Comparative analysis of cell cycle events in zygotic and somatic embryos of Cyclamen persicum indicates strong resemblance of somatic embryos to recalcitrant seeds

Embryo development and germination of Cyclamen persicum have been comparatively characterized for zygotic and somatic embryos with regard to mitotic activity and morphology in order to identify developmental abnormalities in somatic embryogenesis. Zygotic embryo development proved to be highly synchronous with distinct periods of cell division, cell elongation and embryo maturation within a total period of 17 weeks of seed development. Somatic embryo development was accomplished within only 3 weeks, resulting in a mixture of morphologically highly variable embryos. No distinct developmental periods could be identified and no reduction of the mitotic activity was discovered for non-desiccated somatic embryos. Controlled desiccation of somatic embryos severely reduced their germination rate, demonstrating resemblance of somatic embryos to recalcitrant seeds, whereas zygotic Cyclamen seeds could be characterized as typically orthodox.     

Precociously germinating somatic embryos of Vitis vinifera have lower ABA and IAA levels than their germinating zygotic counterparts

Somatic embryos of Vitis vinifera (cv. Grenache noir) develop normally up to the torpedo stage, but they germinate precociously and form viable plantlets with very low frequency. Because a peak in abscisic acid (ABA) in mid‐embryogenesis could be one factor preventing precocious germination during normal seed development, we followed the development of ABA content concurrent with that of the somatic embryos. Additionally, we measured changes in indoleacetic acid (IAA) levels. We also compared the levels of both hormones during precocious germination of somatic embryos and during normal germination of their zygotic counterparts. Somatic embryos were able to accumulate ABA and IAA throughout their development but no peak in ABA concentration was detected during embryogenesis. This suggests that the switch from mid‐ to late‐embryogenesis is not triggered. Furthermore, during precocious germination, i.e. from the torpedo stage onwards, the concentrations of ABA and IAA in somatic embryos were much lower than during normal germination of zygotic embryos. Thus, it is likely that when precocious germination occurs, grape somatic embryos do not accumulate ABA and/or IAA in sufficient concentrations to support normal plantlet development. Therefore, for grape somatic embryos we propose that prevention of precocious germination, i.e. triggering late‐embryogenesis, is attainable by an ABA treatment followed by slow desiccation, as already shown for conifer somatic embryos. Our results also suggest that the role of ABA and IAA for improving normal germination after imposed quiescence should be investigated.     

Protein patterns associated with <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pisum sativum</Emphasis> somatic embryogenesis

Total protein patterns were studied in the course of development of pea somatic embryos using simple protocol of direct regeneration from shoot apical meristems on auxin supplemented medium. Protein content and total protein spectra (SDS-PAGE) of somatic embryos in particular developmental stages were analysed in Pisum sativum, P. arvense, P. elatius and P. jomardi. Expression of seed storage proteins in somatic embryos was compared with their accumulation in zygotic embryos of selected developmental stages. Pea vegetative tissues, namely leaf and root, were used as a negative control not expressing typical seed storage proteins. The biosynthesis and accumulation of seed storage proteins was observed during somatic embryo development (since globular stage), despite of the fact that no special maturation treatment was applied. Major storage proteins typical for pea seed (globulins legumin, vicilin, convicilin and their subunits) were detected in somatic embryos. In general, the biosynthesis of storage proteins in somatic embryos was lower as compared to mature dry seed. However, in some cases the cotyledonary somatic embryos exhibited comparatively high expression of vicilin, convicilin and pea seed lectin, which was even higher than those in immature but morphologically fully developed zygotic embryos. Desiccation treatments did not affect the protein content of somatic embryos. The transfer of desiccated somatic embryos on hormone-free germination medium led to progressive storage protein degradation. The expression of true seed storage proteins may serve as an explicit marker of somatic embryogenesis pathway of regeneration as well as a measure of maturation degree of somatic embryos in pea.     

