electron flow contributes to ATP generation in this strain. Indeed, the ATP-generating ability of PSI is demonstrated by the fact that the PSII-less oxidase-less strain is able to grow at much higher salt concentrations than a strain lacking PSI. A quinone electrode was used to measure the redox state of the plastoquinone pool in vivo in the various strains used in this study. In contrast to what is observed in chloroplasts, the plastoquinone pool was rather reduced in darkness and was oxidized in the light. This is in line with significant electron donation by respiratory pathways (NADPH dehydrogenase and particularly succinate dehydrogenase) in darkness. In the light, the pool becomes oxidized due to the presence of much more PSI than PSII. In the oxidase-less strains, the plastoquinone pool was very much reduced in darkness and was oxidized in the light by PSI. Photosystem II activity did not greatly alter the redox state of the plastoquinone pool. The results suggest that cyclic electron flow around PSI can contribute to generation of ATP, and a strain deficient in linear electron transport pathways provides an excellent model for further investigations of cyclic electron flow.     

Redox and ATP control of photosynthetic cyclic electron flow in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: (II) Involvement of the PGR5–PGRL1 pathway under anaerobic conditions

In oxygenic photosynthesis, cyclic electron flow around photosystem I denotes the recycling of electrons from stromal electron carriers (reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate, NADPH, ferredoxin) towards the plastoquinone pool. Whether or not cyclic electron flow operates similarly in Chlamydomonas and plants has been a matter of debate. Here we would like to emphasize that despite the regulatory or metabolic differences that may exist between green algae and plants, the general mechanism of cyclic electron flow seems conserved across species. The most accurate way to describe cyclic electron flow remains to be a redox equilibration model, while the supramolecular reorganization of the thylakoid membrane (state transitions) has little impact on the maximal rate of cyclic electron flow. The maximum capacity of the cyclic pathways is shown to be around 60 electrons transferred per photosystem per second, which is in Chlamydomonas cells treated with 3(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU) and placed under anoxic conditions. Part I of this work (aerobic conditions) was published in a previous issue of BBA-Bioenergetics (vol. 1797, pp. 44–51) (Alric et al., 2010).     

Cyclic electron transport in chloroplasts. The Q-cycle and the site of action of antimycin

Cyclic electron transport systems have been set up in broken chloroplasts, with photochemically reduced ferredoxin or 9,10-anthraquinone-2-sulphonate as cofactor. In good agreement with the literature, only the ferredoxin-catalyzed pathway was found to be inhibited by antimycin; but both pathways were found to have a slow electrogenic reaction, both were inhibited by the cytochrome b-563 oxidation inhibitor 2-heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline N-oxide (the inhibition being strongest at limiting light intensity), and the two pathways had the same proton/electron stoichiometry at limiting light intensity. It is concluded that a Q-cycle can occur in cyclic electron transport with either cofactor; and therefore that the site of action of antimycin in chloroplasts is not within the Q-cycle, as it is believed to be in mitochondria and bacteria. Instead, a ferredoxin-quinone reductase is proposed as the site of action of antimycin in the ferredoxin-catalyzed cyclic pathway. It is also concluded that the data presented here are consistent with the suggestion that the Q-cycle in photosynthetic electron transport is a facultative one, its degree of engagement depending on competition between the Rieske centre and cytochrome b-563 for reducing equivalents from plastosemiquinone.     

Alternative Photosystem I-Driven Electron Transport Routes: Mechanisms and Functions

In addition to the linear electron transport, several alternative Photosystem I-driven (PS I) electron pathways recycle the electrons to the intersystem electron carriers mediated by either ferredoxin:NADPH reductase, NAD(P)H dehydrogenase, or putative ferredoxin:plastoquinone reductase. The following functions have been proposed for these pathways: adjustment of ATP/NADPH ratio required for CO(2) fixation, generation of the proton gradient for the down-regulation of Photosystem II (PS II), and ATP supply the active transport of inorganic carbon in algal cells. Unlike ferredoxin-dependent cyclic electron transport, the pathways supported by NAD(P)H can function in the dark and are likely involved in chlororespiratory-dependent energization of the thylakoid membrane. This energization may support carotenoid biosynthesis and/or maintain thylakoid ATPase in active state. Active operation of ferredoxin-dependent cyclic electron transport requires moderate reduction of both the intersystem electron carriers and the acceptor side of PS I, whereas the rate of NAD(P)H-dependent pathways under light depends largely on NAD(P)H accumulation in the stroma. Environmental stresses such as photoinhibition, high temperatures, drought, or high salinity stimulated the activity of alternative PS I-driven electron transport pathways. Thus, the energetic and regulatory functions of PS I-driven pathways must be an integral part of photosynthetic organisms and provides additional flexibility to environmental stress.     

