DNA cleavage by EcoRV endonuclease: two metal ions in three metal ion binding sites

Four crystal structures of EcoRV endonuclease mutants K92A and K38A provide new insight into the mechanism of DNA bending and the structural basis for metal-dependent phosphodiester bond cleavage. The removal of a key active site positive charge in the uncleaved K92A-DNA-M(2+) substrate complex results in binding of a sodium ion in the position of the amine nitrogen, suggesting a key role for a positive charge at this position in stabilizing the sharp DNA bend prior to cleavage. By contrast, two structures of K38A cocrystallized with DNA and Mn(2+) ions in different lattice environments reveal cleaved product complexes featuring a common, novel conformation of the scissile phosphate group as compared to all previous EcoRV structures. In these structures, the released 5'-phosphate and 3'-OH groups remain in close juxtaposition with each other and with two Mn(2+) ions that bridge the conserved active site carboxylates. The scissile phosphates are found midway between their positions in the prereactive substrate and postreactive product complexes of the wild-type enzyme. Mn(2+) ions occupy two of the three sites previously described in the prereactive complexes and are plausibly positioned to generate the nucleophilic hydroxide ion, to compensate for the incipient additional negative charge in the transition state, and to ionize a second water for protonation of the 3'-oxyanion. Reconciliation of these findings with earlier X-ray and fluorescence studies suggests a novel mechanism in which a single initially bound metal ion in a third distinct site undergoes a shift in position together with movement of the scissile phosphate deeper into the active site cleft. This reconfigures the local environment to permit binding of the second metal ion followed by movement toward the pentacovalent transition state. The new mechanism suggested here embodies key features of previously proposed two- and three-metal catalytic models, and offers a view of the stereochemical pathway that integrates much of the copious structural and functional data that are available from exhaustive studies in many laboratories.     

EcoRV restriction endonuclease: communication between catalytic metal ions and DNA recognition.

In the absence of magnesium ions, the EcoRV restriction endonuclease binds all DNA sequences with equal affinity but cannot cleave DNA. In the presence of Mg2+, the EcoRV endonuclease cleaves DNA at one particular sequence, GATATC, at least a million times more readily than any other sequence. To elucidate the role of the metal ion, the reactions of the EcoRV restriction enzyme were studied in the presence of MnCl2 instead of MgCl2. The reaction at the EcoRV recognition site was slower with Mn2+. This was caused partly by reduced rates for phosphodiester hydrolysis but also by the translocation of the enzyme along the DNA after cleaving it in one strand. In contrast, alternative sites that differ from the recognition site by one base pair were cleaved faster in the presence of Mn2+ relative to Mg2+. When located at an alternative site on the DNA, the EcoRV enzyme bound Mn2+ ions readily but had a very low affinity for Mg2+. The EcoRV nuclease is thus restrained from cleaving DNA at alternate sites in the presence of Mg2+, but the restraint fails to operate with Mn2+. A discrimination factor, which measures the ratio of the activity of the EcoRV nuclease at its recognition site over that at an alternative site, had values of 3 x 10(5) in MgCl2 and 6 in MnCl2.     

Divalent metal dependence of site-specific DNA binding by EcoRV endonuclease.

Measurements of binding equilibria of EcoRV endonuclease to DNA, for a series of base-analogue substrates, demonstrate that expression of sequence selectivity is strongly enhanced by the presence of Ca2+ ions. Binding constants were determined for short duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing the cognate DNA site, three cleavable noncognate sites, and a fully nonspecific site. At pH 7.5 and 100 mM NaCl, the full range of specificity from the specific (tightest binding) to nonspecific (weakest binding) sites is 0.9 kcal/mol in the absence of metal ions and 5.8 kcal/mol in the presence of Ca2+. Precise determination of binding affinities in the presence of the active Mg2+ cofactor was found to be possible for substrates retaining up to 1.6% of wild-type activity, as determined by the rate of phosphoryl transfer. These measurements show that Ca2+ is a near-perfect analogue for Mg2+ in binding reactions of the wild-type enzyme with DNA base-analogue substrates, as it provides identical DeltaDeltaG degrees bind values among the cleavable noncognate sites. Equilibrium dissociation constants of wild-type and base-analogue sites were also measured for the weakly active EcoRV mutant K38A, in the presence of either Mg2+ or Ca2+. In this case, Ca2+ allows expression of a greater degree of specificity than does Mg2+. DeltaDeltaG degrees bind values of K38A toward specific versus nonspecific sites are 6.1 kcal/mol with Ca2+ and 3.9 kcal/mol with Mg2+, perhaps reflecting metal-specific conformational changes in the ground-state ternary complexes. The enhancement of binding specificity provided by divalent metal ions is likely to be general to many restriction endonucleases and other metal-dependent nucleic acid-modifying enzymes. These results strongly suggest that measurements of DNA binding affinities for EcoRV, and likely for many other restriction endonucleases, should be performed in the presence of divalent metal ions.     