A comparison between Theobroma cacao L. zygotic embryogenesis and somatic embryogenesis from floral explants

Summary In order to improve the late phases of Theobroma cacao L. embryogenesis from tissues of maternal origin, zygotic embryogenesis and somatic embryogenesis were compared, with respect to morphological, histological, and physiological parameters. Zygotic embryogenesis could be divided into three steps: (a) embryogenesis sensu stricto, (b) a growth period in which cotyledonary embryos reached their final dimensions, and (c) a maturation period in which embryos accumulated protein and starch reserves, dehydrated to a water content equal to 30%, and underwent a modification in soluble sugar composition. Monosaccharides and sucrose contents decreased to the benefit of the oligosaccharides raffinose and stachyose. The formation of somatic embryos by use of basic protocols was studied to define the limiting factors that could lie behind their poor development. Morphological abnormalities of somatic embryos, which represented 80% of the total population, were described. A histological study showed that somatic embryos lacked starch and protein reserves; moreover, their water content was much higher than that of their zygotic counterparts. Introducing a growth period into the culture protocol made for better embryo development. Adding sucrose and abscisic acid to the maturation medium was effective in increasing reserve synthesis and resulted in higher germination, conversion, and acclimatization rates.     

Somatic embryogenesis from callus cultures of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Terminalia chebula</Emphasis> Retz.: an important medicinal tree

Somatic embryogenesis was obtained from cotyledon and mature zygotic embryo callus cultures of Terminalia chebula Retz. Callus cultures of cotyledon and mature zygotic embryo were initiated on induction medium containing Murashige and Skoog (MS) nutrients with 1.0 mg/l 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) either 0.01 or 0.1 mg/l Kinetin and 30 g/l sucrose. Induction of somatic embryogenesis, proliferation and development was obtained through different culture passages. Embryogenic cotyledon callus with globular somatic embryos was obtained on MS basal medium supplemented with 50 g/l sucrose. Globular somatic embryos were observed from mature zygotic embryo callus on induction medium. Different stages of somatic embryo development from cotyledon and mature zygotic embryo calluses were observed on MS basal medium supplemented with 50 g/l sucrose after 4 weeks of culture. Histological studies have revealed the developmental stages of somatic embryos. A maximum of 40.3±1.45 cotyledonary somatic embryos/callus was obtained from mature zygotic embryo compared to 7.70±0.37 cotyledonary somatic embryos/callus initiated from cotyledons. Germination of somatic embryos and conversion to plants were achieved. Highest frequency of germination (46.66±0.88) of somatic embryos was obtained on MS basal medium containing benzyladenine (0.5 mg/l) with 30 g/l sucrose.     

Manipulation of conditions for the culture of somatic embryos of white spruce for improved triacylglycerol biosynthesis and desiccation tolerance

In order to enhance post-germinative vigour, somatic embryos of Picea glauca (Moench) Voss. were matured under in-vitro conditions that stimulated triacylglycerol (TAG) biosynthesis. In P. glauca seeds over 90% of the TAG was stored within the megagametophyte, and isolated zygotic embryos contained twice the amount of TAG of somatic embryos cultured for four weeks on basal medium containing 16 M abscisic acid (ABA). Polyethylene glycol-4000 (PEG) as a non-permeating osmoticum with ABA promoted TAG biosynthesis by somatic embryos and sustained maturation throughout an eight-week culture period. Treatments that promoted TAG biosynthesis also prevented precocious germination and promoted desiccation tolerance. Thus, the optimal culture conditions for maturation, desiccation survival, and plantlet regeneration were 16–24 M ABA and 7.5% PEG for eight weeks, followed by desiccation. Under these conditions the levels of TAG per somatic embryo were raised ninefold to about five times the zygotic-embryo level, and the TAG fatty-acid composition became similar to that of zygotic embryos. A study of sectioned material, using light and transmission electron microscopy, showed that the structure and distribution of lipid bodies within these somatic embryos and the degree of embryo development were similar to mature zygotic embryos. Up to 81% of the desiccated somatic embryos regenerated to plantlets during which time the TAG was utilised in a manner similar to zygotic seedlings.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - PEG polyethylene glycol - TAG triacylglycerol - TL total lipid - TEM transmission electron microscopy Plant Research Centre contribution No. 1383We are grateful to Dawn Moore and Ken Stanley for technical assistance, and thank Pat Rennie for the electron microscopy. We acknowledge financial support through an NSERC/Forestry Canada/Weyerhaeuser Canada Ltd (Prince Albert, Sask.) research partnership programme.     