Redox modulation of cyclic electron flow around photosystem I in C3 plants

We have investigated the occurrence of cyclic electron flow in intact spinach leaves. In particular, we have tested the hypothesis that cyclic flow requires the presence of supercomplexes in the thylakoid membrane or other strong associations between proteins. Using biochemical approaches, we found no evidence of the presence of supercomplexes related to cyclic electron flow, making previous structural explanations for the modulation of cyclic flow rather unlikely. On the other hand, we found that the fraction of photosystem I complexes engaged in cyclic flow could be modulated by changes in the redox state of the chloroplast stroma. Our findings support therefore a dynamic model for the occurrence of linear and cyclic electron flow in C3 plants, based on the competition between cytochrome b(6)f and FNR for electrons carried by ferredoxin. This would be ultimately regulated by the balance between the redox state of PSI acceptors and donors during photosynthesis, in a diffusing system.     

NDF6: a thylakoid protein specific to terrestrial plants is essential for activity of chloroplastic NAD(P)H dehydrogenase in Arabidopsis

NAD(P)H dehydrogenase (NDH) is a homolog of respiratory complex I and mediates one of the two pathways of cyclic electron flow around PSI (CEF I). Although 15 ndh subunits have been identified in the chloroplastic and nuclear genomes of higher plants, no electron accepter subunits have been identified to date. To identify the missing chloroplastic NDH subunits, we undertook an in silico approach based on co-expression analysis. In this report, we characterized the novel gene NDF6 (NDH-dependent flow 6; At1g18730) which encodes a protein that is essential for NDH activity. NDF6 has one transmembrane domain and is localized in the thylakoid membrane fraction. Homologous proteins of NDF6 were identified in the genomes of terrestrial plants; however, no homologs have been found in cyanobacteria, which are thought to be the origin of chloroplasts and have a minimal NDH complex unit. NDF6 is unstable in ndhB-impaired or disrupted mutants of higher plants in which the chloroplastic NDH complex is thought to be degraded. These results suggest that NDF6 is a novel subunit of chloroplastic NDH that was added to terrestrial plants during evolution.     

Involvement of a plastid terminal oxidase in plastoquinone oxidation as evidenced by expression of the Arabidopsis thaliana enzyme in tobacco

Chlororespiration has been defined as a respiratory electron transport chain in interaction with photosynthetic electron transport involving both non-photochemical reduction and oxidation of plastoquinones. Different enzymatic activities, including a plastid-encoded NADH dehydrogenase complex, have been reported to be involved in the non-photochemical reduction of plastoquinones. However, the enzyme responsible for plasquinol oxidation has not yet been clearly identified. In order to determine whether the newly discovered plastid oxidase (PTOX) involved in carotenoid biosynthesis acts as a plastoquinol oxidase in higher plant chloroplasts, the Arabidopsis thaliana PTOX gene (At-PTOX) was expressed in tobacco under the control of a strong constitutive promoter. We showed that At-PTOX is functional in tobacco chloroplasts and strongly accelerates the non-photochemical reoxidation of plastoquinols; this effect was inhibited by propyl gallate, a known inhibitor of PTOX. During the dark to light induction phase of photosynthesis at low irradiances, At-PTOX drives significant electron flow to O(2), thus avoiding over-reduction of plastoquinones, when photo- synthetic CO(2) assimilation was not fully induced. We proposed that PTOX, by modulating the redox state of intersystem electron carriers, may participate in the regulation of cyclic electron flow around photosystem I.     

Role of cyclic and pseudo‐cyclic electron transport in response to dynamic light changes in Physcomitrella patens

Photosynthetic organisms support cell metabolism by harvesting sunlight and driving the electron transport chain at the level of thylakoid membranes. Excitation energy and electron flow in the photosynthetic apparatus is continuously modulated in response to dynamic environmental conditions. Alternative electron flow around photosystem I plays a seminal role in this regulation contributing to photoprotection by mitigating overreduction of the electron carriers. Different pathways of alternative electron flow coexist in the moss Physcomitrella patens, including cyclic electron flow mediated by the PGRL1/PGR5 complex and pseudo‐cyclic electron flow mediated by the flavodiiron proteins FLV. In this work, we generated P. patens plants carrying both pgrl1 and flva knock‐out mutations. A comparative analysis of the WT, pgrl1, flva, and pgrl1 flva lines suggests that cyclic and pseudo‐cyclic processes have a synergic role in the regulation of photosynthetic electron transport. However, although both contribute to photosystem I protection from overreduction by modulating electron flow following changes in environmental conditions, FLV activity is particularly relevant in the first seconds after a light change whereas PGRL1 has a major role upon sustained strong illumination.     