Role of magnesium ions in DNA recognition by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The restriction endonuclease EcoRV binds two magnesium ions. One of these ions, Mg(A)(2+), binds to the phosphate group where the cleavage occurs and is required for catalysis, but the role of the other ion, Mg(B)(2+) is debated. Here, multiple independent molecular dynamics simulations suggest that Mg(B)(2+) is crucial for achieving a tightly bound protein-DNA complex and stabilizing a conformation that allows cleavage. In the absence of Mg(B)(2+) in all simulations the protein-DNA hydrogen bond network is significantly disrupted and the sharp kink at the central base pair step of the DNA, which is observed in the two-metal complex, is not present. Also, the active site residues rearrange in such a way that the formation of a nucleophile, required for DNA hydrolysis, is unlikely.     

Catalysis of phosphoryl group transfer. The role of divalent metal ions in the hydrolysis of lactic acid O-phenyl phosphate and salicylic acid O-aryl phosphates.

The spontaneous hydrolyses of lactic acid O-phenyl phosphate (I) and, to a lesser extent, 3-hydroxybutyric acid O-phenyl phosphate (II) have been investigated and compared with similar intramolecular and bimolecular reactions. Compared to bimolecular nucleophilic reactions, the reactivity of II is similar to other systems involving the formation of a six-membered ring intermediate, which suggests that the electrostatic barrier to attack of an anionic nucleophile on a phosphate diester anion is fully present in II. The reactivity of I, as compared to that of II, would suggest that at least a partial overcoming of the electrostatic barrier takes place upon closer approimation of the two reacting centers. The Mn-2+-catalyzed hydrolysis of I exhibits saturation kinetics, consistent with the enhanced reactivity of the metal ion-substrate complex. The binding constant for this complex, determined from kinetics, is in good agreement with that obtained by electron spin resonance (ESR) titration. It is argued that the complex of Mn-2+ with II, as observed by pulsed Fourier transform nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques, is a precursor to the complex of catalytic significance. The hydrolysis of I as catalyzed by a variety of divalent metal ions suggests an optimal metal ion size. The spontaneous and metal ion catalyzed hydrolyses of salicyclic acid O-aryl phosphates (IIIa-d) proceed through cyclic acyl phosphate intermediates after expulsion of phenol. Product studies on the parent compound have failed to detect phenyl phosphate as a product in either the spontaneous or metal ion catalyzed process. The dependence of the second-order rate constant for the metal-catalyzed hydrolysis on leaving group pKa, beta-1-g, decreases significantly relative to beta-1-g for the spontaneous hydrolysis. From the collective data a specific interation of the metal ion with a pentacovalent intermediate is inferred in the rate-determining step for esters I and III. The probable consequences of these mechanistic postulates for phosphoryl transfer reactions in biological systems are discussed.     

Winding of the DNA helix by divalent metal ions.

When supercoiled pBR322 DNA was relaxed at 0 or 22 degrees C by topoisomerase I in the presence of the divalent cations Ca2+, Mn2+ or Co2+, the resulting distributions of topoisomers observed at 22 degrees C had positive supercoils, up to an average delta Lk value of +8.6 (for Ca2+at 0 degrees C), corresponding to an overwinding of the helix by 0.7 degrees/bp. An increase of the divalent cation concentration in the reaction mixture above 50 mM completely reversed the effect. When such ions were present in agarose electrophoresis gels, they caused a relaxation of positively supercoiled DNA molecules, and thus allowed a separation of strongly positively supercoiled topoisomers. The effect of divalent cations on DNA adds a useful tool for the study of DNA topoisomers, for the generation as well as separation of positively supercoiled DNA molecules.     