Somatic embryogenesis of holm oak (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Quercus ilex</Emphasis> L.): ethylene production and polyamine content

The production of ethylene and the endogenous content of polyamines (PAs) have been recorded during the early development, maturation and germination of holm oak (Quercus ilex L.) somatic embryos. Ethylene production was high in embryogenic callus, immature somatic embryos and in explants showing secondary embryogenesis, while it was lower in mature and germinating somatic embryos. A higher ethylene production was also associated to the process of secondary embryogenesis. The exogenous application of 1-amino-1-cyclohexane carboxylic acid was not significantly effective on the production of ethylene by holm oak somatic embryos. Total PAs were more abundant in embryogenic callus and in both somatic and zygotic immature embryos, decreasing later on in the mature and germination phases. Immature somatic embryos of holm oak and immature zygotic embryos contain high levels of spermidine (Spd), which decreased during maturation and germination. Spermine (Spm) concentration was lower than that of Spd. Spm was more abundant in embryogenic callus and immature zygotic embryos than in mature embryos. Ethylene production did not seem to interfere with PA metabolism.     

Embryogenic potential and expression of embryogenesis-related genes in conifers are affected by treatment with a histone deacetylase inhibitor

Somatic embryogenesis is used for vegetative propagation of conifers. Embryogenic cultures can be established from zygotic embryos; however, the embryogenic potential decreases during germination. In Arabidopsis, LEAFY COTYLEDON (LEC) genes are expressed during the embryonic stage, and must be repressed to allow germination. Treatment with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A (TSA) causes de-repression of LEC genes. ABSCISIC ACID3 (ABI3) and its Zea mays ortholog VIVIPAROUS1 (VP1) act together with the LEC genes to promote embryo maturation. In this study, we have asked the question whether TSA treatment in a conifer affects the embryogenic potential and the expression of embryogenesis-related genes. We isolated two conifer LEC1-type HAP3 genes, HAP3A and HAP3B, from Picea abies and Pinus sylvestris. A comparative phylogenetic analysis of plant HAP3 genes suggests that HAP3A and HAP3B are paralogous genes originating from a duplication event in the conifer lineage. The expression of HAP3A is high, in both somatic and zygotic embryos, during early embryo development, but decreases during late embryogeny. In contrast, the expression of VP1 is initially low but increases during late embryogeny. After exposure to TSA, germinating somatic embryos of P. abies maintain the competence to differentiate embryogenic tissue, and simultaneously the germination progression is partially inhibited. Furthermore, when embryogenic cultures of P. abies are exposed to TSA during embryo maturation, the maturation process is arrested and the expression levels of PaHAP3A and PaVP1 are maintained, suggesting a possible link between chromatin structure and expression of embryogenesis-related genes in conifers.     

Effect of abscisic acid and stratification on somatic embryo maturation and germination of holm oak (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Quercus ilex</Emphasis> L.)

Summary The effect of abscisic acid (ABA) was evaluated during the maturation and germination of holm oak (Quercus ilex L.) somatic embryos. The addition of ABA to the culture medium significantly reduced unwanted recurrent embryogenesis in mature somatic embryos without affecting the germination of embryos subjected to stratification at 4°C. Stratification at 4°C for 2 mo. was the most efficient for stimulating somatic embryo germination of holm oak. The addition of 90 and 450 mM sucrose also improved germination, while higher sucrose concentrations were inhibitory.     