Chlororespiration and cyclic electron flow around PSI during photosynthesis and plant stress response

Besides major photosynthetic complexes of oxygenic photosynthesis, new electron carriers have been identified in thylakoid membranes of higher plant chloroplasts. These minor components, located in the stroma lamellae, include a plastidial NAD(P)H dehydrogenase (NDH) complex and a plastid terminal plastoquinone oxidase (PTOX). The NDH complex, by reducing plastoquinones (PQs), participates in one of the two electron transfer pathways operating around photosystem I (PSI), the other likely involving a still uncharacterized ferredoxin-plastoquinone reductase (FQR) and the newly discovered PGR5. The existence of a complex network of mechanisms regulating expression and activity of the NDH complex, and the presence of higher amounts of NDH complex and PTOX in response to environmental stress conditions the phenotype of mutants, indicate that these components likely play a role in the acclimation of photosynthesis to changing environmental conditions. Based on recently published data, we propose that the NDH-dependent cyclic pathway around PSI participates to the ATP supply in conditions of high ATP demand (such as high temperature or water limitation) and together with PTOX regulates cyclic electron transfer activity by tuning the redox state of intersystem electron carriers. In response to severe stress conditions, PTOX associated to the NDH and/or the PGR5 pathway may also limit electron pressure on PSI acceptor and prevent PSI photoinhibition.     

Irrungen,Wirrungen? The Mehler reaction in relation to cyclic electron transport in C3 plants

Plants not only evolve but also reduce oxygen in photosynthesis. Considerable oxygen uptake occurs during photorespiration of C3 plants. Controversies exist on whether direct oxygen reduction in the Mehler reaction together with associated electron transport is also a major sink of electrons when leaves are exposed to sunlight. Here, preference is given to the view that it is not. Whereas photorespiration consumes ATP, the Mehler reaction does not. In isolated chloroplasts photosynthesizing in the presence of saturating bicarbonate, the Mehler reaction is suppressed. In the water – water cycle of leaves, which includes the Mehler reaction, water is oxidized and electrons flow through Photosystems II and I to oxygen producing water. The known properties of coupled electron transport suggest that the water – water cycle cannot act as an efficient electron sink. Rather, by contributing to thylakoid acidification it plays a role in the control of Photosystem II activity. Cyclic electron transport competes with the Mehler reaction for electrons. Both pathways can help to defray possible ATP deficiencies in the chloroplast stroma, but play a more important role by making intrathylakoid protein protonation possible. This is a necessary step for the dissipation of excess excitation energy as heat. Linear electron flow to oxygen relieves the inhibition of cyclic electron transport, which is observed under excessive reduction of intersystem electron carriers. In turn, cyclic electron transport replaces functions of the linear pathway in the control of Photosystem II when oxygen reduction is decreased at low temperatures or, experimentally, when the oxygen concentration of the gas phase is low. Thus, cyclic electron flow acts in flexible relationship with the water–water cycle to control Photosystem II activity. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Alternative electron flows (water-water cycle and cyclic electron flow around PSI) in photosynthesis: molecular mechanisms and physiological functions

An electron flow in addition to the major electron sinks in C(3) plants [both photosynthetic carbon reduction (PCR) and photorespiratory carbon oxidation (PCO) cycles] is termed an alternative electron flow (AEF) and functions in the chloroplasts of leaves. The water-water cycle (WWC; Mehler-ascorbate peroxidase pathway) and cyclic electron flow around PSI (CEF-PSI) have been studied as the main AEFs in chloroplasts and are proposed to play a physiologically important role in both the regulation of photosynthesis and the alleviation of photoinhibition. In the present review, I discuss the molecular mechanisms of both AEFs and their functions in vivo. To determine their physiological function, accurate measurement of the electron flux of AEFs in vivo are required. Methods to assay electron flux in CEF-PSI have been developed recently and their problematic points are discussed. The common physiological function of both the WWC and CEF-PSI is the supply of ATP to drive net CO(2) assimilation. The requirement for ATP depends on the activities of both PCR and PCO cycles, and changes in both WWC and CEF-PSI were compared with the data obtained in intact leaves. Furthermore, the fact that CEF-PSI cannot function independently has been demonstrated. I propose a model for the regulation of CEF-PSI by WWC, in which WWC is indispensable as an electron sink for the expression of CEF-PSI activity.     