Characteristics of the glmS ribozyme suggest only structural roles for divalent metal ions

The glmS ribozyme is a riboswitch class that occurs in certain Gram-positive bacteria, where it resides within mRNAs encoding glucosamine 6-phosphate synthase. Members of this self-cleaving ribozyme class rapidly catalyze RNA transesterification upon binding GlcN6P, and genetic evidence suggests that this cleavage event is important for down-regulating GlmS protein expression. In this report, we present a refined secondary structure model of the glmS ribozyme and determine the importance of a conserved pseudoknot structure for optimal ribozyme function. Analyses of deletion constructs demonstrate that the pseudoknot, together with other structural elements, permits the ribozyme to achieve maximum rate constants for RNA cleavage at physiologically relevant Mg2+ concentrations. In addition, we show that substantial rate enhancements are supported by an exchange-inert cobalt (III) complex and by molar concentrations of monovalent ions. Our findings indicate that the glmS ribozyme forms a complex structure to employ catalytic strategies that do not require the direct participation of divalent metal ions.     

Microscopic insight to specificity of metal ion cofactor in DNA cleavage by restriction endonuclease EcoRV

Restriction endonucleases protect bacterial cells against bacteriophage infection by cleaving the incoming foreign DNA into fragments. In presence of Mg²⁺ ions, EcoRV is able to cleave the DNA but not in presence of Ca²⁺, although the protein binds to DNA in presence of both metal ions. We make an attempt to understand this difference using conformational thermodynamics. We calculate the changes in conformational free energy and entropy of conformational degrees of freedom, like DNA base pair steps and dihedral angles of protein residues in Mg²⁺(A)-EcoRV-DNA complex compared to Ca²⁺(S)-EcoRV-DNA complex using all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories of the complexes. We find that despite conformational stability and order in both complexes, the individual degrees of freedom behave differently in the presence of two different metal ions. The base pairs in cleavage region are highly disordered in Ca²⁺(S)-EcoRV-DNA compared to Mg²⁺(A)-EcoRV-DNA. One of the acidic residues ASP90, coordinating to the metal ion in the vicinity of the cleavage site, is conformationally destabilized and disordered, while basic residue LYS92 gets conformational stability and order in Ca²⁺(S) bound complex than in Mg²⁺(A) bound complex. The enhanced fluctuations hinder placement of the metal ion in the vicinity of the scissile phosphate of DNA. Similar loss of conformational stability and order in the cleavage region is observed by the replacement of the metal ion. Considering the placement of the metal ion near scissile phosphate as requirement for cleavage action, our results suggest that the changes in conformational stability and order of the base pair steps and the protein residues lead to cofactor sensitivity of the enzyme. Our method based on fluctuations of microscopic conformational variables can be applied to understand enzyme activities in other protein-DNA systems.     

Modes of DNA cleavage by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The mechanism of action of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease at its single recognition site on the plasmid pAT153 was analyzed by kinetic methods. In reactions at pH 7.5, close to the optimum for this enzyme, both strands of the DNA were cut in a single concerted reaction: DNA cut in only one strand of the duplex was neither liberated from the enzyme during the catalytic turnover nor accumulated as a steady-state intermediate. In contrast, reactions at pH 6.0 involved the sequential cutting of the two strands of the DNA. Under these conditions, DNA cut in a single strand was an obligatory intermediate in the reaction pathway and a fraction of the nicked DNA dissociated from the enzyme during the turnover. The different reaction profiles are shown to be consistent with a single mechanism in which the kinetic activity of each subunit of the dimeric protein is governed by its affinity for Mg2+ ions. At pH 7.5, Mg2+ is bound to both subunits of the dimer for virtually the complete period of the catalytic turnover, while at pH 6.0 Mg2+ is bound transiently to one subunit at a time. The kinetics of the EcoRV nuclease were unaffected by DNA supercoiling.     

Multiple metal ions drive DNA association by PvuII endonuclease

Restriction enzymes serve as important model systems for understanding the role of metal ions in phosphodiester hydrolysis. To this end, a number of laboratories have reported dramatic differences between the metal ion-dependent and metal ion-independent DNA binding behaviors of these systems. In an effort to illuminate the underlying mechanistic details which give rise to these differences, we have quantitatively dissected these equilibrium behaviors into component association and dissociation rates for the representative PvuII endonuclease and use these data to assess the stoichiometry of metal ion involvement in the binding process. The dependence of PvuII cognate DNA on Ca(II) concentration binding appears to be cooperative, exhibiting half-saturation at 0.6 mM metal ion and yielding an n(H) of 3.5 +/- 0.2 per enzyme homodimer. Using both nitrocellulose filter binding and fluorescence assays, we observe that the cognate DNA dissociation rate (k(-)(1) or k(off)) is very slow (10(-)(3) s(-)(1)) and exhibits a shallow dependence on metal ion concentration. DNA trap cleavage experiments with Mg(II) confirm the general irreversibility of DNA binding relative to cleavage, even at low metal ion concentrations. More dramatically, the association rate (k(1) or k(on)) also appears to be cooperative, increasing more than 100-fold between 0.2 and 10 mM Ca(II), with an optimum value of 2.7 x 10(7) M(-)(1) s (-)(1). Hill analysis of the metal ion dependence of k(on) indicates an n(H) of 3.6 +/- 0.2 per enzyme dimer. This value is consistent with the involvement in DNA association of two metal ions per subunit active site, a result which lends new strength to arguments for two-metal ion mechanisms in restriction enzymes.     