Improving loblolly pine somatic embryo maturation: comparison of somatic and zygotic embryo morphology,germination, and gene expression

Clonal production of loblolly pine ( Pinus taeda L.) through somatic embryogenesis has the potential to meet the increasing industrial demands for high-quality uniform raw materials. A major barrier to the commercialization of this technology is the low quality of the resulting embryos. Twenty-five newly initiated loblolly pine genotypes were followed through the process of liquid culture establishment, embryo maturation, germination, and retrieval from cryogenic storage. A maturation medium, capable of promoting the development of loblolly pine somatic embryos that can germinate, is presented that combines 1/2 P6 modified salts, 2% maltose, 13% polyethylene glycol 8000 (PEG), 5 mg/l abscisic acid (ABA), and 2.5 g/l Gelrite. A procedure for converting and acclimating germinants to growth in soil and greenhouse conditions is also described. A set of somatic seedlings, produced from the maturation medium, showed 100% survival when planted in a field setting. Somatic seedlings showed normal yearly growth relative to standard seedlings from natural seed. The quality of the resulting embryos was examined and compared to that of zygotic embryos using such parameters as morphology, dry weight, germination performance, and gene expression. All of the observations that were made support the conclusion that even with the new maturation medium somatic embryos grow approximately only halfway through the normal sequence of development and then prematurely discontinue growth.     

Recent advances in conifer somatic embryogenesis: improving somatic embryo quality

Somatic embryogenesis of coniferous species was first reported more than 20 years ago. Since then, there has been an explosion of research aimed at developing and optimizing protocols for efficient regeneration of plantlets. Although routinely used both as a means of propagation, as well as a valuable model system for investigating the structural, physiological, and molecular events occurring during embryo development, in vitro embryogenesis is still problematic for some coniferous species. Major problems include: low number of embryos generated; and low frequency of mature embryos able to convert into viable plantlets. Until recent years, despite the fact that embryogenesis is comprised of a sequence of defined steps which include proliferation of embryogenic tissue, embryo maturation, and germination, attempts at improving the whole procedure have been made almost exclusively during the maturation stage. This strategy was based on the assumption that successful regeneration is related to treatments provided during the development of the embryos. Major optimizations of the maturation medium have involved judicious selections of type and concentration of growth regulators, namely abscisic acid, and adjustments of the osmoticum of the culture medium. Extensive work has been conducted in defining the effects of plasmolysing and non-plasmolysing osmoticum agents during maturation, as well as in improving desiccation techniques required for the completion of the maturation program. In the last 2 years, however, work on spruce has clearly demonstrated that the early events in embryogenesis are crucial for the successful completion of the overall embryogenic program. The use of cell tracking techniques, implemented by physiological and molecular studies, has revealed that manipulations of the culture conditions early in the process can increase both number and quality of embryos produced in culture. Additional manipulations of the germination medium can also enhance germination and conversion frequency of somatic embryos matured in a sub-optimal environment. These new findings, together with the unraveling of molecular mechanisms involved in the control/regulation of embryo development hold considerable promise for clonal propagation in conifers.     

Clonal plant production from self- and cross-pollinated seed families of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus sylvestris</Emphasis> (L.) through somatic embryogenesis

Several factors affecting somatic embryogenesis (SE) in Pinus sylvestris from self- and cross-pollinated seed families were studied with the aim of producing large quantities of clonal plants. Somatic embryogenesis initiation from zygotic embryos was improved on a medium with lower than standard concentrations of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2.2 vs. 9.5 μM) and 6-benzyladenine (2.2 vs. 4.5 μM). On this medium, initiation rates of four controlled crosses, including one self-cross, varied from 3% to 25%. Among the maturation factors tested, the concentration of abscisic acid (ABA 80, 120 μM) had no significant effect on the production of mature somatic embryos when the medium contained 0.1 M sucrose. When sucrose concentration was 0.2 M, however, 1.4 times more mature somatic embryos were produced on medium with 80 μM compared with 120 μM ABA. Under our best maturation conditions, mature somatic embryos accumulated amounts of storage proteins that were similar to the amounts in mature zygotic embryos. Activated charcoal exerted a beneficial effect on mature somatic embryo production of 24-week-old cultures; there was no evidence of such an effect in 8-week-old cultures. Thirty-seven embryogenic lines from a self-cross and an out-cross were chosen for clonal plant production. Highly embryogenic lines produced mature somatic embryos that were more likely to convert to plants than those from less embryogenic lines. After 4 months of growth in a shade house, plantlet survival rates exceeded 70% for 31 lines out of 35. This report describes an improved method for accelerated production of large quantities of Scots pine for clonal tests.     