Increased sensitivity of photosynthesis to antimycin A induced by inactivation of the chloroplast ndhB gene. Evidence for a participation of the NADH-dehydrogenase complex to cyclic electron flow around photosystem I

Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum var Petit Havana) ndhB-inactivated mutants (ndhB-) obtained by plastid transformation (E.M. Horvath, S.O. Peter, T. Jo?t, D. Rumeau, L. Cournac, G.V. Horvath, T.A. Kavanagh, C. Sch?fer, G. Peltier, P. MedgyesyHorvath [2000] Plant Physiol 123: 1337-1350) were used to study the role of the NADH-dehydrogenase complex (NDH) during photosynthesis and particularly the involvement of this complex in cyclic electron flow around photosystem I (PSI). Photosynthetic activity was determined on leaf discs by measuring CO2 exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence quenchings during a dark-to-light transition. In the absence of treatment, both non-photochemical and photochemical fluorescence quenchings were similar in ndhB- and wild type (WT). When leaf discs were treated with 5 microM antimycin A, an inhibitor of cyclic electron flow around PSI, both quenchings were strongly affected. At steady state, maximum photosynthetic electron transport activity was inhibited by 20% in WT and by 50% in ndhB-. Under non-photorespiratory conditions (2% O2, 2,500 microL x L(-1) CO2), antimycin A had no effect on photosynthetic activity of WT, whereas a 30% inhibition was observed both on quantum yield of photosynthesis assayed by chlorophyll fluorescence and on CO2 assimilation in ndhB-. The effect of antimycin A on ndhB- could not be mimicked by myxothiazol, an inhibitor of the mitochondrial cytochrome bc1 complex, therefore showing that it is not related to an inhibition of the mitochondrial electron transport chain but rather to an inhibition of cyclic electron flow around PSI. We conclude to the existence of two different pathways of cyclic electron flow operating around PSI in higher plant chloroplasts. One of these pathways, sensitive to antimycin A, probably involves ferredoxin plastoquinone reductase, whereas the other involves the NDH complex. The absence of visible phenotype in ndhB- plants under normal conditions is explained by the complement of these two pathways in the supply of extra-ATP for photosynthesis.     

Are free radicals involved in thiol-based redox signaling?

Cells respond to many stimuli by transmitting signals through redox-regulated pathways. It is generally accepted that in many instances signal transduction is via reversible oxidation of thiol proteins, although there is uncertainty about the specific redox transformations involved. The prevailing view is that thiol oxidation occurs by a two electron mechanism, most commonly involving hydrogen peroxide. Free radicals, on the other hand, are considered as damaging species and not generally regarded as important in cell signaling. This paper examines whether it is justified to dismiss radicals or whether they could have a signaling role. Although there is no direct evidence that radicals are involved in transmitting thiol-based redox signals, evidence is presented that they are generated in cells when these signaling pathways are activated. Radicals produce the same thiol oxidation products as two electron oxidants, although by a different mechanism, and at this point radical-mediated pathways should not be dismissed. There are unresolved issues about how radical mechanisms could achieve sufficient selectivity, but this could be possible through colocalization of radical-generating and signal-transducing proteins. Colocalization is also likely to be important for nonradical signaling mechanisms and identification of such associations should be a priority for advancing the field.     

The role of PGR5 in the redox poising of photosynthetic electron transport

The pgr5 mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana has been described as being deficient in cyclic electron flow around photosystem I, however, the precise role of the PGR5 protein remains unknown. To address this issue, photosynthetic electron transport was examined in intact leaves of pgr5 and wild type A. thaliana. Based on measurements of the kinetics of P700 oxidation in far red light and re-reduction following oxidation in the presence of DCMU, we conclude that this mutant is able to perform cyclic electron flow at a rate similar to the wild type. The PGR5 protein is therefore not essential for cyclic flow. However, cyclic flow is affected by the pgr5 mutation under conditions where this process is normally enhanced in wild type leaves, i.e. high light or low CO(2) concentrations resulted in enhancement of cyclic electron flow. This suggests a different capacity to regulate cyclic flow in response to environmental stimuli in the mutant. We also show that the pgr5 mutant is affected in the redox poising of the chloroplast, with the electron transport chain being substantially reduced under most conditions. This may result in defective feedback regulation of photosynthetic electron transport under some conditions, thus providing a rationale for the reduced efficiency of cyclic electron flow.