Simultaneous stochastic sensing of divalent metal ions

Stochastic sensing is an emerging analytical technique that relies upon single-molecule detection. Transmembrane pores, into which binding sites for analytes have been placed by genetic engineering, have been developed as stochastic sensing elements. Reversible occupation of an engineered binding site modulates the ionic current passing through a pore in a transmembrane potential and thereby provides both the concentration of an analyte and, through a characteristic signature, its identity. Here, we show that the concentrations of two or more divalent metal ions in solution can be determined simultaneously with a single sensor element. Further, the sensor element can be permanently calibrated without a detailed understanding of the kinetics of interaction of the metal ions with the engineered pore.     

Interaction of DNA with divalent metal ions

The interaction between the native DNA macromolecules and Ca2+, Mn2+, Cu2+ ions in solutions of low ionic strength (10(-3) M Na+) is studied using the methods of differential UV spectroscopy and CD spectroscopy. It is shown that the transition metal ions Mn2+ exercise binding to the nitrogen bases of DNA at concentrations approximately 5 x 10(-6) M and form chelates with guanine of N7-Me(2+)-O6 type. Only at high concentrations in solution (5 x 10(-3) M) do Ca2+ ions interact with the nitrogen bases of native DNA. In the process of binding to Ca2+ and Mn2+ the DNA conformation experiences some changes under which the secondary structure of the biopolymer is within the B-form family. The DNA transition to the new conformation is revealed by its binding to Cu2+ ions.     

Activation of Pyrococcus furiosus alkaline phosphatase by divalent metal ions

Treatment of a hyperthermophilic enzyme, alkaline phosphatase from Pyrococcus furiosus (PfuAP), with EDTA completely deactivated PfuAP, indicating that the presence of one or more divalent metal ions is essential for its catalytic activity. Subsequent addition of various divalent metal ions to the apoprotein recovered the enzymatic activity and, in particular, the addition of Co(II) resulted in an over 50-fold increase in activity compared with PfuAP before EDTA treatment. Intriguingly, PfuAP with Co(II) exhibited weaker stability toward heat treatment, suggesting that Co²⁺ destabilizes the tertiary structure of PfuAP at high temperature.     

Inhibition of 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthetase by divalent metal ions.

OAS1 is the small form and OAS2 is the medium form of the human interferon-induced 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthetases. The p42 isoform of OAS1 and the p69 isoform of OAS2 have been expressed in insect cells and purified to give pure, highly active 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthetase. The catalysis of 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthesis is strictly dependent on double-stranded RNA and magnesium ions. We have examined the effect of a series of divalent metal ions: copper, iron and zinc ions strongly inhibited the enzymatic activity, cobalt and nickel ions were partly inhibitory whereas calcium and manganese ions were without effect. However, manganese ions can replace magnesium ions as activator. The inhibitory effect of zinc ions was characterised in detail. The inhibitory constants of Zn(2+) were estimated to be 0.10 mM for OAS1p42 and to 0.02 mM for OAS2p69. Cross-linking experiments showed that zinc ions can control the oligomerisation by enhancing the formation of tetrameric forms of OAS1p42     