Development of white spruce somatic embryos: II. Continual shoot meristem development during germination

Summary This study compares the development of shoot apical meristems of white spruce somatic and zygotic embryos during germination. In mature somatic embryos, the functional part of the shoot apical meristem was bi-layered. After partial drying, a normal shoot meristem was formed from these two cell layers during germination. Other cells within the meristem were vacuolated and separated by intercellular air spaces. In the absence of the partial drying treatment, somatic embryos enlarged in size primarily due to vacuolation of cells and the formation of large intercellular air spaces. A majority of these somatic embryos failed to form a functional shoot apical meristem. Compared with somatic embryos, the shoot apical meristem of a mature zygotic embryo was well organized with a densely cytoplasmic apical layer. The cells within the meristem were tightly packed. Judging from the cell profiles during germination, all cells within the meristem of the zygotic embryo took part in the formation of the vegetative shoot apical meristem.     

A clonal propagation system for Atlantic white cedar (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Chamaecyparis thyoides</Emphasis>) via somatic embryogenesis without the use of plant growth regulators

Atlantic white cedar (AWC; Chamaecyparis thyoides), an aromatic evergreen conifer native to swamps and bogs along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts of the eastern United States was once an important species for timber production due to its durable wood. However, native populations have declined over the past two centuries. We established an in vitro propagation system for AWC via somatic embryogenesis (SE) without the use of plant growth regulators (PGRs). Whole megagametophytes with zygotic embryos from immature AWC cones were cultured on a modified half-strength embryo maturation (EM) medium with three different PGR treatments, including one devoid of PGRs. Both PGR treatment and cone collection date had significant effects on embryogenesis induction, with EM with no PGRs giving the highest embryogenesis induction, which ranged as high as 27%. We also conducted experiments to determine the effects of activated carbon (AC) and abscisic acid (ABA) in the maturation medium on production of mature somatic embryos. AC significantly affected this variable, with 2 g l^?1 producing more embryos than 0 g l^?1. Application of exogenous ABA not only failed to improve production of mature somatic embryos, the highest level tested (200 µM), apparently lowered production of mature embryos compared to the 0 ABA control. The highest numbers of mature somatic embryos per ml of plated embryogenic suspension (32–37) were produced on medium with 2 g l^?1 AC and levels of ABA at 100 µM or lower. The SE system described here has the potential to contribute the restoration of Atlantic white cedar to its native habitat.     

Comparison between somatic and zygotic embryo development in Quercus robur L.

ABSTRACT

Somatic embryogenesis from juvenile explants as an efficient way for oak clonal propagation is drastically limited by the low rate of embryo germination. A comparison of the development of immature somatic and zygotic embryos, and a study of the changes in sugar content and lignin accumulation during somatic versus zygotic embryo development were conducted in view of understanding the effect of reserve substance deficiency upon somatic embryo maturation. A morphological comparison of somatic and zygotic embryos led to the identification of 4 to 7 similar developmental stages in both types of embryos, thus indicating that the accumulation phase in both zygotic and somatic embryos occurs at the same stage, when the cotyledons became thicker and opaque. Carbohydrate analysis showed the presence of glycerol, inositol, mannitol, galactose, trehalose, xylose, arabinose, glucose, fructose and sucrose in all stages of zygotic and somatic embryo development, but in different amounts. The amount of glycerol, inositol, glucose and sucrose during the early stages is larger in zygotic embryos than in somatic ones, but the time course of their accumulation is similar in both types of embryos. Lignin content, which increased continuously during development, showed a similar behaviour in zygotic and somatic embryos. In somatic embryos which were able to germinate, lignin content was higher than in nongerminating embryos at the same stage.     