Ferritin. Binding of beryllium and other divalent metal ions

Rat liver homogenates in 0.1 M Tris, pH 7.5, were heated to 80 degrees C, cooled immediately, and centrifuged at 24,000 X g, and 7Be2+ was added to the supernatant. Twenty-five per cent of the radioactivity was bound to a single protein. It was purified to homogeneity and identified to be ferritin as judged by different criteria. These were sucrose density gradient centrifugation, electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gel of the native or sodium dodecyl sulfate-treated protein, reactivity to antibodies, isoelectric focusing, and total amino acid composition. Comparative study of the ability of ferritin or apoferritin to bind Cd2+, Zn2+, Cu2+, and Be2+ was conducted by using a gel equilibrium technique, Centifree micropartition technique, and microcentrifuge desalting technique. Ferritin could be saturated with Cd2+ or Zn2+ or Cu2+ but not with Be2+ even after 800 g atoms of Be2+ were bound. None of the bound Be2+ was dialyzable at 4 degrees C in 0.05 Tris acetate buffer, pH 8.5, but at pH 6.5 over 80% of the bound metal ion was dialyzed after 72 h. By contrast, apoferritin bound similar amounts of all four metal ions, some of which were dialyzable. By spectrophotometric titrations at pH 6.5 of Be2+ with sulfosalicylic acid (SSA), BeKDSSA was calculated to be 5.0 X 10(-6) M and by competition of sulfosalicyclic acid and ferritin for Be2+ the BeKDferritin was calculated to be 6.8 X 10(-6) M.     

DNA structural transitions induced by divalent metal ions in aqueous solutions

Using methods of IR spectroscopy, light scattering, gel-electrophoresis DNA structural transitions are studied under the action of Cu2+, Zn2+, Mn2+, Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions in aqueous solution. Cu2+, Zn2+, Mn2+ and Ca2+ ions bind both to DNA phosphate groups and bases while Mg2+ ions-only to phosphate groups of DNA. Upon interaction with divalent metal ions studied (except for Mg2+ ions) DNA undergoes structural transition into a compact form. DNA compaction is characterized by a drastic decrease in the volume occupied by DNA molecules with reversible formation of DNA dense particles of well-defined finite size and ordered morphology. The DNA secondary structure in condensed particles corresponds to the B-form family. The mechanism of DNA compaction under Mt2+ ion action is not dominated by electrostatics. The effectiveness of the divalent metal ions studied to induce DNA compaction correlates with the affinity of these ions for DNA nucleic bases: Cu2+>Zn2+>Mn2+>Ca2+>Mg2+. Mt2+ ion interaction with DNA bases (or Mt2+ chelation with a base and an oxygen of a phosphate group) may be responsible for DNA compaction. Mt2+ ion interaction with DNA bases can destabilize DNA causing bends and reducing its persistent length that will facilitate DNA compaction.     

Discrimination between DNA sequences by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease cleaves not only its recognition sequence on DNA, GATATC, but also, at vastly reduced rates, a number of alternative DNA sequences. The plasmid pAT153 contains 12 alternative sites, each of which differs from the recognition sequence by one base pair. The EcoRV nuclease showed a marked preference for one particular site from among these alternatives. This noncognate site was located at the sequence GTTATC, and the mechanism of action of EcoRV at this site was analyzed. The mechanism differed from that at the cognate site in three respects. First, the affinity of the enzyme for the noncognate site was lower than that for the cognate site, but, by itself, this cannot account for the specificity of EcoRV as measured from the values of kcat/Km. Second, the enzyme had a lower affinity for Mg2+ when it was bound to the noncognate site than when it was bound to its cognate site: this appears to be a key factor in limiting the rates of DNA cleavage at alternative sites. Third, the reaction pathway at the noncognate site differed from that at the cognate site. At the former, the EcoRV enzyme cleaved first one strand of the DNA and then the other while at the latter, both strands were cut in one concerted reaction. The difference in reaction pathway allows DNA ligase to proofread the activity of EcoRV by selective repair of single-strand breaks at noncognate sites, as opposed to double-strand breaks at the cognate site. The addition of DNA ligase to reactions with EcoRV made no difference to product formation at the cognate site, but products from reactions at noncognate sites were no longer detected.     

Relaxed specificity of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease normally shows a high specificity for its recognition site on DNA, GATATC. In standard reactions, it cleaves DNA at this site several orders of magnitude more readily than at any alternative sequence. But in the presence of dimethyl sulphoxide and at high pH, the EcoRV enzyme cleaves DNA at several sites that differ from its recognition site by one nucleotide. Of the 18 (3 X 6) possible sequences that differ from GATATC by one base, all were cleaved readily except for the following 4 sites: TATATC, CATATC, GATATA and GATATG. However, two of the sites that could be cleaved by EcoRV in the presence of dimethyl sulphoxide, GAGATC and GATCTC, were only cleaved on DNA that lacked dam methylation: both contain the sequence GATC, the recognition site for the dam methylase of Escherichia coli.