Somatic Embryogenesis in Abies Alba × Abies Alba and Abies Alba × Abies Nordmanniana Hybrids

Maturation and germination of somatic embryos of hybrids A. alba × A. alba and A. alba × A. nordmanniana were followed by protein analysis of single embryogenic -suspensor masses (ESM) and analysis of storage protein accumulation during somatic embryo development. Very important step was one week pre-cultivation of ESM on medium with polyethylene glycol (PEG) and abscisic acid (ABA). Low osmotic potential of maturation medium and addition of ABA supported development of somatic embryo. Also partial drying of somatic embryo during following three weeks was needed for its normal development. In spite of morphologically fully developed, the somatic embryos were not physiologically ready for germination at least in terms of storage protein accumulation.     

Effect of maturation duration on desiccation tolerance in hybrid larch (Larix×leptoeuropaea dengler) somatic embryos

Summary Cotyledonary somatic embryos ofLarix &#x00D7; leptoeuropaea that developed after various maturation times on media containing abscisic acid showed different frequencies of conversion into plants. Drying of these somatic embryos under high relative humidity (RH) before germination improved plantlet recovery and eliminated differences in the performance of somatic embryos matured for different times. However, dehydration of somatic embryos under 98% RH to a water content below that of zygotic embryos excised from mature seeds (0.97 and 1.36 g H₂O/g dry weight, respectively) showed a strong positive correlation between longer maturation time and desiccation tolerance. Drying somatic embryos at 4&#x00B0; C under 59% RH for 1 wk resulted in desiccation to a water content of 0.30 g H₂O/g dry weight, which was the closest to the hydration state of zygotic embryos in dried, stored seeds (0.20 g H₂O/g dry weight). Under this condition, only somatic embryos matured for 5 wk germinated and produced plantlets at a relatively high frequency (73 and 41%, respectively).     

Comparative protein accumulation patterns in soybean somatic and zygotic embryos

Summary The relative maturity and competence of somatic embryos is often estimated on the basis of their morphologic similarity to various stages of immature zygotic embryo development. Morphologic abnormalities noted in soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] somatic embryos are similar to those observed in zygotic embryos maturing in vitro and may reflect common interruptions of normal developmental processes. We provide here a more objective means of assessing the point(s) at which cultured embryos deviate from the normal embryogenical pathway by comparing the accumulation of the embryo-specific marker proteins (11S and 7S storage globulins, soybean agglutinin, and seed lipoxygenase) between somatic and immature zygotic embryos maturing in culture to zygotic embryos maturingin planta. Immature (heart-stage) soybean (cv. ‘McCall’) zygotic embryos were removed from the testa and cultured for 5, 15, or 45 days in nien modified Linsmaer-Skoog salts, 5% sucrose liquid medium. Somatic embryos were induced from immature cotyledon explants on a medium containing either naphthalene acetic acid or 2,4 dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (10 mg·liter⁻¹). The measured level of the marker proteins present in cultured embryos never exceeded those observed in mature soybean seeds. During the culture period, immature zygotic embryos accumulated significant levels of all marker proteins except a 29 kDa soybean agglutinin associated with the final stages of seed maturationin planta. Somatic embryos of all morphologic classes exhibited similar levels of the marker proteins suggesting that morphology may not accurately represent the developmental state of the culture-derived embryos. Somatic embryos induced on naphthalene acetic acid-containing medium accumulated detectable levels of all maturation-specific marker proteins except the 7S β and 29-kD soybean agglutinin antigen and seemed similar in most respects to the cultured zygotic embryos. Embryos induced on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid accumulated none of the mature 7S or 11S storage globulin subunits nor any soybean agglutinin antigen, and yet the synthesis of 7S and 11S precursor polypeptides was similar in both naphthalene acetic acid-and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid-induced somatic embryos. These observations are consistent with the view that embryos induced on high 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic are arrested at a relatively earlier developmental stage than naphthalene acetic acid-induced embryos of similar morphology and may indicate that some external signal (e.g., abscisic acid or desiccation or both) is necessary for the transition to the late maturation stage of seed ontogeny.